Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

lakhvir singh · 23 Dec 2004

WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh! Last night, I was at the Gurudwara and I happened to show my new mobile phone to a close Gyani friend of mine. I lost my earlier cell phone to theft within the Gurudwara premises (over a huge smagam where a lot of people lost personal effects that were left unattended, even for a split second). He asked me how much it cost and when I told him, his response really made me sad and disheartened. In a humble muse, he remarked that even if his whole year's salary was put together, it wouldn't amount to what my new cell cost me (about US $ 375). You can now imagine what our Head Granthi earns in a month. It's so sad. Is that how poorly paid our Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis are? I was really saddened and have been thinking about their plight since last night. This particular Gyani, who is the Head Granthi of our local Gurudwara, is an amazing guy - so humble, down-to-earth and loving. He's just like an ideal grandfather. I have tremendous amount of respect for him because from the little I know of him, I have come to appreciate the role of Granthis, Paathis and Gyanis in our Gurudwaras. They are so selfless and absorbed in their work. So how can Gurudwaras pay them so little? Do they not deserve better, especially if they are doing a great job and seva to the Panth? They are ideal role models, so why are they not taken better care of? Is the Sangat's charaava not for one of those kinds of purposes? Of what use is building bigger and more beautiful Gurudwaras when our own humble sevadaars are not taken care of? At present, Gyanis are seen by Gurudwara managements like some servants who are ordered around by those who know not even an iota of Sikhi. How can we raise concern about their plight to those who themselves not ideal Sikh role models (Gurudwara leaders)? I feel so much for dereseving, selfless Panth Sevadaars who need at least our respect and understanding, that they too have dreams and aspirations for themselves and their families. So why do we hesitate to treat them better? I have come across enough examples of some really good Gyanis who ended up returning to India when they openly criticised (in all the nimarta) the way Gyanis are treated in this country. Many have gone back feeling so let-down and vowing never to come to this country. Is this how we treat the Guru's sevadaars? Fine, there are also some Gyanis who are crooked, but is not the duty of the Gurudwara management to select only the fully-rehatvaan ones? How do we stand up against this disease in our Panth that is eating away our Sikhs? How can the Gyanis do their work well when they are ill-treated (not literally, though) and underpaid? I'm sure they are demoralised but who do they open up to who will listen to them? Also, some of them are so humble to the dust that they cannot muster enough breath to bring it up. Gyanis dererve our respect and care. They are our Guru's messengers. How can we accord them what they deserve, because the people who employ them rarely ever understand them and their important role in our community (and global level, too)? If we take care of our Gyanis, they can be our ideal spokespersons and leaders of our Panth, rather than the chair-sniffing politicians that run our Gurudwaras. WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh!

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Dhan sikhi · 23 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh well said Lakhvir Singh veerji and it is sad and has made me think a lot. I think we could talk to the committees and if they dont listen to you alone then maybe you could get more people to support you. But I think you have to be aware that committee members may be rude if you put pressure on them so are you accept that rather than think that God did not help you? May sound like a minor thing to say but I have been spoken to rudely in a Gurudwara before and if it turns into a fight one may never want to go again. This is certainly the case with some of our youth but I am sure your faith is more stronger in sikhi than to be upset even if you are not heard or if they turn you away angrily. Hope we can raise their pay. Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh,

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Premi · 23 Dec 2004

Well you have to admit though alot of these "Gyanis" are not really Gyanis, just there to make a quick buck. For the most part they have no jeevan of there own. They will tell the sangat to rise at Amrit Vela and then themselves get up around 11 am. They have dug the hole for themselves, there are some good ones, but far a few compared do the ones coming out of India now. Because of this they have lost respect. Shouldn't the messengers be practicing the message themselves before they tell others to? 99% of them don't even do nitnem, you can see them in the strip clubs after keertan!!!!

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

sad · 23 Dec 2004

singh thats what happens when you let criminals and joe bloggs take over your gurdwaras while we sit back and say bhagti before power. Kick the masands out of power, get in proper amritdhari sikhs committees with our relatives backing our votes on election day. What are we waiting for? every gurdwara to close and dry this religion up?

