Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 26 Feb 2005
I can understand, in part, the idea of amrithdaris making strict efforts to only cross paths with other amritdharis. It takes more strength and more courage to remain true to one's path when surrounded by other influences.
But shouldn't these traits be encouraged among Amritdharis?
As Saint-Soldiers, is it our path to lead a self-absorbed life, occasionally stopping to slap the back of our fellow Gursikhs?
Or, should we be riding proud through the dirty water of life...shining like the lotus? We will go about crossing paths with many other people.
Certainly, some will shoot arrows at us, some may try to knock us off our horse, and some may not even care. We may reach out to someone, and in return, that person will try to cut our arm off.
But isn't a true Sikh couragious enough to overcome these things and continue the charge ahead?
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Not Amritdhari · 28 Feb 2005
No there is nothing wrong with non Amritdharis socialising or keeping sangat of Amridharis/vice versa I don't know where you got that idea from. As a Non Amritdhari I am shown alot of Piaar and affection from the Jatha in programs and elsewhere. This type of Piaar is what helps bring people into Sikhi.
Bibeki Singhs will only eat from the hands of other Khalsas.
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
kulwinder Singh · 28 Feb 2005
Dear Redwhiteandblue Kaur Ji
How close you comments are to Gurbani please read.
This Shabad is by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Raag Gauree on Pannaa 332
a(n)jan maahi nira(n)jan reheeai bahurr n bhavajal paaeiaa ||1||
Remaining pure in the midst of impurity, he will never again fall into the terrifying world-ocean. ||1||
Fantastic post as normal from you.
And undoubtedly I agree 100 % with Gurubani.
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Kulbir Singh · 28 Feb 2005
I will say only this much through Gurbani of Satguru jee:
Nanak, Kachdiyaan siyon toR, dhoond Sajjan Sant Pakiyaan||
Break off from Kachay i.e. ones who are not interested in pursuing the goal of attaining Vaheguru. Find (dhoond) Pakkay Sant Gursikhs i.e. such devotees of Vaheguru who are serious of attaining their goal of meeting Vaheguru.
This does not mean not talking or not loving everyone. What I mean is to associate with in the sense of friendships and opening up your heart to. Gursikh loves all but associates only with Khalsa Jan who are serious of meeting Vaheguru. Bakiyaan taun aapaan kee laina hai?
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Kulwinder Singh · 01 Mar 2005
Dear Vir Kulbir Singh Ji
you have written "Bakiyaan taun aapaan kee laina hai? "
For start you live in Country who's freedom and constitution allow you to be what you want to be and how you want to be, that is a collective contribution from the rest of your countrymen majority is non Sikhs.
So a Sikh should be a Ni-Sukhra (ungrateful) ?
You get all the support and help of all the services provided by the large majority of the country ? So you should be Ni-Sukhra ?
You have enjoyed the pleasures of human development mostly done by non-Sikhs , so you should be Ni-sukhra ?
Your fundamental rights are insured in the country who's Good ( All of them was non-Sikh) people made sure that the rules will provide you with the security which you enjoy. So you should be Ni-Sukhra ?
What will open your eyes ? and alert your conscience ?
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 02 Mar 2005
In this instance, I disagree very strongly with Veer Kulbir Ji. In terms of Friendships? Who one pours one's heart out too?
You have all seen the negative discourse on this board, have you not? You have all seen backbiting in gurdwaray, have you not?
There are many Sikhs that stick to a rehat or a jatha or panj kakkars that purposefully dismiss or denegrate Sikhs, or the feelings/thougths of other Sikhs.
Keshdhari, Amritdhari, Rehatdhari - none of these are any guarantee of the sort of character, respect, or trust that you expect from another Sikh will be returned back to you.
A true Gursikh is not one that merely talks Gurbani, or reads it, he or she is one that has genuinely decided to LIVE by Gurbani. And there are many of these people out there.
But the only way to find these Gursikhs, or anyone else worth knowing, is to treat everyone as an individual and get to know them yourself.
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
AnotherSingh · 03 Mar 2005
Sri Guru Granth Sahib Jee
mIxw AOr msMdIAw monw kuVI jo mwr hoie isK vrqn krih AMq krygw KuAwr ]6]
meenaa aar masa(n)dheeaa monaa kurree jo maar hoe sikh varathan karehi a(n)th karaegaa khuaar ||6||
Meenaas, Masandhs, those with haircuts and those who kill their daughters; If a Sikh associates with them, he will not be united with the Lord and will suffer at the time of death.."
