Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

High avastha and mistakes

High avastha and mistakes

singh · 06 Jan 2005

Lately, I've been hearing a lot about sants and brahmgianees. Firstly, let me state that I believe that most of us aren't at the avasthaa to determine who a brahmgianee is and we should refrain from giving these labels. However, this doesn't mean that gursikhs can't reach very high avasthas. Of course they can. How high? Only they and god know. What I want to discuss is, if someone is of a very high spiritual avasthaa, are they then unquestionable and above making mistakes? I personally don't think so. Our guru's taught us many things and some of these things were taught using examples. One example comes to mind. Baba Atal. He was the son of Baba Gurditta and the grandson of Guru Hargobind Sahib Jee. Baba Atal himself was of a very high avastha as well. Were Baba Jee around today, he would be a super brahmgianee. The powers he had, todays babay can't even touch. He had the power to bring the dead back to life. Doing this of course, is against the will of god and against gurmat. Baba Jee was of a an unbelievable avastha and came from the guru's own family. However, baba jee, feeling sorry for someone, made a mistake and brought someone to life. For this, he had to pay with his life. A pooran gursikh like baba Atal jee made a mistake. Yes, a mistake. Yet, todays gursikhs think that the 'sants' of today are above making mistakes. Even the mention of a mistake next to the name of a well known 'sant' will cause all hell to break loose. We need to get over this and realise that only Guru Jee is above mistakes. Everyone else can be wrong. There are more examples as well from the guru's time. We should learn from these lessons that the guru's taught us.

Re: High avastha and mistakes

Bundha · 06 Jan 2005

Singh, totally totally agree with you....................

Re: High avastha and mistakes

UkSingh · 06 Jan 2005

I agree i was thinking about this the other day too no matter how high we think someone is, no one is perfect on this earth, as a perfect person would have become one with Waheguru and be out of the lives and births cycle. Everyone can make mistakes well that's my current understanding, maybe I am wrong.

Re: High avastha and mistakes

Search For Tat · 06 Jan 2005

I totally agree with you singh ji.

Re: High avastha and mistakes

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 06 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. EXACTLY singh veer ji. Thats all we want to put forward...sometimes we have to use harsh words to get the message across..because there are just too many "apologists" out there who constantly harp on just:" no ninda please, sant ke ninda this and that... What I want to reiterate is since when does the questioning of a brahmgiani title to a simple GURSIKH constitute NINDA ? Ninda is talking "bad" FALSELY and Without proof..about someone's character..not saying a so called brahmgiani/sant is not one/ or one ?? ALL Sikhs should only rely on GURU JI who is the only one ABHULL--NO one else. NO other HUMAN shoudl occupy this ABHULL pedestal...the Christaians put the POPE on this pedestal.....and that makes our own small time granthis turned jathedars to try and become "pope of Sikhs".. Bhul Chuk Maaf Manjit kaur

Re: High avastha and mistakes

kaur · 06 Jan 2005

Good post - I agree - ppl with high avastha may make mistakes, although the higher the avasthaa reaches, the less likely they are to make mistakes. But us moorakhs are not in an ideal position to judge other ppl's avasthaa. Although we can guess from the inspiration that we get from them to follow Guru Jee. Those Singhs/Kaurs with high avasthaa, we should treat them with respect and hopefully learn off them. but we shouldn't start worshipping them. in any case, singhs/kaurs with real high avasthaa would only direct us towards Guru Jee. It is Guru Jee who is our Guide/Teacher, but the high avasthaa Singhs/Kaurs provide us with Sangat and inspiration/examples on how to lead a Gursikhi life. Bhul Chuk Maaf _/\_ Waheguru

Re: High avastha and mistakes

Bundha · 06 Jan 2005

Just like to say that my previous reply was doctored/cut short by Admin (there wa no bad language etc) . [b]Admin Note: Bundha jee, your message was deleted because it attacked someone else posting on this forum for no reason. Such personal attacks or unnecessary sarcastic jokes will not be entertained on this forum. You are a valuable contributor on this forum and we appreciate that but we are trying to weed out meaningless posts. In this process of this weeding out unnecessary posts, many posts are not approved. Sorry for any inconvenience. No debate on this note please [/b]

Re: High avastha and mistakes

amarjeet singh · 06 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf i disagree, you contradict urself, u say that only god is perfect, well i agree and this quote 'barahm gi-aanee aap nirankaar' shows tht a true brahmgi-annee is himself god so he is perfect vjkk vjkf

Re: High avastha and mistakes

.... · 06 Jan 2005

There comes a time as well when you become [b]one[/b] with God and everything that you do is within bhana!! And I don't understand what these people keep on saying super brahmgiani, bigger brahmgiani. A brahmgiani is one with God; how can you make something like that bigger or smaller? BrahmGiani Aap Parmeshar!! An example could be the life that Sant Jarnail Singh lived. People can critisize and say what is a sant doing with political ideas while in reality everything that Sant Ji did was because of a direct hukam from Guru Gobind Singh Ji!!

