Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Mkhalsa · 06 Apr 2003

I found this on another forum, and I thought it would be good to share. 35 helps prove that keski is kakkar :D But I noticed there is no metion of sarbloh? perhaps some more knowledgable singhs can comment on this. ------------------------------------------------------------- Re-introduced to an old magazine article in the Sikh Virsa Magazine by a recent post, I felt compelled to transliterate and translate an article which listed 52 Hukams that Guru Gobind Singh issued (Forgive if I translate something wrong...I have not mastered Punjabi - areas where I was unsure have question marks after the translation - any edits would be appreciated). (Reference: Sikh Virsa, December 2000, Vol. 6, No. 61, Pg. 29). 1) Dharam di Kirat karni - Earn by honest means. 2) Daswand dena - Give one tenth of your salary. 3) Gurbani kantth karni - Memorize Gurbani. 4) Amrit Vaelae utthna - Wake up Amrit Vela (before dawn). 5) Sikh sewak di sewa ruchi naal karni - Serve a Sikh Servant with devotion. 6) Gurbani dae arth Sikh vidhvana tuo parrhnae- Learn the meanings of Gurbani from Sikh Scholars. 7) Punj Kakaar di Rehat drirh kar rukhni - Follow the discipline of the 5 K's strictly. 8) Shabad da abhihas karna - Practice Shabad Gurbani in life. 9) Sat-Saroop Satgur da dhian dharna - Concentrate on the True Guru (God). 10)Guru Granth Sahib Ji noo Guru mananaa - Accept the Guru Granth Sahib as Guru. 11)Kaarjaan dae arambh vich ardaas karni - At the beginning of a task, do ardaas. 12)Jaman, maran, ja viah mokae Jup da paatth kar tihaaval (Karaah Parsaad) kar anand sahib dia punj paurian, ardaas, pratham punj pyaariaan atae hazoori granthi noo vartaa kae oprunth sangat noo vartaaouna - At birth, death, or marriage ceremonies, do Japji Sahib, make Karaah Parshaad, do five stanzas of anand sahib, do ardaas, and then distribute Karaah Parshaad to the Panj Pyare, the Granthi, and then to the sangat. 13)Jad tak Karaah Parshaad Parshaad vartadaa rahae sadh sangat addol batthee rahae - Until Karaah Parshaad is completely distributed, the Sangat should remain sitting and unmoving. 14)Anand Viah bina grahist nahi karna - Do not start married life without Anand Karaj (Sikh ceremony of marriage). 15)Par-Istri, Ma-Bhain, Dhi-Bhain, kar jaanani. Par Istri da sang nahi karna - Recognize all other women other than your wife as mothers and sisters. Do not engage in marital behavior with them. 16)Istri da mooh nahi fitkaarnaa - Do not silence your wife? 17)Jagat-jootth tambaaku bikhiaa da tiaag karna - Abandon the worldly, false tobacco-poison. 18)Rehatvaan atae naam jupan vaalae gursikhaa di sangat karni - Keep the company of Sikhs who follow the Rehat and meditate on the Name (of God). 19)Kum karan vich daridar nahi karna - Dont't be lazy while doing work. 20)Gurbani di katha tae keertan roaz sunanaa atae karna - Listen and do kirtan and Gurbani discourses daily. 21)Kisae di ninda, chugali, atae eirkha nahi karni - Do not engage in slander, gossip or spite anyone. 22)Dhan, jawaani, tae kul-jaat da abhiman nahi karnaa (Nanak daadak tahe duae goath. Saak guru sikhan sang hoath) - Do not take pride in wealth, youth and caste. (Mother and Father's caste both castes. All Sikhs of the Guru are siblings)? 