Forum
Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Kulbir Singh · 16 Feb 2005
Following is the translation of news that appeared in Punjabi newspapers of India and Canada on January 24, 2005.
Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Chandigarh, January 23, 2005: From last few months, the Raagmala issue has again captured headlines in newspapers. In a Gurdwara in Sector 15, a large gathering of Sikh scholars who had gathered at the occasion of release of book “Khasht Raag Kin Gaaye” written by Mahinder Singh Josh, passed the resolution of taking out Raagmala from Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee.
Included in the resolutions passed was the resolution of not accepting Raagmala as Gurbani and to stop reading Raagmala at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib. It should be noted that when Jasbir Singh Rode was the jathedar of Siri Akal Takhat Sahib, Raagmala was forced upon Siri Akal Takhat Sahib in 1986. Another resolution was passed appealing to Sikh organisations and all Gursikhs that if SGPC does not come forward in solving the Raagmala issue, Sikh organisations and Sikhs around the world should stop doing paath of Raagmala and not give it the status of Gurbani.
The gathering appealed to SGPC to right away release a hukamnama to Sikh Panth to not read Raagmala. Also the gathering condemned the threats given by pro-Raagmala elements to Sikhs who don’t read Raagmala.
Addressing the gathering Professor Gursharanjit Singh of Guru Nanak Dev University said that in 1936 SGPC published Rehit Maryada had clearly prohibited Panth from reading Raagmala and concluding Bhog of Siri Akhand Paath Sahib on Mundawani. This decision was followed till 1986. He said that if SGPC takes this decision, then segments in Sikh Panth who would clamour and raise hue and cry would eventually pacify just as they did after the introduction of Nanakshahi calendar and after Baba Deep Singh jee’s jyot was removed from Gurdwara Shaheedaan.
Before this, SGPC member Gurpartaap Singh Riyaar released Siri Josh’s book. The book releasing Samagam was headed by Doctor Harjinder Singh Dilgeer.
Other main speakers included Bibi Harbans Kaur Faridabad and Arjun Singh Shergill. Famous scholars who attended the samagam included Doctor Darshan Singh, Dr Maan Singh Nirankari, Kanvar Mahinder Partaap Singh of Sikh Missionary College, Rana Inderjit Singh, Giani Jagmohan Singh and a lot of members of Akhand Kirtani Jatha.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
xingh · 16 Feb 2005
why was Baba Deep Singh jee’s jyot was removed from Gurdwara Shaheedaan????
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Kabadi · 16 Feb 2005
i have no faith in scholars, most of them dont follow a gursikh lifestyle themselves... even thoh they have all that knowledge...
i know thats off topic, but yea, i rather trust gursikhs...
thats my opinion for watever its worth, even thoh i havent said anything pro or anti raag mala
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Kulbir Singh · 16 Feb 2005
Jyot was removed from Gurdwara Sahib because Khalsa does not believe in Jyot stuff. This is Hindu-vaad.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 16 Feb 2005
waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh.
Guru Nanak ji Maharaj took the trouble and travelled all the way to the One of Four Top Hindu Mandir Complexes to show the Hindu pandits the Utter Futility of having a "tiny human aartee"...using tiny lamps and deeveh and lamps jyots etc when compared to the MAGNIFICENT AARTEE God's NATURE is doing 24/7 in the August Presence and Wadiyaee of Waheguru..being carried out by the powerful winds, billions upon billions of suns and moons as deevehs, perfumes from the billions of acres of forests..
Now what would GURU JI say about his SIKHS who have allowed themsleves to fall into the Blind Khhooh of "tiny jyots"...in the AUGUST PRESENCE of the Jyot Ilahi of Guru Granth Sahib jee Maharaj..how can such SIKHS not feel ashamed that with the Shabad Jyot of Waheguru shining out in all its glory..tiny foul smelling jyots are burned in front of Guru ji....jyots that have to be "refuelled, re-lit, get blown out, spilled over and what not ??
Apologists should stop insulting our intelligence by giving such "lame excuses" as jyots are needed in case the electricity goes out ??... I read in the Daily Ajit soemtime ago that long ques of people were lining up in front of Gudwara baba deep Singh ji to pour in shudh Pure GHEE for the Jyots..and "commercial" people had set up numerous stalls outside the Gurdwara to SELL these people shudh ghee..what a TRAVESTY of GURU JI's teachings. The faster we come to our senses and return to SHUDH GURBANI ONLY..and get ourselves released from rituals like aartees jyots talls and conch blowing etc the better we will be.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Gerk · 17 Feb 2005
"i have no faith in scholars, most of them dont follow a gursikh lifestyle themselves... even thoh they have all that knowledge..."
This is the exact reason scholars SHOULD be trusted.
Let me ask you, if you were deciding whether to buy some item and you could get reviews from two people, from the salesman trying to sell you the item, and the second a engineer who designs similar products but has nothing to do with the item you want to buy.
Whose review would you trust, the person who has something vested in you buying his product or the person who is impartial and objective?
Scholars almost all of whom have PhDs generally go though years if not decades of schooling and then devote the rest of their lives studying a subject and trying to uncover the truth about it in service to humanity.
Scholars are also trained not to let their own personal bias slip into their findings. Yes, this means at times they must go going against popular opinion, but as Sikhs we should be in the search of truth, not mollifying lies.
[%sig%]
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
gkd · 17 Feb 2005
amazing how we akj'ers are so pro anti-ragmalla, and advertise it etc....
but the taksaalis just do their buisiness...this makes no sense....belive what u want, dont' advertise..it causes strife..u want panthic etka, start thinking of the panth not our jatha bandi
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Kulbir Singh · 17 Feb 2005
---------
but the taksaalis just do their buisiness...this makes no sense....belive what u want, dont' advertise..it causes strife..u want panthic etka, start thinking of the panth not our jatha bandi
-----------
In modern times, Jatha Bhindran is the one that started this debate by releasing a book on Raagmala - "Raagmala Gurbani Hai". Before that, there was not much debate on the subject of Raagmala.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Premi · 17 Feb 2005
And the sagaa continues...............WHO CARES..............Live and let live. Agree to disagree!!!!
"Scholars" are gov't funded and they are paid for the most part to create controversy, in the name of "research". Is it not the same "Scholars" that say Guru took opium???
I wouldn't take there info without a good look at who they really are!!!
But maybe you don't want pathic ektaa?????God knows!!!
What is the big deal about Jots? If you don't want to light don't. I mean your "oh so Panthic Khalsa Jagir and Tohra are great because they implemented the Calendar but really love the RSS on the inside SGPC" themselves have jots lighted in Harmander Sahib with every saroop?? And in Delhi and Dukh nivaraan sahib etc, etc. Almost all Sgpc gurdwara's have them, why don't you go a "convert" them before here as everybody looks towards them for guidance, which is what they don't provide and why Deras have mushroomed everywhere.
