Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Your opinion please

Your opinion please

Bahdy · 17 Feb 2005

Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh I am writing this message as a humble request to all the sangat for their opinions on a specific matter regarding caste/race! I have always been taught that caste plays no part in Sikhi, but I have noticed recently there has been a resurgence in matters relating to caste. Now this is not a local matter, because i have noticed this as an issue in 4 continents now. I do not wish to sound over-sensitive, but as a trainee Sikh i was always taught that this was a non-issue and the behaviour of indivisuals has really begun to anger me. Now certain individuals (especially from the North American region) have now started to divide Great Historical Sikhs by caste/race too. They do this by claiming that their specific caste is not actually a caste, but a race. Below are just some specific examples of their work. FAMOUS JATT ICONS ICON'S NAME JATT CLAN RELIGION Baba Buddha Sahib Randhawa Sikhism Jatt Dhanna Bhagat Dhaliwal Bhagti Movement Baba Deep Singh Ji Shaheed Guram Sikhism Nawab Kapur Singh Virk Sikhism Akali Phoola Singh Sran Sikhism Bhai Mani Singh Dulat Sikhism THE ICONS OF THE JATT RACE By Lord Jatt BEHOLD!!! And suddenly I close my eyes, I hear the Merciless Scythian War cries, A Seeking Voice takes me back in time, And I see the Earth, the Water, the Land sublime. "What is this!" SHOCKED, I shout, "What's going on!", "What's all this about?", "Relax", the Mysterious Voice insists, "I am Wisdom", it continues and persists, "And now you will watch, your Ancestor's grace, The Icons of the Jatt Race". And so my friends, this time travel starts, The knowledge of the minds, the tales of the hearts, The folklores all enjoy, an Oldie or a Kid, So now let's just talk what our forefathers did. Long ago, in a land far-far away, They worshipped the Sun, as the Greeks say, And fearless they were, young or old, Massa Getae were they called, as I am told. They tamed the Horse, their gift to mankind, Love for Earth and Water, always in their mind, They fought the wars, they ruled the lands, They hunted in the forests, they relaxed in the sands. And the time passed, now they thought it's worth, To move towards all directions of the Earth. One of those tribes moved towards the East, And all came, man, woman, child and their beast, They came towards the rivers of Beas and Chenab, One of them said "Let's call it Punjab". They protected the land, worked tough in the fields, And then celebrated with drum beats, the season of yields, Thus created a Culture, of celebration, bravery and gut, And took pride in the title "Son of a Jatt". Now about their love, something on romance, Born lovers they were, and its not just by chance, That we still remember Ranjha, and his love Heer Sial, And the roarings of our Great Mirza Jatt Kharral. In Jeona Maur and Jagga, Robinhood was seen, Where Justice was the thirst, they had been. And now on Religion, and the word of God, The wisdom of Baba Budha and Ranjit Singh's Sword, Their countless Sacrifices, in a never ending spree, And those who died, because they were Born Free. Their Destiny, their Pride and their Esteem on Earth's Face, They are the Icons of the Jatt Race. Gill salutes Jatt Ancestors, to them much respect, thus, Their Unseen Hands, always blessing us, We are like a Tree, and they, our Base, May we never forget, the Icons of the Jatt Race.

Re: Your opinion please

Me ME ME · 17 Feb 2005

What a Joke!! How strange that Lord Jat thinks that Baba Budha, Baba Deep Singh and Bhai Mani Singh should be recognised for their Jatism as a pose to their Sikhi. Sikhi grabbed them an took them way above being a Jatt.

Re: Your opinion please

- · 17 Feb 2005

I wonder why jatts have this superiority complex because from what I am told, though I could be wrong, they are actually quite down on the superiority scale.

Re: Your opinion please

sach vaapaar karo vaapaaree · 17 Feb 2005

hamree jaath paath gur satgur ham vaychio sir gur kay

Re: Your opinion please

sach vaapaar karo vaapaaree · 17 Feb 2005

people who have ego about their caste are worse than insects in the toilet

Re: Your opinion please

Singhstah · 17 Feb 2005

wat a load of utter crap

Re: Your opinion please

???? · 17 Feb 2005

the peeps going into ego of jaat paat again are going furthing into what Guru took us out from.

Re: Your opinion please

S Singh · 17 Feb 2005

>> >>I wonder why jatts have this superiority complex because from what I >>am told, though I could be wrong, they are actually quite down on the >>superiority scale. Utter tripe. But I dont think it is so called Jat who have superiority complex it is the so called thakhans (Ramgarhia) who name Gurdwara so they are associated with the Thakaans etc.

Re: Your opinion please

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 17 Feb 2005

Guru Nanak's take on the matter is incontrovertible.

Re: Your opinion please

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 17 Feb 2005

i agree with S Singh.... I know of no Jatt gurdwaras..but there are plenty of rangharia Gurdawras, Bhatra Gurdwaras, Bhagat ravidass gurdwaras. etc etc..??? why??? jarnail Singh

Re: Your opinion please

Me ME ME · 18 Feb 2005

S Singh and Giani Arshi seem to be a bit defensive of the 'Jatt' caste. Regardless of the 'Ramgharia' Gurdwaras, the comments that this posting refers to are anti-Gurmat. Jats, Ramgharias etc are all a waste of space and are not Sikhs.