23)Mat uchi tae suchi rakhni - Keep the religious discipline high and pure. 24)Shubh karman tao kadae naa ttarnaa - Do not refrain from doing Righteous deeds. 25)Budh bal da daataa vaheguroo noo jaananaa - Recognize God as the giver of intellect and strength. 26)Sugandh (kasam sahu) dae kar itbaar janaaoun vaalae tae yakeen nahi karna - Do not believe a person who swears (one who tries/attempts to convince someone with a 'saun or saugandh'). 27)Sutantar Vicharna. Raaj Kaaj dian kamaan tae doosrae mutaa dia purshaan noo huk nahi daenaa - Rule Independently? In the affaris of government, do not give people of other religions authority/power. 28)Raajniti parhni - Study politics. 29)Dushman naal saam, daam, bhaed, aadiak, upaa vartnae - With the enemy, practice/deploy the various techniques/tactics of diplomacy (saam, daam, dand, bhed). 30)Shaster vidyaa atae ghorhae di savaari da abhiaas karna - Practice the knowledge of weaponry and horse riding. 31)Doosrae mataa dae pustak, vidyaa parhni. Pur bhrosaa drirh Gurbani, Akal Purakh tae karnaa - Study the books and knowledge of other faiths. But keep trust in Gurbani and Akal Purukh. 32)Gurupdaesaa noo dhaaran karna - Follow the teachings of the Guru. 33)Raheraas da paath kar kharae ho kae ardaas karni - After Rehras Paatth, do Ardaas standing up. 34)Saun valae sohila atae 'paun guru pani pita...' salok parhna - Recite Sohila and 'paun guru pani pita...' stanza before going to sleep. 35)Dastaar bina nahi rehnaa - Wear a turban at all times. 36)Singha da adha naam nahi bulauna - Do not call a Singh by half of their name (nickname). 37)Sharaab nai saevani - Do not partake of alcoholic drinks. 38)Sir munae noo kanaiaa nahi daeni. Uos ghar daevni jithae Akal Purukh di sikhi ha, jo karzaai naa hovae, bhalae subhaa da hovae, bibaeki atae gyanvaan hovae - Do not given a daughter's hand to a clean shaven. Give her hand in a house where God's Sikhi exists, where the household is not in debt, is of a good nature, is disciplined and knowledgable. 39)Subh kaaraj Gurbani anusaar karnae - Do all work in accordance with Gurbani. 40)Chugali kar kisae da kam nahi vigaarnaa - Do not ruin someone's work by gossip. 41)Kaurha bachan nahi kahinaa - Do not utter bitter statements. 42)Darshan yaatraa gurdwaaraa di hi karni - Make pilgrimages to Gurudwaras only. 43)Bachan karkae paalnaa - Fulfill all promises that are made. 44)Pardaesi, lorvaan, dukhi, apung manukh di yataahshkat sewa karni - Do as much sewa as you can for foreigners, the needy and the troubled. 45)Putari da dhan bikh jananaa - Recognize the property of a daughter as poison? 46)Dikhaawae da Sikh nahi bananaa - Do not become an outward show-off Sikh. 47)Sikhi kesaa-suaasa sang nibhaaouni - Live and die a Keshadhaari Sikh 48)Chori, yaari, tthugi, dhokaa, dagaa bahi karnaa - Refrain from engaging in theft, adultery/promiscuity/permissiveness, fraud, deceit, embezzlement. 49)Sikh da itbaar karna - Believe a Sikh. 50)Jhutthi gavaahi nahi daeni - Do not give false testimony. 51)Dhroh nahi karnaa - Do not cheat. 52)Langar-Parshaad ik ras vartaaunaa - Distribute Langar and Karaah Parshaad with equality.

