Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

. · 20 Jan 2005

please do not bash nihungs, i am neither akj or nihung, i have heard that in the buddah dal you have to take amrit from a seperate bhatta for different castes First i want to ask is this true? I want to seriously understand why? where does the tradition hail from? has it been observed by any british/french commentaries pre colonial? which nihung dals carry out this practice? I would appreciate honest answers to develop my understanding instead of rebuttals and counter reactions. I have asked many questions on the nihung websites they have not been answered.

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

search for Tat · 21 Jan 2005

Bhai Randhir singh one of the first singhs of his tiome to give Amrit to low castes and do seva with them. This is clear in his autobiograhy. The irony here is UK nangs have accused everyone from AKJ, DT, SGPC are being stuck in caste. When the reality it is them, not the others. When they openly call themselves hindus, why does this surprise anyone? The fact the Buddha dal supposedly recognise nakli niddar, then it must be true. Hindus dressed as Sikhs! And they have the nerve to say DT and Babbars have no right to wear Gursikhi bana!

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

Kaur · 21 Jan 2005

What are the nihung websites?

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

jagroop singh · 21 Jan 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer/Bhain '.' Ji, It is interesting to note that you have asked these questions and received no answers. i too have personally found that the 'Sanaatan Sikhi' currently being preached is about as firm as water and as steady as jelly! i too have heard of this practice in passing but find no mention throughout their copious amounts of online literature. Just a thought...despite whatever reasoning you encounter, assuming that this practice turns out to be 'authentic Buddha Dal tradition', please share with this forum. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

Amar Singh · 21 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetha. Before everyone jumps on the Nihang Bashing band wagon we have to establish if this is actually true. What are your sources that Nihangs do this? I have heard all sorts from people about different groups (including akj) but peoples views on the group sometimes merges the lines of reality. I honestly believe that there is no truth in separate bhatta’s for different castes in the Amrit Sanchar. I have never heard of this from any UK Nihang so where has this come from. Most likely its just an anti-Nihang rumour. FYI “Bhai Randhir singh one of the first singhs of his tiome to give Amrit to low castes and do seva with them”, this is not the case, do your research. Firstly the 5 pyarai give Amrit not Bhai Randhir Singh, and secondly anyone regardless of caste is given Amrit. Numerouse Sikhs like Bhagat Pooran Singh did sewa for all people regardless of caste.

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

uk singh · 21 Jan 2005

allegedly they also held separate langars for lower caste sikhs.. ie Mazbis or telis as they felt these groups placed no emphasis on cleanliness..

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

Jagpreet Singh · 21 Jan 2005

There is a clear distinction between budha dal and the 'sanatanics'. However, until the budha dal release an official statement condeming Nidar Singhs claim we can only assume they are the same group. The Kirpan Amrit is definetly part of the Hazoor Sahib Nihangs maryada on not budha dal. Regarding the low caste amrit, I am not too sure if this is part of the budha dal. I know the namdharis also practice this.

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

uk singh · 21 Jan 2005

see http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=2049&t=2049

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

S Singh · 21 Jan 2005

uk singh, your attempt at trying to equate Babek with caste based discrimination is absurd. Babek is Gurmat and has been practiced by many Mahapursh of various Sapradhahs and Jathe, but caste based discrimination is against the very foundations of Gurmat. Please see the Gurmat section of this website for more information.

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

Tat · 22 Jan 2005

I think this caste thing and the Nihangs is total rubbish, without any evidence of it happening or being part of the Buddha Dal Maryada only a fool will take it to be completly true.

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

Anon Singh · 23 Jan 2005

I have heard about this being mentioned in Khalsa Dharam Shaster which is what Nihangs rely on? Not sure.

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

hai · 23 Jan 2005

How about we all stop talking about what we 'have heard' and things that are 'allegedly' going on.. Or will that mean that will leave nothing to put other down with :-o lol Come on people, base allegations on fact and not hearsay..

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

machete · 23 Jan 2005

anyone who is willing to live by the sikh code of conduct is entitled to take amrit. amrit is always prepared by panj pairyea and is stirred with a khanda(not a kirpan) there is one bata which every1 drinks from. u have no caste when jioning the khalsa. u r given a new life, as a member of the khlasa panth. it is that simple i dont know where people r getting this kirpan thing from and this bata thing from. if there r people practising these mad views. they need there brains tested.

