navdeep bains the sikh mp??? doubts
enquiring citizen · 01 Feb 2005
This is a big issue. our SIKH MP has declared that he considers the Canadian Charter of Rights HIGHER than Akhal Takhat. how will people respect sikhs, if one of their own is bashing them?
navdeep bains placed flowers on mahatma gandhi's statue with paul martin, canada's prime minister. the same prime minister who made excuses NOT to go to Sri Harmandar Sahib because of the current same-sex marriage issue.
mahatma gandhi called Guru Gobind Singh ji 'bhulla general', meaning a general who is lost. now his children are placing flowers on his statue?
brothers and sisters, this is wrong dealings from our Sikh MP. is this who we elected?
and to clear doubts, navdeep bains was not given siropa by akhal takhat, but shrimani prabandak committee gave siropa on to him.
are we place politics ahead of sikhi? is he not crushing our rights as sikhs, by bashing our supreme power infront of the media?
Re: navdeep bains the sikh mp??? doubts
Amanpreet Singh Bal · 01 Feb 2005
I was present during the press conference. Navdeep didn't give out the statement which was attributed to him about considering Charter of Rights higher than Akal Takhat.
Are we talking about respecting the institution and concept of Sri Akal Takhat Sahib or the Jathedar of the Sri Akal Takhat as an individual. Just look at the story relating to Pakhandi Baba Dhanwant Singh and role played by the Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti.
Is it appropriate for a Sharabi(alcohol drinker) to hold meeting at Sri Akal Takhat Sahib and provide advice to Sri Akal Takhat's Jathedar on how to handle same sex marriage issue? Same sex marriage is taboo but what about drinking alcohol? I'm not trying to justify the same sex marriage but we must not forget that no political party want to neutralize the Charter of Rights. Just before Navdeep's interview we had the opportunity to interview Jason Kenney(M.P. from Alberta) who is also the Deputy House Leader for P.C. and he clearly stated that his party is not in favour of changing Charter of Rights/Constitution/holding refrendum on this issue. He also stated that his party is not in favour of using notwithstanding clause. He stated that his party will be presenting a private member's bill if the same sex marriage bill is passed.
Amanpreet Singh Bal(a.k.a. Jaspal Singh Bal)
Re: navdeep bains the sikh mp??? doubts
Harminder Singh Mann · 02 Feb 2005
As sikhs in canada,
regardless of what our religious convictions are, we have to look at this society as being secular. The view of marriage, gursikhs have, will not change. The issue here is about human rights, and these people want to have the same rights as other people engaging in a parallel (albeit more conventional) lifestyle.
As a sikh, I am supportive of the freedom for minority rights. It is not my place to judge what lifestyle someone has chosen, and I don't see how this is affecting anyone directly, except the bond between the "newly married" couple. If adoption etc, were considered. I would draw the line there.
I don't know enough about jathedar vedanti to comment on his stance, I am not sure whether a gurmatta had taken place either.
Equality Rights
Equality before and under law and equal protection and benefit of law 15. (1) Every individual is equal before and under the law and has the right to the equal protection and equal benefit of the law without discrimination and, in particular, without discrimination based on race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, sex, age or mental or physical disability.
http://laws.justice.gc.ca/en/charter/#egalite
without getting too technical and in over my head. I just wanted to say that we should stay steadfast in what we believe. Let us follow our path fully, let us not stop anyone from following their path (providing their path isn't causing harm or potential danger to anyone). This charter has given us the right, although we have had to fight, and will continue to fight, to be protected. Let us support that which has helped us. Please do not take anything I am saying as putting the charter over sikhi, or the charter over waheguru. That is not my intention, just as it isn't my intention to prove anyone wrong or hurt anyone's sentiments.
We have a voice in parliament, this can be the same voice that can some day get an apology out of the indian government for the atrocities caused to sikhs (not that it would patch up anything, but our own stigma, in our community will be uplifted).
regards,
Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: navdeep bains the sikh mp??? doubts
santbir singh · 02 Feb 2005
malhi is a disgrace to sikhs and it is a sad state of affairs that sikhs would back this man because of one issue. he is (in)famous in ottawa for one reason, and one reason only... getting drunk every year at the annual liberal mp's formal dinner. one year he fell off his chair and his dastaar rolled off onto the ground.
yeah, real great man. let's praise him some more.
this is a ludicrous story.
