Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

String Instruments Vs Vaaja

String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Premi · 21 Feb 2005

Admin Note: This response by "Premi" was posted under "Fairy Tales about Raagmala" but since this is a separate topic, we have moved this response by "Premi" to a new thread. Admin ******"Premi's" post starts here*********** ______________I do not think that a person getting ras and spiritual benefits from listening to kirtan done on a vaaja is any different from the kirtan done on a string instrument_______________ What a weak response. So now it is OK to break the Keertan Rehat but not others? They used to use Vajaas and the modern tabla we play in the homes of prostitutes not gurdawara's, this was all done by "modern" Sikhs. On the same coin many great Gurmukhs like Baba Gurbachan Singh, Baba Nand Singh have gotten great spiritual heights reading the Raagmalla. I mean 95% of the tunes we are playing on the vajaa are filmy (yes that does include Tapoban, the mighty iron gurdwara aswell). If you listen to old movies'; return true;" onmouseout="window.status=''; return true;">old movies songs they are pretty much the same as the tunes we are planning. ________while there are numerous rehitnaamaas that stress the importance of sarbloh_____________ Please do qoute some!!!!! And why has not the Akaal Takht laid any stress on the issue of Sarbloh versus steel???? They did not mention it in there Rehat? Anyways another useless post. I imagine Mr Kulbir Singh and his clan will be coming to the conclusion soon that because nodody refutted the claims , therefore Raagmalaa is not bani. Am I right??? Anyways I may have said some harsh things in my posts, if I have offended you I do apologize, just trying to get you to see from both points. I really do think you guys have a great system of bringing back the old time rehats etc. Hopefully one day we can all be as committed as you guys are!!!! Premi

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

. · 21 Feb 2005

I am not presenting any arguments but expressing what I have always felt on this topic. I think one must follow the Keertan Maryada of singing in raags and using string instruments. I feel we must try it to find if it brings any spiritual difference. The Gurbani is supreme, with paras kala, but Guru jee used music, raags as an instrument to express the feeling. And Gurbani combined with proper raag and instrument would be purely magical. Since long I have been trying to find answer to the question, how did Gurujee actually ucharan bani and certainly although it was in raag, I feel it was not similar to the way we hear the classical gurbani keertan done by classical raagis today, who put on a rather musical show with all that aaaa, oooo etc.. That is not how I feel Gurujee sang Gurbani. Guru Sahibaan's spoke Gurbani with so much love, that everyone including, the Nature would become still and listen to Gurbani when Guru jee sang. Once I had this experience when I heard one Gursikh sing a shabad with so much love and so softly, I could feel everything became still and listened to the keertan... Although, love is most important, I feel if we are ignoring the raag associated with the shabad, we are not utilizing one very important information Gurujee gave us to realize the maximum spiritual benefit from the shabad. Music pentrates subconcious minds where our clever concious minds stop the sikhiya from penetrating. [%sig%]

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Tee · 22 Feb 2005

does it really matter what instrument is used, isnt the gurbani and understanding the gurbani the most important bit? Bhai sahib randhir used to play the vaja when he did kirtan non stop (over 30 hours!!!!) he got loads of ras, all the moneh listenin to his kirtan got on a high! the gurbani and the correct pronounciation is very important, yes i no the guru's used stringed instrument, but i dnt think it mattas as much as evry one else makes it out to be. bhul chuk maaf karna vahigurujikakhalsa vahigurujikifateh

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Singh · 22 Feb 2005

Admin Note: Moved from "Fairy Tales about Raagmala". This post belongs to this thread. "I do not think that a person getting ras and spiritual benefits from listening to kirtan done on a vaaja is any different from the kirtan done on a string instrument." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ So then you're also telling me that a person getting ras and spiritual benefits from listening to keertan done in raga is no different from keertan done without raga. The main difference with filmy, western, folk, old sufi tunes, Punjab folk, etc. Is that the Indian ragas are not "composed" by a composer, but were created via a lengthy evolutionary process over the centuries. THEY DO NOT by any means represent the mind of the composer but a universal idea a composition of the universe. You have to try to understand the musicology here, Musically speaking lets divide ras now (to make it easier) Even without vocally singing Keertan over the raga there is enormous amounts of RAS, RAS of Centuries of bhagti that my friend we can not even dream about is only a plus with what guru sahib has assigned us. No one except Sache Pitah, Waheguru could create and execute such sound, such ecstasy, Such delivery, Of the sounds that the ragas posses. Explain how with a vaja and a filmy tune any one will receive RAS? (implying without Shabad Guru). The Ragas transmit not personal but impersonal emotion. Please don’t ever underestimate the hypnotic powers of the raag. We prostate to the Ragas everyday yet we don’t believe in them. We choose to believe are matt over the gurus. When it comes to sarbloh I believe In the powers of sarbloh, with my every breath .The only reason why I made the statement about steel was to get my point across. Sarbloh is and will be forever Guru sahibs rehat. But my problem is, so is “raag dha Keertan”. Tapoban makes this fine statement which make me a sacrifice to their foundation 100000 lacs over, "Gurdwara Tapoban Saahib is dedicated to preserving and practicing Tat-Gurmat Maryada or the most pristine and original form of Sikhism" But how did they miss Gurus Mat Here?..........

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

singh · 22 Feb 2005

"I feel it was not similar to the way we hear the classical gurbani keertan done by classical raagis today, who put on a rather musical show with all that aaaa, oooo etc.. That is not how I feel Gurujee sang Gurbani." ------------------------------------------------------------------ why?................why do u feel that, You have to study music before you opinionate on this. You call them aaaa, and ooooos. If you ever one day decide to take up classical indian music. You will regret and then understand why the aaaaaa, and oooos take place. The human voice was given a gift to be able to sing keertan on the raags as music. The human voice crys in agony in bondage, from the seperation of akaal purkh. Theres nothin aaaa. ooo about it. The problem is your hearing and not feeling (the aaa, ooooo). If youve heard these ragis do aaa,ooos in the darbar sahib, you shouldnt be feeling this way at all, Its expression over the raags.....sometimes...warmups to get ready to perform in front of their Guru. Its almost as if the human voice becomes another instrument....isnt that beautiful??? waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

