Question on Reincarnation
Gurpreet Kaur · 28 Jun 2003
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh
I was asked the following from a Muslim, I wanted to ask the Sangat if they had any thoughts on this?, I don't know how to respond?!
>>Getting back to Reincarnation itself. Again this is an example of how "eastern religious thought" (Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism) & "middle eastern religious thought" are diametrically opposed. Hence, either Reincarnation is true and Life After Death false, thereby concluding that the Middle Eastern conception of Allaah is false, or vice-versa. You say that it makes sense that humanity has evolved spiritually. However, according to my understanding, those that are reincarnated, having failed in the previous life, have NO KNOWLEDGE of their previous life. This is putting aside the conjecture, and it is conjecture since it is pseudo-science, of so-called life after death experiences or regression hypnosis, since these are cases far and few between and restricted to subjective personalised human experiences which are highly inconclusive. If one does not have knowledge of what evil it committed in the previous life, how does one work towards becoming merged with Waheguru? It seems like it is a state of hit-or-miss with nothing that is concrete. Regardless of whether they move to a body of greater spirituality, there is no guarantee that one will move higher or lower in the chain or that one will acquire the liberation needed to become one with Waheguru. It maybe that even in a higher spiritual body, the environment one finds itself in may corrupt it and force it back down the ladder? Also, I want to ask: For how long will this birth and death cycle last for? Until every human is one with Waheguru? Or will it last forever? Islaam says, no. Since both religions affirm that life is a test, it only stands to reason that one be informed of the outcomes of the test at the end of the life as opposed to going through an unknown number of rebirths the resulting complications of which are clear.
Imagine you were reincarnated as a Hindu, and had no access to the truth except that which you were inculcated with, i.e. animal worship. What type of justice would it be for God to repunish a person who hasn't even been exposed to the truth that may or may not be out there. Or are they in a neutral state whereby they will be reincarnated in the same spiritual state? However, again we go back to the notion that if they were to reacquire this neutral state even then anything could happen in the next life. It seems like this is a "role your dice and take a chance". For me this is not God's Justice. Unless I've missed something out then please correct me.
As for the concept of Mukhti and Karma. Gods essence is absolute and perfect. Would you agree or disagree? If you disagree, then God is not perfect and does not have absolute attributes, therefore, He was not God to start off with. If, however, you say that God has Absolute Perfect attributes, perfection in the absolute sense not in the relative, then explain how it is that we, with our imperfection, end up merging with God? What is the result of this merging? Does it mean that we become one with His divine essence? Can we surmise, therefore, when we become one with God we become one with his absolute perfect essence? How do you explain, if of course you accept this, God being perfect and absolute, and yet allowing His creation to merge with Him?
Furthermore, if God is in everything and everywhere, do we become one with God who is in everything and everywhere? We become one with the creation? Moreover, God who has absolute eternal attributes who is beyond time (according to the Mool Mantra) and yet everywhere and in everything. How is God with his absolute perfect attributes beyond time, yet everywhere and in everything, thus, part of time? This concept is ajeeb. Please explain because I'm willing to understand. The above seems contradictory to me.
As for the foetus and whether it will be judged, then the Messenger of Allaah has explained clearly to us that there will be three who will not receive judgment, and one of them will be the one who dies and has not reached the state of maturity, i.e. puberty, since only after puberty will ones Record of Accounts commence. We believe that there are two angels on either shoulder of each and everyone of us recording everything we do and this "Record of Deeds" will be given to us on the DoJ. And again this is from the Justice of Allaah that He will not hold a toddler responsible. However, I wish to ask you the same question. What will happen to the foetus if it were to die? Would it not become one with Waheguru having not been effected by the 5 vices? Or will it move onto a body of higher spirituality? If so, why and upon what basis? If you say it becomes one with Waheguru, then this would entail justice according to the rules you have set, if not, then this is injustice, unless I've missed something out then please correct me.<<
Gurfateh!