according to rehit, alcohal and tobacco are never to be consumed, yet the most governments in the world make signifacant profit from taxing and regulating these drugs. should we then not pay taxes? should we not collect benifits from our country. as a canadian, should i not get health care because money for health care is cycled back through tobacco levies and taxes?
just because there has been a religious definition of marriage means nothing. sikhs should be the last people that wish to have live in a country that uses religous regulations as the basis of laws. christians and muslims claim that marriage must be defined in the way their religions always have. what other laws should be defined according to chrisitan and muslim laws? should we stone women to death for having sex before marriage? should we make animal sacrifices? should we keep slaves? all of these are mentioned as laws in the Old Testemant (Jewish Tanakh) in the Book of Leviticus. should we use those rules as a basis of our society?
if we did, then sikhs would be second class citizens. so, we just pick and choose the religious rules that suit us? who's to decide? catholic priests? muslim mullah's? anglican dioceses? should they recommend to the government which rules should be kept and which should not???
we all know that sikh's do not remove any keas from their bodies. should navdeep singh bains then fight touth and nail for barbershops, razors and shavers to be banned from canada. if he does not, is he putting the canadian charter of rights and freedoms over the akal takht???
the canadian charter of rights and freedoms have given sikhs amazing oppurtunities. many of us here can walk around in bana, wearing large kirpans, go in and out of shopping malls, to school and into work and NOBODY says ANYTHING! not sure why we would criticise a document that upholds some principals pretty dear to the heart of sikhi.
guru tegh bahadur died for the rights of hindus. he didn't agree with hindus! guru gobind singh sahib jee in zafarnama said that he was an idol breaker! ALL the gurus who wrote bani, criticized hindus for a lot of their empty rituals, their sexism and their caste system. yet guru nanak, in his ninth form, died for these very same people! why? because sikhi believes in, above all else, the freedom of choice. human beings should be allowed to determine their own destiny, without outside pressure, as long as their choices do not harm others around them.
whether homosexual marriage is allowed in sikhi or not, is a COMPLETELY SEPARATE MATTER. what we do in our DHARAM is different than what we say is allowable for other people! this is what so many sikhs are failing to see. do you think, under baba banda singh bahadur's khalsa raj, hindus were not allowed to worship idols or practice their rules of daily life? of course not! guru hargobind sahib jee even built a masjid and a mandir in the city of Sri Guru Hargobindpura for the hindu and muslim residents of the city! what we don't allow in our religion should be separate than what we allow for others!!!!!!!
sikhs have a duty to stand for human rights, minority rights and equality rights. gay marriage is a direct extension of all these rights. to use religous arugments as to why we should not allow gay marriage flies in the face of what the gurus did. thats the EXACT same thing aurganzeb did when he executed guru tegh bahadur sahib jee. thats the exact same thing that wazir khan did when he tortured and killed the chotte sahibzade.
forget whether we should allow homosexual marriage in sikhi. i personaly don't think a stooge like vedanti has the right to decide such a thing. vedanti is the same man who had badal TELL HIM what punishment to give to BADAL! forget the charter of rights and freedoms being higher than the akal takht, the "jathedar" himself is a joke, and has openly showed that he is subservient to a patit and a tankhayia like badal, someone who has the blood of a lot of sikhs on his hands.
vedanti came out of the damdami taksal, and it is should be remembered that a great sikh like baba gurbachan singh himself refused to meet vedanti because he had become so anti-gurmukh, and that was over 40 years ago!
navdeep singh has a duty to ensure that he votes not according to what rehit says but according to the principals of freedom of choice that guru tegh bahadur sahib jee DIED for. i dont think any of us would like to live in a state that used religious laws as a basis for government laws... think TALIBAN.
this is a stupid debate that just needs to stop. we can argue forever whether sikhi should allow for gay marriages or not. but that's not the issue here. the issue is that sikhs should allow for others to freely practice their rights. to use religious definitions of marriage are pretty riduculous. the bible and quaran are FILLED with people who CHEAT on their wives, who have MORE than one wife, etc. abraham, the father of judaism, christianity and islam himself had sex with his SLAVE GIRL, who he was not married to, obviously. islam claims its ancestry from the product of that out of marriage relationship...
not really what we should be grounding our laws on.
if we want to use other religion's definitions... then good luck of finding consensus. ask anyone who's taken a first year anthropology course about the different types of marriage relationships found all over the world. you'd have a hell of a hard time trying to come up with a definition that suited all religions.
i think sikhs need to take a step back and use the gyan that guru jee has blessed us with to actually consider this issue carefully and properly. what exactly are you all proposing? do you really want a theocratic state? do you just want a theocratic state sometimes??? when? how often? for what circumstances? these are pretty important questions.