Re: Your opinion please

Bundha · 18 Feb 2005

Actually Jatt gurdwaras are called Singh Sabah Gurdwaras. Most if not all Singh Sabah gurdwarass in england are Jatt controlled adn they do not hide the fact. When I was growing up the term 'jat' was always used when someone did something silly or stupid, he/she would be called 'jatt'. I always regarded jats as rather backwards with lots of land and little brains where are the takhans had the brains and skills. I was quite surprised when I grew up that people were proud to be jats ! [%sig%]

Re: Your opinion please

Bahdysut · 18 Feb 2005

Vahiguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vahiguru Ji Ki Fateh J Singh, I have already asked people in the know regarding this issue. The use of Ramgarhia Gurdvara’s started in Tanganyika (which is present day Kenya, Uganda and Tanzania in East Africa). I was informed that when the workers (who were all Ramgarhia) arrived in East Africa constructed and maintained Gurdvarae which were abrutly titled ‘Ramgarhia Gurdvarae’. Now apparantly the reason why this happened was historically in India the Tarkhans/Ramgarhia would build all the Gurdvarae, but when it came time to set up the committee’s, many were unable to secure seats (due to there being a large number of the Jatt community who would be voted in democratically). Now whether it was due to any kind of discriminatory pratice is unclear and not confirmable, but it did occur. So when the time came for the Ramgarhia section of the community to build (and more importantly run) their Gurudvarae, they titled them as Ramgarhia. Now by writing this, I am by no means placing my weight behind it or condoning others historical actions. My personal opinion is that the conceept of Gurudvarae based on division is abhorent. But please Sangat Ji, stick to the topic at hand (which relates to certain indivisduals trying to take our hero's in Sikhi and try to nigate their contribution to Sikhi by adding labels to them which they themselves rejected) and lets not let this turn into a ‘Jatt vs everyone else’ debate/issue.

Re: Your opinion please

namey · 18 Feb 2005

If it wasn't 4 jatts...where would you get your freshly produced food from? And what brains are required to carve a piece of wood?? Both jatts and thakaans utilise their skills on nature. The farmers lay the seeds and watch the crops harvest...then reap what they sowed. then the thakaans gobble up the food in the form of roti, sabzi...to get energy to work on chopped down trees! Oh chak de pfatte!! (now don't tell me you;ve neva used that catchphrase B4! always wondered of it's origins...) But anyway... ...Just sum food 4 thought! Bhul chuk maaf. But dis daas is an utter moorakh. _/\_ [%sig%]

Re: Your opinion please

hmmm · 18 Feb 2005

hey singh sabha is not a jatt gurdwara. In fact a lot of non jat non practicing but sikh affiliated people who would have otherwise be percieved to go to gurdwaras more down to their caste actually go to singh sabhas. the committees in singh sabhas are made up of sikhs. When the committees are made sikhs with minimum if not maximum loyalty to rehit are looked for. However in some cases unfortunatly certain groups and families have extensive links in the community where monnai get involved for personal gain like a bussines sense and to keep the take, its vital to stick to the network and that sadly how punjabi society operates outside sikhi fresh from punjab with caste. Thats all it is. To vouch for a fact singh sabhas are not jatt gurdwaras i can confirm the committee in my local one is very mixed and my own friend was asked to be part of it who is not a jatt but ex pakistani migrant into punjab. The sole reason he was asked was because although he has not taken amrit he has maintained kes, dastar, does prescirbed bani everyday, fought for dastar issues of sikhs in the force. This is in contrast to the majority sangat in the area which is mona and out fr the take, so when it comes to it people look at your record not your damn caste.

Re: Your opinion please

hmmm · 18 Feb 2005

my uncle has been an ex pardaan of one of the east coast american gurdwaras 6 years ago. I can confirm though i believe i am casteless that we were not jat to begin with. My uncle was chosen due to his dedication and commitment. I kjnow exactly who you guys are talking about. the cronies at jattworld are mostly lost monnai, they are not sikh. When they are lost they are looking and screaming for an identity. Just like paks in uk waving pakistani flags on eid, going nuts on cricket matches committing suicide when they loose, screaming. This is what happens when people loose what they really are. so then you get empty shells left. I cant disproove the essays on jattworld because some of it is actually recorded in history, But i do happen to think that they have lost the plot and gone too far with their own matt. The fact is most pnjabis are from jat culture even todays non jats, we are not from a luv kush theory from ram/krishan/, punjabis are blatently of persian descent outside the pale of hindus. Soime Hinduised persians became categorised into castes by accepting brahmins as their priests. Jat culture was based on scythic culture which tried to oppose islam and hinduism creeping on punjab. The type of jat the cronies talk about is a modern entity that came about due to the successes of the khalsa where every tom dick harry became a sikh to get their gain and given jagirs. This is why they keep talking of whos got more land? who has outdone who? stupidness like that, what they fail to see is that amrit and sikhi is what took sikhs from pits to tops. Then again they wont even keep their kes so what to talk of amrit and sikhi?

Re: Your opinion please

Bundha · 18 Feb 2005

Scratch the surface and all the jaat/paat prejudicies are still there, how sad. [%sig%]

Re: Your opinion please

.... · 18 Feb 2005

lord jatt/ and co is not stupid hes a logical guy but living in a distant world that belongs in history. They need to realise the differences between passion and what is! Jats and rajputs are the two largest south asian quama spread from india to pakistan that would potentially dominate If ever they came under one banner they would be the rulers. Herodutus pointed that out directly. Some jats later became muslim, some sikh, some hindu some athiest. Lord jat/his likes/ and others at jatland.com have these dreams of a united jattish identity that transcends religions and borders. Their dreams sadly remain dreams as different groups of jatts have taken on variety of religions. Sadly again when it comes to wars between muslims and sikhs in 1947 it was more jat v jat and then sikh v hindu again it was jat v jat in hariauna. Given this close proximity of tug of war over land, water, domination and religions taken as go betweens it would be impossible when faced with facts as to how lord jats type visions would ever work out. After 1984 who really wants to sing about Jat jeona maur as a punjabi legend? all that would come into the mind of the average sikh is thats a hindu and we have been done over by hindus. How many sikhs with a lord jat thinking would want to extend their memories of jat culture all the way to gupta? but guptas are now converted into hindus with brahmin like status. So faced with a new world we have to put the past where it belongs, or take what is suitable from it if it helps us become better and discard the outdated gunk. Sikhism is very clear and concise. It goes with the living it sadly its used part time by many which is why youth get confused as to what they are meant to be.

Re: Your opinion please

.... · 18 Feb 2005

bundha ji true sikhs do not believe in jaat paat and just by mentioning jat or researching it doesnt make one a jaat paati.

Re: Your opinion please

Bundha · 18 Feb 2005

.... point taken.

