Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Cools · 13 Jan 2005

Great stories about how the Nakali Sadhu got beats for pretending to be Sri Guru Gobind Singh or the Cowardly Radhasoamis etc. Now for some serious actions. What will we ever do about the Namdharis and their Gurudom?! No other group claims to have direct Guru lineage from Guru Gobind Singh. Pakhandi Namdhari guru Jagjit Singh claims to be the 15th Nanak. But why do we not do anything about their claims. Just because they wear white and do paka Rag Kirtan we seem to let them get away with their claims. They have now started puting a white Nishaan Sahib outside their deras. They are classified as Gurdwaras, they are part of the local council of Gurdwaras along with Singh Sabha Gurdwaras. They claim our history is a mistake. They mock our Kirpans and claim that we have got it wrong. They mock our Guru, Sacahy Padshah Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. So why do we associate ourselves with them. Why have we never done anything about them. Just because they are politically linked!? When did we start getting scared of the politically connected. Isn't it time we did something about it ?

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

A Singh · 13 Jan 2005

what did Maharaaj Himself do when when he has 22 or more rival gurus at Baba Bakala? Didn't Guru Gobind Singh Maharaaj even meet Baba Ram Rai and even protected his wife Punjaab Kaur and his dera in dehradun? apparently calling himself the true successor to Guru Har Rai sahib? So if Maharaaj, allowed them to practice their own version of sikhi, and the puraatan Khalsa tolerated them although kpet away from them, then what do you suggest we should do with namdharies, given the above?

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

gaiani · 14 Jan 2005

dear asingh plez get your facts rite, where does it say baba ram rai claimed to be guru? and there is only one version of sikhi. what are you sayin puraatan khalsa was known to beat soldier who were even suspected of lookin at someone with a wrong eye, how wud they tolerate such outrages.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

mushhulee neer na veesrai · 14 Jan 2005

Dear A. Singh, but there is also the story of the masands, and what was done with them by Guru Gobind Singh Ji, or the mahants, and what happened in Saka Nankana. I think it wuold benefit manmukhs like me if you could discuss the difference between the Masands, the Mahants, the Radhasoamis, the Namdharis, Nirankaris, and the Ram Rayae. which ones deserved thrashing from Khalsa, and which didn't ?

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Cools · 14 Jan 2005

Let's then at least keep away from them. We allow them to do Kirtan in our Gurdwaras because they are considered to to good classical Raag kirtan. Local Sikh Council of Gurdwaras allow them to be part of the group. They are consulted on Sikh issues. We even give them a float when we have Nagar Kirtans. Their monthly publications such as 'Satyug' are seen inside UK Gurdwara libraries. We should have no contact with them as per Dhirmalias or Ram Rais. But the fact is we do.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Bundha · 14 Jan 2005

A singh, Guru Gobind Singh Ji ascended the heavens in 1708. Namdharis say that the Guruship passed to Baba Balak in 1812 and Baba Ram Singh came much later, so Baba Ram Singh never did darshan of Guru Ji. As far as I know Baba Ram Singh was a good Gursikh and as such the Sikhs had no problem with him. It is after him that the namdharies have set up this Guruship and have tried to make a connection between Guru Sahib Ji and Baba Balak and so to Baba Ram Singh, these are absolutely lies and should be re-butted vigourously. If these people are propogating more and more lies we as Sikhs should/must do something about it. On the surface they are very polite and accommodating but underneath they have a different agenda. They emailed me about the site that I run and politely asked why I had no info on Baba Ram Singh when I told them that I believed that Guru Granth Sahib Ji is my iternal Guru and I did not believe their lies they tried very hard in long winded arguments and polite emails to engage me in discussion. I think they lost interest after a little while. In the discussions with them they revealed that they were busy setting up new sites to put their order of events of Sikh history. They are putting a lot of time and effort into these sites and to the casual surfer the info can be overwhelming and doubts planted in the mind. We need to vigourously stand up to these people.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 15 Jan 2005