gurFateh
also, please please stop praising malhi. the man is a REAL disgrace. he is a drunk who has been in parliament for over 10 years and has yet to pass ANY significant legislation. besides some pretty useless motions, he has just sat back, happy to recieve his big pay cheque and get drunk any chance he gets. ask sikhs who live in ottawa and they'll tell you his real story. the guy's a BIG TIME joke.
remember what shaheed baba jarnail sing khalsa said about kesadharis that drink...
we should keep that in mind.
santbir singh
Re: navdeep bains the sikh mp??? doubts
Amanpreet Singh Bal · 02 Feb 2005
It seems we are allowing our emotions to carry us. Before we comments about mother/son or brother/sister marrying each other, we should make an effort to understand the issue/existing law etc. Thsi type of realitiosnhip is called incest and is disallowed according to our constitution. We must not forget that the constitution was made by the society. Just before anyone of you jump and advocate banning same sex marriage issue by using the law or saying that the society doesn't favour same sex marriage, I want to state that "Yes as a society we have the power to do so and we are very fortunate to live in a society weher we can make such changes(not Taliban style system), we should ask ourselves one . Are we ready to make change to Charter of Rights? If so what will happen if tomrrow, the Christian majority imposes their values system on us(after all we are a minority)"
I like younger generation to wake up. It's time for them to collectively declare that they are ready to take charge of their destiny. because majority of so called leadership has failed to protect/enhance our community's interest in last 20 years. When I look around I see many Canadian Badal/Tohras etc. and in my oopinion they are no different that Mahants.
Amanpreet Singh Bal(a.k.a. Jaspal Singh Bal)
Re: navdeep bains the sikh mp??? doubts
santbir singh · 02 Feb 2005
from an older taksali singh i met here in vancouver i was told about this. i asked other older taksalis about this issue, when they have come to the lower mainland to do katha - vichaar, and they have confirmed it. i understand the hesitation to not accept the story, since there are so many false rumours going around, and that's fine.
the point i was attempting to make was that vedanti showed himself to be a stooge of badal. when badal was given "tankha" a couple of years ago, we all know that his spokesman was going in and out of the singh sahibain's room and telling them what decision to come to.
in addition. badal did ardaas several times during the dharam yudh morcha, from the period of 1982-84 whereby he firmly stated that he would not stop the morcha until the demands of the anandpur sahib resolution were completely fulfilled. out of all the leaders who made that ardaas, only shaheed baba jarnail singh khalsa had the courage to stick to his promise.
making a promise infront of guru jee is no small thing and for a "leader" to make such a dramatic promise and then break it... time and time again, is a matter of huge disgrace. the fact that vedanti is the "jathedar" chosen by this man should make us all think twice.
this speaks to a larger issue. we all seem to be enamoured with the current jathedar of akal takht sahib. have we all forgotten that bhai ranjit singh was jathedar and was removed against maryada and vedanti was installed only after singh sahib bhai mohan singh refused to take on the jathedari, and then puran singh's disastrous tenure. the drama from just a few short years ago has all been forgotten. didn't many members of the sangat set up websites and petitions to DEMAND that ranjit singh be reinstated...
so just because a couple of years have passed we've all grown complacent, and now we're all too damn scared to say anything. he's not a guru! he's not some brahmgiani! he's a granthi from darbar sahib who was good at maneouvering the intricate back room deals and inner politics of the sgpc. thats it!
just because he has the title of jathedar does not mean that everything he says is somehow divine! that's not his takht! its the takht of akal purkh and the khalsa has been given the task of maintaining it, not vedanti.
what makes me sad about this whole situation regarding vedanti is the blind follower mentality so many sikhs show. i would ask the sangat to try and imagine they were alive in the lets say the 1880's or the early 1900's. during both those times, the "jathedar" of akal takht acted in complete defiance of maryada and made outrageous "hukamnamas" that were subsequently rejected by the panth. in the 1880's, professor gurmukh singh, the greak singh sabha scholar, was kicked out of the panth for advocating an end to the caste system! because he wanted to sit in langar and recieve karah parshad, the jathedar declared him a tankhaiya. in the early 1900's, after the jalianwala bagh massacre, the "jathedar" of akal takht gave not only a siropa to general dyer, the man directly responsible for the deaths of over 100 sikhs (and some muslim and hindu patriots as well), but also made him an "honourary sikh". we've all heard the story. when dyer said he couldn't stop shaving or stop smoking, the jathedar joked, saying, thats okay, you can take your time.
