Re: "Jot" some questions
Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 06 Mar 2005
<<<<<<<<<<<
But when a Jot of a GurSikh attains God what happens then?
Will Akaal Purkh "make" another Jot who is send to maya?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
When the WATER DROP reaches the OCEAN and MERGES with its waters.. same as GURMUKH/GURSIKH MERGES with WAHEGURU JYOT....no more DISTINCTION/ separation....
Why would Waheguru want to make another "jyot" ( type of CC carbon copy ?? ) of this Gurmukh for maya ?? confusing
Jarnail Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
kulwinder Singh · 07 Mar 2005
Dear ?,
God's Creation is not ceased, it is still going on and will go on for ever, this is his play, out of his play some things impress him that much/ or he just shower his blessing / or some good souls 's contribution take some of other with them to merge with him.
You seems to think that his creation is ceased or he have some pre booked order which is neither right to imagine nor it is visible in his creation.
Never mind new Human beings, he is creating new Galaxies all the time, the magnitude of his deeds is beyond comprehension of average intellect.
The processes of creating more and having his Jot in them does not decrease or increase him, HE IS SIMPLY THAT BIG THAT IT IS NOT EVEN WITHIIN HUMAN CALCULATIONS TO COMPERIHEND HIM.
We should not look/ seek or try to comprehend him completely because that will certainly be waste of time.
Just love him, recognize his Hukam and love his creation and try to see him in everything and you will find you answers.
If the above make sense then fine, other wise ignore it.
Thanks
Kulwinder Singh
[%sig%]
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 08 Mar 2005
A very interesting question indeed. I don’t claim that what I am going to write is one hundred percent correct but this is what my understanding is from Gurbani:
First of all new jyots are not created. Anything that is created can be destroyed too. Since the jeev-aatma is made of same material as Vaheguru, it cannot be destroyed or created. Jeev-Aatma is part of Vaheguru but is still different from him. Even at the time when it is fully merged in Vaheguru it maintains independent identity that can seen. Sikhi does not believe in the kind of mukti or salvation where one loses identity and ceases to exist. The fact that there are several shabads in Gurbani that clearly show how much bliss and Anand Bhagats enjoy in the next world, prove it beyond doubt that self-destruction or becoming shuniya (as written by some Buddhist and Hindu mystics) is not the Gurmat way of salvation.
No one is more merged in Vaheguru than our ten Guru Sahibaan. Does it mean that they have lost identity and don’t exist anymore? Does Baba Deep Singh not exist anymore? Is Baba Buddha jee not in existence anymore? Is Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee not in existence anymore? Only if they exist, then alone they are in bliss and Anand. If they have merged in Vaheguru in such a way that they don’t even exist anymore, than we cannot say that they are in anand. Bhagats don’t lose consciousness when they become one with Vaheguru. It is our consciousness that enables us to have Anand and if we don’t exist anymore, then we cannot say that we will be having any anand.
Just read the description of Karam Khand and Sach Khand. It clearly states that "Tithai Bhagat vasae ke loh" i.e. There bhagats reside and do anand. The shabad of "Begumpura Shehar ko nao" clearly states that Bhagats living in Begumpura or Sach Khand have a very worryfree, blissful life. "Dukh andoh nahi tih thaayo".
As for jeev-aatma, it is “Raam kee Ansh”. Therefore, it cannot be destroyed or created. This concept cannot be fathomed or comprehended while we are living in this enchanted world of five elements. Only if our consciousness gets beyond this world, into our real being, can we understand what we are and what Vaheguru is.
Here is a Shabad of Bhagat Kabir jee on ang 871 (Na ih maanas, na ih deyo) that explains what Jeev Aatma is:
It is nor human, neither it is fully Vaheguru himself. Neither it is a Jatee or celibate and a worshipper of Shiv jee. How can it be, when it is above Shiva? It is not a Jogi or an Avdhoot (a kind of mendicant). Jeev Aatma has no mother and it is son to none. This Jeev-atama that resides in this human body is beyond the comprehension of normal person. It is not a house-holder and nor it is a beggar. It is not a Brahmin, Khatree, Tappa, or Sheikh. It was never born and it will never die. Whoever cries for the Jeev-aatma when it leaves the body is foolish and loses his honour for doing so because death of the body is not the death of Jeev-aatma. By Guru’s grace, Bhagat Kabir jee says that he has found the right path and is now free from the worldly life and death. In the end, Bhagat Kabir jee makes it clear that the Jeev-aatma is Raam kee Ansh i.e. made of same substance that Vaheguru is and is part of him. It is such an ink that cannot be destroyed.
A similar shabad by Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee on ang 868 explains the Jeev-aatma as follows:
Listen to this wonderful description of the jeev-Aatma that is called Paraatma. This Paraatma is actually the roop of Vaheguru himself i.e. has similar qualities as Vaheguru. It is part of Vaheguru. (Rahao)
Jeev-aatma never gets old and it was never a child. It never gets entangled in pain and nor it goes to Jammdoots. It was never born and it will never die. It has been part of Vaheguru since the creation. It never feels cold or heat. It has no enemy and no friend. It is beyond happiness and sorrow. It can do anything it wants and everything is in its control. It has no father or mother. It is beyond maaiya and has always been there. It does not get stained by sins and punn or good deeds. It always stays awake. This maaiya or the illusion that is in the Trai-Gunn (three qualities) is just a shadow of the Jeev-Atma.
