Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

Singh · 31 Dec 2004

In this debate about BrahmGiani, some followers of "Sants" have stated that so-and-so was/is a BrahmGiani and therefore we should follow exactly what they say. Gurbani says that a BrahmGiani is one who is one with God. But how do we know who has reached this stage of BrahmGian? Often, the line BRAHMGIANI KI GATH BRAHMGIANI JAANAI is quoted to show that only a BrahmGiani can know another BrahmGiani, but recently some "Sant" followers have questioned the translation of the word GATH. The word GATH means STATE or STATUS. This is clear from other parts in Gurbani where the word GATH is used. Phrases such as PARM GATH are used widely in Gurbani to meet the Supreme State/Status. E.G. jith miliai param gath paaeeai || Meeting Him, the supreme status is obtained. [ang 71] So, BRAHMGIANI KI GATH BRAHMGIANI JAANAI actually means: "A BrahmGiani's State Is Known Only By A BrahmGiani." This is inline with the rest of Gurbani. In the below line, the word Gath is used again and it clearly states that only God knows our GATH or STATE. a(n)thar kee gath thum hee jaanee thujh hee paahi nibaero || Only You know the state of my innermost self; You alone can judge me. [ang 618] So, very clearly, only God can know what is inside a person, whether their STATE is high or low. We can only know their external actions, not their internal state. THEREFORE, for us to say that so and so is a Brahm Giani is 100% Manmat.

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

-- · 31 Dec 2004

Sukhmani Sahib also explains the qualities of a Brahmgiani! If someone has those qualities, of course that person will be respected coz of their guuns. What can we say, for gurbani already explains it better than any person could.

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

Tript · 01 Jan 2005

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!! The reason people are fighting over the chair is simple. Whoever gets to be jathedar becomes Pooran BrahmGiani overnight and so whatever they say from that point onwards is unquestionable. People will respect them almost like Guru Ji and they become "somebody" worldwide. The cause of all this is everyone who goes against Gurmat by giving unsubstantiatable titles like "Pooran BrahmGiani" and "Sant Baba". If these titles weren't so readily applied to whoever becoems Jathedar, people would think twice before over-regarding fellow Gursikhs and catapulting them into divine untouchablility. Is it any wonder that people are now fighting over such a Jathedari? Bhai Harnam Singh Dhumma and Bhai Ram Singh will both become Jathedars of their own Taksals and they will both be known hence forth as "Sant Baba" and "BrahmGiani". People will now see them as God-like and do whatever they say. Its strange that all this is also seen to be the purest form of Gurmat, as Guru Ji destroyed all this man-following and joined Sikhs directly to God through only Himself. The best thing we can all do is wake up and see how far we have gone from Gurmat. Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa! Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

Dharamveer Singh · 02 Jan 2005

well said all the posters especially Tript ji. we have well and truly DESERTED GURBANI... the Divine Message from Akal purakh. Guru Ji came to deliver his message in 10 human forms..and finally Guru Gobind Singh ji put an end to HUMAN DEHDHAREE SAKSHEE POOJA by putting us under GURU GRANTH JI. 1. many were NOT at happy with this development...they started spurious stories about Guru ji not departing for sachkhand but just "disappearing" somewhere to "re-appear" as Guru so and so....and so thsier LIE continues to this day... in fact their GURU has GRADUATED from just Plain GURU Ji ( as in GURU NANAK-GURU GOBIND SINGH JI ) ....to SATGURU JI. This GROUP has OFFICIALLY DROPPED GURU GRANTH/GURBANI from their agenda. Namdharees/Radhasoamis etc now DO NOT DEPEND EXCLUSIVELY ON SIKHS to recruit members.. 2. Others "afraid" to go that far as those in Group 1 above, never the less began to "discover" certain SUPER-HUMANS... who they named BRAHMGIANI/SANT/BABA/MAHAPURASH...etc etc..and put these up on PEDESTALS so HIGH that no ordinary human could challenge theri every word....whenever these super humans opened their "divine brahmgiani mouths"..it was WORD FROM GOD !! challenge at your own risk. These brahmgianis then began passing down their Jathedaris/deras/jathas etc to favourites and good chamchas...or kingmakers behind the scenes started making jathedars/sants of theri own candidates.... THIS GROUP still has NEED of GURU GRANTH/GURBANI and use it as a "recruitment tool" among sikhs...but they are slowly moving away from GURBANI and towards SAKSHEE POOJA of their Brahmgianis ONLY...( the Brahmgiani can do no wrong...if he says mid day is midnight..so be it...IT has to be DARK at noon.) 3. In a departure from group tactics of group one those in group two still threaten any sikh who dares oppose their brahmgiani. Group one doesnt care two hoots about what sikhs say about them or their guru as they are already well established as independent religions....while the second group still immature and need both the brahmgiani and the sikhs. Dharamveer singh taksali

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

SS · 05 Jan 2005

Good post. I can see why the pro-Brahmgiani people have nothing to add now!