Re: Your opinion please

M S · 18 Feb 2005

Today most Jatts are monay. Jatts are to busy banging the dhol with a bottle of barcardi on their head not a dastar!!

Re: Your opinion please

singh · 19 Feb 2005

"Today most Jatts are monay. Jatts are to busy banging the dhol with a bottle of barcardi on their head not a dastar!!" ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Dear M S that is a pretty moorakh statement youve made, how can you gerneralize jatts like that. In fact There is a lot of hardworking, and truthful living jatts that dont drink and do where dastars on their head, mass amounts of jatts were shaheed in 86' for the panth, and why i call them jats because not all of the shaheeds took guru ka amrit. And i feel that statement you made is even disrespecting them. No they all dont bang the dhol with bacardi on their head. A lot of them practice truth. It might not make them true sikhs for calling themselves jatts, but that still doesnt give you the right to make that statement.

Re: Your opinion please

.. · 19 Feb 2005

m s its that kind of stereotyping that is wrong. i know many good hearted jatts who do not drink may have cut hair and do simran and paat, my friends dad wakes up 3am does panj banis asa di var and sukhmani sahib every morning without fail. We should increase as much unity as we can singh. Less condemning, i would rather see our brothers and sisters have as much rehit as they can than see them get pissed off leaving after getting cussed which has happened and move over to bahai, sufis, buddhism etc. We have to make concious efforts to form bonds one day such people will have something born in them to take amrit. Not everyone will have an ideal approach to life, l;east we can do is hope n do ardas. I am not a jatt but many families in my relatives have been ruined by alcohol including mine, i blame the stupidity and selfishness of the person drinking it affects others around them.

Re: Your opinion please

ahem · 19 Feb 2005

what singh has said can be verified by visiting holy bones gurdwara leicster khalsa human rights. Out of 3000 shaheed recorded profiles of names pend localities and time well over 500 were monnai and mostly jat. This is not a caste thing its how it is, not all jatts are drinking shrabi kebabi. Its upto us to at least make the effort and understand that not every single jat is the type you encounter on jattworld.com or jazzy b type. One good monna jat i know lost everything after 84 his father was killed, tortured, and then the family had to leave their zameena in uttar pradesh and then the gov took the sons right away from the zameen which was huge amounts of land. Hence sacrificing everything livelihood, family members and coming to england penniless and starting all over again. To be fair its also a fact the kharkoo movement was side stepped which slowly turned into jat against jat one type wanting khalistan the other being moderates not. this whole thing is nothing to do with caste itself its about numbers and jats just happen to be the majority hence easily get crunched into someones eyes as bad or good and definatly do impact influence results. So if they all came under one punjab would be another story thats why iot is very important we keep radaswamis and rss in check and not allow dissollutioned brothers to be swept away.

Re: Your opinion please

Singh_meharban · 19 Feb 2005

There could be some skill (and also stupidness), associated with a caste; but linking oneself with a caste due to feeling of superiority or insecurity; is wrong for a sikh. No one is superior due to race and no one is insecure with Lord on his side.

Re: Your opinion please

................. · 19 Feb 2005

jats are not a caste cos they in all walks of life, and not a race because theres a lot intermixing from the start as other races were accepted into jatherahood which is why jats looks very smart some with european, arabic, refined looking while some look native desi. jats are more a culture that kept its jatherahood bukhara from other religions. Way to influential to dissapear, with a long history. Ramgharias do look closer to sikhi because they keep paghs with trimmed beards and jatts are direct in your face monai or pagh. But when it comes to dieing for sikhi its jats who are the front no one can dispute that. If jats are stuck up about their caste they will tell you, if they love and accept you they will tell you. Thats a lot better than being sly about caste, loads of others pretend to be without caste and say they fight against it but they open their own gurdwaras, backstab other sikhs, do slyness, all while saying their sikh. What happened to ramgharias in 84? The people trying to make jats look bad need to open their own eyes to how they see others who are not the same as them. It is their own brahminvaad and jelousy obsession with jats that hurts them. Do yourselves a favour and dont bother with topics like this you will only put up more borders. The only thing you can do is accept the facts as they are and if you guys want to make changes then let us tear down the ramgharia signs on gurdwaras first, let us see how many of you marry your daughters and sisters to chamars. This is silly on one hand caste gurdwaras are justified on the other jats are singled out for baiting.

Re: Your opinion please

rav · 19 Feb 2005

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/8170103045/qid=1108667002/sr=11-1/ref=sr_11_1/103-5385710-5809451 Editorial Reviews Dr. Cynthia Mahmood, Assistant Professor of Anthropology, University of Maine from Waterville, ME USA Author traces Punjabi cultural characteristics back to the Scythians.....a resonance from ancient to modern times... quite a readable book. Product Description: THE NOMDAS (Past and present) The thunder of their hoofs was heard for miles away sending people scampering for cover and safety. First to tame and mount the horse, these marauding nomads ruled the steppe for five hundred years. History calls them the Scythians. Around 300 BC, these noble warriors were displaced from their homeland by their nomadic cousins. Some made their way to the Indus Valley, the heart of what came to be known as Punjab. Two millennium later some of their descendants are on the move again, primarily because of economic and political pressures. These are the Sikhs who have migrated and joined the mainstream in western countries and have distinguished themselves as entrepreneurs, politicians, professors, artists, writers, doctors and engineers. THE MAVERICKS (old and new) Jats, the progeny of the Scythians flourished in Punjab. They excelled in farming and animal husbandry. Matchless as soldiers, they are unafraid to take arms to fight for their rights and those of fellow beings. Many converted to Islam, some embraced the Sikh faith, while others were assimilated into Hinduism. But, they remained nomadic at heart: fiercely independent. Their rugged individualism often sets them at odds with one another, splitting them into factions. Customer Reviews Reviewer: Dr. Cynthia Mahmood, Assistant Professor of Anthropology, University of Maine (Waterville, ME USA) - In this interesting essay Bhupinder Singh Mahal attempts to trace Punjabi cultural characteristics back to the Scythians, focusing particularly on the independent nomadic spirit that still infuses the Punjabi (especially Punjabi Sikh) diaspora. It is quite a readable book, and the author's creation of a resonance from ancient to modern times rings true for anybody with a sense of the Punjabi character. There are fascinating asides and plausible if speculative linkages among various old and new traditions, the characteristic turban-wearing among them. However, this book suffers from the same problems that plague much South Asian academic writing - lack of citations. There are informal references to all manner of writings, but no detailed citations that one could check, and little attempt to rigorously evaluate sources for their reliability which unfortunately makes the treatise less than scholarly. This author's experience in Canada adds something to his understanding of Punjabis and the issues they face. He is able, for example, to draw on Canadian stereotypes about the people of Newfoundland ("Newfies") to comment on subcontinental humor about Sikhs. He grasps more than most Sikh authors in Punjab the truly global character of the community today, and therefore is well placed to expound on his theme of long-term nomadism in the culture. The diasporan South Asians are not best viewed as "ex-pats" at a distance from their homelands; rather, the diaspora is itself part of the South Asian cultural heartland. (Certainly we have seen this in the Khalistan movement, for example.) On this key point, the author has an important insight to offer. Trying to track the motif of travel back into history is an innovative, if by nature speculative, endeavor. Bhupinder Singh Mahal is to be commended for the attempt.

