Non-veg. in the Khalsa raj.
need clarity... · 07 Jan 2005
Waheguru ji ka kalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh,
I have been thinking over the past few days about the life within the khalsa raj. When all mankind will be under sikh rule.
At the present moment there are those that choose to kill animals for the consumption of there flesh, for no other reason other than that of taste, but then there are those who have no choice, to eat flesh, such as that of fish, sealions..etc, the tribes that live in those areas were vegitation pretty much does not exist. What will happen to these people....?
The bhuddists of tibet and china are typically non-vegeration too, even the Dali-lama prefers a non-veg diet, even though his kitchen caters for both alternatives...again, on the topic of 'jeev hathea' killing of innocent animals, were would we stand?
The more deeper i begin to go, the more the Bani on page 1289, regarding eating of meat/arguing if it is right or wrong, begins to lean towards non-veg...that one should not hold a value to either choice...but then Kabir sahib clearly argues for a vegetarian life style...
Would some of you very well read saghat members please ellaborate on what i am thinking?
Are we missing the boat on this whole issue, of meat. For those tribes, faiths that do not condemn meat, are they to be punished in the house of waheguru?
I must mention that i have been a vegetarian all my life...but i feel there may be a loop hole in our way of thinking, too narrow maybe?
Gurfateh,
Kulbir Singh Dhillon UK wala.
Re: Non-veg. in the Khalsa raj.
............... · 07 Jan 2005
Are u really Kulbir singh Dhillon, or is that a nakli nihang joke from our Uk wale?
Anyway, the Sikh raj was not exactly a good example of Gurmat, just read deeply into Maharaja Ranjit singhs escapades.
The more bani i read, the more I am convinced of vegetarianism. You mention the daliam lama, but there are just as many other non-sikh religious leaders that are openly vegeatarian. Even in America now fundamental Christians are openly pushing vegetarianism.
Not that it is relavant.
I think bani is very clearly non veg.
Re: Non-veg. in the Khalsa raj.
the real deal... · 07 Jan 2005
Yes i'm Kulbir Singh Dhillon, Uk wala, because someone might mistake me with my veer kulbir Singh, a sikh of Canada...
Re. Mahraja Ranjit Singh and his darbar, yes i'm well read on the build up to, and the escapades of his raj, but i was refering more to the khalsa rag we dream about, that is mentioned in our ardas....
Yes some other religious leaders are converting to a vegetarian lifestyle, but to be more specific, how about the ones that have really no choice...were do they fit into the picture? will they be excepted of asked to move further south were there is vegitation?
"RAG KERA GA KHALSA, AKHI RE NA KHOEE'.... THE REIGN OF THE PURE...
KULBIR SINGH DHILLON UK. WALA.
Re: Non-veg. in the Khalsa raj.
Mandeep Singh · 07 Jan 2005
this is a very tough and tenacious subject which i have given thought to and is a bit more complex than just a few tribes etc... i will at the moment just post a 'short' answer as to what i think a 'khalistan' state should perhaps enforce.
sikhism doesnt force its teachings on anyone though certain principles make certain actions, seen by some faiths and opinions as innocent, as crimes i.e. jeev hathia for example, we see killing animals (eating meat the same crime i guess - dont start a debate on this its not the main argument here - start another thread) as one of the 'big' crimes. basically, should we enforce a 'sikh law' onto non-followers ESPECIALLY when so many religions 'celebrate' in one form or another killing of animals either directly e.g. sacrificing a lamb (as Islam dictates and many OTHER tribes do), or indirectly e.g. Christmas turkeys or special meals with meat etc.... (i realise very quickly as i type that xmas turkeys is not what the religion dictates just tradition, not religion but nevertheless the point is made.....)
As a law student the fundamental issue in BASIC law is as such when prosecuting a person: to be proven guilty one must fulfill BOTH the actus reus (physical act that constitutes the crime) and the mens rea (the 'mental' element of the crime - intention, recklessness, gross negligence etc....). Now it would be easy to prove the actus reus - the person ate the meat or killed the animal. mens rea bit more difficult - did that person have the 'mental intention' in committing the crime? the answer it could be argued is NO (though 99% of cases the jury/judge/state will argue YES as OBJECTIVELY they DID have the intention to EAT/KILL the animal - forgetting the implications etc....). However, as argued in brackets they would be found guilty. HOWEVER, where there WOULD be a problem is under (under UK/EU Law and i guess under US Constitutional Law) Human Rights legislation and more specifically the FREEDOM TO EXPRESS ONE'S FAITH.
Anyways I have gone on quite long and probably lost interest by now and wont write the whole answer (there is no fixed answer and im probably rambling like a fool and so forgive me) and forgive me for not suggesting a proper solution - A khalistan state (if there is ever one - I dont really honestly support the idea of but nevertheless am open to debate and thought) would have to i guess go about the meat issue by either totally banning it (very difficult and as sikhs could mean that we are enforcing Sikhi on others) or by EDUCATING people about the meat issue and slowly implementing a ban (fines? etc...).
However, as many sikh scholar and great souls have said, if Khalistan/Sikh rule IS going to be established it is going to be with EVERYONE'S AGREEMENT AND HAPPINESS and THEREFORE you could then easily argue that we WOULD HAVE NO PROBLEM FOLLOWING GURU JI'S MARYADA and so wouldnt have to worry about tribes, human rights, economics etc... etc....
I tried promising in the beginning this would be a short answer and i hope that the above is of interesting reading. I think it is only the tip of the arguments and have thorougly enjoyed writing it especially as i feel my brain draining away in my GAP year as i work (no brain is used in my job - Sales Consultant at Travelex - i am a 'Cash Machine') and need an intellectual challenge (procrastinating about writing my book).
Bhul chuk maaf karni,
daas,
Mandeep Singh