singh · 22 Feb 2005

(admin- you missed half my post! :) "I do not think that a person getting ras and spiritual benefits from listening to kirtan done on a vaaja is any different from the kirtan done on a string instrument." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ So then you're also telling me that a person getting ras and spiritual benefits from listening to keertan done in raga is no different from keertan done without raga. The main difference with filmy, western, folk, old sufi tunes, Punjab folk, etc. Is that the Indian ragas are not "composed" by a composer, but were created via a lengthy evolutionary process over the centuries. THEY DO NOT by any means represent the mind of the composer but a universal idea a composition of the universe. You have to try to understand the musicology here, Musically speaking lets divide ras now (to make it easier) Even without vocally singing Keertan over the raga there is enormous amounts of RAS, RAS of Centuries of bhagti that my friend we can not even dream about is only a plus with what guru sahib has assigned us. No one except Sache Pitah, Waheguru could create and execute such sound, such ecstasy, Such delivery, Of the sounds that the ragas posses. Explain how with a vaja and a filmy tune any one will receive RAS? (implying without Shabad Guru). The Ragas transmit not personal but impersonal emotion. Please don’t ever underestimate the hypnotic powers of the raag. We prostate to the Ragas everyday yet we don’t believe in them. We choose to believe are matt over the gurus. When it comes to sarbloh I believe In the powers of sarbloh, with my every breath .The only reason why I made the statement about steel was to get my point across. Sarbloh is and will be forever Guru sahibs rehat. But my problem is, so is “raag dha Keertan”. Tapoban makes this fine statement which make me a sacrifice to their foundation 100000 lacs over, "Gurdwara Tapoban Saahib is dedicated to preserving and practicing Tat-Gurmat Maryada or the most pristine and original form of Sikhism" But how did they miss Gurus Mat Here?.......... They say ants are better than us because they can follow a leader, Guru saahib showed us the way but we still fall off track. Yes! raags are harder to learn, Yes! strings are harder to master, But have we lost that "cha" that "prem" To learn, and go perform and present it to guru sahib in his darbar. Or do we feel because Guru sahib isn’t in a living human body now therefore we can slack off, we can throw in filmy tunes and start playing on a reed organ that the British introduced to us, Great! now we can loose more of Gurus matt (We also lost the aspect of sarbloh, as a rehat in a lot of the panth). I want you to honestly ask yourself would any of are ten gurus condemn that cheap imitation for waheguru's music in there darbars, You singing HIS keertan in the tunes that YOU choose. Lastly I want to bring up another difference, Indian raags are monodic (A style of composition dominated by a single melodic line), not polyphonic (Having two or more phonetic values) Cant we see why Guru saahib has chosen Raag, he made no mistake, “a true genius” . What you don’t understand is the simplicity and ecstasy that raag brings one. Raags can present a human, a plant, even a dog! with emotions that have been unprecedented. For saying what you have said, you are applying that the guru never knew the secret, and the glory of music. That if we sing in other tunes OR raags it does not matter. You’re wrong, Bhai mardana played his rabab in raags, these are things we know, we can always argue about things we don’t know, but why find excuses for the things we do know?. Tapoban has taken Great leaps back To Guru's Original Khalsa, “choli parke agay singh!!! But why leave the raags?, Why not go all the way?.............

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

singh · 22 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh) "I do not think that a person getting ras and spiritual benefits from listening to kirtan done on a vaaja is any different from the kirtan done on a string instrument." ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ So then you're also telling me that a person getting ras and spiritual benefits from listening to keertan done in raga is no different from keertan done without raga. The main difference with filmy, western, folk, old sufi tunes, Punjab folk, etc. Is that the Indian ragas are not "composed" by a composer, but were created via a lengthy evolutionary process over the centuries. THEY DO NOT by any means represent the mind of the composer but a universal idea a composition of the universe. You have to try to understand the musicology here, Musically speaking lets divide ras now (to make it easier) Even without vocally singing Keertan over the raga there is enormous amounts of RAS, RAS of Centuries of bhagti that my friend we can not even dream about is only a plus with what guru sahib has assigned us. No one except Sache Pitah, Waheguru could create and execute such sound, such ecstasy, Such delivery, Of the sounds that the ragas posses. Explain how with a vaja and a filmy tune any one will receive RAS? (implying without Shabad Guru). The Ragas transmit not personal but impersonal emotion. Please don’t ever underestimate the hypnotic powers of the raag. We prostate to the Ragas everyday yet we don’t believe in them. We choose to believe are matt over the gurus. When it comes to sarbloh I believe In the powers of sarbloh, with my every breath .The only reason why I made the statement about steel was to get my point across. Sarbloh is and will be forever Guru sahibs rehat. But my problem is, so is “raag dha Keertan”. Tapoban makes this fine statement which make me a sacrifice to their foundation 100000 lacs over, "Gurdwara Tapoban Saahib is dedicated to preserving and practicing Tat-Gurmat Maryada or the most pristine and original form of Sikhism" But how did they miss Gurus Mat Here?.......... They say ants are better than us because they can follow a leader, Guru saahib showed us the way but we still fall off track. Yes! raags are harder to learn, Yes! strings are harder to master, But have we lost that "cha" that "prem" To learn, and go perform and present it to guru sahib in his darbar. Or do we feel because Guru sahib isn’t in a living human body now therefore we can slack off, we can throw in filmy tunes and start playing on a reed organ that the British introduced to us, Great! now we can loose more of Gurus matt (We also lost the aspect of sarbloh, as a rehat in a lot of the panth). I want you to honestly ask yourself would any of are ten gurus condemn that cheap imitation for waheguru's music in there darbars, You singing HIS keertan in the tunes that YOU choose. Lastly I want to bring up another difference, Indian raags are monodic (A style of composition dominated by a single melodic line), not polyphonic (Having two or more phonetic values) Cant we see why Guru saahib has chosen Raag, he made no mistake, “a true genius” . What you don’t understand is the simplicity and ecstasy that raag brings one. Raags can present a human, a plant, even a dog! with emotions that have been unprecedented. For saying what you have said, you are applying that the guru never knew the secret, and the glory of music. That if we sing in other tunes OR raags it does not matter. You’re wrong, Bhai mardana played his rabab in raags, these are things we know, we can always argue about things we don’t know, but why find excuses for the things we do know?. Tapoban has taken Great leaps back To Guru's Original Khalsa, “choli parke agay singh!!! But why leave the raags?, Why not go all the way?.............

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

singh · 22 Feb 2005

(dear admin, i feel as though you guy ripped off one of my arms and left it in the "Fairy Tales about Raagmala". how about you guys add all the raga and string post to this thread starting with my first one ......it would make more sense, this thread feels scattered and just pointless. Start it with my first thread where i asked bhai kulbir singh for his opinion (which im still awaiting :) Following the next response by another singh replied by "premi" and just add the two on top of this.. "Gur poorey kirpa dharee prabh pooree loch hamareee" Waheguru Ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Singha · 22 Feb 2005

I 100% agree with singh on the bringing back of raag kirtan, Guru Arjan Dev Ji took enourmous effort to compose SGGS in raag format, must have been done for a reason right? Its all well and dandy to take a tuk from here and there to make a stance that dancing isnt allowed in sikhi, holding hands isnt allowed in sikhi and all sorts of other maryadas. So when bani goes over and over stating the raag of the shabad, shouldnt we the sikhs of the guru try to at least respect the raag system that Maharaj wrote bani in? In the holding hands thread, Kulbir Singh and Jarnail Singh adamently stated that holding hands is a western thing and Sikhs shouldnt follow it, same as giving wedding rings etc, isnt the Harmonium a western instrument? So why are Sikhs using it?

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Anon · 22 Feb 2005

In the Jungles I doubt Khalsa ported large instruments, dilruba, taus and other such around with them. I would not be suprised if a goat was slaughtered :O a simple drum was made, karas were used, and Keertan was sung together in a simple manner. It is not a Paap to use a Vajja as an instrument. But it is certainly desirable to bring back the traditional style of Keertan. This does need to be done. Some Vajja based Keertan can bring such amazing Anand. It is bad to call this Keertan wrong or Pakhandhee. In the same way it may be better to wear an ucha blue dumalla but it is still acceptable to wear a smaller Gurmukhi dastar.

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

listener · 22 Feb 2005

I am personally not against raag kirtan, but I do think being obsessed with just raag kirtan is not also good. By this, I mean, it is Shabad Guru either way. Bani can never be bad. Personally i find most youth find it hard to listen to raag kirtan. It maybe Kaan ras, but more youth listen to non-raag kirtan. I have also found when listening to raag kirtan, it is good, but when the raagi starts his sa re ga stuff, it breaks the whole mood. Is that not ego? Raag kirtan should only have Gurbani, none of this sa ra ga stuff. Raag is about the emotion behind the shabad when it is written. Quite often the tunes of the raag may create than emotion in some, but others we do not feel that emotion. Most do not even know what the meaning or which emotion is behind each Raag, including some raagis. Sometimes some tunes, not filmy tunes, but simple tunes, create more emotion. You may disagree, but most know it is true.... No one complains about Bhai Harjinder Singh SriNagar wale, who does these tunes all the time. His kirtan is heard more than anyones. Are we saying what he does is wrong? Is him joining so many people to Gurbani a paap? Many people do appreciate kirtan whether simple tunes, or raag both are good. Condemning one or the other is wrong....

