Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

beards.... help

beards.... help

Gurpreet · 05 Feb 2005

i was wondering how some sikh guys manage to keep their beards so neet n tidy, flat against their face. does this hurt and how do you do it? what do you use? im using ordinary gell and mine is all over the place... [%sig%]

Re: beards.... help

akj_singh_4eva_and_eva_amen · 05 Feb 2005

vjkk vjkf u shud NOT NOT NOT use gel on ur beard l;et it be natural, it looks unbeleivably stupid for a sikh with a long dhari to have it plastreed againt his face, one shud leave it as vahiguru has given it otherwise its a paap vjkk vjkf

Re: beards.... help

Manpreet Kaur · 05 Feb 2005

DON"T USE ANYTHING A natural flowing beard looks beautiful!

Re: beards.... help

kanwaldeep singh · 06 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh Akj singh 4eva and Manpreet Kaur have hit the nail right on the head. A flowing natural beard looks much better than one plastered to your face.Nothing like having the image of guru Gobind singh ji. daas kanwaldeep singh [%sig%]

Re: beards.... help

uiop · 06 Feb 2005

geling you beard is also a cause of acne as when u wash it out it touches ur skin in various places adn leads to a buildup of grime.

Re: beards.... help

simple man · 07 Feb 2005

eewww plastered to your face beard looks awful !!!!!!!!!! you tell me what looks better: [img]http://www.siliconindia.com/person_ftweek/images1/kathuria_ch.jpg[/img] [img]http://www.flonnet.com/fl2026/images/20040102002803803.jpg[/img] OR ... [img]http://www.kpkhalsa.com/images/Khalsa1.jpg[/img] [img]http://www.sandersphotos.com/INDIAN%20HARBHINDER%20SINGH.jpg[/img] [%sig%]

Re: beards.... help

Amar Singh · 07 Feb 2005

"one shud leave it as vahiguru has given it otherwise its a paap" now we are the Guru and can make up our own rules and what a paap is. Get real no one has this right but Guru Ji. Why don't you leave your kesh as Waheguru Ji intended and stop tying it up in an unatural joora on your head, surely this is a major paap also. Even with a full flowing open beard most people use a brush to shape it and keep it smart as did Bhai Rama Singh Ji. Is this also a paap as we are not leaving it as nature intended. Please don't make up your own rules etc, you really sound stupid.

Re: beards.... help

khalsa · 07 Feb 2005

what did Sant Jarnail singh jee say about tying up beards? What did Bhai sahib Randheer singh say about tying up beards? What do most gursikhs who have alot kaamiee and do alot of paat and have really good amrit velas say about tying up beards? I suggest anybody who wants to tie up their beard to go check with any of the above sources and see what kinda answer you get.

Re: beards.... help

uk wala... · 07 Feb 2005

I totally agree with my brother Amar singh... Some of you should listen to the comments/statements you are making. Why are we so 'overwhelmed' by just the outer appearances... for this is of little value, are we not a bi-product of the five elements, which will eventually turn to ash? I strongly feel that a lot of sikhs have missed the boat, let your beard flow or have it tied up.....all is irrelevant to the actual truth, that being you and your personal relationship with waheguru. To 'Gurpreet', try using the 'fixo' stuff with a little baby oil mixed in....less flaky substances on your beard, brother. To 'simple man', put up some handsome sardars with tied beards....then you can compare.... Do not turn my beautiful sikhi into a fundamentalist dream world... Kulbir Singh Dhillon UK. Wala

Re: beards.... help

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 07 Feb 2005

To answer Gurpreet's original question, I have seen some veerjis set their beards by applying some sort of hair fixer and pressing a cloth over the beard, tying in on the back of their head. I have no idea what sort of fixer is used, or if it hurts.