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Singhnee · 07 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! Veer jeeo you did a great punn by posting and translating these hukamnaamaas. These will be very helpful to follow more gurmat and Gur-updesh in our daily life. Thanks a lot. Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Seva Singh · 07 Apr 2003

35 doesnt prove keski is a kakar what are you talking about? If i thought Kesh was a kakar, would you expect me to walk around with my hair open? Its part of rehit to keep your kesh coverd with two dastars at all time even though keski isnt a kakar.

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Tarnveer Singh · 07 Apr 2003

GurFateh! This is awesome! Can some veer or bhain tell this moorakh more about when and under what circumstances these hukams were given? Like, were they all given at once to a certain sangat, like a handwritten document to the "sangat of so-and-so"? Or is this list pieced together from separate ones? Where can I find the original in Punjabi? Any further elaboration would be greatly apprecitated. Fateh! Tarnveer Singh Khalistan Zindabad!

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Singhnee · 07 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! .>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 35 doesnt prove keski is a kakar what are you talking about? C? Its part of rehit to keep your kesh coverd with two dastars at all time even though keski isnt a kakar. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Bhai Sahib jeeo, think again about this one please... >>>>35)Dastaar bina nahi rehnaa - Wear a turban at all times. <<<<<<<< Did Guru sahib gave this hukam only to Singhs??? I don't think Guru Sahib give different hukams to singhs and singhnies. So the big part of so called KHALSA PANTH is not following Guru Sahib's hukamnama. We can see just few bibies wearing dastaars out of AKJ. We should seriously consider this point. Why punj pyaaaraas let bibies Amrit shakk without dastaar. Why they don't follow Guru Sahib's hukam. This is total MANMATT and manmatt is not accepted by Guru Sahib jee. Most of the part of Sangat is innocent. People don't know about Guru sahib's hukams and Gurmat but the Jathedaars(leaders), organizers of religious events and scholars who know gurmat are responsible for all these dhills. I have seen many good singhs(in my own family too) without dastaars at home with nanga jooRaa. If I requested to cover his head, he said "why, under what hukam of punj pyaaray I have to keep dastaar on 24 hours. You think you are more siaani than punj?". Bhai Seva Singh jee comments, "If i thought Kesh was a kakar, would you expect me to walk around with my hair open?" Yes I already gave one example and millions of example are here around us. Most singhnies walk around without dastaars and many singhs don't wear it when they are home. It happens because PANTH is not accepting the TRUTH of fifth kakaar(keski). If keski is a kakaar then you won't see this dhill in panth. Bhuk chuk dee muaafi jee. Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Kaur II · 07 Apr 2003

The only way one can keep a dastaar on at ALL times would be if one considers keski a kakaar from which they can never be separate. So #35 does indeed prove keski is a kakaar. And as "Singhnee" bhain jee has stated, this hukam of Guru Sahib is also for bibiyaan who should also keep a keski on at all times.

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Skittles · 07 Apr 2003

Singhnee jee, Having a distaar on at all times is not an argument for keski as a kakaar (as seva singh has mentioned). If it was then why would #7 on the list be included. Wouldn't Guru Sahib automatically know HIMSELF that Keski was a kakaar? So why would He have to write the 35th Hukam to re-emphasize it?? I don't see Guru Sahib making seperate hukams for Kara, Kachera, Kirpan, Kanga? So When Guru Sahib said "follow the rehit of the 5 K's" doesn't it seem that He meant KESH and not keski? Those who say that #35 is proving that keski is a kakaar are misinterpreting this Hukam for their own benefit. It's easy to say "oh, Guru Sahib said keep your head covered with a distaar at all times, so that must mean that Keski is a kakaar." Just think for a second, doesn't that seem TOO far a leap of logic? It can also be argued that Hukam #35 was levied to Singhs only. Afterall, Hukams #15 and #16 are meant specifically for men also (in my opinion). Since those two hukams are gender specific one has to be open to believe that #35 could also be gender specific. Waheguru jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru jee Kee Fateh

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

rs · 07 Apr 2003

Skittles, If the mention of dastaar in #35 excludes keski as kakaar, than shouldn't the mention of keeping kes in #47 also exclude kes as a kakaar? #15 and #16 can be taken as being gender specific because they mention gender (although I think most sikhs will agree that these two hukams apply for the reverse cases as well). #35 doesn't state any gender so how can it be taken as being gender specific? That way, we could take all hukams and gurbani and arbitrarily assign them to whichever gender, according to our own manmat.

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Khalsa · 07 Apr 2003

what is the authenticy of these hukams??

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Keski = Kakaar · 07 Apr 2003

Dearest "Skittles", OF COURSE having a dastaar on at all times is an argument for Keski as a kakaar! Who keeps a dastaar on at all times otherwise?? How is that "too far a leap of logic"?? Perhaps your logic is too far advanced for me, but let me break it down for you as I understand it: Dastaar on at all times = Keski. Seems pretty simple to me. In the list above, there are other instances of repetition: for example, gossip/slander under #21 and 40. You speak of repetition, but have you stopped to wonder why unshorn Kes would be repeated as a Kakaar if it is also included as a Bujjer kurehit? THERE'S some repetition that truly makes no sense.