As we have read above, Jeev-Aatma is not created and cannot die. It is part of Vaheguru but retains independent consciousness. When this consciousness, that is done by the Mann, falls below Vaheguru’s consciousness, it (the mann, not the aatma) has to go through all the worldly sorrows, worries, happinesses, problems etc. Mann is actually jyot saroop i.e. jeev-aatma saroop.
--------------
I am a bit confusied when it comes to this point.
The Jot that all the beings got is created from Akaal Purkh.
Our job as human beings is to be One with Akaal Purkh again by doing simran and seva.
Lets say that some GurSikhs attain WaheGuru then they will be forever One with God?
-------------
Yes, jeev-aatmas that get merged into Vaheguru always stay with Vaheguru. How the jeev-aatma got separated from him originally is a riddle that we can realise or solve only when we elevate ourselves to that level of understanding. Till that time, we should patiently employ the Guru-
Bhagtee that Guru Sahib has bestowed us with, to realise the truth of this life, of who we are and about Vaheguru.
---------
Other who waste their lives cant leave this transmirgation. So the Jot is still in the maya.
----------
Jyot meaning Aatma is still in maaiya but is unstained from maaiya. It is our mann that gets stained and falls from its jyot saroopi level (Mann tu jyot saroop hain, apna mool pachhaan). I think mann and Jyot are connected in such a way as one cannot be without the other. So long as our mann stays entangled in this maaiya, our soul too stays here but unstained. When mann gets the same consciousness or level of consciousness of the Aatma, then the jeev gets free from this world. The conscousness of the jeev-aatma is same as Vaheguru's but on a smaller magnitude.
----------
But when a Jot of a GurSikh attains God what happens then?
Will Akaal Purkh "make" another Jot who is send to maya?
------------
Jyots are not created or destroyed. Whatever number of jyots were there originally, is what we have now. The numbers don’t decrease or increase. This world too does not get big or small - Jo kichh paaiya so ikai vaar.
----------
If every human being will be a GurSikhs then will the human race stop at that point?
----------
Not only this human race but the whole world made of five elements will be clawed back into nothingness. Then again at his will he will bring it into being. Kayee baar pasariyo pasaar.
----------
Kulwinder”s
God's Creation is not ceased, it is still going on and will go on for ever, this is his play, out of his play some things impress him that much/ or he just shower his blessing / or some good souls 's contribution take some of other with them to merge with him.
You seems to think that his creation is ceased or he have some pre booked order which is neither right to imagine nor it is visible in his creation.
Never mind new Human beings, he is creating new Galaxies all the time, the magnitude of his deeds is beyond comprehension of average intellect.
The processes of creating more and having his Jot in them does not decrease or increase him, HE IS SIMPLY THAT BIG THAT IT IS NOT EVEN WITHIIN HUMAN CALCULATIONS TO COMPERIHEND HIM.
---------------
The whole of the seen world or the world made of five elements is unstable, transient, temporary and enchanted. In the world many galaxies are created and many are destroyed but this destruction and creation is nothing at all. The real world is the next world where we live in our real self as opposed to live in this body as we do now. That place is eternal. Sach Khand is eternal as the name itself says. Sach means eternal.
All that I have written above is based on my meagre understanding of Gurbani and what I gathered from the books of Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and other gursikhs. I could be wrong in my interpretation and don’t claim all that I wrote above to be one hundred percent correct.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
Lakhvir Singh · 08 Mar 2005
WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.
Wow, now you've got me thinking, too . . . and wondering about some more questions . . . . . .
How can the jeev-atma (which is unborn and undying, just like God) be punished by the Messengers of Death depending on the deeds that it has gathered? Or is something else taken by the Jamdoots? It is certainly not the body that pays for its deeds. then what does?
Since we are made of physical elements, are we imagining what is beyond, in the physical sense? Of all the collective jeev-atmas at the abode of Waheguru, do they still maintain their human identities because those identies were only of the body . . . . For example, Guru Nanak Dev Ji's jyot through the other nine Gurus was one jeev-atma, do the ten Gurus exist as separate entities in Sachkhand? Because that is how I'm tending to think, although the jeev-atma of Nanak to Gobind was one, how can they be separate in Sachkhand?
Then we have the other jeev-atmas of other great souls at the Feet of Waheguru. How do they all relate to each other? Difficult questions, I know, but just to help us understand that we are only looking at all this through our physical tendencies and that is why this subject will overwhelm us sooner than later.
A spiritual person on earth is blessed with the darshan of whoever he/she devotedly remembers. If one desires the partakh darshan of Sahib Guru Nanak Dev Ji, through the Grace of the True Guru, it is granted. If one desires the partakh darshan of Sahib Guru Gobind Singh Ji, thrugh the Grace of the True Guru, it is granted. Likewise for any religious figure for followers of their own religions. Does this mean that the jeev-atma residing in Sachkhand now assumes the identity of the body it represented? If not, then the partkah darshan is of what nature?
