Guru Granth Sahib Cds
Parminderjit Singh · 27 Jun 2003
How we are going to deal with CD version of Sri Guru Granth Sahib? Will the same respect can be given? I am very much concerned with this new emerging technology
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Parminderjit Singh · 27 Jun 2003
How we are going to deal with CD version of Sri Guru Granth Sahib? Will the same respect can be given? I am very much concerned with this new emerging technologykaur · 28 Jun 2003
yeah i want to know 2Kulbir Singh · 28 Jun 2003
In my personal opinion, Gur-gaddi has been given to the laridaar form of Siri Guru Granth Sahib only. Other forms should be respected but Guruship is with laridaar saroop only. What if a person gets Siri Guru Granth Sahib memorized? Is such person any different from an electronic form (CD, Disks etc) of Gurbani? Daas, Kulbir SinghSS · 28 Jun 2003
if a person has Siri Guru Granth Sahib memorized, he deserves alot more respect then the average person.Kulbir Singh · 28 Jun 2003
SS wrote: > if a person has Siri Guru Granth Sahib memorized, he deserves > alot more respect then the average person. > I agree that such person deserves a lot more respect than an average person, but do we do chaur on that person because his mind has all baani stored in there just as baani is stored in a CD? Should we give that person same respect as Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee? After all he too has all baani stored in his head. I guess the answer would be NO. Daas, Kulbir SinghManjit Singh · 28 Jun 2003
Now it will be even easier for those who consider Pad-Chhade saroop as Guru Sahib Ji. All the customs like anand karj, naming a new born child etc could be performed on the computer. And when a DVD version comes in they won't need Granthi Singhs any more. Also having parkash of gurusahib at home will be easier for them. Another thing I was thinking if some hindi speaking sikhs starts calling hindi version of Guru Granth Sahib as Guru Sahib ji and also starts doing customs like anand karj from there, is that will be worse than those who doing all that with Pad-Chhade(Modern Panjabi) saroop? I will call all such so called sikh as Guruless khalsa if not anything worse. Bhul Chuk maaf ji.Mkhalsa · 29 Jun 2003
What if its larivaar printing on the cd? in a way it deserves respect, at least as much as a gutka if nothing else.. but then again, i agree that it isnt really bani until it is displayed and you can see it, right? hmm.. a lot of singhs are getting sikhitothemax on their pda (handheld computer) nowadays and we use this in keertan etc instead of pothi, should the pda get more respect? especially since most of us also use this same handheld for our everyday lives, taking notes, calendar functions, reminders, sometimes even for net/email... >>>>>Another thing I was thinking if some hindi speaking sikhs starts calling hindi version of Guru Granth Sahib as Guru Sahib ji and also starts doing customs like anand karj from there, is that will be worse than those who doing all that with Pad-Chhade(Modern Panjabi) saroop?<<<<<<< American sikhs here in the US did parkash of a version of guru granth sahib where half of each page is padched bani and the other half of the page is english translation... this is still done at most ashrams.. I think a few years ago akal takht sent a letter here saying it is not to be considered guru sahib and a few ashrams in california did remove it, but i beleive its come back now. so this is already ahppening, not in hindi, but in english, then again it is a necessity in a way.. one thing though, ive seen a lot of times they do hukamnama in english only which is kind of weird..Jarnail Singh "Arshi" · 03 Jul 2003
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. IMHO these type of concerns come baout when we forget that SHABAD Is the GURU.......not the physical paper, ink, hard cover etc. The Paper of the SGGS is the same as those used for ordinary books, the Printers Ink used is also used for printing......books, posters,,xxx,xxx etc. Similarly on a CD/DVD ( I have one) the SHABAD is GURU...not the plastic CD.When GURBANI is Displayed on my Monitor, I sit with covered head and pay due respect, when I print any Gurbani I treat the page with respect. The CD and the DVD came in the ordinary MAIL in an ordinary envelope ( what did I expect....that Five Amritdharie Post men would be accompanying the CD/DVD carrying it on their head and waving a chaur all the way from USA... I am sorry I did not expect this and it didnt happen..and neither is it going to happen anyway. Our aim should be to FOLLOW what it says in GURBANI, try to LIVE our lives the way of the GURU....Sabad dhun surt chela said Guru nanak....It means what it says, Dasan dass Jarnail singhDaas · 04 Jul 2003
Manjit Singh wrote the following : "I will call all such so called sikh as Guruless khalsa if not anything worse" All I can say is you or anyone else has no right to state the above Guru Ji alone can decide who is khalsa and who isn't !!!!! "paat(h) purrai mukh jhoot(h)o bolai nigurae kee math ouhai || He reads the scriptures, but tells lies; such is the intellect of one who has no guru." I wonder how many of us fall under the above catergory regardless of which saroop you read from ????? Bhul Chuk Maf Karna