Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

khalistan

khalistan

america sucks · 10 Feb 2005

My question to those that believe in Khalistan is what would that achieve to have our own separate country, where we're not going to still be the majority living there? I don't , as much as i'm a sikh, i don't believe having our own country will prove anything. It's like Quebec wanting to separate from Canada.

Re: khalistan

bhopinder singh · 10 Feb 2005

my question to you why jews need israel why french who have same script same religion same white skin blue eyes have seprate country (same as england) why did prime minister of israel tell he has to wall all of israel because palastanians are going to outbreed them and theirfore distroy israel as a entity (stats show they are growing in alarming rate) why did the former immigration minister judy sugrow tell not to worry about the immigration , which is they control thr number of immigrants so as they never become threat to the geopolitical entity of the whites why no outsiders are allowed to settle in himachal pardesh

Re: khalistan

bhopinder singh · 10 Feb 2005

it is not america but you that sucks

Re: khalistan

Toker · 10 Feb 2005

Quite right. It's a backward step to create more divisions and borders. It's also quite insidious when religion is brought into these political matters.

Re: khalistan

gkd · 11 Feb 2005

think about it this way, how did the african slaves become free men from their white masters? by running away. Here how do the sikhs rise above the oppressors by creating their own country with their kamai. not 2 say that the sikhs are running away, but 2 show the lateral event line. [%sig%]

Re: khalistan

Singhstah · 11 Feb 2005

Raj bina nahin dharam chale hain, dharam bina sabh dalle malle hain- without rule a religion cannot operate properly,otherwise the religion perishes.

Re: khalistan

bhopinder singh · 11 Feb 2005

some of us are talking about converting hindus on the other hand hindus are talking the opposite who is better equipped what is happening in punjab

Re: khalistan

asdf.com · 11 Feb 2005

what is with all this talk of separation and borders. i think we need one big country for the whold world and call it 'Khalistan'.

Re: khalistan

uk singh · 11 Feb 2005

see http://www.sikhknowledge.tk/ and goto the bottom of the page where you find a link to a word doc 'Why Khalistan?'

Re: khalistan

Toker · 11 Feb 2005

Singhstah if a religion cannot survive without force of arms (i.e. the power to hurt other people physically) which is the defining characteristic of any type of "rulership", then let it perish. However, the Sikh beliefs are in no danger of dying out without khalistan and nuclear weapons (according to some pipe dreams, khalistan would be sandwiched between 2 nuclear powers).

Re: khalistan

someone else · 11 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh sandwhiched Toker? no khalsitan will stand independently and does not care of what the power is pf those around. 2 nuclear powers, so what? Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: khalistan

Bo Jackson · 11 Feb 2005

but if khalistan is created in punjab, what will that do? There still be alcohol drugs and everything. It will not be some great place were gursikhs can go to get away from everything.

Re: khalistan

Harjeev Singh · 11 Feb 2005

wahe guru ji ka khalsa wahe guru ji ki fateh ! Guru Gobind Singh Ji said "Rajj Bina Nahin dhram Chale hain, dhram bina sabh dale male hain" it means no religion can progress without its own self-determined rule, religions without self rule will faid away. If sikhs had a self-determined rule (khalsa rajj, khalistan) the Golden temple, Akal Thakt sahib would never been attacked ! thousands of sikhs would not have been masacred across india(hindu raj) Sikhs would not be classed as long haired hindus in the constituion of india they would not be called " a lawless breed of people, a menance to society, a threat to the law abiding hindus" Punjab would not have been broken in to small parts If muslims can have Pakistan Hindus can have Hindustan Why can't sikhs have Khalistan ? KHALISTAN IS A PLACE ON THE WORLD MAP WHERE SIKHS HAVE THEIR OWN SOVERIEGN SELF-DETERMINED GOVERMENT WHERE THEY CAN HAVE A GLOW OF FREEDOM AND POLITICALY, ECONOMICALY, CULTURELY SAFE GUARD THEIR INTEREST'S WITHOUT THE FEAR OF PERSECUTION, GENOCIDE, ETHNIC CLEANSING. WAHE GURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATHE [%sig%]

Re: khalistan

Toker · 11 Feb 2005

If the nuclear powers that be really meant nothing to your in your quest for khalistan, you would go to Punjab right now and declare it independent. Military power means something.

Re: khalistan

Toker · 11 Feb 2005

Harjeev I fundamentally disagree with you. It's going too far to say that the Golden Temple was attacked because there was no khalistan. It's a basic fact that in any nation-state, the government holds a MONOPOLY on the use of violent force. Anyone who tries to arm up and form an army gets SQUASHED. If you want power in a modern secular democracy like India you have to be a part of the political process, and participate in elections. Nobody will want to play politics with you if you start acting in a threatening way (i.e. keeping firearms and building an army). It's a very good way to add to your growing army of enemies though. Just some words of advice.