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

diesel · 22 Feb 2005

I used to live on AKJ style kirtan, it was the only style of kirtan that I could get into and felt that I got something from it. I could not relate to raag kirtan even though I'd tried listening to it, something just did not click. I remember once (about 6 years ago now) I visited a camp for a day and was talking to a Singh there and the topic of kirtan came up. I was going on about my love for the type of kirtan I was into and this Singh was mad over raag. I remember him saying 'there's something about raag that pulls at the heart-strings like nothing I can describe'. I heard him say that but didn't really take any notice because I didn't know what he was on about to be honest. Then one day I heard a shabad in raag, and there something about it made me fall in love with it. It was at this point that the comment made by that Singh finally made sense. The shabad (words and meaning), the way it was sung, everything about it was perfect. Now for me personally, its all about raag, I can't get enough of it. I still listen to AKJ style kirtan and other styles but nothing seems to hit home like raag, nothing else seems to be able to pull at my heart in quite the same way. [%sig%]

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

singh · 22 Feb 2005

"being obsessed with just raag kirtan is not also good. By this, I mean, it is Shabad Guru either way. Bani can never be bad. " ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- But listener keep in mind that raag was the only music associated with keertan before thats all there was before (in guru sahibs time). If someone was obsessed with just raag keertan how can that be bad, you need to reassess your post. And here i do agree with you bani can never be bad...very true. "Many people do appreciate kirtan whether simple tunes, or raag both are good. Condemning one or the other is wrong...." -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Condemning keertan is wrong, yes. But not the music thats associated with it. Listen i want you to reflect on a statement that was made about raags in my previous post. "The Ragas transmit not personal but impersonal emotion" this is a statement that judges all other music to raga...... Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

harminder singh · 22 Feb 2005

This has been a very productive topic, I was talking to bhai baldeep singh (grandnephew of bhai avtaar singh), and he stated that, from his knowledge, 90% of guru granth sahib should be sung in "dhrupadh" (a form of devotional singing)....then he started singing.....my friend who is not "sabaat surat" was sitting 5 feet away and his eyes welled up!.... If the sangat were listen to bhai avtar singh ji's kirtan....and then compare what we listen to now...you'll see/feel the difference. Guruji's court (guru ka darbar) was a place where the presence of the true-king was sung and the music of the (worldly kings)...was actually taken and developed further. Guruji's court was one of truth and excellence. Personally, I feel that that eminence has been lost with tacky lights around palki sahib, weird rammallay, vaaja, and filmy tunes. I do not, under any circumstance, condemn those gurmukhs who singh with utmost pyaar..no ones bhagtee and pyaar is being challenged here. please listen to the following shabads....by bhai avtar singh ji, and then imagine how kirtan was (as bhai avtar singh is known to have shabad reets from guruji's times) 1) man jaapo raam gopal (raag kanra) listen to it between 9-12pm ( a composition kept in its true form from guru arjun devji's time) 2)main banjaran raam ki (raag gauri bairaagan) listen to this between 3pm-6pm 3) meray greh ayayay, raaja raam bhutaar (proud to be sikh.com)...listen to this at amritvela as it is in raag asavari (3am-6am).... listen to the precision, the devotion, the beauty of the sound, and the pukaar of bhai avtar singh ji... (ps. I am not making him into a sant, so please refrain from going off on that tangent) maharaaj kirpa karray and we should all do ardaas that kirtan in its puratan maryada be restored to guruji's darbar....otherwise it'll be washed out. waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

BirRaas Singh · 22 Feb 2005

The first time i listened to a shabad by Bhai Avtar Singh, it was "tohee mohee mohee tohee antar kaisaa" and i fell in love with this style of kirtan, it was soemthing id never heard before and as explained above "it pulls on the strings of your heart", i got hold of their set 31 raags and it never left my cd player since :) I met Bhai Baldeep Singh when he was in the UK a lil while ago and i applaud his efforts in trying to carry on the revival of puratan kirtan maryada, and the buetiful instruments he has created, i hope people like him encourage more youth to take time out to learn classical instruments.

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

singh · 22 Feb 2005

Exactly....its authentic. How is it that we dont understand the importance of "raag dha keertan", If you go anywhere else in india you will see different religions and they play the same music, with the same instruments to their gurus. They would never dare change. Thats what there gurus wanted. Could someone please elaborate how it is that we always manage to change sikhi? Has the guru-disciple mindstate changed after guru sahib left his body? Have we now lost that same respect that the gursikhs gave guru sahib then? Here are a few quotes from bani underling Gurus love for raga...... raagai naadhai baaharaa einee hukam n boojhiaa jaae || Those Ragas which are not in the Sound-current of the Naad - by these, the Lord's Will cannot be understood. Guru Raam Daas Ji Salok Vaaraan Thay Vadheek 1423 raag naadh sabh sach hai keemath kehee n jaae || Those Ragas which are in the Sound-current of the Naad are totally true; their value cannot be expressed. Guru Raam Daas Ji Salok Vaaraan Thay Vadheek 1423 gourree raag sulakhanee jae khasamai chith karaee || Gauree Raga is auspicious, if, through it, one comes to think of his Lord and Master. Guru Amar Daas Ji Raag Gauree 311 dhha(n)n s raag sura(n)garrae aalaapath sabh thikh jaae || Blessed are those beautiful Ragas which, when chanted, quench all thirst. Guru Arjan Dev Ji Raag Raamkalee 958 guramukh malaar raag jo karehi thin man than seethal hoe || Those Gurmukhs who sing in the Raga of Malaar - their minds and bodies become cool and calm. Guru Amar Daas Ji Raag Malaar 1285 sorat(h) so ras peejeeai kabehoo n feekaa hoe || In Raga Sorat'h, drink in this sublime essence, which never loses its taste. Guru Arjan Dev Ji Salok Vaaraan Thay Vadheek 1425 Here is one from bhai Gurdas jis vaaran... raaganaadh sa(n)baadh rakh bhaakhiaa bhaao subhaao alaaeae|| Considering the ragas and nadas only as the medium, the Gurmukh discusses and recites with love. Bhai Gurdaas Ji Vaars Bhai Gurdaas 6 lastly picture this scene: Alight breeze flowing across the amrit sarovar mingles with a lonely voice. The musician recites a line from a raag malaar -- it could be baba budha ji. The words float high above, supported only by a rabab. Then a chorus of four others echoes the melody. Someone picks up the tabla, another begins shaking the tamborine into ecstasy. Gradually, the singing gathers momentum and a gathering of devotees, mesmerised, starts swaying to the hypnotic waves of the raga. -lets bring that back Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

asdf.com · 23 Feb 2005

It is the naam kamaii of the person/jatha, rather than the tunes/instruments that determines the 'ras' of the keertan!