Re: Your opinion please

kaz · 19 Feb 2005

I THINK THE ISSUES OF CASTES WILL ALWAYS ARISE IN SIKHS BECAUSE WE HAVE GURDWARAS NAMED UNDER CASTES, E.G RAMGARHRIA GURDWARA, BHAGAT RAVIDASS GURUDWARA. I HAVE NEVER COME ACROSS JATT GURDWARA !!!!!!!! IF YOU TALK ABOUT JATT DOMINATED COMMITEES, ALL THEM GURDWARAS WILL BE NAMED UNDER THE GURUS OR SINGH SABHA WHICH IS NOT A CASTE IT IS A RACE!!!!! THESE GURDWARAS WILL BE JATT DOMINATED BECAUSE RAMGARHIAS AND RAVIDASSIA HAVE MADE THEIR OWN GURDWARAS AND PERFER TO GO THERE, WHO WILL RUN AND GO TO THE GURDWARAS NAMED UNDER GURUS AND SINGH SABHAS, THE PEOPLE THAT DON'T PUT THEIR CASTE FIRST !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: Your opinion please

singh · 19 Feb 2005

what about darkans? they did this many moons ago with jassa singh ramgharia no one peeped an eyebrow then. now all of a sudden some jatt goes and does it. truth is there is no caste but apply that back to everyone why just jattts?

Re: Your opinion please

singh · 20 Feb 2005

Just who is doing more castism? singh sabha = - seva open for all sikhs on every level - allows democratic parties to form from any sikh - sevedars taken in what room for caste? -actively encourages community welfare - sends election forms to all sikhs on election time rahgardless of their caste ramgharia gurdwara = (Constituition declaration filled and signed in by ramgharia sevedars) - oath signatory to work for welfare of ramgharia community ( opposed to sikh) - permitting hindu vishwakarmis on committee board (hindu equivelent of ramgharias) - declaring the committee sevedar is of ramgharia origin (automatically excluding any other sikh) - the written constituition of ramgharia gurdwara is based on a hindu caste system that only a person born from a carpenters family may be eligable to enter the committee The crux is not about being disgruntled with committee but the sheer hindu castism existing inside a caste gurdwara set up written constitition operating. ramgharias went and opened their own gurdwaras because of their own caste complex this is reflected by their caste constitituition . In order to justify ramgharia gurdwaras existing they will point out that singh sabhas are jatt gurdwaras. Singh sabha lehar is a legend a revolution that freed gurdwaras from mahants and british control. This is a big insult so many singhs were shaheed for this struggle which led to singh sabha. ravidasis opened their "temples", it is upto them to adopt gurmat rehit, if they so badly want sikhi then where are the dastars? panj kakars?nishan sahib?. So then singh sabha is left with no one else attending but jatts. So why do others keep saying this is a jatt gurdwara? It really boils down to rehit, singh sabha is closer to khalsa rehit than other gurdwaras, if others say thats jat due to their insecurities then they need to evaluate their claims in terms of sikhi.

Re: Your opinion please

hera · 20 Feb 2005

when it comes to sikhs caste is not about your proffession or same as the hindu caste system as some would have us believe then backing up their views with gurbani which talks about brahmin hold on society. The point is different. Its the type of influence that prevails like, turkans ravidadsis, have hindu gangetic influence that is why the sanatn sikhs say ramgharias are closer to the sanatan ideology. The ramgharia gurdwara neville rd led a nagar kirtan to back hindus in their crusade on babri masjid in 1992. The true khalsa will never take the side of oppression. This is a clear signal of gangetic influence on ramgharias. But jatts, were fairly independant with their own history, recorded family trees, customs. Because others stick to part hindu customs obviously jatts being indepedant in nature will differ as the jatt history is virtually non gangetic. This is the difference, if all otthers took their hindu influences off and followed sikhi and backed the khalsa on miri piri there would be no difference. It is quiet hypocritic to tell jatts off when the people doing that are themselves more open to sanatan culture. The youth are not always religious, and hence you get the jatt vibe more. What i do not understand is why do people pick out non practicing sikhs calling themselves jatt to smear jatts? Let them be, whats eating you? Stop putting blame on people just sort yourself out.

Re: Your opinion please

M S · 21 Feb 2005

Today most Tarkaans are pugwallay with trimmed beards. Tarkaans are to busy banging the dhol with a bottle of barcardi on their head on top of their 'ready made cardboard' pugs!!

Re: Your opinion please

S Singh · 21 Feb 2005

Yes how many thakhans you ever seen with full beard ? Also they wear them hat type turbans set so hard with starch etc that they last for years. I agree with what singh said in that it is the thakans etc who propagate and fueld the caste divide in Sikhi by openly naming Gurdwara along caste lines even though there is not part for that in Sikhi. I remember years ago a relative telling me about how they had one Gurdwara in the village where everyone went regardless of caste. Then a few people started to complain saying they needed village land for a Gurdwara that the "lower castes" could use. Many of the perceived "upper caste" pleaded with them not to do this as it was against the teachings of our Guru and doing so would just propogate a divide. They did not listen and built their own Gurdwara.

