Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Only Sikhs???

Only Sikhs???

an opinion · 01 Mar 2005

Are ONLY Sikhs able to reach God? (I see this message in some of the other threads and thought I would ask for clarification). I always thought others could also reach God and that God was not the personal possession of any one religion. Islam and Christianity both state they are the only path to salvation; does Sikhi join this group in stating it is the only path? For fear that this will come across as insincere, I honestly would like to know via Gurbani or other theology how this conclusion is true. Thank you in advance. humbly yours.

Re: Only Sikhs???

Sohangani · 02 Mar 2005

Read a few of Kulbir Singh's posts and you'll get your answer. [%sig%]

Re: Only Sikhs???

.. · 02 Mar 2005

Sikhism is not a religion of you are either with us or against us. It is a faith where we are all brothers and sisters and can sit down together in peace. It is a religion of 'sarab sanjhivaltha' that brings all together in harmony. The updesh of gurbani/saints/gurus/sikh religion/sikh dharam is that for a Sikh to be a TRUE SIKH, for a hindu to be a TRUE HINDU, for a muslim to be a TRUE MUSLIM. _________________ maaroo mehalaa 5 || Maaroo, Fifth Mehl: aleh agam khudhaaee ba(n)dhae || O slave of the inaccessible Lord God Allah, shhodd khiaal dhuneeaa kae dhha(n)dhhae || forsake thoughts of worldly entanglements. hoe pai khaak fakeer musaafar eihu dharavaes kabool dharaa ||1|| Become the dust of the feet of the humble fakeers, and consider yourself a traveller on this journey. O saintly dervish, you shall be approved in the Court of the Lord. ||1|| sach nivaaj yakeen musalaa || Let Truth be your prayer, and faith your prayer-mat. manasaa maar nivaarihu aasaa || Subdue your desires, and overcome your hopes. dhaeh maseeth man moulaanaa kalam khudhaaee paak kharaa ||2|| Let your body be the mosque, and your mind the priest. Let true purity be God's Word for you. ||2|| saraa sareeath lae ka(n)maavahu || Let your practice be to live the spiritual life. thareekath tharak khoj ttolaavahu || Let your spiritual cleansing be to renounce the world and seek God. maarafath man maarahu abadhaalaa milahu hakeekath jith fir n maraa ||3|| Let control of the mind be your spiritual wisdom, O holy man; meeting with God, you shall never die again. ||3|| kuraan kathaeb dhil maahi kamaahee || Practice within your heart the teachings of the Koran and the Bible; dhas aouraath rakhahu badh raahee || restrain the ten sensory organs from straying into evil. pa(n)ch maradh sidhak lae baadhhahu khair sabooree kabool paraa ||4|| Tie up the five demons of desire with faith, charity and contentment, and you shall be acceptable. ||4|| makaa mihar rojaa pai khaakaa || Let compassion be your Mecca, and the dust of the feet of the holy your fast. bhisath peer lafaj kamaae a(n)dhaajaa || Let Paradise be your practice of the Prophet's Word. hoor noor musak khudhaaeiaa ba(n)dhagee aleh aalaa hujaraa ||5|| God is the beauty, the light and the fragrance. Meditation on Allah is the secluded meditation chamber. ||5|| sach kamaavai soee kaajee || He alone is a Qazi, who practices the Truth. jo dhil sodhhai soee haajee || He alone is a Haji, a pilgrim to Mecca, who purifies his heart. so mulaa maloon nivaarai so dharavaes jis sifath dhharaa ||6|| He alone is a