I mean do you really think you are more of a khalsa than Sant Harnaam Singh, Baba Gurbachan Singh, etc, etc who used to light Jots? I really doubt it. But they would not argue over it. They would agree to disagree.
I mean did not Baba Harnaam Singh have darshan of shaheed Singhs when he was reading Chandee Di Vaar and they said if you want to read this banee all night then youy must light the jot all night aswell??
The key was the used to agree to disagree and not take it personally, which is what we tend to do like it is an attack on us.
Love and Peace to all, let us stop arguing the age old arguments and try and love each other as human beings and help one and other in times of Atmick downfall.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
tableji · 17 Feb 2005
Kulbir Singh, it doesnt matter, who did what...we jus do what is right now! instead of pointing fingers ...
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Premi · 17 Feb 2005
______Now what would GURU JI say about his SIKHS who have allowed themsleves to fall into the Blind Khhooh of "tiny jyots"...in the AUGUST PRESENCE of the Jyot Ilahi of Guru Granth Sahib jee Maharaj..how can such SIKHS not feel ashamed that with the Shabad Jyot of Waheguru shining out in all its glory..tiny foul smelling jyots are burned in front of Guru ji....jyots that have to be "refuelled, re-lit, get blown out, spilled over and what not ??__________
No offence,
Why were a hazooria (a sign of humility) in front of Guru Garnth Sahib, the August Giver? It is just a piece of cloth hanging from your neck which does not mean you have humility??? That argument has no base Gyani Jee.Do you not feel ashamed when you go there seeing your deeds with a piece of cloth stating humility?? Forget about other Sikhs. Dirty smelly unwashed Hazoorias which are used at the mouth and by some on the feet in front of the Akaal Purkh? What a fallacy.
Then you say it is part of Banaa (some would agree, some do not).I mean it is not in your SGPC maryada which says the uniform is of the Turban and 5 K's. Well jot is part of the sumagree of Guru jee (some would agree. some not)
Jots have been lighten for far longer than you have been around, historically dated back to the times of the Guru's. It is both practical and spiritual gift.
But hey you don't want to light it that is fine. Lighting a jot will take you to God neither will wearing a hazooria. It all comes down to "Jin prem Kiyoe , tin hee prabh paieoo"
So let us not hate each other over such small things we are the children of the great Lord Guru Nanak. The "chosen ones", to guide the world from the bad path, and to guide ourselves also. Love and be loved!
Premi
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
why? · 17 Feb 2005
Why should the truth be suppressed for panthik ekta?
If raagmala is not bani, why should we not try to enlighten our brothers of this fact instead of saying "oh, I know its not bani, but I'm not going to say anything because he might hate me for it and we won't be friends anymore". Isn't a true friend one who will always try to put you on the right path, regardless of the consequences. Well, in this case, why should it not be shown that raagmaalaa is not bani?
If, for ekta's sake, we do not let this truth out, then people will keep on reading this add on and thinking its bani, and the more history that passes, the harder it will get to take raagmaalaa out, so I disagree that we should just sit here and not tell the truth (e.i. raagmaala is not bani) to our brothers and sisters, because it is our duty as their kin to try to help them on their path to sikhi and the true maryaada.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Dogma · 17 Feb 2005
"Why should the truth be suppressed for panthik ekta? "
Who's truth? what truth? The truth as YOU see it?
pssshhhh..
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
ms · 17 Feb 2005
you guys arguing about all this things will NEVER BRING PANTHIC EKTA so bring real problems and real questions to the table
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
gkd · 17 Feb 2005
stoopid youth, youth thing they know everything..they have modifed sikhi to make them look and act hard-core its sad....i call it nang syndrome...but its not quite nanganisim.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
namey · 18 Feb 2005
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa! Waheguru ji ki Fateh!!
Master Jaswant Singh Ji (Amritsar waale) said that a jot was ALWAYS, without fail, kept alight when Akhand Paath Sahib was being recited, along with a Japji Sahib lardee. They were reminiscing from their experiences woth Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Jee and jatha in praatan times...
Bhul chuk di khimaa(n) bakshanee jeeO.
Das is still a lowly learner.
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa! Waheguru ji ki Fateh!!
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
M Singh · 18 Feb 2005
Maney Jee, I think the reason for the jyot is because anyone who has lived in India knows how often the light goes. Blackouts happen everyday. So with a Jyot(flame) near by, the Akhand Paath does not have to stop.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji kI fateh.
M singh writes:
>>
Maney Jee, I think the reason for the jyot is because anyone who has lived in India knows how often the light goes. Blackouts happen everyday. So with a Jyot(flame) near by, the Akhand Paath does not have to <<<
Then WHY INSIST on the JYOT/Red Cloth/Coconut/etc...in WESTERN COUNTRIES..and MALAYSIA where the electricity NEVER goes out (99.99%)..and WE have VERY GOOD BACK UP Electric Lighting/Gas Lights also...which are so good that the BACK UP will come in (KICK IN INSTANTLY even before the PAATHI...realises the lights blinked !!
a related "joke". ... Last Year I attended a Akhand Paath managed by these Jyot/Red Cloth/Coconut types babay..and there was AArtee, Panj jaikaras at Bhog...this yera I attended the same Akhand Paath at the same home...NO Panj jaikaras, NO AARtee ?? I was surprised....until I learnt the REASON. The previous Akhand Paath was a Happy one, held to Ardass Guru Ji to save a life ( sick person)...this Akhand Paath was SAD because the person died/ and such a barsi paath....no aartee no panj jaikaras.. ??
These babay never cease to AMAZE ME...
Jarnail Singh
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
, · 21 Feb 2005
It seems as Malaysia is a place where it is common to view some strange rituals.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 Feb 2005
OR put it this way....in MALAYSIA lives this...**** of a guy who takes PANGA with everybody who does anything against Sikh Rehat maryada..DO you "see" any mails from malaysia/singapore.... except this "pangga man of a gyani"..
People have TOLD me a thousand times....live and let live...panthic ekta ji......why bother ji,.... they have threatened me, cajoled me, tried to buy me off, flattered me....doen everythign to make me shut up....but Pangga Man is one of a kind..
Pangga mans DHARRA is ONLy with GURU JI...anyone else doesnt count whether rich and famous, santiness and babajiness...gyaniness and agiyaniness....IF Pangga Man sees a ritual, a paakhand, whatever that is anti gurmatt..PM will raise hell...people shake their heads in disbeleif....and make whispering sounds behind my back...but PM goes on...
Yours humbly...PM of malaysia.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
malaysian sikh · 22 Feb 2006
gyani ji,
ur own family is not keshadhari? .. then why not u take panga with them first .. why just picking on others .. Ur ego is too big .. cool down gyani ..