pretty disgusting, no?
so. would you all blindly follow such a man just because he is jathedar. this whole, we can not criticise the jathedar of akal takht because of his position is pretty absurd. we're a panth of equals, not one of hierarchies. guru gobind singh didn't make some "higher" khalsa, and some "follower" khalsa. he made the khalsa... period. sikhs have a right and the DUTY to call their leaders to task!!!! we have that OBLIGATION.
tell me, why else would guru gobind singh sahib jee allow for the panj piaraih to correct him or order him those few times after 1699. not because the guru jee was wrong, or he didnt know what to do. of course not! guru jee is completely perfect. it was because guru jee wanted sikhs to know that they had that duty to ensure that maryada was always being followed. if the panj and the panth could order the guru out of chamkaur, then he knew they would have the courage to keep their military and political leaders in line in the future.
well, we don't seem to be doing that anymore! the days of humble, gursikh leaders like sardar navab kapur singh seem to be gone, but also the era of sikhs demanding a certain set of standars from their leaders has also disappeared. i remember reading a story, perhaps in dilgeer's akal takht book, about the panthic meeting that took palce back when the sgpc was created in 1920. they were deciding on panj piaraih as the "panthic committee" for the job of running the sgpc in an interim period. sant teja singh, of the baba attar singh line, was asked, and almost everyone agreed. he accepted his position, but then, one SINGLE sikh stood up in the sangat (in front of akal takht) and openly declared that teja singh should not be allowed to be one of the panj. instead of pouncing on the guy and telling him to stop disrespecting a sant baba, like most would probably do today, the sangat asked this singh what his problem was. he said that he had heard evidence that teja singh allowed people to sometimes matha dhek to him. when asked of this, teja singh admitted that he had allowed this at times in the past. he immediatly asked for tankha and made a promise infront of the panth never ever to allow such a thing again.
can you imagine, one single sikh having the guts to stand up and ask for acountability. imagine if sikhs had kept that up throughout the last 80 years... what would the sgpc be now today? then perhaps positions like jathedar of akal tkaht would be worth of respect from all sikhs.
to me, and im not saying i am an expert by any strech of the imagination, it seems that vedanti is not the greatest calibar of jathedar possible. does he have the guts or the courage to demand accountablity from people like badal and jagir kaur. would he dare????
he hasn't shown that he can. not once. he hasn't, in fact, shown any indepdendant thinking at all! he's a stooge, plain and simple, and those of you who claim to give respect to the countless shaheeds who have given their lives defending akal takht should think twice about whether this man has the moral standing to be allowed to call himself jathedar of akal takht.
santbir singh
Re: navdeep bains the sikh mp??? doubts
second thoughts · 03 Feb 2005
The whole gay marriage vote is not the major issue for me in terms of Navdeep Singh. It's the other things. Going to Ghandi's memorial place and placing flowers, and even worse, the dinner in which the murderer of many sikhs, Jadish Tytler, participated. I liked Navdeep Singh and could have easily overlooked the gay marriage issue. But not these other things. Can you see a Jew attending a dinner with a Nazi? Or a Jewish MP ever placing flowers over the grave of Arafat? I doubt it. They have guts and stick up for what they believe in. I was saddened beyond belief when I heard about this. I shouldn't have been though. We've had so many spineless punjabi politicians and leaders, who's main goal has always been to get the praises of those in power and advance up the ladder of power. Punjab is full of people like this. For some reason, I expected more from Navdeep Singh. I was wrong. Really disappointing. Unless there is some really good explanation (something along the lines of, "I wasn't there, it was just a media mistake."), I for one will not ever support this guy again.
Re: navdeep bains the sikh mp??? doubts
santbir singh · 04 Feb 2005
my "rambling" about vedanti was in response to this question,
Author: Singh
Date: 02-02-05 19:16
Santbir, exactly when did Sant Gurbachan Singh refuse to see Vedanti? Sounds like a rumour to me.
concerning navdeep going and laying flowers at gandhi's memorial or eating with tytler, that's beyond disgusting and a really really horrible thing. that's a purely selfish act and is tantamount to spitting at the memory of the shaheeds of 1984 and those sikhs who REALLY fought for independence, not skinny pedophilic jokes like gandhi.
the issue though is whether gay marriage should be supported by sikhs. again, this is not an issue of whether it's allowable in sikhi and i think others have stated much more clearly and gracefully why this issue is pretty clear cut.
santbir singh
Re: navdeep bains the sikh mp??? doubts
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 07 Feb 2005
There are a number of issues here, and people are responding with little insight or with a bagful of emotions and lack of understanding of the legal issues.