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

singh · 23 Feb 2005

I would truly like to hear Tapobans faisla on this. Bhai kulbir singh i urge you once again come forward and may we do vichaar on this. Wahguru ji ka khalsa wahguru ji ki fateh,

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

singh · 23 Feb 2005

"Author: Anon Date: 02-22-05 10:20 In the Jungles I doubt Khalsa ported large instruments, dilruba, taus and other such around with them. I would not be suprised if a goat was slaughtered :O a simple drum was made, karas were used, and Keertan was sung together in a simple manner. It is not a Paap to use a Vajja as an instrument. But it is certainly desirable to bring back the traditional style of Keertan. This does need to be done. Some Vajja based Keertan can bring such amazing Anand. It is bad to call this Keertan wrong or Pakhandhee. In the same way it may be better to wear an ucha blue dumalla but it is still acceptable to wear a smaller Gurmukhi dastar." --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Read my first post over again. Theres no way you read it

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

khoji · 23 Feb 2005

My dear brothers, Logically speaking, you all know, that various raags have various moods.. like some are sad , some jovial etc etc... Now if there is a shabad that explains the emotion of "Virah" as one guru sahibaan must have felt for his Guru then in that case if we sing that shabad in a raag that is for jovial mood how can that touch our hearts. So thats the reason various raags were defined.... Moreover if it is sung in a specified raag its ok and if not even then its ok just that singer will not be able to express the emotion correctly ... but what is needed from us listeners is to understand the bani ... nothing else Inj taa asi kisi vi gall da mudda utha sakday haan ... par aiday naal rabb milan nahin lagga .. khoji

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Me · 23 Feb 2005

How can someone say you shouldnt as a Sikh get obsessed with Raag kirtan, the Bani is composed in Raag..were the Guru's obsessed with it? What a ridiculous thread. Everyone knows that tapoban and the Kirtan they do is not even done in Maryada even 1%, banging the vaja and shouting Waheguru is not Gurmat Sangeet Maryada, I get a headache listening to all the shouting, God is not deaf, something which should be kept in account, especially at AKJ events.

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

i · 23 Feb 2005

this is an excellent topic.lets not spoil it by starting to argue now....

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Singh · 23 Feb 2005

Here is a post from earlier on this month that the Adminsposted, it is about the old time jatha and raag. very interesting.I suggest you all read it with an open mind and not bring any jathebandi into this subject. Very good subject is this though.keepit going. _________________________________________________________ Author: Admin Date: 02-09-05 12:18 The Gift of Keertan is Given by the Guru Taken from Gurmat Lekh by Bhai Saahib Randheer Singh Translated by Admin www.tapoban.org In truth, the fountain of Har-keertan flows forth in every hair and pore of only those Gurmukhs who are in tune with the vibrations of the shabad and in whom the nectar and heavenly light has blossomed. The raags and naads walk with folded hands behind those cherished gurmukhs of the guru, who sing the praises and virtues of Vaahiguru, drenched in the divine colours of love and devotion. When one becomes coloured in God’s colours and starts keertan in these divine colours, then one attains enlightenment from the heavenly world about the raags. Many personal examples of such keertan experiences come to mind, but here sharing just one experience of the philosopher’s stone like power of keertan will not be devoid of spiritual bliss. One time, we were engrossed in the joy of simple, straightforward keertan together with all the keertanee Singhs, in the village Tandray, district Ludhiana. Intoxicated in the repetition of the blissful shabad, we were doing keertan, when out of nowhere, a blind tabla playing Singh, who was an expert of raag vidiyaa, came and started playing tabla. Back then, we used to just make do with a dholkee and even now, we make do with this. We didn’t have even the slightest clue about the ghars of raags and we still don’t. What would be the benefit of making an empty boast? We consider it our good fortune to sing gurbani with child like love and devotion. As well, from the very beginning our primary focus has been on doing keertan of pure gurbanee only. Through the grace of Guru Maharaj, at the very least, we can certainly feel the divine nectar from keertan binding to us. Without knowing the feeling, without the realization of being connected with the ras (pleasure, nectar of keertan), we didn’t consider keertan to have had its effect on our account (lekhaa). As well, keertan was sung to obtain that spiritual nectar. Never was the purpose of keertan to put a show on for people or to please people and this has not been our purpose to this day. Pierced by the divine nectar, we would do keertan for many hours and many pehars (a pehar is 6 hours) without tiring. The celestial colours of keertan would continue blossoming in increasing amounts. The keertani jatha was ecstatically doing keertan at the apex of this blossoming of divine spiritual colours when the blind raag expert, tabla player arrived. Lots of great keertan was done and he also played the tabla with extra enthusiasm. There was no limit to his astonishment when he found the jatha to be complete in sur and taal. After the completion of the keertan, he began praising the keertan with a member of the sangat who was knowledgeable about raag vidiyaa. He wasn’t aware that a keertania of the jatha was listening to him praising the keertan. A surprising thing that he told was that he had heard that some raagi jathas, filled with pride about their raag-vidiyaa, had said that this jatha only knew how to rip their larynxes apart (by screaming and shouting), and that they don’t have even the slightest clue about raags. Today however, hearing a Bilaaval raag shabad performed in the beats and measures of raag Bilaaval from this jatha brought more bliss than I’ve ever had from hearing any raagi. The most amazing thing was that the time of day was for singing Bilaaval raag as well. Hearing this, we kept our laughter and our amazement inside, for we didn’t even know which raag was bilaaval raag, or how to sing it and what the time for singing it was. None of us had learnt how to sing raags from any raag vidiya school. He was overflowing in his praise of our expertise in raag. He thought that the entire jatha had obtained raag vidiyaa from some outstanding raag vidiyaa school. We listened to these words of his quietly and did not let on that we had heard anything. However, we had full faith and knowledge that we had no quality of raag vidiyaa within us. Rather, we became certain, and it was the first day that our faith became bound in this, that Satguru Jee blesses us with the skills to perform His keertan. Satguru Jee himself assists in the keertan of those who are in a state of longing and drenched in love. Without any conscious effort, the knowledge of raags and naads appears. Countless thanks go to the Guru, the knower of hearts, for Himself getting keertan sevaa done by his devotees. Even us unknowing, naïve fools have become receptacles for his gracious glance. Dhan Satgur Nanak Nirankari, Dhan!

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

singh · 24 Feb 2005

"The raags and naads walk with folded hands behind those cherished gurmukhs of the guru, who sing the praises and virtues of Vaahiguru," ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Please confirm this in Guru granth sahib maharaj We didn’t have even the slightest clue about the ghars of raags and we still don’t. What would be the benefit of making an empty boast? ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Maybee bhai sahib and the jatha didnt then, but why can't we change that now? As well, from the very beginning our primary focus has been on doing keertan of pure gurbanee only. ----------------------------------------------------------------- Yes, but this can still be done singing with raags Never was the purpose of keertan to put a show on for people or to please people and this has not been our purpose to this day. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- It should never be the purpose, The reason why one would sing in raags is for the guru only. However, we had full faith and knowledge that we had no quality of raag vidiyaa within us. Rather, we became certain, and it was the first day that our faith became bound in this, that Satguru Jee blesses us with the skills to perform His keertan. Satguru Jee himself assists in the keertan of those who are in a state of longing and drenched in love. Without any conscious effort, the knowledge of raags and naads appears. Countless thanks go to the Guru, the knower of hearts, for Himself getting keertan sevaa done by his devotees. Even us unknowing, naïve fools have become receptacles for his gracious glance. ------------------------------------------------------------------------- If this is a writen account of bhai sahib randhir singh, i dont think theres a single one of us in this forum that can compare to the gursikh he was, But for the no avastha fools like me cant we step in and learn raag dha keertan. Its not like we have to goto jail for loong periods of time. Guru sahib did kirpa on this jatha. But has he done less on us, every single one of us a has acess to a computer with internet. We all have good lives, cars, beds to sleep on at night. Not many hardships we had to face like the Gursikhs before us. We can take the time out to learn raags, and if not whats are excuse. *** Bhai kulbir singh i do not know why you refuse to do vichaar with me on this, but it is your wish. Waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

