Mus1c downloads
. · 31 Jan 2005
http://www.mus1k.com/downloads.htm
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
. · 31 Jan 2005
http://www.mus1k.com/downloads.htmanon kaur · 31 Jan 2005
Ok.. y ? If the gurus tried to stop songs etc then why are we know composing tracks about the gurus? I appreciate what you guys are doing and I've read threads about similar issues but the reasoning behind it doesnt make any sense to me! Why do you feel the need to write this stuff and then sell it on? (just out of interest, what happens to the profits?) (no offence as it is well written and must have taken a great deal of effort) Gurbani is the most complex literary text ever ! The organisation, the rhymes etc is so scientific, makes shakespeare look like nothing, if that won't get people into sikhi (sense the words are soothing even if you don't know what they mean) then how will this?? I know people are saying this introduces youth to sikhi, it doesn't! I'm a teenager myself, this stuff never inspired me in any way, if anything its a bit of a turn off, kind of like the christian 'rock stars' that go from school to school holding discos. The ONLY thing that got me into sikhi (and other people that I know of) is KIRTAN!Mkhalsa · 31 Jan 2005
I was laughing when I heard it.. I know they meant well, but its just funny....Jasvir kaur · 31 Jan 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru Ji ki fateh. Dear Anon kaur ji, You have said things absolutley RIGHT. Compared to GURBANI....about which Guru Ji Himself says: Dhur Ki banni aiyee jin SAGLEE CHINT MITAYEE... what value can these glass beads be ?? the Words to note are : SAGLEE CHINT MITAYEE....100% Chint mitayee..what chinta worry etc is LEFT after GURBANI has doen its work ?? absolutley Nothing ZERO 0.. so what is the need for these lyrics ??? This is a result of "christian" influence... but there is a vast difference between the christian bible and gurbani.... GURBANI.. all 1429 Aangs of it is SHEER BLISS..in Raag Poetry Motion...while 99% of the Bible is words words words..apart from the soul stirring Psalms..so the christians have no alternative but to write lyrics, carols etc to SUPPLEMENT the Bone DRY bible !! While GURBANI is DRIPPING wet with Naam/AMRIT NECTAR Rass which DOESNT need any "artiifical sweetners".... You are also right in observing that it is a fallacy that teens are impressed enough and come streaming into Sikhi by these lyrics...a load of bull. As a teenager I was attracted into Going to the Gurdwara only by KIRTAN...and then I advanced from there.... IF GURBANI AMRIT cannot make things sweet for someone..how can artifical sweetner do the job ?? These are just CLAIMS by the ARTIFICIAL SWEETNER MANUFACTURERS to sell their product.."wont cause diabetes..( meaning these lyrics wont cause pain of having to LEARN GURMUKHI/PUNJABI/GURBANI..), wont cause obesiety..(meaning they are so "LIGHT" compared to GURBANI, its a breeze to learn them..no effort needed to do anything !!! wah wah wah...and wont cause worry..Meaning Glass Beads carrying person has no worry about being robbed..BECAUSE he only has Glass Beads and NO NAAM KAMAII that comes from GURBANI !!! If we read Sikh history we will know that Bhai lehna Ji came to hear about Guur nanak and developed the "NEED " to meet Guru Ji through HEARING the paath of JAPJI SAHIB....Bhai Amardass ji developed this "need" through listening to paath of JAPJI SAHIB also.....and we know BOTH became GURU after that... Has anyone ever been told that anyone developed a "NEED" to go meet HEER or RANJHA after having listened to the Love ballad being sung..even though this was being sung in every village of Punjab for hundreds of years..Heer ranjha of waris Shah is a beautiful piece of literature...admired by millions...BUT it is GLASS BEADS/artificial sweetner compared to GURBANI. Jasvir kaurgkd · 31 Jan 2005
guru ji stoping songs omggggPardeep Singh Bilga · 01 Feb 2005