Mullah, who banishes evil; he alone is a saintly dervish, who takes the Support of the Lord's Praise. ||6|| sabhae vakhath sabhae kar vaelaa || khaalak yaadh dhilai mehi moulaa || Always, at every moment, remember God, the Creator within your heart. thasabee yaadh karahu dhas maradhan su(n)nath seel ba(n)dhhaan baraa ||7|| Let your meditation beads be the subjugation of the ten senses. Let good conduct and self-restraint be your circumcision. ||7|| dhil mehi jaanahu sabh filehaalaa || You must know in your heart that everything is temporary. khilakhaanaa biraadhar hamoo ja(n)jaalaa || Family, household and siblings are all entanglements. meer malak oumarae faanaaeiaa eaek mukaam khudhaae dharaa ||8|| Kings, rulers and nobles are mortal and transitory; only God's Gate is the permanent place. ||8|| aval sifath dhoojee saabooree || First, is the Lord's Praise; second, contentment; theejai halaemee chouthhai khairee || third, humility, and fourth, giving to charities. pa(n)javai pa(n)jae eikath mukaamai eaehi pa(n)j vakhath thaerae aparaparaa ||9|| Fifth is to hold one's desires in restraint. These are the five most sublime daily prayers. ||9|| sagalee jaan karahu moudheefaa || Let your daily worship be the knowledge that God is everywhere. badh amal shhodd karahu hathh koojaa || Let renunciation of evil actions be the water-jug you carry. khudhaae eaek bujh dhaevahu baa(n)gaa(n) buragoo barakhuradhaar kharaa ||10|| Let realization of the One Lord God be your call to prayer; be a good child of God - let this be your trumpet. ||10|| hak halaal bakhorahu khaanaa || Let what is earned righteously be your blessed food. dhil dhareeaao dhhovahu mailaanaa || Wash away pollution with the river of your heart. peer pashhaanai bhisathee soee ajaraaeel n dhoj t(h)araa ||11|| One who realizes the Prophet attains heaven. Azraa-eel, the Messenger of Death, does not cast him into hell. ||11|| kaaeiaa kiradhaar aourath yakeenaa || Let good deeds be your body, and faith your bride. ra(n)g thamaasae maan hakeenaa || Play and enjoy the Lord's love and delight. naapaak paak kar hadhoor hadheesaa saabath soorath dhasathaar siraa ||12|| Purify what is impure, and let the Lord's Presence be your religious tradition. Let your total awareness be the turban on your head. ||12|| musalamaan mom dhil hovai || To be Muslim is to be kind-hearted, a(n)thar kee mal dhil thae dhhovai || and wash away pollution from within the heart. dhuneeaa ra(n)g n aavai naerrai jio kusam paatt ghio paak haraa ||13|| He does not even approach worldly pleasures; he is pure, like flowers, silk, ghee and the deer-skin. ||13|| jaa ko mihar mihar miharavaanaa || One who is blessed with the mercy and compassion of the Merciful Lord, soee maradh maradh maradhaanaa || is the manliest man among men. soee saekh masaaeik haajee so ba(n)dhaa jis najar naraa ||14|| He alone is a Shaykh, a preacher, a Haji, and he alone is God's slave, who is blessed with God's Grace. ||14|| kudharath kaadhar karan kareemaa || The Creator Lord has Creative Power; the Merciful Lord has Mercy. sifath muhabath athhaah reheemaa || The Praises and the Love of the Merciful Lord are unfathomable. hak hukam sach khudhaaeiaa bujh naanak ba(n)dh khalaas tharaa ||15||3||12|| Realize the True Hukam, the Command of the Lord, O Nanak; you shall be released from bondage, and carried across. ||15||3||12||