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Sardaro · 07 Apr 2003

35 has no mention of gender... does anyone know the history of these hukams?

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

member · 07 Apr 2003

wjkkwjkf read a book called keski, not kesh the kakkar by prof. uday singh this is a GREAT book that counters all the anti-keski arguments and tells how the rehit of keski was lost by people, then try to argue against it. -fateh

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

ignorant · 07 Apr 2003

Could someone answer the questions raised by Tarnveer Singh's post above? Kulbir Singh?

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

sangh · 07 Apr 2003

From my understanding this docuement was handed out many years back in UK and I have seen a similar gurmukhi version at a friends house, he has 100 copies which he recieved from india one year...From what I know it is not an authenic hukamnama given by Maharaaj Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji rather a collection and compliation of the hukams. As per the keski kakaar argument you may want to look at the AUTHENTIC hukamnama given to the sangat of Kabul in which kes is listed amongst the other four. No mention of keski is given. As per the argument #35: 35)Dastaar bina nahi rehnaa - Wear a turban at all times. How is one expected to take kesi ishnaan? If we are to except this as the hukam which states keski as the kakaar then by having the keski tied around our waste defeats the purpose as it is not longer in dastaar form. My personal view is that kes is the kakaar however one should not be without keski (make or female), and thus is a mandatory part of the khalsa bana however not a kakkaar.

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Singhnee · 08 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! When we go to take Amrit, organizers announce that they will be providing punj kakaars at the Gurduaara Sahib. We all know we get five kakaars from Guru Sahib jee when we take Amrit. kes are already there how organizers can give us kes if one considers kes as kakaar. Kes are daat of Waheguru as our whole body is created by Waheguru jee. Kes are just a part of our body. We get punj kakaars from outside. Those are keski, kangha, karha, kirpaan and kachhehraa. There's already hukam for not cutting kes. It's a bujjar kurehat. If kes were kakaar then Guru Sahib jee didn't have to consider kes as a bujjer kurehat. There is a purpose behind every hukam. For proof you can check the history. There is a historical proof that there was no Amrit sinchaar without keski before May 1930. New jathedaar of Akaal Takhat Sahib, Gurumukh Singh Musaafir, was resposible for this dhill. His Singhni was not wearing dastaar. Then he started two Amrit Sinchaars. One was on Sunday and another on Wednesday. In one there was hukam of keski and second was without keski for dhillian bibiaan. Before that there was no Amrit Sinchaar without keski at all. It reminds me of that monkey experiment posted by kulbir singh jee. Kulbir Singh jee or Balpreet Singh jee could you please give documented proof of this historic incident? I forgot some datails of it. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 15)Par-Istri, Ma-Bhain, Dhi-Bhain, kar jaanani. Par Istri da sang nahi karna - Recognize all other women other than your wife as mothers and sisters. Do not engage in marital behavior with them. 16)Istri da mooh nahi fitkaarnaa - Do not silence your wife? <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Above hukams are for both genders. Do you think women don't have to recognize men as their son, brothers and father? or can women engage in marital behaviour with them??? Guru Sahib jee included above hukam in bujjar kurehat which is for both men and women. In 16 Guru sahib mentioned gender because at that time (even in these days in many families)place in society was not higher in comparison to men. There are many hukams in Gurbani which tell a wife to respect her husband. So in above mentioned hukams Guru Sahib jee mentioned gender just because of smaaj kureets. Otherwise there are same hukams for men and women in Gurbaani. Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Balpreet Singh · 08 Apr 2003

The Hukumnama from Kabul is a fake. Dr. Ganda Singh has collected all the hukumnamas issued by the Gurus and they all share some common features. They all have a nishaan at the top, with a message and manglacharan in the hand of Guru jee and at the bottom is written a message in the hand of a scribe. The Kabul Hukumnama does not follow this set-up. It's also not included in the Dr. Ganda Singh book. In the "Keski Proof" thread, there is clear proof that the kakaar given was keskee by way of the Bhatt Vehis which are the most contemporary source from those times.