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

gurpreet singh · 23 Jan 2005

It is part of buddha dal maryada to have 2 battay, one for the mazbhi's, one for the non-mazbhi's. The seperate langar is also true. for accounts of this in earlier history, please read sketch of the sikhs. The mazbhi's are also referred to as 4th pauree. They even include converts from islam. I can't speak for anyone, but the reason it isn't discussed is because of its controversy. There are dals which are mazbhi dals. Most singhs who adhere to this practice and are strong proponents of it will not let their batta be touched by a mazbhi. One singh had once mentioned that if a mazbhi touches his baata, he puts it in fire to make it "sucha" again. Many of these singhs are bibeki and do consider mazbhi's to be "soot/shoot". I have mentioned facts, nothing which is of opinion. a comment above discussing bibekta was brought up and it came across as if what nihangs do is an insult to bibek. In essence, bibek is using your discriminatory faculties and these people choose to do it their way. waheguruji ka khalsa, waheguruji ki fateh

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

gittimrodha · 24 Jan 2005

if i am not wrong a maulvi came from islam and wanted to take amrit during bhai sahib randhir singhs time. The major gurdwaras would not allow it at the same time they would not allow lower castes to take amrit and mahants even prevented lower castes coming to gurdwaras in punjab. Bhai sahib however took amrit with maulvi karim baksh i think he was renamed bhai sant singh and then bhai sahib randhir singh ji helped lower castes come into sikhi. who refers to mazhbis as 4th pauri? and whoever does are there any rehetnamas/dasam/gurbani to back it up? I am pretty sure many west panjab jat clans also converted from islam to sikhi as well as rajputs who were predominatly influenced by islamic and hindu culture. I do not see the 4th pauri status there. Well just because this is controversial does not mean it should not be discussed. It needs to make sense for it to stand, but so far that just takes the piss out of what Guru Gobind Singh Ji created in the first place. Whats the point having 5 singhs from 5 different castes taking amrit if we are going to seperate the bowls we take amrit from because of the caste your forefather had? not that we have it now anyway. Whats wrong with a mazhbi if they have taken amrit and adhere to gurmat rehat that the baata needs to be put in fire? what if a brahmin touched it does it turn to gold? What do you mean many of these singhs are bibeki? sarbloh? whats that proove? i can eat in iron, if im going to differentiate between fellow amritdharis then obviously im not following what my master taught me. Well we can also say the bnp and taliban are using bibek too to differentiate using faculties their way. Now thats just taking the piss out of bibek. excuse my language but i am disgusted and i would first need facts as to WHY are there are seperate bhattas for different castes in nihung dals? I can list you out so much history of old sikhs who were full of brahmin rituals, like "only eating from the brahmin cook" and getting "muslims to eat pigs legs before they took amrit" that did not make it puratan pure or sanatan sikhi. I do not see where our Satguru commanded any of this. Please provide FACTUAL evidence from the sikh religion itself.

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

gittimrodha · 24 Jan 2005

if i am not wrong a maulvi came from islam and wanted to take amrit during bhai sahib randhir singhs time. The major gurdwaras would not allow it at the same time they would not allow lower castes to take amrit and mahants even prevented lower castes coming to gurdwaras in punjab. Bhai sahib however took amrit with maulvi karim baksh i think he was renamed bhai sant singh and then bhai sahib randhir singh ji helped lower castes come into sikhi. who refers to mazhbis as 4th pauri? and whoever does are there any rehetnamas/dasam/gurbani to back it up? I am pretty sure many west panjab jat clans also converted from islam to sikhi as well as rajputs who were predominatly influenced by islamic and hindu culture. I do not see the 4th pauri status there. Well just because this is controversial does not mean it should not be discussed. It needs to make sense for it to stand, but so far that just takes the piss out of what Guru Gobind Singh Ji created in the first place. Whats the point having 5 singhs from 5 different castes taking amrit if we are going to seperate the bowls we take amrit from because of the caste your forefather had? not that we have it now anyway. Whats wrong with a mazhbi if they have taken amrit and adhere to gurmat rehat that the baata needs to be put in fire? what if a brahmin touched it does it turn to gold? What do you mean many of these singhs are bibeki? sarbloh? whats that proove? i can eat in iron, if im going to differentiate between fellow amritdharis then obviously im not following what my master taught me. Well we can also say the bnp and taliban are using bibek too to differentiate using faculties their way. Now thats just taking the piss out of bibek. excuse my language but i am disgusted and i would first need facts as to WHY are there are seperate bhattas for different castes in nihung dals? I can list you out so much history of old sikhs who were full of brahmin rituals, like "only eating from the brahmin cook" and getting "muslims to eat pigs legs before they took amrit" that did not make it puratan pure or sanatan sikhi. I do not see where our Satguru commanded any of this. Please provide FACTUAL evidence from the sikh religion itself.