Re: Question on Reincarnation
NOT AMRITDHARI YET · 29 Jun 2003
i recall u was told last tyme to keep away from the muslim sangata who are trying to question and convert u..they will pose more questions and each one of these will be answered by a wise gursikh by someone like kulbir singh ji or someone very soon. but the root problem wont stop that is them coming up to u and trying to convert u unless u put ur foot down and ignore them and walk ur own way. certain people in this world are missionary that is what some people get kicks out of, ur wasting ur time with them, even if ur in the right they wont ever buy what u say cos the whole mental mindset is to discredit ur belief, well thats the feeling i get rather than his or her excuse saying they wish to learn etc..
panji do urself a favour and blank them, trust me i used to have debates with these people and u end up wasting ur time, cos the whole point is to convert u, even if u give the right answers all they do is walk away, do u spend ur time goin through thsi all the time? once u step down and just tell em u aint got time for their religion or questions they will stop coming upto u. and if u wish to learn more on sikhism there r soo many sites panji on the net, a good source is www.sikhitothemax.com, www,gurbani.org i can provide more if u wish.
please dont take any offence i didnt mean any i am saying for ur own benefit from experience these people wont stop once they know they can come up to u and approach u about religion its like a salesman tactic..
see past the mentality and jus lern up ur religion rather than soak their questions cos if they were truly interested in sikhism and how the justice differs in eastern thought compared to semitic religions they wud go to the library do some research, or use the net to their advantage, but instead they are approaching a sikh girl who doesnt know much about her religion, so y wud they rather come to u than the net or library?
Re: Question on Reincarnation
NOT AMRITDHARI YET · 29 Jun 2003
the guru granth sahib is translated into english and is in quiet a few libraries these people who question u shud be reading that and that will answer all their inquiries, and if they havent got the time for that then how comes they find teh time to enquire and question u??, that surely shows they must be interested or picking a certain point for reasons.
its like me if i wanna know whatr islam is about im not going to ask a muslim they will give their opinion , they may or may not know, i wud rather research the source of islam the quran and hadiths cos that is what muslims regard as the word of god the essence of their belief, the same wud then apply for a muslim wanting to learn on sikhism..
it seems these people r just trying to pick nitty gritty points twist them around and mimick them with their manmutt twisted logic, i cud do the same but i wont cos god has willed islam hinduism sikhism christianity to be here on earth.. In islam and sikhism the will of god is repeated many times in verses so if we believe in that will then we have to accept that and understand why god has sent diff religions to earth rather than try to dominate or hurt other peoples feelings about their religion. If we do not accept islam hinduism and sikhism are here on earth then we do not accept the will of the Creator who created these diff paths hence we dont believe in that will of God and that too is a contradiction when we talk about how great the will of God is from the verses..
Re: Question on Reincarnation
Gurpreet Kaur · 30 Jun 2003
Gurfateh
Dear Bhaji,
Thanks for your response, I totally understand what you are saying. As for being warned to stay away from Muslims, I think if you are having a discussion with someone, and there are no feelings involved which are prohibited in Sikhi (and Guru Ji has guided me well till now), then it shouldn't be such a problem to others? Unless you say that merely because I am a female?
See, you said even if you have right answers they won't listen. I already know this, who will want to give up something they have believed for so many years? Especially not someone with such a big ego. But I do NOT have all the right answers, and if this guy or the other Muslims 'girls' who are in my class provoke me to go out there and ask for answers, or make me 'want' to learn more, then how is this wrong?
To me, to be completely honest, it's come as a blessing in disguise, its made me a lot more closer to Sikhi than ever before, and for that I thank the Guru and the Sangat like yourself.
I appreciate where you are coming from, there are many girls targeted this way, I just sincerely wanted to ask a question, that's all. In fact Il explain fully. After the first instance where this group said we care for you so much that we want to help you realise the Truth so you are not led astray, and the replies to my posts, I realised I shouldn't bother with these people, it seemed futile. I changed my email add too.
Our Sikh Society at Uni, the email adds are public, and I have been getting emails daily, with 'heavy' material on Islam, nothing offensive may I add, just discussions and so on.
So, if there was a topic that I was unaware about I would go look it up, on the sites you suggested, as well as others. But reincarnation was confusing, couldnt find relevant stuff. I posted here because the Gursikhs who respond are very learned and I highly value their opinion, and on Sikhnet, for the same reason.
Thankyou again for your advice Bhaji, I am not as worthy as the Gurmukhs here, so please forgive me as your sister.
Gurpreet
Gurfateh
Re: Question on Reincarnation
NOT AMRITDHARI YET · 30 Jun 2003
panji im very very sorry i understand ur situation clearer now.. u r worthy have faith n be strong..the answers will come very shortly..its people like me who r not worthy who misjudged ur situation. im waiting for someone much better and knowledgable than myself to respond, i know kulbir singh or 2 other singsh here wud give u the perfect answers.if i say something it comes out mish mashed.. but if no one comes bak il put this on my shoulders and respond to this.
once again im very very sorry if i sed anything wrong..muslims do generate a lot of material about religion, hey theres a website called www.sikhawareness.com they usually have tonnes of info too..