If, for example, I have had many past lives as a human, and the reason that I have this particular human life is because in those past lives, I missed my goal and that this is yet another golden chance to get There, and say, that happens, does my soul assume the identity of the roop I finally merged with God? I understand that the soul is without any link the the body and that it is completetly different from the house it resides / resided in. So when it comes down to Sachkhand, how are the jeev-atmas not merged into One (like water with water) and still has connections to its last human house?
If the jeev-atma is unborn and undying, has God exhausted the number sent forth into His vast creation? A small jyot resides in everything living (and non-living creations, too). When an old tree finally crumbles down and dies, in which I suppose resided a jyot, I presume that when another seedling takes life, an already existing jeev-atma enters it (could have been in a human in a past life and could merit only this new house in its next life). Do jeev-atmas also await to enter a certain created element, and until that happens, they simply have to wait for ages and ages? Maybe that explains the possibility (or the truth) that the number of jeev-atmas in this existence are already here and no new ones are being sent forth. This cyle just goes on and on and the Big Director continues to redefine the actors in His Eternal Cosmic Drama.
Okay, i think I may have asked some really terrible questions, but since the topic was on, I thought I'd throw in some of my thoughts. I know that no matter what we know or think, it may or may not help us in the real mission that we are here on earth, but at least it should help us lay to rest the issue as soon as the mind accepts the fact that is futile to go to such depths.
Each one of us will find the answers we seek, all doubts cleared – or confimed – when the time comes for the jyot within us to leave this mortal vessel it resides in. Where are all the jeev-atmas distributed in the cosmos? Where ours ends up, we will know the answers. If we have the infinite kipra of the True Guru upon us, our jeev-atma will be in Sachkhand. If the deeds we have earned do not merit that, where the jeev-atma lands, can only be left to the wisdom of Gurbani.
In conclusion, I must add that this jeev-atma with my body realises its Divine nature. This body needs to help it back onto the track that leads to its Creator, otherwise it is back full-circle. This little mind cannot comprehend these issues and it probably never will. All it asks for is the wisdom to follow the simple instructions of the Guru which takes an entire lifetime of toil to become one with the Guru. I now leave all my questions behind and seek only what the Guru wants of me. No matter how much knowledge or wisdom we may gather, in the end only the deeds and blessings of the True Guru wll take the jeev-atma to where it deserves to be. And Waheguru wants back each one of those little jyots, no matter how many cycles they go through. The nature of the jyot within us has no other place but to merge into Waheguru. And when that happens, there is no me and no you, only the One Infinite Light that was there before creation and will remain beyond creation.
I humbly seek the Sangat's forgiveness for my silly questions. Do ignore them. I only shared my thoughts.
WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 08 Mar 2005
J. Singh,
-------------
I for one have hard time accepting that gursikhs become one with (merge in) Vaheguru but their identities (Self, I or ego) still remain seperate from HIM. Can't be. Jhot saroop is jhot saroop. Now the BIG question is that do
we really selflessly love Vaheguru or are we just japping His Naam for our own selfish reasons (to get the blissful anand)?
----------------
Unless we have consciousness, we cannot have anand. Guru Sahib has made it clear that Bhagats have an eternal life and they forever stay in bliss. Sikh way of salvation is not to decimate oneself but to be one with Vaheguru. It is the perfect union, where the gursikh’s consciousness cannot get out of Vaheguru’s anand but it is not destroyed. There are several stories of gursikhs in India, where gursikhs who have already left this world come and help them. Shaheed Singhs like Baba Deep Singh have not been destroyed and to this day they can come to this world at will.
As for japping Naam and the reason for it, we are definitely not japping naam to destroy ourselves. Think of it. We all know the concept of Jeevan-mukat i.e. Brahmgiyanis who become one with Vaheguru while living in this human body. Do they lose self-consciousness? I think not. They do however lose the false ego of thinking oneself in the material terms. This is what I think means by losing one’s ego. Those shabads I quoted in the previous post make it clear that the Jeev-aatma cannot be destroyed.
---------
Could "Tithai Bhagat vasae ke loh" not mean that bhagats that are alive in their human form reside there in complete anand as they are "ek-mik" with Vaheguru? "Begumpura Shehar ko nao" could also mean a state for bhagats that are alive here on Earth but their "liv" is "jurri hoi" with Vaheguru. Nirangkaar is in Sachkhand but also everywhere else (sabhe ghat Raam Bolle). How can bodiless aatma experience anand if the shabad by Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee maharaj states that aatma is beyond happiness
and sorrow. Isn't anand a state of continuos bliss & happiness?
----------
No Veer jeeo, these interpretations that you have given are not supported by any other gursikh scholar. Just read the first pankiti of the 5th shabad of Siri Sohila Sahib:
EEHA KHAAT CHALO HAR LAAHA, AGAI BASAN SUHELA ||
(Over here in this world earn the profit of Naam and in the next world you shall always reside happily and in bliss).