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Skittles · 08 Apr 2003

"Dastaar on at all times = Keski. Seems pretty simple to me." - Just because it seems simple to you doesn't mean that it's correct. "If the mention of dastaar in #35 excludes keski as kakaar, than shouldn't the mention of keeping kes in #47 also exclude kes as a kakaar?" - No. I don't think the issue of Kesh as a Kakaar has ever been argued. One thing puzzles me though. If I keep all five K's and I assume that Keski is a kakaar. Does that mean that I can cut my hair as long as I wear a Keski? Afterall, all 5 K's are being kept are they not? (i.e. Kara, Kachera, Kirpan, Kanga, Keski) However, if you start saying that "no, hair is a kakaar too" then shouldn't you be advocating 6 K's? (Kara, Kachera, Kirpan, Kanga, Keski, Kesh). SO which is it? If Keski is a kakaar then that means Kesh is out...no? Or wait...Kesh is in and SO is Keski...so that's 6 K's???!??!?

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Mkhalsa · 08 Apr 2003

>>>>>Does that mean that I can cut my hair as long as I wear a Keski?<<<<<<<< LOL!!!! Pyare Skittles Jeeo, have you ever heard of the 4 bujjar kuraits????!! obviously you cannot cut your hair!!!

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

rs · 08 Apr 2003

Skittles said 'No. I don't think the issue of Kesh as a Kakaar has ever been argued.' ???? Then what are we arguing about right now? 'One thing puzzles me though.......' I'm having a hard time figuring out how this could puzzle anyone. Have you ever heard of the 4 bujjer kurehits? Let me explain. Guru Saahib gave us 5 kakkars and as well, he forbade sikhs from committing four actions, termed as bujjer kurehits. Actually, we are forbidden from many other things as well, but these 4 are especially serious. Committing them will have you become a patit and you will have to reshuk amrit. One of these four is cutting of hair. Are things beginning to clear up for you? Can you connect the dots from here? Are you seeing the light? Well, let me try clarifying the picture a little more. If you commit a bujjer kurehit, you are no longer considered a khalsa until you reshuk amrit, regardless of whether you wear your kakkars or not. If you temporarily lose a kakaar, you are still a khalsa and don't have to reshuk amrit. Cutting your hair falls into the bujjer kurehit category. This makes kes higher up than the kakkars. Hopefully, the pieces are beginning to fit together and form a picture for you. If not, then hopefully somebody else will be able to help you out.

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Mr. Singh · 08 Apr 2003

>>>>>>>>>>>>>> If I keep all five K's and I assume that Keski is a kakaar. Does that mean that I can cut my hair as long as I wear a Keski? >>>>>>>>>>>>>> ofcourse not. Cutting your kesh is a bajur kurahit. But using your logic it would be okay to walk around without a dastaar because keski is then not required. Also, if one person were to cut their hair would they be taking off a kakkar (which you get peshed for) or would they be breaking their amrit? because cutting kesh is a bajjar kurahit? >>>>>>>>>>>>>> 5 K's are being kept are they not? (i.e. Kara, Kachera, Kirpan, Kanga, Keski) However, if you start saying that "no, hair is a kakaar too" then shouldn't you be advocating 6 K's? >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Kesh is not a kakkar that's the whole point. Cutting kesh is a bajjur kurahit. Keski is a kakkar. What is the ned for repetition...if cutting kesh is a bajjur kurahit then why is it also a kakkar? >>>>>>>>>>>>> (Kara, Kachera, Kirpan, Kanga, Keski, Kesh). SO which is it? If Keski is a kakaar then that means Kesh is out...no? Or wait...Kesh is in and SO is Keski...so that's 6 K's???!??!? >>>>>>>>>>>>> I don't you realize that it is a firm stand of the Akhand Keertanee jatha that Keski and not kes is a kakkar. It is not ok to cut one's hair because if one does they break their amrit and are no longer sikhs. If you have any further misconceptions please state them. Their are only keski, kirpan, kanga, kara, kacchehra Skittles I was quite suprised that you are not aware of the 4 bajur kurahits. one of them is cutting kesh. So your argument does not apply rather backfires because if kesh was a kakkar then that means we could walk around with our heads uncovered shamelessly.