Re: Only Sikhs???

eng · 02 Mar 2005

Everyone can achieve God. Guru Sahibaan came to tell us that karmkand, shariyat is not the way to God. But naam, shabd is the way to God. Naam Shabd mahima is in every religion.

Re: Only Sikhs???

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 02 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Gurmatt and Gurbani and Guru Nanak Ji's Gaddi Raah ( Path to Waheguru) are 100% "different" from the Christian concept of "GOD", ways of reaching God and what it all means. I would go far as to say these are as Black is to White. There is no concept of NAAM in any other Religion... Naam Simran..remembrance of Waheguru through this unique way is only in Sikhi.The Waheguru of Sikhi/Gurmatt/Gurbani is all Powerful yet all humble, ALL highest yet all lowest, He loves us all with grater love than we can ever even imagine, He doesnt punish us, he doesnt get angry...Mitth Bolrra ji har sajan mora ...kadeh na boleh korra !! no matter how much I annoy him..he never utters an angry word !!. Essentially what the other religions preach and what sikhi preaches are also worlds apart... the others want to reach"heaven", avoid going to narak (hell), have Devils and Shaitans to way lay you and put you off the path, everyone who "dies" goes to heaven/hell and you can "recognise" your father mother etc etc..they are waiting for you...another eligion offers thousands upon thousands of Hourries fairies maidens and wine to drink, golden palaces and servants... Sikhi doesnt WANT or NEED any of these... ALL we want is to MERGE with the LIFE FORCE we came out from..as the water merges in the ocean The "GOD" of others thunders in anger and frustrated destroys whole townsa dn cities venting his anger on helpless people as wella s sinners, He sends down His "son' who has taken over ALL sins on his own head IF you beleive in him....etc etc... These are FUNDAMENTAL differences.. SO the WAHEGURU of SIKHI is DIFFERENT from "GOD"..and YES WAHEGURU can only be reached through GURMATT..."god" can be reached by other means....everybody CANNOT be NUMBER ONE...there are various levels, stages, ways and methods...SIKHI GURMATT are ONE RAASTA..unique and one of its KIND..the Only KIND. This is off the cuff..a detailed answer will be forthcoming...after my other learned veers have contributed. Jarnail Singh

Re: Only Sikhs???

...... · 02 Mar 2005

if we believes in multi pathways to god then what was the need for sikhi? what was the need for gurdwara? there must be many dimensions outside this one, people come and go. There are certain sant who have confirmed that very religious people from different religion were born to become gursikh so had chance to go to God. If we all went to the same place then we would all be one religion there would be no need for more religions. Despite the sanatanist challenge on the concept due to the fluidity issue even hindu books from where sanatanists like to back from only deal with those in the varn jati. Anyone outside this so called fluidity is a malesh. No matter if a muslim never lied always japped on Allah in hindu book he she will be malesh. Punjabis are malesh just for residing in punjab according to the gita because we never accept brahmin suuperiority. It is with the arrival of sufis first a kind of tolerance between orthodox islam and hindus was set about, from where ideas arise that all ways go to God and books or pilgrimages are not needed.

Re: Only Sikhs???

.. · 02 Mar 2005

If it was possible then why would Guru Nanak Dev Ji have come to lead people?

Re: Only Sikhs???

KHALISTANI · 02 Mar 2005

Sat Guru Sri Guru Nanak dev ji came to lead people because Akal Purukh wanted him to do so. All the Guru's had gained Mukti in there previous lives. When they were not Sikh's. Guru Gobind Singh Ji got mukti for meditating on the name of kaal which he tought was the creator.

Re: Only Sikhs???

eng · 02 Mar 2005

.., Few sikhs are not able to see beyond Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. And there they go wrong. Hold on to your sikhi but do a thorough search on internet. Every religion mentions a path to God. And the path is same for every religion. Sikhism is new and thats why more well documented.

Re: Only Sikhs???

Jagjit Singh T · 02 Mar 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh! IMHO Sikhism is well documented only to the fact of Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji is so complete. It was 'documented' by the Gurus themselves, not by third parties after they had physically left. I don't think it has much to do with because it is new. Other religions too mention paths to God, but they are not all the same. They differ in the route taken, directness, how difficult the path is to travel upon, even to how far they go. The path laid before us by the Gurus in Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji is direct and allows a person (regardless of background), who practises what the Guru advises, to realise (with vaheguru's grace) their oneness with vaheguru and reality. To the extent where there is no more you! only vaheguru. Investigate other paths if you feel the need to, but use a good torch - the touchstone of truth...Gurbani. i hope it helps.

Re: Only Sikhs???

