SGPC against same-sex marriage
Tribune News Service · 14 Jan 2005
SGPC against same-sex marriage
Sarbjit Dhaliwal
Tribune News Service
Chandigarh, January 13
The SGPC is against same-sex marriage, which has become a hot issue in countries like Canada, where Sikhs are settled in a big number.
Taking a clear and firm stand on the issue, Mr Sukhdev Singh Bhaur, general secretary, SGPC, said today that such marriages were against the Gurmat and Sikh code of conduct. “Because of this reason, the SGPC was against such marriages,” he added.
There are six Sikh MPs in Canadian Parliament. They are divided on the issue. Three of them have taken a stand against the Bill to be passed next month by the Canadian Government to legalise such marriages in that country. However, two MPs — Mr Ujjal Dosanj and Mr Navdeep Singh Bains — are supporting the Bill. Ms Ruby Dhalla, another MP, has not made her stand clear yet.
Asked that certain Sikh MPs are supporting the Bill in Canada, Mr Bhaur said that it was because of politics of votes that they were supporting it. Sikh MPs should only support what was in accordance with the Sikh “maryada” and code of conduct. They should stick to what has the approval of the Gurmat, he added.
Mr Sukhdev Singh is not alone to say so. Leading Sikh scholars, including Dr Kharak Singh, who has authored books on Sikh religion, and Dr Jodh Singh, Editor-in-Chief of the Sikh Encyclopaedia, are of the same view. Dr Jodh Singh said that the concept of same-sex marriages was against the spirit of Guru Granth Sahib. It was also against the law of nature.
“To go against the law of nature was not advisable for those who have been given the responsibility by people to shape the destiny of their respective countries,” said Dr Jodh Singh. “Man has been paying a heavy price for violating the law of nature,” he added, pointing out the devastation caused by tsunami.
Questioning those supporting the same-sex marriage, Dr Jodh Singh asked whether two men married to each other could give birth to a baby, and likewise could two women married in the same manner procreate? If the answer was no, then why to support such marriages, he said.
Dr Kharak Singh, who was a member the Sikh Dharam Parchar Committee of the SGPC that decides about such issues, says that same-sex marriages was an unnatural phenomenon and Sikhism does not approve of it.
Meanwhile, informed sources said that top echelons of the Sikh clergy were expected to issue a statement with regard to the same-sex marriages either tomorrow or early next week.
“Obviously, the legalisation of such marriages by Canadian Parliament by enacting the law next month would influence the Sikh way of life especially of its youth, in that country,” Canadian Sikhs have told Sikh leaders here.
Re: SGPC against same-sex marriage
mushhulee neer na veesrai · 14 Jan 2005
Navdeep Singh Bains is the first amritdhari Gursikh in the Canadian parliament.
I think before jumping to conclusions we should ask for his reasons on voting for the legalizing of gay marriages in Canada.
You might be against gay marriage but you might still vote to allow it. It seems self-defeating but there are reasons. I suggest you contact Navdeep Singh and ask him for his thoughts, and post them here.
(my letter is below)
TO: Navdeep Singh Bains
Dear Sardar Navdeep Singh Ji,
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa,
Vaheguru ji ki fatheh!
As you may have heard, the SGPC has made their position clear that they are against gay and lesbian marriages. They have accused you and Ujjal Dosanjh in the Tribune Newspaper of voting in favour of legalizing gay marriage in Canada for the purpose of votes. Could you please clarify your position and your intentions for the Sikh community of Canada? We have a lot of hope for you and we are inspired by you, being the first Amritdhari Gursikh in parliament. Please communicate to your Gursikh constituents and inform them of your stance on this issue and your motivations.
Thank you,
__________________________________
Re: SGPC against same-sex marriage
Chand-tora SIngh · 15 Jan 2005
Gay Marriages all good if they stay between Gorey - but no LAVA WITHIN SIKHI BETWEEN TWO MEN OR TWO WOMEN!
Re: SGPC against same-sex marriage
Jarnail Singh Gyani · 15 Jan 2005
I think we have to be a part of the society that we live in. A SIKH MP in Malaysia wouldnt go agaisnt the Govt decree on Hallal meat at Govt functions....and the Muslims who have the right to go to mosque from office during office hours...etc etc
The MP in Canada represents ALL sectors of Society who voted him in..NOT only SIKHS and even lesser "Amrtidharee Sikhs".. How many "Amrtidhar4ee votes" did he get ?? Are they enought o sustain him in Parliament ?? Then how can he pander to their tastes only and ignore the 99.9)% others who voted for him ? IF he tries that he will be out in the next election and where does that leave us.