Re: Question on Reincarnation
Kulbir Singh · 30 Jun 2003
Gurpreet Kaur bhain jeeo,
You are most welcome to ask your Gursikh veers and bhains answers you want. Here is a humble answer from me. Hopefully you will be satisfied by this. If you have any question, please don't hesitate to ask:
The question asked by the individual is a result of his less-than-enough understanding of the concept of Karma, Reincarnation, oneness with Vaheguru and Sikhi. In order to write response to these questions, one needs to have a lot of understanding of Gurmat. I will try to answer these questions not going into too much details.
>>>>>>>>>
You say that it makes sense that humanity has evolved spiritually. However, according to my understanding, those that are reincarnated, having failed in the previous life, have NO KNOWLEDGE of their previous life. This is putting aside the conjecture, and it is conjecture since it is pseudo-science, of so-called life after death experiences or regression hypnosis, since these are cases far and few between and restricted to subjective personalised human experiences which are highly inconclusive. If one does not have knowledge of what evil it committed in the previous life, how does one work towards becoming merged with Waheguru?
>>>>>>>>>>>
This world is a khel of Vaheguru. To run this world he has a system in place. This system is that of Karma. Some faiths like Buddhism consider Karma to be everything but in Sikhi, Karma can be overridden by grace.
To answer this question we first need to understand how the system of karma works. There is three kind of karma (karams)
1) The actions that we are currently doing
2) The actions we did previously but we have not suffered the consequences of those karma yet i.e. the karma for which reaction has not been ordained by Vaheguru yet.
3) The actions that we did previously and we have been ordained by Vaheguru to suffer those in this life.
Let us take an example of a bank account. Say prior to your birth in this life, you had total of 100 karma outstanding i.e. you haven't suffered consequence of 100 karma yet. At that point assume that Vaheguru ordained that since 100 karma are impossible to payoff in one lifetime, he decrees that you have to reap the fruits of 25 karma out of 100 karma in this lifetime.
The 25 karma that have been written on your forehead for this life cannot be changed and the gurbani pankitis like "Lekh naa matayee hay Sakhi, jo likhiya Kartaar" refer to these kind of karma (called Pralabhadh Karma).
The 75 karma outstanding and that have not been decreed by Vaheguru, are called Sanchit Karma and these karma are the first ones to burn when we do naam abhyaas. Pankitis like "Gur kaa shabad kaatay kot karam", (The shabad of Guru destroys tens of millions karma) pertain to these kind of karma.
The Pralabadh Karma (25 karma) cannot be erased but the effect of those karma can be minimized through baani. There are many saakhis to prove this. One of the saakhis is where Sooli (death by hanging) was changed to just a sool (small cut in foot) because of sangat of Guru Nanak Dev jee.
Based on our Pralabhad Karma (25 karma) we are put in situations and our reaction in those situations make up for our vartamaan karma i.e. the karma or actions that will determine our future. For example, based on our Pralabadh karma (25 karma) say you become poor and have lot of debt. One is poor because of his or her karma but if because of the situation arising from Pralabadh karma, we start stealing or do other kind of sinful karma, then we will be building bad karma. We don't have any control over Pralabadh karma but we have freewill on how we are going to react in this situation.
People talk about kismat, taqdeer or bhaag. Kismat, taqdeer of bhaag is nothing but our past karma. Our present condition is the direct reflection of our past karma. If one is rich, one is because of good karma in the past but most of the times, rich people end up in hell because while they become rich or king because of good karma, they also commit a lot of sin when they become king or are at other places of authority. These bad karma done in the intoxication of authority or money leads them to hell.
Our Tadbeer (present karma) shape our future just as our past karma shaped our present. In reality all that we have is present. Past is a dream and future is also a dream. The past was enjoyed or suffered as present and the future will be enjoyed or suffered by us as present So really all that exists is this moment of present. Everything else i.e. future or past is now a dream.
I think the system of Karma is extremely fair system. The janam of reincarnation is also based on Karma. Based on one’s karma, Vaheguru ordains the janam in the next life.