Singhnee · 02 Mar 2005

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! >>>>>>>>>>Are ONLY Sikhs able to reach God?<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Gurbani says so. It is commonsense, If other religions were able to help reach Waheguru why Guru Nanak Dev jee had to start new religion? If Kuraan, Veds, Shasters or other religion granths were perfect to teach people how to reach God why Guru Sahibaan needed to Uchaar Gurbaani and compile Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee? Hindus have concept of 'narak-surg', Muslims have concept of'Junnat' by and Sikhs ONLY have concept of Sachkhand. According to Hindu phylosophy in naraks people get punished and have bad time, In surgs they have good time, but it does not mention of meeting God there. Hindus' have many Gods, i. e. Ram, Krishan, Seeta, Ganesh, many Maataas etc. How a religion can help you reach God if it does not have concept of meeting REAL God. According to Muslim phylosophy, jajanam is samething as naraks for punishment of bad deeds and religious and great muslims reach 'Zunnat' where they get beautiful paryeeaan(females) to bhog. They don't have concept of meeting Allah there. Anyone can judge Christianity from Bible's spirituality level. According to Gurbaani, Sikhs' distination is Sachkhand where they meet Waheguru !!!! "Shachkhand vasai nirankaar". Gurbaani says: "hindu Anna , Turku Kaana, doha(n) te giaani syaana" Guru Nanak Dev jee rejected all other religions and started Sikhi in hukam of Waheguru. Most of us have mistaken to understand our Guru Sahibaans' teachings. Most of us read incomplete message of Gurbani by jumping to conclusion after listening first few punkities of a shabad. Mostly, In Gurbani, Guru Sahib discuss many aspects and at the end he delivers his message. Siri Harmander Sahib at Siri Amritsar Sahib jee, has four doors which mean for all castes/people but there is only one path to reach inside "HARMANDER"(Weheguru's home). If all path were equally enable to reach Waheguru then there were going to be four entrances at Siri Harmander Sahib jee. Single entrance of Siri Harmander Sahib jee is a clear answer to main question of this thread.

Re: Only Sikhs???

eng · 02 Mar 2005

I agree with Jagjit. You can investigate other paths on your own in an unbiased way. I did a research and found sikhism to give one condensed view of the way to God. Since I did a research I know they talk about the same. But as I am born in a sikh family I have a preference towards sikhism. Other paths seem to be a little hard and requires time and energy. But I did not understand the statement "Guru Gobind Singh Ji got mukti for meditating on the name of kaal which he tought was the creator." Can somebody explain this to me?

Re: Only Sikhs???

Jagjit Singh T · 02 Mar 2005

Dear eng, it might help if can where this is written, is it written by Guru Gobind Singh ji himself, e.g. in Dasam Granth. what would be really helpful would be the tuks preceeding and after the line - it helps to put it into context.

Re: Only Sikhs???

eng · 02 Mar 2005

I don't know ... Its mentioned in the comment by "khalistani" id.

Re: Only Sikhs???

RK · 02 Mar 2005

>>You can investigate other paths on your own in an unbiased way. I did a research and found sikhism to give one condensed view of the way to God. Since I did a research I know they talk about the same. But as I am born in a sikh family I have a preference towards sikhism.<< I know this has been discussed many times before but can someone please explain to me how other religions are the same when they do not have the essential tools to get to Vaheguru? For example, they do not have Naam, and they do not have a Satguru to give them that Naam, they do not have Gurbani to guide them, they do not have a concept of Sachkhand. So how on earth are they the same as SIkhi? Unless you do not believe in bani, in which case you are not a Sikh, there is no way a person with their head in the right place can put Sikhi on the same level as other religions.

Re: Only Sikhs???

.. · 02 Mar 2005

Guru Gobind Singh did not worship an devi/devta in the form of Dusht Daman. Dusht Daman worshipped mahakal which can only be the creator/kartapurkh. And then they explain in their bani that a time came when the worshipper and the worshipped/kartapurkh became ONE.

Re: Only Sikhs???

Sohangani · 03 Mar 2005

RK Says: I know this has been discussed many times before but can someone please explain to me how other religions are the same when they do not have the essential tools to get to Vaheguru? For example, they do not have Naam, and they do not have a Satguru to give them that Naam, they do not have Gurbani to guide them, they do not have a concept of Sachkhand. ---------------- Sohangani Says: Bhain Jio, this is a very personal point to make. Religions have different methods of practice, many of them have concepts that are unique to them, and most of them can say about theirs what you have said about yours. Saying things in this way doesn't make anything better. [%sig%]

Re: Only Sikhs???