FINALLY- some people who share my views (anon kaur and Mkhalsa)- where were you guys over the last couple of weeks? You may find this interesting if you have not already seen: http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=26515&t=25780# Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fatehJasvir kaur · 01 Feb 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Just a comment i found on naother forum... very interesting... WHY DID GURU JI take SO MUCH trouble to SRESS all this.. 45 EXTRA AANGS just to Make SURE the RAAG is on EACH HYMN....???? The message is: The "Kirtan-Marayada" as practiced in the gurus' time and presently prescribed in Sri Guru Granth Sahib is systematically side-lined as we progress thru 21st century. It is over-powering to see how much the authors of Sri Guru Granth Sahib took to prescribe specific guidelines to sing Gurbani. Some one told me that Guru Arjan could save around 45 pages in Sri Guru Granth Sahib if he prescribed the raag only in the beginning of the relevant section and not repeat for every hymn. But he did so understandably to make it very clear how a particular hymn may be sung. He prescribed the right raag, right taal, right dhuni, etc to leave no room for improvising but still giving sufficient latitude to bring in a wide range of creativity within those parameters. Let us exert our influence where ever possible to encourage preservation and promotion of real Sikh Kirtan traditions. (Bhai) Harbans LalJarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 01 Feb 2005
i just hope admin is not forced to close this thread...notice jasvir Kaur's message is signed bhai harbans lall..?? lols ?stay cool Jarnail singhanon kaur · 01 Feb 2005
My apologies to Pardeep Singh! No-one has said where the profits from these album sales go to ???Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 01 Feb 2005
>> The ONLY thing that got me into sikhi (and other people that I know of) is KIRTAN! << Me too. I had to go change my religion and everything ;-)singh · 02 Feb 2005
i dont see how theres anything wrong with it, i see a couple of kids with passion for music and Prem for sikhi..... my 2 centsJarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 02 Feb 2005
i dont see how theres anything wrong with it, i see a couple of kids with passion for music and Prem for sikhi..... my 2 cents .. YES Ji..and all of us are also "just expressing" our own 2 cents each..these are just opinions..NOT HUKMNAMAS ..BANNING the albums or sayign those listening/buying/ etc will go to "hell" ???.. For the record i have many "well wishers" all over the globe....and i often get all sorts of VCD's DVD's..sometimes as many as four or five a week..albums etc...this latest one ahs also been sent to me..I listened...enjoyed..and put it away...maybe will listen another day. I have committed no sin and dont say others have if they bought these... BUT GURBANI is GURBANI....and these music are music..thats all...hey even the whistling of the wind throught he elaves of trees is also music of sorts..BUT GURBANI SAYS..that all this type of music CANNOT get you to Meet WAHEGURU....ONLY GURBANI is capable of THAT. Jarail singhharbhajan · 02 Feb 2005
hahahahahhahaha passion for kachi bani, and prem for sikhi, LOL, erm ok......... "khehndhe kache, sundhe kache kache aakh vakhanee" im just gonna leave it there. wjkk wjkfharbhajan · 02 Feb 2005
btw, my 2 aunties use 2 listen to kachi bani, just like that, and guess what, now they've ran off from the family, cut their kesh, eat meat, and have gone off with boyfriends. yep, that kinda stuff defianatly gets ppl into sikhi hanasingh · 02 Feb 2005
Theres different stages my friend, maybee everyones just not a as ponchay as u fellows are, greatest bhagti starts from prem, if singing songs about prem towards sikhi gets you on the rite path so be it. Maybee in a few years when they get older they'll realize the more successful ways to achive guru sahib as taught in bani. Religion grows with love, and love comes in many ways.anon kaur · 03 Feb 2005
Fair point Singh bhaji, but in what way do these songs fill anyones mind with prem ? Why not distribute kirtan cds sung in beautiful tunes that are both relaxing and easy to understand rather than music with beats to which one can dance and that can have connotations with other less sikhi orientated cultures ?BirRaas Singh · 04 Feb 2005
seems that people have double standards, a while ago when the "immortal productions" tribute to 1984 cd came out, with tracks such as blood for blood, and AK47, people loved those but now when someone sings songs about the history and bravery of past singhs and the gurus then it becomes kachi bani? how about the dhadis in the gurdwaras singing about revenge on the GOI, doesnt everyone listen to them? in the times of the guru there was dhadhis, were they singing kachi bani too? many people have been inspired by books such as the autobiography of bhai randhir singh, why read that when we can read bani or listen to kirtan? everyone is inspired in a different way, some people may never think about reading bani, some may never think about readin about sikh history, this kind of stuff is easy access and they are more likely to listen, and then trigger them to investigate into sikhi. the poeple who made the cd aint singin about pimps and hoes, booze and rolling on dubs so give them a break. but i guess its typical nature of some people to always put down people who put in effortsingh · 04 Feb 2005