I am not a canadian but thats what i think.
Jarnail singh
< Dealing with the issue - not it's symptoms >
jagroop singh · 15 Jan 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
The homosexuality & Sikhi issue comes up alot and i find the best way to identify the GurMat perspective is to adequately conceptualise the issue in relation to GurMat and not the other way round.
The Semitic scriptures (Torah/Old Testament, New Testament/Bible, Qu'Ran) take a firm, unflinching and definitive stand against homosexuality. We find that God literally hurls fire and brimstone upon gay communities because of their ways and opposition to God's Laws i.e.:
"And likewise also the men, leaving the natural use of the woman, burned in their lust one toward another; men with men working that which is unseemly, and receiving in themselves that recompence of their error which was meet."
(Testament, Romans 1:24-27)
"And Lot! (Remember) when he said unto his folk: Will ye commit abomination such as no creature ever did before you? Lo! ye come with lust unto men instead of women. Nay, but ye are wanton folk".
(Al Qu'Ran, Surah 7:80-1)
GurBani on the other hand does not make a special point of singling out homosexuals and their ways. Why is this?
Because within the wider scheme of things it is irrelevant - GurBani deals with the roots of issue - not the symptoms. Neither does GurBani claim that homosexuality is scientifically unnatural because this would be a flawed argument - homosexual behaviour is rife in the natural world i.e. especially amongst certain primates who are the second most 'intelligent' species after us.
Stepping aside from all this irrelevancy and Kachi Bani/Other Scriptures, we must remember that GurBani tells us that humans have achieved the pinnacle of material creation - the human body. The GurSikh uses this unique opportunity to target the cause of birth/re-birth - s/he aims to defeat the 5 thieves, one of them being (and arguably the most powerful) Kaam/Lust.
Remember this can be just as prevalent within a heterosexual marriage as it can be in a same-sex marriage i.e. lets not try to discuss the symptoms/logical conclusions of Kaam and instead approach it as Siree Guru Sahib Ji does so. Let us also consider, in order to focus upon the real issue, that GurMat also makes it clear that ANY sexual behaviour outside of Anaand Karaaj is not prohibited if one wishes to meet VahiGuru - so let's now focus on the relevant issues...
Anand Karaaj/marriage keeps Kaam controlled within certain parameters. Also, male and female GurSikhs who reacher higher Avasthas/Spiritual States naturally lose all need for it, except for/if/when they want to have children. They come to understand it's snares and so protect their spiritual wealth.
A person who is homosexual, which like all human tendencies/attributes is a result of Karam/previous actions, can have a GurSikhi Jeevan if they do not act upon these desires and instead attach themselves to Naam (just like a heterosexual GurSikh must also ultimately do so in order to reach VahiGuru).
However, whereas the heterosexual GurSikh has an option to enter into Anaand Karaj with the opposite sex, the homosexual generally does not have the will to do so and nor does s/he have the option to enter into Anaand Karaj with a same-sex partner. Why this 'discrimination'?
Because as stated earlier the whole point of Anaand Karaj is to firstly control Kaam, to enable procreation and to FINALLY allow the GurSikh to rise above Kaam. A same-sex marriage therefore is not conducive to a GurSikhi Jeevan because:
- Procreation cannot take place.
- Sexual behaviour would, even if it is between people who are 'in love', ultimately only satisfy feelings of Kaam because no children would be created through it.
The above two reasons when considered together illustrate the fact that as a 'practising' homosexual, actually going beyond all the snares of Kaam amongst these circumstances and eventually becoming a 'celibate GurSikh' would not be easy to do so...and the insipid and transient taste for Kaam has to be completely annihilated before the taste of Naam can be fully savoured.
To any homosexual Veers/Bhains who may be reading this thread, please understand that my post is not intended to hurt you or make you feel bad. There is no reason to feel bad about your sexual tendencies and don't listen to those who spout needless hate and judgement which is not what GurSikhi is about. This would merely distract you from dealing with your past Karams, just as we all have to if we wish to meet VahiGuru.
What is also worth considering, as a final note, is that GurBani uses 'pseudo-sexual' metaphors when describing how the True Husband (VahiGuru) eventually 'ravages' the Soul Bride, who 'yearns' only for Him i.e.:
'jaisee tarun bhataar urjhee pireh sivai ih man laal deejai.