jugroop singh · 25 Feb 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! For what it's worth... When i got interested in Sikhi about 5 years ago, i heard alot of Raag-based Kirtan on Astra TV stations and some cd's. i enjoyed it but PERSONALLY there wasn't a really deep connection - i think it was just kismat; what other explanation can there be for the feelings and intimations that arise, making us depart from one path to another, from one place to another, from one mat to another...it is VahiGuru HimSelf who leads us to the kind of Sikhi He wants us to experience. Then i experienced 'AKJ Keertan' in the UK - it was an amazing revelation...i felt deep inside that many of the people singing Keertan were really 'up for it' and somehow i could feel this inside...but there was still something about the style and mood, which i first couldn't put my finger on, which made me lose my initial intense reactions. Then i started to listen pretty much only to Tapoban's Keertan Section which i have found is the Keertan style/convention which touches me the most - simply because it suits my preferences...no other reason aside from that...it creates feelings inside me which feel as though my love for the Guru is increasing...i think the style, the love, the fact that Keertanis are not named, there is no Dhunni etc. has led to these feelings. PLEASE DO NOT TAKE THIS TO MEAN THAT I WANT TO START A Pratan AKJ/Modern AKJ Keertan Maryada debate! i guess the only truly relevant and USEFUL question i asked was: Which kind of Keertan singing/listening really moves me and allows my heart to sing/listen, drenched with love? i think this is the way we should perhaps frame the question to ourselves - to OURSELVES!!! When reading Bhai Sahib's account, this was confirmed even more. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

sanatan santra · 25 Feb 2005

if you sing bani from your heart thats what counts whether it be with vaja or string instrument. It is also vital to preserve string instruments as this is prescribed in bani. So Both are right. The essence is true love for God, what use is singing in beautiful raags using rehbaab if the heart is full of bad things?

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

BirRaas Singh · 25 Feb 2005

I dont mean to offend anyone, but sometimes people show allot of hypocrisy in their beliefs, on one side Tapobans articles heavily stress the need to have all Guru Granth Sahib Saroops in larivar format, to this I 100% agree, no doubt., if we apply the same arguements to the format of kirtan then no one wants to know. sanatan santra said "The essence is true love for God, what use is singing in beautiful raags using rehbaab if the heart is full of bad things?" your first comment is correct, but your 2nd comment is baseless, if all sikhs strive to love god, jin prem kio tin hi prabh paiyo, then why would we have a heart full of bad things? Many people on this site esspecially stress the need for sarbloh bibek, the aspect of bana, if we can stress the need for these maryadas then why not kirtan maryada? I agree that learning strings/raag is hard work and takes many years of study, but when has rehit ever been easy? keeping sarbloh bibek is hard, keeping bana is hard in western world, keeping amrivela is hard, keeping concentration in simran is hard, if we can put in the effort to keep these rehits why not put in the same to learning raag and strings? sarbloh bibeks say "give it a try, i guarentee you will fall in love with it", my benti to the sangat here is give learning raag and strings a go, you will fall in love with it

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Kulbir Singh · 25 Feb 2005

BirRaas Singh Veer jeeo, asee paindoo vaaja masaa vajaunday haan, rabaab kithon vajaavaangay? Saanu 18 saal vich hajay takk vaaja chalauna nahi aaiya. Tu yaar sathon Rabaab dee aas rakhda hain? hehe!! I will discuss the kirtan maryada with Singhs over this weekend and see what they say. I personally am not against Nirdhaarat Raag Kirtan and actually love it. If it is determined that it is maryada to sing only in Nirdhaarat Raags, then we should surely follow this maryada. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

singh · 26 Feb 2005

lakh lakh shukar thoda pyaray! Bhai kubir singh, please do get this faislaa from the singhs and if you do get time read my first post, and do take into factor some of those points. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

sanatan santra · 27 Feb 2005

mere birraas singh the point you have taken as "baseless" is assuming that ALL sikhs strive to love God. That practically is the case for real rehetvan sikhs, BUT not too sure bout others if you get ma dreffffft!!

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

kaur · 27 Feb 2005

I think it is a good Upraala if Gurdwara Sahib adopts Raag Maryada, as we should seek to uphold our traditional musical techniques. But saying that, we must not make the Raag itself the centre attention. Our pyaar is always with the Shabad. Just like with all Rehits granted by Guru Jee - we must ensure that we don't make them rituals, but do them with full pyaar to gain the full benefit. Waheguroo

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 27 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh I have only heard keertan performed on traditional stringed instruments once. It was an amazing experience. I hold a B.Mus. degree and performed professionally using four different instruments (including voice). But - there in front of me were these beautiful instruments that I had never seen before in my life! When the ragis were finished, I was so tempted to reach over and try playing one myself. At the same time - it was heartbreaking. These beautiful, precious instruments...who can play them now? Where is this part of our history going? Where could one even go to find such a beautiful instrument, let alone learn how to play it - or to master it? Music is a living language. Certainly, there can be value to putting shabads to music using a popular tune, that perhaps more of the sangat knows. Certainly, there can be value to performing them on an intstrument that is easier for the entire sangat to learn. Music is also a discipline. It is something that is learned over years, not hours. It would be cruel to insist that a sangat member learn an instrument that s/he has no desire to play. But - please - it is so important to rediscover this precious part of our history. Let's find a way to remember it and celebrate it in some way, instead of letting it get lost to the sands of time. Daas, Redwhiteandblue Kaur

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

singh · 01 Mar 2005

I will discuss the kirtan maryada with Singhs over this weekend and see what they say. I personally am not against Nirdhaarat Raag Kirtan and actually love it. If it is determined that it is maryada to sing only in Nirdhaarat Raags, then we should surely follow this maryada. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ bhai kulbir singh, what did the singhs say.........is it maryada>?

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Singh · 02 Mar 2005

Its interesting how we seem to overlook something which is so important and still go on about being the tat khalsa. Guru Ji didn’t go to the trouble of putting almostevery single shabad in Guru Granth Sahib Ji to a raag for the fun of it, or for some self proclaimed Khalsa’s to use their own man-mat and ignore it. Everyone knows that raag alone does not make kirtan special, however our Guru Ji himself used raag and specifically had Guru Granth Sahib Ji set up in a raag structure, therefore if we are indeed his Sikhs we would respect and follow that regardless of how hard it is to learn. Sometimes you see people with bana and all the show, who not only do kirtan in a disgraceful bhangra style and tune but also completely out of sur. This appears to be the most popular form amongst the jatha which is surprising for a so called kirtanee jatha. It’s amazing how only about a hundred years ago Sikhs were the masters of this Guru blessed art and now we have deteriorated to such painful (on the ears) and amateur levels.

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

...... · 02 Mar 2005

respect to preserving string instruments. But many chardi kala gursikhs from the past have sang on vaja including sants. So i do not agree the nihung statement that vaja is a pross. If one leads life with avatsa and God centred and sing shabad on vaja then no one else should judge. You cant just look at the instrument and judge it that way, what comes with it is what counts. I feel great when i hear people like dhulla veer ji and giani amolak singh because they sang from heart. I feel respect to string instrument and rags but not always the same effect as someone who sings from inside.

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

sikh · 02 Mar 2005

There is absolutely nothing anti-gurmat about using a vajaa. It's a musical instrument and the guru's were proficient in many types of musical instruments. Yes, they used stringed instruments, but they did not limit keertan to simply stringed instruments. Many great raagis have performed raag quite well on vaajas. I personally wish that stringed instruments would make a come back, but that doesn't mean stringed instruments are the only instruments allowed for doing keertan.