How are you going to reside happily if you don't exist anymore? How will you know that you are happy if you don't have consciousness?
Another pankiti:
NANAK BHAGAT SOHEHE DARVARAY, MANMUKH SADA BHAVAAT ||
(Siri Guru jee says that the Bhagats look beautiful at the darbaar of Vaheguru whereas the manmukhs forever wander).
This pankiti makes it clear that bhagats reside at the darbar of Vaheguru and not only that they reside there, but they look just beautiful. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written this in many books that Bhagats are merged with Vaheguru in Sach Khand but they don't lose identity and can be distinguished.
There are countless pankitis in Gurbani that tell us clearly that Bhagats do have everlasting life in the next world. They forever stay in the bliss of Vaheguru. They are not destroyed. If they were to destroy themselves, then how could they have been in bliss in Sach Khand or Begumpura as noted by Siri Guru jee.
-------------
And, I think, it's our brain not aatma where the state of consciousness and unconsciousness is experienced. You can cut this hudd-maas da putla into small pieces, but if the signal doesn't reach the brain, there is no feeling of pain!
-------------
No consciousness does not reside in the Brain. However our jeev-aatma cannot function on its own in this enchanted world and as thus has to use Brain and body to function. But consciousness including feelings, memories etc. all go with us when we leave this world. Brain is just maas da tukdaa and nothing else. Brain is good only for this world but not for the next world. When someone gets hurt in the head and loses memory or consciousness, it does not mean that one’s real self or jeev-aatma has lost memory. It just means that our brain i.e. the medium to remember things in this world gets impaired. Nothing else. Our real self cannot be destroyed. Only our physical being can be destroyed.
When we go to the darbar of Dharam Rai and he accounts for our good and bad sins, it is our real self or we the jeev-aatma who accounts for all good and bad deeds. It is punished for bad deeds and rewarded for good deeds. All this is done when we are fully conscious of everything and our memory that is hindered by being in this body really get augmented fully and now we can remember all our deeds done in all previous lives.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 09 Mar 2005
-----------
Again, I interpret this pankati a little differently. To me it means that bhagats look beautiful at the darbaar of Vaheguru (when their aatma goes there to get merged into Vaheguru - jyoti jyot samaun) whereas the manmukhs never reach there and wander forever in 84 lakh juni.
------------
If there is no difference between Aatma and Parm-aatma (Vaheguru) then how can one say that they look beautiful in the darbar of Vaheguru? The very fact that they are distinguishable and can be discerned from Vaheguru and be seen as beautiful and in anand, proves that they have not lost their identity and have not decimated. The fact of the matter is that the real consciousness is obtained over there. The consciousness that we have not is the false one and this is what we have to shatter. This false conscousness is also called Haume.
I repeat my earlier assertion that if they don't exist and if there is no consciousness on part of Bhagats, then who is in Anand? If you say it is Vaheguru in Anand, then what is the greatness for bhagats to do bhagtee, when Vaheguru is already in Anand? Bhagtee of Bhagats does not increase or decrease Vaheguru's anand. Vaheguru is always in Anand but we are not or you can say that our consciousness is not in Anand at this time. When our conscousness or our Mann (I think mann is conscousness, and Mann is different from Brain) rises up to the level beyond the 5 elements and 3 gunns of maaiya, then it can realise and understand the real self. To get there we have to japp Naam.
-----------
What is SachKhand to you? Do you think Vaheguru resides at a specific "physical" place out there or is He everywhere
"ramiya" hoya?
---------
There is no doubt that Vaheguru is ramiya hoiya everywhere but he is also seated on his divine throne in Sach Khand. Sach Khand according to my understanding at this time and according to gurmukhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and Bhai Vir Singh jee is an actual place, where Bhagats and Vaheguru reside.
Sach Khand is huge and inside of Sach Khand is Karam Khand, and then Sharam Khand and then Giyaan Khand, then Dharam Khand and finally our Earth - Karam Bhoomi. Karam Bhoomi is most asthool (macro) while Sach Khand is most Sooksham (micro). Everything is in Sach Khand but Sach Khand also exists beyond everything else. It is too big. Everything else is too small in front of it. This physical world that we live in is just a false world and does not even count. The real world is the next world. This is just a transient world.
The above is based on writings of Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 09 Mar 2005
------------
"How can the jeev-atma (which is unborn and undying, just like God) be punished by the Messengers of Death depending on the deeds that it has gathered? Or is something else taken by the Jamdoots? It is certainly not the body that pays for its deeds. then what does?"
So the jeev-atma doesnt go to dharam raj? i always thought that the body dies but the jeev-atma moves on, either taken by jammdoots to go before dharam raj, or above to the higher khands..so if the jeev-atma doesnt, then what does? when one suffers in 'hell' or gets beaten by the jammdoots, then how does feel pain, because you said that:
-----------
According to spiritual scholars, our being is constituted of Mann and Aatma. Mann in return is constituted of Mann, Chit, and Budhi. Aatma is always pure and stays unstained. Mann is the one that feels pain and it is mann that does bhagti and mann is what needs to be purified. This is why all shabads are always addressed to mann.