When guru nanak dev ji can call himself "Nanak Nich" .. why are u calling urself gyani ? are u higher then guruji?
from selayang
paramjit singh
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
malaysian sikh · 22 Feb 2006
gyani ji,
ur own family is not keshadhari? .. then why not u take panga with them first .. why just picking on others .. Ur ego is too big .. cool down gyani ..
When guru nanak dev ji can call himself "Nanak Nich" .. why are u calling urself gyani ? are u higher then guruji?
from selayang
paramjit singh
[%sig%]
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Bundha · 22 Feb 2006
You may blow your own trumpet all you like Arshi! but there is a fundamental flaw in your argument.
YoU assume you KNOW it All, you ASSume THaT you understand everything that IS going on around you so you condemn anything you DO NoT understand. It never occurs to YoU that something may BE correct but IT maybe is YOU who does not understand it.
THEN armed with the “I AM only doing Gurus work” or “I only follow Guru Ji” you ThEn go oFF on your fantasy bashings.
[%sig%]
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
gabroo · 22 Feb 2006
i think this was a wrong move.
enforcing this on the other gursikhs who believe in raagmalla, instead of ORGANISING a debate!.
this, to me, seems like the move of somebody malicious who wants to create a severe break in the panth.
you cant enforce such a move if half of the panth (if not more) believe in ragmala. it needs to be decided unaninmously.
Enforcing such things is NO different than enforcing islam on someone, for example! ...because in this case, some pro ragmala supporters believe in it deeply and with heart. if their believe is incorrect, it needs to be shown to them.
VaheGuru. I only hope Gursikh dont silly like during the langar decision --- because THIS decision is TRULY close to heart to those Gursikhs who think ragmala shouldn't be removed (since they know not why).
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
w/ever · 22 Feb 2006
"Other main speakers included........................and a lot of members of Akhand Kirtani Jatha."
now there's a surprise!
:S
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
LionKing (LK) · 22 Feb 2006
Panga man has not a SINGLE TIME claimed to "know it all", to "understand it all" and what not.
All Panga man says (I love the name), is that we as Sikhs should strive to follow the Panth Parvan Rehit Maryada, and not some jyot divey, lala thaga and what not.
Most Scholars at the time, where not merely scholars but also Gurmukh pyaarey, from all different Jathebandis, i.e. Akali Kaur Singh (although I dont agree with everything he said...)
Was a learned man, knew his history and what not, but at the same time practised his Sikhi. Please read the list of the Panth who were there during the time, it wans't one banda, dou bandey, there were 80-90 (if not more) Sikhs from various jathebadiya, Sampardava, etc etc
Panth has filter out baseless rituals with Gurbani as litmus test. We completly throw Gurbani into the bin, and decide to blindly accept what someone has to say about waht is puratan and what is no.
Use your Ukal, Guru Sahib has blessed us with it.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Amrik Singh · 22 Feb 2006
Who's the hell is the scholars ...r they amrathdhari are all are aware of ragmala ...how they dare to change guru granth sahib ji maharaj ...
Bhindrawaley santh proved that ragmala gurbani hey .... then wat else is required..
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Bundha · 22 Feb 2006
Amrik Ji, you are right, we would rather believe a scholar then a Gursikh.
<<< Panga man has not a SINGLE TIME claimed to "know it all", to "understand it all" and what not >>>
He doesn't have to mate, it is written in every post he puts up.............the Punga will come when DharamRaja comes !
[%sig%]
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
seva · 22 Feb 2006
Since when has scholars and Gursikhs been different? All the great scholars were Gursikhs,and all the great Gursikhs were scholars.
For example, Bhai Gurdas ji, Bhai Mani Singh, Baba Deep Singh, kavi Sontokh singh, Bhai Randhir Singh, etc.
Why do people automatically assume these scholars are not Gursikhs. Maybe one or two are not, but that does not mean all of them are not Gursikhs.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Feb 2006
small people discuss small things.... paramjit singh from selayang wants to "know" if my family is keshadharee..IF you are in SELAYANG...you dont have to ask this..everyone KNOWS IT. Its just CHIKKARR THROWING and trying to "personalise" the debate towards ME..instead of towards the SUBJECT - which is RAAGMAALA IS NOT GURBANI. PERIOD. ( Chikkarr throwing and bringing my family in are worthless arguments) And just for info I dont have any GHONAS(non-keshadhrees) in my family and i DONT employ MUSLIM MAIDS to wash my kachheras..Kirt karo, Waand Chhako and Naam Jappo is my motto.
Bundha ji on the other hand seems to be the Bodyguard of DharamRaj himself....dharamraaj this and dharmraaj. THAT....what are you His "CHAMCHA" or what ?? Danke dee chot te..I dont give two hoots to what you or your dharamraaj think of me..as long as i am doing the GURU Ji's work..I am fine. You can go on carrying this so called dharamraaj on your back ( for all the good it will do you !!)
so all you "paramjits", "Gur ka sikh", "bundhas".... and what not..lay off all this personal stuff ( its all water of a ducks back !!) Concentrate on the SUBJECTS..and write something everyone can BENEFIT FROM..( IF you can that is ..but looks like this is a tough one- chikkarr is much easier to throw around)
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Gurdaspuria · 22 Feb 2006
Waheguru Jee ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh
Simple questions to the believers of Ragmala:
What Gurmat you get from Ragmala?
Please list......
I could not find any.
Let us stop spreading ignorance.
Waheguru Jee ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Bundha · 23 Feb 2006
Arshi,
<<<< so all you "paramjits", "Gur ka sikh", "bundhas".... and what not..lay off all this personal stuff ( its all water of a ducks back !!) >>>
This is good coming from a person who PERSONALISES everything himself. YOU are the one who started to blow your own trumpet so why do you get upset when people respond?
RAAGMALA is Guru Ki bani, PERIOD.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Feb 2006
Gurdas puria jio,
Waheguru ji ka kahlsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
WHAT "Gurmat" can any one possible get from a "LIST".
These people dont get it....the Very TITLE of Raagmaamala..LIST of Raags means this Cannot be Gurbani.
Same for TATKARA....Table of Contents..no one in his right mind expects to get any "Gurmat" from a TATKARA...yet inspite of each Bir of Guru Granth Ji having a TATKARA...no body calls it Gurbani, and no body READS it.
The NAME of the AUTHOR of raagmaala occurs in the Raagmaala..Bangala MADH MADHAV Gaveh.....
The Clever Bippar who cut and pasted this kirt into Guru Granth ji began it from the AAnk No. 34 of the Original Raagmala of Madhav nal ..and in his ignorance or slyness changed certain words and made spelling mistakes..something GURBANI cannot and Will NEVER CONDONE..these Mistakes DONT occur in the ORIGINAL....so who is trying to fool who ??