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

harminder singh · 02 Mar 2005

no offence to anyone here again, but how can one really be sure they are hearing something from within someone else? isn't assuming that you are at a point where you can judge another..man-mat? gurusahib doesn't give us ijaazaat to "indulge" in that type of discriminatory thinking...for rehit and us, yes...but judging another isn't good. As per the earlier days in the jatha, bhai sahib bhai randhir singh met jawala singh (father of bhai avtar singh) 3 times, listened to him sing shabads in raag, in 4taal...and joined in with his karray. bhai sahib requested jawala singh to come back again. This is taken from the book about raags written by gurcharan singh (Son of jawala singh). Anything in maryada is better than not being in maryada...agreed?

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Ranjit Singh · 02 Mar 2005

I personally find raag keertan to be very moving. When at Tapoban Saahib, I hear singhs or singhneaa doing raag keertan, it is incredibly uplifting and beautiful. I am firmly of the belief that we should promote the learning of raag keertan as much as we can. Having said that, I also have to say that there is place for non classical raag keertan as well. If we go by what the veers above are saying, many people who are not proficient musically will never be able to perform keertan. Our guru's told everyone to sing the praises of vaahiguru, and to sing them daily. It would be best if these were sung in gurmat raags and we should strive for that. However, if I am unable to sing in raag, for whatever reason, it doesn't mean I should simply stop singing vaahiguru's praises. If I can't pronounce gurbanee correctly and haven't been able to get proper santhiya, it doesn't mean that I stop doing my nitnem and reading banee. I do my best with what I know. The fact of the matter is, that there are few people with the knowledge and ability to teach proper gurbanee raag. Most people that I know would love to learn proper raag, but they are unable to, due to the lack of teachers. Additionally, learning raag isn't easy. Of course, sikhee isn't easy and we still have to try. However, if we look at the many great gursikhs who did keertan, but not necessarily always in the correct raag (although many did at times due raag keertan), we can deduce why. Many of these gursikhs were simple people, who may have been farming many hours a day or doing other services (military) and they didn't have access to proper raag schools. They may also have lacked money and time. They still wanted to sing the guru's banee, and they did so. They did it with great love and devotion and moved many souls with their keertan. This doesn't mean they were against raag vidiyaa or raag keertan, simply that they were unable to get that training and made due with what they had. Historically, there is also a precedent for this. It's commonly said that when sata and balvand left, the sikh sangat did keertan in simple tunes. It's also said that when Guru Hargobind Sahib Jee were imprisoned, gursikhs did chownkees in pinds throughout punjab, singing gurbanee. Many of these gursikhs weren't trained in any raag vidiyaa and used simple folk tunes. I don't know how accurate these stories are, but they seem plausible. Also, raag keertan doesn't mean going crazy doing vocal gymnastics with all the alaaps, etc. Giani Amolak Singh Jee, Bhai Dharm Singh Zakmee and others do amazing keertan in raag, but with the emphasis clearly on the shabad and not on their musical talents. I've heard gursikhs do amazing keertan in seemingly simple tunes that everyone can sing along with and later learnt that they it was performed in the correct raag. We should strive to learn keertan in the correct raags and should promote this as much as possible. In my humble opinion, raag vidiya should become more of a focus at Gurdvara Tapoban saahib as well. My saying it may be a little hypocritical, since I'm about the least musically talented person around and will be lucky if I can do keertan in simple tunes in this lifetime, let alone raag. At the end of the day however, people are going to sing gurbanee, and sing it in the best way they know how. Instead of constantly complaining about this, the veers who are learnt in classical raag keertan, should teach as many people as they can and go to as many keertans as they can and let the sangat hear the beauty of gurbanee sung in the correct raag.

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

string singh · 03 Mar 2005

looking at it from a musical perspective....the vaaja is insufficient for performing raag. indian classical music, and raag is based on a system of "shrutis" or microtones. whereas a vaja is fixed scale to cut a long story short....say raag x has a "sa" note in it.....well that "sa" note may not be the same "sa" as the one in raag y. there could be a different of a microtone or two. so how can raag be played on a vaaja when the vaaja can only play one sa?

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Amardeep · 04 Mar 2005

"aaa Ooo" This is so so typically of Sikhs today!!! I can't believe we've become so uncultured over the centuries! Hardly surprising when most Singhs at Reinsbhais I've gone to think it's so "chardi kala" when the Tabla player is wacking the living daylights out of the tabla and of course even better when he breaks it! Guys, get a grip, Admin are correct to separate this from the raagmala thread, but listening to Pakhandi tunes in the name of Gurbani Kirtan is a huge fallacy, these are tunes taken from whore houses, bollywood films (whore houses again) and good old Punjabi Folk Jat-boot tunes (which again, I'm sure all will agree are no better than the former whore house tunes). Simplicity is a virtue but not downright stupidness. We are Khalsa, who claim to have Raj, yet "aaa ooo" clearly shows we can't live like Rajas, since our mentality can't beyond the complexity of a tumbi.

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Singh · 20 Apr 2006

Keertan should be done in raag and only raag. And by this I mean not just any raags but those that are prescribed to certain shabads. If we do them out of the raag they are in we are changing the bani. We can't sit here and argue why the Guru ji's used raag but we should not at least change the bani. If there is no raag attached to a bani feel free to read it how you wish. If a raagi jatha can copy songs of Hindi movies (I just heard a shabad by Bhai Satvinder Singh /Harvinder Singhs jatha and it was straight of a song Mukesh had sung in a movie, not that I listen to him but I do study all sorts of music so that at the end of the day I feel blessed that Guru Ji gave us gurmat sangeet which is a higher form than other music and I am also a music student). Now If a raagi can copy that then they can copy raag. I know 18 year old kids who copy kirtan so easily whether it be akj style or raag and they have never undergone professional training. Although it is not perfected raag can be copied so to ensure bani is properly recited. In terms of tanti saaj.. it would be nice to see them come back.. Some may argue that they aren't important but then do you really want to a see and age long tradition die? We listen to stories about our gurus and how great they were and we want to try being like them can we try preserving their gifts as well or is it too "bhamin" or just a "waste of time" or not worth it"? I am not saying Bani isn't important because without bani there would be not gurmat sangeet but if we do kirtan we should stick to the maryada (i think its in akal takths rehit maryada to do proper raag kirtan). Sorry for the long post. If you think this makes no sense I think i does.

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

k · 20 Apr 2006

THis is a FANTASTIC thread - lets not spoil this with personal attacks, abuse and 'cleverness'. Anyway, I would just like to make a point on this matter. A lot of people here are attacking Tapoban Sahib, saying that they are supposed to be the Tat-KHalsa of this day & age, yet they cannot even perform Keertan in Gurmat Sangeet. I am personally pro-Gurmat Sangeet, but I am NOT anti-Sangatee Style, providing Keertan is done with the utmost shardaa, humility and serenity (i.e. no bashing/shouting). I am not from Tapoban Sahib, but I do know that they are doing a BRILLIANT job, with Guru Sahib's Kirpaa, in reviving the true Gursikhi RehNee BehNee Jeevan (lifestyle). However, beause they do not perform GUrmat Sangeet, some members of this forum get 'ras' out of putting them down, as we all do when 'we know something they dont'. Please, I am sure that over time, this revival WILL be complete, but lets continue with the parchaar and not make these silly/childish assumptions. P.S. - Patience is a virtue - let Kulbir SIngh get back to us in his own time - he's not going to blank you out!

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

singh · 20 Apr 2006

I find Raag keertan dry. People talk about it being uplifting, but very few attend raag darbaars. This is just talk and show. If anyone speaks out, then they just jump on them and blackmail them with comments, like those above. Most young sikhs do not speak about it openly because of this. But in reality, most people find raags very dry.

