Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is corporal punishment according to Gurmat?

Is corporal punishment according to Gurmat?

Kulbir Singh · 17 Jan 2005

When we were studying in a school in India, corporal punishment was a norm. Students used to get canned or other wise beaten for not doing homework or for disciplinary reasons. This continues today too in India. Should teachers be allowed to use physical force when disciplining students? Should parents be allowed to use physical force when disciplining students? What is the Sikhi view on this? Daas, Kulbir Singh Talkative girls earn Headmaster’s ire Jangveer Singh Tribune News Service Patiala, January 16 Fifteen schoolgirls were severely caned by the Headmaster of Manjholi Government Elementary School on palms and knuckles when they did not obey his orders to sit down in class on Friday. He kept hitting the girls with the stick till it broke. The beating resulted in hairline fractures on the thumbs of two girls and a broken knuckle of another. Nearly 12 girls suffered bruises. Headmaster Ravinder Singh became infuriated when girl students of Class VIII kept talking to one another and did not heed to his direction to sit down when he had come to take class. As a punishment, he first told the girl students to keep standing. Then he called for a stick and caned the girls. The girls were hit repeatedly on palms and some of them were also hit on the back of their palms and knuckles. At least three of them — Gurpreet Kaur, Kulwinder Kaur and Reeta Rani — were injured while others, including Sandeep Kaur, Jaswinder Kaur, Sushma Devi, Baljinder Kaur, Sukhbir Kaur, Mandeep Kaur, Ramandeep Kaur, Rajinder Kaur, Sarabjit Kaur, Gurvinder Kaur, Manpreet Kaur, Arvinder Kaur, Seema Rani and Sonam Rani, also received bruises. Parents of the girl students have complained to the sarpanch of Manjholi village against the treatment meted out to their children. Manjholi sarpanch Sarabjit Kaur said parents from this village and also from Haripur Jhungian village had complained against the beating of their children. She said she would take up the matter with the District Education Department authorities. Meanwhile, Mr Rajinder Singh, father of student Reeta Rani who received injuries, said the incident was intolerable. He said the Headmaster did not have any excuse for such a behaviour with girl students and demanded immediate transfer of the teacher from the school. The Headmaster said he had been seized by anger because of the non-serious attitude of the girl students. Admitting handing out corporal punishment to the girls, he said he was, however, now sorry for his action.

Re: Is corporal punishment according to Gurmat?

uk singh · 17 Jan 2005

To instill fear into students or the general masses, heavy handedness is sometimes required. Personally I feel it is neccessary as it prevents loutish behaviour and criminals in particular think twice about committing crime. In the UK a law has recently come into force where children cannot be reprimanded to an extent where marks are left on thier bodies including scratches/bruises. When I was growing up, I was hit many times by my parents/grandfather for being mischevious and I respect them for it. I'm not of the Christian belief that fear breeds hatred. Our relationship with Waheguru is similar. We certainly fear him and the results of our past actions, but at the same time we love him for all that he has provided.

Re: Is corporal punishment according to Gurmat?

blech · 18 Jan 2005

uksingh...you said: "To instill fear into students or the general masses, heavy handedness is sometimes required. " I bet thats what Massa Rangar and Indira Gandhi thought about how they should rule as well! Guru Nanak Dev Jee told Babar differently (i.e. that he should treat those he ruled with respect, and not use heavy handed methods to earn peoples' respect).