Jarnail Singh
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
singh ji · 23 Feb 2006
to Gurdaspuria
listen to the spritual meanings of raagmala given by sri maan sant gyani baba gurbachan singh ji khalsa bhindranwale.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
ram ji · 23 Feb 2006
Jyot was removed from Gurdwara Sahib because Khalsa does not believe in Jyot stuff. This is Hindu-vaad.
what is the hindu vad.when we makeing deg in gurughar we keep our right on our head for keep hand sucha.why?is not hindu vad?
[%sig%]
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
manjh payara guru ko · 23 Feb 2006
what about the lefthand is this is not part of the body and also what about indreys .
[%sig%]
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Gurdaspuria · 23 Feb 2006
Waheguru Jee ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh
I respect fully ask Veer Singh jee,
Since you have listened the spiritual meaning of raagmale by Baba Gurbachan Singh ji Khalsa Bhindranwale. Could please write few lines What spiritual meaning you learned.
Waheguru Jee ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
sanjo · 24 Feb 2006
someone mentioned that sant jarnail singh khalsa bhindranwale gave proof that raagmaala was gurbani, can u specify a link or any evidence so that i can see for myself. i am very interested in what sant ji had to say and indeed sant gurbachan singh ji khalsa bhindranwale
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
amarjeet singh · 24 Feb 2006
bundha ji,
"RAAGMALA is Guru Ki bani, PERIOD."
please dont lie, its not very good
koorh bol murdaar khai
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
ssingh · 26 Feb 2006
"someone mentioned that sant jarnail singh khalsa bhindranwale gave proof that raagmaala was gurbani, can u specify a link or any evidence so that i can see for myself. i am very interested in what sant ji had to say and indeed sant gurbachan singh ji khalsa bhindranwale"
Please go to gurmatveechar.com, giani pooran singh ji, raagmala. start with number 3.
"I respect fully ask Veer Singh jee,
Since you have listened the spiritual meaning of raagmale by Baba Gurbachan Singh ji Khalsa Bhindranwale. Could please write few lines What spiritual meaning you learned."
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
X singh · 26 Feb 2006
why is it that all of you say raagmala is bani period, but cannot explain why the raags are different from the GGS, and what its spiritual meaning is?
A bit sad really......blind worship!
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Anjaan · 27 Feb 2006
Dear brothers and sisters
After reading the post, the debate of RaagMala continues........(in reference to other posts)......and I just could not let this one go without putting a post up myself.....
I think this is quite hilarious really......
BICHARA Gyani Sahib is getting a bashing as ususal (dont worry Panga Man...LOL...I wont bash you in this post.....).....people argueing by bringing jathabandis into petty little arguments......
To me it seems that the YOUTH have got a greater understanding of Gurbani than our parents/forefathers/learned and spitiual souls etc etc.....The Youth cannot keep hush for a bit......they here from one source that RaagMala is bani and from another source it is not bani......
We all respect MaharajJi and bow towards them.........my undersating is that the person who is anti-raagamala is not going to bow down towards MaharajJi because there is Raagmala written in it.....
just to let you know that I am a firm believer of RaagMala...why? because I respect MaharaJi and bow towards them and accept their bani including Raag mala.....
As the YOUTH on this post is very knowledgable, and are the highest of the Sikh religion and are very learned, including our self-proclaimed Panga Man...LOL,.......could someone put up a post on the actual meaninig of raagmala word for word.....and then people can decide what is raagMala...
The whole sikh nation would be most grateful if someone could do this seva........
i look forward to seeing a post up here soon......
PANGA MAN...Gyani Sahib you are hilarious...although, the title does suit you well........
Anjaan ( i surely am...)
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Not so learned · 28 Feb 2006
Well come on then...all you Gyanis etc out there, lets have a translation.........
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 28 Feb 2006
do birds give milk ?? IF they do..then you can wait for a raagmala "translation" so far NONE of the Teekas even bothered to give one ?? surprised ?..by the way none of the raagmala supporters has ever done a TEEKA of the complete Sri Guru Granth ji even though they claim a MONOPOLY on Gurbani bestowed upon them by none other than Guru gobind Singh Ji....
well dear Not so learned ji....when you get the birds milk..do give a drink too....
Jarnail singh
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Khalistan_zindabaad · 28 Feb 2006
http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/video/files/TaksalRaagMaala.wmv
http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/video/files/TaksalRaagMaala2.wmv
there you go please observe and enjoy. . . . gurfateh
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Guru ghar da kookar · 28 Feb 2006
Guru Payre Khalsa jio.
Waheguru jee ka Khalsa,
Waheguru jee kee Fateh.
Have a look at this if it can serve ur purpose:::::::::::::
rwg mwlw ]
Raag Maalaa:
raag maalaa.
rwg eyk sMig pMc brMgn ]
Each Raga has five wives,
raag ayk sang panch barangan.
sMig Alwpih AwTau nµdn ]
and eight sons, who emit distinctive notes.
sang alaapeh aath-o nandan.
pRQm rwg BYrau vY krhI ]
In the first place is Raag Bhairao.
paratham raag bhairo vai karhee.
It is accompanied by the voices of its five Raaginis:
panch raagnee sang uchrahee.
pRQm BYrvI iblwvlI ]
First come Bhairavee, and Bilaavalee;
paratham bhairvee bilaavalee.
puMinAwkI gwvih bMglI ]
then the songs of Punni-aakee and Bangalee;
punni-aakee gaavahi banglee.
puin AslyKI kI BeI bwrI ]
and then Asalaykhee.
pun aslaykhee kee bha-ee baaree.
ey BYrau kI pwcau nwrI ]
These are the five consorts of Bhairao.
ay bhairo kee paacha-o naaree.
pMcm hrK idswK sunwvih ]
The sounds of Pancham, Harakh and Disaakh;
pancham harakh disaakh sunaaveh.
bMgwlm mDu mwDv gwvih ]1]
the songs of Bangaalam, Madh and Maadhav. ||1||
bangaalam maDh maaDhav gaavahi. ||1||
llq iblwvl gwvhI ApunI ApunI BWiq ]
Lalat and Bilaaval - each gives out its own melody.
lalat bilaaval gaavhee apunee apunee bhaaNt.
Ast puqR BYrv ky gwvih gwien pwqR ]1]
when these eight sons of Bhairao are sung by accomplished musicians. ||1||
asat putar bhairav kay gaavahi gaa-in paatar. ||1||
duqIAw mwlkausk Awlwpih ]
In the second family is Maalakausak,
dutee-aa maalka-usak aalaapeh.
sMig rwgnI pwcau Qwpih ]
who brings his five Raaginis:
sang raagnee paacha-o thaapeh.
goNfkrI Aru dyvgMDwrI ]
Gondakaree and Dayv Gandhaaree,
goNdkaree ar dayvganDhaaree.
gMDwrI sIhuqI aucwrI ]
the voices of Gandhaaree and Seehutee,
ganDhaaree seehutee uchaaree.
