Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Kulwinder Singh · 05 Feb 2005
Should We Ban Saint Status Now ? (may be ban is wrong word we could use disallow the use of it.)
===========================================================
My Intentions for this topic are: To see what is the status of our minds and feelings in this new Century regarding Saints.
Saints are always been part and parcel of our traditions, Some did lot of good in the past and some times we have been cheated very badly by these so called Saints. What is our situation now do we have true saints now or do we have to make due with Saintly figures rather then true saints ?
I just want to know from all of you, please contribute.
When I say “Should we Ban Saint Status now ?” It must not impact on the past Good Saints who did lot of good in their life time and lived admirable life.
It is a question not judgement so please do not assume I am forcing my Judgment.
============================================================
Should we have debate in the community that all the people who have Saint as status in their name should not use it?
A real Saint would not have problem giving up that title? or may be I am wrong.
If somebody want to call them self as Jathedar that is fine as Jathedar mean the head of Jath. But Saint does have very powerful meaning and it is difficult to authorised somebody to take that status. Saints Status is very high is Sikhism does anybody deserve it in present time ?
Would we be doing Injustice to some deserving souls who may deserve the title ?( if there are some true saints around, please tell if you know one).
What contribution Saints of Sikhs have done in the past, present and what contribution we can expect from Saints.( In this question I am saying saint to the users of Saint status, no guarantees that they are real Saints)
Do we need Saints ? Can we make Saints ? Are Saints are endangered Spices or have we lost them for ever ? Is their any hope we may Get a true Saint in present time or in future.
Do you know any true Saint now ?
Have you met a true Saint and what was your experience ?
Status Saint better or being Saintly is better these days ?
Should we wish for one type of fragrance in Sikh or multiple type of fragrance are good, as long as they are good fragrance .( hint to say that different Saints have generated different fragrances ).
=============================================================
Just a note: ( I do apologies if I am hurting somebody with this topic ? I have just came out of another topic ( sarbloh) where I should have been more sensitive and I am trying not to repeat the mistake again but as I know I am moorakh and could do the same mistake again.)
=============================================================
[%sig%]
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Thakur kaur Taksali · 06 Feb 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
Bete Kulwinder Singh Ji, the rot has spread too far.
We have GYANIS..a dime a dozen who have no gyan..I can name many
We have SANTS... a Dime triple darjan....with no santiness
We have SADHS..without any sadhuness
We have BABAS..without any bibek
We have MAHARAJS...without any raj
We have Jathedars..without any jathas..
We have Akalis ..without any Akaal
We have Granthis..without any knowledge of Granths..except parrotted banis/sakhis.....and who sleep most of the time
We have Kirtaniyas..without any raag vidya except bollywood tunes..
We have SIKHS who dont sikh anything ? just leek they fakir
We have Pardhaans who just stick to kurseeaan
We have Sewadaars who steal rations and do nindiya of others
We have Gurmatt parcharaks..who also do part time work in Offices
We have Office workers who do part time Parchaar work
We have teachers who teach nothing but nindiya...
ARE we going to ban all of them ??
GURU JI gave us 1429 Aangs of Ilahi bani... the BEST in the Universe so as to LEARN GURBANI, VICHAAR GURBANI, and FOLLOW GURBANI and LIVE GURBANI....but what do we do..we go look for some sant ji who will give us the magic formula to drink..and we will get instant gratification....GURU NANAK Ji ddint interefere with Waheguru's HUKM and grant His One and ONLY Loving Sisiter and her husband a SON/Daughter..but many many "sants" of Guru Nanak claim to give such boons to thousands of childless "sikh" women ( in return of muthee chaapi of their thighs...and more...) We had one such Kali kambliwala whose muthee chapee spree led to an all out assault by the same ladies..and he was sent so fast to the airport that he left his kaleh lekh behind but took his kali kambli to Europe..I still see his adverts in the European Papers..so he has not learnt his lesson..just shifted base. When he just arrived.. SANGATAAN were rushing to fill up his SAMAGAMS where he sang Kirtan so beautifully.....and the ladies were tripping over each other to muthee chapee him in "upstairs rooms"...when he saw one exceptionally beautiful young girl..he asked her to muthee chappe his legs higher and higher..until the ladies got out their Chhittars ( I whacked HIM three Good ones on his back...i am proud of it)
Please excuse any mistakes...i am dictating and my youngest pootee is typing.