Our Mann, at this time has degenerated to a very lower plane and its avastha or spiritual state is in dire state. Its consciousness is stuck in the 3 gunns (Rajo, Sato and Tamo) of maiya. When we japp Naam, our mind gets tuned to it and finally regains its real and original spiritual consciousness. When it reaches its original consciousness, it becomes one with aatma again and as such become “Jyot Saroop”. Till mann is lost in lower planes of consciousness, it gets punished and rewarded in worldly senses.
Jeev-aatma consists of Aatma and Mann (mann, chit and Budhi). Though Aatma does not suffer any happiness or sorrow, it is nevertheless, separated from Vaheguru since it is connected to Mann. When Mann gets purified through Naam, it becomes one with aatma and then the jeev-aatma becomes with Vaheguru.
------------------
"It has no enemy and no friend. It is beyond happiness and sorrow. It can do anything it wants and everything is in its control."
So 'what' feels sorrow, if its not the jeev-atma then what else is there? Same thing with when one feels anand, if the jeev-atma doesnt feel happiness, 'what is it' then?
--------------
As stated above, it is our mann that feels happiness or sorrow and it is our mann that gets punished by Jammdoots. Aatma is unstained.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 09 Mar 2005
-------
They look beautiful because they have reached the darbar of Vaheguru as beautiful "suhaagans" and have met their kant or Khasm.
----------
But Veer jeeo, how do you know they are beautiful, if they are totally merged and have lost their identity? If someone does not exist and has decimated or merged to such level that one cannot discern any difference between Vaheguru and the jeev-aatma, how did Guru Sahib call them beautiful then?
The question we were originally discussing was that Bhagats merge in Vaheguru and lose their identity and self-being or not? I am maintaining that Bhagats don't lose their identity and consciousness. The fact that Guru Sahib could say that Bhagats look beautiful, proves that they don't lose their self-being and don't decimate.
--------
I had asked the question in my earlier post that do we really selflessly love Vaheguru or are we just doing bhagti for our own selfish reasons to get the blissful anand?
---------
Whatever our avastha becomes later on is a different thing but as far as I know, we begin doing Bhagti of Vaheguru to deliver us out of this terrible ocean (Agan saagar). Many gursikhs start doing bhagti for a worldly reason and that is totally acceptable too. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee started doing bhagti to pass his BA exams. Once his surti touched Gurbani, he became oblivious of his worldly causes to do bhagti and pursued only selfless bhagtee. So once the jeev-aatma gets to know Vaheguru, it falls in love with him and ultimately wants nothing else but him.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2005
----------
how can the maan be physically beaten? when one is being taken to dharam raj..are they in the form of a body? and also in hell..i know the body is left behind..so what is 'it' that gets punished physically then..maan? how is that so?
also in sach khand and other khands..is it just jeev-atma and maan that is there? because i have heard from gursikhs of experiences where they went to sach khand for a small amount of time and saw certain gursikhs...so did they see them in 'body' form? because they were seen sitting there happily doing simran..with a mala..
---------------
Since all these punishments and rewards of heaven take place in Dharam Khand, our jeev-aatma (mann or Antashkaran and Aatma) takes on the astral body suitable for Dharam Khand.
As for experiencing dukh and sukh, it is always our mann that experiences dukh or sukh, whether this world or the next world. Our physical body cannot experience anything but it is the mann that experiences this sitting in this physical body. Same way, our jeev-aatma takes on the astral body required for Dharam Khand.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2005
Avidya jee,
I have explained my understanding under this thread.
Could you answer the questions raised in the original post and also let us know what is the condition of Bhagats when they are one with Vaheguru?
Do they still have consciousness and do they maintain a separate entity? If you say they do not maintain separate entity, then how can they be discerned from Vaheguru in Sach Khand?
As for pankitis like "Brahmgiyani aap Nirankaar", I think they mean quite the opposite of what you say. It means Nirankaar himself is the greatest brahmgiyani. Brahmgiyani means one who know Brahm i.e. Vaheguru. Since Vaheguru is beant therefore his knowledge too is infinite and beyond limits. As such there has to be different levels, actually infinite levels of Brahmgiyanis. The more one knows and sees Vaheguru more giyaan one has about Brahm and more of a Brahmgiyani one is. The ultimate knowledge of Brahm is known to Brahm himself. Therefore, he alone is the greatest Brahmgiyani or say Pooran Brahmgiyani.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2005
Veer J. Singh jeeo,
What more can I say? I guess we will find out the truth only when we ourselves experience all this. May Guru Sahib do kirpa on us and reveal all these secrets to us.
Kya Kaheeye, kicch kahee na jaaye ||
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2005
---------
No, no, no Kulbir Singh ji, with all due respect I don't think that's what it means :-). I read your explanation but I think the pankati "Brahmgiyani aap
Nirankaar" simply pays the ultimate compliment to a Brahmgiyani who is "ik-mik" with Vaheguru while being in human form.