By "those with haircuts", does it mean monas in general or just those who were once gursikhs and then cut their hair?
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
kulwinder Singh · 03 Mar 2005
Sikho kuch Sikho,
Hukam Pashano Ji
Try to understand what are the meaning of Guru Ji's Hukam, What Guru Ji want us to achieve in life and are we doing that or not.
Do not become tangled in the words,
Lakeer De Fakeer na Bano Ji.
How protected Kashmiri Pundits ? Guru Gobind Singh Ji.
If he had any sentiments to disassociate with people for the sake of their religion then he would not have said.
Ek Pita Ekes Kai Hum Barak,
One Father and we are all his children.
So Sikho Kuch Sikho.
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Kulwinder Singh · 03 Mar 2005
sorry my spell checker did the trick the line is
Who protected Kashmiri Pundits ? on the above post.
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Kulbir Singh · 03 Mar 2005
Someone asked a very important question that if Gursikhs don't associate with non-amritdharis, how would they do parchaar?
There is no doubt that Gurbani instructs us to not associate with such people whose sangat is detrimental to our spiritual health. Having said this we need to determine two things. Firstly how to do parchaar if we don't associate with non-amritdharis and secondly, what exactly do we mean by associating.
Associating is a very broad word. When we say that we should avoid associating with manmukhs we mean that we should not do roti-beti dee sanjh with them. If we notice that someone's sangat is getting us away from Guru Sahib then we should avoid such sangat. Simple as that. Why so much controversey on this clear hukam from Guru Sahib?
As for how to do parchaar, if we see a potential candidate for gursikhee, then there is nothing wrong in doing sangat of such person and doing parchaar of Gursikhee. But if we notice an inveterate manmukh then we should not waste time on such person trying change his or her views because it is like playing flute in front of a buffalo.
Sodhi Harbhajan Singh narrates a very interesting incident of how inveterate manmukhs cannot comprehend the concept of Naam. One of their relatives was on deathbed waiting for death to arrive. His relatives including Sodhi jee were very concerned that this person who had never remembered Vaheguru even in his dreams would have rough times in the next world.
They requested him to utter Naam in his last moments but he stayed adamant in not saying it. One of his son-in-law's name was Raam. They brought his son-in-law in front of the dying man and asked him who he was. Instead of saying "Raam" the dying man said he (his son-in-law was his daughters's husband. Saying this he died. He could not say his son-in-law's name. If he had said "Raam" he could have had some good Karma as Ajaamal did.
Such persons who are inveterate and incorrigible manmukhs should be avoided and we should not waste our time on them. But on the other hand if there is a candidate who has even a slight propensity and inclination towards Gurmat, we should try to tell him or her about Siri Guru jee.
But one thing we must keep in mind. Everyone is the way everyone is because of will of Vaheguru. As such we should never ever hate anyone. It is our pyaara, Gopal Govinda, Sacha Paatshaah who is doing everything. We should avoid bad sangat.
Having said this, I should mention that I have met some really good Hindus and Muslims whom I enjoy talking to. Once our neighbour's father visited us from Pakistan. He stayed with us for the night and I was really surprised to see this holy man getting up at 3 am and indulging in Zikar-e-Khudaa. He belonged to a silsila (sect) of Sufis. I could hear him doing zikar or simran of "Laa Ilaahi il Allah" for hours till dawn. Doing sangat of such good persons is not wrong. Doing his sangat I became more resolved than ever to indulge in abhyaas kamaayee of Gurmat Naam. We had long discussions on the topics of spirituality and Vaheguru.
As for Kachde, my earlier post really hurt some of our gursikh veers here. I don't see what was wrong in writing the following:
"Break off from Kachay i.e. ones who are not interested in pursuing the goal of attaining Vaheguru. Find (dhoond) Pakkay Sant Gursikhs i.e. such devotees of Vaheguru who are serious of attaining their goal of meeting Vaheguru."
What is wrong in associating with only those persons who are serious of achieving the goal of meeting Vaheguru? I also mentioned in my next paragraph that in my previous post that we should not hate anyone and have only love for others, even if we avoid their sangat due to our spiritual well-being.
I got a lecture from our Veer Kulwinder Singh for being ungrateful to the country I am living in. Being a gursikh, I am grateful to only and only Vaheguru. He alone is the doer. If it was not for him, my own blood relations could turn into Jammdoots as written by Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee in Baramaaha Sahib - Prabh Suami Kant vihooniya, Meeth Sajjan Sabh Jaam.