Gurpreet Singh · 05 Mar 2005

whoever with one ik maan ik chit focuses on naam, they alone go to sachkhand, Rehit is there to protect you from the 5 vikaars and help you focus iwth eik maan eik chit. In their previous life, Sahib Sri Guru GObind Singh Ji Maharaj, were not a "sikh" but still reached god because they spent their whole life meditating on god. They didnt even follow gristi jeevan as they went to tapasiyta, buyt they still reached god. So whoever can focus eik maan ik chit on naam, they alone can reach akaal

Re: Only Sikhs???

Singhnee · 06 Mar 2005

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa! Waheguru jee kee fateh! Veer Gurpreet Singh jee, Only those who HAVE naam can focus on naam, right? Who don't have naam, there is no way for them to reach God, agree? Gurbani says: "NANAK KE GHAR KEVAL, NAAM" ONLY GURU NANAK'S HOME HAS NAAM. It clears all shankay. to obtain naam, one has to born in Guru Nanak's house and we all agree that without naam one can't reach sachkhand/God.

Re: Only Sikhs???

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 06 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Bhain Singhanee jio, Is the Comma after KEVAL....or BEFORE. You have written it after...thus supporting your argument. However if we place it BEFORE then the meaning changes to..In the House of nanak there is ONLY NAAM and NAAM ONLY....just like they say in the Courts..The Whole Truth, and NOTHING but the TRUTH. Guru nanak came with the NAAM and Nothing bUT the NAAM...and we REQUIRE ONLY NAAM , the WHOLE NAAM and NOTHING but the NAAM... I would be interested to know the source of your comma placement. It sure makes for interesting reading...vichaar of Gurbani is a wonderful thing....Thanks in advance. Jarnail Singh

Re: Only Sikhs???

yo · 07 Mar 2005

upon sach khand i agree with all that only sikhs can go there. but i found out from an elder singh who know muslim that some muslim sects do some kind of naam in a muslim way and one muslim group even has a technique to keep doing it. It depends on who you talk to, some stress more importance on quran others on the actual meditation of Allah. One muslim i spoke to claimed that the name of Allah is continuesly flows through a persons heart with each breathe. I did not question at the time because i had more things to ask. Some hindu group do too with a chain of their own gurus. But on one side we have the sanatanists saying that whats it matter what religion you are if you meditate upon God? But how i analyse it thus, there is no compassion for a non muslim in islam, God becomes angry wrathful and happy like a normal person ( in sikhi God is Saibungh), his pyar only extends to muslims ( sikhi God provides for all), when i saw the prayer at mecca it sounded beautiful i though vah if only our own ragis sang with this amount of passion and zeal wed bring the entire pakistan and india towards sikhi. But then i looked at the subtitles the prayer was from the quran talking about the gory suffering in detail of non muslims, and how the muslim goes to paradise, the mental focus at mecca on peak prayer time at hajj was this. So if a muslim is meditating on the name of Allah and accepting the quran as his word of allah reading from it , this would mean non muslims are not equal in his eye in his daily lifes dealings. However the gurmukh is required instead of doing yogis penance to look at all created beings with one akh. Even if hindus have taken nam from their gurus, what will the mental focus be? krishan? shiva? durga?ram? These are all created being by Waheguru. It is not waheguru name himself. the whole focus is on a statue. What does maharaj say about worshipping images? Radaswamis and nirankaris believe in formless God and take nam, but will they reach God? If they do not accept the whole philosophy of khalsa panth and remaining 10 Gurus instead of man made gurus then how will they make it? The main reason both gurus are big is because they talk big about spirituality compassion and loving people. Most spiritual seekers are on an inner quest. What they see in gurdwara? what they see in sikh around us? But then it is upto them to research and upto us to make sure the right literature gets to such people in our local gurdwaras.