Bebe
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Sant Ka Marag Dharam Ki Paurhi · 06 Feb 2005
If you view and observe a Sant, you can gain some knowledge and insight into the lifestyle. What are you going to do with the knowledge unless you gain the ras, experience.
"Manjil Faquira Vali Mildi Hai Mar Mar Ke"
To experience something you have to die over and over again to obtain that Manjil, stage.
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Sant Ka Marag Dharam Ki Paurhi · 06 Feb 2005
That kali kambli that 'kaur 'taksali' is talking about is probably a copycat one.
When there is one that has done the kamaii, worked so hard to get to where they are at and receive duty from Akal Purkh, then there are also people that get up and start to copy that person with intentions for personal gain. There is this one place 'Tapoban Dhakki Sahib' (where late Charnjeet Singh stayed for a while), when the mahapursh there gained widespread popularity, then there were a couple of other places that started calling there dera 'Dhakki Sahib' and started copying.
The 'Kali Kambli' mahapursh (real one) Sant Narain Singh 'Moni' are Brahmgiani. I don't think they have even been to Malaysia before.
I'll share a story about Sant Narain Singh - there was a wrestling tournament going on and the top wrestler had an open challenge for anyone. Sant Narain Singh was there and wrestled the guy. The wrestler was a massive person. Sant Narain Singh picked him up and flipped him over onto his back. And then they said "Ja Guru Hoi Val Lakha Bahe Kia Keeja"(not sure about exact spelling for the gurbani tuk, but it means what can thousands of arms do when the Guru with you).
Bhul Chuk Maaf
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Gurpreet Singh · 06 Feb 2005
Ban the Sant time? Why would u do that? REAL Sants are sent down by akal purakhu to help guide us. These sants deserve respect. If you have a problem with everyone with "sant" infront of their name, than its you with the problem not them.
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 06 Feb 2005
There is a disconnect here that I cannot understand. For a religion that speaks of courage there seems to be no shortage of Sikhs that wish to ban things instead of having the courage to stand up to them.
Fake saints...miracle sap...astrological readings...these are all things that prey on the gullible. And they are all happening right now as we speak.
Even if Amritsar succeeds in disallowing fake saints (which I doubt they will be able to do), there are and will be plenty of new ways to sucker those anxious to get a leg up on whatever. The only thing we would be "banning" is our legacy of strength.
We need to stand up against frauds. We need to stand up against cultural trappings that are valued above Gurbani. And...we need to keep a firm commitment to the education of our people, and not see slacking off in school as a "cool" thing to do. If one does not posess the basic analytical skills to recognize a fraud...one will be suckered by a lot more in life than just a fake saint.
bol chuk maaf
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Manjeet Singh · 07 Feb 2005
Who's the 108 Brahamgaini Sant who is advertising on Sukh Sagar Radio for bookings of his UK visit? What a joke!
When things are this bad, you know something needs to be done! The Sant term is being abused.
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Kulwinder Singh · 07 Feb 2005
Dear “ Me “ Ji you are too wise for this, try some other forms where your level of thinking prevails.
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Gurdaspuria · 07 Feb 2005
Waheguru jee ka Khalsa
Waheguru jee kee Fateh
I believe there must be awareness: why we should not call others Sant/Sadh/satguru and we must not let anybody address us by Sant/Sadh/satguru based on Gurbani.
In recent days It has been hot issue who is true sadh, sant and SatGuru, ?