>>>>>>>>>
It seems like it is a state of hit-or-miss with nothing that is concrete. Regardless of whether they move to a body of greater spirituality, there is no guarantee that one will move higher or lower in the chain or that one will acquire the liberation needed to become one with Waheguru. It maybe that even in a higher spiritual body, the environment one finds itself in may corrupt it and force it back down the ladder?
>>>>>>>.
You are right. There is no guarantee that one will only move upward in the ladder. Guru Nanak Sahib in his great Baani – Siri Jap jee Sahib states that some fortunate ones are liberated while some unfortunate ones forever wander in the cycle of life and death. This creation is a khel of Vaheguru. When he wishes, he destroys all creation and at that point he alone is left and when he feels like he creates it again. This creation has been deleted and created many times before.
>>>>>
Also, I want to ask: For how long will this birth and death cycle last for? Until every human is one with Waheguru? Or will it last forever?
>>>>>
This is the jurisdiction of Vaheguru. Who are we to tell how long he will keep this creation going? This question is not an important one. Guru Nanak Sahib clearly preaches that we should not worry about when this world was created and likewise there is no need to worry about when this world will be destroyed. What we need to worry about is fulfilling our purpose of coming to this world i.e. doing naam abhyaas and getting darshan of Vaheguru. This is our turn to meet Vaheguru. So says Guru Arjun Dev jee in Siri Rehraas Sahib.
>>>>
Islaam says, no. Since both religions affirm that life is a test, it only stands to reason that one be informed of the outcomes of the test at the end of the life as opposed to going through an unknown number of rebirths the resulting complications of which are clear.
>>>>>>>>>>
In Sikhi too one is informed of the outcome of the test after life. After one dies, one is taken to Dharam Rai for accountability of deeds done in life. Based on those deeds one gets life forms in heaven, hell and then in this world.
How is it fair to people to be left in graves for hundreds of years, waiting for the day of judgement? What about the souls sitting in graves for hundreds of years? How is that fair? How can you say that they would find out the outcome of their test right after death? Rather than wait in the graves for the judgement day, is it not better they come back in more life forms and get elevated in the path of spirituality.
To say that one gets only one chance is totally absurd. If you are a parent, and you child committed a mistake, would you not give him another chance? Then why would Vaheguru not give another chance by letting him come back in this world and get a fresh start?
REINCARNATION IS FAR MORE FAIR FOR THE SOULS THAN WAIT IN THE GRAVES FOR THOUSANDS OF YEARS AS ISLAM PREACHES.
>>>>
Imagine you were reincarnated as a Hindu, and had no access to the truth except that which you were inculcated with, i.e. animal worship. What type of justice would it be for God to repunish a person who hasn't even been exposed to the truth that may or may not be out there.
>>>>>>>>
By the same token, how would it be fair for a person, under the Islamic way of one life form, if that person never hears about Islam in his life? How would such person get treated on the judgement day? If a Hindu living in a remote village never hears about Islam, is that Hindu doomed on the judgement day? Looks like under the Islamic law, that Hindu will get Jahannam i.e. hell.
>>>>>>>
Or are they in a neutral state whereby they will be reincarnated in the same spiritual state?
>>>>
No they are not in a neutral state. They will get another life form based on millions of karma they do in their life form.
>>>>>
However, again we go back to the notion that if they were to reacquire this neutral state even then anything could happen in the next life. It seems like this is a "role your dice and take a chance". For me this is not God's Justice. Unless I've missed something out then please correct me.
>>>>>>>>.
What is not fair is the Islamic and Judeo-Christian notion that we get only once chance and the we rot in the graves for the judgement day. On the judgement day ones who did not accept Islam, will stay in hell forever. Is this fair? Is this kind of Allah you believe in? Is Allah so merciless?
>>>>
As for the concept of Mukhti and Karma. Gods essence is absolute and perfect. Would you agree or disagree? If you disagree, then God is not perfect and does not have absolute attributes, therefore, He was not God to start off with.
>>>>
I agree
>>>>>>>>>
If, however, you say that God has Absolute Perfect attributes, perfection in the absolute sense not in the relative, then explain how it is that we, with our imperfection, end up merging with God? What is the result of this merging? Does it mean that we become one with His divine essence? Can we surmise, therefore, when we become one with God we become one with his absolute perfect essence? How do you explain, if of course you accept this, God being perfect and absolute, and yet allowing His creation to merge with Him?
