Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Is it okay to use force

Is it okay to use force

sukha · 05 Jan 2005

a friend of mine is of opinion that if required husband should use physical force to bring his wife under control. he thinks that women need to be told what to do and if you don't keep control on them, they can cause major damage to the family. he gives many historical examples to prove his point. he gives his own example saying that sometimes he has to "fix" his wive. he says that if he relaxes wth his wife and shows her too much luv, she goes nuts. she has to be brought on earth periodically. i donno too much about sikh faiht. i do see a lot of my elders doing what he is saying.

Re: Is it okay to use force

Manmat · 05 Jan 2005

thats not gurmat marriage. such a thing is manmat. a singhni should beat down her husband with a lathi if he tries 2 own her :) marriage is a symbiotic relationship. not a muslim/old casteist, punjabi style "man dominates over woman" relationship.

Re: Is it okay to use force

amar singh · 05 Jan 2005

vjkk vjkf if a woman is being mistreated she should ensure her husband is battered and if not someone else should ensure this vjkk vjkf

Re: Is it okay to use force

Singhstah · 05 Jan 2005

is u'r friend on drugs

Re: Is it okay to use force

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 06 Jan 2005

Sikhi has no place for such advise,where a man thinks it is his intrinsic right to keep a female down,beat her etc.THAT IS MORALLY WRONG AND ANTI SIKH GURMAT. No man should have to resort to such methods.However should a disagreement happen ,both the spouses should sit down like friends and discuss it as according to GURMAT if that helps,otherwise like a civilised humans, discuss and agree to to respect each other. No one human being can own another. How many Sikhs will understand that the more they try to assert ,the more further one will drive the person they are tying to assert upon.It is natural human reaction. If they have no clue how to approach,then take a hukam from Gurbani ,and think it over.9.99% of the time by the time one readsa nad ponders over the Gurbani tuk, senses prevail and the man can think cooly and calm and collectively. I shall not go into Gurbani too much here,but men that behave and try such intimidating approaches towards women are nothing but little failed hitlers in their lives. A sincere,genuine gentleman of a Sikh walking with confidence and the belive in his Guru need not use such bullying tactics to "control" women.The moment a man feels he has to "control" a women,I can assure that is no more a man. A man in harmony with a partner does NOT need to "control".Only control freaks use such tactics.Often becaue they themselves are not in control of their own lives. Men Control your haume,and life is far sweeter when in partnership with your partner you walk the road to Guru Ji.NO IT IS NOT OK TO USE FORCE AGAINST WOMEN. WJKK WJKF

Re: Is it okay to use force

Manpreet Kaur · 06 Jan 2005

I've seen this many times too. Those husbands need some SERIOUS HELP. I believe near the end of asa di vaar it says stuff about how kings are born from women. Something along those lines. If someone can post them. Sikhi has a high status of women. No lower than men. A sighni with a husband like that needs to be beat up with a velna, tied up and slapped around for everytime he speaks and see how it feels. Im glad we got good Singh veers who have adopted to Sikhi and left this muslim punjabi male dominated thing far away.

Re: Is it okay to use force

Gerk · 06 Jan 2005

You are either joking or 12 year old, I don't know which one yet.

Re: Is it okay to use force

Kamal · 07 Jan 2005

Does your friend believe that obedience to him is the only way to run his family? We only serve obedience to WaheGuru. How can one person treat another in a way that demeens them. It only causes actions that result in the oppressed looking for alternatives in, love and belief. As all posts on this forum have stated it not Sikhi to deny somebody their right to vent their feelings or beliefs. Sikhi is stronger today because of our acceptance belief that others may express themselves. We may not agree with them and we may have strong arguments to their contrary, however only WaheGuruJi can judge us.

Re: Is it okay to use force

Dil · 07 Jan 2005

VJKK,VJKF; I came accross some references from quran, where woman is treated as a slave and child bearing machine only. To control wives, husband can use force and even can desert her for some time. If still woman is not correting herself the she can be beaten with with a stick. Complete detail is given in Quran, as I heard fro some muslim friends. In sikhism woman is given equal status as man. It should be condemed at all levels. VJKK.VGJKF;

Re: Is it okay to use force

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 07 Jan 2005

send the sicko to my house. although 76 nearing 77 next week i will give him a taste of Guru Gobind Singh Ji's daughter Manjit kaur

Re: Is it okay to use force

Tony Singhprano · 07 Jan 2005

what do you tell your wife, who has 2 black eyes nothing ...... you already told her twice the above statement is only a commentary and does not reflect my personal views. its sad cause its true Tony Singhprano

Re: Is it okay to use force

Jagjitsingh · 07 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ke khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, a gurmat marriage is where both mutually respect each other, and do seva and bhagtee together while living in Grist. As both follow gurmat and do abyass nirmata is always there. Neither is higher or lower, both are the same as two bodies with one soul. waheguru ji ke khalsa waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Is it okay to use force

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 08 Jan 2005

dear Tony Ji, MY WIFE has two BLACK EYES.... all the time. No fault of mine though...she was born with them. jarnail singh