Re: beards.... help

Questions · 07 Feb 2005

The hair on the head is different to the hair everywhere else. This is as per Mahan Kosh and most other definitions (note to Sanatanist/UK Nihangs - this doesnt give you a license to shave your chest or legs, just yet). Kes is hair on the head. Other hair still cannot be removed but is not the same as hair on the head (Sir de Rom). Thus the "leave your hair" loose argument does not apply. Perhaps you should tie a kangha, keski and dastar (or maybe dumalla) on your chin should you wish to use the same logic. What are the intentions behind tying a beard? If there were situations where a beard had to be tied, did such situations exist in Praatan times? Did Nihang Singhs tie their dharis? If not how did they manage their dastar in such situations? Clue: Bhai Fauja Singh practising Gatka (right) http://www.akj.org.uk/gallery/images/puratan/FaujaSingh-2.jpg Is the issue of leaving the Dhari loose, to do with leaving the body as Guru made it, or remaining in the form of Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj Himself (Khalsa Roop)? Did any of the Gurus tie their beards? Which Mahapurkh Sikhs in history have tied their beards? What have Mahapurkhs said about tying beards? After pondering over the above, your answer to the mystery of the beard will be revealed.

Re: beards.... help

Dogma · 07 Feb 2005

There is the situation that arises where someone might have the NEED to tie their beard. For example. I know of many Singhs who work in industrial locations who tie up their beards because of the risk they have of having their dhari getting caught in some machine. Before everyone gets on their high horse about not tying beards, please perhaps realize that everyone's situation in life is different then yours... Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh! On a side note: I know that alot of Sant's said don't tie your beard, or many mahapurakhs have not tied their beards as well...but how about we all try listening to ALL of the bachans a Sant/Mahapurakh has made and not just the ones that are the easiest to follow. As I recall Amritvela, Sangat, Simran, Seva seem to be given a "little" bit of focus by Sant/Mahapurakhs...easier to live up to the physical attributes of a Singh then it is to live up to the spiritual ones I suppose...*sigh*

Re: beards.... help

Amar Singh · 07 Feb 2005

"The hair on the head is different to the hair everywhere else. " Please elaborate. For your information Kesh is uncut hair, the word does not specify where on the body. If indeed you take Mahan Kosh's definition as literal than you are contradicting your self when you argue other hair on the body cannot be removed, as you are admitting Kesh is only on the head. Guru Ji revealed to us to keep Kesh uncut hair, and never specified where on the body as the word stands for itself. Using the logic of Kesh only being on the head means all other hairs can be shaved as they do not come under the definition of Kesh. Why is it wrong to tie the kesh on the head and not on the face. Where if anywhere has Guru Ji specified this. Indeed our all knowing Guru would have mentioned such things if they were of any importance. If it is wrong to tie the beard is it ok to apply oil and brush it? What's the difference, why is one acceptable under your own laws and the other a paap. By brushing and oiling your beard you are still changing the natural shape and look of the beard in most cases to look smart, exactly in the same way some choose to tie their beards. The intentions and results are exactly the same. All this rubbish reminds me of the taliban who used to go around arresting people if their beard was too short or too long.

Re: beards.... help

Manjeet Singh · 07 Feb 2005

Muslims & Jews don't gel their beards. They are so proud of their beards. I am so embaressed when some shiny gel bearded Sikh jumps on the train and stands next to a Muslim who has his beard flowing.

Re: beards.... help

o_O · 07 Feb 2005

hey silly, the beard grows natural and should be left as is.

Re: beards.... help

time wasting... · 07 Feb 2005

Get over the fact that not all of us want to think in such a narrow fashion....for if tieing of hair on head is acceptable, then so should tieing of beard...what's to argue..... Give me a shred of evidence that our guru's did not die the beards...? Please no sakhi's, i ask for evidence... reality is you cannot, therefore drop your narrow-minded views "Do not turn my beautiful sikhi into a fundamentalist dream world" I say again. Fateh, Kulbir Singh Dhillon - UK Wala.

