Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

posting in larridaar

posting in larridaar

:s · 22 Jan 2005

MKhalsa veerji in another thread posted this: __________ JoraDhaAkhyaPurkhKumavdhaySayApvithAmaydhKhula __________ what's the point of posting in larridaar if you're going to jugde where the words begin/end anyways?

Re: posting in larridaar

jss · 22 Jan 2005

i was thinking the exact same thing....

Re: posting in larridaar

Mkhalsa · 23 Jan 2005

because in english, it would make zero sense if all letters were lower case.. plus have you seen panthkhalsa.org hukamnama? the point is awareness about lareedar.. everyoneknowsyourcantwriteenglishinlareedar.

Re: posting in larridaar

Singh · 23 Jan 2005

The English language doesn't allow for us to be able to grasp the beginning of the words. For many reasons, including the fact that English has capital and small letters. Gurmukhi script does not. Anyways, stop trying to be so picky and judgmental. MKhalsa was just trying to promote the idea of lareevaar, although its obviously not the same because of his use of the English script.

Re: posting in larridaar

anon · 23 Jan 2005

me tooo.........

Re: posting in larridaar

Jarnail singh gyani · 23 Jan 2005

The idea is for YOU to start judging...where the word begins and ends...NOT take some READY MADE solution decided by SOME ONE ELSE. Once you decide to be One on One with GURU JI....HIS KIRPA will be on YOU to make the correct decision... IF we take the decisions made by Some one else ( no matter how educated, even Prof Sahib Singh Ji of Darpan Fame, Bhai Veer Singh Ji etc )..then we are just "COPY-PASTE" that persons' interaction with HIS GURU JI. We are all children of the same GURU JI but we each have differences....and GURU JI treats all of us DIFFERENTLY. SO make that small effort to interact with GURU JI on one to one..and you will realise it has many benefits....one of which is ATTENTION..one needs to pay MORE ATTENTION if one is doing the separating of words, rather than depending on someone elses interpretations.. Jarnail Singh

Re: posting in larridaar

Gursikha(n) kee har dhooR deh · 23 Jan 2005

-------------------- The English language doesn't allow for us to be able to grasp the beginning of the words. -------------------- regarding this, what are the different things that allow us to determine the beginnings/endings of gurmukhi words? something like if it has a sihaari on the last akhar, it's usually the ending of the word. eg. gurprasaad(i) in mool mantr has a sihaari on teh dadda

Re: posting in larridaar

:s · 23 Jan 2005

i agree with Jarnail Singh for the most part, but getting help from someone who is more knowledgeable is not a bad idea.

Re: posting in larridaar

Jarnail singh gyani · 25 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Dear S ji, Its not my contention that we must not seek someone more knowledgeable.....Far from it. That would be almost criminal negligence !! We MUST learn from some one who knows Gurbani, listen to a good paathi reading gurbani, learn the meanings, nuances of pronounciation etc etc..and use POTHIS that have the words already separated (Pad chhed)..during the learning stage. Once we have learnt the Paath and are comfortable doing it at a reasonable speed, and can do it with love and understanding....thats when the PAYING ATTENTION comes into play for our One on One experience with Guru Ji. At this stage we must ensure we use a LARIDAAR SROOP ( Gutka pothi etc) to do our paath....slow and steady do the paath with devotion and love to gain full benefit... as we go along we separate the words according to guru Ji's Kirpa.. ( most of the time the separation is the same as when we learnt the paath..but surprise surprise..sometimes it is not..thats GURU JI's KIRPA..one on one. ) The Pad chhed part is only for BEGINNERS...but when we extend this into later parts as well then we will "gloss over" the words as the separation is already done..and tend to "speed". This is what i am against. Jarnail singh.