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

premee · 20 Apr 2006

Dry? Why did guroo ji go through the trouble of placing shabads with certain raags, so we could throw them out without notice and label them dry? I suppose bhangra beats and hindi pop songs and of course ignoring the raag that the shabad belongs to are all acceptable. Let's not forget the banging of tabla and screeching of voices, I'm sure this is just what was meant to come out of our kirtan. Kirtan is about your(!) connection with Akal purakh and with the shabad, how can a connection be made if you're not even doing the shabad in the correct raag?!?! It's sad that the only definition people have of 'raag' is vocal sangeet, ooh--aaah as people call it, complete rubbish. Go to Gurmat Sangeet project's website and listen to the local children sing 'raag kirtan', see how 'simple' it is. Stop worrying about stringed instruments, first accept that what you're playing on vaja is incorrect.

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Jeewan Singh · 20 Apr 2006

Everyone is talking about how the tunes keertanees use theses days are from bollywood or pop "music." If you never listen that pop "music", how do you know where they came from? I never listen to that "music", so I have no idea where the tune comes from, to me its new and therefore everytime I listen to the kirtan I only think of the Gurbani, nothing else. The best thing to do is to stop listening to that bollywood stuff, it only helps you more. Also, the Guru's did use popular tunes of their times for Gurbani, such as Asa Di Vaar, its supposed to be sung to the tune of 'Tunda-Asraajaa.' Which was a tune used to praise a raja of the times. Was it wrong for them to use that pop tune? What does everyone think?

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Ignorance! · 20 Apr 2006

Wow, you don't listen to 'pop' music very good, ignorance is bliss after all eh? So that person singing that shabad has obviously listened to 'that' music so it's okay for them to present it to sangat in that format just because wonderful souls like you don't listen to music eh? I'm not sure about Tunda-Asraaja, but what I know is that everything our Guroo Ji's did were for a specific purpose, so when they say Asaa Mahaalla 1 we should all have the decency to follow our shabad in that raag, what right do we have to go against that? It's in there clear and simple for us to follow, and the funny thing is people are still against it, WHY? Obviously there is no understanding of what raag is..I guess it shows that ignorance truly is bliss for most people. This is an EXCELLENT article by Bhai Amardeep Singh JI from Singapore, I'm sure everyone has seen it floating around but today read it from your heart! UNDERSTANDING THE MUSICAL FRAMEWORK OF GURU GRANTH SAHIB Amardeep Singh Hearing the modern experimentalists keertanias doing keertan in highly dramatized forms leads my mind to pose some basic questions like “What does Guru Granth Sahib, our eternal Guru command us on the subject of Keertan?” “Why is that the Gurus chose Raags to classify Gurbani?” “What is the relation between Shabad and Raag?” “Do we need the aid of experimental music to propagate the message of Guru Granth Sahib?” “Have our Keertanias experimented with the vastness of Raags and Taals as prescribed by Gurus?” “What impact will experimentation have on our future generations?” Keertan today has been commercialized to such an extent that barring a few, most Keertanias are only concerned about making a quick money. Their limitations to experiment with the prescribed vastness of Guru Granth Sahib always gets camouflaged in the excuse that Sangat does not prefer to listen to Keertan as prescribed by the Gurus. Gurus wrote Shabads in poetical-metric forms and then associate them with Raags and Ghars (Beats/Taals). Does this mean that Gurus have left no scope for experimentation with music? The indication of Raag and Ghar (Beat) with every Shabad implies that Gurus had a definite motive behind fixing a framework. This framework was not set to limit the ability of human mind to experiment with music but to act as an aid in spiritual development. A simple mathematical permutation and combination on notes of any Raag would indicate that each Raag offers thousands of tunes to experiment with. Poetry (the form in which Gurbani is written) and Music (Raags) are two sides of the same coin. They are independent but yet complement each other. Music versifies and provides melody, uniformity and cadence to Poetry. The factor that binds music and poetry is their Metrical-form (Ghar). Music (Raag) is based on Sound (Swar - Notes) and a combination of Notes produce distinct musical effects. Poetry is determined by Word (Shabad), which communicates a message. Music (Raag) on the other hand conveys a feeling to the heart and is therefore universal. Spirituality after all is striking the right balance between mind and heart. Therefore when Gurbani (Poetry) is complemented with Raag (Music) and bound by Ghar , the resulting effect on mind and body can become the catalyst to change. As explained earlier that Raag conveys a feeling and Shabad a message. A Raag is capable of touching the hearts with the feeling like Joy, Sorrow, Detachment, etc. Upon studying the structure of Guru Granth Sahib it can be seen that shabads relating to common THEMES are generally placed under each Raag. When the broad THEMES of Shabads are overlaid with feelings conveyed by Raags, there emerges a reason behind classification of Shabads under a broad classification of 31 Raags. Its clear that the Gurus used Raags to increase delivery power of shabad to our mind by invoking complementary feelings in our hearts through the usage of prescribed Raags. Within the rules of Hindustani Classical Music, uncountable Raags can be created. In fact any form of music (non-Indian and non-classical) can be classified under some form of Raag. Hence it is a misconception that Raags are something highly classical and beyond the realms of common mans understanding. In-fact any form of music is Raag. But in Guru Granth Sahib, the Gurus have gone into depths of Poetry, Music and Metrical forms to lay the framework that is best suited to convey the feeling and message of the Shabad simultaneously to the human mind and heart. When each of the prescribed Raag offers uncountable permutation and combination of musical compositions, then why is it that the modern Keertanias are not experimenting within the prescribed framework of the Gurus? Gurbani says Among all Ragas, that one is sublime, O Siblings of Destiny, by which the Lord comes to abide in the mind. (Page 1423) Clearly, only that Raag is prescribed by which feeling of spirituality is aroused. Gurus have not prescribed catchy musical tunes that dominate the Shabad. The essence of Keertan lies in effective delivery of the message of Shabad, using Raag and Taal as a medium. The medium cannot dominate the essence. This is where our modern day keertanias are making the mistake of experimenting beyond the prescribed framework of Guru Granth Sahib and singing shabads in catchy tunes. At the end it’s the tune that remains in the mind and not the message. Music is a double edged sword. While it can be effectively used for constructive Keertan by operating within prescribed frameworks Guru Granth Sahib, on the other hand it can also be used for arousing destructive feelings by use of catchy tunes (as explained earlier, any form of music can be classified into a Raag). It would be interesting to note that the main object for having caused the current day deterioration in quality of Keertan is the most widely used musical instrument called Harmonium. Harmonium is not an Indian instrument. Over 100 year back, the Europeans bought the Harmonica to India. The air box of this European instrument was experimented by Indian musicians to develop a new instrument called Harmonium. This instrument is not best suited for Indian Classical music. According to Indian Classical Music, the human ear can recognize 22 musical notes in an Octave. The Harmonium only offers 12 discreet keys in an Octave. Only string instruments offer the ability to play 22 notes in an Octave by pressing the string at mid-points. It is for this reason that Indian Music was always played with accompaniment of only string instruments. In fact if one sees the old pictures of Harmandir Sahib, one would only find string instruments being used by the Keertanias. Although Harmonium offered a compromise to Indian Classical music and should have never been used in the Indian system but it gained rapid acceptance because it was very easy to learn and use. Learning a string instrument required close to 4 – 5 years professional training but Harmonium could be learnt in less than 2 months. This was a great blessing to aspiring Sikhs who also wanted be able to do Keertan. While there is no harm in using Harmonium and we must also accept its contribution in making it easier for the masses to learn Keertan and help them start their spiritual journey. But it also caused the biggest deterioration to Keertan singing. The professional Keertanias, were now finding it hard to keep pace with rapid generation of new breed of Amateur Keertanias. Materialistic desires lead them to shorten their classical training period by moving to Harmonium. Over generations, this trend lead to complete elimination of string instruments from the Gurudwaras. Lack of dedication that crept in because of the ability to learn Keertan in just 2 months also lead to Keertanias start doing Keertan in catchy filmi tunes. Yes our modern day Keertanias should be given 100% score for having the ability to experiment with music. But unfortunately, this experimentation with catchy tunes is causing more harm than good to the Keertan, as they have stopped experimenting within the prescribed framework of Guru Granth Sahib. An instrument that was supposed to attract the Sikhs to Gurbani has become the very reason for the downfall in present day standards of Keertan. It would have been fine if Harmonium would have been adapted but not at the expense of compromise on string instruments. It should have acted as a stepping stone for the budding Sikh Keertanias to quickly acquire musical sense and move forward to experimenting within the prescribed framework of Guru Granth Sahib. Instead they have chosen the short cut. The reason for citing above example is to show the long term pitfalls associated with un-checked experimentation. Modern day experimentalists keertanias need to be cautious and introspect. The first question that needs to be answered is that what is attracting the youth to this new style of Keertan? For all probability it is the music that is attracting them because Keertan is being done in modern day, highly dramatized form. I have heard a shabad “Mitar Pyarae Noon…..” in which Thunder, Lightning and sounds of wild animals complement the shabad to project the scene of Machiwara jungle. The only reason one would get attracted to such style of Keertan is because of music. Like any MTV Top of the Charts, such music can’t last long in the minds of the youth. On the other hand maybe the youth is getting attracted to this style of Keertan because effective English Translations are being provided. If that is the case, then the translations can also be provided while doing Keertan in the prescribed framework of Guru Granth Sahib. After all there are thousands of tunes that can be created from each of the prescribed Raag and these tunes need not be highly classical in order to cater to the tastes of the youth. Even Gurus did not allow the dominance of classical music over the Shabad. Gurus support forwardness but where should we draw the line? Who knows, next could be an experiment with Jaap Sahib being sung in RAP STYLE! Will Jaap Sahib in RAP STYLE lead to feelings of spirituality? The future of Keertan lies in the hands of present day Keertanias. They need to definitely look at ways of improvising and attracting the youth but not at the cost of further deterioration of Keertan. Our Keertanias should first make the effort to acquire full knowledge of the musical framework of Guru Granth Sahib and adapt from within it, to be attract the youth not on a short term basis but on long term basis. I have full faith in the Guru and believe that if our Keertanias make an earnest effort to implement the commands of Guru Granth Sahib in their Keertan singing style, then the pied pipers will not need to walk the streets to attract the youth, they will come to the Gurudwaras by themselves. In the next sequel to this article we will examine another aspect of Keertan singing that has gone unchecked for years and is leading us on the path contrary to that of Gurmat. FLOW AND PAUSE IN GURBANI & KEERTAN follows……….

