Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Learning from mistakes.

Learning from mistakes.

learn · 05 Feb 2005

vaheguroo jee ka khalsa vaheguroo jee kee fateh! We usually learn from the mistakes we make. But sometimes its important to learn from the mistakes of others. One of my friends used to talk to some gursikh's online. Both singhs and singhnees alike. One day before she knew it, she became addicted and developed a habbit of talking to singhs mostly. She claimed that she did not like them in any such way and that she looked at them as brothers . Day's passed while talking to a singh. She talked to him for one year . the singh was only 1 or 2 years older than her. She thought in her head, that he good looking and awesome, and that she would be able to marry him and that he was the right match for her. She was wrong. The singh did not look at her in any such way. The singh looked at her as a sister and a friend. she happened to find this out when she heard the singh was to get married. she asked him and he told her that he was going to get married in 3 months, and that she was invited to attend the wedding. This had crushed my friend. My question is: who are we kiddingwhen we say that he or she is my bhain or veer, when in the inside, the majority of us think different. The majority of us are filled with lust. we see him or her as beautiful, people that we can marry, people that are perfect for us. i know this doesnt apply to all people because their states of mind are different. but to most people..yes this does happen. There is a limit to talking to the opposite sex. Some people say it is okay. Talk all you want on msn..they are my brother and sister. but what happens in the end? the girl/boy end up liking that person. now what happened to he or she is my brother/sister? i think we shold try avoiding talking to members of the opposite sex especially when there is a chance of us striking kaam by talking to the person and glancing at them and for yahoo or other im's we should limit talking/chatting to people of the opposite sex. useless chatting leads to addictions which is bad for your jeevan and can leave some emotional side effects

Re: Learning from mistakes.

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 06 Feb 2005

too much of anything is bad..Gurbani advises sehaj...little sleep, little food, little of everything....no excesses. Talking never hurt anybody...it is through talking that we exchange gurmatt/rehat/ides.gurbani vichaar...and this can be between the sexes. CONTROL..of the Mann, dirty thoughts, etc is advised for all ocassions.....even when walking on the street, in gurdwara langgar hall etc..the mann can go gallopping off in various directions. Gurbani advises us to "KNOW" others..as brothers, sisters, mothers, fathers......what we do is just stick to "mere calling" another Bhen Ji, Mata Ji, Bapu Ji..WITHOUT any such "knowing in our hearts",,,it is just a WORD we throw around..like many more such words....empty words..devoid of any moral attachment or deeper meaning...and then we get intoi the Moral Dilemma of having to Marry someone we already "CALLED BHEN JI" ??? IF from Standard One MR> A has been referring to a girl ( B) as Bhen Ji.....and then when they BOTH reach University..and the parents decide to get them MARRIED...and everything goes as planned.. CAN A marry B ?? What is the "WALL between them that stops the marriage"..the fact that they called each other "brother/sister all these eighteen years or so ???? WERE they ACTUALLY Brother/sister ? and is the "solution" to this dilemma ABSTAIN from calling any girl/boy as Bhen Ji/Bhraa Ji ??? And If we teach our children to ABSTAIN..then how do they communicate..what do they say when they meet one another ? MY students keep coming back to me with this "dilemma"....some just "smile" and dont say anything !! Some just AVOID the oposite sex !! soem say dont go to Gurdwara ?/ IMHO the perfect solution lies in what we have in OUR HEART. The INJUNCTION to treat all as Ones sister/brother etc COMES INTO PLAY only after one is MARRIED...and the Bhen/Bhraa Ji is MEANT to DETER SEXUAL CONTACT..not "language/spoken words". Our GURMATT MARYADA BANS SEXUAL CONTACT with anyone other than your legal wife/husband. As Children and school mates, work mates, college mates, university matres etc..where there is NO POSSIBILITY of SEXUAL CONTACT..the salutation Bhen Ji.Bhraa Ji is just a word...it doesnt MAKE anybody an actual Blood Bhen or Bhraa so that marriage becomes Taboo. This is a wrong attachment to the word. MARRIAGE is ONLY TABOO between BLOOD BROTHERS/SISTERS. Jarnail Singh

Re: Learning from mistakes.

qwertyuier5345 · 06 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh If you dont see them as a bhenji or veerji or you are not sure then don't call them anything other than their name and if you don't know their name then think of some other way to call them. If I say brother I mean brother, it is deisrepectful to then go get married to that person and do what married people do if you called them broter! Today, ppl call anyone brother but next thing you know they are dating and the whole class is in shock that they did this. They were mates and could have easily called eachother by their names. If you call someone brother you mean I treat you like my brother and that is such a clean rishta that you cant go around fancying the guy then. It makes me sick to even think that. Its like, andhoro kuch te baron kuch (saying something and doing someting: not very Sikh like in my opinion. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Learning from mistakes.

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 06 Feb 2005

I don't believe in segregating anyone. Our Gurus taught us to be strong. The world is not divided like a Gurdwara, with men on one side and women on the other. The world is full of both sexes. And any person with career or educational pursuits ahead of them is going to go about their path alongside men and women. Attractions may happen, disappointments may happen. It is nature's way. Our faith says to overcome Kaam. To be disciplined enough to fight it. Not to make a cowardly attempt to run away. It is not easy to have courage. It is much harder to live it than it is simply to talk about it.

Re: Learning from mistakes.

Kulbir Singh · 08 Feb 2005

It is best to not chat to members of opposite sex. There have been so many problems with respect to this that young Sikhs who are serious of their aim of achieving the ultimate in Sikhi – Vaheguru – to take a second look at their chatting habits. Unnecessarily communicating with members of opposite sex is fatal to Sikhi of young Sikhs. It is against our culture to do so and definitely against Gurmat to indulge in such open talks with opposite sex. This brother sister thing is just a fallacy. Don’t get trapped in this. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written in one of his books that even co-education is not a good idea. He writes that this co-education where there is an open opportunity to do chori-yaari with opposite sex, has destroyed honour of many respectable families. Baaki tuhaadi marzee hai. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Learning from mistakes.

so true · 08 Feb 2005

So true Kulbir Singh, Agree with you 100%. Only chat when needed.

Re: Learning from mistakes.

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 09 Feb 2005

and 99.99% of "chats" are idle chatter about nonsense things and topics... who "chats" about serious things like gurbani vichaar/philosophy ?? almost nobody. IN GURBANI.....Idle Chatter is likened to the "whispering of the leaves of trees" ...just like the leaves of tres shake and whisper in the wind..but this noise is of no use to anybody...much less the trees themselves.... boys and girls who indulge in such idle chatter are jsut asting time. Better to find something useful to do. Jarnail Singh