Veer Kulwinder Singh jeeo, for more than a decade and a half, I have paid much more in taxes to this country I live in than an average Canadian. Today too, when I do my annual taxes and look at the amount of taxes I pay, I really get upset. And to make matters worse, these taxes don't include other taxes like GST, PST, muncipal taxes, transportation taxes, gas taxes etc etc. I am not getting anything for free. Beside, Khalsa noo sabh kuchh Parmeshar kolon mildaa hai. Hor kisai da koi ihsaan nahi. Khalsa has no need to thank anyone else but Vaheguru. By thanking Vaheguru, everyone else gets thanked automatically.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Kulwinder Singh · 04 Mar 2005
Dear Kulbir Singh Ji,
You are very well read Gursikh, your knowledge shine obviously from your writings, which always bring your Pride in Sikhi, your faith in Maharaj Ji (SGGS), your commitment to your way of life out well from all angles in the text you write, but sadly you come arose on the form as breath taking arrogant towards Majority of Non Rehiti Sikhs of your own opinion.
The real decent human being is who value others life forms on earth never mind Humans he should give respect to the environment ( Combined of plants, animals, living creatures, water, air and so on.) and thankful to even the Earth for letting him/her flourish on it’s chest.
Guru Gobind Singh Ji never mind thanking his own Sikhs, on several occasions when ever he thought was appropriate thanked the Khalsa, He also blessed the Non-Sikh Saweks throughout the history for being a good companion and soldiers against the operation, Nabi Khan and Gani Khan should not be thanked then ?
Those Hindu Vir's who done great seva to Sikh Penth even in current difficult times should not be thanked ?
Vir Ji you said “Khalsa has no need to thank anyone else but Vaheguru.” Which in a broad way ok to say as it is right for a Sikh to say everything is done by God.
That is a complementary in general form, of course it is the will of God is to allow human to make their own decisions, but do not say that everything what happened on earth by human is will of GOD,
Then what Baba **** ****** is accused of is a will of God or a fault of this Baba ?
The Atrocities of Arungzeb was will of GOD or Arungzeb’s evil work ?
Same way all the Good done on the earth is also done by people who make choices although the independence of making choice is granted by GOD to humans.
Vir Ji by being arrogant you are putting a concrete wall around Sikhi and stopping it to shine it as it deserve, be careful, You are my brother as we both are sons of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, That give me right to Gently awake you from your deep sleep from not loving others like you would love anybody else and see their contribution as valuable as our father would see them.
Guru Ji never turned blind eye to anything admirable done by others, Guru Nanak Dev Ji even admire the Bania ( Shopkeeper) for his skills and promptness to count his profit and loss everyday that should make you think where you going my dear brother.
Open your arms for the world, you are strong enough not to get contaminated even if somebody evil give you a hug, to be honest you may change their evil ness just by mere hug.
Bul Chuk Maf.
I do get frustrated with your comments some time, sorry about that but I can’t help it, that is how I am.
By the way I do not think you was paying tax in Canada when they was making the constitution, which provide you with most of the rights you have in Canada, by not thanking other you will be isolated and if Isolation was desired the Guru Nanak Dev Ji would not have gone to debate with Sidh on the Sumaer Perbat.
Also when did you or anybody gave even a single cent to the gentleman who invented the protocol for the internet to work?
Should we be thankful to him ?
Should we be thankful to those World War two Soldiers who gave their lives so we could live in free world ?
Your moorakh Brother
Kulwinder Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Kulbir Singh · 04 Mar 2005
Veer Kulwinder Singh jeeo,
------------
but sadly you come arose on the form as breath taking arrogant towards Majority of Non Rehiti Sikhs of your own opinion.
------------
I want to ensure you that I have nothing against non-amritdhaari veers and bhains. I myself was once non-amritdhari and even a monna. I don’t have an iota of hatred for them. You don’t have to eat from someone to prove that you love them and besides, I am not the only Singh in the world who does this. Several Gursikhs from almost all Sikh jathebandis kept some form of bibek in the past and still do.
Under this thread, I wrote very clearly that I love non-amritdharis too and am just following my Guru’s hukam to not have roti-beti dee saanjh with them. Take for example Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib; a hefty percentage of students who learn Punjabi, Gurmukhi, Gurbani Paath and Sikh History are monnay bachay. Never has it occurred to me (or other Singhs) that they are inferior kids or anything like that.