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Gyani JS Dhillon "Arshi" · 24 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh. Haan Ji.. IF the Gurdwara Management is AMRITDHAREE and well interested in the affairs of the Gurdawra...they will come to AMRITVELA... and then show me which "Gyani" will dare to sleep until 11 am ?? IF the Gurdwara Management and the "SANGAT" straggle in around 10.00 am for the Akhand path Bhog ( and dont even turn up in Gurdwara on other normal days.... why should the "gyani" bother to wake up early ??? GURU JI is NOT part of the equation here for either side....not for the Gyani, not for the Pardhaans, not for the sangat....meaning nobody is "AFRAID" or having BHAI or PYAAR ...BHAU of GURU JI. Now to the million dollar question..Which comes First - Good Management - the chicken.... or good Gyani - the egg !! A GOOD GYANI will not be able to LAST a month with ROTTEN gurdwara managemnt...and a BAD GYANI will not last a WEEK with GOOD GURDWARA MANAGEMENT. So what SAD says above is 100% TRUE. The MASANDS occupying our Gurdwaras MUST be REMOVED ASAP.....and I mean the MASANDS all the way from AMRITSAR to ....anywhere in the SIKH World. Jarnail Singh

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Singhani · 24 Dec 2004

How do you know they are in the strib clubs? Practise what you preach.

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Singh123 · 25 Dec 2004

Fateh I believe that committees should consist of amritdhari people and become an example to the rest of the community. I want to mention that I have come aross some amritdhari people who are so arrogant in their thinking and believe that only amritdhari people should run the gurdwaras and the sehajdhari sikhs should be kicked out of gurdwara committees. I do not believe that the solution is to kick the sehajdhari guys out. You never know when Guru Jee may do their kirpa on the sehajdhari individuals and bless them with sikhi. If we kick them out of gurdwara committees, we may deprive them the opportunity to become gursikhs later. However, individuals should be kicked out from committees if they do anything anti-gurmat because in those circumstances the beadbi of guru jee should not be allowed. Amritdhari people do not have a monopoly and should not say that they are better than other people and only they can run gurdwaras. I have come across such people. That is the ideal positon but no way are they superior. I believe that individuals have to go through various stages in life to be blessed with amrit, it is not something that we can have by ourself, the guru jee has to bless us with the gift of amrit. By kicking sehajdhari people out of committees, people may become frustrated and not turn up at gurdwaras etc which is wrong because the whole purpose of Sikhi is to remember god yourself and encourage other people to remember god. Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

<Admin Edit - Inappropriate Name> · 25 Dec 2004

amrtidharees that have ghumaan - haumaii that they are the chosen ones, special in any way, are a thousdand times worse than a humble mona who may have guru jis kirpa nay day and becoem one with him..but an amritdharee's haumaii will always keep him away from guru ji because he falsely thinks he is already there and so no need to try ...just like the hare that slept because he thought he was a winner....and the poor tortoise kept slugging away and finally won the day.. these haumaii bharreh amritdharees just clog their arteries with ghumaan bharee cholestrol and they will die of a heart attack due to over stretching their heart with pride....be humble...humility will win.

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Bundha · 26 Dec 2004

Whatever your name is you are 100% WRONG. Let me guess you are a mona. If a person is amridhari then no matter how off-course he has gone from the true path due to haumai/pride etc etc but he/she now belongs to the Guru, and Guru Ji will put him on the correct path - sooner or later - it may take one life time or many but hs/she is STILL on the correct path. A mono however good he/she is has not taken the first step towards Guru Ji (as Guru Ji commands) so no matter how good he is he will never be liberated.

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

singh · 26 Dec 2004

I cannot speak for Giyanis, but Kirtanees certainly profit at popular gurdwara sahibs esp on Gurburabs. This way the committees attract well known jathe who not only make money from myriad tapes/cds/dvds but also from sangat who give regardless of who's on stage. In an ideal world the giyanis should receive a % of the bheta from the golak or their salary should be sufficient for them to live comfortablly. There does appear to be a hierarchy even within the Giyani fold, where you have the head granthi and then sub giyanis...some who distribute degh, and others who perform rol duties and some do the choar sahib. In major guru ghars, maybe they should have performance related pay, just like teachers, where they teach gurbani/kirtan santhiya to the sangat and get bonuses depending on how well they teach. This will also keep them in jobs longer as they have an cash incentive.

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Sahibzaadeyian dee prernaa · 28 Dec 2004

