Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

self contradictions ??84 lakh Joons cut by Raagmala ??

self contradictions ??84 lakh Joons cut by Raagmala ??

Jarnail singh gyani · 23 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguur Ji ki Fateh. Below is a summarised view of an article by S. Gursharan Singh Kusel Canada on Raagmala which appeared in Sikh Marg. " Gursharan Singh Ji writes that he just read a book by kathakaar Jaswant Singh who writes in his book: Raagmala gurbani hai...When Guru Arjun Ji had finished compiling the (GURU) Granth Ji and putting the Bhog at Mundawni, the Sikhs requested GURU JI to write something that would RELEASE them FROM 84 lakh Joons... a sort of Prem mala...and lo and behold Guru Ji instantly wrote RAAGMALA.. AT last the SIKHS had got the means to ESCAPE the 84 lakh joon circle.... ( What the rest of the GURBANI in 1429 AAngs is for escapes me !!!) Then the writer to strengthen his case for raagmala being the 84 lakh joon cutter, cites that Sant Gurbachan Singh bhinderawaleh also agree to this and have given such nice and wonderful menaings of raagmala that astound even great gianis... BUT the writer forgets that Sant Giani kartar Singh writing the Biography of His mentor sant gurbachan Singh Ji states in his book that SANT JI beleived in having 84 Ishnaans( kesi+body) and 84 Paaths of Japji Sahib at baoli sahib Goindwaal to ESCAPE the 84 lakh Joon circle....didnt SANT JI realise that reading Raagmala would do the same or is a case of "avar updesseh aap na kareh ??"OR only jaswant singh ji knew this secret formula for 84 lakh joon chakara ending. Then another question springs to mind...when Guur Granth Ji has not yet been compiled and GURBANI was read from POTHIS ( Guru nanak ji - Guru Arjun Ji's time)...how was this question of 84 lakh joons circle ending answered by Sikhs ?? WHAT did they READ to escape the 84 lakh Joons since RAAGMALA was not yet written ?? ALL the SIKHS of Guur nanak Ji to Guur Ramdass ji must have gone into this circle of 84 lakh joons BECAUSE all they had was GURBANI of Four GURUS only ?? BUT if we read GURBANI time and again it says the same thing..ONLY NAAM of WAHEGURU can rid us of this 84 lakh joon circle..where and in which line of Gurbani is raagmala made the cure for this disease ?? 2. Giani Gurditt Singh writer of Mundawni gives an idea as to who SANG this raagmala... this answer is from raagmala itself: It says Gaveh gain Patar..a Patar SANG this raagmala..and the Patar is the Singing Prostitute Kamkandala..in the ORIGINAL this is written as : Patar sunnee kamkandala teh pur vasseh chand ke kala....the words punn gaveeh, un gaiyeh, etc tell the whole story. This is how the proponents of raagmala gurbani hai get caught in their own silt traps.. Raagmala gurbani nahin Hai. Jarnail Singh (all errors and omissions mine)

Re: self contradictions ??84 lakh Joons cut by Raagmala ??

Khalsa84 · 23 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Bhai Jarnail Singh Gyani Ji. I respect your views. I have one question, there have been countless threads on Raag Mala. Im just confused as to why you would keep on bringing up such issues again. I read your post and youve been doing some research. But Jee, the pro-Raag Mala GurSikhs are not going to change and neither are the anti-Raag Mala GurSikhs. You know that better than me. my benti: Guru Maharaj knows the Panth is split on this issue. It's a test to us if we dwell on this and if it effects our kamayee. Thats it. When they want, they will answer the "mystery" straight out. But til then, let's just leave it and talk about other issues. I hope you agree. bhul chuk vudh ghutt maaf karna

Re: self contradictions ??84 lakh Joons cut by Raagmala ??

gkd · 23 Jan 2005

live and let live, these sort of beliefs are personal and shoudl be kept of all panthik message boards.

Re: self contradictions ??84 lakh Joons cut by Raagmala ??

ekta · 24 Jan 2005

you fail to see the point giani ji: many singh,singhnees read sukhmani sahibs to rid them of 84 lakh joons many singh,singhness read mool mantra to rid them of 84 lakh joons many singh,singhness read gur mantra to rid them of 84 lakh joons many singh,singhness read jap jee to rid them of 84 lakh joons many singh,singhness read sehj paaths to rid them of 84 lakh joons some may want to read rag mala to rid them of 84 lakh joons ALL GURBANI does this !!!!!! May be if you read a full sehj paath with full bharosa the reading of rag mala is the final stamp to rid you of 84 lakh joons There is not one way to get to rid of 84 lakh joons and 84 ishnans and paaths at goinwal sahib is one of them even if you dont agree finally the word patar is used in Gurbani in more than one place(do a search) and each time the meaning is adkari ie worthy the arth of this line is Gavan gain patar those who are worthy, sing the praises of the Lord this arth is consistant with Gurbani so there is no problem. by the way always a rag mala debate will never solve it arguing here or on any other forum may be we should all lobby Bibi Jagiro (kuri mar) to set up meetings to sort out all panthic controversies this is the only way to get a panthic answer one way or another no point arguing and wasting SIMRAN time laj mare jo nam na levai nam bihoon sukhee kio sauve those of us without nam are we happy in our lives das wont be till gurkirpa of nam although i shouldnt be giving you advice giani ji may be you should post more inspirational topics since you are gian van and not controversial ones as you seem to do. eh shoba nahee dinda for a giani

Re: self contradictions ??84 lakh Joons cut by Raagmala ??

Rashminder Singh · 24 Jan 2005

well said veerji.......... raagmaalaa is not a baani and it is so sad that song sang by a prostitute is readed with shradha in guru darbaar may vaheguru bless all with enlightment Raagmaalaa baani nahi hai............. Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh

Re: self contradictions ??84 lakh Joons cut by Raagmala ??

