Re: Your opinion please
sach vaapaar karo vaapaaree · 17 Feb 2005
hamree jaath paath gur satgur ham vaychio sir gur kay
Re: Your opinion please
sach vaapaar karo vaapaaree · 17 Feb 2005
people who have ego about their caste are worse than insects in the toilet
Re: Your opinion please
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 17 Feb 2005
Guru Nanak's take on the matter is incontrovertible.
Re: Your opinion please
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Feb 2005
i agree with S Singh.... I know of no Jatt gurdwaras..but there are plenty of rangharia Gurdawras, Bhatra Gurdwaras, Bhagat ravidass gurdwaras. etc etc..??? why???
jarnail Singh
Re: Your opinion please
Singh_meharban · 19 Feb 2005
There could be some skill (and also stupidness), associated with a caste; but linking oneself with a caste due to feeling of superiority or insecurity; is wrong for a sikh. No one is superior due to race and no one is insecure with Lord on his side.
Re: Your opinion please
................. · 19 Feb 2005
jats are not a caste cos they in all walks of life, and not a race because theres a lot intermixing from the start as other races were accepted into jatherahood which is why jats looks very smart some with european, arabic, refined looking while some look native desi.
jats are more a culture that kept its jatherahood bukhara from other religions. Way to influential to dissapear, with a long history.
Ramgharias do look closer to sikhi because they keep paghs with trimmed beards and jatts are direct in your face monai or pagh.
But when it comes to dieing for sikhi its jats who are the front no one can dispute that. If jats are stuck up about their caste they will tell you, if they love and accept you they will tell you. Thats a lot better than being sly about caste, loads of others pretend to be without caste and say they fight against it but they open their own gurdwaras, backstab other sikhs, do slyness, all while saying their sikh. What happened to ramgharias in 84?
The people trying to make jats look bad need to open their own eyes to how they see others who are not the same as them. It is their own brahminvaad and jelousy obsession with jats that hurts them.
Do yourselves a favour and dont bother with topics like this you will only put up more borders.
The only thing you can do is accept the facts as they are and if you guys want to make changes then let us tear down the ramgharia signs on gurdwaras first, let us see how many of you marry your daughters and sisters to chamars. This is silly on one hand caste gurdwaras are justified on the other jats are singled out for baiting.
Re: Your opinion please
Kulbir Singh · 21 Feb 2005
Some of the posts under this thread seem to be a result of extremely low intelligence. I don’t understand how being born in a Tarkhaan family or in Jatt family can be of importance when it comes to Sikhi. Sikhi is about obeying hukams of Guru Sahib and leading a life drenched in Naam Rass.
The biggest Jatt is Vaheguru himself who provides all the food necessary for this world and he alone is the greatest Tarkhaan for shaping and carving such beautiful creatures in this world. When Vaheguru himself is the greatest Jatt and the greatest Tarkhaan, why are we fighting over this?
Our Guru Sahibaan were of Khatri background. Who could be more Veer (brave) than Guru Sahib himself? Guru Gobind Singh jee’s bravery and courage knew no bounds and he was from a Khatree background. They say that Jatts can only fight but have no brain but in our history some of the greatest vidvaans have been from Jatt background e.g. Baba Deep Singh, Kavi Santokh Singh etc. Bhai Sukha Singh who killed Massa Rangarh was of a Tarkhaan background. Sikh history has shattered all stereotypes associated with different castes.
First we divide ourselves between Jatts, Khatrees and Tarkhaans. Then we divide ourselves between Majha, Malwa and Doaba. This regional division of Majha, Malwa and Doaba even haunts us here in Canada. The reality is that we are Khalsa of Guru Gobind Singh jee and after Amrit Chhak we are nothing but Khalsa. Hamree Jaat Paat Gur Satgur…
Having said that it won’t be incongruous to mention that Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written that our previous castes and other backgrounds vanish only if we keep strict Khalsa rehit. If we don’t keep strict rehit of not associating with Manmukhs in the cases of Roti and Beti, we cannot escape the influence of our previous castes.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Your opinion please
Harsimrat Kaur · 21 Feb 2005
guru ji taught us al load of things. Guru nanak dev ji said
´there is no hindu, there is no muslim´
meaning everyone is equal.
why fight over what caste group people are. we are all from one caste group. KHALSA. Guru gobind singh ji gave us the names singh and kaur. this means we come from the KHALSA caste. stop fighting. the first thing gurbani teachs us is about PEACE and MEDITATION.
Do what gurbani teachs you and nothing else!!!!!
Re: Your opinion please
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh.
Almost everyone seems to have missed the Ultimate "medicine" to cure this "dreaded disease"...mentioned by Kulbir Singh ji ...Bhai Sahib BHAI Randheer Singh jee has written that this Caste disease will be KILLED ONLY by REHAT. Just like "darkness" has no feet when LIGHT appears....jaat paat has no feet when REHAT takes over the Fort.
Keep your REHAT and be a KHALSA of GURU GRANTH JI....its a "joke" that only "Dabrro ghussrro kachey pillay sikhs" bring up caste..its a FACT that once REHAT occupies our Body and Mind Fort...small things like castes etc have no place..even in the cracks....but once our REHAT weakens..the cracks widen and such "thieves" creep in..KEEP THEM OUT at all costs.
BTW the jibe about SINGH SABHA GURDWARAS being "jatt gurdwaras by default" is a cheap shot at a Mahaan lehr that shook off the shackles of Hindu mahants and Bipparwaad..and made our Gurdawras free of these parasites...seems like their "modern day agents" are still trying their luck to creep back in and control our gurdwaras...
Jarnail Singh
Re: Your opinion please
kulwinder Singh · 28 Feb 2005
Shame ! Shame ! and Shame !
on all the fake Sikhs,
one thing for sure either you are Jat, Tarkhan, Chamarm or Khatari or Sikh.
So people who bring caste to divide Sikhism now or paint the ugly paint of casteism on Great Sikhism are the No 1 Enemy of Sikh Penth.
Everybody should be on alert,
Admin you should be careful in filtering the evil intentions, I feel on this thread the start and some other part fall well below the good intentions.
I strongly advise admin to close this topic now and preferably delete the entire topic from the form history I do mean this seriously.
Thanks
Kulwinder Singh
[%sig%]
Re: Your opinion please
singhz lets unite · 01 Feb 2006
Shri Guru Nanak Dev Ji said that a person is only is low cuz of the things they do, the way they act. and the only way the person is high is with the stuff that person does. caste took place cuz of back in the days im talkin back in really back long long looooooooong time ago when mankind was just begining to get used to earth and how life works, there wasnt any education back then. thts when this caste system took place. there is on such thing as jaat Sikh or tharkhan Sikh etc etc. there is only one type of Sikh. even bhrahmans are a lot lower thatn, theyre nothing is front of Khalsa. im not Khalsa is supposed to be a caste but u get wat i mean...