Re: Only Sikhs???

singhnee · 07 Mar 2005

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa! Waheguru jee kee fateh! Bhai sahib Arshi jee, one can't change meanings of gurbani or grammer to support their own belief. Atleast who has bhao-bhavni of Guru Sahib jee. If we place comma(,) before keval it does not make sense. It says Guru Nanak de ghar vich only naam hee hai nothing else he has. There's no way you can place comma before keval. Guru Nanak's ghar has everything including Naam.

Re: Only Sikhs???

AnotherSingh · 07 Mar 2005

I remember reading a translation of katha by Baba Isher Singh ji (Rara) and he said that yogis using hatha yoga could reach God. Other paths can reach God but it is harder for them. For example, this is kaljug and in kaljug baba ji said that something like 999 out of 1000 hath yogis would go mad from the heat of the practice. It is very difficult for other paths, but they do exist. That being said, Christianity and Islam aim for heaven which is much different and lower than Sach Khand. They both provide descriptions of heaven, but in Japji the Guru states that Sach Khand cannot be described. This proves what I'm saying. They can get to where they aim for, but to reach Sach Khand requires immense nimarta. Without Naam meditation, how will they get that nimarta? There are Sufi sects that meditate on God's name. I don't know if they can reach Sach Khand. I believe that they probably can, it's just much more difficult. Bhul chuk maaf.

Re: Only Sikhs???

.. · 08 Mar 2005

if others can reach sach khand why the need for sikhism? the answer was already there. i dont understabnd this.

Re: Only Sikhs???

GurChela · 08 Mar 2005

To everyone: What is Naam? [%sig%]

Re: Only Sikhs???

jaggagajda · 08 Mar 2005

what is hatha yoga? is there any bani reference to yogis attaining sach khand?(reaching waheguru)

Re: Only Sikhs???

RK · 08 Mar 2005

Hatha yoga deals with body posture and control over the body. It basically says liberation is achieved after different centres in the body are brought into harmony with the cosmos. ha means sun and that means moon, which is where hatha comes from, as our body is said to have suns and moons within it. On the other hand, this is different from going to Sachkhand, which as, said before, can only be attained through Naam given by Satguru, Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji. Every other religion goes where they aim to go, Christians, if they follow their faith properly, can go to heaven, Hindus swarag, and muslims zannat, why do you want to send them to Sachkhand when they do not even aim to go there?

Re: Only Sikhs???

hmm · 09 Mar 2005

different sants and also chardi kala sikhs say different things about sach khand. One may say a hath yogi reach there, another say the only people in sach khand are very very few that you can count them on your hand, then another will say namrasiya sikh and shaheed go there too. So who do we believe?

Re: Only Sikhs???

@zero · 14 Mar 2005

i did believe only sikhs get to waheguru but this thread on sikhsangat has taken me back a bit now what the writer is saying is making me question what i believe can anyone please help clear my doubts? author "gurpeet singh" everyone should read bachitar nataak, the whole thing, not just the ab mein apni katha bakhano. After reading it I came to the conclusion that YOu can be Muslim, or Hindu and still achieve mukti, but sikhi is still the best and simplest path. It doesnt matter what religion you are, you can still do simran, so you can still achieve mukti. Bijla SIngh said "My Guru is above all. My Guru says without True Naam, one cannot be liberated and True Naam can only be obtained from the true Guru. true Guru is Guru Granth Sahib Ji." You said true guru is guru granth sahib, which is 100% correct. But does vaheguru/Raam/Allah/God not have the same jot as Guru Granth Sahib. THe bani is guru granth sahib is the same jot as akal purakh, so if a hindu or muslim starts doing simran on raam or allah they can still achieve "gurprasad" from Allah/Raam/Vaqheguru, and still achieve mukti. In guru gobind singh ji's previous life, they werent a "sikh" although they still practiced the principles of sikhi and worshipped MahaKaal, or the supreme death (just another name for Vaheguru. and they still achieved mukti, Guru Gobind Singh ji even explains it in Ab Mein Apni Katha Bakhano how their soul and Vaheguru became just one jot during the time they did tapasiya in the himalayas. And you cant even say that these days Muslims and Hindus dont do simran at amritvela, and only sikhs do. I personally know a bunch of ismaili Muslims in brampton that do amritvela everyday, how many of us "sikhs" do this? Sooooooooo, i guess, you can call yourself a sikh, and still keep your rehit and say "this is the best religion in the world" without doing any simran, but if a "Muslim" goes and does simran on allah everyday at amritvela, than who really has a true religion? Rehit maryada is here to protect you from the 5 vikaars and help you concentrate better in your simran, not to give you mukti, mukti is only achieved through constant remembrance. SO what is the point of arguing what a true religion is or not, if any religion can give you mukti if you do simran? http://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?showtopic=10082&st=24

