Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise
respectfully · 23 Dec 2004
There is no way around it - it is a compromise.
As much as we may cry about how it is terrible that we have to take off our kirpans in airplanes, we always have the choice of not flying. I could care less what justifications are offered - ie. "A train/bus isn't possible, it takes too long".."It's too expensive (and long) to travel by ship" etc. So what is more important - our Guru ji's hukum or the realities of modern life? The answer is obvious yet we fold like accordians on
Regardless of the other rehits or maryadas we argue about and push as authentic and disagree on, there is no doubting that the kirpan is an essential part of rehit. That the vast majority of us compromise on our kirpans says a fair bit.
respectfully,
Respectfully
Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise
I Say Go For The Boat · 23 Dec 2004
Swimming? Hahahaha that's impossible - you'll be eaten alive by a fish or something - other else drown. hahahaha. try taking a ship full of other sikhs like they did back in the times of the komagatamaru
Go for the boat people ... that way when you touch ground in the country you started from you can officially be called an FOB.
Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise
respectfully · 23 Dec 2004
Funny but I could care less whether you go to India or not, and care even less than that as to your manner of travel. However, you've missed the point entirely.
By choosing to fly to India, you compromise on your kirpan. Is flying to India more important or is your Guru ji's hukum more important? Is swimming to India with your kirpan not a better option than flying to India without your kirpan? The answer depends on whether the realities of modern life are more important to you or Guru ji's hukum is more important....
The only way to resolve this dilemma is by justifying the removal of our kirpans and stating, in one form or another, that sometimes, it is ok to remove our kirpans and that we don't have to keep this kakkar on our person at all times. I'm not sure I buy this line of reasoning.
I too travel via airplane and have to remove my kirpan when doing so and even though I wear a small one on a necklace, I don't consider that to be a kirpan - its something there to soothe my guilty conscience more than anything else. The fact of the matter remains, if my Guru ji's hukum reigned supreme in my heart (and the fore-mentioned justification isn't applicable) than I would forego the removal of my kirpan at the cost of my own life in order to maintain Guru ji's commanded rehit.
I don't have any answer but this is an excellent question, and one I think many of us have been dodging for a while. It may be that someone more learned can offer an acceptable justification or historical precedent or maybe there is a need for self-reflection or maybe we simply have to face the fact we're blatantly disobeying our Guru ji's hukum.
respectfully,
Respectfully
harpreet wrote:
> You want us to swim to india.
Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise
AnotherSingh · 23 Dec 2004
It is different b/c kesh is the most important kakaar.
Without kesh the other kakaars mean nothing.
-I'm sorry, I've forgotten the reference for this. Either Dasam Granth Sahib or Sarbloh Granth Sahib.
Also, once kesh is cut, it takes a long time to grow back. Kirpan can simply be taken off and put back on. Cutting kesh is a kurhait, taking off kirpan is not (not that I'm saying we should).
In addition, I remember reading Bhai Nand Lal ji's writings where he said that a Sikh family loses their honour if their children have cut hair and a family with cut hair regains honour if they grow kesh.
bhul chuk maaf.
Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise
.............................. · 24 Dec 2004
If you doing something like seva or going to India to visit historical gurdhwaras then it would be alrite to temporarily wear the necklace kirpan on the airplane.
Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise
sarjit singhkhalsa · 24 Dec 2004
look at khalistan.com if we have our own country we would have khalistan air line then wewould have not troubles which we facing today so please support council of khalistan
Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise
<Admin Edit - Inappropriate name> · 25 Dec 2004
choree lakh di choree kakh dee...
a miss is a good as a mile...
a fail grade due to just half a mark.....or due to 99 marks less is still a FAIL
a compromise is a compromise.
Fateh Singh could have compromised,,escaped the wall of death...and kept hsi kesh again...after all kesh never stop growing !1but he didnt compromise
Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise
The Rehat Maryada · 27 Dec 2004
If the Kangha, Kara or Kirpan are separated from your body, it is forbidden to eat or drink until they are replaced. Upon the replacement of your missing Kakkar, an Ardas must be performed for the loss and beg for forgiveness. The Ardas may be performed either in a Gurdwara or the place where you are replacing your Kakkar. Having done this, you may eat and drink.
The Rehat Maryada
http://www.damdamitaksal.com/lit_rehat_13.htm
Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise
Manpreet Kaur · 29 Dec 2004
g veerji I'm definetely not the greatest Sikh maybe thats the reason I get down sometimes but when stuffs not going well, nobody understands but God. He knows everything, our deepest feelings, who better to depend on and have love for than Him? He always hugs his children close. Maybe you don't feel the closeness right now or the love, but you will. Gods very close and waiting to love us. Always remember Waheguru. He will support you in everything. Remebering Him and doing your pathe and listening to kirtan will all help bring chardi kala into your life. Guru ji blessed his Khalsa with kakkars for a reason. You say that some people have caused you pain and my only advice to that is to keep to yourself, do as much seva, and build your relationship with God. It doesn't matter what you did in the past, God always forgives his children. Your an amritdharee Singh, God's devotee! Don't forget what you are here for in this world! Always remember our Waheguru and He will embrace you and take all the pain away. You have been given this wonderful life from Guru ji to brake away from pain that your feeling right now and the cycle of birth of death to attain peace. Don't let it go away in waste. Singh ji, you are Guru Gobind Singh ji's son and hes always waiting for you to surrender to him so he can show you the way of truth and peace. Listen to Guru ji's hukam, keep your kakkars on at all times, and don't worry about what others think. Always try to remember our Guru ji. Keep focussed and don't let life bring you down. Dukh and sukh are both blessings from God. Singh ji, I have been at rock bottom in my life, well thats what it felt life and Guru ji changed it around completely :) who knows what you been through or are going through right now, but Guru ji will be your support if you listen to him
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise
Manpreet Kaur · 05 Jan 2005
My brothers wedding is going to be long distance. This is the first time I ever have to remove my kirpan. I don't feeel to goood about this:( Im dreading the whole plane ride already and its 3 months away. im already starting to feel guilty and weird inside about it. Something really has to be, own Plane for Sikhs, something!!!!!:(:(
Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise
Manpreet Kaur · 06 Jan 2005
Maybe I can sneak it in on the plane ride!
Re: The Kirpan /Kesh Compromise
Manpreet Kaur · 09 Jan 2005
Before Sept 11 it was allowed depend on its size or something. Its no longer allowed to be worn though:(