"Why not distribute kirtan cds sung in beautiful tunes that are both relaxing and easy to understand" ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The problem is the traditional sound of keertan isnt always appealing to kids in the new generation. Sure me and you love keertan that is traditional , but not everyone will appreciate the style. When it comes down to the core, The vaja isnt even a native indian instrument. The so called traditional music today has even been contemporized. The harmonium poses problems in Indian classical music, as its temper is equal, and does not match the unequal temper of Indian ragas music. The harmonium has replaced the sarangi isnt that moving to contemporary? The harmonium was never sikhi oriented until now. Bani could have been presented to the guru in many ways, but are guru ke laal chose music, are gurus chose music. Music was and is for all mankind as is bani. The fusion of the two creates alot of anand, a lot of prem. Regarding why the composers for that music chose the dancing rhythms, i dont know. But do consider even when you look at traditional raags people danced and stll do dance to them today (not sikhs) but in the same indian raags. In the end we are all learning, i cant say i agree with singing katchi bani, because i dont. But dont forget its kirpa that carries us across, and prem that sparks bhagthi. I think even baby steps forward still count as going forward. The fact that they made that attempt and showed they are fans of Guru sahib does overjoy me. These days people dont even look towards Guru Gobind singh ji as a role model. They would rather look to the next biggest rapper on the urban scene. That bebe ji is expression, And i admire that. Composing music and getting it to a finished project takes a lot of work and patience. From composing to mixing and mastering, these kids really did express their "musicality". The best part they chose sikhi, (over money, drugs and sex) and still thought it was cool. Bravo to them. [%sig%]ajit singh · 04 Feb 2005
hmmmm, gotta say, totally agree with anon kaur there. yes, tru kids nowadays will rather listen to kachi bani than kirtan. but then won't they just start listening to kachi bani all the time, thinking oh great, all u have to do in sikhism is listen to these songs about the gurus in the past. to get kids into sikhi, the best thing to do really is not give them cd's of kachi bani, but take them to rensaibae kirtans, im sure that will do them a lot more good. i think most of us here will agree that kachi bani is wrong, so you r trying to get kids into sikhi by making them do wrong things, like harbhajan sed above, his aunties completely went the opposite way when they started to listen to kachi bani. if anything, kachi bani is going to scare kids away from sikhi.ajit singh · 04 Feb 2005
when i listened to those tracks, i get the same feelings like when there are songs on t.v etc. that feeling brings the 5 thieves back into my mind, and draws me further from sikhi. even when i listened to kirtan for the first time, i could tell there was something different about it, and thats what brought me closer to sikhi, if we truly want to get kids into sikhi, then giving them kachi bani is one big mistake. [%sig%]Jarnail Singh Gyani "arshi" · 05 Feb 2005
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Have a read of my new thread on Naam Simran. Even "naam Simran" of just WAHEGURU alone cannot beat KIRTAN of GURBANI.. So how can "poetry" that is man made...come up to Gurbani ILAHI GURBANI Dhur Ki Bani....NO way. Jogis, Bodhis, Islam BANNED MUSIC...becasue in their scheme of things MUSIC..INTERFERES with their concept of "simran"..that is repetition of OM,99 names of Allah etc... BUT GURU JI says KIRTAN is PARDHAAN..SUPREME. These musical lyrics are good for "entertainment" if you must have such..BUT dotn think they cna REPLACE KIRTAN of GURBANI. Jarnail Singh