Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

bibekis and rolled oats

bibekis and rolled oats

question · 10 Jan 2005

i was wondering, are bibekis allowed to use rolled oats in cooking? They are steamed oats that have been rolled to flatten them so that when we re cook them they will cook easier, but are bibekis allowed to use them since they have been steamed and rolled beforehand?

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

singh · 10 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf depends who have rolled and steamed them , if it is done by amritdhari sikhs then thats ok, if not then no. vjkk vjkf

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

* · 11 Jan 2005

I had never previously questioned rolled oats, but I looked into it now and you're right -- they really ARE pre-steamed! I had no idea before. Anyways, with this new knowledge, I'd say that it doesn't seem in accordance with bibek to consume rolled oats anymore. Good-bye oatmeal cookies!! :'(

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

logical argument · 11 Jan 2005

There are very, very few foods out there which have not been handled/processed in one way or another by non-amritdharis. I fail to see the distinction between someone operating a machine to semi-prepare oats and someone operating the machine which milks cows and that person who operates the machine which adds vitamins to that milk and that person who then 'cooks'/pasteurizes the milk etc. If you're a sarbloh bibeki and you buy milk from the store, it is ridiculous to then argue against rolled oats and any number of other goods. If you want to be a TRUE sarbloh bibeki, you should be milking your own cow, which you also feed and take care of, and restrict yourself to only those foods which you grow yourself. Is this practical? For most people, probably not. But if you're going to make arguments restricting rolled oats, then you must immediately give up all foods which have any small amount of processing done. That's right - start grinding your own flour because there is some cigarette-smoking, meat-eating, non-amritdhari who operates the machine which harvests the wheat and then process the flour. Every dairy product you find in the store has been handled and processed to one degree or another so you must immediately stop consuming any and all dairy products from grocery stores. That's right, no milk for you.

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

A Singh · 11 Jan 2005

What if they were rolled by an Amrit Dhari, but were accidently touched by a non-amrit dhari? Does this now make this food unsuitable for a bibeki? If so, are we any worse than Brahmins?

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

* · 11 Jan 2005

I don't think the ROLLING of the oats is the problem. If there's going to be a problem with rolled oats, it'll be with the steaming process. Bibeki material/ingredients should be dry and previous uncooked. The processing of food materials is hard to avoid here (ie. flour is ground, milk is processed, almost everything is handled in some way or another). But they should generally not be pre-cooked. I don't know too much about this though, so hopefully more knowledgeable gursikhs will reply.

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

Singh · 11 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh There is a common saying "Excess of everything is bad". I think the same applies to keeping rehat as well. There is a very very thin line between what is rehat and what is baahmanvaad. Sarabloh Bibek rehat is not meant to make us Baahman. This rehat is to assist us in the prime important rehat of Naam Abhyaas Kamai. Same is true for all other physical rehat. When we start to go out of limits we end up just thinking about that stuff. Please answer a simple question. We all know that to a naam abhyaasi bhagat jan food doesn't matters. They eat or not makes no difference as "Akhand keertan Tin Bhojan Choora" and "Har naam hamara bhojan". But before we reach that stage we know this human body needs a solid and healthy diet. As this is temple of Akal Purakh. We have to look after this body. Now a Singh who has just started on path of naam kamai will need to eat food also. If this Singh has to think all the time what to eat and what not to eat. If this is bibeki or not or if that has been cooked or touched by non amritdhari is this now a big headache. Guru Sahib made us reject all superstitions. Food touched by non amritdhari cannot become brisht as food touched by a low caste can not become brisht. For a gursikh all are equal. Now on the other hand this does not mean that we are free to eat anything/everything. From anyone's hands. Sarabloh bibek is the rehat. That has to be followed. But with caution that we don't fall in the same ditch in which Guru Nanak Sahib saw al the pandats and mullahs. As a guru ka sikh, we should avoid all food that we doubt might have been prepared from hands of someone who is not tyaar bar tyaar. But as far as machine prepared stuff is concerned we have to apply common sense. There is a difference in the machine and a man. Machine will not be a bedeen. I have personally see three phases of rehat relating to food in my life and I will like to share the experience with all of you: By Guruji's kirpa I have been a pure vegetarian so far. 1. After getting pesh I kept the sarabloh bibek rehat. But used to eat things like packed dry food like buiscuits/cookies etc, cereals which are rolled, also used to accept degh/langar at Gurughar even if it was prepared by non amritdhari. Apart from that all time I kept sarabloh bibek rehat. This phase was good. But something was missing. Naam abhyaas was not giving that much anand. 2. Followed full sarabloh rehat and even stayed hungry for 2-3 days many times as nothing was available to eat. This phase was real chardhikala. Naam abhyaas gave too much anand. But then at a stage I went into phase of o someone touched it I will not eat. Someone touched my baata, now I cannot eat. And there again downfall started. I ended up being a baahman. Just rigidity in outward rehat with no inner peace. 3. I follow sarabloh bibek rehat, but if sometime I see some premi offering food with too much pyaar even if they r not tyaar bar tyaar I try to tell them that I can not accept. But if they still insist with prem I accept it. I can't refuse it. It tastes like amrit even if it is a bitter tasting papaya. Follow the rehat with prem. Prem for Guru sahib is no doubt above everything but to love his human beings is also like loving him. I am not saying that start eating from hands of everyother person but if once in life there is an option of selecting food from hands of a sweeper who is non amritdhari but is full of pyaar or from hands of a sarabloh bibeki who is full of hankaar and would refuse to marry his daughter to a low caste singh, I will accept the first option. I hope my words have not offended anyone. Daas is full of augun and hope gursikhs will discard my mistakes andpray for naamdaan for daas. Guru ke singhaan ki charan dhood lochda Ik nimaana singh

