Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Kulbir Singh · 31 Dec 2004

Sadh Sangat jeeo, Vaheguru jee ka Khalsa Vaheguru jee kee fateh!! During our visit to Takhat Siri Patna Sahib on December 13-14, we also went for darshan of Gurdwara Bala Pritam Sahib, which is within walking distance from Takhat Siri Patna Sahib. This is the place, where Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj used to give darshan to the queen who had no child of her own. She loved Siri Guru jee as her own child. While visiting Bala Pritam Sahib, we found out from the Granthi Singh there that there is an old Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee’s bir with Siri Guru jee’s signature on it kept in that Gurdwara Sahib. Naturally we got very excited and requested the Granthi Singh to let us have darshan but he did not agree and flatly refused to let us have darshan. He said that he has strict orders from the committee to not allow anyone to have darshan of this bir as it was very old. We got very disheartened after hearing the negative response from the Granthi Singh. I was determined to get darshan of this saroop as I wanted to see signature of Guru Sahib and also wanted to see if it had Raagmala in it. The Granthi Singh told me before-hand that this saroop did have Raagmala in it. This statement from him did not shake me at all because I am of the firm belief that Raagmala is not baani of Guru Sahib and someone added it at a later date. I knew that there must be some explanation behind Raagmala in this saroop. By the kirpa of Guru Sahib, I found out good explanations behind it. I earnestly pleaded with the Granthi Singh to let us have darshan of this saroop and secretly I was doing ardaas before Guru Sahib too to allow us to have his darshan. After much cajoling the Granthi Singh agreed to allow us to have darshan of this saroop. We excitingly followed the Granth Singh who did ardaas before Guru Sahib for parkash. After parkash he showed us the signatures of Guru Sahib (I think it was 8th or 9th Guru). Guru Sahib had written Mool Mantra (from Ik Oankaar to Gurprasaad). It was a beautiful sight. On the right handside (the right ang) were signatures of Guru Sahib and on the left ang (page) was the last page of Tatkara (table of contents). I noticed that there was no mention of Raagmala in the Tatkara. This thing struck me very much because if Raagmala had been there in the original writing, it would have been mentioned in the Tatkara too. The handwriting was absolutely magnificent. We read many shabads in it as we scrolled towards the end. The Granth Singh then opened the last ang (page) and there was really Raagmala there. We read Raagmala and also took pictures. I asked him to turn one page back and there I was expecting to see Mundawani but there was Ratanmaala before Raagmala. Then there were a bunch of other baanis before Raagmala, starting with one Salok Mahalla Pehla: Jit Dar Lakh Mohammada”. Also, it appeared to me that the handwriting of the last few angs did not match with the rest of the Saroop. To be sure, more research is required. The irony is that all these other baanis e.g. Ratanmala, Salok Mahalla Pehla: Jit Dar Lakh Mohammada” etc have been removed from Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee after declaring them Kachi Baani (false baani). Then how can Raagmala, that is written after these kachi Baanis, be real Baani? Something for my pro-Raagmala veers to consider. I will post pictures of this saroop on this site very soon. Hopefully, my pro-Raagmala veers and bhains will not take this negatively and will discuss this in a serene manner. We should not fail to understand that both sides whether anti-Raagmala or Pro-Raagmala, have good intentions only. To accuse the other side of malice or manmatt is purely manmatt and anti-Gurmat stance. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Premi · 31 Dec 2004

The thing is that this goes both ways. There are old saroops that have Ragmalla in them that are really old and also have them in the Tatkara. I remember a Baba that stayed with the Sant Gurbachan Singh, said once that they went out looking for the original saroop that was given guruship. He was saying when they founf that saroop in some pind in India. They to were looking for Ragmalla to end the debate in there minds. When they saw the sarrop they asked the people taking care of it if it had raagmalla, they said that Teja Singh Bhasoriaa had requested to have it's Darshan when he saw it had Raagmalla he to out a small knife and ripped it out of the saroop. So they too were upset that it had not Raagmalla. So they were about to do Sukhasan and one Singh said that we have not checked the Tatkara and sure enough it had Raagmalla in it. So I mean it goes both ways there are saroops with and without it. I think the sarbatt Khalsa nees to come to a decision on this. It was Baba Hari Singh from Randhava that said this during Katha once. He was actually there when they went to see the old saroop

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Harbhajan Singh · 31 Dec 2004

Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!!! As Bhai Kulbir Singh has asked that this discussion be taken seriously and conducted in a serene manner I would like to ask 'Premi' where he got the fairytale of Teja Singh Bhasoriaa, If this is true then forgive me but if it has been passed down by ear then that statement is not taking this discussion seriously. I have had many discussions with pro-raagmalaa gursikhs in which they bring Teja Singh Bhasoriaa into the discussion like it is there only wepon against Jatha. For your information Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Jee did not talk to Teja Singh after he was discommunicated from the panth. So the connection ends there. Also cutting Raagmalaa out of old saroops is like saying a well known organisation was known to have burnt saroops with no raagmalaa in them. Whats the point???? Have the discussion on Raagmalaa itself and not stories. Can anyone also advise why no one has actually come out and pointed out the distorted history in the Mundavani book and also why claims against Raagmalaa in the Mundavani book have not been challenged. If a so called RSS Jathedar tries to exclude someone from the Panth the they should have the brains to come out and challenge the statements in the book. Many times Pro-Raagmalaa Gursikhs have tried to challenge the stand of Anti-raagmalaa Gursikhs with Fairytales, threats, tiny anomolies in any bani they can find which can be aligned to the same numbering system in raagmalaa. But they so far cannot answer these two questions below. I wish some learned Gursikh will try to make a decent effort which has some logical and common sense in the answer. 1. Gurbani was written so that if read with a true heart, sould and mind, a spiritual connection can mature within oneself in which Waheguru can be realised. Where is the spiritual content in Raagmalaa? please give examples which can lead the unconvinced into the light!!! 2. Mundavani is the seal of Guru Sahib? Right!!! If Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee Maharhaj compiled the Sri Guru Granth Sahib then when adding Sri Gru Tegh Bahadur Jee's Bani did he add Mundavani after Sri Guru tegh Bahadur jee's Bani was placed in all the relevant places in the logical order in which the original Adi Granth was compiled. If Raagmalaa was bani then why not include it within the structure of the Gurbani and then show that Raagmalaa is Bani of Guru Jee. Please answer the above? I also wish this DISCUSSION to be taken seriously. So please answer the questions. Bhul Chuk Marf Karna. Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!!!

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Bijla Singh · 01 Jan 2005

here we go again. discussion of "facts" and "fairy tales". lets see how "serious" this discussion gets. Guru Rakha.

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Rain drop · 01 Jan 2005

"The thing is that this goes both ways. There are old saroops that have Ragmalla in them that are really old and also have them in the Tatkara." Dear Premi Veer Ji According to the "logic", a single Saroop without Ragmalla effects the debate much more than many Saroops with Ragmalla. Why the writer missed Ragmalla is difficult to explain, but why they had written it, is simple to understand.

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 01 Jan 2005

Rain Drop Ji above has hit the nail right. NO Premi Sikh Copying the GURU GRANTH JI would dare to REMOVE any bani..so the Fact that MANY Birs exist WITHOUT RAAGMALA weighs in More heavily than those with additions... SGPC in its Rehat maryada also had to PUT it in Wriitng: NO ONE SHOULD DARE TP PRINT a SROOP of GURU GRANTH JI .."WITHOUT" Raagmala...they DID NOT HAVE to say: DONT PRINT A SROOP "WITH" ADDITIONAL banis... This proves that "adding" was not and is still not such a big "crime".... BUT DELETING/REMOVING was and is still a CRIME... Its the Birs of Guru granth WITHOUT RAAGMALA that are therefoe authentic..and those that have it added were prepared aby spurious copiers....because there are also sroops with MORE than Raagmala as Kulbir singh ji has seen with his own eyes. The comment about Teja singh Bhasauria is correct. After he was excommunicated Bhai sahib bhai randheer Singh ji didnt even look at him..so its pointless bringing him into this argument. jarnail Singh

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Singh · 01 Jan 2005

Well said Rain Drop!

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Singhstah · 01 Jan 2005

This old debate is just so stupid, instead of just thinking about wether ragmalla is bani or not all day lets think about the rest of Guroo Sahibs angs and follow them.

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Nehlay par dehla · 01 Jan 2005

Singhstah, this is a good way of diverting attention from the issue. When you can't answer a question, it is clever to say something like what you have written. Let us hear from ragmala supporters. What do they have to say in response to what kulbir singh, raindrop, giani jarnail singh and harbhajan singh wrote? stop threatening and give some real answers.

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

spectator · 01 Jan 2005

The thing that convinced me that raagmala is not bani, is because it comes after other compositions which all the Panth including sants and DT accepted as not being bani. Compositions such as Rattan mala. Bhai Kulbir singh has pointed out this out again. No pro-raagmalia has ever been able to state how a raagmala supposedly written by Guru Sahib can come after compositions that they all accept as not Gurbani. This completely proves that additions were made and raagmala is one of them.

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Gurpreet Singh · 02 Jan 2005

"Guru Sahib had written Mool Mantra (from Ik Oankaar to Gurprasaad)" Was the mool mantar written seperately?????? and was only from Ik Oankarr to Gurprasad?????? can u post pictures?

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Gerk · 02 Jan 2005

Off-topic question: Anyone want to give a quick summery of the contents of Raggmala?

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Singhstah · 02 Jan 2005

Actually i'm AGAINST ragmalla as bani so i didnt make my post to "divert" attention from the issue because i cant think of an answer, i made my post because i'm fed up of fighting between the akj and taksal who are both extremly panthic. Nehlay par dehla wrote: > Singhstah, this is a good way of diverting attention from the > issue. When you can't answer a question, it is clever to say > something like what you have written. > > Let us hear from ragmala supporters. What do they have to say > in response to what kulbir singh, raindrop, giani jarnail singh > and harbhajan singh wrote? > > stop threatening and give some real answers.

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

ns · 02 Jan 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Kulbir Singh mentions: "We should not fail to understand that both sides whether anti-Raagmala or Pro-Raagmala, have good intentions only. To accuse the other side of malice or manmatt is purely manmatt and anti-Gurmat stance" I couldn't agree more, but isnt' it also a fact that the panth had done ardass at Akal Takht many years ago to end this debate. And hukamnama which Guru Ji gave , the interpetation of it was read it or don't read doens't matter. My question is why waste energy on something which is an IVORY tower debate when we load of other challanges to handle. I 'm sure Gursikhs are well aware of which challanges and I can mention a few when or if you get tired of this debate.. This and a few other debates remind me of the following quote from a famous philosopher ‘We cannot have facts without thinking but we cannot have thinking without the facts’. Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

kaur 12123 · 02 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh i agree that we should not fight abt this or even debate abt it. it is only splitting the sikh community even more. personally i think we cannot be 100% sure so let us not goagainst Ragmaala either as if that is part of Guru Ji sroop then it is really bad that we deny it of that status and if the hukam says it doesnt make a difference either way then y not just forget abt the debate. bhul chuk maaf Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 04 Jan 2005

Bhen kaur 12123 Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Both sides are very passionate about their viewpoints..."fight"/"argue" etc wont solve anything. Personally for me I dont beleive ragmala is bani and never will..and it must be the same for some in the other camp. The Singhs who made the 1930 Maryada with an option on raagmala must have been thinking along the same lineas as you bhen ji...BUT 75 yeras later the SAME DIVIDE still EXISTS....no amount of "just keep quiet"/"dont argue"/"dont fight"/"forget it"/ etc etc is going to make this problem go away... the GURU KHALSA PANTH MUST DECIDE one way or the other..this festering cancer of doubt must be removed once and for all before we begin to lose faith even in the system...tomorrow the divide may be so much more entrenched the Guru khalsa panth decision may not be acceptable to all...Sweeping dirt under the carpet was never a good decision...not 75 years ago and not now and not 75 years in the future. Jarnail Singh

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Harpartap Singh · 04 Jan 2005

VahegurujikaKhalsa, vahegurujikiFateh! Bhai Kulbir Singh ji, If you are aware of the history of this particular saroop you had darshan of, please could you provide it i.e. a sakhi surrounding when it came to be compiled. Also any indication of the date of this saroop? Thanks in advance

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Harpartap Singh · 06 Jan 2005

Any comment Bhai Sahib? You must have some indication about the origins of the saroop you had darshan of???