Re: beards.... help

Manpreet Kaur · 07 Feb 2005

They are not narrow minded...its mostly because some feel people tie up their beards or use gel to "secure" it due to an inferior complex. They think it looks better if its "groomed". You know what I mean. Also..people might do it to get the trimmed look. If its for work reasons..then cool..tie it up and take it out. My personal opinion...FLOWING BEARD LOOKS BETTER without the twists and the sticky stuff or the net things. hahaha. those look hilarious.

Re: beards.... help

gaiani · 07 Feb 2005

ok for uk wala, use your head here how wud u tie a turban without a joora? or one that wont fall off if tilted?

Re: beards.... help

singhnee · 07 Feb 2005

Time wasting jee we tie our head hair and then wear a dastaar. do we have to wear dastaar on our beard after tying it too??? do you also tie your underarm hair........just wondering Think about that. There is no comparison of head hair and beard hair. >>>>>>>>>>>Give me a shred of evidence that our guru's did not die the beards...? Please no sakhi's, i ask for evidence... reality is you cannot, therefore drop your narrow-minded views<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< Could you please give sangtan a single evidence of tied beard by any of our Guru Sahib jee??? If you can we will accept your modren sikhi concept.

Re: beards.... help

Harpreet Sinhg · 07 Feb 2005

this is a funny topic, I use in my beard, I like a flowing beard. I have VERY frizzy hair, I use a small amount of gel on the side to keep it down and neat, I dont htink it is bad, I think we have bigger issues to worry about then gelling our beards. Sikhi is much bigger then these issues...... "Do not turn my beautiful sikhi into a fundamentalist dream world" Kulbir Singh Dhillon UK. Wala Every thing needs to be done in moderation

Re: beards.... help

Manjeet Singh · 08 Feb 2005

KEEP THE BEARDS FLOWING!! DOWN WITH GELLED BEARDS!! Just my personal protest :)

Re: beards.... help

{}{}{}:@:@:@:@ · 08 Feb 2005

GELLED BEARDS DOWN DOWN TIED BEARDS DOWN DOWN Flowing BEARDS UP UP UPUPUP !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

Re: beards.... help

Singh · 08 Feb 2005

kulbir singh dhillon (uk walay), you wrote: ""To 'simple man', put up some handsome sardars with tied beards....then you can compare....""" Why don't you put up your own pic for sangat? there can be handsome people with tied beard but Singh Sardar can only be with open beard. down with tied beards.

Re: beards.... help

Manpreet Kaur · 08 Feb 2005

There were interesting posts similar to this. Check this out: http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=26485&t=26090#reply_26485

Re: beards.... help

Manpreet Kaur · 08 Feb 2005

>>>>>>Every thing needs to be done in moderation<<<<< Brother Harpreet Singh ji, Whats your explanation of "MODERATION"? I believe "moderation" leads to amritdharee bibiya not wearing keskis/dastaara or even worse not covering their heads at all. Moderation leads to Singhs wearing little doo rag things with it open from the back instead of proper big gurmukhi dastaars. Moderation leads to little tiny kashere so they can fit under dress pants. Moderation leads to bibiya wearing make up or bleaching after being blessed with amrit di daat thinking its "OK" because they live in a modern society and they have to do things with "moderation" and following proper rehat would just be stupid because we're in a new world from the time of the Gurus (guess guru gobing sing ji didn't know the world would come to this) LAST BUT NOT LEAST.. it leads to people who do things with "moderation" to look at others who follow tat khalsa rehat/maryada and label them as fanatics, funamentalists etc. I don't think rehat should be compromised at all under any circumstances. Look at Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh ji, he woulda gave up his life before he was forced to compromise rehat. HE WENT ON HUNGER STRIKES FOR DAYS AT A TIME!!... Anyway getting back on topic. Harpreet Singh ji, your "moderation" is deadly and gives people a reason behind compromising things. "Tunni Munni ikk baraabar" (ones who trim and ones who tie their beard are of same level) - Sant Jarnail Singh Khalsa Bindrawale Manpreet Kaur