It is very import to sort out this term so that no body can scare us with "SANT KE NINDA". In reality the term Sadh and Sant is used for Satguru.
The Gurbani has addressed Satguru using many names. Some of these names are: beloved, friend, companion, Sadh, Sant, etc. If the definition of Satguru is not completely understood as per Gurbani, this can lead to the worshipping of earthly “saints.” Understanding this principle is very important. Only this understanding can stop this spreading of dehdhari (bodily) Satgurus, Sadhs or Sants who are preaching their own holiness and misleading people. In the Gurus’ era, no one ever called each other Sadh or Sant. Instead they simply called each other Bhai (Brother/Sister).
In some places in Gurbani, the term Sadh or Sant is also used to refer to God. Occasionally it is also used to refer to the people who follow the path of Satguru, the ultimate saint. In some places in Gurbani, these earthly Sadhs or Sants are called thugs (thieves), who mislead innocent people into rituals and away from the path of Satguru.
The Gurbani, like a mother, cradles us, holds our hand, warns us from the wrong path, teaches us Gurmat, and re-enforces the importance of meditating on God’s name. It also tells us to be a Sikh of Satguru, to be humble, and to meditate on God’s name with great love and devotion.
If we carefully read Gurbani, we can easily find the direction given by our Gurus and Bhagats in Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji: Be humble, it is better to be called Gursikh, Bhai, or Bhain rather than Sadh or Sant. If we think ourselves superior to the rest of the mankind then it is extremely difficult to establish or keep a close relationship with God
This is based on numerous quotations from Gurbani so that the true character of Real Satguru-Sadh-Sant can be understood to dispel ignorance about terms.
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Thakur kaur Taksali · 07 Feb 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji KI Fateh Ji.
Gurdasspuria has put it as best as can be said.
awareness...genuine awareness of what gurbani actually says and not what the "sants" and their chelas tell you is the key.
Sikhi and gurmat has no place for earthly human sants/sadhs/gurus...that is why Guru Ji STOPPED the human Guru Line at 10veen patshahi and put us under Guru Granth ji. The word Sant and Sadh is for GURU JI, WAHEGURU and SADH SANGAT ONLY.
Those in Human Form who persist in calling themsleves SANT/SADH/BABA are identified in Gurbani as BENARAS KE THUGGH. Ever woondered why these sants NEVER read this Shabad... avoid it like the PLAGUE..but every two bit sant will read Sukhmani Sahib umpteen times and try to frighten you with sant kee ninda ????..reason is becasue GURBANI uncovers these FRAUDS for what they are. The "gurbani, parchaar, amrit sanchaars etc are just "fronts" for tehri own chellagiri and chamchagiiri.
I am also a sikh woamn and i have been there ..alone and in the comapny of other women who were misguided...now i stay as far away as i can from anyone who is a sant/sadh/babaji...especially whose visit/kirtan/etc is advertised as Saadh ke Saang.... Sadh kee sewa...etc quotes from Gurbani which clearly refers to SADH SANGAT and not one SAADH.
bebe
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Lakhvir Singh · 07 Feb 2005
Kulbir Singh Ji (UK wala) Ji,
WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.
Who exactly is this guy (Pehowa wala) that you mention is coming to Kenya? The Kenya sangat here is so raw in Sikhi that if such a person comes to do parchar here and he is of questionable character, he/she needs to be stopped.
I'm in Kenya. I know nothing about this guy. If he steps onto our soil and I don't know much about him, I may not know what the real picture is.
Please, please, please, Sangat Ji, tell me all about this guy 'Pehowa wala' and with GuruJi's kipra, help us stop such a person coming amidst our community.
Also please advice me how I can approach this matter with the sangat, or the gurudwara committee/sponsor that is bringing him here.
In Kenya, we need strong parchar and such a person can really not help us much. Sikhi in Kenya is in its revival stages and we need the right people and the right parchar. Please help me here to help create the awareness . . . before it is too late.