DnwsrI ey pwcau gweI ]
and the fifth song of Dhanaasaree.
Dhanaasree ay paacha-o gaa-ee.
mwl rwg kausk sMig lweI ]
This chain of Maalakausak brings along :
maal raag ka-usak sang laa-ee.
mwrU msqAMg myvwrw ]
Maaroo, Masta-ang and Mayvaaraa,
maaroo masatang mayvaaraa.
pRblcMf kausk auBwrw ]
Prabal, Chandakausak,
parabalchand ka-usak ubhaaraa.
KauKt Aau Baurwnd gwey ]
Khau, Khat and Bauraanad singing.
kha-ukhat a-o bha-uraanad gaa-ay.
Ast mwlkausk sMig lwey ]1]
These are the eight sons of Maalakausak. ||1||
asat maalka-usak sang laa-ay. ||1||
puin AwieAau ihMfolu pMc nwir sMig Ast suq ]
Then comes Hindol with his five wives and eight sons;
pun aa-i-a-o hindol panch naar sang asat sut.
auTih qwn klol gwien qwr imlwvhI ]1]
it rises in waves when the sweet-voiced chorus sings. ||1||
utheh taan kalol gaa-in taar milaavahee. ||1||
qylµgI dyvkrI AweI ]
There come Taylangee and Darvakaree;
taylangee dayvkaree aa-ee.
bsMqI sMdUr suhweI ]
Basantee and Sandoor follow;
basantee sandoor suhaa-ee.
srs AhIrI lY Bwrjw ]
then Aheeree, the finest of women.
saras aheeree lai bhaarjaa.
sMig lweI pWcau Awrjw ]
These five wives come together.
sang laa-ee paaNcha-o aarjaa.
surmwnµd Bwskr Awey ]
The sons: Surmaanand and Bhaaskar come,
surmaanand bhaaskar aa-ay.
cMdRibMb mMgln suhwey ]
Chandrabinb and Mangalan follow.
chandarbimb manglan suhaa-ay.
srsbwn Aau Awih ibnodw ]
Sarasbaan and Binodaa then come,
sarasbaan a-o aahi binodaa.
gwvih srs bsMq kmodw ]
and the thrilling songs of Basant and Kamodaa.
gaavahi saras basant kamodaa.
Ast puqR mY khy svwrI ]
These are the eight sons I have listed.
asat putar mai kahay savaaree.
puin AweI dIpk kI bwrI ]1]
Then comes the turn of Deepak. ||1||
pun aa-ee deepak kee baaree. ||1||
kCylI ptmMjrI tofI khI Alwip ]
Kachhaylee, Patamanjaree and Todee are sung;
kachhaylee patmanjree todee kahee alaap.
kwmodI Aau gUjrI sMig dIpk ky Qwip ]1]
Kaamodee and Goojaree accompany Deepak. ||1||
kaamodee a-o goojree sang deepak kay thaap. ||1||
kwlµkw kuMql Aau rwmw ]
Kaalankaa, Kuntal and Raamaa,
kaalankaa kuntal a-o raamaa.
kmlkusm cMpk ky nwmw ]
Kamalakusam and Champak are their names;
kamalkusam champak kay naamaa.
gaurw Aau kwnrw kl´wnw ]
Gauraa, Kaanaraa and Kaylaanaa;
ga-uraa a-o kaanraa kal-yaanaa.
Ast puqR dIpk ky jwnw ]1]
these are the eight sons of Deepak. ||1||
asat putar deepak kay jaanaa. ||1||
sB imil isrIrwg vY gwvih ]
All join together and sing Siree Raag,
sabh mil sireeraag vai gaavahi.
pWcau sMig brMgn lwvih ]
which is accompanied by its five wives.:
paaNcha-o sang barangan laaveh.
bYrwrI krnwtI DrI ]
Bairaaree and Karnaatee,
bairaaree karnaatee Dharee.
gvrI gwvih AwswvrI ]
the songs of Gawree and Aasaavaree;
gavree gaaveh aasaavaree.
iqh pwCY isMDvI AlwpI ]
then follows Sindhavee.
tih paachhai sinDhvee alaapee.
isrIrwg isau pWcau QwpI ]1]
These are the five wives of Siree Raag. ||1||
sireeraag si-o paaNcha-o thaapee. ||1||
swlU swrg swgrw Aaur goNf gMBIr ]
Saaloo, Saarang, Saagaraa, Gond and Gambheer
saaloo saarag saagraa a-or gond gambheer.
Ast puqR sRIrwg ky guMf kuMB hmIr ]1]
- the eight sons of Siree Raag include Gund, Kumb and Hameer. ||1||
asat putar sareeraag kay gund kumbh hameer. ||1||
Kstm myG rwg vY gwvih ]
In the sixth place, Maygh Raag is sung,
khastam maygh raag vai gaavahi.
pWcau sMig brMgn lwvih ]
with its five wives in accompaniment:
paaNcha-o sang barangan laaveh.
soriT goNf mlwrI DunI ]
Sorat`h, Gond, and the melody of Malaaree;
sorath gond malaaree Dhunee.
puin gwvih Awsw gun gunI ]
then the harmonies of Aasaa are sung.
pun gaavahi aasaa gun gunee.
aUcY suir sUhau puin kInI ]
And finally comes the high tone Soohau.
oochai sur sooha-o pun keenee.
myG rwg isau pWcau cInI ]1]
These are the five with Maygh Raag. ||1||
maygh raag si-o paaNcha-o cheenee. ||1||
bYrwDr gjDr kydwrw ]
Bairaadhar, Gajadhar, Kaydaaraa,
bairaaDhar gajDhar kaydaaraa.
jblIDr nt Aau jlDwrw ]
Jabaleedhar, Nat and Jaladhaaraa.
jableeDhar nat a-o jalDhaaraa.
puin gwvih sMkr Aau isAwmw ]
Then come the songs of Shankar and Shi-aamaa.
pun gaavahi sankar a-o si-aamaa.
myG rwg puqRn ky nwmw ]1]
These are the names of the sons of Maygh Raag. ||1||
maygh raag putran kay naamaa. ||1||
Kst rwg auin gwey sMig rwgnI qIs ]
So all together, they sing the six Raagas and the thirty Raaginis,
khasat raag un gaa-ay sang raagnee tees.
sBY puqR rwgMn ky ATwrh ds bIs ]1]1]
and all the forty-eight sons of the Raagas. ||1||1||
sabhai putar raagann kay athaarah das bees. ||1||1||
Taken from www.granthsahib.com.