Re: High avastha and mistakes

Jagjitsingh · 06 Jan 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, i have all the respect in the world for high awastaa Gursikhs. We, youth, discuss Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh, Baba Jarnial Singh ji, Baba Attar singh ji and others. But I think the example above of Baba Atal ji is excellent. Which bhramgiani is Aap Paremeshar. Surely that is our 10 Guru Sahibaan themselves. They were the true bhramgianis. It is about them that we can clearly state they were perfect. Bani states, everyones makes mistakes, but only the Guru is perfect. Many Gursikhs could have been Gurus. For example Baba Buddha Ji. He was so blessed, that he gave the Guruship to our Guru sahibaan. Surely he could have been a Guru. He was much higher than any calling themselves a bhramgiani today. But the reality was he did not, he was not worthy. Only the 10 Sahibaan were. He must have made some mistakes, even though he had every Gursikh virtue in him. He was perfect in his virtues, but only the Guru is the perfect being. Many of our high avastha gursikhs, I believe are perfect in their virtues, and their jeevans are ideal reflections of Gurmat. But the Perfect Being was Sahib Siri Gobind Singh ji, and our other Guru Sahibaan. As Gursikhs we should be sensible enough, to realise the words Bhramgiani Aap Parmeshar should only be used for them. Otherwise we shall some day feel disappointed in those we hold at this level. The fundamental truth always reveals itself, and I believe recent events show this. It may hurt for those who feel this, but we should move on and realise on Guru sahibaan and Gurbani are perfect. If we put pporan faith in Gurbani alone, we will never be let down or disappointed. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: High avastha and mistakes

.... · 07 Jan 2005

What do you mean by high avastha? There might be a some higher avastha where a mistake can be made, but not when the person has merged with Akal Purkh. Then it is God that does all of the actions through the person, and God does not err.

Re: High avastha and mistakes

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 07 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. How correct veer jagjit Singh Ji. Out of so many worthy Gurmukhs, Guru ji chose Bhai Lehna Ji to be GURU ANGAD Ji...Bhai Buddha Ji had been known to to Guru Nnak Ji from the age of 5, and he was in the service of the Sikh Gurus until the Sixth Guru.... that means Baba Buddha Ji "missed" Five chances of being chosen "Guru"..at some stage he was even older than the Gurus he was annointing.. But precisely because the Brahmgianis of that Time knew their own worth, not one consented or was called so by other Gurmukhs...unlike today where there is now a race to invent super duper titles to distinguish ones self from other brahmgianais.. A SIKH is duty bound to rely only on the GURU GRANTH JI to provide him/her illumination..depending upon another human no matter how high avastha, is blasphemy..to say the least. We love to quote Gurbani..Brahmgiani AAp parmeshar..little do we realise that ONLY GURU JI knew exactly what this phrase actually means..GURU JI had to use the "limited" potential of human language/vocabulary to express such high avastha thoughts...and then to compound the problem, we humans are further limited by our own understanding of such terms..we tend to bring it all down to our own level of understanding..what we must try to do is Rely on GURU Ji's Kirpa to UPLIFT our own AVASTHA higher to "understand" Gurbani....but since that is too difficult..we take the easy way out and "bring" gurbani "DOWN" to our low levels....and there is where we stumble into the pit. Thank you for a refreshing insight. Jarnail Singh

Re: High avastha and mistakes

singh · 07 Jan 2005

>>What do you mean by high avastha? There might be a some higher avastha where a mistake can be made, but not when the person has merged with Akal Purkh. Then it is God that does all of the actions through the person, and God does not err.<< Hmm... perhaps. But, how do you know if someone has reached this level? Everyone claims that the one they affiliate with has reached this level. How do you know for sure? Is it then right for us to make these claims if we can't be sure? Would it not be better to simply treat high avastha gursikhs with respect, like gursikhs and not like we would our gurus? If a gursikh at that level can't be wrong... well maybe, I don't know... but we, the ones acting as the followers, the chelay, we aren't at that level and can surely be wrong in our judgement. We can't be sure about the level of someone's avastha. So why not reserve that unquestioning faith for our gurus and no other being? That way, we can't go wrong.