Veer ji, i fully understand what you have said and respect your feelings as i carry the same since i found the same and that also at the death ceremony of my very young friend's husband's commited suicide. there were various other issues what needed to be discussed at gurdwara and this gyani ji just ended up sayin' aj kul taa chup hi bhalee hai behnji' Our panth is full of diseases that if we start the cure to one, it leaves so many side effects for others. Ardaas to waheguru ji is the only way to me only if we continue atleast on our parts indvidually. hope you agree.lakhvir singh wrote: > WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh! > > Last night, I was at the Gurudwara and I happened to show my > new mobile phone to a close Gyani friend of mine. I lost my > earlier cell phone to theft within the Gurudwara premises (over > a huge smagam where a lot of people lost personal effects that > were left unattended, even for a split second). He asked me how > much it cost and when I told him, his response really made me > sad and disheartened. In a humble muse, he remarked that even > if his whole year's salary was put together, it wouldn't amount > to what my new cell cost me (about US $ 375). You can now > imagine what our Head Granthi earns in a month. It's so sad. > > Is that how poorly paid our Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis are? > I was really saddened and have been thinking about their plight > since last night. This particular Gyani, who is the Head > Granthi of our local Gurudwara, is an amazing guy - so humble, > down-to-earth and loving. He's just like an ideal grandfather. > I have tremendous amount of respect for him because from the > little I know of him, I have come to appreciate the role of > Granthis, Paathis and Gyanis in our Gurudwaras. They are so > selfless and absorbed in their work. So how can Gurudwaras pay > them so little? Do they not deserve better, especially if they > are doing a great job and seva to the Panth? They are ideal > role models, so why are they not taken better care of? Is the > Sangat's charaava not for one of those kinds of purposes? Of > what use is building bigger and more beautiful Gurudwaras when > our own humble sevadaars are not taken care of? At present, > Gyanis are seen by Gurudwara managements like some servants who > are ordered around by those who know not even an iota of Sikhi. > > How can we raise concern about their plight to those who > themselves not ideal Sikh role models (Gurudwara leaders)? I > feel so much for dereseving, selfless Panth Sevadaars who need > at least our respect and understanding, that they too have > dreams and aspirations for themselves and their families. So > why do we hesitate to treat them better? I have come across > enough examples of some really good Gyanis who ended up > returning to India when they openly criticised (in all the > nimarta) the way Gyanis are treated in this country. Many have > gone back feeling so let-down and vowing never to come to this > country. Is this how we treat the Guru's sevadaars? Fine, there > are also some Gyanis who are crooked, but is not the duty of > the Gurudwara management to select only the fully-rehatvaan > ones? > > How do we stand up against this disease in our Panth that is > eating away our Sikhs? How can the Gyanis do their work well > when they are ill-treated (not literally, though) and > underpaid? I'm sure they are demoralised but who do they open > up to who will listen to them? Also, some of them are so humble > to the dust that they cannot muster enough breath to bring it > up. > > Gyanis dererve our respect and care. They are our Guru's > messengers. How can we accord them what they deserve, because > the people who employ them rarely ever understand them and > their important role in our community (and global level, too)? > If we take care of our Gyanis, they can be our ideal > spokespersons and leaders of our Panth, rather than the > chair-sniffing politicians that run our Gurudwaras. > > WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh!

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Gyani Jarnail Singh · 28 Dec 2004

waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Dear Bundha Ji, Thats where I completely DISAGREE with you and the Sants of Taksaal who wrote DT Maryada. Your notion that once a person "becomes an amrtidharee" he is HOME is WRONG. This is Similar to the Christian claim that Once you take JESUS into your heart..You are HOME FREE....GOD will SAVE you no matter what...Your ORIGINAL SIN is now upon Jesu's HEAD..you are clean washed etc etc. Amrit dhaarna is not the same as taking Jesus into your heart and be SAVED FOREVER..no matter how many SINS you COMMIT/Bajjar Kurehits you do/ No matter how many LIFE TIMES it takes GURU JI will SAVE YOU...etc is all a load of... This "false philosophy" is responsible for all the horrible sins and crimes the christians committed on the world in the name of Jesus...who will SAVE them no matter what. Amrit is JUST the FIRST STEP...along the Path to GURU JI...the First DAY in the SCHOOL of KHALSA. If a person registers for school and attends the first day...but then never puts in any effort to study and pass the exams...WILL FAIL. What you are saying is Just REGISTRATION is ENOUGH..no need to attend school at all... the PRINCIPAl (GURU JI) will run after you and try to PASS you through any means possible..that may be possible in the corrupt ridden Indian School system..BUT NOT in GURU ji's School. I dont think any Sikh will be BORN ten thousand times in a Sikh house so that Guru Ji can SAVE HIM just becasue in one life time he attended/ or was forced by his parents to attend/or just followed his friends..etc and took "amrit"...people have a thosuand and one reasons to "take amrit"...and if this is done just as a routine it remains just that. This NOTION of "automatic Saving" is why amrit is being taken so lightly...just take it, and then relax...Guru ji is there for a TEN THOUSAND Janams to take care of you !!! why worry ??? Jarnail Singh