----------
I was going to rest my case but this post of yours prompted me to write once again. Let us forget about my translation of this pankiti as it would take us off topic but let us discuss what you just wrote here. You write that Brahmgiyani is "ikk-mikk" with Vaheguru while in Human form. Then don't you see that this Brahmgiyani is distinct from Vaheguru i.e. being ikk-mikk, he still maintains his identity?
We hear how Gurmukh pyaaray like Sant Attar Singh jee and Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee reached the zeniths of spiritual state and were ikk-mikk too but still had their own identity.
To say that they will lost identity immediately after they leave their body fails my logic. They were one when they were in human body but still retained their distinctness. They will cease to be distinct when they leave their body? Why?
As far as I have understood Gurbani and I will repeat that my understandings can be flawed since I am a mortal being, one's spiritual state stays the same after death as it was during life in this world. Any enhancements or elevations of spiritual states can occur only when in this human body, not afterwards. So if Bhagats can be separate while being ikk mikk with him in this world, why can't they be the same in the next world?
There are too many pankitis of Bhagats and Vaheguru residing together. I have just remembered another one:
Bhagat Sung Prabh Gosht karat ||
Teh Harkh, na sog, naa janam na mirat ||
(There is no death or birth, sorrow or worldly happiness there. Prabhu i.e. Vaheguru does gosht i.e. talks to his bhagats there).
This is the state of oneness with Vaheguru, yet gosht is done with Vaheguru.
------------
I thought I had answered this question but may be you didn't quite understand what I had meant (or may be I wasn't able to communicate what I meant). They look beautiful like "suhaagans" when they REACH in front of kant Vaheguru to be ONE with His Jyot.
------------
Guru Sahib has written that Bhagat Soheh Darvaaray i.e. Present continious tense. They are still Sohing in the Darbaar. Your explanation that this is the scene when they first come in front of Vaheguru is not supported by any translater of Gurbani. They become beautiful only when they are merged in Vaheguru and not before the merging? In any case, how can they even reach Sach Khand in front of Vaheguru if they have not even merged? Only the one who's consciousness is merged in the praise of Vaheguru can reach the state of being in front of Vaheguru.
I don't think there is a big vacuum into which the soul is pulled and lost forever. This is not the case at all. Gurbani does not talk about decimation of soul anywhere. Aatma cannot be decimated as per Gurbaani. It is abinaashi. By your theory, we are destroying ourselves by japping Naam. Gurbani talks about eternal life and eternal bliss and not decimation of our self being. When we say bliss, we say bliss that the jeev-aatma enjoys and not Vaheguru. Jeev-aatma can enjoy this bliss only if it is distinct and has some consciousness? How else can it do so? If Guru Sahib was talking about its decimation, then Guru Sahib would have said that Vaheguru enjoys bliss after the soul is merged in him but no. Gurbani talks about the Bhagats staying in bliss forever, after merging. This proves that they don't lose their identity.
And you write that they look beautiful sohagans. How can one be a sugaagan unless the suhaag (Vaheguru) does bhog with you? Suhaagan one becomes only after bhog with Vaheguru. And to do bhog, you need two entities. If you say that Vaheguru is only alone, then whom is he doing bhog with? With himself?
-------------
There is no difference between the two jyots once jeev-aatmas have merged into Vaheguru-jyot (after their "bandhans" are cut and they are freed from the circle of 84).
-------------
But this statement is also true when the jeev-aatma is in this world i.e. has not left the human body yet. They merge with Vaheguru while living and stay like this after physical death too. If they don't lose identity while in this world, how can they lose it after death? What changes after physical death?
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2005
Veer J. Singh jeeo,
--------
I just feel like saying that, all these debates aside, I am not even close to the dust of the feet of great guru-pyaare like yourself. I may not agree with you all the time but I enjoy reading your posts and I am moved and fascinated by your knowledge and love of Gurbani.
----------
Judging from your posts under this thread I can say that you yourself are so well-versed in your logic and understanding. I already stated in the beginning that my understanding can be flawed and I don’t claim it to be fully correct. I am only a mortal being. Till we reach that spiritual state and see everything ourselves, we can never be sure. Our interpretations and understandings can be flawed. Guru Sahib kirpa karan.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2005
Avidya jee,
You have not answered my previous questions and have just repeated your earlier post in different words. Here are the questions for your convenience:
Could you answer the questions raised in the original post and also let us know what is the condition of Bhagats when they are one with Vaheguru?
Do they still have consciousness and do they maintain a separate entity? If you say they do not maintain separate entity, then how can they be discerned from Vaheguru in Sach Khand?
If they don't exist anymore and are totally finished, then why does Gurbani say that the Bhagats look beautiful in in the Darbar of Vaheguru? How can they look beautiful if they don't exist?
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2005
Avidya jeeo,
----------
Of course the bhagats look beautiful in that darbar, but what and where is that darbar you describe?
--------
The answer to this too is staring in your face. See few posts above, where I have tried to explain about Sach Khand. I have repeatedly written that this place is Sach Khand.