I think your impression that I have “Breath-taking arrogance” for non-amritdhari stems from the fact that I advocate associating or doing sangat of gursikhs and avoiding sangat of manmukhs. But Veer jee, this is only based on Gurbani. How many pankitis do you want, instructing us to avoid manmukhs?
You have taken my comment that Khalsa need not thank anyone else but Vaheguru, out of context. I don’t know why you raised the question of constitution and taxes to begin with. But I said to you that I am not getting anything for free here in this country. I pay taxes and my father has been working in this country for 35 years and has paid enough taxes. He was around when the constitution was drafted and finalised in the early eighties.
If you bow before one Vaheguru, you don’t have to bow before anyone else. If you thank Vaheguru, you don’t have to thank anyone. If you satisfy Vaheguru and make him happy you don’t have to make anyone else happy, they automatically get happy with you. It is like that story when Rishi Durbaasha with 10,000 of his followers came to embarrass Panchaali by asking her to feed them. As per Mahabharata, she satisfied everyone’s hunger by feeding Krishna alone. It is a long story that if you want I can post but the point is that if you thank Vaheguru, you don’t to thank anyone else.
Having said that, I am not against thanking individuals who you feel deserve recognition. There is no such maryada of not thanking anyone. I said something in a different mauj and you seem to be in a different frequency.
---------------
Vir Ji by being arrogant you are putting a concrete wall around Sikhi and stopping it to shine it as it deserve, be careful, You are my brother as we both are sons of Guru Gobind Singh Ji, That give me right to Gently awake you from your deep sleep from not loving others like you would love anybody else and see their contribution as valuable as our father would see them.
------------
I appreciate your concerns and love for me in general and Sikhi in particular.
----------
Open your arms for the world, you are strong enough not to get contaminated even if somebody evil give you a hug, to be honest you may change their evil ness just by mere hug.
---------
You seem to have really misunderstood and think that I don’t hug anyone or don’t go near anyone. I happen to work for an employer where I am constantly in touch with all kind of people. I never preached that we should not even touch anyone or even talk to manmukhs. You totally took everything out of proportion.
---------
I do get frustrated with your comments some time, sorry about that but I can’t help it, that is how I am.
----------
Kyoon, Fikar-e-Duniya mein sarr khapataa hoon,
Main kahaan aur yeh vabaal kahaan |
Veer jeeo, Fikar-e-duniya chhad devo. Do what you can but don’t worry too much about anything. Our duty is to do Karma and it is up to Vaheguru to worry about anything.
---------
By the way I do not think you was paying tax in Canada when they was making the constitution, which provide you with most of the rights you have in Canada, by not thanking other you will be isolated and if Isolation was desired the Guru Nanak Dev Ji would not have gone to debate with Sidh on the Sumaer Perbat.
-----------
Yaar, kuchh nahi hon lagaa. Guru Sahib saaday naal hunn. “Sirr upper Thaada Gur soora”. Guru Sahib is always with his Khalsa. “Kichh haath kisai de kichh nahi, sabh chale, chalaaye”.
-----------
Also when did you or anybody gave even a single cent to the gentleman who invented the protocol for the internet to work?
Should we be thankful to him ?
----------
Everything that you and I have in this life is because of some good or bad karma we did in our previous lives. Nothing comes for free. Koi khaas loR nahi kisai hor da shukar karan di. If we are able to thank Vaheguru by doing his Naam Simran, there is no need to worry then.
-----------
Should we be thankful to those World War two Soldiers who gave their lives so we could live in free world ?
----------
There is no need to thank anyone else. We all probably were there in the world wars and who knows we may have died there. Our elder brothers – thousands of Gursikhs – fought in these wars.
-------
Your moorakh Brother
Kulwinder Singh
---------
You Maha-moorakh, Maha-Arrogant Veer,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 05 Mar 2005
I for one, respect Kulbir Singh ji very highly and it breaks my heart to disagree with him. But here I do.
My impression of Amrit is that a true amritdhari would be more humble, more willing to be of sacrifice, and more apt to be sensitive to the needs of others.
However, it seems that amrit is promoted as a reason to indulge in selfish behaviour and brahmin-like divisions...even amongst fellow Sikhs. I have no idea why certain desi Sikhs are obsessed with such practice, but I find it to pe particularly abhorrant, as well as contrary to the spirit of gurmat.