Please also furnish me with as much information (including his pciture) about this 'Pehowa wala' so that I can state facts to our Sikhs here . . . Please, please, please . . . As soon as you can . . .
WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh.
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
to "qwertyuio" · 08 Feb 2005
Re. the Akal Takht not listening to one of our sisters. This situation occured a few years ago too, with another monster using the title of sant,
"Dera head gets 10-yr jail for rape
Tribune News Service
Hoshiarpur, January 29
Baba Dhanwant Singh, head of the Noor Vishwa Ruhani Charitable Trust based at Pilli Jhikki village, near Garhshankar, was sentenced to 10-year imprisonment by the fast-track court headed by Mr R.L. Ahuja here today for allegedly raping an unmarried daughter of an ardent follower of the dera.
The allegations levelled by Navin Kaur (name changed) in 2000 against the dera chief that she had been raped by the baba had kicked up a storm as the dera had a large number of followers, not only in the Doaba area, but around the globe.
Even as the dera authorities and the baba had been refuting allegations, Baba Dhanwant Singh was arrested by the Garhshankar police on August 29, 2002, following an inquiry by the Nawanshahr SSP.
The enquiry was ordered by the Jalandhar IG, Mr S.K. Sharma, on the basis of a complaint filed by the father of the girl."
Good to hear that pehowa wala is planning a trip in November 2005, thank you for the advance notice...LOL
And we wonder why Sikhi is in the situation that it is....
Kulbir Singh Dhillon UK. wala
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Kulbir Singh · 08 Feb 2005
Benti to everyone to stick to the topic and not get individuals involved in this debate.
As for banning the saint status in Sikhi, I don’t think anyone in this world has the power to ban the Sant Status. Guru Sahib himself bestows this status on his gursikhs and only he can take it away.
The gursikhs who get elevated spiritually reach high spiritual states and reach the status of Bhagat / Sant / Saadh. But such gursikhs are so humble that they consider themselves to be dust of feet of everyone. First of all, then never let anyone call them anything but a Sikh. They never let the name “Sant” get attached to their name. They always remain “Guru Panth key Daas”.
In Gurmat, there is no precedent of granting anyone the Sant status. On their own, many times Gursikhs call each other sants or bhagats but there is no maryada of declaring anyone a Sant. In the light of this, Guru Panth cannot ban the status of Sant. This status or avastha or spiritual state comes from Guru Sahib and he alone can take it away. However, what Guru Panth can do is ban the prefix "Sant" to be used with anyone. This would be a welcome move by Siri Akal Takhat Sahib.
In Gurbani, most of the times, when the word “Sant’, “Saadh” is used as a singular it is used for Guru Sahib. By the same token, these words have been used for Gursikhs as well. Even Vaheguru has been called a “Sant”. It all depends on the pankiti of Gurbani. Please read “Sant Padd Nirnai” written by Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. This book is an authority on this topic.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Waste of Time · 08 Feb 2005
When the sangat who follow a "Sant" around are all non-amritdharis or non-keshdharis then we must question what the motives of this "Sant".
When the "Sant" cruises in a private number plate Merc, then we must question whether this is the image of a great humble Sant we have in our minds.
Sukh Sagar Radio are advertising some "Sant" , I think he calls himself BrahmGiani 108 Sant Baba Kartar Singh Mahraj who is coming down to the UK this month. He appears to have an Agent for bookings and schedule information. The advert is like some Superstar is coming down to the UK. Where is the humilty of the Sant?
The modern term 'Sant' has been abused over the last 20 years. I want to be proved wrong. I want to see those Sants of the Nand Singh, Attar Singh, Isher Singh, Jarnail Singh calibre. Not the Pakhands that live off the Kamai of Nanaksar or RaraSahib or any other dera.
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Kulwinder Singh · 08 Feb 2005
Can Somebody give some name of current good Saints ? if possible.
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
Gurdaspuria · 08 Feb 2005
Waheguru jee ka Khalsa
Waheguru jee kee Fateh
What is the root cause of this proliferation of these so called sadh and sants?