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

interesting · 11 Jan 2005

"Logical Argument" made some logical points I would be grateful if a Sarbloh Bibeki Veer/Bhaen explains the point at which they draw the line, particularly for us Singhs/Kaurs living in the West, as such a diet (i.e., milking your own cow and growing ALL your own fruits and vegs) would otherwise be very difficult; food in the West is always processed in some way or another, even if it is just to put it in packaging. More generally, could someone also explain the historical background and context of the Sarbloh Bibek Rehit, as I am not fully aware of what it entails and its justifications (even though I have some ideas). Please excuse my ignorance and thanks in advance mr curious singh

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

logical argument · 12 Jan 2005

I really liked your post Singh - some excellent points! But I think it becomes very hard to make the distinction between food prepared by man and food prepared by machine. What really is the difference if a man pours milk into a pot, heats it up (pasteurizes it) and then pours it into a bottle to be sold.....or, if he cleans and operates the machine which heats (pasteurizes) the raw milk and then operates the machine pouring milk into a bottle? I honestly feel these distinctions are little more than justification for accepting some foods and rejecting others. While I do not doubt what you have written re your own bhagti, it is entirely possible that the extra anand you felt came from the progression in your kamai and not from the extra strictness you applied to food selection. By all means, cook our food in sarbloh - it doesn't do any harm and actually adds iron to our meal content but when we're talking about grocery food selection, we're creating flimsy and, in my opinion, artificial distinctions to make ourselves feel better. If buying milk from the store is 'ok' then so is buying cereal made by machines, cookies made by machines, bread made by a machine.

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

kaur · 12 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf i know a sarabloh bibek singh. He gets his own milk from a cow. He gets his water from a spring in the hills (malverns) He makes his own bread, cheese and butter. He only eats from iron utensils He only eats from amrtidhari sikhs. Now that is being sarabloh bibek vjkk vjkf

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

P_Singh · 12 Jan 2005

Waheguroo Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguroo Ji Ki Fateh! Dear Sangat Ji, I haven't posted on this site for a LONG TIME now, although I visit daily... There is something which I've waited to bring up and this seems the ideal time... I'm interested in sarbloh rehat, BUT I think its unfair that people (i.e. on this site) talk about how you should keep this rehat for example...BUT NO ONE tells you HOW TO DO IT! For example, theres hardly any sarblohi singhs here where I live, so who could I go and ask about this rehat?? PLEASE...EVEN IF SOMEONE STARTS A NEW THREAD, IT WOULD BE GREAT! ATLEAST THEN YOU'D BE HELPING SOME PEOPLE OUT THERE THINK, IF NOT START TO KEEP SARBLOH REHAT! For e.g. are you allowed to buy milk from the store? IF NOT, how do you get around this???? I REALLY, REALLY HOPE THAT SOMEONE - ANYONE- takes up the seva of writing up practically, how one is to keep this rehat..... I'm really far away from keeping this rehat, but need to know- HOW!! Thanks... (PLEASE, don't start arguing about whether this is compulsary etc etc, just provide info on 'HOW' this rehat can be kept..) (",) SORRY if I've sounded harsh or said anything out of line...maaf karna...