Bhul chuk dee kheema,
Fateh.
[%sig%]
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
answer · 28 Feb 2006
jarnail singh arshi ji, fareedkoti teeka and sato wali gali teeka by kirpal singh are from raag maala supporters. there are other but it is enough to show that your research is not complete. elders like you should provide guidance to the youth to unite together but I hardly see that happening since you are so obsessed with childish debates and foolish arguments of yours.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
akj singh · 01 Mar 2006
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
im an akj singh but i just dont understand what's al this fuss abt ragmala cant and shouldn't be read. Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji has 1430 pages and ragmala is included in the last few pages of Guru Maharaj ji.what ever written in that 1430 pages are from Guruji's time.not from year 2006 or from 1990 but it has been there from 300 over years now. and now some people who claim to be over educated saying that ragmala shouldnt be read and it should be remove from Guru Maharaj ji. what is happening to the panth? by doing all this we are cutting up Maharaj ji's limbs. ive been hearing parchaar saying that we should respect Maharaj ji in every way we can and now all this happening. im sorry for saying this but i think the panth is going to the drains.we dont have ekta,we dont have pyar,we dont have nimrata in us anymore.im sorry if im hurting anyone but this the fact and everyone knows it! if we deny it, then we are just lying to ourselves to make ourselves look good and happy.Guruji sure had some reasons rite why He included ragmala into the Guru Granth Sahib Ji,then why are we being smarter than the Guru now? are we over educated? are we over flowing with paper degrees and phd's? well i think ive said wht i wanted to say and now the judgement and the decision is up to us all. im sorry if ive hurt anyone but im just voicing out what i feel.
guru rakha. waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Not so learned · 01 Mar 2006
Well Gyani Sahib Ji (and other anti raag Mala people).....you thinking my post was aimed at you? I am sorry, but you are wrong......
Aparrently, the bird has given milk and the translation has been provided......it is quite sweet actually......I see nothing wrong with the Raag Mala......it may not have Guru Nanak Dev Hi Maharaj-His name in it, but learning something about Raags is good.....does it matter no-one knows who wrote it? DOES IT MATTER......it is written in Maharaj-Ji and you bow towards Maharaj-Ji, that means that you accept this Baani......
So you are saying that you abide by the hukum of Maharaj-Ji????
Reading your posts in various topics.........I have the following quote....
"Hum nahi changey, Bura nuhi Koy"
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Singh · 01 Mar 2006
Please now explain what is the spiritual meaning behind that?
Please explain why some of the raags in the SGGS are not mentioned there?
Please explain why there are raags there that are not in the SGGS?
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Khalistan_zindabaad · 01 Mar 2006
in which books if any does bhai randheer singh say not to read raagmala. . .
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Truth · 01 Mar 2006
"akj singh" this is not difficult to understand. Look at Puratan Saroops and you will see there are not 1430 Angs. There is a huge variation in the number of Angs based on handwriting style etc. Furthermore after Mundavani, there are many other Kachi Banis added. Just look for yourself and you will see. The Panth decided to take these out in the first half of this century. Raagmala in the first draft of the Akal Takht Maryada was also said not to be read.
If you don't understand the background then it is better not to add your own opinion. It is very naive to think that for over 300 years every single Saroop has had the same number of pages, same number of Banis, no mistakes.
To say there is "nothing bad" in Raagmala does not make it Gurbani.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
A humble servant · 01 Mar 2006
Raag-Mala is Dhur Ki Bani – God’s Word.
It signifies the glorious music of the Lord. It is the happiness that evolves through the meeting of Nar-Nari (Lord –Devotee). This very state cannot be described, and it can be felt by the "Suhagins" of Lord. The Raag itself is the feed for the soul and the soul flourishes when it absorbs the heavenly music of the Lord.
The Raag is a medium of pure state that connects us to the pure one. The Raag acts as a catalyst (enhancer) for the spiritual seeker, and it helps in connecting with the Almighty. The true understanding of this occurs when one is moving towards the purity(true worship of the Lord).
The Lord Himself is the creator of the Raag. Raag and Raagni are the two sides of a scale – takri tol tarazu. From it came Adam and Eve in the dargah. From Him came – Sun & Moon, Heaven & Hell. Day & Night, Poem of Love – the notes in sat-saagar (seven sarovars). The whole Universe is moving under His will in a very melodious manner.
The Anhad-Naad itself as quoted in SGGS Ji is a Raag of various unique sounds blended in a harmonious manner. The baby's laughter & cries are the true love –Raag / Raagni. The meeting of male & female in sohaag is Raag / Raagni. The Gurmukhs listen to this day and night.
The Unstruck Melody constantly vibrates within;
my mind is exalted and uplifted-
I am lovingly absorbed in the Lord.
SGGS 91
Now, if we look back at the history of Ten Guru times – Guru Nanak Ji Himself sang the Bani in various Raagas with the music played by Baba Mardana Ji. The Gurbani quoted in SGGS Ji is Dhur Ki Bani – was conveyed by the Gurus and Bhagats exactly the way it came to them. As we notice in SGGS Ji –most of the Bani is quoted in Raagas.
The Unstruck Celestial Music vibrates for them at the Lord`s Door,
and they are honored at the True Door.
SGGS 42
The Raagi-Kirtaniyas used to sing Gurbani in pure Raagas during the times of Gurus. The knowledge of pure Raagas has diminished over the time, yet we find few Raagis still doing kirtan in pure Raagas, such as Bhai Samund Singh, Bhai Dilbag Singh, Bhai Avtaar Singh, Bhai Jawalla Singh, Bhai Chand (from the enerations of Baba Mardana Ji).
By great good fortune, one sings the Kirtan of God`s Praises.
SGGS.
Guru Nanak Sahib went to Baghdad during one of his long trips (Udasi). At one time Baba started singing Gurbani in Raaga around mid-night. The venue happened to be in the vicinity of the dera of Peer Bahabul Din – A Muslim Saint. Guru Ji was opposed by the radical ones as the music is not accepted amongst radical muslims.
Guru Patshah gave this godly wisdom to the muslims including the Peer that Raag is the creation of the Lord, and singing His praise in Raaga only creates bliss.If you attach the same Ragga with a wrong doing of lustful dance, and get absorbed in it. This can be the source of the hell for you. The Raag itself is pure, and adulterating it with evil deeds only creates the ill results.
Raag-Raagni is God's own desire to know Himself by unfolding His Samadhi after 36 Ages, and to glorify Himself in the dance of meeting, separation and then meeting again. He created this play of Love Himself. Raag was deaf mute (pingla) at creation, and Raagni was the first sound.
Meeting her Husband, the soul-bride sings the songs of joy,
and celebrates her Lord and Master
SGGS 499
That is why to Him, a true devotee is dearest than even the very self. He serves His devotees. The child is the father of man.