Re: High avastha and mistakes

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 07 Jan 2005

What is so lacking in our GURUS that we cant leave everything to them ? why must we seek out humans...no matter how high avastha..they are still humans..how can a person trust a human guide compared to GURU JI ?? I have reached 76 years of age with 7 children, and 29 grandchildren and 12 great grandchildren...and GURU JI has NEVER failed to guide me in my time of tribulations...and beleive me I have passed through so many ( one of them was learning how to use the computer to try and do my share of propogating sikhi as i have lived it..and how i struggled with my four year old laughing at grandma !!..but i persevered and now i am doing the guru's work )..When I see the hundreds of youths chanting after babays abd brahmgianis just like sheep being led to slaughter...i just cant understand this "death wish"..yes its Spiritual death going after the wrong brahmgiani !!! About 45 years ago at a great trying time when my hubby and me were both jobless, our house had no atta,rice,sugar etc. My hubby came back from the local Gurdwara and told me, there was a "sant ji" who would be visiting our house to have parshada under Panj Piyarae !!..I prayed to GURU Ji to save our honour.... the Sant never turned up with his jatha..but i received a job offer to start the very next day.... we never wanted from that day..it was the lowest point of our life...but we have nevewr looked back since GURU JI is in front of us all the time. manjit kaur

Re: High avastha and mistakes

perhaps · 07 Jan 2005

perhaps you are saying something that makes sense. i do not know, only the Guru knows. I can only say that when you meet true gursikhs, it is proper to be a daas and humbly bow down to feet! like in the time for Bhai Randhir Singh i dont know how the sangat would treat bhai sahib as i cannot recall any memory of that time and i do not know what i was doing then only God knows. In conclusion, I would like to point out that if I met someone like Bhai Randhir Singh I would try to show as much humility as possible.

Re: High avastha and mistakes

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 07 Jan 2005

dear perhaps ji, I would to. Humility is the virtue that GURU Arjun Ji taught us.. manjit kaur

Re: High avastha and mistakes

jagroop singh · 07 Jan 2005

VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh! Veer/Bhain 'perhaps' ji, You wrote: 'like in the time for Bhai Randhir Singh i don't know how the sangat would treat bhai sahib as i cannot recall any memory of that time and i do not know what i was doing then only God knows. In conclusion, I would like to point out that if I met someone like Bhai Randhir Singh I would try to show as much humility as possible.' ...and Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh would try to stop you from doing so which is the hallmark of a GurMukh. Bhai Sahib once knew that a particulary humble young GurSikh was going to try and touch his feet and because of this, he went and stood in some water to prevent this from happening before it occurred. The GurSikh jumped into the water nonetheless and tried to touch his feet! From this, i learnt that: - Real GurMukhs do not want personal attention and adoration and actively try to avoid the circumstances within which it can occur whilst continuing with the Seva they are blessed with. - GurMukhs deserve our respect and SatKaar and sometimes we may want to humble ourselves before them physically but the question is, if we keep these feelings inside, they increase and take the form of Love which eventually always recognises Siree Guru Sahib's face in the faces of GurMukhs...after all, Siree Guru Sahib is The Love of Loves. i personally believe that Siree Guru Sahib Ji blesses us with more Kirpa if we use this approach. Try just 'imagining' that you are touching the feet of the Ucha Avastha-Waala Singhs and Singhnian you meet...instead of actually doing so. In fact, imagine you are touching the feet of strangers who you see during your daily life...the feet of those who want to hurt you or speak ill of you. Keep begging to be the dust which settles under the feet of everyone...not just the GurMukhs. i think this will bring you closer to Siree Guru Sahib Ji. In fact, Siree Guru Sahib Ji will do Kirpa, if it is His Will, and bless you with even more interaction with Ucha Avastha Waala GurSikhs! i firmly believe that reserving selective shows of physical SaatKaar towards specific 'Sant/Babas' takes us away from GurMat. Bhul chuk maaf karna jio. VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!

Re: High avastha and mistakes

random singh · 08 Jan 2005

Guru Ji says it best from his own word of THE TRUEST BHRAMYGYIANI SACHE PATSHAH SRI GURU NANAK DEV SAHIB JI bhullan andar sabh ko abhull Guru Kartar Everyone makes mistakes; only the Guru and the Creator are infallible.

Re: High avastha and mistakes

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 08 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. bravo veer jagroop Singh Ji. My sentiments exactly. I try to do that in my mind and let me tell you it really works....GURU JI takes the place of the one you LOVE...slowly but surely. Good advice. Works like a charm. Drop the Dekhawa...people like this dekahawa buisness....it cuts both ways. For example in full sangat i do the ususal matha tek...but in private with my Guru Ji, i do full dandout/nakk raggar as long as i like/love flows out of my heart. IF I were to do this in snagat... I will hold up the line of matha tekars unnecessarily, provoke some, create bad feelings in others, haumaii in me etc etc. This same hold true of respect given to sants/baabas..if the sangat would keep it private ( in their hearts) it would be wonderful..matha tek only to GURU JI. Jarnail singh