-------------
1) If the jeev aatma is pure waheguru in essence, what exactly is it that maintains independence from waheguru in that union?
-----------
All I know is that Guru Sahib has written in several places in Gurbani that Bhagats stay in bliss in the next world. What maintains independence and what does not, Guru Sahib jee jaanday hunn. All I know is that Bhagats don’t decimate or cease to exist in Sach Khand. They stay there forever in bliss.
----------
2) If you pose there is something else that is in union with God, from where does it come? In other words what is the actual SOURCE of that independent thing?
----------
Same as above.
I have written enough above. It is now your turn to answer my questions in the previous post.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2005
Vidiya jee (you are vidiya and not avidya),
Does avidya means uneducated here or something else? Sorry if I misunderstood it.
-----------
Please tell me what your source for this (in other words which of Bhai Randhir Singh's texts) as I am interested in this approach.
-----------
There is not one book but many books. Andithi Duniya, Sach Khand Darshan and Gurmat Karam Philosophy are the best books on this subject.
----------
In answer to your question I must pose some further questions again...sorry!
----------
I don’t know what my answers have to do with your answer to questions. I was asking for your opinion on this subject.
-----------
1) Do you believe that Waheguru in it's ultimate form is sagun or nirgun, is Waheguru nirankar?
----------
Sargun means anything made of 5 elements and is within the trai-gunn of this maaiya. Vaheguru is definitely beyond the trai-gunn and as thus his real self is Nirgun. He is called Sargun too because he alone is the doer in this world as well. Gurmat propagates only Nirgun Pooja as per my humble understanding.
-----------
From your posts so far you seem to hold the view that the bhagats get to a stage where they independently worship waheguru in a physical place, with the object of attention being a physical deity (bagats as individuals, darbar and the ruler of the darbar in some sphere). Yet Waheguru is nirankar! So are the bhagats metaphorically worshipping the ultimate 'Tuhi' in it's nirankar form, or are they as you'd have it, worshipping Waheguru in a sagun form in a spiritual place as their object of focus?
Now if you reject the idea of a physical worship, and accept that actually Waheguru in it's ultimate form is nirankar and nirgun, then you must also accept that the aatma itself if it is to be the same as waheguru is also not sagun in it's purest form (unless you hold as you SEEM to be suggesting that the aatma is possessing something OTHER than the same essence as Waheguru) but is in essence nirgun (see quotes to the tre gun in gurbani)...
--------------
As per my meagre understanding of Gurbani and Gurmat, the Gurdwara Sahib is the best replication possible, of Sach Khand. It is impossible to describe Sach Khand and as such it cannot be written either. Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee has declared that describing it in this world is like chewing iron i.e. impossible. All I know is that Vaheguru is in Sach Khand, while being in this world too, and his Bhagats reside there and stay absorbed in his praises and in sifat-salaah, just as they do in this world when they reach the pinnacles of spirituality.
I wrote before too that I don’t know how it is possible but from Gurbani one cannot derive the understanding that bhagats cease to exist in Sach Khand. On the contrary, Gurbani says that Bhagats do stay alive and conscious. I say they are conscious because only then they can enjoy anand. Anand is a vastoo or a sentiment or whatever, that is enjoyed and you need someone to enjoy it. Bhagats and Vaheguru alike enjoy the Anand.
The foremost proof is that aatma never ceases to exist. It never dies. It does stay absorbed in Vaheguru but does not get eliminated. When Guru Sahib says tuhi tuhi, it simply means everyone is so absorbed in Vaheguru in Sach Khand, that everyone looks like Vaheguru.
Just think of this outcry of “Tuhi Tuhi” by our Guru Sahibaan. Who is saying tuhi tuhi? Guru Sahib right? Then this alone proves that there are two entities at least – one tuhi tuhi Vaheguru and one who is saying tuhi tuhi i.e. our Guru Sahib.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2005
Gurmukh Pyaray Veer J. Singh jeeo,
Sorry if I am irritating you by commenting on your post. I think we are all learning a lot through this debate but I apologise if my posts come across as impertinent and insolent or cause indignation in any form.
-------------
Pyaare Veer jeo, I thought I was clear about this point. In my meager understanding, as long as jeev-aatma is in human form, it has it's own identity like we all do. Brahmgiyani being in his physical form obviously is distinct from Vaheguru with his own aatma, until he "jyoti jyot samma" into Vaheguru. Once he jyoti jyot samma, there is no duality. It becomes part of the Param-Jyot, a jyot that is forever in anand. It's also true that a Brahmgiyani is "ikk-mikk" with Vaheguru while being here as his "liv" is jurri hoi with Vaheguru through naam kamai.
-------------
I think it is a Gurmat principle that our spiritual avastha stays the same after physical death as during life here in this world. If one is a Kaami and Krodhi person in this life, he is going to stay that way in the next world too and even in the next janam until he fixes this problem. Same way the good attributes stay with us in the next life.
Our spiritual avastha and our relationship with Vaheguru does not change after physical death. It stays the same. No where in Gurbani it says that after physical death, Brahmgiyanis cease to exist and get decimated in Vaheguru’s saroop. It does however talk about bhagats getting ikk-mikk with Vaheguru but does not mention Bhagats ceasing to exist.