Raag Maalla provides a brief description of various Raags and Raagnis. It is a part of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. It is an index of various Raags & Raagnis as such. One can truly understand these definitions in the true Samadhi abhias with His blessings. All the notes are married in a pure rythemic state in a pure raag. The raags are embodiment of pure feelings or states of pure emotions blended with various parts of day and night. It is true that all the Raagas listed in SGGS Ji are not enlisted in Raag-Maalla. What do we know about this, and should be engage in any such accuratic assessments?
The soul purpose of a Lord's devotee is to enlighten the very self. The Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji is Dhur Ki Bani - the godly wisdom communicated through various Brahmgianis (Gurus & Bhagats). One ought not to indulge in getting in the nth degree details and any such backgrounds of this brahmgyan. The Lord is infinite – beyond explanation, and so is His wisdom. In fact we have to break our scaling abilities, and empty up ourselves like a little baby. Daas can try describing one of the personal experiences here. Daas was casually sitting down in the living room (of course with His company) one day. A quote from SGGS Ji came in the thoughts, and the urge was there to analyze, and understand it completly. A trace of ego was building in. A set of meanings and explanation walked through the mind. The meanings of the very quotes kept on changing every few seconds, everytime the mind tried going a bit deeper into the Gurbani. Daas went through this process for couple minutes, and then the Lord conveyed the message – "I am beyond description, and no one can understand Me, My Bhagats, and My Divine Wisdom in complete".
No one knows Your limits.
SGGS 268
Daas apologized before the Lord, and begged for nothing but His limitless love. Daas is greatful to the Lord to clarify this bharam sooner.
A similar situation occurred with Bhai Sahib Bhai Vir Singh Ji many years back. He was engaged in writing the translation of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji over few years of his efforts. Bhai Sahib Ji got into severe depression as he was coming closer to the completion of this task. He isolated himself completely from everyone, and instructed his sevadar not to let anyone come to his room. The sevadar was asked to keep log entries of all the visitors so that he could communicate with the visitors later on. The Lord sent Brahmgiani Baba Harnaam Singh Ji Rampur Kheda Wale to visit Bhai Sahib Ji. Baba Ji had never physically seen or met Bhai Sahib Ji before this (yet they were soul mates).
As Baba Ji was talking to the sevadar, Bhai Vir Singh ji realized (through his anbhav) this. He asked sevadar in a loud voice (from a deep room) to send Baba Ji in. Upon asking by Baba Ji, Bhai Sahib Ji explained the reason for his depression – He was occupied in writing the translation of SGGS Ji for quite sometime. Now that he is almost near the end, he is realizing that the translation he did in the earlier days is not accurate anymore (the meanings now are lot different), and this is worrying him a lot. His biggest worry is if this translation gets out to the public, it is going to do a disservice by locking the finite explanation of infinite brahmgyan. It can mislead many spiritual seekers. This was the reason for his depression. So, the point here is that the meanings of the Gurbani for an individual relates to his or her spiritual state. The meanings take a different turn as the level of purity in devotee's mind is elevated,. "Karte ki mehma varan na sakoon""Ooche apaar beant soami"
The Gurbani is the most precious jewel of all. The mind itself is analogous to a mirror. The clarity in the mirror goes up as it gets cleaner. SGGS Ji quotes –
Their minds become pure, and they remain immersed in the Lord;
they are honored in His Court.
SGGS 26
If you want to know more about Him or His wisdom, seek for the company of His saints or Brahmgianis. Do not get trapped into the illusion of deh-pooja though. You have to serve the Guru selflessly, and get his blessings to accomplish the salvation as was done by Bhai Lehna Ji. Bhai Lehna ji saw the Lord in Guru Nanak Dev Ji. Bhai Lehna ji was destined to get the salvation through Guru Nanak's blessings. With his total surrender, utmost faith and service, he eventually became the Naanak himself – "Guru Angad". The Lord Himself does not take birth, or has any shape or color. Yet, he becomes apparent through His bhagats. SGGS Ji quotes –
When this soul and that Lord are blended, then, having been blended,
they cannot be known separately.
SGGS 342
We ought to read or listen to the Gurbani and act on the brahmgyan. The meanings will come out as the spiritual state elevates.
Those Gurmukhs who have tasted it remain intuitively absorbed in the Lord.
SGGS 26
We cannot conceal the Infinite Lord, who liberates us. We should simply engage in a selfless prema-bhagti (devotional-love), and get out of any scaling ideas. He is beyond any of our imagination, and He Himself is the scale of Total Love (self).
God Himself is the balance scale, He Himself is the weigher,
and He Himself weighs with the weights.
SGGS 605
A Humble Servant
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Khalistan_zindabaad · 01 Mar 2006
http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/video/files/TaksalRaagMaala.wmv
http://www.gursikhijeevan.com/media/video/files/TaksalRaagMaala2.wmv
there you go please observe and enjoy. . . . gurfateh
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
response to humble servant · 01 Mar 2006
you stated :
>The Lord Himself is the creator of the Raag. Raag and Raagni are the two >sides of a scale – takri tol tarazu. From it came Adam and Eve in the dargah.
Does raagmala suggest we believe in adam and eve?
The rest of your post is well written, but it does not answer any of the questions posed here. Let me remind you of them.
Please now explain what is the spiritual meaning behind raagmala?
Please explain why some of the raags in the SGGS are not mentioned there?
Please explain why there are raags there that are not in the SGGS?
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Prabhjoyt singh · 01 Mar 2006
http://gursikhijeevan.com/media/audio/index.php?q=f&f=%2FKatha%2FSant_Baba_Kartaar_Singh_Ji_Khalsa_Bhinderwale%2FSalok_Mahla_Naunva_And_Raag_Mala
http://gursikhijeevan.com/media/audio/index.php?q=f&f=%2FKatha%2FSant_Jarnail_Singh_Ji_Khalsa_Bhinderawale%2FSalok_Mahla_9va_And_Raag_Maala
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
... · 01 Mar 2006
humble servant, we're not saying raags are not important
stop going off topic
ragmala contains raags which are not present in sggs ji
it is an extraction from a love poem which contains adult content.
all gurbani in sggs ji is to do with praise of naam/ praise of god.
ragmala is fundmentally different from the rest of sggs ji, just like ratan mala and other pieces of kachee banee which can be found in 'pratan birs'
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
... · 01 Mar 2006
akj singh you are NOT akj, because you beleive in ragmala
you cannot be akj and believe in ragmalai
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 01 Mar 2006
Author: answer
Date: 02-28-06 23:29
jarnail singh arshi ji, fareedkoti teeka and sato wali gali teeka by kirpal singh are from raag maala supporters. there are other but it is enough to show that your research is not complete. elders like you should provide guidance to the youth to unite together but I hardly see that happening since you are so obsessed with childish debates and foolish arguments of yours.