Re: Your opinion please

Kulbir Singh · 21 Feb 2005

Some of the posts under this thread seem to be a result of extremely low intelligence. I don’t understand how being born in a Tarkhaan family or in Jatt family can be of importance when it comes to Sikhi. Sikhi is about obeying hukams of Guru Sahib and leading a life drenched in Naam Rass. The biggest Jatt is Vaheguru himself who provides all the food necessary for this world and he alone is the greatest Tarkhaan for shaping and carving such beautiful creatures in this world. When Vaheguru himself is the greatest Jatt and the greatest Tarkhaan, why are we fighting over this? Our Guru Sahibaan were of Khatri background. Who could be more Veer (brave) than Guru Sahib himself? Guru Gobind Singh jee’s bravery and courage knew no bounds and he was from a Khatree background. They say that Jatts can only fight but have no brain but in our history some of the greatest vidvaans have been from Jatt background e.g. Baba Deep Singh, Kavi Santokh Singh etc. Bhai Sukha Singh who killed Massa Rangarh was of a Tarkhaan background. Sikh history has shattered all stereotypes associated with different castes. First we divide ourselves between Jatts, Khatrees and Tarkhaans. Then we divide ourselves between Majha, Malwa and Doaba. This regional division of Majha, Malwa and Doaba even haunts us here in Canada. The reality is that we are Khalsa of Guru Gobind Singh jee and after Amrit Chhak we are nothing but Khalsa. Hamree Jaat Paat Gur Satgur… Having said that it won’t be incongruous to mention that Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written that our previous castes and other backgrounds vanish only if we keep strict Khalsa rehit. If we don’t keep strict rehit of not associating with Manmukhs in the cases of Roti and Beti, we cannot escape the influence of our previous castes. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Your opinion please

000000 · 21 Feb 2005

baba deep singh ji was not from a tarkan background !!!!!!!!!!!!!! we are not fighting in these post's but just saying to take out issues of casteism in sikhi, we have to stop naming our gurdwaras under caste first!! we read gurbani in the gurdwara, which say's there should bo no caste, but the same gurdwara will be named under caste e.g ramgarhria gurdwara!! the commitee will be structured on the basis of caste!!

Re: Your opinion please

Harsimrat Kaur · 21 Feb 2005

guru ji taught us al load of things. Guru nanak dev ji said ´there is no hindu, there is no muslim´ meaning everyone is equal. why fight over what caste group people are. we are all from one caste group. KHALSA. Guru gobind singh ji gave us the names singh and kaur. this means we come from the KHALSA caste. stop fighting. the first thing gurbani teachs us is about PEACE and MEDITATION. Do what gurbani teachs you and nothing else!!!!!

Re: Your opinion please

000000000 · 21 Feb 2005

gurbani teaches us there is no caste !!!!!!!!1 let's stop naming gurdwaras under caste e.g ramgarhria gurdwara why not call them khalsa gurdwara !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Re: Your opinion please

hera · 22 Feb 2005

i could not agree more with kulbir singh. Prob is two different things. kulbir singh is a dedicated gursikhi aspiring towards practical sikhism like many here and that would be the prime goal of taking amrit for many especially in jatha. BUT then comes what actually happens most of the time. It might be sad, sick, crazy, bad But can we deny there are no differences? Can we say no this is wrong and this is how it should be and everything would be ok? Singho i say what i say not out of ignorance but what i experienced with ramgharia sikhs, is a total opposite comes across like a shock when compared to singhs from desh punjab. Karkoo singhs are looked upon as mad brainless terrorists, in 1992 the nagar kirtan alliance with sanatan hindus on babri was fresh at a time when ludhiana faced a massacre torture of singhs, rapes of singhanis, and killings of children right after gurdaspur. On televisions ramharias put up old wise men to keep that message " we are the extension of hinduism". sanatan sikhs gain more ground with these hindu beliefs. If this hindu matt was absent and complete khalsa like was adopted as bhai kulbir singh and many of us would want then there woyuld be no ramgharia terkaan jatt or anyone. but khalsa. I never used to believe that punjabi people would feel the hurt of punjab more or less than others, but having spent time with ramgharias i have found we are ridiculed for our pend accents, direct ways, we are made out to look like we are backward. But where are these people when the jang kicks off? I certainly do not refer to caste here i mean african sikhs they have a serious problem with punjabi sikhs that is why they split off. It is unfair thus to blame us for castism. You establish contacts and find out yourselves i dont want to be accused of any stirring. I feel the biggest underlieing thing is not the actual caste one is born in, but the culture adopted and maintained.

Re: Your opinion please

skaur · 22 Feb 2005

'The biggest Jatt is Vaheguru himself who provides all the food necessary for this world and he alone is the greatest Tarkhaan for shaping and carving such beautiful creatures in this world. When Vaheguru himself is the greatest Jatt and the greatest Tarkhaan,' Nice analogy... ...all due respect Bhai Jee... ...but I also think some of the above comments were just light-hearted JOKES! Pul chuk muaAf!! Waheguru Ji Ka Fateh! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!

Re: Your opinion please

M S · 22 Feb 2005

Baba Deep Singh, a Tarkaan. OH MY DAYS! Can this be true?! What a controversy! WHO CARES? Baba Deep Singh was a Khalsa. Not a Brar or a Sandhu or a Channa or a Patel This thread shows how poor we actually are. We have just mocked Sikhi. I thought the youngsters had dropped this way of thinking. Obviously not, the caste system and discrimination of others is here for a while.