Cools is MORE than RIGHT....we are the ones who "Paal snakes in our Godh..and then wonder how we got bitten.. Initially the Namdharies were part of the Independence Movement and the GOvt killed them...NOW they are PART of the GOVT and meant to destroy Sikhi from inside. They are PART of the Govt in Punjab as well, Hanspal singh Congressi is one, they are bossom buddies of badal akalis ( BAD...Dal..Army of BADDIES ), their leader has rewgualr "parwachan" in the major Punjabi newspapers, their leader represented the SIKHS at the UNO ( why ?/ becasue SIKHS dont have a representative..thats why !!)..the other "SIKH" rep was Harbhajan Yogi..another Fraud. IF Sikhs want a rep they call the uneducated jathedars from Punjab who cant say a word in English..so its all our fault. The ONLY solution is to make the GURU KHALSA PANTH its RIGHT place in the scheme of things.....GURU GRANTH - GURU KHALSA PANTH equation ordained by GURU GOBIND SINGH JI has been BROKEN by us. The PARGATT DEH of GURU JI is GURU KHALSA PANTH...thats why these namdharies/radhasoamis.nirankaris.narakis etc etc take advantage and have DEH-Dharee "GURUS"/Partakh Darshan/Deh POOJA. Jarnail singh

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Sarblohi · 15 Jan 2005

very nice of you "gyani" arshi, calling people who devoted their lives to preaching sikhi in foreign lands to uneducated masses and creating gursikhs, as a fraud shabash tere

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 16 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. dear sarblohi veer jio, I used to be a yogi proponent until i heard all those funny aquarious age..and all that stuff coming out of yuba city HQ.. And then the Rickross site came up and i further disilluiuoned.. And then some so called "Chardikalla' singhs came for a visit to malaysia recently and the way they were swearing the F words..and ( saying Oops i hope i didnt break my Amrit..in the same breath)..and i arrived at where i am now vis a vis yogi.... Yogi was very close to the Powers that be in the sgpc/badal etc ...and no one who is clean can be that close to these coal sellers....if one enters a coal cellar one comes out a bit dirty.. There has been NO SRI SINGH SAHIB in Sikh history except a Takhat jathedar..or a sgpc/badal pithoo. Any way i dont deny that Yogi has done a lot of good work initially bringing Sikhi ( his brand) to America....so we win soem lose some. Let Waheguru be the Judge as Yogi is departed now and i dont want to discuss him. Thank you. for the Shabash tere. My comments are my own without fear or favour to anyone. Jarnail singh.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

GKD · 17 Jan 2005

i hear the nirankaaris are becoming a large problem, they are gaining numbers like crazy. Their tents are set up in dheli and u can c them upto the horizon...

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 17 Jan 2005

We have narkdhari gurbachana's son "baba" hardev "singh" openly doing his "apostle of peace and love" so called samagams in India and elsewhere, we have in some pinds in Panjab (even my nanaka pind) where they used to have a naamdhari who regularly made up 1/5th of 5 "Singhs" when somebody wished to give langar. What are we coming to?!! When are we going to have anyone of the calibre of Sant Jarnail Singh Khalsa Bhindranwale to lead us? We have become sleeping lions, too lazy to do anything about the hyenas who are looting us. SINGHA JAAG VEY, HUN "JAGO" AIYA

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Cools · 17 Jan 2005

As Gyaniji has mentioned the Namdharis have sneakly involved themselves with a lot of the higher profile Sikhs i.e Badal and Yogi. Another danger is they way they are muscling in to the Ramgarhia Gurdwaras. The majority of Namdharis are of Tarkaan Backgrounds and they are marrying their Girls into mainstream Sikh families who practice the caste system. You tend to find many familes of Tarkaan backgrounds with Namdhari relatives. You find a lot of overlap in families like this, where they become sympathetic to the Namdhari beliefs and hold the fake Guru in high esteem.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

uk singh · 17 Jan 2005

negativity aside, we should be grateful that they have kept the art of gurmat sangeet alive. BTW - has anyone heard or listened to Bhai Baldeep Singh (nephew of Bhai Avtar Singh) perform kirtan in the US? Anyone know where I can purchase it?