>>>>>>>
Veer ji..i have both these teekas..and i know they are by the SANT group...but my question was about TEEKA of Raagmaala..both these DONT have any..as it is impsossible to give "meanings" to a List of Names.
I am "obsessed" by your LAST LINE...i have been told time and again..
"my childish...obsession..arguments.. stupidity..etc will DISAPPEAR in a Split SECOND..CHHINN...IF only I say ...ALL SANTS and SADHS are BRAHMGIANIS...Raagmaala is GURBANI on Par with japji Sahib..MoolMantar is up to Hosi bhi Sach...Jarnail Singh Bhinderwalleh is ALIVE and in Charrdeekalla.....etc etc and I will then BECOME MAHAPURASH..SANT..Most GYANWAAN of all GYANIS..and I will be for EKTA..PEACE..
BUT IF i continue in my ERRORONEOUS WAYS..I am stupid, budhu, Jamdoot will be gunning for me....
But cant there be EKTA..IF the other Party DROPS all their stupid arguments...??? million dollar question..
2. BHAI VIR SINGH JI was NOT at the END of his Translation of Guru Granth ji..he just REACHED aang 400 thereabouts when he died. He "changed" his mind about Raagmaala due to some PERSONAL reasons/Conflicts with some other scholars...read their books to find out what reasons he had..
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
answer · 01 Mar 2006
jarnail singh arshi ji, thank you for clarification. I have seen unpublished teekas but those who have them won't publish them. I can't understand why. baba gurbachan singh ji of damdami taksal has done translation of raag maala but then again some agree and some don't. non-acceptance exists on both sides. both claim to be open minded and make claims of changing their "beliefs" once provided with all the answers but majority are close minded and will always come up with more and more questions. I only pointed out your childish behavior not of others. I do not know why you assume that every pro-raag maala person believes in everything you stated. sant ji is in chardee kala just like every other shaheed singh. every true sant is a brahmgyani. moolmantar's length is your personal belief and neither the shorter nor the longer can be called manmat or kachi bani. for some reason you seem to have hatred for raag maala supporters and make personal attacks.
it is not the question of other party doing something but the question of what we are willing to do as a panth. if an elder like yourself wants to classify sikhs in different parties then can there really be an eakta? is this a gansgter fight we are trying to win?
I don't know why you brought up Bhai Veer Singh Ji. he was a great gursikh. it is easy to make up stories. both sides have their own versions. I have read almost every book out there on raag maala and i stand by what i believe in but at the same time i don't hate those who have different beliefs. gyani ji, this issue could not be solved in last 150 years. perhaps it is time to change plans and tackle it differently rather than attacking and fighting like bunch of kids. the youth today needs to know more about sikhi and need to practice sikhi so they can have sikh character full of nimarta, naam simran and seva which is missing even in your posts. just my thoughts. continue with your debate if you wish. gurfateh
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
akj singh · 02 Mar 2006
dear author ... ji
thank you for your comment. to be very frank with you, you dont have any rights to tell me that i'm not an akj singh and i can't be one. i dont have to prove to anyone whether i am or i'm not.Maharaj ji knows very well. anyway thank u again for r comment. May God Bless You. :)
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
? · 02 Mar 2006
akj singh ...ji is right, you cant call youreself akj if you dont follow rehit akj believe in.
like me saying im taxali but i believe keski is 5th kakkar and ragmala isnt bani
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
pagal man · 02 Mar 2006
so is raagmala bani?
A simple Yes or a No will do. This way the people that say no can be thrown out from the panth and the people that say yes will have a ardaas performed for them to keep them in chardkala.
Why do i make such a statement? That way the people who hate sant (real ones) make there own kakkar and say dont read this bani will no longer be in the panth and the problem will be eliminated. Then we can have panth ekta as 100% if not 200% of the panths problem would be gone. Finally we'll get rid of SGPC and then khalsa will have raaj.
Quite simple really. Think about.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
just me · 03 Mar 2006
wow what a long thread. Still no one has answered the key questions:
Please now explain what is the spiritual meaning behind raagmala?
Please explain why some of the raags in the SGGS are not mentioned there?
Please explain why there are raags there that are not in the SGGS?
Plus i have some more
If raagmala is bani, how do you explain the compositions before it being removed by the Panth for not being Gurbani?
How can something be bani, then have not bani, then have bani again. Did Guru Ji not realise someone has just written kacchie bani in the middle?
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Khalistan_zindabaad · 03 Mar 2006
http://gursikhijeevan.com/media/audio/index.php?q=f&f=%2FKatha%2FSant_Baba_Kartaar_Singh_Ji_Khalsa_Bhinderwale%2FSalok_Mahla_Naunva_And_Raag_Mala
http://gursikhijeevan.com/media/audio/index.php?q=f&f=%2FKatha%2FSant_Jarnail_Singh_Ji_Khalsa_Bhinderawale%2FSalok_Mahla_9va_And_Raag_Maala
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Singh · 03 Mar 2006
what a stupid post. Please think before writing next time. You say kick out AKJ, Sikh Missionary, the scholars, etc, and you will have ekta in the Panth. That is half the Panth silly!
If you and all these sants, take all their katha from Mahakavi Bhai Sontokh singh, but want to kick him out of the Panth because he was againt raagmala.
Is raagmala bani ? simpe answer NO! because no one can answer the quatrions and prove that it is.
pagal man wrote:
> so is raagmala bani?
>
> A simple Yes or a No will do. This way the people that say no
> can be thrown out from the panth and the people that say yes
> will have a ardaas performed for them to keep them in
> chardkala.
>
> Why do i make such a statement? That way the people who hate
> sant (real ones) make there own kakkar and say dont read this
> bani will no longer be in the panth and the problem will be
> eliminated. Then we can have panth ekta as 100% if not 200% of
> the panths problem would be gone. Finally we'll get rid of
> SGPC and then khalsa will have raaj.
>
> Quite simple really. Think about.
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
amarjeet singh · 03 Mar 2006
raagmala is not gurbani chaps.
for all those who beleive otherwise, im afraid you are wrong
the best thing to do is never read it again and just do a sukhmani sahib for every raagmala you have done.
and then ull realise that raagmala being bani is as likely as osama bin laden and george bush being best freinds.
:-)
Re: Scholars Appeal sangat to not read Raagmala
Stupidity · 06 Mar 2006
If you believe that Raag mala is not Bani, then you should NOT bow down towards Majaraj Ji....simple answer.....why dont you rip out the pages from Majaraj Ji where raag mala is written.....only then you should bow down towards them...
ACCEPT IT FOLKS........RAAG MALA IS BANI.....WHETHER YOU LIKE IT OR NOT.....