Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Sikhism beyond India

Sikhism beyond India

Nav Singh · 07 Feb 2005

We all know tens of thousands of Sikhs are leaving India every year to settle abroad and that there is a significant Sikh Diaspora settled in the UK, US, Canada, Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand, Germany etc. What kind of shape will Sikhs and Sikhism outside of India take 50 or a 100 years from now? I'd like people's thoughts on this...please keep in mind, I am thinking LONG TERM 50, 100, or even 200 years from now. 1.) Do you think Sikhism, when it is removed from its traditional Punjabi/Indian background and close contact with Hinduism, will emerge in a more purified way? (Free of caste, dowry etc.) Or will Sikhism just die out without the vehicle of Punjabi culture to carry it? 2.) Do you think Sikhism will become a "world religion" like Buddhism, Islam or Christianity, 50 or 100 years from now, where we people from all sorts of backgrounds (Chinese, Africans, Frenchmen, Anglos) participating in the religion or will it become an "ethnic" religion like Judaism or Zorastrianism where people from one ethnic background like the Punjabis practice it? 3.) Will the Sikhs settled abroad bring reform and new ideas to the practice of Sikhism in India? 4.) Will neo-Sikh and pseudo-Sikh groups (like Namdharis, Nirankaris, Radha Soamis) proliferate in the Sikh diaspora over time? 5.) As Sikhs settle all over the world, will the practice of Sikhism be affected by other religious majorities encountered by Sikh immigrants (for example will Sikhs in the US be affected by Christian practices, Sikhs in Thailand by Buddhist traditions)?

Re: Sikhism beyond India

Singh · 08 Feb 2005

Although it takes time to reply to this post, I encourage others to make the effort. It is a worthwhile topic. 1) I think that removal from Punjabi culture will remove certain impurities such as focus on the caste system, dowry, etc. But here I'm talking about rehitvan Khalsas not, regular Punjabi immigrants. But at the same time certain impurities like dating, etc. will also be introduced. But I think removal from Punjab will be overall a positive. 2) Sikhi was designed to be a multi-ethnic faith and in the times of the Gurus, it was indeed a multi-ethnic faith. There were Bengali Sikhs, and Afghan Sikhs and even Sikhs in Sri Lanka. But due to neglect and circumstances, those sangats have been lost. I think Sikhi will never be restricted just to Punjabis since it was never designed to be a single-ethnic faith. But we have to get over the belief that Sikhi is not a missionary faith. What exactly were all the Manjis? And what did the Gurus go on such long travels to do? To preach of course. 3) Sikhs abroad will defintely bring new ideas to India. I can see a revival of many things coming from the West. The Gadhar Party was from the West and in the same way, I see Sikh Independence movements also coming from the West one day. 4) I don't think groups like Namdharis will grow in the west. For a young Namdhari, I think it's easier to identify as a Sikh as opposed to an obscure group. I could be wrong, but I think that future generations of Namdharis setlled abroad will assimilate into the larger Sikh community. As for Radha Soami and Nirankari: I don't consider them to be Sikhs and I'm not sure what level of parchar they are doing in the Sikh community in the West. 5) Practices like tables and chairs are western but were rejected. In California I believe there was once a gurdwara designed like a church with pews and benches etc. But I don't see these changes being widely accepted. To be clear though, Punjab is the homeland of the Sikhs. All Sikhs are residents of Anandpur Sahib and in that way we are all Pardesi when we live away from there. Anandpur is our home. So we will never and should never break our connection to there. And we should never forget that Punjab and Sikhi are inseparably linked.

Re: Sikhism beyond India

Sahibzaadeyian dee prernaa · 08 Feb 2005

There is always a reason behind what Lord Waheguru does. Guru Nanak said, ' ujjad jao'' to good people who served him nicely and we all know what he meant by saying that-( wherever these good people would go, would only spread goodness) SO there might be a reason that Waheguru ji is helping true Sikhs settle in the foreign lands And we keep our voices up by repeatedly saying RAAJ KAREGA KHALSA AAKEE RUHEY NAA KOYEY< KHUAAR HOEY SAB MILENGEY, BUCHEY SHARAN JO HOEY May Khalsa Raaj takes place while i'm alive! vahegurujikakhalsavahegurujikifateh PS- An elderly lady in our street used to say:'jab aeyga beesa(when the years would start with the no. 20) naa rahega isaa naa rahega moosa means(no other main religions of the world would prosperous). Please don't take it as a talk against any other religion - its just a shared thought

Re: Sikhism beyond India

AnotherSingh · 08 Feb 2005

There was a prophecy attributed to Guru Nanak wherein he stated that true Sikhi in india would decrease and it would then come back into india from the outside. I'm not sure of it's authenticity but it's mentioned in Cunninghams History of the Sikhs. 4.) Will neo-Sikh and pseudo-Sikh groups (like Namdharis, Nirankaris, Radha Soamis) proliferate in the Sikh diaspora over time? They already are here. If you look on the internet or in the back pages of certain magazines these fake ''gurus'' advertise for people to learn meditation from a ''true master''. Their target audience is not just sikhs, it's anybody who will listen.

Re: Sikhism beyond India

TRIGGER · 08 Feb 2005

We (punjabis) are the one`s to be blamed for the relatively advertising of sikhi. Sikhi is meant for humanity, yet generaly only punjabis are seen in the gurudwara. Punjabis seem to keep sikhi amongst themselves- I`m not saying we should stuff it down everyone`s throat, but we don`t even give people the chance to find out about sikhi. Say if every time we had something like an akhand paath eg for a birthday in the family and non-sikh / non-punjabi friends and neighbours were invited, then imagine the amount of parchaar that could have been done ... ??

Re: Sikhism beyond India

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 09 Feb 2005

As Sikhs travel abroad in this world, so does Sikhi. There are people of many races and backgrounds now practicing the faith (including me). 1.) Do you think Sikhism, when it is removed from its traditional Punjabi/Indian background and close contact with Hinduism, will emerge in a more purified way? (Free of caste, dowry etc.) Or will Sikhism just die out without the vehicle of Punjabi culture to carry it? I think it's highly likely that it will. To a "gori" like me...and many other non-Indians...the idea of dowry is ludicrous, the 786:1000 is a ghastly human tragedy, and caste is something that is completely unknown to us and likely to stay that way. 2.) Do you think Sikhism will become a "world religion" like Buddhism, Islam or Christianity, 50 or 100 years from now, where we people from all sorts of backgrounds (Chinese, Africans, Frenchmen, Anglos) participating in the religion or will it become an "ethnic" religion like Judaism or Zorastrianism where people from one ethnic background like the Punjabis practice it? That really depends on whether religion itself will grow or fade. Certainly in the west, the "if it feels good, do it" secular humanistic attitude is taking the place of religion. I think it is certainly possible that Sikhi can beome a world religion...if there are enough people that will bother with religion to follow it. 3.) Will the Sikhs settled abroad bring reform and new ideas to the practice of Sikhism in India? I doubt it. If Gurbani can't convince the Panjabis that castes should be ignored...I don't see NRIs being more powerful than Guru Sahib. 4.) Will neo-Sikh and pseudo-Sikh groups (like Namdharis, Nirankaris, Radha Soamis) proliferate in the Sikh diaspora over time? I guess it's possible...but serious proliferation in multiple countries will also require an interest in religion over secular pleasures. Plus...there has to be an interest in such a thing by the local populace. I don't see the pseudo-Sikh groups being overly attractive to westerners at this time. 5.) As Sikhs settle all over the world, will the practice of Sikhism be affected by other religious majorities encountered by Sikh immigrants (for example will Sikhs in the US be affected by Christian practices, Sikhs in Thailand by Buddhist traditions)? I'm sure it will...but I don't think the effect will be particularly damaging to Sikkhi. For example, I put up a Christmas tree in my home and exchange gifts with my closest friends...not because I see it as a strictly Christian thing to do...but because it's what I really like to do. I love holiday time in America, and I respect what Christmas means to Christians, even though that is not my path any more.