>>>>>>>
The jeev or the living beings are made of physical body and sooksham sareer. The sooksham sareer is made of mann and aatma. This has be further subdivided as antashkaran but I am not going to go into those detais. It is beyond the scope of this debate.
Anyway, The aatma is made of same material or essence as Vaheguru and this aatma is the real self of the jeev (living creation). The mann (not exactly mind) is the one that gives aatma a distinct identity from Vaheguru. When we do naam abhyaas and do bhagti by living our lives according to the teachings of Guru Sahib, we slowly destroy our mann and eventually realize that we are only one with Vaheguru. There is a wall of falsehood dividing us and Vaheguru. By Naam abhyaas we can destroy this wall of falsehood (KooRai Paal).
Being one with Vaheguru means merging in his divine self by destroying ego and mann. Merging in Vaheguru does not mean destroying our self identity but it means being one with Vaheguru in Vaheguru’s original form that is beyond the material world.
>>>>>>>>>.
Furthermore, if God is in everything and everywhere, do we become one with God who is in everything and everywhere? We become one with the creation?
>>>>>>>>>
Sure when one is one with Vaheguru, one is one with his creation too. So what is wrong with that. That is why only the Sikhs can have real love for the whole world.
>>>>>>>
Moreover, God who has absolute eternal attributes who is beyond time (according to the Mool Mantra) and yet everywhere and in everything. How is God with his absolute perfect attributes beyond time, yet everywhere and in everything, thus, part of time? This concept is ajeeb.
>>>>>>>
This is not as ajeeb as the concept of Islam where God is not everywhere but sitting in Jannat. How is he running the world from there? At least the Christians believe in Trinity and believe that the Holy Ghost runs the show. I wonder what Islam has to say here.
Anyway, as I said before, it is the original saroop (Nirgun Saroop) of Vaheguru that is beyond time. His creation is a result of his thoughts and as such all creation is within him and he is within his creation.
>>>>>>>.
As for the foetus and whether it will be judged,
>>>>>>
The foetus is a joon (life form). It is a punishment to the jeev or something bad he did. The life of a feotus is pure hell according to Gurbani. Staying in the feotus is like living in fire. So it is more like a bhog jooni (janam for suffering punishments) as opposed to Karam jooni (human form)
>>>>>>>>
then the Messenger of Allaah has explained clearly to us that there will be three who will not receive judgment, and one of them will be the one who dies and has not reached the state of maturity, i.e. puberty, since only after puberty will ones Record of Accounts commence.
>>>>>>>
So they go to jannat? This is pretty absurd. Where do cats, dogs and donkeys go? Hell or heaven. After all they too are living. What happened to their souls. Where are they now?
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Question on Reincarnation
NOT AMRITDHARI YET · 30 Jun 2003
panji i wud like to suggest something. ur privacy is being invaded on the net in emails at uni..hence wudnt it be better if u hold a meeting through the nationa union of students or a sikh society or a related org, get as many people together who r in the same predicament as u, sikhs, buddhists , hindus christians jews u name it , big numbers, and then get a petition drawn up detailing whats going on with these emails that are being hammered everyday on ur pc at uni, and consuming ur time having to delte them when u shudnt have to recieve them in the first place, abusing and mimicking ur identity in subtle ways, emails that have no use whatsoever in ur studies or uni related, plain and simple its intimidation in the garb of religion. the teachers need to know whats going on and get the directors to take note and action against these groups, and inform external bodies who can help if the need be.. so petition the IT dept to provide the students with a blocking facility at the very least so u can choos eto ignore them totally as well as for others. this way awareness of the situation is highlighted as well as getting summit done..
debates with people like this is like a clash of cultures and is bound to end up with heated disputes, cos that kind of mindset dont see anything wrong with doing whatthey r doing and it adds to friction between cultures and religions. life in uni then becomes a lil more complicated, i wudnt like any student to go through that.
Re: Question on Reincarnation
Gurpreet Kaur · 30 Jun 2003
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa
Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh
Dear Sadh Sangat Ji,
Thankyou for your responses, Indy Ji and Kulbir Singh Ji, as I expected, you have cleared all the confusion for me. Many Thanks.
'NOT AMRITDHARI YET', Bhaji don't make me feel ashamed by apologising, what you said was out of concern for your sister. I appreciate your response as much as the others.
Bhul Chuk Dee Khima
Gurpreet Kaur
Gurfateh