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

kookar-Di-Poochh · 05 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. SS veer, Thats because they dont have anything to add....their case rests totally on "WHAT MY BRAHGIANI SAID"..( read Sukhamni Sahib and see what horrors await you..... if you dare to criticise my brahmgiani)..NO arguments based on facts, no historical references, nothing....its no wonder they are quiet....but wait a minute.... they might come out and start "questioning" who this Kookar is, who this SS is, who Dharmveer is ?? since they all speak the Same language..they have to be the same person becasue how could so many people be saying the same LOGICAL things... that is their second line of defence ( to attack the person/poster and try and make him disappear!! fat hope) kookar

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

SantKeeNindaaNaanakaa... · 05 Jan 2005

Sant Kee Nindaa Naanakaa Bahuri Bahuri Avtaar || Fateh Ji I am a strong believer that Brahmgiani's exist and all i have to say is Moorakhai Naal Naa Lujheeai.... so..maybe that's why none of the Pro-Brahmgiani's havent posted any views...we don't have time to argue, only got time for Bani and Santhiya! Fateh Ji

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

impressed... · 05 Jan 2005

Vah, VAh....dharamveer singh and singh, very well put. Beautiful.. I have had the opportunity to spend over eight years with a so-called super bhramgaini...mann of pehowa. For eight years with the assistence of his close chele, we were led to believe that he was a reincarnation of guru nanak (based upon the janamsakhi by bala, of Guru Nanak, when supposedly Guru Nanak whilst conversing with ajitta randhawa said that ten births as a guru, seventy four (74) as a sant, then the big guy returns.)mann of pehowa thought himself to be one of these 74 sants...and i'm pretty sure the rest of these sants are counting themselves in the 74 too. When this kind of mythology and faulse representation begins to lead our faith and the so-called leaders of sikhi, what else is left! I say let them soak in the stupidity of there environments, for when we were close to mann of pehowa, before being told personally by one of his victims, the true personalitiy of mann of pehowa, we too would not have listened to anyone. They will use gurbani to asert there side of the story. But one thing is for sure, the past few years were spent with my internal self questioning why no further development was being made, on a spiritual level, under the guidance of this monster...some of you may want to remove your blinkers too. For those sikhs waitng for the second coming....to rectify the problems, be ready for a new faith to be establised, for the likes of our guru's and other son's/daughters of god will not even try to re-establish the mess we have made of guru Nanaks sikhi.... Gurfateh, Kulbir Singh Dhillon..Uk wala.

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

Manpreet Kaur · 06 Jan 2005

We have young Sikhs all over the world following these Baba, Sants thinking they are brahmgianis. It's like if they say your blue dastaar is yellow. THEY ALL Start chanting ITS YELLOW! ITS YELLOW! ITS YELLOW! I agree with your posts Tript jee and Dharaveer Singh jee

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 06 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Veer Dharamveer Singh TAKSALI is a taksali after my own heart..a Taksali of the Genuine Taksal of Guru Granth Ji. More such taksalis are sorely needed. May waheguru Ji Bless You with even more bibek budhi. Jarnail Singh.

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 06 Jan 2005

Santkeenindanaka...writes.... "I am a strong believer that Brahmgiani's exist and all i have to say is Moorakhai Naal Naa Lujheeai.... so..maybe that's why none of the Pro-Brahmgiani's havent posted any views...we don't have time to argue, only got time for Bani and Santhiya!" The words to note are "Moorakhaan naal na lojhiyeeh"....what HEIGHT of HANKAAR and HAUMAII to call others a moorakh and self as "brahmgianis".. BUT this si not the point i want to make...IF this brahmgiani group who are not really interested in "moorkhaan naal na lujhiyeh types.. then WHY couldnt they Keep their COOL and NOT REPLY at ALL.... WHY THIS REPLY ?? Poor brahmgiani must have taken away some time from his bhagtee and santhiya to write this utterly "moorakhalee" piece of advice. MY dear friend writes about REAL NINDA on another forum..and I quote Her below: Ninda' is generally referred to as the indulgence in IDLE criticism > of another due to perosonal ego as a putdown personifying jealousy, > coveting,intolerance and hidden/ulterior motives its hallmarks, > malintent its foundation. > > However, constructive criticism does not fall under this category, It > rises above the urge to condemn, to promote something with > selflessness as its intent, it is highly recommended - as it forms > the impetus to bring about necessary change, without which there would > be no change or improvement in human values/thinking. > > Mrs A Singh Jarnail Singh

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

SS · 06 Jan 2005

"SantKeeNindaaNaanakaa" said:- >> I am a strong believer that Brahmgiani's exist and all i have to say is Moorakhai Naal Naa Lujheeai.... so..maybe that's why none of the Pro-Brahmgiani's havent posted any views...we don't have time to argue, only got time for Bani and Santhiya! << You have stated: 1. You strongly believe in Brahmganis 2. You only have time for Gurbani If you only have time for Gurbani, then the Vichar that has been put forward in the first post on this thread uses Gurbani to clearly show that your belief in Brahmgianis is falsehood. So, if you only have time for Gurbani, you would understand that the Gurbani you are reading is not compatible with your "strong" belief in Brahmgianis. Would you stick to your understanding of Brahmgianis, or that one given in Gurbani?