Re: beards.... help

J Singh · 08 Feb 2005

Reading some of the posts makes me wonder if I am really on a gurmukh forum. It's becoming such a fashion to just diss others who look a little different from us. Comments like "Singhs with tied beards have inferiority complex" are just ridiculous. How about saying that people trying to imitate puraatan singhs having a "superiority complex". How far do we want to take this. A singh who doesn't wear a blue chola with full dumalla and doesn't keep strict sarbloh is already a "dhilla" (lessor) singh for some of us! Work on your own sikhi people and judge others based on Gurbani, not thru your own narrow-minded, biased and blurred glasses. Inspire people to change, not force them to run for life when they see us:-)!! VJKK VJKF

Re: beards.... help

g · 08 Feb 2005

I just hope we dont become crazzy like the muslims... they are going around in iraq killing barbars because they cut peoples beards... I hope we never become this way

Re: beards.... help

to 'Singh' · 08 Feb 2005

You wrote:"Why don't you put up your own pic for sangat?" Firstly i do not tie my beard, my beard is free flowing, because it is naturally short, and with a little bit of baby oil, looks fresh, (i guess like most of your beards), but the difference between you and me, is that i do not support this oppressing views that somehow Waheguru will favour me if my beard is not tied...and that those who choose to tie there beards somehow are internally wishing they could trim some facial hair... lets try and focus on the bigger problems that are facing the panth...like those that seem to be leading the panth (sprirtually/politically.) and lets try to tell the world about our beautiful Sikhi, for we cannot tell our own, and i wonder why with fundamental views, that some of you live by. Fateh, Kulbir Singh Dhillon Uk wala

Re: beards.... help

Kabadi · 08 Feb 2005

If you are allowed to tie your beard for work purposes, as the panj pyarai do say at most amrit sanchars... than it obviously is not a KUREHIT... there are many singhs who tie their beard and have done massive bhagti... i prefer open dhari also, but the way this discussion is going makes no sense...

Re: beards.... help

Questions · 08 Feb 2005

Amar Singh let me answer your queries. Mahan Kosh definition as "literal"? Please tell me of other definitions of "HAIR ON THE HEAD". If you read old Rehatnameh you would see when Kesh is referred to it is always in context of the hair on the head. There is no contradiction in saying leave body hair. There are Rehatnameh (eg Bhai Daya Singh) which actually specifically say "do not remove your body hair". Body hair is differenciated from hair on the head. This does not mean you can remove your hair on the body. Removing hair anywhere is a Bujjar Kurehat and you must Pesh infront of the Panj Pyare. Infact one Rehatnama says the punishment for the removal of hair is DEATH, but only through the Guru's mercy has this punishment not been implemented. Both removal of Kesh and removal of body hair are forbidden within Sikhi. Guru Ji has not specified anywhere that it is wrong to tie your dhari, because the idea of tying the Dhari was never in place at the time. By your logic all modern things which Guru has not mentioned as Paap, we can do. Guru has told us to remain in Khalsa Roop and if Guru Gobind Singh did not tie his beard neither can you. If you need to keep your beard out the way please refer to the above picture of Bhai Fauja Singh for a Gurmat way of doing it. People make out this rule of tying dharis as "taliban" because they keep bringing it up. Your dhari is a non issue - you keep it the same way it was kept 300 years ago. People make Sikhi sound Taliban when they continuously mutilate Khalsa Roop and then wonder why people do Parchar against beard tying. If you think Sant Jarnail Singh was Taliban, please go ahead and believe that.