Re: Your opinion please

khoji · 23 Feb 2005

amlaan ute haun nabere, khadiyan rahnigiyan jaatan - Bulleh Shah mera aiy sawaal hai .. jihna nay sewa kiti humanity di jay oh jatt see, ramgarhiay see ya kujh hor see ohday naal asi kiwain uchchay ho jaanday haan... asi sikha hai nahin sirf apnay aap nu samjhi baithay haan ... sirf pehraway naal rabb milda taan koi vi aey kar sakda si... aina bharman to uththo tay khoj karo os malik di ...... na o mandiran gurudwaryan chon kisay nu milya hai na hi mil sakda hai ... aa sirf mahaul banan vastay han.. ki sada malik naal pyaar banya rahay ... jihnu kisay nu rabb milna hai apnay andaron hi milna hai...vani ch aa gal kai vaar aayi hai ... asi fer vi duniyavi gallan ch aayee jaanay haan jay guru nanak dev ji nay pandita brahmana nu ganga snan karan tay keha si ki aisa karan day naal mukti nahin mil sakdi fair sahnu kiwain sarowaran ya dariyavan ch snan karan naal mukti mil sakdi hai ... jay os wailay oh theek nahin si tay ajj aa kiwain theek ho sakda hai .. ais karkay malik di khoj karo ...

Re: Your opinion please

singh5 · 26 Feb 2005

caste is not a big problem unless marriage because we dont want to mix up with hindu religion. Jats are more honest and straight about things. Tarks practice caste in a very organised, non visible, and proffesional manner. If it is due to discrimnination tarks opened ramgharia gurdwara then why was their own gurdwara named after caste and why does its rules convey caste practice? How did this formula remedy their suffering? Surely a suffering komb would address the problem and try to eliminate the root of the problem as was the case with racism, moghul rule to maharaja ranjit singhs free for all empire. Like creating a new gurdwara no caste name, free for all in every level and promote how it stands against castism in the face of what it had endured. But that did not happen, which can then only lead me to believe this was a deliberate move to cause division between the sikh panth motivated by castists because that is exactly what it had achieved and stands mirrored with its policies. In fact they are doing caste to a higher level and associating that with religion taking it into Guru Jis house, enforcing it on sangat which is outrageous unless they stop brahmin practice. It is self interests that seems the reasons they went that way rather than a jat bias. Why then are jats coming under fire? Why do these sikhs protesting about caste not mention ramgharia indian president giani zail singh? He signed over darbar sahib to get destroyed, he had the power above indra ghandi to do something. Coincidently simple pendu jats flocked to the khalsa, tarks flocked under giani zail singh. So how will they ever meet eye to eye? What about the sikhs in delhi giving siropas to delhi riot killers? or pardan mantri manmohan singh letting sikh killers in his cabinet??

Re: Your opinion please

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 26 Feb 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh. Almost everyone seems to have missed the Ultimate "medicine" to cure this "dreaded disease"...mentioned by Kulbir Singh ji ...Bhai Sahib BHAI Randheer Singh jee has written that this Caste disease will be KILLED ONLY by REHAT. Just like "darkness" has no feet when LIGHT appears....jaat paat has no feet when REHAT takes over the Fort. Keep your REHAT and be a KHALSA of GURU GRANTH JI....its a "joke" that only "Dabrro ghussrro kachey pillay sikhs" bring up caste..its a FACT that once REHAT occupies our Body and Mind Fort...small things like castes etc have no place..even in the cracks....but once our REHAT weakens..the cracks widen and such "thieves" creep in..KEEP THEM OUT at all costs. BTW the jibe about SINGH SABHA GURDWARAS being "jatt gurdwaras by default" is a cheap shot at a Mahaan lehr that shook off the shackles of Hindu mahants and Bipparwaad..and made our Gurdawras free of these parasites...seems like their "modern day agents" are still trying their luck to creep back in and control our gurdwaras... Jarnail Singh

Re: Your opinion please

kulwinder Singh · 28 Feb 2005

Shame ! Shame ! and Shame ! on all the fake Sikhs, one thing for sure either you are Jat, Tarkhan, Chamarm or Khatari or Sikh. So people who bring caste to divide Sikhism now or paint the ugly paint of casteism on Great Sikhism are the No 1 Enemy of Sikh Penth. Everybody should be on alert, Admin you should be careful in filtering the evil intentions, I feel on this thread the start and some other part fall well below the good intentions. I strongly advise admin to close this topic now and preferably delete the entire topic from the form history I do mean this seriously. Thanks Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: Your opinion please

SINGH · 01 Mar 2005

i don't understand why people sing in songs about jatts so much...why? why would you want to separate sikhs into groups?

Re: Your opinion please

...... · 02 Mar 2005

veer kulwinder singh the same advice needs to be presented to caste gurdwara parthaans to change their own "evil" maryada which bias against most other sikh. Until then the majority with zilch sikhi knowledge will continue to feel on rebound as well as the divide that are more apparent than caste. Singh i think that is the case because jatts are majority. Artist needs market audience and jatt song sells because jatts are the largest group in both india and pakistan. Someone told me jatts are around 38 million in pakistan punjab and the northern pak kashmiri branch of rajputs also have jatt background, and 35ish million jatts in north india. When these songs sell they sell across the world. Jatt culture is very strong in certain clans and regions in pakistan too we are lucky we have not got it that bad but in pakistan they chop a persons head off and kill off families if a person from next caste elopes with their daughter. Only 18 19 million jatts come under sikhism, the rest are in different religions so i do not think its about dividing sikhs up but that cannot be ruled out either because i did not remmeber this many jatt songs 15 20 years ago. New singhs and singhnia will change caste because education makes us think in a balanced way. you get more ras out of following sikhi than singing about caste. If it was about dividing sikhs up then im sure artists would sing songs praising other castes because most artists that do these songs are not jatt themselves ie surinder shinda, kuldeep manak,amar arshi, chamkila, most surprisingly yamla jatt who was in fact chamar but one of the most respected singers of punjabi folk who took on the jatt title to incease the market selling.

Re: Your opinion please

singhji · 02 Mar 2005

2 be quite honest i think guru nanak did not abolish the caste system i think he abolished the result of the caste system which ultimately is unequality, we recognise different cultures and castes but treat each and every caste and individual equally. quik example, you work in a chemist you are a pharmasict no 1 can say no thats categorising because thats foolish you recognise individual or cultural diffrences but should coose to not act regarding the difference. guru ji rid us of the catse SYSTEM take time to notice the system ,the way it works not rid caste.

Re: Your opinion please

. · 03 Mar 2005

guru ji was addressing the hindu caste system that unfairly imposes restrictions on society when brahmins connived with upper caste moghuls. Jatt history rebelled against caste system. One has to study what they are talking about when addressing jatts because they were never in the hindu caste to start with. The ones that were, became rajputters and maurs who totally changed their ways and got brahminfied. Its these type who tried to subdue jatt power. Its jatts who fought against both hindu influence and muslim conquerers for centuries of struggles. This is like today we stand united against more gorafied conversion and islamic influence or hindu influence. we express our independance, and sikhi has accomodated that without a clash. It gets complcated when someone says "jatt terkaan chammar". Different castes cannot be compared in the same way purely because the former two came from hindus and were part of the sanatan fold and affected by brahmin policy. Jatts were north western warrior tribes who lived independant with their own customs very different from hindus.

Re: Your opinion please

Singh · 14 Mar 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh One thing i must say that the Poem in the first post is very neat and passionate. Loved it. Fateh

Re: Jatt Tarkhan Pfff All Hot Air!

Vic Bahra · 31 Jan 2006

Waheguro Jee Khaa Khalsa, Waheguroo Jee Key Fateh! I have been reading this stuff on this site and I never ever been compelled to post on a website before. All this caste business is nonsense. I am from a Tarkhan, some say Dhimaan background. I read a very interesting post on another site about the history of Tarkhan’s and Jatt’s. Apparently they were very close and used to share “Hookah Pani” together till sometime in the 19th Century when they seemed to start fighting. Many Tarkhan’s seemed to have formed their own villages at that time. My own village is the famous (or in some quarters infamous) Loharan, near Jalander City . It is a 100% Tarkhan village and all the land around there is farmed by the Tarkhans (some leased to Jatts). My own experience is that our family have always been closely allied to the Jatt families, and we have always helped them financially (when need arose). Our ancestor is reputed to be a Rajput who took to the plough and carpentry. This ancestor is reputed to have taken amrit and become a Sikh and stopped seeing ploughing and trade as inferior occupations for low caste jatts and tarkhans. We have never had anything to do with Ramgarhia Gurudwara’s as my family does not agree with the Ramgarhia Gurudwara concept. So to think that Ramgarhia’s are one united body who agree with this is wrong. The only time I encountered this Jatt Tarkhan question was my marriage. Lo and Behold you guessed it I got married to a lovely Jatt woman. It is then all the prejudices came out. My families’ tolerant attitude towards Jatts changed and stereotypes were made of them and fun made. My wife experienced the same from her family but they made fun of us. How is it 5 years later? Fine. However, as someone said above, scratch below the surface and the stench of the racial hatred and caste bashing is overwhelming. The question is what do we do about it, when web sites like this Jattworld keep hatred alive? Vic Bahra [%sig%]

Re: Your opinion please

. · 31 Jan 2006

there ARE a lot of youth who represent JATTs" but u know they are not religous at all ,wait let me correct myself MOST OF THEM are not reliogous at all. so just leave them alone i guess, they are in there own world. i mean im a so called"jatt" but who cares? only thing that matters is that we are sikhs guru jis children. They might learn over time...

Re: Your opinion please

singh · 01 Feb 2006

admin close this thread. Kulbir singh killed the issue many posts ago...

Re: Your opinion please

singhz lets unite · 01 Feb 2006

Shri Guru Nanak Dev Ji said that a person is only is low cuz of the things they do, the way they act. and the only way the person is high is with the stuff that person does. caste took place cuz of back in the days im talkin back in really back long long looooooooong time ago when mankind was just begining to get used to earth and how life works, there wasnt any education back then. thts when this caste system took place. there is on such thing as jaat Sikh or tharkhan Sikh etc etc. there is only one type of Sikh. even bhrahmans are a lot lower thatn, theyre nothing is front of Khalsa. im not Khalsa is supposed to be a caste but u get wat i mean...

Re: Your opinion please

KS Matharu · 18 Apr 2006

WJKK WJKF I have been reading some of the statement put onto this forum and i never thought OUR Sikh religion was like this. I belive that we should be proud of where we came from and who we are.... (i am proud that MOST Matharu Ramgarhia's we in the military went to war including my Babaji, and had the Ramgarhia Regiment. I know Jats are proud of the Jat Regiment and Rajputs are proud or the Rajputana Rifles. This is nothing to hide and shouldn't be frowned upon) but i am totally against people causing segragation in Sikhi (eg Ramgarhia commitees, Singh Sabha, Ravi Dassi Institues...etc) My family has nothing to do with the so called "Ramgarhia" Gurdware, and we all disagree with all caste based gurdware. It's a disgrace to Sikhi. It makes me sick when people refer to themselves as "Jat Sikh", "Ramgarhia Sikh" an so on. We are no longer ONE UNITED KHALSA...we're in our little CULT LIKE groups. What would our Guru ji's say? Think about that next time you say I'M A RAMGARHIA SIKH or I'M A JATT SIKH. WJKK WJKF

Re: Your opinion please

LK · 18 Apr 2006

Where were these jatts before Guru Nanak Dev Ji's time. Where were these Jatt's bravery, when the mughals had taken over? Why did Guru Nanak Dev Ji have to raise his voice - what were the jatts doing? Jatts are nothing without Khandey Battey Di Pahul.