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

J Singh · 12 Jan 2005

VJKK VJKF In my humble opinion, sarabloh is not a mandatory rehat for an amritdhari gursikh, and one should not look down upon other singhs who don't follow sarabloh bebik as being any less than the ones who do. I have observed many sarabloh discussions and they almost always end up at individual experiences, examples of some singh we admire, and questions like, "Why did Guru Sahib use Sarabloh to prepare amrit?" My answer is that Guru Sahib NEVER instructed us to use sarabloh alone and forsake all other material. For example clay pots have been used for centuries to prepare daal, milk, curd etc. Ask any old singh how they extracted makkan (butter) from curd and you shall have your answer to keeping strict sarabloh. I am sure that they have all seen daals being cooked all day in clay pots and water being kept cold in clay pots as well. Just a matter of what we choose to "believe". Bhul-chuk maaf karna ji VJKK VJKF

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

Mkhalsa · 13 Jan 2005

"machine made" is rarely actually "machine made" usually there is a LOT of human intervention. Anyone who has family members who watch food network as much as mine do would know this.

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

Singh · 13 Jan 2005

Guru ji's Hukam when a Sikh takes Amrit is not to have roti beti di sanjh with a non Amritdhari. From this I understand that a Sikh should only eat food prepared by an Amritdhari. As for Sarbloh, that's a separate issue. Keeping Bibek is not as hard as it may seem. It is possible to buy machines which make soya milk, bread, pasta etc. Everything can be made by your own hands. If you really want to do it, nothing will stand in your way. A friend of mine was fortunate that his Amritdhari Uncle in India even sent him some home ground flour!!! However, as a Bhaji said above, if someone offers you food even though they are non Amritdhari but have so much pyar its seems wrong to refuse to eat it...

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

Singh · 13 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh "logical argument ", I know what you are talking about. Man/Machine are two different things. Tell me very quickly, you know how bad Tobacco is considered in Sikhism. Most of the gurughar have special notice saying that it should not be brought inside the premises leave aside using it. If a person is smoking, holding a cigerette in one hand and pouring ingredients with the other hand, will u eat that thing even if it was prepared by machine. This is why I said earlier man/machine are different. Let me tell you a very clear fact. I have seen with my own eyes in India, so called famous pachranga achaars by so many factories are prepared by bhaiye, who consume liquor, are always chewing tobacco and smoke too much. They don't even wash hands after going to loo. Such people prepare these pickles, which everyone eats with so much taste. Most of the dry things / raw vegetables /pulses can be washed. Except milk almost everything is very easy to be used in sarabloh bibek rehat. Milk no doubt is difficult to get. Everyone cannot manage a cow. So this is where I said living in circumstances like these we should not be too much hard on these things. If we keep thinking about how to arrange cow and milk it then when will we do the simran. But equally important, we need to keep rehat. Any gursikh should strive to get better in keeping rehat day by day. We can not reach sachkand on first day of journey. But we can go step by step. This is where I talked about a singh who has just entred the sikhism fold. To him kamai of naam simran is most important. But so is keeping himself healthy by eating food. These are my personal thoughts and I can not claim myself to be a brahmgiani. I personally feel that progressing step by step on Sikhi path is a better approach rather then trying to do everything in one step. Jail Chithian mentions a very good incident. Bhai Sahib mentions that when he first got the Naam, he said that he will recite it all night and will not stop before getting the darshan. But he says that a stage came when he could not do it anymore. "Hath" is not answer to anything. Rehat is not being stubborn. "Hath na patije naa boh bhekhe" "Man hath kine na paaya kar upaav thake sabh koye" But on other hand "Rehat bina neh sikh akhaave, rehat bina dar chotaan khaavey" Remember the shabad "Pritham rehat yeh jaan khande ki pahul chake" Why was rehat numbered?? Why was it not said that before pahul, we should have been salabloh bibeki. So first pahul, then kakaars, then keep away from bajjar kurehts then comes rest of the rehat. You can not be a doctor the day you enter a medical college. Also you cannot be a doctor if you keep on saying I will not study, prepare for exams and become doctor as I have now entered the college. So we can only pray to Guru sahib bless us with naam simran kamai which inturn will give us strength to follow the rehat which in turn will help us do more naam simran and cycle goes on till we reach the ultimate. I lived all my life in India and there by Guru sahib's kirpa I never faced any problem for keeping sarabloh rehat. I came to West and am here for last 5 years now. Except milk and desi ghee, I have never faced any problem with keeping sarabloh rehat. Even if I have to go to remote areas for 2-3 days, where I know I will not be able to find anything to eat, I bake my own bread, prepare parshaade for 2 time from home, and keep some pinnian and dry fruit. Fruit and raw vegetable are avialble everywhere so I can prepare sandwich easily. It takes no hassle to do this. I never have to think about keeping the sarabloh rehat. Guru sahib keeps his kirpa. Its very easy. Remember if you are a non vegetarian, it will look like a hard life style when you see a vegetarian as many of my friends at work feel. They think how I survive on rabbit food. Similarly if you are non bibeki, it looks like a very difficult rehat. But remeber "Charan sharan gur ek penda jaaye chal, Satgur kot penda aage hoye let hain" Just move one step forward, and Guru sahib will come and help you move many steps further. Anand is no doubt by kamai, naam simran but remember a soldier no matter how much he parades, if he is wearing dirty uniform will not be liked by the officer. Khalsa is tyaar bar tyaar fauj of Akal Purakh. If a normal wordly soldier has to live in such tough discipline how can we expect to live with laziness. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji's Jail Chitthian is a true example of how a soldier lives in difficult times. But as far as I have known from Bhai Sahib's nitnemi and close singhs, he was not kattar. He kept sarabloh bibek rehat all his life but he was not rigid like a pandat. There are incidents from his life where he chose prem over kattarta. Bhul chuk di khima da jaachak