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

gittimrodha · 24 Jan 2005

n lastly local amritsari mazhbis played a role in 1984 and supporting ddt where the heck was the glorious sanatan dals hiding?

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

asdf · 24 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh NO real and proper Guru Da Singh will treat others with inequality, no one can make your batta impure, I would happily take amrit with a person that was muslim but I have already taken amrit now so cant do that. I dont think that Bhai Khanaiya Ji used different 'cups' when he gave water to the moghuls and sikhs lol. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

not to sound white.. · 25 Jan 2005

but whats a mazbhi sikh?

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

asdf · 25 Jan 2005

>>> Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh NO real and proper Guru Da Singh will treat others with inequality, no one can make your batta impure, I would happily take amrit with a person that was muslim but I have already taken amrit now so cant do that. I dont think that Bhai Khanaiya Ji used different 'cups' when he gave water to the moghuls and sikhs lol. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh >>> The above 'asdf' is not this 'asdf', nor do the views necessarily represent the ones of this 'asdf'. Bhai Khanaiya wasn't carrying around any cups!! I think the method would have been to pour out the water into the person's hands.

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

pipalz · 25 Jan 2005

So why does this happen? do the people doing this not believe in the power of amrit naam di daat can transform the disciple? then thats why it is important that the panj are nam jappan waley sikh.

Re: Nihungs n Seperate Bhattey For Different Castes

sikha da dust · 25 Jan 2005

i am perplexed by the buddah dals and nirmalas stance. Upon seeing a conversation between a european converted nirmala and others, the nirmala stated that " at least the nirmalas and budda dal are upfront about caste but other groups in sikhism are not". This totally sideline the point. over to budda dal, before we go further i need to stress that jaat paat truly means nothing , i also believe a lot of who were never from india would not care. But now lets go by Budda dals own definitions. It is said that the chief of budda dal must be a khattri hailing from kshatriya heritage because tradition has it that khattris are supposed to be "kshatriya warriors". BUT Khattris are a bussiness class of merchants in punjab and about are 90% hindu including the sub jaatis, khattris would rank 3rd in the hindu caste system. Southern branch of punjabi jatts are well over 70% descendants of powerful rajput clans, were given the honourable title of "kshatriyas" in the caste system. The kshatriya was supposedly the warrior protector of the lands. The northern branch of punjabi jatts and north west frontier tribes remained out of the pale. The southerly group is most dominant, active in sikh policy making, and economically progressing. So going by buddah dals own rules the head chief should be a kshatriya from a south punjabi jatt background and not a khattri vaish. As for the nirmalas only to be a jatt and none else heres food for sochana. People will take status that provides progress. The British gave the land act, after the implementation of the act there was a sudden upsurge number of people calling themselves jatts never seen before changing their identities for upliftment. So how will the nirmalas know for a fact they have chosen a jatt? Now one question comes to mind, if englishmen/women wished to take amrit will they have a seperate bhatta for them and a different one for punjabi sikhs? Is this becauuse they are foreign? what habits does a foreigner have that punjabis would not that would exclude them from taking amrit from the same bowl? they drink? they shag? they club? they eat meat? but heyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy are most of the western born punjabi so called sikhs any different from that? especially cross caste examing? every caste race on the planet is more or less in the same boat. hence give some legit grounding for this please! I think one of the most potent challenging facts stand against this single act of the buddah dal is the muslim spy of aurangzeb taking amrit in 1699 after realising the beautiful jot of Guru ji and this is recorded. A muslim taking amrit in the original call!