Re: Your opinion please

. · 20 Apr 2006

whats a jatt? a farmer are we farmers...most of us say errrr.... NO!! i know i dont go n plough the fields evry day caste is a load of bull, get over it, stop using these terms. they mean nothing, jus a way 4 sum1 2 belittle u how can people even dare to think about giving a 4kin caste to some of the greatest sant sipahis that walked this earth!!!! waheguru... dhan dhan baba deep singh jee AKAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAL!!! [%sig%]

Re: Your opinion please

PTE SINGH · 20 Apr 2006

How petty and small are the people that started this ‘ Jatt Bashing’. Because of one irrelevant article. Castes, creeds, nations and races exist, that is a fact. As Sikhs we are told not prejudice, divide or prejudge on the basis of caste and I do not. However some of the people who started writing the anti Jatt stuff seem to differ in view. People like LK Now I am a Sikh, a Jatt a Punjabi an Englishmen and an Arsenal fan. I take pride (not Hankar) in all these, but I do not think less of those that are non-Sikh non-Jatt or non English etc, (Though as an arsenal fan I am more superior to supporters of other clubs J). I do not hunt the Glory of past Sikhs, Jatts or Englishmen to make myself look good. I take pride because I try to up keep the traditions and conduct of being a good Sikh, a Jatt a Punjabi and an Englishmen. If I wanted to write an article about great English Sikhs that would not mean that I am putting down those Sikhs that are not English. If I wanted to write about great non Punjabi Sikhs like Baba Banda Singh Bahadar, that does not mean that all Punjabi Sikhs are less significant. That person’s article, though thoughtless, does not put down people of any other caste or creed, nor does it state that being Jatt supersedes Sikhi. So why do the people of other castes think its fine to put down Jatts in this forum. Its peoples own insecurities and pettiness that makes them low not their castes. [%sig%]

Re: Your opinion please

cut · 21 Apr 2006

"The biggest Misconception regarding the term "Jatt" is defining it as a "Caste" as per the standards set by the Indian Caste System. Nothing can be far away from truth as this misconception. The fact that Jatt is a Race has been widely supported by both historians and raciologists working in this field and has been discussed in detail. Here are some negations and rebuttals to the false claim that Jatt is a so called "Caste". These rebuttals have not been and cannot be negated and the truth lies in the fact that Jatt is a Race and not a Caste as traditionally thought. Here are five rebuttals that will prove this point. Rebuttal 1) ETHNIC NATURE: If you look at the Nature of a "Caste", you will notice that its spread throughout India. Eg Caste consists of professions divided into four Categories called Varnas. The Caste System, in its present form, is further based solely upon birth. Thus, as per Caste Rules, Farmer Profession is categorized under Vaisya Category (Varna). And Remember that as per Caste SYSTEM in its present form, this is to be based upon Birth i.e. Farmer's son MUST ONLY be Farmer if Caste System has to be maintained. This point will further be used as a rebuttal in proving how Jatt is not a Caste. Now talking about Ethnicity, you will notice that Caste is not Ethnic in nature at all. Eg a Priest living in North of India will belong to a Brahmin Caste and a Priest living in South of India will also belong to Brahmin Caste. THERE IS NO ETHNIC SIMILARITY HERE. In the same way, NOTE VERY CAREFULLY that a Farmer of North India will be a Vaish and a Farmer of South of India will also be a Vaish. This Logic leads us to conclude that IF Jatt is a Caste (assuming the proposition that Jatts are Farmers) then Jatts must also be Present uniformly throughout India, (just like Brahmins) the land where Caste System is present. But observation tells us that Jatts are only present in Punjab, Haryana and parts of Uttar Pardesh. This gives an Ethnic Nature to Jatt Identity strongly proving the case that assumption "Jatt means Farmer" is false and thereby further concluding assumption that Jatt is a Caste is False too. FIRST REBUTTAL OVER. Rebuttal 2) RACE PRESENCE: It should be noted that this discussion is yet not concerned with Historical viewpoint and raciological and archaeological study of Jatt History. Its just about rebuttals to how Jatt is not a "Caste". What it is then, is a matter of study that will be made in further papers. Caste is present in different Races. Eg Priestly Caste Brahmins are present in South Indian Dravidian Race as well as in North Indian Races. If its assumed that Jatt is a caste, why then are there no Jatts in, lets say, Dravidian Races? Again, the Ethnic Nature Rebuttal further strengthens this point and further helps this rebuttal in making yet another point in how Jatt is not a Caste. Rebuttal 3) FUNDAMENTALS OF CASTES: All the fundamentals, rules and regulations of Castes are goverened by Religious Law Books such as Manusmriti written by a man called Manu. All of these books are part of Hinduism, written by Hindu Mystics. Two thirds of Jatt Community does not follow Hinduism and thereby Manusmriti, that defines and regulates the basic backbone of Caste System holds no relevance for this two thirds of Jatt Community who are not Hindus but are Jatts. Yet another strong rebuttal as how Jatt is not a Caste. Rebuttal 4) PROFESSIONAL NATURE OF CASTES: Castes are professional in nature. Though Caste System further makes it a compulsion to make it based upon birth. But Jatts can be found in just any profession: Business, Politics, Sports and so on. Proving further Jatt is Not a Caste. Rebuttal 5) CASTE-EXCOMMUNICATION: This is yet another important point. As a punitive measure, the Caste of a person can be degraded if some pre-defined rules are not set i.e. a person who is a Brahmin can be degraded to a Shudra Caste and so on. Thus Caste follows the rule of Ex-Communication. But a Jatt born among the Jatts can, under no condition, be ex-communicated. Good or Evil, a Jatt shall always remain a Jatt. Together, the above five points of rebuttals thereby confirm the fact without doubt that Jatt is not a Caste." http://www.jattworld.com/portal/modules/mysections/article.php?lid=10 [%sig%]

Re: Your opinion please

A Singh · 21 Apr 2006

"Bhai Mani Singh Dulat Sikhism" What a JOKE!!! This is the perhaps the biggest lie and ridicule presented and accepted by so many today! Bhai Mani Singh was not a Jat (if we even step outside of the realms of casteless ideals for a moment). This is lie constructed by the famous Nirmala Gyani Gyan Singh, who himself was a Dulat Jat and wanted to give himself the appearence of a distinguished lineage. This is not the only case where this can been done, many other cases exist where non-Jats have been made into Jatts by certain dubious historians and now with the 'we don't believe in caste' issue running through, no one assesses the accuracy of these claims - the result, everyone whilst paying lip service to casteless ideals, still gets off on good old Jatt pride even when in reality there isn't any there!!!