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Cools · 17 Jan 2005

There we go again!!. Let's get the 'pro-Namdhari' banners out because they do Raag Kirtan and dress in white.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

uk singh · 17 Jan 2005

Teaching raag kirtan to non namdharis is a great seva. Across the pond here in England several amritdhari youth have learnt the vidiya and perform amazing kirtan. They have not adopted namdhari practices and do not wear white clothing. How many Singhs would teach namdharis kirtan if we held this giyaan?? The only alternative is to learn from pandits who charge £30-50 per hour and most are based in India.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

daaas · 17 Jan 2005

Cools Veerji, i can second your point about the tharkans and most of the namdharis being tharkans.. cuz myself i am coming into that lineage. I know a lot of key points about namdharis since my grandfather was one... a lot of my dads side is all namdharis .. actually my grandmother is coming from the family (her nankai) .. of baba ram singh ji .. as, most of you have mentioned, it is true that baba ram singh ji was a true gursikh.. but its his followers thereafter that messed everythingup.. .. a lot of my relatives do respect guru granth sahib ji as guru .. but they for some reason want a physical guide to guide them and hence they see that in the present guru. They do a lot of bani, simran, .. .. i simply can not argue wit them as this is part of their life in india now.. but im glad my parents do not follow it .. i am a amritdhari singh of guru gobind singh and i am damn proud of it !! bhul chuk maph!

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Kulwinder Singh · 18 Jan 2005

All of you who just want to lash out on other for not being synch with your views are some how good Sikhs seems strange idea, Sikhism is a big philosophy people will understand it some time in their own way and link with it in their unique way. As long as they link with shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, let them and if you want to improve your own life, forget about other worry about yourself. those who want to sort these people out, forget that apart from having no dialog on the personal basis anything else will just back fire on us. If somebody is false then they are not going to achieve anything in life on following false path. so just be careful where you going, and God will look after the rest. BE VERY CAREFULL WHEN SUGGESTING THESE SOLUTIONS. FIRST SORT YOUR OWN HOUSE, THEIR ARE FACTIONS IN ALMOST ALL THE JATHAS IN PRESENT SIKH COMMUNITY REGARDLESS IF THE JATHA IS POLITICAL OR RELIGIOUS SO IF YOU ARE NOT IN SYNCH WITH EACH OTHER IN SOCALLED ACCEPTED GROUPS THEN WHAT YOU EXPECT FROM THOSE WHO OVER THE CENTRUIES HAVE OPPOSE TO OUR BELIVES, FACTS AND HISTORY. BE GOOD SIKH YOURSELF AND LEAD BY EXAMPLE, THEN OTHER WILL FOLLOW BY LOOKING AT YOU, RATHER THEN RAMMING OTHER WITH YOUR SHOUTINGS. It is better to have interface with those who you want to educate and win over rather then shutting the doors and labelling others as Fraud and evils. Let bring changes where it is required for betterment with most peaceful dialog and logics of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. ALSO STOP BELAMING JUST INDIAN GOVERNMENT FOR EVERYTHING BAD HAPPEN IN THE SIKH COMMUNITY, EVEN INDIAN GOVERNMENT HAVE MORE INFULANCE IN SIKH COMMUNITY THEN MJORITY MUST FEEL CLOSE TO THEM OTHERWISE IT IS SIMPLY NOT POSSIBLE ESPICALLY OUTSIDE INDIA. Basically we are not happy with anything anybody do apart from it is done by just us. Beware , Some people want sikhs to have some dispute in the light of Bezehti Issue, they want to label Sikhs as trouble maker. SO BE VERY CAREFULL HOW YOU TACKEL IT.. BE 50000% CAREFULL. DO NOT ACT IN STUPIDITY AND FALL RIGHT INTO THE TRAPE

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Guldeep Singh · 18 Jan 2005

uk singh ji. Bhai Baljit Singh Ji's Kirtan can be found on website I once saw. I think it is called Namdhari Radio or something. Do a search. You will find it.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

uk singh · 18 Jan 2005

Sardar Guldeep Singh Ji - I was referring to Baldeep Singh.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Cools · 19 Jan 2005

Kulwinder Singh, I accept all your points. I didn't start this thread to jump on the Behzti bandwagon. I personally feel that this is a big issue that is of concern to me as a Sikh, as is the Sanatan Sikh problem and Baba Harneck ( and other potentially dangerous babay) in the UK. We have a serious problem due to the lack of focus from mainstream Sikhs and groups/sects like these cause even more confusion. I am not attacking the Naam Kamai of a Namdhari. I myself have a Namdhari Grandfather who practices his AmritVela and is strict about his nit-nem. I would be lying to you if I said he has not influenced my life in some way. I have been on the receiving end of the Namdhari Parchar/Philosophy and know how easy it is to fall in the family trap. Basically we are all influenced by our Sangat and if you have the Sangat of these sects within your families than you are more likely to accept their beliefs or become confused about your beliefs. The result is that extended families like mine end up having a mixture of confusion towards Sikhi, where Sikhs start doing the matha tek of fake Gurus/Baby in order not to offend their siblings or relatives.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 20 Jan 2005

Kulwinder Singh wrote: "THEIR ARE FACTIONS IN ALMOST ALL THE JATHAS IN PRESENT SIKH COMMUNITY REGARDLESS IF THE JATHA IS POLITICAL OR RELIGIOUS SO IF YOU ARE NOT IN SYNCH WITH EACH OTHER IN SOCALLED ACCEPTED GROUPS THEN WHAT YOU EXPECT FROM THOSE WHO OVER THE CENTRUIES HAVE OPPOSE TO OUR BELIVES, FACTS AND HISTORY." Yes, Kulwinder Singh, you are right that there are factions within the jathe- Taksal, AKJ etc. However, the common thing is that they are 100% believers in Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj and NOT ANY DEH-DHARI GURU, unlike the namdharis- we cannot even think about accepting ANY sect who believe in a living Guru. Sab Sikhan Ko Hukam Hai, Guru Manio Granth

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Kulwinder Singh · 21 Jan 2005

Dear Pardeep Singh Ji, You have said "we cannot even think about accepting ANY sect who believe in a living Guru" I do not contradict you on that at all, I agree with your statement, the point I made was, what we going to do about them is first sort ourselves out. having all different types of fictions make our case weaker to oppose these people, I rather bring them in line with Akal Takhat by dialog and logical explanations to their members in contrast to conflict, Sikhism is not in a comfortable time right now and we should not open more conflicts right at this stage. Use sweet way convincing people of the right path rather then pushing them in line. It hurts me too see any kind of fictions among Sikhs. To me I only see Guru Granth Sahib Ji and nobody else, But I am willing to bite my lip and listen in exchange for they listen to me, to hear the right thing, I have not meet a single human being who will not accept the Glory of Guru Granth Sahib Ji after even a knowing a little bit about them.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

n · 21 Jan 2005

these groups are attracting people because they welcome people in we need to do the same thing we got to stop hating each other and yeah if u wanna do something do it dont just talk about it do it today first know what they are about and do ardaas to guru ji pray that you are doing the right thing and move and do something keep the simran going and do something spread sikhi

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

hm · 21 Jan 2005

well baba jarnail singhs vision when he did parchar was that he wanted all these groups namdharis and others to come under the fold of sikhi. So i think dialogue might work, till we try we dont know. Personally i think it will because sikhi is the most ideal path with no holes. All man made sects are full of holes, whatever ras spiritual they get its from their contact with actual sikhi ie bani.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

hm · 21 Jan 2005

i hope i didnt get this wrong, i cant verify that baba jarnail singhs stand was always that but i just read it somewhere many years ago, if i am wrong please correct me.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

search for Tat · 21 Jan 2005

In baba ram singh ji biography, which is freely availble in most sikh libraries, at the end is photocopies of his last letters. In this he condemns the Guru ship thing. He has written it clearly in black and white.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Jarnail singh gyani · 22 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh. Dear" Search for tat" jio, Its NOT baba Raam Singh Ji namdhari that is at fault. We all know he was a Great Gursikh, and a great fighter for Independence for which he was EXILED for LIFE to horrible prisons Far away from PUNJAB. Baba ji was the FIRST Indian to promote SWADESHI PRODUCTS...( to strike an economic blow at Briitsh factories ).....this idea was later HIJACKED (STOLEN) by GANDHI..and he took the credit for it. The Neo-namdharis with their "Satgurs and maharajs" are NOT following even ONE teaching of Baba Raam Singh ji...just as the Neo-Nirankaris dont follow any of the teachings of the ORIGINAL NIRANKARIS, and the Neo-NANAKSARIS dont follow any of the teachings of baba Nand Singh or baba isher Singh....or their "lifestyle" of bhagtee/meditation/austerity. These "Founders" are there just for SHOW....to have a LINEAGE, respected "history" etc. No body gives two hoots about what they actually taught or did or wrote down....WHY SHOULD THEY ?? The Modern Day BABAS/ SANTS Satgurs want to ride in the latest mercedes, have the palatial palaces,sleep in the company of the most beautiful maidens on the softest dunlopillow mattreses, and the best of foods.....while Baba Nand Singh spent 20 hours a day meditating and ate just daal roti..and probably "slept" standing up...so Which Modern Baba Sant would want to live that lifestyle ?? Baba nand Singh Ji is JUST "BACK UP INSURANCE" for the Modern day Nanksari KU-Babas and KU-sants...and IF the name of baba nand Singh..doesnt "SCARE" you, then they bring in the SUKHMANI SAHIB ASHTPADIS...that will surely work on any weak hearted sikh...and if that also doesnt work then they send in the goon squad to beat u up. Jarnail Singh