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Jeewan Singh · 20 Apr 2006

Please do not call me a wonderful soul, I am nothing of the sort. I never said Raags were not to be followed, I was just commenting on those who keep on talking about pop "music." I was curious so I looked up Raag on Wikipedia [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raag] and in the article it mentions how some Indian Pop "music" resemble raags. Also after reading the article above and noting that many tunes [even those that are not classical] could be in raag; maybe we are just pointing fingers at Kirtanis just because their kirtan doesn't sound classical and they aren't telling the whole world that they do all their kirtan in Raags. I also fail to understand why the Harmonium is a lesser instrument when compared to Indian string instruments. Could someone explain that?

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

just me · 21 Apr 2006

1) many tunes in bollywood are adaptions of raag. Does that make a raag anti-Gurmat? 2) harmonium is not an instrument for prostitutes. No instrument is good or bad. They are just instruments. Stop being so sad. If it is easier to learn keertan on a waaja, so whats wrong with that? As long as the person joins with the Gur-shabad, its fine. Are you telling us dilrubas, and other string instruments were never used in prostitutes houses? Because they were! 3) you guys are more kaan rass, because you guys spend more time worrying about the raag than the shabad.

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Ignorance! · 21 Apr 2006

Much of Indian pop music, perhaps not so much the modern ones have come from the Raags system, many which our Guroo Jis themselves have created. The point here is not about 'classical' or 'modern', the point here is about FOLLOWING the instructions your Guroo Ji gave you and singing the shabad in the right format (right raag), it can be as simple and complicated as you want. It can sound like a nursery rhyme or a masterpiece, the point is it must be in the correct raag. From the above article it says: Harmonium is not an Indian instrument. Over 100 year back, the Europeans bought the Harmonica to India. The air box of this European instrument was experimented by Indian musicians to develop a new instrument called Harmonium. This instrument is not best suited for Indian Classical music. According to Indian Classical Music, the human ear can recognize 22 musical notes in an Octave. The Harmonium only offers 12 discreet keys in an Octave. Only string instruments offer the ability to play 22 notes in an Octave by pressing the string at mid-points. It is for this reason that Indian Music was always played with accompaniment of only string instruments. In fact if one sees the old pictures of Harmandir Sahib, one would only find string instruments being used by the Keertanias. Although Harmonium offered a compromise to Indian Classical music and should have never been used in the Indian system but it gained rapid acceptance because it was very easy to learn and use. Learning a string instrument required close to 4 – 5 years professional training but Harmonium could be learnt in less than 2 months. This was a great blessing to aspiring Sikhs who also wanted be able to do Keertan. While there is no harm in using Harmonium and we must also accept its contribution in making it easier for the masses to learn Keertan and help them start their spiritual journey. But it also caused the biggest deterioration to Keertan singing. The professional Keertanias, were now finding it hard to keep pace with rapid generation of new breed of Amateur Keertanias. Materialistic desires lead them to shorten their classical training period by moving to Harmonium. Over generations, this trend lead to complete elimination of string instruments from the Gurudwaras. Lack of dedication that crept in because of the ability to learn Keertan in just 2 months also lead to Keertanias start doing Keertan in catchy filmi tunes.

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

Visitor · 21 Apr 2006

Is there any info online about the exact tunings of various scales and Gurbani raags?

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

hmmmm · 21 Apr 2006

dont tell us that stringed instruments are not used for wrong purposes i.e. bollywood etc...

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

observer · 21 Apr 2006

what is wrong with people learning keertan on a waaja in 2 months. By your own admission it takes 4-5 years to do the same raags on a string instrument. If people use a waaja to join to bani then it is fine. It is the bani that is important. Stop being so fanatical!

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

visitor · 21 Apr 2006

sorry to be a pain but is there any classic instrumental player on internet who knows the proper music theory of the gurbani raags and could answer detailed questions on email? thanks

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

gurmatsangeetkar · 25 Apr 2006

what is your question in regards to [%sig%]

Re: String Instruments Vs Vaaja

visitor · 25 Apr 2006

Sat Sri Akal thank you for your responsse. i have so many questions on this subject perhaps email would be a better way (addy provided - delete underscores). specifically i want to know the correct tunings/tones required for traditional gurmat sangeet. i imagine giving someone a chart with 3 octaves of western piano with subdivisions between each note, alongside which the notes of each raag can be marked down (e.g. a column for each raag/that) along the precise applicable subdivisions (as exact as possible). i want to calculate frequencies from this chart or other source, plus for each obtain information about any rules for deviation/counterpoint etc.