Like the wife, who is bound by love to her husband, and serves her beloved - like this, give your heart to the Beloved Lord.
man laaleh deejai bhog kareejai habh khusee-aa rang maanay'.
Give your heart to your Beloved Lord, and enjoy His bed, and enjoy all pleasure and bliss.
and elsewhere Siree Guru Sahib Ji says:
'kaajal fool tambol ras lay Dhan kee-aa seegaar.
The wife takes flowers, and fragrance of betel, and decorates herself.
sayjai kant na aa-i-o ayvai bha-i-aa vikaar'.
But her Husband Lord does not come to her bed, and so these efforts are useless.
Therefore Siree Guru Sahib Ji teaches us that the only 'lust' which is positive is the 'lust' felt by the Soul Bride for The True Husband; this 'lust' is Vairaag and through it we achieve the only True Pleasure.
The real question we must all ask ourselves as individuals is: How can this True Pleasure be attained if we have, as i do, Vairaag for material pleasures such as lust or even tasty foods?
No-one ever said GurSikhi was a piece of cake!
(((( : - ) >>>
Bhul chuk maaf karna jio.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: SGPC against same-sex marriage
bhopinder singh · 15 Jan 2005
dr jodh singh should not base the whole issue on procreation as the cloning will prove that
Re: SGPC against same-sex marriage
nimaana gursikh · 15 Jan 2005
i totaly agree with bhai sahib jagroop singh ji
yes i am a gay and trying to be gursikh too, i might get married to a women to prove myself hetrosexual in society but what if i dont satisfy her needs................?
i know most of u guys will hate what i am saying but u cant understand my feelings
put yourself in my shoes and then feel the pain in all those gursikh lifes who are gays or lesbians and want to be a sikh too
Vahegurujikakhalsavahegurujikifateh
Re: SGPC against same-sex marriage
tribune news service · 16 Jan 2005
3-time Canadian MP opposes same sex marriage
Prabhjot Singh
Tribune News Service
Chandigarh, January 15
The move of the Liberal government to bring same sex marriage bill before House of Commons may be the reason behind the last-minute cancellation of visit of Canadian Prime Minister, Mr Paul Martin, to Amritsar for paying obeisance at Golden Temple and Durgiana Mandir.
The other reason could be that the Federal Minister, Mr Ujjal Dosanjh, who was to accompany him to Amritsar had made certain “objectionable†comments after Operation Bluestar in the Golden temple complex.
According to the revised plan, Mr Paul Martin will arrive in New Delhi on January 17 and depart the next day. His visits to Amritsar, Agra and Mumbai have been cancelled. “It is because of tsunami,†says Mr Ujjal Dosanjh, Health Minister of Canada, dismissing speculations that same sex marriage bill was the reason behind change in programme.
Mr Dosanjh believes that religion was “something individual and personal†and had nothing to do with the governance or law making.
“We are strongly committed to same sex marriage,†asserted Mr Dosanjh while Mr Gurmant Grewal, three-time member of Canadian Parliament, held that in 1998, the House of Commons had reiterated in retaining the traditional definition of marriage meaning that it was between a man and a woman.
Talking to newsmen here today, Mr Grewal said the issue of same sex marriage had been there for a long time. “It is Parliament which has to debate and decide about the definition of marriage. This is what the Supreme Court of Canada has said,†maintains Mr Grewal holding that once the house of Commons passed the definition to which the present Prime Minister and his Deputy were party, how could they now “vote in favour of change of definition of marriage. If they do, they will prove to be hypocrites.â€
He further held that curtailing visit to India may not give the right signals for promoting bilateral relations and trade. In 1998 when the then Liberal government passed sanctions against India and Pakistan, he said, he and his party opposed it stressing the need to ensure peace in South Asia and brining two neighbours together for a dialogue.
Mr Grewal said that while Canada was trying to regulate Immigration business by introducing license system, India would do well to do the same to check both “kabootarbazi†or illegal human smuggling trade.
He said that at least four MPs of the ruling Liberal Party had been blacklisted in immigration cases. “Even the Immigration Minister has been forced to resign by the Opposition because of corruption and favouritism charges against her ,†he said.
Mr Gurmant Grewal accompanied Speaker of House of Commons to Pakistan where important issues like progress of democracy, donning of uniform by President Musharraf and confidence building measures between India and Pakistan were discussed.
Re: SGPC against same-sex marriage
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 17 Jan 2005
Totally agree with Chand-tora Singh - as long as a same sex marriage is NOT allowed to happen in front of Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji- it's fine for westerners to carry on doing what they want- we need to look after our- SIKH- interests. I dread what the future will bring though, as I have, to my amazement learned of a rising trend amongst Panjabi/Sikh (monay) males who are becoming gay.
