A sample response or statement
Jagjit Singh · 21 Dec 2004
A sample response or statement for local media or friends etc wishing to discuss this issue. Please send in more if you have better ones. ( adapted from a few statements) Dear Sir/Madam I consider myself to be a fair minded person and a Sikh. I am reasonably well educated and always try to understand the other's point of view in any discussion. I have considered the playwrights point of view on this issue and after considering various reasons as to why she would have written this have come to the conclusion that she has quite coldly written the play so as to cause maximum offence to her own community (neatly neutralising any accusations of racism!) and thus raise her own profile as a result of the protests she surely knew would ensue. The writer has simply presented a stereotypical picture of the Asian community, one which I am tired of seeing and would have hoped that an Asian writer would try to correct. As others have pointed out, (fairly or not) the play is not well written, aimless and lacks reality. I would offer the opinion that this was a blatant attempt at publicity for the playwright and the Rep has unfortunately allowed itself to be used in this way. Whilst all plays aim to raise the profile of their creators and generate both revenue (and provoke thought?) surely denigrating a persons faith and the religion as a whole is too high a price for this. In this day and age, we should know and understand how to respect each other. With Freedom must come responsibility. I think that one should draw the line when we are making a mockery of others beliefs. Sikhs are generally a peaceful community as the local Constabulary will confirm - most Sikh festivals and occasions pass without incident, as do Sikh protests including those made against the Indian government in relation to 1984. However, Sikhs have shown throughout history to have a tendency to fight back when put upon, and I believe that is what happened yesterday. However the violence reported on media coverage has been blown out of proportion. More policemen get injured in one hour, while controlling the results of binge drinking every weekend. The protest went on for two weeks very peacefully. One or two people went overboard and it is reported as mass violence. Where is the camera footage of this violence?? At the cancelling of the play the statement receiving media coverage was that "the safety of the audience could not be guaranteed". This statement was propaganda by the theatre. This was not the statement of the Police or the Sikh community. The rep, a publicly funded facility has a responsibility to its environment aswell as the 'integrity'- and I use the term facetiously - of the writer and the message they are trying to convey. I welcome the opportunity to see plays that encourage me to think about issues I may not in everyday life. I do not wish to see that at the expense of others, especially minorities. Sikhs are a very small minority in the UK. They would rightly be worried about being depicted negatively because to counter that there is a lack of positive experiences shared with Sikhs getting media coverage. We don't have a problem laughing at ourselves. 'Goodness Gracious Me' was a good example of Asians having the mickey taken. The Sikhs have one of the greatest histories of any people. They are not against freedoms, they have stood and given lives for freedoms (WW1 & WW2), for all to exist free from persecution and rape. The ninth guru gave his life for the freedom of another religion (Hindus) to express its beliefs freely and without persecution from the Muslim Moguls, But we are being portrayed as anti-freedom of speech by the media. The media coverage was appalling and totally bias. Radio 5 Live said it was an attack on the right to offend. What about balancing it with the right to be offended and as a result the right to protest. Channel 4 said the majority of the protesters were middle-age males. Are they insinuating that females don't feel the same way. That may be Sikhs really are rapists and wife-beaters. This issue is not about freedom of speech. Many powerful groups however, whom are against eroding freedoms brought about by this government in relation to id cards, hunting bill and recent legislation in relation to race and religion want to tie this into that argument. The media naturally is one of these groups. The real issue here is sensationalism, creating backlash, picking a soft in-articulate target and getting media coverage for something which otherwise was a crap piece of work. There was no reason at all to have the play based in a Sikh temple, as it had no bearing on the story whatsoever. As a British Sikh, and one that is proud of it's culture, religion and heritage, I am appalled that, rather than portraying the many rich and diverse aspects of culture and religion, the only way that a play writer can get an audience nowadays is with a cheap and false picture (reflected by the writers corrupt thought patterns). Creating such a play evidently required minimal effort and it is a shame that Birmingham Rep and the writer is relying on "Nick Griffin"-type publicity to get people in the doors. Considering the content of the play and the wider environment of the Rep I find it hard to justify the decision to show the play. If the management of the Rep were unaware of the offence this play would cause, then surely the decision making at that level should be brought into question. I have no problem with Free Speech of people's opinions or beliefs. However, I do believe that this play was written with a message against Sikhism and the sanctity of the Sikh temple, to choose this as the location was insensitive at the least, and manipulative and calculating at worst. All writers write about what they know, after all it lends realism to the end result, but I believe this playwright has substituted controversy in place of talent? If this has led to damage to the Rep as a result, then perhaps something from the Christian Scriptures would be relevant - "For they have sown the wind, and they shall reap the whirlwind.". ~ Hosea 8:7 In this day and age, I would have thought building bridges was a main priority for all, not burning the ropes that are keeping us together with all that is happening in this world. I would have least expected this from a person, who I would have thought, was from a Sikh background. This lady obviously has a chip on the shoulder with Sikhs. This playwright is as much a Sikh as Ian Huntley is a Christian. Religion is not what your born into or you say you belong to. It is all about practicing what your faith teaches. Neither have excelled in that. Mr Gurdip Singh Wakefield