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Skittles · 08 Apr 2003

I am aware of the Bujjar Kurhaits. Sorry, it was my mistake to try to disagree with the issue of Keski as a kakaar on an akj forum. I suppose this debate should be had on a forum with more open-minded individuals. But it should be said, that if Keski as a kakaar was so rock-solid a position, then why hasn't the rest of the Panth accepted it as a kakaar? Oh wait, let me guess...because the rest of the panth is wrong and AKJ is right because they have researched it. The surprising thing is that anyone can find evidence for their position in anything. Once again, sorry for rocking the boat. And for the record, I have no problem with girls wearing a keski. (Which is ultimately what this issue comes down to). I think girls in keski's look as beautiful as ANY other girl out there. I think that they have a right to wear a keski if they wish. So please don't take my disagreement with this issue as a sign that I just don't think women should wear keskis.

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

member · 08 Apr 2003

jeeez wats wrong wid everyone jsut cuz it says u have to wear a dastar doesnt' mean its a kakar! i think alot of ppl agree that both male and female should wear dastar just not that its a kakar, not for the fact they dont wanan wear it when they at home, but just for the simple fact that the majority of documentation avialable all show kes to be the kakar. yes keski does make sense to be the 5th kakar, but who are we to use our own logic, isn't that called manmat! i use to think it was kakkar untill i read the dasam granth where it says kes. no some ppl dispute this to be guru jee's actuall work. But do wat u want, if u not sure wear yur dastar as a kakar. But the majority of the panth agrees the Kakar is kes, therefore if someone asks u, u should say kes is the kakar, but it was guru jees hukam to always have a dastar.

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Singhnee · 08 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> How is one expected to take kesi ishnaan? If we are to except this as the hukam which states keski as the kakaar then by having the keski tied around our waste defeats the purpose as it is not longer in dastaar form. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< I ask you one question. kangha is a kakaar and we have to keep it in our kes thats the hukam. So what you call it when it's in your hand to comb your kes??? Does it become a piece of wood then??? Another, When you change your dastaar or remove it before you sleep or any other time then what you call it when it's not tied around your head. Does it become a long piece of fabric or chaador??? sangh jeeo talk about logic don't say something just to argue. There is a hukam for ishnaan(kes ishnaan) and you tie your keski around waste and for other body ishnaan you have to tie your kirpan around head. It's still a kirpaan. Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Mkhalsa · 08 Apr 2003

Skittles jeeo, first off we are very open minded people. I never beleive anything anyone tells me, i sit there and question adn question until they are fed up with me, but that way i learn something. And i would not beleive keski is a kakar if it isnt true. I have not seen one SHRED of evidence kes is a kakkar except for books written in the last 20 yeras or so. Historically, it is documented that keski is a kakkar and in fact before last century.. the word kakkar wasnt even used!! thats why it is hard to prove anything.. with your logic i could prove that kirpan or something else is not a kakkar, but that is a useless debate. Also this is the institute of GURMAT studies and is a sikh forum, not an akj one. we are all guru khalsa panth, and if you have any solid arguemtns against keski as a kakkar i truly want to hear them, i am not just being nice here, i have a curiosity and i want to know, so please teach us soemthing since you are so much wiser :)

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Skittles · 08 Apr 2003

Mkhalsa Ji, Nope...not wiser at all. ..and I respectfully decline to make any arguement against keski as a kakaar on this forum. Perhaps another time and DEFINITELY another place we can discuss this further.

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Mkhalsa · 08 Apr 2003

pyareo, if you do not want to this with me here, please please email me, i want to know your views, it is important to me :) --your shorta veer

Re: Guru Gobind Singh Sahib's 52 Hukamnamas

Admin · 08 Apr 2003

Khalsa jee, We have decided to close this thread as it is not doing any good to the sangat visiting this site. We have reached a point in this debate where nothing new is being offered and this debate is spoiling the spiritual atmosphere of this site. If you want to know our stance on this issue of Keski, please refer to the Gurmat Literature section. Let us post inspirational stories on this site. Let us ensure that our posts are such that the sangat who comes here gets a spiritual upliftment as opposed to being swamped with abuses and curses at each other. Our aim is to be one with Vaheguru and to attain this goal, we need to indulge in Naam and Gurbani. If someone has a genuine question on Keski or any other part of rehit, please feel free to discuss but let us not start arguing. Constructive debating is okay but not destructive one. Keeping this in mind, we have decided to close this thread. Admin.