Re: Only Sikhs???

bhujangan · 14 Mar 2005

The above quotes have many flaws in their reasoning, the most important of which is that they are based on Bachittar Natak, which is a contreversial subject in itself. I really do not know much but some stuff I picked out were: >>But does vaheguru/Raam/Allah/God not have the same jot as Guru Granth Sahib. THe bani is guru granth sahib is the same jot as akal purakh, so if a hindu or muslim starts doing simran on raam or allah they can still achieve "gurprasad" from Allah/Raam/Vaqheguru, and still achieve mukti.<< How do you achieve gurparsaad without having a guru? Gurparsaad means that with Satguru ji's kirpa, then Vaheguru is attained, but if you have not adopted Satguru, then how will you attain kirpa from them? If you are aiming for mukti from chrasi lakh joons, then I think though I am not sure that you can achieve that through other bhagti, but if your aim is Sachkhand and to meet Vaheguru, then just like the moolmanter says, you need guru jis kirpa, and if you want guru jis kirpa, you have to first accept them as your guru first by becoming thier sikh or disciple. >>Sooooooooo, i guess, you can call yourself a sikh, and still keep your rehit and say "this is the best religion in the world" without doing any simran, but if a "Muslim" goes and does simran on allah everyday at amritvela, than who really has a true religion?<< Are you trying to ask who has the true religion, or who is following thier religion properly? If you are asking about true religion, then obviously the SIkh still has true religion as has been proven time and time again on this forum, but if he does not do naam abhyaas then he is not following his religion properly. >>Rehit maryada is here to protect you from the 5 vikaars and help you concentrate better in your simran, not to give you mukti, mukti is only achieved through constant remembrance. SO what is the point of arguing what a true religion is or not, if any religion can give you mukti if you do simran?<<< You are right that rehit maryada is there as a tool to help you japp naam, but since naam is only given by guru ji, what is the point of saying any relgion can give you mukti? THe above comments taken from another site did not really have much substance in them, they are based on Bani which has been meddled with, and which is debated over by the panth, while the fact that only Sikhs can go to Sachkhand and meet Vaheguru has been proven by Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji, of which there are no doubs what so ever.

Re: Only Sikhs???

@zero · 15 Mar 2005

thank you bhujangan jio for taking time to read and counter the post. That made a lot of sense what you said, very logical approach. I got a bit clouded when the issue of Guru Gobind Singh jis last life was bought up, because i have read numerous books which contain the sakhi of Guru jis last life. In the past i did believe that but if bachitter natak is debated then i must be careful in what i accept and believe too and leave that as grey area for research to be carried out. sorry to go into a different note but Does this then also mean that we believe in yugs as real or is that metaphorical? reason i ask is if everything was true at one time, then people lived thousands of years, did all kinds of penance, went to God, so and so, and things changed and got worse to now barely living upto 70 years and thats if your lucky. How comes the earth has physical changes? but the moon and sun are the same? the same air we breathe, the same wind hits our face, the same ground we walk on.

Re: Only Sikhs???

raj · 15 Nov 2005

I would like to know the romanised spelling and meaning "hak hak adies Guru Gobind Singh, badshah dervais Guru Gobing Singh". Would appreciate if it is done by Bhai Nandalal and where could it be found in the Gurbani. Thanking You, Raj Kuala Lumpur , Malaysia

Re: Only Sikhs???

g · 15 Nov 2005

I think every single one of us are going to be very very very suprised when we die... we have no idea whats in store for us