Bundha · 24 Jan 2005

There are certain people who will persist in flogging dead horses in a blinkered manner in the mistaken belief that if they throw enough mud then some will stick. In my experience most people have entrenched views on the major subjects and no matter how much discussion goes on they will not change their minds, infact their positions become even more entrenched. I have never heard of anyone on a forum say “yes, I used to think this way but due to the enlightened discussion on this forum I have changed my mind.” For example, people are for-meat or against-meat, for-women in panj piyaray or against women in panj piyaray, for-langar on the floor or against langar on the floor, pro-sant or against-sant, pro-raagmala or against-raagmala and no matter how much argument ensues they will not change their minds infact they will argue there position even more vigorously. I for one am against-meat, pro-langar on the floor, pro-sant and pro-raagmala and no matter what anyone says I know (in my own mind) I am right, and I am sure most everyone else is the same. So, we then get certain ‘enlightened’ people who persist with their agendas, rather why not be constructive and open topics for discussion where we can all partake and learn and feel good about Sikhi.

Re: self contradictions ??84 lakh Joons cut by Raagmala ??

Mkhalsa · 24 Jan 2005

>>>I have never heard of anyone on a forum say “yes, I used to think this way but due to the enlightened discussion on this forum I have changed my mind.” <<<< Interesting.. I have said this many times.. There was a time I used to think bibeki was a form of brahmanism and used to mock singhs (guru forgive me) who kept it (Although, they were usually the hypocritical ones). But discussions by bhai kulbir singh jee, harpreet singh and others on akj.org at the time (yes that forum was once great) changed my mind 180 degrees. There are a lot of people out there who are ignorant of the issues or why they beleive what they beleive and sometimes, if you enlighten them (properly) not attacking (as I seem to be famous for, but try my best not to), they may change their minds. I have learned a lot in the fights over the years. In fact, up until last year, every time a raag mala debate would start, I would go back and actually read it, go through the meanings and think, "hey, maybe im wrong, i mean there are so many great gursikhs in taksal, theres gotta be something to it" but everytime I went back to see if it is bani, guru sahib showed me its not and I knew in my heart I cant read it, so after those few years of doing that, I gave up on trying to beleive its bani, because frankly, its not. I also highly and deeply respect sants. Does that make my pro-sant? no. Why? because ive seen enough frauds out there to know. Everyone is human, even guru sahib says this, all of us are human and all humans besides guru sahib can make mistakes. In fact, I recently started not liking dhuni (simran in keertan) but I deeply beleive in my heart and from people I have talked to that Bhai Randhir Singh Jee did it, but I still disagree with it--and this is from someone who is labelled a "randheeri." So what? does that make him any less in my eyes? NO! In fact, I respect him so much, just as I respect baba gurbachan singh jee and baba jarnail singh deeply. I only wish I could have met such a man as baba jarnail singh jee and kiss his feet. Again, I couldnt have learned about any of these great men or had any respect for them if it werent for forums like this one. Langar on the floor- there was a time I didnt even KNOW this was an issue! Again, I learned this on a forum and why we should sit on the floor. Why am I against meat, well I always have been, thats how I was raised, the very site of meat sickens me and I feel like puking. But why was I against it? again, learned this from forums! So many great posts I learned from, if only I had the foresight to save them. So, except for those of us who are always bickering, there are people out there without well formed or educated opinions who have no idea what they beleive or why they beleive it. They quietly read our posts, listening to what we have to say, and take the good from it, as I once did with the numerous arguments on akj.org years ago, they used to fight just as much as we do now, except for the fact that now most arguments are nipped in the bud before they get heated. Back then, it went on and on and on.. I learned a lot from those arguments, I dont know if it ended with the bitter dislike that seems to plague forums now, but I didnt see any. Anyway, just my two cents.

Re: self contradictions ??84 lakh Joons cut by Raagmala ??

akj singh 4eva and eva amen · 24 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf raagmala isnt bani and we persist in saying this because this love story is deforming the true from of our guru which is a maha paap vjkk vjkf

Re: self contradictions ??84 lakh Joons cut by Raagmala ??

hai · 25 Jan 2005

If you don't think Raag Mala is Bani then don't read it, no one is making you do anything.. Read it if you want to, don't if you don't want to.. Its simple really..

Re: self contradictions ??84 lakh Joons cut by Raagmala ??

Dogma · 25 Jan 2005

Another discussion on leading to bickering and hate between Gursikhs. Rarely have I seen a discussion begun on the other angs of Guru Granth Sahib Jee... The funny thing is that the beginning of Guru Granth Sahib Jee (ie. Mool Mantar) is sooooo deep that a whole seperate FORUM could be started on it...but I have yet to see one person start a thread on the meaning of mool mantar. Can anyone open a thread on how the sacrifices of the countless shaheeds we've had in our kaum has inspired them? Can anyone open a thread on what Gurmantar means to them on a personal spiritual level? Can anyone open a thread on how to create LOVE between all Gursikhs, instead of bringing up topics that are KNOWN to cause nothing but bickering? Sorry for the bluntness, but NO FORUMS will ever SOLVE the issue of whether Raag Mala is Gurbani or not. So let's all be smart for ONCE, and stop beating a dead horse. I beg of ADMIN to LOCK this topic as well as I'm sure NO NEW information or NO NEW arguments will be brought up in this discussion. Let us promote EKTA between all Sikh Brother and Sisters. I might not agree with my fellow Sikh about Raag Mala or Keski. But I love him just the same.... Ek Pita, Ekas Kai Hum Barak. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: self contradictions ??84 lakh Joons cut by Raagmala ??

Admin · 25 Jan 2005

Topic locked. Admin