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

Rashminder Singh Oz · 16 Jan 2005

true said Singh Veerji, i liked ur post i know sarbhloh rehit is very important but to what extent? if someone touch the utensil by mistake, so how can we throw all the food in bin Vaheguru

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 16 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Imho, veer Singh Ji in his two posts above has explained things quite clearly. we can keep sarblohi bibek without bieng too Brahmanish and driving people away. Bhai Sahib ji kept his bibek in the Jail and very well too..not kattar as well..so should we. Use the Guur Given Intellect - budh bibek to keep food bibek. Jarnail Singh

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

theorist · 16 Jan 2005

I do not get the "if someone gives it to you with pyaar then you should take it" argument. How come we make a compromise with our bibek for this, but if someone gives us a chiken leg with pyaar, then we will not have it? If that person's real intention is through pyaar, then (s)he will understand when you politily say know and explain that dspite their sharda and respect, you cannot disobey your gurus hukam, they will totally understand.

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

. · 17 Jan 2005

How do you eat from only amritdari hands if your parents are not amritdari. And for me to cook all my own meals all the time would be really difficult.

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

Singh · 17 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh "theorist" veerji/bhenji, Tomorrow someone comes and tells you with "Prem" to smoke, will you smoke? Its not a question of compromising on these things. There are so omany times white people offer me to smoke. Is it their fault? They will do this because of ignorance. But its our duty to tell them that smoking is not what we will even think about and rather they should also give it up. Love demands respect. THEORY says that if someone offers you something with prem, if we can not accept it we should politely refuse it. Believe me if someone really has prem and shardha and if they offer you something to eat, when you try to convince them politely with prem that as a sarabloh bibeki you cannot accept that food, its 100% that premi will not force. Sometime there is an option to accept it and offer it to someone next. Modern day sarabloh bibek definition has changed. Most of us have become rude. We have become rigid. We try to act as brahmins. Showing others that we r sarabloh bibeki so their food is inferior and not acceptable. We will shout at someone non amritdhari if he touches our baata. This is where the problem has come in. Problem does not lies in the theory its the practical implementation where we have made it so difficult for a normal human being that people run away as soon as they hear they may have to keep sarabloh bibek rehat. Our parents have given birth to us. Today many parents still force things which we will say are anti gurmat. There are so many questions on these forums where queries are "My dad will not let me do my nitnem.... or I want to get married to gursikh but my dad insists on caste based non clean shaven...". Do we as gursikh really accept these things? Good parents don't force their edicts. Good parents only ask us to to do good things. We have to convince our parents that sarabloh bibek rehat is not going to take their son/daughter away from them. If we can convince them for so many other decisions of life, why can't we do this as well. Most of the times you will see in such circumstances, understanding parents will themselves adopt the rehat slowly as they see you progressing on the path. Where there is naam simran in home, the atmosphere itself becomes devine. This is the quality of naam and through naami, Guru changes so many things. Believe me if your environment is still not peaceful, if you have a house where paretns are still fighting and asking you to eat what they cook, there is still more need of naam kamai at your end. Keep rehat with love and humility, do naam abhyaas kamai with passion and words which come out of your mouth will make others realise that what you are saying is right. No one will force you to eat from their hand and no one will feel that you are acting as a rigid baahman. Bhul chuk di khima da jaachak Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

theorist · 17 Jan 2005

Singh bahji, what you said is exactly what I was trying to say, that you should not compromise on guru ji's rehit. If someone does get upset that you are not accepting their food, it is because their haumai has been hurt, but their real intention was out of pyaar, then they will totally understand.

