Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

huh?

huh?

ddd · 22 Jan 2005

taken from http://www.sikhtimes.com/books_090803a.html -someone explain this?- 'Kabir, those mortals who consume marijuana, fish, and wine,' 'will go to hell despite all pilgrimages, fasts, and rituals.' (Kabir, Adi Granth, p. 1377) The author implores the reader to carefully consider Kabir's choice of words. The author dismisses outright the possibility that Kabir utilized marijuana and fish in the symbolic sense to imply all narcotics and all non-vegetarian foods. Instead, Kala Afghana points out that 'marijuana, fish, and wine' have been used in the colloquial sense as reference to those who frequent brothels. The author claims that this meaning of the phrase was, and still is, popular in Varanasi (formerly known as Banaras or Benares), Kabir's place of origin. The phrase derives its colloquial meaning from the notion that the consumption of 'marijuana, fish, and wine' increases sex drive. In other words, Kabir is admonishing not non-vegetarianism but sexual promiscuity. Bhai Randhir Singh employs faulty logic - a kind of guilt by association - when he substitutes 'marijuana, fish, and wine' for Kabir's intended target: sexual promiscuity.

Re: huh?

Anon Singh · 22 Jan 2005

Lol. You can use Kala Afgana's explanation (excommunicated from the Panth) of the Tuk or you can use Bhai Sahib's explanation (honoured by the Panth at all hte Takhts). Your choice...I know which explanation makes more sense to me. "No matter what you do, whatever rituals, consuming marijuana, fish, and wine will send you to hell" has a relatively simple meaning to me. There are plenty of examples in Bani and Rehatnamas when a particular concept can be used as an umbrella term/concept for multiple things. This Tuk is very simple to understand.

Re: huh?

huh? · 22 Jan 2005

faulty logic? whereas Kala Afghana is supposed to be some scholar? When it comes to discerning Gurbani, I'll take the world of a Gurmukh over the word of scholar anyday.

Re: huh?

P Singh · 23 Jan 2005

It is good to ask your inner self then take anyone's word for it in my opinion.

Re: huh?

interesting · 23 Jan 2005

Jarnail Singh gyani and Kulbir Singh pls wat are your views on this matter.