Akal Takhat hukamnama
singh khalsa · 06 Jul 2003
WJKK WJKF
not to question any of the hukamnamay passed by Sri Akal Takhat Sahib, but i have a question. Was there a hukamnama passed regarding the Dasam Granth? it would be nice if somebody could enlighten me on this. thank you.
Re: Akal Takhat hukamnama
Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 07 Jul 2003
yes veer ji ther ewuz, it banned all public discussions regarding dasam granth ji
Re: Akal Takhat hukamnama
Nihang Degh Singh · 07 Jul 2003
Do you mean Shri Guru Dasam Granth sahib ji?
Re: Akal Takhat hukamnama
Kulbir Singh · 07 Jul 2003
Nihang Degh Singh wrote:
> Do you mean Shri Guru Dasam Granth sahib ji?
There is only one Guru at present and that is Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. We don't have three Gurus as Nihungs preach. They consider Siri Dasam Granth and Siri Sarbloh Granth as Gurus. This is wrong. Guru Gobind Singh jee said:
SABH SIKHAN KAO HUKAM HAI, GURU MANIYO GRANTH||
It is Damdami Saroop of Aad Granth that is the Guru.
Not considering Dasam Granth as Guru does not mean that I am disputing the baani of Dasam Granth.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Akal Takhat hukamnama
singh khalsa · 07 Jul 2003
thank you for the help, but regarding the Baani of Dasam Granth. I am not questioning it. But i just want to know if it is true that Akal Takhat said Dasam Granth is written by the pen of Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj.
Re: Akal Takhat hukamnama
Gabroo Khalistan Dah · 07 Jul 2003
its not the nihungs that say that, its the propoganda filled sites of the indian chelaye who have made sites depicting the beliefs of our nihung brothers....
that is fact
nihangs are sikhs , they believe everrything we do with slight differences phung, and meat , which is not even widely accepeted in the nihungs... main difference is that they are nomadic and without attatchement........
my dadaji(dads chacha ji) he wuz a familly man, who would do his kethi etc. and would spend 3months in nomad wihtout his wife and children, and sometimes his wife would accompnay him, who wuz a nihung female.
so don't let these sites skew ur image plz
and wwe know the sites i refer 2
Re: Akal Takhat hukamnama
Sarbloh Badman · 08 Jul 2003
do u guys see the triyah charitrer and hakayat bani in dasam granth as authentic? what did bhai sahib say about it in his study? plez plez reply cuz no1 has ever answered that question.
Re: Akal Takhat hukamnama
Kulbir Singh · 08 Jul 2003
Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has never written anything on Triya Charitter or Hikayaat. I am not aware of his stand on these baanis. I don't think he was against it. If he had been against it, he would have made it known as he did in the case of Ragmala.
Maybe Master Jaswant Singh jee from Amritsar can shed light on this. What was Bhai Sahib's stand on the above stated baanis.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Akal Takhat hukamnama
singh khalsa · 09 Jul 2003
what is the Akal Takhat's stance on the Dasam Granth? I have heard that the Akal Takhat has accepted the Dasam Granth as written by the pen of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. Is this true ?
Re: Akal Takhat hukamnama
Kulbir Singh · 09 Jul 2003
I believe Akal Takhat Sahib believes that whole of Dasam Granth is Gurbani. In the late 70s Giani Bhag Singh was excommunicated from Panth for writing against Dasam Granth. I have that hukamnama at home.
I really think that the issue of Dasam Granth is a non-issue. They (chelas of Kala Afghana) keep saying that parkash of only Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee should be done and not that of Dasam Granth. But I ask them, who in panth does parkash of Dasam Granth? With the exception of some Nihungs and few Gurdwaras in Bihar and South India, people don't even know what Dasam Granth is.
By raising the issue of Dasam Granth, these pseudo-scholars are making this non-issue an issue. I don't see any Gurdwara doing katha of Triya Charitter or Hikayaat. No one talks about Chandi Charitter anywhere. Why are these people raising these issues then? I guess there are could be three reasons why they are doing so:
1) They are fools.
2) They have been paid by some anti-social elements to cause a rift in the Sikhs.
3) They are looking for an issue to get famous.
If nihungs are doing parkash of Dasam Granth, then why is Kala Afghana's stomach aching? Does he think that Nihungs are going to stop doing what they have been doing for long time, just by reading the writings of Kala Afghana? I guess no. Stop this futile exercise, Kala Afghana.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Akal Takhat hukamnama
singh khalsa · 09 Jul 2003
thank you very much for your post Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh Ji. it made a lot of sense and i agree 100%. Mehirvani tohadi.
WJKK WJKF