Re: beards.... help

Manpreet Kaur · 08 Feb 2005

>>>Reading some of the posts makes me wonder if I am really on a gurmukh forum. It's becoming such a fashion to just diss others who look a little different from us. Comments like "Singhs with tied beards have inferiority complex" are just ridiculous.<<<< J SIngh, I would suggest for you not to jump to conclusions. I'm not DISSINg anyone. That is far from the purpose of why I even post on this forum. Bhai SaHib Randhir Singh mentions that some who tie their beards is due to an inferiority complex in one of his books. I infact completly AGREE with that. If your tying it up other than safety/work reasons that is. Funny how you mention the whole attacking people dissing thing...sounds to me in your post your doing the dissing.. >>>Work on your own sikhi people and judge others based on Gurbani, not thru your own narrow-minded, biased and blurred glasses.<<< NOTE: narrow minded biased blurred glasses...hahahah come on j singh ji Anyway...these are my personal views. Yes ofcourse we have biggger issues in the panth to work on and we have our own Sikhi to improve.... I agree but that does not mean little things like this should never be discussed.

Re: beards.... help

J Singh · 08 Feb 2005

Manpreet Kaur ji, I am just stating my observation while reading this link. I am well aware what Bhai Shahib and Sant Bhindawale have said. All I am saying is that we should stick to gurbani and not pick and choose what old great Singh have said to suit our argument. I would go a step further and say that it's possible that "some" who don't tie may even have inferiority complex as well :-). How do we know. VJKK VJKF

Re: beards.... help

Amar Singh · 09 Feb 2005

"Questions " Mahan Kosh specifies Kesh as hair on the head, however by using a rehatnamah least of all Bhai Dya Singh’s who most people regard as changed to now say removal of hair from the body is also wrong is a contradiction. If Kesh is only on the head as you believe than why is it a paap to tie the dhari as its not Kesh anyway. Lets say its wrong to remove body hair which according to you isn’t’ Kesh anyway based on old hukamnamah than how does this mean tying the beard is wrong, there is a big difference between cutting and tying you know. For people who think it is unatural to tie the beard which makes it a paap, is it therefore natural to aplly oil to it which gives it a unatural and fake shine? Is it wrong to brush it into shape? Where will this stupidity end. People tied their beards as did Sikhs pre Guru Gobind Singh Ji’s time to prevent them being burnt by the musket backflash. Guru Ji was not ***admin-cut****, and knew about muskets which were introduced around Guru Ji’s time etc. Guru Ji knew the obvious risk they possessed to flowing beards which was obvious. If he felt tying the beard to prevent them getting burnt was such a big deal why didn’t he say so, as the risk was present even than and is not a modern thing. You say remain in Guru’s roop but do you wear bana where ever you go (in the office etc) or just at Rainsebais when its easy, do you ride a horse, do you carry a bow and arrows, are you always armed to the teeth. Therefore please don’t contradict yourself with saying it’s a sin to tie the beard as we are not in Guru’s roop, as we are all not completely in Guru’s roop, even you. No one is saying Jarnail Singh was Taliban so please do not try and put words in my mouth. I have seen video’s of him with people who tie their beards, and indeed thousands of people who tied their beards fought and died for the panth. If you are going to take everything preached by Jarnail Singh as your maryada as with tying the beard are you now also going to accept Kesh not keski is the kekkar, as this is also part of Taksal Maryada where Jarnail was Jathedar of.

Re: beards.... help

Amar Singh · 10 Feb 2005

Don’t know what happened to my post. What I meant was that for those who think that tying the beard is going against Guru’s roop, Guru Ji’s form also consisted of bhana ALL THE TIME and not just at easy Rainsebai’s, a bow and arrows, full weapons etc. Therefore why are people trying to argue that people are going against Guru’s roop when tying the Kesh when they themselves are not keeping Guru’s roop 100%. Think about all the sharda full Afghan Sikhs, 99% of which tie their beards. These Sikh’s happily decided to leave their homeland and go through great hardships when the taliban told them to give up Sikhi or get out. Now some self proclaimed khalsa’s think that they have the right to call them paapi’s just becouse they tie their beards.