FIRST and FOREMOST:Vedanti had NO bussiness to be interfering in the internal issues of INDEPENDENT CANADA.The issue of same sex marriage was an issue for Canada and the Canadians.
Vedanti really has no business in this.Nobody asked him for his views.giving his views over the isue would have been one thing,BUT by issueing an edict he has made a fool of himslef, and brought both the Panth and the Akal Takhat into disrepute and under uneccessary scrutiny, and created divisions as usual is with Sikh politicians.
Mr Navdeep Singh is a citizen and an MP of Canada NOT India or SAD or SGPC.Whether he likes it or not,he has to follow the flow of the political will of his party.This does not mean by voting in favour of the bill,he personally agrees.Like Mr Malhi has disagreed,it does not mean he will now kloose his citizenship of Canada.So in the same vein,it does not mean navdeep is no longer a Sikh.
People trying to link him to a tan-khaiya really need to GROW UP IN life.I would like to ask such people, would they follow an edict that a politically appointed Vedanti issues ,if he says all Sikhs living in foreign lands MUST go back to Punjab to live.How many of you will follow that advice or edict?If you dont then you should be declared a tan-khaiya?
Navdip Singh Bains is right.As a Sikh he may not at personal level agree with the same sex marriages,but as a canadian MP he has to follow the human rights charter.
I dont agree with same sex marriage on a personal level, but, as a resident of UK I have to respect and abide by the equal rights commision guidelines of this country, and function by them.That does NOT mean I am lesser Sikh now.
The so called custodian of the Akal Takhat- Vedanti-Badal appointed- simply is out or tune and order,and has NO right to be dictating to the Canadian Sikh MPs.The bill is an internal affair of Canada and Canadians.
Vedanti should be minding his own business and the problems that Sikhs have at home, and with their own issues such as the turban and the patitipoona and the continual denial to Sikh women EQUAL RIGHTS,with no special conditions attached.
He should be advising the Sikh politicians to be cleaner than clean and NOT hold offices and bring the Panth into any disrepute by being parties to murders ,corruption, bribery and scandals.
If any such person does hold an office( sadly bibi jagir kaur to start with ...) he should be advising that person to step down until the judiacry has cleared the person.He should be advising Sardar Badal, not to play politics with Sikh psyche or use Sikh votes to harness in his personal wealth.
Vedanti should be out on the streets and in the villages of the Punjab seeking commitment from Sikh sangats to follow the Sikhi as ordained by the Tenth Master, and preserve the unique Sikh identity, instead of being a busy body involving in the affairs of another independent country.he should be out there trying to get the justice for the 1984 HOLOCUST victims.he should be out there on the streets trying to ensure Sikh women are treated FAIRLY and equally, and RAPIST are at once ousted from sikh panth.
Vedanti ji , please watch out,what falls out of your mouth the next time, irrelevent verbal diarrhoea is bad for health, and for breath.
This is the 21st century, time to move on responsibly, and with a sense of duty of care towards the Panth,and humanity not expecting all from the Panth for personal ego and fame.
Gurcharan Singh Kulim
Re: navdeep bains the sikh mp??? doubts
enquiring citizen · 08 Feb 2005
friends,
the main issues are as follows:
- navdeep bains declared in public that he considers the charter higher than akhal takhat. as a a sikh he should not have said this in public. despite his personal views on the gay marriage issue, saying in public his non-supportive nature to the akhal takhat, this brings it down in the eyes of other people
- placing flowers on gandhi's statue. as a sikh it was wronog, and also as a politican.
- having dinner with jagdish tyler.
these are the issues that makes us DOUBT navdeep bains. he is supposed to support his riding, and his riding are full with punjabi sikhs.
his actions are truly disgusting, and we all need to rethink where we want to place our trust.
does your job come before sikhi? NEVER!
Re: navdeep bains the sikh mp??? doubts
please respond to me ... · 08 Feb 2005
Enquiring citizen...
Why hide behind a fake name ?? I see your posts on many forums... Can you .. rather than bashing him on public forums.. but at least goto him and ask him why he did that??
Re: navdeep bains the sikh mp??? doubts
enquiring citizen · 14 Feb 2005
i think we should practice what we preach!