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Bundha · 28 Dec 2004

Gyani Ji, You again misunderstand me. No way am I saying that once you have taken amrit that you are saved, what I am saying is that as soon as you have taken amrit you have taken the first step towards Guru Ji, but you have now been stamped with Guru Ji's ' Mohar ', you have become Guru-wala, and as such the Guru will always look out for you, not so if you have not taken amrit or are a mona etc, in this case you have not taken the first step towards your Guru. No matter how much sewa or good intentioned you are if you have not taken that first step then how can the Guru save you ? YOU have to take that first step to show your commitment to the Guru. <<>> Do you think amrit is taken lightly ??? I would say quite the opposite. Sikhs will not go near amrit as if it is some sort off horrific thing. To take amrit is to make a commitment to your Guru, you have to be kasdhari/no meat/no alcohol/ 5 banis............ you think this is taken lightly? it is no easy feat and for this Guru Ji will look down on you and smile. But, yes if you do take amrit Guru Ji will take care of you, absolutely.

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

kaur12123 · 29 Dec 2004

i do agree banda

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Javir Kaur · 29 Dec 2004

i agree with bundha ji on this one. Amrit is the vital first step...an amrtidharee will have to work hard after taking the first step...BUT one who doesnt even take the First Step cant go anywhere. I too have read the taksaal Maryada and book paath darshan..sant ji does say that Guru ji waill save his sikh and give him birth 10,000 times as a sikh to save him. this is making amrit a joke. gurbani clealry says manukha janam is very very rare..as rare as bird's milk.... so 10,000 janams just to be saved is taking things too far. snat ji is wrong..very wrong. sikhi is asupreme gift from waheguru and coems ONCE...dont take the 10,000 chances lottery being offered...??? make use of THIS JANAM and get muktee.Thats what probabaly what is meant by gyani ji. so in the end bundha ji and gyani ji are in agreement in a way. jasvir kaur

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

kookar-Di-Poochh · 30 Dec 2004

its patently "XXXX" to beleive sant ji really wrote that. thats proof enought hat "brahmgianis" CAN BE WRONG...ONLY GURU JI is ABHULL. Gurbani says again and again and again and again..... .... .... .... ... that MANUKHA JANAM is so PRECIOUS, doesnt come agian, only ONCE, etc etc and here is a brahmgiani who writes that a SIKH will get 10,000 Janams to be SAVED...then WHY BOTHER..... you still have 9,9999 janams to do bhagtee....Drink, womanise and be merry in 9,9999 janams and just use one for namam abahiyaas. WHAT was sant ji thinking ?? Can some Taksali explain ?? Kookar dee poocchh

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Dharamveer Singh · 02 Jan 2005

dont be misled by these 10,000 janams....you only have ONE manukha janam...THIS ONE. dont waste it...." Gobind Milan Ke EH teree BARREEAA..says Gurbani..no other janams...IF there were indeed 9,999 more janams and barriyass Guru ji would ahve said so in GURBANI. not everything a "brahmgiani" says is right..he is only human. dharamveer singh Taksali

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Bundha · 02 Jan 2005

<<<<< thats proof enought hat "brahmgianis" CAN BE WRONG...ONLY GURU JI is ABHULL. >>>> Kooker, you obviously have no idea what stage a brahmgiani is. Try reading Sukhmani Sahib " Brahmgiani aap parmaswar " A brahmgiani stage becomes so high he/she becomes one with God.

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

Jarnail Singh Gyani · 03 Jan 2005

Bundha ji, I dont know about kookar ji..veer?bhen? but i have read sukhmani sahib jee it dosent mention any one's name as to who is a brahmgiani...the "NAMES" are attached by us humans....and once a person is made into a brahmgiani we make him aap parmeshar. Not a SINGLE so called brahmgiani is mentioned by name anywhere in Gurbani. ALL of them came afterwards..and are man made. jarnail Singh

Re: Plight of Gurudwara Gyanis and Granthis

kookar-Di-Poochh · 03 Jan 2005

bundha veer, perhaps it is you who dont know ?... unless you are a self styled Brahmgiani as well.. i have read sukhmani sahib and the entire guru ji...i can see only one brahmgiani...guru ji...no body else...maybe your eyes can see things i cant. based on sukhmani sahib which is used to threaten and frighten innocvent gursikhs into being brahmgiani followers...i dont feel at all thtreatened to declare guru ji the one and only brahmgianai and guru ji doesnt make mistakes....unlike these so many self made brahmgianis who lie, cheat, slander, sign lettters and then say no they didnt etc..i dont give them two cents.... my poocch has been wingee for 12 yeards and it will take some real convincing argument to straighten ti....noioyt the ussual..read sukhmani..baba ji said so,,sant ji says this...etc. sorry no offense meant. kdp