self contradictions ??84 lakh Joons cut by Raagmala ??
Jarnail singh gyani · 23 Jan 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguur Ji ki Fateh. Below is a summarised view of an article by S. Gursharan Singh Kusel Canada on Raagmala which appeared in Sikh Marg. " Gursharan Singh Ji writes that he just read a book by kathakaar Jaswant Singh who writes in his book: Raagmala gurbani hai...When Guru Arjun Ji had finished compiling the (GURU) Granth Ji and putting the Bhog at Mundawni, the Sikhs requested GURU JI to write something that would RELEASE them FROM 84 lakh Joons... a sort of Prem mala...and lo and behold Guru Ji instantly wrote RAAGMALA.. AT last the SIKHS had got the means to ESCAPE the 84 lakh joon circle.... ( What the rest of the GURBANI in 1429 AAngs is for escapes me !!!) Then the writer to strengthen his case for raagmala being the 84 lakh joon cutter, cites that Sant Gurbachan Singh bhinderawaleh also agree to this and have given such nice and wonderful menaings of raagmala that astound even great gianis... BUT the writer forgets that Sant Giani kartar Singh writing the Biography of His mentor sant gurbachan Singh Ji states in his book that SANT JI beleived in having 84 Ishnaans( kesi+body) and 84 Paaths of Japji Sahib at baoli sahib Goindwaal to ESCAPE the 84 lakh Joon circle....didnt SANT JI realise that reading Raagmala would do the same or is a case of "avar updesseh aap na kareh ??"OR only jaswant singh ji knew this secret formula for 84 lakh joon chakara ending. Then another question springs to mind...when Guur Granth Ji has not yet been compiled and GURBANI was read from POTHIS ( Guru nanak ji - Guru Arjun Ji's time)...how was this question of 84 lakh joons circle ending answered by Sikhs ?? WHAT did they READ to escape the 84 lakh Joons since RAAGMALA was not yet written ?? ALL the SIKHS of Guur nanak Ji to Guur Ramdass ji must have gone into this circle of 84 lakh joons BECAUSE all they had was GURBANI of Four GURUS only ?? BUT if we read GURBANI time and again it says the same thing..ONLY NAAM of WAHEGURU can rid us of this 84 lakh joon circle..where and in which line of Gurbani is raagmala made the cure for this disease ?? 2. Giani Gurditt Singh writer of Mundawni gives an idea as to who SANG this raagmala... this answer is from raagmala itself: It says Gaveh gain Patar..a Patar SANG this raagmala..and the Patar is the Singing Prostitute Kamkandala..in the ORIGINAL this is written as : Patar sunnee kamkandala teh pur vasseh chand ke kala....the words punn gaveeh, un gaiyeh, etc tell the whole story. This is how the proponents of raagmala gurbani hai get caught in their own silt traps.. Raagmala gurbani nahin Hai. Jarnail Singh (all errors and omissions mine)