I agree that they become ikk-mikk but I still maintain that in order to have anand, one must have consciousness. You write that a jyot is forever in anand. Veer jeeo, a jyot will be in anand only if exists. If it ceases to exist, then how can it be in anand? Please reply to this.
-----------
We can play with words all we want but the analogy of sugaagan and suhaag is just to prove that aatma finally reaches Vaheguru darbaar and merges into HIM to be in bliss forever and ever. To be ONE with the beloved Vaheguru is not destroying or decimating. On the contrary, it's the ultimate anand! Jeev-jyot goes back to the Param-Jyot where it originally came from. It's not separate from Vaheguru at all
-----------
I think all the merging takes place while bhagats are alive. There is no such scene that a soul goes to Sach Khand in front of Vaheguru and then rushes into it to become one with it. This notion however is supported by Radhasoamis who even have a dialogue with respect to this. Radhasoami God asks the soul, “Who are you”. The soul replies humbly, “I am your soul”. Radhasoami asks, “Who has sent you here and how did you come here”. The soul replies, “My Guru has sent me here to be one with you”. Saying this the soul rushes forward and gets pulled in the saroop of Vaheguru. So veer jeeo, this notion is Radhasoami notion that we go to Vaheguru and ask him to merge with him. No where it says in Gurbani that a meeting takes place after physical death. All that is taken care of while living in this world.
----------
. We can keep on going at it but, in a nutshell, that's what I believe.
---------
I respect your opinion and belief.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: "Jot" some questions
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 10 Mar 2005
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefatheh!!!!!
i feel like the ant (keeRaa) in the lions (shers) den...
but i just wanted to say some thoughts that came to my mind ...
____
bhai kulbir singh ji said:
I think all the merging takes place while bhagats are alive. There is no such scene that a soul goes to Sach Khand in front of Vaheguru and then rushes into it to become one with it.
____
by guru sahib's kirpa through sangat of gurmukhs some gurmukhs have told me that when the jeev-atma is leaving the 5-element body, that is when the "transaction" or "processing" occurs
in those 5 seconds, 5 minutes, 5 hours - depending on if it was an accident, a heart-attack, or a murder, etc. etc. - there are different outcomes
the jeev atma could be dragged out of the 5-element body by jamdoots,
or be ushered away from the body by gursikhs
in the case of jamdoots, the destination is dharamraaj
in the case of gursikhs, the destination would be guru sahib's darbaar in sach khand
_____
Bhai J SIngh ji said:
To be ONE with the beloved Vaheguru is not destroying or decimating. On the contrary, it's the ultimate anand! Jeev-jyot goes back to the Param-Jyot where it originally came from. It's not separate from Vaheguru at all.
_________
I agree with Bhai SAhib, but I think what Bhai Kulbir SIngh ji is trying to say that despite having been united with Akaal Purakh, the jeev-atma still maintains a form as per the hukam and will of Akaal Purakh, for the purposes of Akaal Purakh's objectives.
Akaal Purakh wanted there to be a Baba Deep Singh - therefore Akaal Purakh did this rachnaa - wrote this play - that some jeev-atma will be born into a Gursikh family and will grow up to become Baba Deep Singh and will get shaheed.
It's very likely that Baba Deep Singh jee's jeev-atma was in sach-khand before he came into his five-element body on this earth, and is in sach khand right now - and while he was on earth, he was also in sach khand because sach khand is beyond the 5-elements.
Also, Guru maharaaj knows and we don't - but there could be 10 or 100 or 1000 more earths, and 1 million or 1 billion more gursikhs !!!
And guru sahib's hukam for the jeev-atma of Baba Deep Singh jee might be that he will give his darshan at these places, on these planets, at these times, to these people !!!
It is all a play.. and who comes and goes where and when, why, and how.. and where they go afterwards - it is beyond our understanding.
Some gurmukhs have told me that just like Guru Nanak Sahib was able to transport (by breaking his 5 elements) from place to place, the jeev-atma that is out of the worldly body is not BOUND in the pinjaraa and can fly to any destination without worrying about the 5 element-body getting deteriorated because they do not have a body at that point - they are just aatma + man.
So they could be in 15 places around the whole universe at the same time - and the whole time they are in anand, because this is the definition of anand for a gursikh:
[i]raaj n chaahou mukt na chaahou mann preet charan kamlaaray [i]
Therefore, J Singh ji - i think we may not be able to assume that bhagats are in anand because they are mukt - mukt is not a big deal
Mukt means you will not come back to this world
But there are gurmukhs who got shaheed in 1984, 1978, even the 1800's and earlier...
and their jeev atmas are inhabiting 5-element bodies on this earth right now
somebody in your sangat may have been a shaheed from the past
This proves that Guru maharaaj's hukam is above everything
and Guru maharaaj's seva is anand for a gursikh, not mukti or being independent of a body
i don't know anything and i'm starting to ramble on so please forgive me
vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa
vaaheguroojeekeefatheh!!!!!!