Re: SGPC against same-sex marriage
nimana gursikh · 17 Jan 2005
VahegurujikakhalsaVahegurujikifateh
my family doesnt know about this and even if they know they will no accept me
saadsangat is the true family for all gursikhs and these gursikhs never accepted this then how can my family accept me the way i am
I have cried many nights on my terrace since i was a kid, no one at all understood my feelings. I realised that i was a gay since i was hardly 12year old, i had no interest in dressing up like males and when i grew up i realised i had no attraction to opposite sex, I was a manmukh that time "niguraa" so i had no restriction so went in to relations with so many guys until i was in year 12
then a time came, i got sangat and i changed myself......... started nitnem and one day i was blessed with guru ka amrit.
everything was cool until i met a amritdhari gursikh who himself was a gay since birth....... he told me his hidden sadfull story, he was bullied by his classmates always coz they came to know he was a gay
then what..... he admitted in front of almost 2000 students on stage that he was a gay and he fainted coz of depression
this was the first time in my life that i faced the truth and shared my feelings with someone.... coz we were sailing in the same boat
then one day we did a bhul, i mean bajjar kurehit....... i cried a lot and felt sorry in front of guru ji and i knew only panj pyare can bless me...... so i decided to go to panj pyare.... even though it wasnt a easy thing for me to do..........
so we both went to panj pyare, they asked me everything and i told them i have done a bajjar kurehit with a male and i feel sorry for it, yeh i got punishment and took amrit daat again but i cried in front of them " plss help me" "plss help me" anyhow they ordered me to get married soon.....
then my friend went there to panj and felt sorry for everything and he cried a lot and plead to panj pyare "pls let me marry this guy or atleast allow me to live with this guy" he said to panj he loves me and he admit he is a gay and thats how guru ji made him and he said even if he get married to a girl, he can never keep her happy and satisfied..... and he wanted to be a gursikh too....
i was in same situation....... i didnt wanted to leave gursikhi but couldnt even hide the truth
Panj payare told him that it might not be acceptable to guru ji but u can do anything on your own risk
then what............. he went back to his country n i got myself engaged
and will get married in 2 years...........
we both live in english countries........ its depressing for me to see people having thier rights and living according to thier wishes
i obviously dont want to lose my gursikhi...... but dont know if i could make my wife happy and satisfied......
I consider this to be punishment of my past karmaa's
i still cry few times........ i got so much hidden in myself........
May Vaheguru bless me with a normal happy married life
Nimana Gursikh
Re: SGPC against same-sex marriage
jagroop singh · 18 Jan 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Bhain 'anonkaur' ji wrote:
'Maybe this is a blessing in a very good disguise as you can completely throw your self into paat and simran, please guru ji and thus obtain happiness'.
Veer 'Nimaana Gursikh' ji, she is absolutely right. This is truly the silver-lining to the cloud.
Can I also say that it is very positive that you have been able to share all this and speak from your heart ias such a courageous manner - always remember that Siree Guru Sahib Ji's forgiveness knows no bounds...
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: SGPC against same-sex marriage
Gurjit singh · 26 Jan 2005
Navdeep Bains is a leader in our society today even if he was muslim hindu or chirsitan or even Gay he still a great leader, he is not mixing relgion with his status of power, like jus imagine if he we did ban gay marragies, would that mean Gay ppl would jus dissppear, to ban gay marragies is to ignore a issue in our society, and navdeep knows that he mite have lost some support but he belives he did the right thing and most hardcore sikhs wouldnt understand it, there are sooo many gay ppl 2day it would be a shock if any of us desis found out, their probally even ur own aunties and uncles, jus that Desi look down on it so much that most of these "human beings" are depressed and have their head down in shame, i Say let them live their life, u should be free 2 love whoever u want, jus like how we are free to be any religion we want,
Meat is prohibited, does that mean we Ban meat throughtout Canada, don't sikhs own a ton of meat shops
Cuttin ur hair is prhobitied, does that mean we Ban barber shops
Smokin is prohibited and bad for ur health, but does that mean sikhs will stop sellin them in their stores
Gay is jus antoher issue, u have a problem wit it then dont be GAy, noone is forcing it on anyone, but 2 Control someones life is wrong, personal i dont like gay ppl @ all, i dont think i could say freinds wit someoen if they came up to me and told me they were gay, but doesnt mean we make laws to take away their freedom