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Jas S Channa · 22 Jan 2005

In Latif's book 'History of Punjab' which was written very close to the time of Baba Ram Singh, he says that Ram Singh Namdhari actually claimed he was the re-incarnation of Sri Guru Gobind Singh. Anyway the Namdharis always push a 'special' version of the Sau Sakhi forward when it comes to justifcation of their existance. I have Namdhari relatives and I know Namdharis are not allowed to eat langar prepared in a Sikh Gurdwara, even down to degh. Which I always find strange as my Namdhari Cousins can sit in Pizza Hut for lunch but not in a Sikh Gurdwara. Also many Namdharis are Paan (betel leaf with sapuru and some other wierd addictive things) eaters and can regularly be seen lining up Paan for their personal consumption. I think they get this habit because the hang around with all the Indian Classical Music Ustaads.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

jss · 22 Jan 2005

funny how gyiani jarnail singh claimed yogi to be a fruad...then provided absolutly no evidence to convince us of it....he simply said..i don't want to discuss it... funnier still ...in the same post..he says it's up to waheguru to judge him...so then giyani ji are you waheguru??? cuz you CERTAINLY judged him when you called him a fraud.... dear admin... what happened to that policy you guys posted a couple of days/weeks ago..where you guys said you wouldn't allow threads or posts that bash others without any evidence???...i was soo happy when i saw that...lets please enforce that policy so we can actually have more productive discussions instead of having the same old people pressing their same old (anti everything) aganda....

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

machete · 23 Jan 2005

it is every sikhs duty to protect the truth. it is every sikhs duty to protect the honour of guru ji. if there r certain groups slanderin guru ji and spredin falsness. then a true sikh must speak against these activities and make the masses aware. if all peaceful means fail the sikh has no choice but to lift the sword and go in to war. u tease a lion u get bit. but right now we need to shame and name the fake sects and make sure the futher youth dont get cuaght up in these false webs.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Kulwinder Singh · 24 Jan 2005

Dear Machete, Before you lift the sword, try to look into your Jiven to see if you are a good Sikh, first make your life worth then think of snatching somebody else. I have no love for anybody who is against Guru Granth Sahib Ji, and Do not even see never mind believing in any Fake Tome Dick or Harry. But the kind of action Machete is saying need to be handled by those who have at least some similarities to Baba Deep Singh Ji's kind.

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

Jarnail singh gyani · 24 Jan 2005

dear jss, its not funny but sadly a fact..and Yogi''s farudiness is being proved by the day..now that we have news about "successors" being chosen for yogi..Since when did SIKHS have chosen successors.( let me know of any SIKH misiionary College/organisations/jathas/Gurdwaras that chose successors..genuine ones dont..but deras do because of huge business/lands/properties a yogis dera has) I did mention a SITE that has all the FACTS..www.rickross.com..i decided it serves no purpose to waste the time of this Forum with what is already availble elsewhere...and since Yogi is dead..i decided it is unsikh to rake him up....but you seem to have different ideas. What I said is WAHEGURU will JUDGE him and "reward" or "punish" him..i still beleive he is a fraud..this is a BELIEF and not "judgement" of Waheguru....i hope you can notice the DIFFERENCE. Further evidence of his fraudiness can be read through kamalarose kaur columns all over the net and sikh mailing lists. Lets NOT waste valuable time of the sangat on this by gone event. jarnail singh

Re: The Namdharis-When are we going to do anything about it???

jss · 26 Jan 2005

The Damdami taksaal chooses a successor to take care of taksal...what do you have to say about that?... a successor is just there to make sure the seva of the 3HO runs smoothly... and how do you know www.rickross.com is FACTS??? i read that site a while ago and believed it all..but upon further reading...none of the allegations they presented had been proven ... and just cuz one lady goes on the net and spreads her "story" doesn't make it true right away....do you konw the jeevan of this lady making her accusations?....have you looked into the facts?....or you just belieiving things from hearsay??