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 06 Jan 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. I am gladenned after reading Manprit kaur's post. Shows that we are making an impact...more and more sane people will come to realise that they are being made fools of by these babays....being made to shut your eyes and wait 20 years for a non-existant surprise...and then slipping away quietly without showing what the surprise was...is the height of hypnosis of an entire community !!! What is more surprising that instead of catching on to the huge propoganda exercise played on them, the "closed eyes singhs" have just kept their eyes closed and accepted the next INFALLIBLE BABA as the Supreme TRUTH...repeating after him..keep eyes closed khalsa ji..sant ji is coming back alive..dont open ypur eyes until I say so. Surprise Surprise..in this 21st Century we are not the only FOOLS... I just read a news report from JAPAN that says the Hottest selling item for the New Year is a "paper printed Talsiman in Yellow" that is placed on the Computer Monitor/CPU...to PREVENT VIRUS/WORMS/ATTACK on the Computer.....????? IN JAPAN ?? 21st Century ??? or DARK AGES ?? I can now understand perfectly how sikhs fall for the baaby propoganda of brahmgiani ki gatt brahmgiani janeh.... ask a Computer hacker/computer programmer about how this talisman ( jadoo mantar) can prevent a computer virus attack ?? and he will laugh at you.....tell the same to a brahmgiani enthusiast and he will "laugh" at us and reply" brahmgiani ki gatth... or moorkhaan naal na lujyieyh ?? Wah wah..true a fool is born every minute. Manjit kaur

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

SantKeeNindaaNaanakaa... · 06 Jan 2005

Fateh Ji! Jarnail Singh Gyani Ji Wrote... >>The words to note are "Moorakhaan naal na lojhiyeeh"....what HEIGHT of HANKAAR and HAUMAII to call others a moorakh and self as "brahmgianis"..<< Bhai Sahib ji, the Tukk is "Moorakhai" NOT Moorakhaan....and I never said that out of Hankar and I am certainly NOT calling myself a brahmgiani or anywhere near that avastha!!! All i am saying is that people have become very SCARED of the words and titles such as: BRAHMGIANI, SANT, MAHAPURKH etc the reason being is that these anti-sant people seem afraid they will not have the same amount of Love and Respect for Sahib Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj as they once did. They cannot see that the sant is actually helping the sevadars become one with Akaal! By giving them guidance and explaining Gurbani to them constantly. Do not judge a person but if u truly feel strongly about a "so-called" sant then simply do ardas that they see what you feel is the right path. We haven't got time for Sikhs to be slandering other Sikhs. we get enough of Non-Sikhs slandering us! Stick together and "Dekh ki Andit Keetaa" Turn a Blind eye to controversial issues.... May the True Guru Bless His Khalsa Panth... Fateh Ji!! Sant Kee Nindaa Naanakaa Bahuri Bahuri Avtaar || Brahmgiaanee Aap Nirankaar || Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

faattae naakan ttoottae kaadh · 07 Jan 2005

raag goojaree bhagathaa kee baanee Raag Goojaree, The Words Of The Devotees: ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh || One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: sree kabeer jeeo kaa choupadhaa ghar 2 dhoojaa || Chau-Padas Of Kabeer Jee, Second House: chaar paav dhue si(n)g gu(n)g mukh thab kaisae gun geehai || With four feet, two horns and a mute mouth, how could you sing the Praises of the Lord? oot(h)ath bait(h)ath t(h)aegaa parihai thab kath moodd lukeehai ||1|| Standing up and sitting down, the stick shall still fall on you, so where will you hide your head? ||1|| har bin bail biraanae hueehai || Without the Lord, you are like a stray ox; faattae naakan ttoottae kaadhhan kodho ko bhus kheehai ||1|| rehaao || with your nose torn, and your shoulders injured, you shall have only the straw of coarse grain to eat. ||1||Pause|| saaro dhin ddolath ban meheeaa ajahu n paett agheehai || All day long, you shall wander in the forest, and even then, your belly will not be full. jan bhagathan ko keho n maano keeou apano peehai ||2|| You did not follow the advice of the humble devotees, and so you shall obtain the fruits of your actions. ||2|| dhukh sukh karath mehaa bhram booddo anik jon bharameehai || Enduring pleasure and pain, drowned in the great ocean of doubt, you shall wander in numerous reincarnations. rathan janam khoeiou prabh bisariou eihu aousar kath peehai ||3|| You have lost the jewel of human birth by forgetting God; when will you have such an opportunity again? ||3|| bhramath firath thaelak kae kap jio gath bin rain biheehai || You turn on the wheel of reincarnation, like an ox at the oil-press; the night of your life passes away without salvation. kehath kabeer raam naam bin moo(n)dd dhhunae pashhutheehai ||4||1|| Says Kabeer, without the Name of the Lord, you shall pound your head, and regret and repent. ||4||1||

Re: BrahmGiani Ki *GATH* BrahmGiani Jaanai

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 07 Jan 2005

dear sant ki ninda Nanka ji, Waheguru ji ka khalsa wheguru ji ki fateh. Sorry for the misunderstanding. Bhul Chuk Maaf. Jarnail singh