There are several posts that are here that indicate a concern of a slippery slope. A recent one discussed holding hands being anti-gurmat. A repeated concern voiced is that if first holding hands is acceptable, then more prominent public displays of affection would be appropriate.
Well, I see a slippery slope here. This insistence of social dividing lines in the Indo-Canadian community has gone so far that Rajinder Singh Atwal had repeatedly stabbed his 17 year old daughter until she met her death. WHY?????
Her crime was.....GASP....dating a white man??
THAT WAS THE REASON WHY HER OWN FATHER BLUDGEONED HER TO DEATH?????
I for one am thoroughly disgusted with this sort of logic, and this kind of behaviour.
I do not mean to insult anyone here...and I apologize if I have.
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Non Amritdhari · 06 Mar 2005
What exactly is the problem here?
Because Amritdharis won't eat from your hands? As a non Amritdhari I have no problem with Bibeki Singhs.
The most inspiring, piaar-filled experiences and love I have been shown, are from Bibeki Gursikhs.
It is everyone who is blowing this out of proportion saying Bibeki Amritdharis dont love non Amritdharis. A true Gursikh loves everyone. That does not mean he would eat food off a murderer or prostitute - but he still shows them love - and would you expect a Gursikh to prefer the Sangat of a murderer or prostitute over that of a Gurmukh?
And what has an honour killing got to do with Amritdharis and non Amritdharis?
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Kulwinder Singh · 06 Mar 2005
Dear Non Amritdharis Ji,
Murderer and prostitute are light years apart,
One mentioned have killed somebody for something, other one sells their body for money ( many of them do because they do not have choice or was exploited earlier),
One have caused huge hurt, other one may be hurt herself by others.
Be Kind and careful in your language, regardless of your status as Amrit Dhari or non Amrit Dhari, Even as a human you should be wise enough to make a distinguish between the two.
I am not asking you to love either of them but be just wise to see the difference.
And Dear pipz Ji, I admire your “ Knowledge of other Peoples Castes” I though Jagir Kaur is declared Sikh , I never knew that she belived in caste system and does not want to be known as Sikh and her “ Preferred” Status is Lubana rather Then Sikh, Many Thanks to You Vir Ji, People like you do “great Seva to Sikh Penth” in painting the penth in the mud of castism in a very disguised way so people can not say to you what on earth was the need to bring the caste in this post ?
Never the less your point apart from bring the caste does have weight on the level where you say “THE REALITY most parents were forced to accept it they did not kill their kid. They had to live with the pain so please if theres thousands of cases where people accept and 2 or 3 decide to kill lets not bring religion into it.”
You may say that Redwhite&blue mentioned the name of the Rajinder Singh with his caste based Surname, If that man have used that name in General before then Redwhite&Blue kaur is in no wrong but If he has never done that before and Redwhite&blue has posted his Caste based Surname then she is wrong in bringing that out, But I do doubt it very much that she would do that kind of mistake.
You strangely ask question “Now if you miss red and white chilled with drinkers and meat eaters 247 how would u end up? honestly? “
I think reading Redwhite&Blue’s post , If she was chilling up with Drinkers and meat eaters 24/7 then she will, certainly want them to give up any kind of bad habits so they are not hurting themselves or others around them, where it is meat issue – we all know there are two arguments in the Sikh Penth about it , that does not mean I eat meat, I am Vegetarian but I do not label others bad if they are not.
I think she will end up very happy and satisfied to have helped any of them if they needed her help.
I think there is need for more focusing on the real issues, and permoteing even on the form the welcoming message, the tolerance, the unconditional love for all regardless of their religion and spiritual status as it has been shown by our Guru’s throughout the history.
We need to say bad is bad if the contents are bad of somebody’s character and they hurt other beings in their life style or by thier actions for everything else there is love available for all creations of GOD. Those who have bigger heart need to even show compassion even more then average to those who are labelled bad to change them to good.
That is what I think anyway and that is how Guru Nanak acted in his life, remmber : Sajan Thag, Bhumia Chor and others.
Redwhite&Blue have raise an Important question of these people who act in such way of killing someone as they do, but we can not say that this have nothing to do with our collective cultural thinking.
Unfortunately the tangle of religion and cultural is such that, we do have obligation to condemn these kind of things in public to get the facts right as this has lot to do with the culture but nothing to do with the religion, Those who think there is no need for this kind of interface from the Sikh Community are failing to see the amount of money rest of the world spend on PR, which is always been appalling in Sikh Community. Our failure to talk to the world has kept us down well below the status we deserve on the world level.
I congratulate Redwhite&Blue Kaur for raising this issue.
We should learn how to deal with these issues and condemn them in proper way when they happen rather then keeping quite and avoiding because that only bring question marks on Sikh Community, which is highly undesirable and misfortunate.
Bul Chuk Maf
Kulwinder Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 24 Mar 2005
I'm not quite sure why quoting a news story is a controversy. But...as I have no desire to learn or understand the caste system...perhaps there will be some things that I do not understand.
This is the story as I know it. I used the name as it appeared in the story. I was not the author of this article.
http://www.canada.com/vancouver/theprovince/news/story.html?id=acbb3224-7370-43f4-8d36-57cb08dec984
Father guilty in stabbing death of teen
Canadian Press
NEW WESTMINSTER, B.C. (CP) -- A father who the Crown says stabbed his 17-year-old daughter to death to prevent her from living with her boyfriend was found guilty Friday of second-degree murder.
A jury delivered its verdict against Rajinder Singh Atwal, 48, after five hours of deliberations that began Thursday. A conviction for second-degree murder carries an automatic life term with no chance of parole for between 10 and 25 years.
Justice Catherine Wedge of the B.C. Supreme Court will decide when Atwal will be eligible for parole at a later hearing.
The trial heard Atwal left the Vancouver area July 30, 2003, to drive his daughter to Prince George, B.C., to be with her boyfriend, Todd McIsaac.
Later that afternoon, Atwal drove her bloodied body, with multiple stab wounds, to Langley Memorial Hospital, where she was pronounced dead.
He claimed his daughter had stabbed herself when he stopped for a rest break at Cache Creek. Atwal said he had left the car and when he returned, he found his daughter had stabbed herself.
But a pathologist told the court the knife blows that killed the popular girl were not self-inflicted.
During his testimony, McIsaac wept as he recalled the last time he spoke with Amandeep after she had returned home from Prince George to visit relatives in the Vancouver suburb of New Westminster.
"She said she missed me and wanted to come back," McIsaac said. "I told her I loved her."
McIsaac, 20, broke down when Crown counsel Keith Kinash asked what arrangement they had made to meet the next day in Prince George.
He said Amandeep's father was planning to drive her there from New Westminster and he had wanted to meet her half way.
The lovers, who met in school in Kitimat, B.C., had run away to Prince George 10 days before over the objections of the girl's family, McIsaac said.
They had only been in Prince George three days when she went with her parents to relatives in New Westminster so she could explain away her sudden move to Prince George.
Her relationship with McIsaac wouldn't be mentioned, he said. Instead, she would tell relatives she was going to Prince George to attend school.
But when Amandeep called him July 29, she said her relatives were making her uncomfortable and she was cutting short her visit. Her father would be driving her back the next day.
"She said he wanted to bring her back," McIsaac said. "He insisted on driving her back."
McIsaac said he met Amandeep in a high-school science class in 2001 and they became inseparable.
"But we had to keep it secret from her parents and other East Indians because she'd get into trouble," he said.
He said her parents didn't want her dating boys.
The trial also heard that about two months before she was fatally stabbed, Amandeep had told a friend that her father pulled a knife on her.
"She said her dad got a knife and went after her with it and she got scared and went to the bathroom and locked the door," said Andrea Mendoza, 18, who lived across the street from the Atwal family in Kitimat.
Mendoza said the earlier knife incident occurred around June 3 when Amandeep and McIsaac were also involved in a car accident.
She said Amandeep was "shook up and scared" when she talked about the fight she'd had with her dad.
"There was an argument about Todd and her dad got a knife and she got scared," Mendoza said. "They were fighting and it escalated."
The court also heard from Amandeep's best friend, Andrea Spowart, about the secret affair she had carried out with McIsaac and how Amandeep used "alibis" to keep it from her parents.
"She told them she was out with me and she said, if they tried to contact me, to stall them," said Spowart.
Spowart said that after the car accident, Amandeep told her Atwal had said he wished his daughter had died "so he wouldn't have to deal with her."
© Canadian Press 2005
Re: Amritdharis associating with non-Amridharis - questions
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 27 Mar 2005
5 dots ji,
Your story is quite powerful and one that I don't think I will soon be able to...or even want to, forget.
Multiple colons ji,
Your point about networking is dead-on and should probably be repeated.
I just wish you all had names...even fake ones. It's kind of hard to address someone whose screen name is all punctuation! LOL!
WJKK, WJKF