Re: khalistan

bhopinder singh · 11 Feb 2005

toker what did it mean to vietnamis in 1974 what did it mean to afghanistan in 1978 concept of superpower in terms of conventional power does not exist what about 20000 nuclear weapons that former ussr had; did it stop it from disintegration and also nepal is sandwitched between two nuclear powers

Re: khalistan

america sucks · 11 Feb 2005

using the sikh approach to the situation maybe we can act as peacekeepers to the problem..its the sikhi thing to do

Re: khalistan

Toker · 11 Feb 2005

Vietnam: the US would say that it pulled out its forces because of political changes at home rather than a decisive military defeat. The Vietnamese suffered losses running into millions before the US decided to call it a day. It's a mistake to measure the success of a war in terms of attrition, but compare the cost in lives each side paid. Afghanistan: had the Mujahideen (US-funded, US-led and US-equipped) and was in effect a conventional war fought over territory that had no more significance than ideological to either side (i.e. Communism vs Capitalism). Sure, the Soviets pulled out, but not before reducing the entire country to rubble. It never recovered from the war, and today the Russians if not the Soviets (different name, same fish) are back in there. PDPA played off east versus west and look at the price they had to pay. Afghan king was exiled and Mujahideen put in charge. Cr*p government because they could'nt get the cash to rebuild the country, and Talebans came in to restore order. The rest is well known to all. Afghanistan should be a lesson in what happens to militant theocracies. You mention that the concept of superpower does not exist. You need to expand on that assertion, because right now it appears to most people that the US and China at least are unassailable superpowers, and a large part of that has to be to do with the fact that they have nuclear weapons. The US is also extremely nervous about other countries' alleged nuclear programmes, and Iran and North Korea have both been mentioned recently. You begin to see what nuclear power means? Also Bhopinder the difference between the examples you give is that what you're proposing is a buffer state between 2 enemies. Look how tense things were a couple of years ago between India and Pak because of nuclear tests. If there was ever a repeat of that scenario with a khalistan in the region, the khalistan would have to choose a side. Everyone knows that India has lines of defence already in Punjab, aimed at defending against a Pak attack as best it can. Let me give you an example of your utopia khalistan: KASHMIR.

Re: khalistan

Harjeev Singh · 12 Feb 2005

wahe guru ji ka khalsa wahe guru ji ki fateh toker :" Anyone to trys to arm up and form a army gets squashed" I don't think you know what KHALSA PANTH is, it is an ARMY. AKAL PURUKH KI FUAJ If Guru Gobind singh ji did not ARM UP AND FORM A ARMY the moguls and british would still be in india. There would be no hindus they all would have been wiped out and converted ! Hindus are weak people that were enslaved in india for around 1000 years, it is the KHALSA FAUJ that liberated them by giving their BLOOD. Guru Teg Bahadur the 9th Guru had to give matyrdom in delhi because hindus came crying and weeping to him because their religion was in danger and they did not have the gutts to face their operessers. The partition of india and pakistan was wrong becuase it was a 2 way split, more self-determined soveriegn rules should have been established because some nations had their own independet rules before the british occupied. Sikhs had khalsa rajj, the ruler was shere-e-panjab maharaja ranjit singh. We had our own FLAG, CURRENCY, ARMY, CONSITUTION, CAPITAL. Panjab was the last rule to be taken over. Other nations were tamils, nagas, kashmires, assamese, manipurs, who are still fighting today for liberation. india and pakistan is more a conflict between hinduism vs islam, with khalistan being liberated india will have to remove all its artilery from panjab which is good sign less chance of war, and pakistan will have to reposition or remove its artilery from facing khalistan, which will ease tensions between paks and hindus because their will be a gap between the two, a buffer zone. SIKHS shoudn't get involved in this war because at the moment darbar sahib is in hindu controlled panjab and nankana sahib is in pak controlled panjab, both shirnes must be guarded with our lives! KHALSA RAJJ (KHALISTAN) MUST BE ESTABLISHED TO SAFE GUARD OUR INTERESTS. [%sig%]

Re: khalistan

Singh · 12 Feb 2005

Ahh, toker. People want khalistan.. because they want a place where they won't be killed simply for being sikh. Where their sister's and mother's won't be paraded naked and raped. Where there shrines won't be destroyed. Where there history won't be tampered with. Where they won't have to live as slaves. Where they can enjoy many of the freedoms you enjoy outside of india. If india had been a true democracy, there probably never would have been a need or desire to call for a separate state. If you honestly believe that india was or is a modern secular democracy, then you live in fantasy land. " Anyone who tries to arm up and form an army gets SQUASHED. " So the sikhs just started forming an army out of the blue. They had nothing better to do and figured, 'hey, let's build an army and take on India. That'll be fun.' So basically, they asked for it, right? It was their fault. They didn't use the political system but just blindly turned to violence. Yup. That's what happened, right? Toker, go read some history on post partition punjab before you start posting useless things. If you've already read it, then go read it again, this time with your glasses on.

Re: khalistan

Lord Singh · 12 Feb 2005

Some of You are mad - Its obvious that after all thats happened - the Sikhs need a Khalistan - If after all thats happened you dont say Khalistan - You cant call yourself a Sikh - Theres no need to say why we need it - theres enough facts on the net for that - try www.shaheedkhalsa.com - thats one - but my main point is - KHALISTAN IS 100% NEEDED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!!!!!!!!!! [%sig%]

Re: khalistan

Admin · 12 Feb 2005

We have decided to close this thread and we have decided to not approve Toker's latest post as it would have made the atmosphere of this forum very communal. Sikhs don't have anything against Hindus as you think they do and we don't want to make this forum a fight between Hindus and Sikhs. Toker, it seems like you are a nationalist and a fanatic Hindu and we suggest that you to go somewhere else to do your RSS propaganda. The focus of this forum is to provide spiritual guidance to Sikhs. Admin