1) we don't try to comprehend Gurbani
2) We don't want do our own Kamayee as Gurbani recommends
3) We try go get ready made so called blessing.
4) We believe in stories more than Gurbani
5) If somebody gets the courge to stand agaianst there so called sadh/sants. People will scare him with "sant kee ninda"
...
Waheguru jee ka Khalsa
W@aheguru jee kee fateh
Waheguru jee kee Fateh
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
interesting · 09 Feb 2005
Should we Ban Saints?
Well there are many ppl living today claiming to be Gurus. But these are fake Gurus - only true Guru is Siri Guru Granth Sahib Maharaaj. The fake Gurus always get distinguished from the True Guru. Just look at Sikh History.
Same way there are many fake Sants. But should we ban them? No, because then we'd have to do the same for the Gurus, because of the fake Gurus. Just as in Guru Jee's time, the fake Sants always get caught out, whilst the true splendour of the Real Sants always becomes apparent --> this is the Khel/Play of Waheguroo.
Bhul Chuk Maaf
Waheguroo
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
interesting · 09 Feb 2005
>>Can Somebody give some name of current good Saints ? if possible.
Just to add. There probably are many saints that are living at the moment. But they are currently Gupt - they are changing the lives of many towards Gurmat in their own way, but don't make a fuss about it. It is only when they have left that we realise collectively their spiritual greatness.
Remember that many people scorned Guru Nanak Dev Jee in their travels, (even though many others were influenced). It is only once the Gurus left that ppl realised their greatness.
Even today, ppl cannot tell the difference between good and bad. We have Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee Maharaaj, Sache Paatshah to guide us, but moorakhs like me cannot follow their message.
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
SantKaMarag DharamKiPauri · 09 Feb 2005
Any possible offending material removed.
A person is innocent until proved otherwise.
Baba Ji Mann Singh has been accused of all manner of things but has yet not been charged. Why ????
How long does it take for someone being accused and that person being arrested and charged ????
These allegations – and that’s all they are, allegations – have been aimed at baba Ji for easily over a year, why has no one arrested or charged him ? The reason is that these allegations are false. The fact that his uncle is one of the accusers is very telling. This is all to do with the family trying to get land of Baba Ji and Baba Ji refusing because the land is the sangats and not the relatives, hence the false accusations.
How long are these allegations going to go on ? Why has somebody not done anything to charge him if the case is so bloody water tight ! People like **** would have been on the first plane to India to get their pound of flesh if there was any truth in the allegations. So, until anything concrete happens I suggest you all shut it !
Re: Should We Ban Saint Status Now ?
let him try Canada... · 09 Feb 2005
To: "SantKaMarag DharamKiPauri"
Your obviously new to the topic re. mann of pehowa...the girls that he has raped, are many,but three we know well, of which two were not willing to come forward, and the third one has come forward to the press in india, and has been advised to refeign from going through the courts, because of mann pehowa having very good/strong political connections, and her case could being thrown out, which would make him look even cleaner....get it...!
Please ask this 'great mahapursh' LOL, to step foot on Canadian soil....
I personally have not been effected by him, but those i have called my sisters have, even though i wasted over eight years believing all the crap he said, like before he leaves this earth, us that were the inner circle sanghat would be given everything(spiritual that we may have lacked), by him placing his hand on our heads...what a crock of....
The sanghat must look closley at his close group/chele, and judge for yourselves...itss easy
These allegations will solidify, even though the sant samarg has no back bone, after meeting with the victims and giving them a 100% guarantee of there support, they did an 'about turn'...guess we should have seen that coming, for if this popular sant gets nailed because of his mis-deeds, then what would become of the other members of the sant samarg, what would people think of them?
I apologise to all those that have to be exposed to this information again, lets just sit back and enjoy the moment...
lets stop flogging this dead horse...right Admin?
Kulbir Singh Dhillon UK wala.