Re: beards.... help

Questions · 11 Feb 2005

Amar Singh what you are saying makes no sense. It was claimed if the Dhari cannot be tied then why can the head hair be tied. I clearly showed that headhair and dhari hair cannot be equated in that way. You have now completely twisted what I said and now said: "If Kesh is only on the head as you believe than why is it a paap to tie the dhari as its not Kesh anyway." Hehe. Prove to me Kesh is hair other than on the head. Read any Rehatnama or historical source. Kesh is derived from a Sanskrit word. And it means hair on the head. If you cannot prove Kesh is hair anywhere, you are in position to promote it. Just because Dhari Hair does not count as Kesh it does not mean we should not treat it with respect. Our body is like a temple and the temple walls are treated with the utmost respect. The removal of hair from anywhere on the body is a bujjar Kurehat as the kurehat reffers not only to hair removal but any type of mutilation of the body temple, for example tattooing. No one is asking you to dress like a Praatan 18th Century Nihang Singh. If you want to that is obviously better. But tying the beard to give the impression it is trimmed is not Gurmat. You state guns may have set Beards on fire. In this case how did Praatan Singhs keep their Dharis out the way. You say "why did Guru Ji not say anything against tying beards" What an idiotic comment. Tying beards did not come into fashion for a very long period after Guru Ji. No Praatan Singhs in India tie their beards. No Akali Nihangs tie their beards. Again, for explanation as to how Singhs kept their Dhari out the way, refer to the picture of Bhai Fauja Singh that has been posted. If you want to carry on tying your Dhari up you may, but you look very silly. and "part of Taksal Maryada where Jarnail was Jathedar of." ........ a little bit of respect for Sant Jee please? If you do not want to show Respect to your Dhari maybe you should show Respect to Gurmukhs. Would Guru Gobind Singh Ji tie his beard?

Re: beards.... help

akj_4eva_and_eva_amen · 11 Feb 2005

vjkk vjkf where is the need for one to tie ones dhari? how can you say tying a joora is the same as tying up your dhari. a joora must be tied for the keski to be tied onto the head the dhari should be left flowing as guru ji intended it to be, if we can do as we like with our hair, why dont we all wear pony tails and plaits? tying up ones dhari is most of the time just for appearnces sake, theres no need singhs, leave it flowing vjkk vjkf

Re: beards.... help

Toker · 11 Feb 2005

What is the desperate need to ask anyone other than yourself about what you should do with your beard? Don't you trust yourself?

Re: beards.... help

J Singh · 11 Feb 2005

Questions, don't be absolutely certain about your comments. Just because it looks "silly" to you or just because you "think" no puraatan singhs tied their beards does make it a fact. Open beard looks great but there is no restriction on tying it anywhere. Show little tolerence as no one is asking you to tie. Now rhetorical questions like, would Guru Gobind Singh Ji tie his beard?, or would Guru Gobind Singh Ji drive a porche or chat on forums? sound silly to me as well!:-)! VJKK VJKF

Re: beards.... help

someone else · 11 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh Toker we here trust our sikh brothers and sisters, i do wander whgy u come to read these posts, dont u trust urself that u come here to learn? I dont think u are in a position as a non-sikh to understand the significance of a turban or beard. The sikh community is made up of individuals that are separate yet one so if they ask another it is only because they trust those that they are a part of Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: beards.... help

Toker · 11 Feb 2005

OK, to clear up any misunderstandings I can confirm that I know enough about Sikhs and I'm not here to learn. I'm here to help. It's a free world and you're free to block your ears to reason if that's what you want to do. However, beware that if you continue to con your way into controlling and influencing others you will reap the rewards in the end. You obviously have some problem with the fact that I pointed out to the original poster that he does'nt need to ask others about what to do with something as personal as his own face hair. You will have to expend a lot of effort to protect people from hearing the truth. Maybe all your effort.

Re: beards.... help

someone else · 13 Feb 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh the truth? protect people? I'm not these people's guiding angel that I'm tiring to hide them from something, and maybe you think what you say is the truth but at present you only asked a question and didnt actually make a point: ''What is the desperate need to ask anyone other than yourself about what you should do with your beard? Don't you trust yourself?'' Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh