Too many Sikh cooks spoil the tsunami broth
Daily Times · 16 Jan 2005
Too many Sikh cooks spoil the tsunami broth
An excerpt from:
Daily Times, Pakistan
NAGAPATTINAM - India’s Sikh community dispatched 110 chefs from northern Punjab state to the tsunami-battered southern coast only to be told that the survivors would not eat what they cook.
In Tamil Nadu state, where the tsunamis killed some 8,000 people, villagers live on a staple diet of rice and, if they are lucky, fish.
Unlike people from northern India they do not eat wheat bread, potatoes or meat. “A big army of Sikhs from Punjab have arrived to help the affected people,†said local government official Shanta Seela Nair, head of rehabilitation operations in Nagapattinam district, the worst hit in the December 26 tragedy.
“They wanted to set up community kitchens and we told them the food they cook will not be eaten by the local people. Instead the cooks can be used as volunteers for help in other areas,†Nair said.
“But they also need to eat their own food. So we let them set up a kitchen at a college ground,†she said. According to Sikh tradition, “langaars†or community kitchens, offer free food to the poor and needy across north India where the religion was founded in the late 15th century. The Sikhs, resplendent in blue, orange and white turbans, travelled more than 2,500 kilometres by train. Trucks, loaded with donated rice, wheat flour, potatoes, onions, cooking stoves and gas cylinders followed them down. Nair, the state’s senior administrator, said “perishable goods†such as wheat flour and rice were sent to remote villages.
“Their intention was good but they did not bother to find out whether local villagers like what they cook,†she said. The 300-strong Sikh or “disciple†team includes 110 cooks, 40 doctors and the remainder volunteeer support staff. They were organised from the religion’s holiest shrine, the Golden Temple in Amritsar.
The doctors have plied their trade from village to village while the cooks have had to muck in on general relief work. “We are a bit disappointed,†said chef Kuldeep Singh Nassupur. “Despite all this, some (people) still walk in (to the langaar) asking for food and we never say no.†One of his colleagues Hardeep Singh said that during a disaster the most important factor for the Sikh religion was “serving the needy.â€
Re: Too many Sikh cooks spoil the tsunami broth
Jarnail Singh Gyani · 16 Jan 2005
This news report appeared in the local newspapers under headings such as:-
Tsunami Victims SHUN Sikh FOOD... and the picture of the huge pile of Langgar Rotis accompanies this...
What BAD publicity for the Guru ka Langgar...a lesson to Sikhs to NOT force theri langgar on rajeh pujeh people. A "genuinely starving" person will eat anything....but those who want to choose ??? should be left alone.
The SAME picture appeared on the Ajit jalandhar website witht the person in charge claiming 10,000 people ate the langgar daily... who is telling the truth ? God only knows.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Too many Sikh cooks spoil the tsunami broth
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 18 Jan 2005
Dear all,
It is true that beggers cannot be choosy with what they get.But let us not forget these people are NOT beggers,they have had a livelihood but fate cage that.
My view is that the institution of the Sikh langger i unparallel in the world and it is great that we have such wonderful system given to us by our Gurus.
But when disasters happen in places that are far from the Punjab and not familiar with punjabi foods,then the sikhs need to be sensitive to that fact as well,rather than blindly sending in thousands of supplies of food that will be wasted.The SGPC is not yesterday organisation,it has been around for many years, decades in fact.It should have a system here it understands the local cultures, languages and diet and systems so that its help blends in rather than stand out like a sire thumb and stick out.
It is a possibility that initially thousands have availed themselves of the langger,but more aid is coming through they would prefer their own foods...
Some of the press of India is not Sikh friendly at all, at every opportunity they get a chance to make a mockery or label Sikhs negatively they do not hesitate to do that.
Recently the Hindudtan timeswriting about the play behzhti- wrote about the sikhs in britain as being "the often ruthless wild and lawless sections of the Sikhs"...now to make fun of the Sikh efforts is no surprise again....
My suggestion is for the SGPC to say, they have fed the initial needy and it is time for them to move on to new pastures like the Sikh victims of Car Nicobar who will more than appreciate the langger.
We know where langger has been made available to the needy like in Malaysia,these same tamils of south India who are now alledgedly making noses at the Guru ka langger often que up for hours to get some langger in the local Gurduaras.In some places these poor people queing up often out number the sangat.
My two cents worth is that times have changed,sadly SGPC still has not caught up with the world in IT,it is time that SGPC asses the situations rather than running in wildly,hoo haahing and gaining points for Bibi jagir kaur or badal ji ...they should be concerned about the image o the Sikh panth, and up lifting the spirit of Sikhism.Let us see them help the poor Sikh victims in the Car nicobar.
Re: Too many Sikh cooks spoil the tsunami broth
Jarnail singh gyani · 18 Jan 2005
so the chinese will have to learn how to make rotian kheer daal etc and then the punjabis will eat ?? they may all be dead by then.
This is all politics..the baddies of bad-dal bibi jageero are all there just to jack up surjit barnala.. there are sikhs in the andamans nicobar who genuinely need this langgar but...the gov of andaman is not a bad-dal pithoo...so..
What hurt so much was the word SHUN.."locals SHUN' Sikh cooking.." in the Press Headlines.... They didnt say..we cant eat this food, or we are not sued to it... they said WE SHUN IT.
this is a gross INSULT
Jarnail singh gyani