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

Kulbir Singh · 17 Jan 2005

Rehit of Guru Sahib cannot be compromised for any reason. We don’t have the authority to change or alter or compromise on rehit. We got amrit of Guru Sahib only on the condition that we would keep rehit of Guru Sahib. Naam is daaroo (medicine) that would work only if sanjam or parhez of rehit is kept. A veer has written that he is usually a bibeki and a sarblohi but if someone offers him with love, he compromises on rehit and eats from that person. This veer is entitled to his views and can do as he pleases but I just want to mention that such actions are against Gurmat. Our biggest loyalty should lie with Guru Sahib and our love for Guru Sahib should surpass all other loves. For the love of a worldly person, how can we forsake or sacrifice love for Guru Sahib? Once this daas went to a city with other akj Singhs to attend kirtan program. At the place where we were staying, a bibi came and with a lot of bairaag started cajoling us to eat food from her. She was not wearing keski and had her hair dyed with henna (A Sikh who dyes hair is a tankhaaiya). While asking us to eat from her, she started crying too and sobbingly requested us to eat from her as she had prepared food with great love. Many in sangat were moved and we were put on spot as all eyes were on us. She was creating a scene. Then a Singh got up and with utmost humility asked her why she was not wearing a dastaar and if she had love, why she can’t keep rehit. She did not know what to say but kept insisting that sangat eat from her. With the exception of few bibekis, all the sangat ate from her and the bibekis slowly left the place to go out. We heard many Singhs were saying that Bibekis Singhs had hearts of stone. I don’t understand why people who don’t keep rehit want to force Singhs who keep rehit to eat food from them. If they have so much love, why can’t they keep rehit? They want to stay in manmatt and not only that but they also want Singhs who keep rehit to drop their rehit and adopt dhill (weakness) and eat from them. Such attitude is totally wrong. And the Bibeki Singhs who succumb to such pressure and give up their rehit are misled and wrong. Guru Sahib’s rehit cannot be compromised. [b] A Positive Story on Bibek [/b] A couple decided to keep bibek and stopped eating from outside. This gursikh bibi is very committed to rehit and was leading the couple in keeping rehit. At that point she only used to eat from her mother who did not used to wear a dastaar but was an amritdhari otherwise. One day Singhs visited her and she prepared samundar (hot milk) and served the Singhs in sarbloh. One of the elderly Singhs went to kitchen and asked that bibi if she was a bibeki gursikh i.e. did not eat from non-amritdharis and was tyaar bar tyaar otherwise(did nitnem, gave daswandh etc.). The bibi replied that she was a bibeki and did not eat from non-amritdharis. Singh asked her if she ate from her mother who did not wear a keski at that time. The Bibi’s heart sank at the thought that Singhs were not going to eat from her and she replied to the elderly singh that she did eat from her mother who did not wear a dastaar. Hearing this, the Singh said (with love and humility) that he would be unable to eat from her since she did not yet have bibek pehra. The bibi was desperate to serve the Singhs and thought that what good was her life if she could not serve Singhs. She thought for a moment and pleaded to the elderly singh that she would stop eating from her mother for the sake of Singhs but she could not bear the sight of Singhs leaving without eating. This bibi had great love for Singhs and wanted to serve gursikhs of Dashmesh jee at any cost. Singh jee smiled and said that it would be hard for her to not eat from her mother and her mother would get upset. He asked her not to bother for their sake but the bibi stayed firm and adamant. The elderly Singh thought for a moment and said that if she promised to keep rehit, then next time they come, they would eat from her. The bibi was a little disappointed but at the same time was happy to know that Singhs would eat from her next time. A few days later when the Singhs came again, that bibi could not contain her happiness. Every second seemed like a year to her. Such was her impatience in serving Singhs. The Singhs came and they already knew that this bibi had stopped eating from her mother. They too were delighted at the sacrifice of this bibi. Her parents were very upset with her and had stopped talking to her temporarily. The Singhs came and she served samundar with great love and Singhs drank samunder with equal love. Eventually, that bibi’s parents too became gursikhs. Now this is what I call love. What kind of love is this when bibiyaan want rehitvaan gursikhs to shed or drop their rehit and eat from them, when they themselves don’t want to keep rehit? Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

theorist · 18 Jan 2005

I think the above post was utterly perfect!!!

Re: bibekis and rolled oats

Tarrandeep Kaur · 18 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf KULBIR SINGH U R 100% RITE, CUDNT PUT IT ANY BETTER THEN WHAT U HAVE SED vjkk vjkf