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

AKJ SINGH 4 LIFE · 06 Jan 2005

way 2 go against hukumn of siri akaal takht sahib guys! no discussions of such matter allowed as to keep panthik etka

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

Jagjit singh · 06 Jan 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh The Akal thakht as far as i know has not made a hukamnama on this, but Joginder singh vedanti made that statement. But surely this should be followed by the Jathedars themselves. The Patna Sahib jathedar has been making statements and even giving tankayas. This is especially suspicious when Iqbal singh himself was against raagmala, and he and vedanti were present during the research. A picture in the Mudhavanee book clearly shows this. This whole affair is his persoanl vendatta against Giani Gurdit singh and vedanti. Both Vedanti and Iqbal singh have shown their characters to be dubious in this affair. First denying their links to the book, which are clearly documented. Then Iqbal singh claiming Vedanti threatened to kill him. Now both them being best buds, thanks to Badal, and putting Giani Gurdit singh on the chopping block. Upon questioning by senior scholars and Gursikhs in India. A new twist now emerges. When scholars and Gursikhs have asked Iqbal singh and vedanti to disprove the contents of the book. They say they cannot. So why the Peshi on 8th jan? Suddenly now the Peshi is because Giani Gurdit singh gave a siropa to Kala Afghani. An allegation which has not been proved at all. In fact very dubious since Giani Gurdit singh was one of the singhs in the Dharam parchaar Committee to ex-communicate Kala Afghani. Is this another jathedar playing fictitous word games, like Iqbal singh so called threats to kill him? So we have a peshi on 8th jan, which is a face saving stunt by Vedanti and Iqbal singh. Giani Gurdit singh is put to the chop, and his book though completely factual is indirectly having a question mark put on it. Further 2 jathedars who will judge Giani Gurdit singh and his following of Akal Thakht maryada, are people those who openly do not follow it themselves. So how can they be in the Punj. They are Iqbal singh, Patna Sahib jathedar and Hazoor sahib jathedar. Both are gross violators of this maryada. Iqbal singh at Yuba city openly said when questioned on langar maryada, that the Akal Thakht maryada does not apply to him. Surely it applies to every sikh. I think Panthik thinking and blantant honestly needs to be shown by Jathedars first before they can honestly expect the Panth to respect them, and respect their statements. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

kaur id · 06 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh but who are we to say that take this page out and put this in? how do we know , maybe someone apporached Guru Ji with this page and they accepted it out of love or something, there are numerous possibilities, I cant risk upsetting Baba Ji with the pick and chose tactics...I am not saying you are wrong but that although I have read reasons against, I think this is bani and we cant take out Ragmaala, next we wil not agree with one of the Bhagats and then say they popped in out of no where, lets not start to edit Guru Ji's great gift of bani to us. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

--->akharinaam<--- · 06 Jan 2005

need to see photos

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

ns · 06 Jan 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Jarnail Singh Ji wrote to Bhen kaur 12123 " BUT 75 yeras later the SAME DIVIDE still EXISTS....no amount of "just keep quiet"/"dont argue"/"dont fight"/"forget it"/ etc etc is going to make this problem go away... the GURU KHALSA PANTH MUST DECIDE" I agree wholeheartedly the PANTH must decide, but you miss the point it's not about keeping quite it's about moving on to a trillion more current issues in the climate. Do you think the sarbat khalsa will be called upon at the Akal Takht once more for this issue, will that ever happen in the next 75 years? Well, I hope so and much earlier if possible, because there are a lot of things that the Khalsa Panth needs to sort out including some of the issues in the current rehat marayda and as Raagmala being one of them. I sincerely hope the debate doesn't go on about Raagmala over these kind of internet forums for the next 75 years. Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.

Re: Old Saroop with Raagmala in it

facts... · 07 Jan 2005

There is never any question of any bhagat bani being removed. Coz that is clearly in Gurbani and part of Guru Arjan dev jis numerical structure. Lets nots get unnnecessarily emotional over things that are not true. The raagmala comes after Mudhavenee which everyone accepts as the seal of the Guru Granth sahib ji. Sants and DT accept this. Raagmala comes after numerous other poems, such as rattan mala. All the panth agreed the rest of these poems are not Gurbani. Raagmala comes after them!! So the dispute is only because of raagmala, nothing else. Emotional blackmail about removing bhagats bani, or ripping up Guru Granth Sahib is false propoganda by those who are intentionally causing trouble. In Uk, everyone knows who these people are, no names need to be mentioned. kaur id wrote: > Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh > but who are we to say that take this page out and put this in? > how do we know , maybe someone apporached Guru Ji with this > page and they accepted it out of love or something, there are > numerous possibilities, I cant risk upsetting Baba Ji with the > pick and chose tactics...I am not saying you are wrong but that > although I have read reasons against, I think this is bani and > we cant take out Ragmaala, next we wil not agree with one of > the Bhagats and then say they popped in out of no where, lets > not start to edit Guru Ji's great gift of bani to us. > Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh