Forum
Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
kulwinder Singh · 20 Dec 2004
Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix caste marriages,
Whether you use your caste base sir name (Bhogal, Dhillion , Ramm, or Sharma ) or not , but do you believe in marriages in the same caste , or do you believe in equality in all other walks of life but marriages is something you prefer in your own caste( if you have one or believe in one .)
What is your opinion? Should we say to children that Sing and Kaur is all that matter if you can find your own love as long as they are Sikh ( regardless of what colour, caste, country or category they from).
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
mR bull quack · 20 Dec 2004
Bhai sahib too many times have i heard this bullquack about caste, please if anythign marry purposely to soemone of the "lower" caste to prove the so called sikhs, that such talk is hughly anti gurmat
inabit
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
.... · 20 Dec 2004
bhaji kulvinder singh caste is not a big thing in young sikhs. The old grandads try to make us stick to it but the youth are waking up from doldrum to sikh spirit wherein lies our strength.
I would much rather marry a person with rehat who i find suitable jeevan with in order to make that work than be dictated by caste boundary. I am lucky my own parents understanding of this but many parents still live century back in their goldie oldie days which are long gone.
The youth are the strentgh of sikhism through them will come change as is evidently erupting the clash between culture and sikhi every here and there.
your question depends on its context. If you mean find a love via dating that is wrong. Its best to leave it for elders to help you find a suitable match.
Once i went gurdwara first time i wore dastaar an elderly lady random came out with "make sure you marry within your own biradri". I explained to her i believe in khalsa and that requires me to see all with the same eye. She then pulled out a photo of sai baba and said she believes more in him. This confirmed to me how lost some of our elders are who should be trying to uplift the sikh panth as muslims do for their panth and help their one grow.
I think it would really help if people of different castes just prayed in one same place. You will always get haters who start spreading malicious info about one group or another. I cant understand why punjabi people have a problem with each other when they are made from the same clay, breathe the same air, eat the same food as the rest of us. Everything should come down to rehat and akhand kirtan jatha/tapoban is fine example of such a variety from different backgrounds.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Mandeep Singh · 20 Dec 2004
regardless of colour, caste or creed and if anyone says any other they are not adhering to sikhi and therefore cannot claim to be one. sikhi is universal with the message of equality whether one is chinese, tarkhan, cuban, white, african, jat etc......
bhul Chuk Maaf Karni,
Daas
Mandeep Singh
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Dhan Sikhism · 21 Dec 2004
I definitley don't believe in caste, its so archaic.. Guru Nanak Sahiab was onto something..
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Gyani JS Dhillon "Arshi" · 21 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
"Caste" is not important..per se..everybody will tell you that.
On another Forum, there is a JATT arguing his nose off that although he "beleives firmly" in Guru Ji's HUKM about No "castes" etc... and also has "total FAITH" in Bhagat Ravidass Ji's GURBANi as equal to all the GURUS..he wouldnt "give his daughter" to even Bhagat Ravidass Ji himself...or allow Bhagat Ravidasss Ji's daughter to marry his son !! He claims Bhagat Ravidass "lost" his caste on a SPIRITUAL LEVEL.... his BLOOD/DNA etc is still low caste !!..
And sadly this is what most people think....on a "philosophical" level/propoganda/empty talk level etc..where ever one is not actually required to "give his daughter /son " to a allegedly low caste..every one will PROUDLY SAY all this empty talk..Haan Ji mae bhee amrtidharee hoon..etc etc. This will happen as long as the AAG is in some body's house... AAgni devta/Besantar Devta when the neighbour's house is on FIRE....but when one's OWN house is burning.... we shout "FIRE' FIRE" and rush to call the FIRE BRIGADE !!! HYPOCRACY rules 99.9% of Sikhs. Those "high castes" who have married into "low castes" can be counted on the fingers....ususally it is "mazboori" of the parents whereby the boy/girl have fallen in love and dont give a heck for anybody's views.....or the parents are desperate and look atn the boy's job/qualification..but have to bear with relatives/friends etc point fingers their whole life...so and so gave his daughter to a chheemba/jhivar.
We are very lucky that in MALAYSIA we have NO CASTE BASED Gurdwaras..not a SINGLE ONE... although in certian places we do have large concentrations of mazhbi sikhs ( One Gurdwara in IPOH Perak has a large number of such but it still NOT called by Caste as in UK) At other places there used to be quite a few mazhbis...and the JATTS of olden days used to have separate PANGAT in the langgar hall for them..slowly that has disappeared..but the "caste" is still a river running underground..
Peiople who have a choice..still Check the PIND/District in PUNJAB..and no one can "ESCAPE" bluffing his way out of that one. That is why as long as PUNJAB exists..no matter where anyone is he can prove his credentials..names "surenames" adopted/invented or otherwise have no value. In Malaysia as yet we have no such "bluffing"...as the Sikhs are just second/Third Generation with strong PUNJAB Background...( Everybody knows everybody else).....but I am aware that in Canada/UK etc there are large numbers of false "Jatts"....and WHY is this..to have "upward mobility" !! and this proves that "SIKHI/GURMATT" plays second fiddle to the "need fro upward mobility" in our Community even though in the west it is EDUCATION ec that should count for more. To a Westerner A Mc Donald is not "superior" to a Kennedy... BUT to a SIKH from Punjab a Ravidassia is defintely lower than a Dhillon ( the very FACT that Ravidassia have "changed" the Name of their Community..they forget that BHAGAT RAVIDASS JI Himself in his GURBANI "humbly" ( TRUTH) says he is a CHAMAAR...BUT no chamaar is willing to say this about himself..instead they "invented" a "honourable" name for themselves !!! On the other hand "chhembaas" are not calling themlseves "NAMDEVIAAS", Julahas are not calling themselves KABEERIAS"... This is only in the SIKH Community..Muslim Chamaars have no problems.
The PUNJABIS and the SIKHS forget that there is NO INTRINSIC VALUE in a Jatt - Dhillon that a Chamaar doesnt have. both are human beings..both can study hard achieve greatness, become rich.. in fact Jatts were no where during GURU Ji's time but have been "elevated" from British Times by deliberate Govt Policy. MY Own Great Grandfather was given a huge piece of land in Jhang for services to the British Army..and in "protest" against that my Grandfather took an active part in the Akali Movement/Gurdwara Sudhaar Lehr....and was a "MLA ( Member of the Legilsative assembly Punjab of the Liaqat Ministry which was essentially a JATT MINISTRY comprising Sikh jatts, Muslim jatts and Hindu Jatts ) BTW my family still lives in MANDI KALAN SANGRUR and the "house of Gopal singh Akali MLA" is easily found...but that is not what i want to say here...what i want to say that the JATT elevation is a fairly recent part of our history...it is just a measure of govt policy...and nothing biological superiority etc as the HINDU BRAHMANWAAD.MANNU logic has led us to BLINDLY BELIEVE. No where else in the world do we have this sort of Problem...our GURU JI tried to eliminate it and free us from OURSELVES..but we have fallen backwards.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
smiles* · 21 Dec 2004
Bhai sahib Randhir Singh has set beautiful examples by getting amritdhari sikhs married from different castes when no one dared ( but within the context of keeping sikh way of life preserved). Bhai sahib was a living example of gurmat.
caste can and will be important in marriage to people who either feel different to other sikhs in the way they are or claim to live/express/ grown up. If sikhs put culture aside and adopted gurmat there would be no differences this goes to all casts terks jats kamboj saini etc. If they were proper sikh no difference.
I approove mix marriage only if both sides are amritdhari and free from castpuna in their respective families so they can adhree to gurmat. I will not encourage mixed caste marriages as that is upto individuals what they choose, the first thing to break through would be castpuna and living according to gurbanis instruction.
there is nothing wrong in marriage of same caste and that doesnt hinder my belief of equality.
Life is hard as it is, i would rather not make it more complicated by finding a partner only of my caste, to me guns in sikhi are more important.
Love in anand karaj should be love for sikh way of life ultimatly to merge with Vaheguru Ji that is what we should seek in a partner not material love but one who wants to help our soul journey.
If the partner is a diff origin you need to take many factors into consideration. Are you going to be living with family or not? This will affect everyone around you if so. Background research on the person, when they came into sikhi, what are their goals out of being a sikh? what would they want from a marriage? how do they envisage a sikh married life? what is right and wrong? if that matches with what you want then get siyaney advice first. BUt i have heard that sometime there is culture clash for exampl, white sikh female marrying punjabi sikh. Female used to western way. But this is something punjabi sikhs will blame the colour or culture. But the same is now happening in punjabi sikhs in western countries as our own girls have a somewhat western effect too. So its not about colour race or caste just how a person is bought up and if that person matches your reuiqrments and you to theirs.
Finally the weird thing is caste is not too much of an issue outside the practicing sikh diaspora. This is despite all the glorifieing of caste songs by jazzy b n co. I think monai are more advancing than us in this regard.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 22 Dec 2004
Everyone will probably attack me for mentioning this, but I feel that Sikhs from the Jatt background are always getting a lot of stick from everybody. I myself am a Jatt, but more importantly, a Sikh first.
It is refreshing to learn from what has been said regarding so called "inter-racial marriages" (if such a thing exists, as we don't believe in caste, right?)
However, I would only agree with this type of marriage if both sides were practising Amritdharis. If a mona Jatt marries a typical English girl, will he not be doing worse than marrying somebody of his same caste as any children they have will be further away from their original roots (the "Indian" couple may one day decide to take amrit, but is it less likely with the goree?).
Another point I would like to make is, from my personal experience, I genuinely believe that 99% of Amritdhari people who are Jatts would not allow their kids to marry non-Jatts, even if they were Amritdhari too. This is obviously a sad matter, as Guru Gobind Singh ji made it quite clear that caste has no place in the Khalsa.
The controversial point I want to make is, aren't Jatts less likely than other groups to "stray" from the Khalsa way of life? Sects such as Narkdhari, Namdhari, Radhasoamis have a large proportion of their followers from these so called "lower castes"- is this because these people feel alienated by the mainstream Sikhs- who are dominated by Jatts? This is certainly the case in many areas of the UK (I cannot comment on Canada, US as I have not been there). Most of the Gurdwaras in England, who stick to Khalsa rehit have a predominantly "Jatt Sikh" congregation.
When I was a child, we lived in an area where the nearest "Gurdwara" was a "Guru Ravidas Temple". Most of the people on our street were monay Jatt families and would go to this temple every Sunday (it was also convenient as lack of cars etc meant it was easier to get to) and sat with so called "chamaars" without any discrimination whatsoever. However, after operation blue star, the local Gurdwaras organised transport to get to London to protest against this sacrilege outside the Indian Embassy. Guess what- the "Guru Ravidas temple" committee didn't want to go. This led to the whole street boycotting this temple and starting to to the Guru Nanak Gurdwara which was afurther distance away. We all know the next pattern of events, which saw many monay Sikhs (mostly Jatts) who were clean shaven and heavy drinkers, growing their kes and taking Khande ki pahul.
I hope I have not offended anybody with these comments, bhul chuk maaf.
Gur fateh
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Gyani JS Dhillon "Arshi" · 22 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
smiles says:
Finally the weird thing is caste is not too much of an issue outside the practicing sikh diaspora. This is despite all the glorifieing of caste songs by jazzy b n co. I think monai are more advancing than us in this regard.
Yes this caste thing doesnt seem to be a such a "big issue" among MONAS ??
Perhaps this is because the "Amritdharees" and even more so the "PAKKA Amrtidharees" have created NEW "castes"...such as "pooran Hazoori Singh", Akal Takhtee / sgpc Singh", "Taksali Singh" " AKJ Singh" "Patna Sahib singh" Baba this and baba that Singh"....based on who and which panj Jatha one took Amrit from. People are so "proud" of telling where and which "gurdwara or takhat" they took Amrit from..in an effort to show off their superiority !!! This is not a dig at anybody...we can pretend it doesnt exist and bury it under the carpet..but the stink will still haunt us. Sorry to be so blunt but reality is there.
Monai have dropped the visible symbols of Sikhi.....and they dont think two hoots about dropping caste as well ??
My personal experience with many many people i have met over the years shows the above comment about amrtidharees is true...instead of helping us to become better Sikhs, we become even worse as the haumaii of "amrit" comes into play. The monai are not bluffing or simply crying bluff when they say the "amritdharees" groups look "down" on them as "inferior", "failures" etc... To me the only difference between this Mannu caste and new caste system seems that in the Amrtidharee system, a mona can gain acceptance as UPOWARD MOBILITY by becoming an Amrtidharee of the GROUP he wants upward mobility in ( by this I mean even becoming an amrtidharee will not bring automatic Upward Mobility If one failed to choose the "correct takhat/baba/dera/taksaal etc"...but in the mannu caste system one remains a low/high caste by BIRTH and can do nothing about it. a sgpc amritdharee will always be looked down by some other supposedly better dera/ amritdharee ( i am living in this world and this is not imaginary)
I am also an Amrtidharee and have a vested interest in bringing in hundreds of children into Amrit...so I am not in the business of downplaying the importance of Amrit and "supporting" monas....but there is no smoke without fire and we must rethink...there is a serious "shortcoming" in our attitudes. These must change.
jarnail Singh
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
. · 23 Dec 2004
pardeep singh ji theres no reason why anyone should attack you. No particular group/caste should be blamed. Had the case been ONLY jats then fair enough but its not.
To your point concerning jat marries english girl, this would be only relevant as far sikh and non sikh go.
Now marriage of sikhs within different castes then would sikhi be gauranteed in future?
That depends on both the man and woman aspirations spiritual/temporal and their goals of liberation and commitment through amrit. However i know of many jatha families who have mixed marriages one such family 3 amritdari daughters all married happily to 3 amritdari males from entirely different castes and they have children already blooming in gursikhi life.
The jatha is probably one of the most diverse groups in sikhi at the moment. Its all about gursikhi values and taking amrit.
One doesnt become a khalsa by taking amrit, khalsa is a state that we strive for no matter what caste you come from.
Interesting controversial point pardeep singh ji. Radaswamis deras now have a large proprtion of duabey jats from england from the 90s onwards ask anyone affiliated.
Nirankaris have a varied base from all religions countries and races in india and abroad their annual samagams stretch hundreds of thousands from whites blacks asians christians hindus muslims sikh ( so called or ex sikhs) tamils.
The radaswami guru is a dhillon jat and his right hand bodygaurd is a johal jat. In the 80s it was a flocking call for lower castes who streamed out of singh sabhas to rs . Most of my own relatives are recently radaswami affiliated. I have managed to stop my grandmother converting 4 years ago after we did a dual visit to Darbar Sahib and then to beas.
Namdaris have gained significant numbers from diaspora sikhs in africa. The african diaspora of the 60s was predominantly terkan, had it been other castes im sure the same could have happened living 100 years in alien lands its easy to stray but then again we have great sikhs from africa too Gyani Amolak singh ji, Puran Singh ji etc .
Now a large number of sikh youth both male and female are turning towards islam and smaller cases christianity/jehovas witnesses from all castes incuding jats in england. This would not be possible on scale in canada due to the sheer dense concentration of sikhs and punjabi jats in 2 3 key areas.
Jats constitute bulk 70% of sikh population and more than often live in homogenous societies brampton surrey southall hounslow derby gravesend west brom so n so. while the rest are smaller minute numbers hence why the picture looks distorting that jats are less likely to stray from khalsa life, and more so that jats are more khalsa affiliated.
I see no reason excuse why people convert into these sects. I hardly think someones going to become a radaswami from a lower caste because their alienated by jats in sikhi when the radaswami guru himself is a jat, even the resthouses and particular seva is allocated according to your caste.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
. · 23 Dec 2004
good number of all kinds in gnnsj and akj majority khalsa. if we look at minor differences then we should perhaps start the ones we have have major differences like nihungs majority of whom are jat and are told to drink from seperate bhattey from mazhabis chautha paahr summit and only khatri gets to be the supreme commander.
Of course we can pick and choose all day till we are blue in the face this way or that way to bash jat and non jat which keep subtle borders. The fact of the matter is we need direction unity and that should come from all corners the way it did in Guru Sahibs time. 4 doors for all humanity. In unity lies a lot.
What cast is left if your melted in naam rang? if you had a daughter to marry you have a got choice between a pooran rehat gursikh from another caste or a dikavah vala in the same? Just scenario! i would rather my kid marry a chardi kala gur ka sikh that means caste is no issue ( to me at least).
In pakistan punjab the jats were 3 times more in number than sikh jats, the muslim jats, rajas, and lilaris frequently intermarry. They are over the punjab hurdle and more pan islamic. Even if they refuse to marry ex south indian mohajirs ( which i think is due to racial characteristics). Sikhs cant even get over hurdle 1 yet with fellow punjabi sikhs yet.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Rain drop · 23 Dec 2004
I do not object intercaste marriages;
But what additional benefit we get from "within caste" that,
a similar environment, is assured.
A non jat girl from a city finds totally different environment and moods, when she is married to a jat farming family.
A German lady may find suffocation in Pakistan with Muslim family. (Crickter Imran case).
"nature and life style" of course differ with some castes(generally). Castes in India, at least, are linked to style of living and thinking.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
singh · 23 Dec 2004
Pardeep Singh wrote' Most of the Gurdwaras in England, who stick to Khalsa rehit have a predominantly "Jatt Sikh" congregation.'
It's strange that so called Jats are preyed on time and time again for promoting caste segregation when they have no Gurdwaras named after them.
Rather, tarkhans have Ramgharia names and chamaars Ravi Dass for their respective Gurdwaras..
As far as I know most ppl in the Jatha in the UK at least have married within caste. However attitudes are slowly changing and the youth in particular are marrying into other castes.
What one should do is find a partner strong in their rehat and obviously baptised.
People in India are still following caste as they do not believe that the lower castes lead a clean lifestyle and there are big social differences. This mindset has been carried over to the West.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
kulwinder Singh · 24 Dec 2004
How about saying if you ask cast when choosing a partner in life it breaches the contract between Guru and Sikh and if you are not Sikh then you do what you want to do, just do not claim to be Sikh. because guru will be distance from you for sure, Jeh eh karie bipran kee reet mai na karoo in kee parteet. and their is no other more evil bipran kee reet then cast system.
Also one person has said that the Dating is bad ? why all dating mean is meeting somebody, Guru do want you to make a good decision, how on earth you will find somebody is right for you otherwise ?
Should Major Jathes have protocol in the functions to say openly all the time that a Sikh should marry a Sikh and the cast is completely irrelevant to Sikhs ? If this is said all the time in the temples then our kids may start having more moral support to get rid off this evil casteism as Guru's want us to.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Gyani JS Dhillon "Arshi" · 24 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
Veer Kulwinder Singh has hit upon a very good idea.
Every Samagam/rehn sabaii/jord mela/akhand paath etc should ahve at least 10 minutes devoted to bringing this to the sangat's attention.
Devote another 10 minutes to condemning ALCOHOL and Bhangra Dancing in the streets during weddings.
Bring all this out into the open where everyone can be constantly reminded that GURU JI doesnt put any VALUE on Caste...but on Kirt Kamaii of Naam.
2. Another thing that my friend Kirpal Singh brought up in an article is that we should make it COMPULSORY that in an Akhand Paath there should eb at least FIVE SINGHS/KAURS present at all times. IF the Granthi/Paathi is left ALONE with GURU JI then he should be able to STOP this BEADBI of GURU JI by putting a Rumalla over Guru Ji and going home. Its beadbi of GURU Ji and just brahmanwaad to carry on Akahnd apath of GURBANi with NO ONE present.
3. About thirty years ago in a small town where I was "paathi" while on School holidays, when I came for the 4am-6am raol, I noticed that the paath was at Panna 1370..with only 60 pannas left. The preceeding paathi told me to take it very very slowly as BHOG was at 9.30 am as no sangat would arrive before 10.00 am. In my youthful barvado, I carried on my normal sped of 30 pannas an hour...and began the BHOG ALL ALONE in the Gurdwara Sahib BB and when the Bhog was completed I did ardass and went home. When the first of the "sangat" began to straggle in around 9.30..they were astonished to see everything quiet and not as susual when the granthi doing the bhog would be droning away word by word lengthening each word to make it last as long as possible.... They learnt their lesson.... firstly I was BANNED from their Gurdwara as paathi....and secondly they decided that from henceforth all akhand paaths would begin at 7.am so that bhog could be around 6.30...I went back to school to finsih my HSC. ( i maintain i did the right thing as Guru Ji and I were the only ones present and why should we wait unnecessarily for late comers )
Jarnail Singh
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
hm · 24 Dec 2004
I do know a good number of jatha sikhs from the london surrounding areas that are now mixed jaat marriage in the past 5 years. Yes the parents are in mazboori situation and yes it may be a case of one sikh choosing another but in the cases i have seen majority have worked out fine and the parents come to acept it in the end.
The answer to above is their future sikh children would be even more khalsa like because they have no caste culture on their side.
Youngsters are now choosing their own partners we are powerless to stop that. If your child wishes to choose their own sikh partner living with Guru Jis ideals should we support them or prevent them?
Someone above has mentioned Bhai Randhir singh had people married into different jaats can this be verified please?
If we stuck to the same jaat then whats the bigger picture of the sikh future, seeing that one jatha is dominated by one jaat another to another? suppose you get a child from a different jaat wants to become a jatha singhani singh, they put years of their lives into gurmatt. In marriage sorry but your the wrong jaat none can do , mariage is supposed to be a big part of sikhi. So then that person goes into another jatha where they dont have that problem. As this happens wont we see polarisations of different jaats dominating different jathas thereby increasing division than bridging the gap?
If polarising increases as we can see with one groiup difference from next then where will we end up?
What would be Guru Gobind Singh jis answer to this?
We live in a world of stereotyping. A large number of delhi jats are city dwellers please visit khyala region thats a jatt stronghold in delhi. Theres this picture that we make out that all other castes tend to be city people while we come from villages. Its true in some cases and not in others. Many lower backward castes do live in villages but without actually owning lands and in small numbers hence their presence is felt less. Even depends on which punjab region you come from some are heavily jatt concentrated some are mixed but still pinds.
Habits, features, traits vary from region to region rather than jaat to jaat in some cases. I have kashmiri cousins who are more like kashmiris,gurdaspuria cousins who sturdy built like west punjabis/afghans and delhi cousins look a bit darker.
How many of us farm in england?
jemima khan entered one extreme to the next from a high city life with everything to a life behind doors. One extreme to the next is bound to fail because its not natural. However is that case to sikhs?
How different are we in england? our grandfathers camne here in 1950s we livein the same 3 bedroom houses, enter the same education system live on the same streets, bought up together in same schools. How different is our lifestyle here and now that would be miles apart in marriage? However there is a lifestyle difference between proffesionals, ordinary factory workers, and bussinessmen families within all castes.
Surely if we were so different we wouldnt have a high number of divorce cases in arranged marriages within the same jaats.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
sikh · 24 Dec 2004
If the aim is to live a khalsa life then what does it matter what caste you are? In the jatha one amritdhari marries another so both owe their everything to Guru. But it looks to me some are using outside mona type cast cultures but are we jatt durkan once we take amrit? we aint we are sikhs of Guru.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
bad world · 24 Dec 2004
What does the Akhal Takhat say on mix cast marriage?
I can relate to whats written up above. When i was looking to get hitched i spread the word when it came to amritdari families they had blank expressions i didnt get anywhere. I thought hey am i that ugly? lol
Then i was forced to change my position and accept rishte from chunni vali bibis and now their families were not amritdhari.
Sometimes it sucks and i wish i was born into the caste where i could easily find my match, maybe its my bad karam to be born in the wrong caste.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
kulwinder Singh · 24 Dec 2004
Dear Gyani JS Dhillon "Arshi"
I am please to see your enthusiasm to get rid of the negative and evil in the society, but I am bit amazed by your mentioning of ALCOHOL and Bhangra Dancing in the streets during weddings, to the same level as the pure evil of caste system, Cast is brahmanwad, it put rifts among the Sikhs,
So far I have not seen Dancing in the street putting rift in the community, or alcohol making segregation, Alcohol is bad for everybody as losing one's balance or mind can not be good. but it is still an evil attached to an individual or a family rather then the whole community. your intolerance of bhangra on the streets to me seem very out of tune with the crisis in the sikhi. it is like some body is starving to death and somebody while want to address that also want to say something about the colours of the plates in which we are going to feed the hungry.
More we open our eyes to real principles which weaken the Sikhs, the more you will find brining people is far more important to have a
common good platform rather then pointing out people for their personal weakness which are bad but bad for them and their families, To bring people together deal with the major issues, first save the house from fire then think or decorating as you want later.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Gyani JS Dhillon "Arshi" · 25 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh.
Veer Kulwinder Singh ji,
Alcohol consumption and related Bhnagra dancing are part and parcel of the linked chain of caste that we are trying to break free of.
At some real "Amrtidharee" Anand Karajs which I have personally attended, whereby Caste per se was not a consideration on the part of both parties...ALCOHOL consumption and bhangra dancing etc was also a DEFINITE NO NO...In fact there was NO WEDDING DINNER etc and instead a JORD MELA Samagam at the Gurdwara with sehaj paath da Bhog/Kirtan/ Guru ka Langgar was the Norm. The age old adage.... the "weakest link" in a CHAIN is the WEAKEST SPOT holds true...any link that we break in this chain...will weaken the chain for good and for good measure we must attack ALL the LINKS.
IF "Alcohol consumption and Bhangra dancing Parties" is NOT "brahmnawaad". while CASTE IS.......OK I accept..Your Point......BUT it is NOT GURMATT either.... so should we accept these ?.
Secondly all these are interconnected in another way.... you see it is an accepted fact that the "higher" your caste...the more Foonfah you have at your wedding.... so alcohol, bhangra djs dancing singers invited, hundred and one foods catered, Marriage palaces, hotels, etc etc are all there to IMPRESS people...when the Namdhari babas advocate simple marriages of Rs 1.25, there is no caste/food catered/marriage palaces/bhangra/djs/singers/ expensive milni gifts/etc etc .
Sadly I must agree with you on the plate colour thing. Do you beleive there are actually people who will refuse to be served in any plate other than sarb loh.....in that case I would fondly like to beleive that these people have also dropped caste from their life..if they havent then the sarb loh is just a dhong....so "colour/Metal of plate " is also part of the same chain that has caste in it as a link.
Drinking and bhangra dancing are part of the norm of the community and are fast becoming a COMPULSORY NORM..which parent will dare to have his son/ daughter's wedding without these..who wants to bear with the sniggering looks and cheapskate title..Individuals are powerless to drop these outward symbols of "richness"...the COMMUNITY as a WHOLE MUST DROP them for everybody.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
<Admin Edit - Inappropriate Name> · 25 Dec 2004
DRUGS ALCOHOL and BHANGRA are collectively very BAD for the entire COMMUNITY and not only individuals.
Look at how drugs are destroying the very fabric of Punjabi Society..how can a DRUG ADDICT be a good Khalsa Singh ?? Is it a individual problem.
When an insect attacks only the Leaves" of the plant..the farmer still sprays the whole plant ( even the entire khet)...he doesnt sau this is an "leaf problem" lets worry about the rest of the tree.
Individual singhs make up the community....if a singh drinks and dances in pubs how on earth is he going to make a good singh ??
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
number 1 · 25 Dec 2004
farming communities?
lobanas own land and farm from the border to jullanthar, sainis chauhan rajs and kambs farm.
saying jats are more khalsa seems like an excuse. Makhan shah lobana, shaheed jinda and sukha, chamkaur battle, etc etc im not gonna go into caste on this one but work it out for yourselves.
Most of asia lives on farming, patels and south indians own land and farm.
So going by the reason farming communities are more like patels hu would be more like jats than other castes would. But you no patels are not.
Desperate attempts to preserve race and culture in a religion like sikhi with the wind of time is utterly disasterous then you will end up with loose cannons firing back like bhatti and and the rest.
You cant dictate vipran ki reet limits in a society in the west. If you live by the gurus path your offspring will respect you for it. I can count xxx of students who are more disgusted at their parents for being into caste at home and then putting on a sikhi face in society. What does caste generate? haumai.whats the biggest rog?
Those third generation sikhs at logger head with their families end up getting more distant, confused, and finally leaving to shape their own destiny cos quiet frankly this is not punjab anywmore universities colleges means your daughters and sons get to see different people, and those different people are not like our parents and some of us here make out. their families wont even let their kids think for themselves. So think very carefully where these caste excuses will take us. We will loose more than gain.
Is it worth it for a name that only lasts one life? or something that goes beyond life after life and benefits the jeend of the panth.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
hm · 26 Dec 2004
Those singhs who are still undacova into jaat you know its breaking down why dont you just accept guru jis teachings? What do the rehatnamas say on marriage? You know you cant hold onto jaat forever.
Are you any better than those people who open gurdwaras on cast? Both of you are trying to keep jaat alive alongside sikhi.
To categorise people not from your caste shows me that you feel other sikhs are not the same as you.
The irony! Here we are battling against the media, society to show them please dont label sikhs as fundamentalists, fanatics, or mistake us as bin ladens. Yet we on the other hand are very fast to put other sikhs into categories when it suits us.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
this topic is a joke · 26 Dec 2004
Going by the above we are now going to ignore singhs and kaurs for taking amrit and still hold their caste against them? What about Janam naash?Sharam Naash? This means such people do not believe in the status of khandey bhattey amrit, that gurbani, living according to gurmat doesnt change a person and that person no matter what they do still remain a chumar nai khokar cheema in spite of taking amrit.
the point is not that ravidaaas followers, namdev temple are straying from khalsa baptism and having opened their own gurdwaras BUT that whosoever comes from such groups and partakes in amrit from the same bhatta and lives by the same rehat will be discriminated against on account of the caste they were born into for which they had no control over. is this khalsa or brahmincal?
The chardi kala paratun sikhs are only known as flana singh flana kaur. Then the british land act comes along all of a sudden an explosion of jaat paat and heritage status.
Guys come on! Before that act we were from different groups. This notion about sticking to cast is a myth based on two facts. 1)Punjabi groups have been marrying into different ethnic groups throughout its entire history to end up with what we have now. 2) before the b land act, coming from different groups, we are still marrying those groups but under the false notion they are the same caste. So in effect we are a cross bred result of different castes already. What we hold onto is a) Title and family honour b) man made mut.
The kattarness on this issue is beyond a joke! None of us are pure whatever castes we think we are. Even in addition to that, in all the wars, holocausts, tyranical empires that sikhi endured do you think women were left alone by moghuls, afghans, brits, when singhs were massacred? there were no abortions, if every single woman would jump in a well for this thing we call "khandani izat" would we have had any women left to carry the faith on? Yet we are proud saini jat turkan cheema blah.
The facts are punjab is a gateway to asia we are mixed bunch of people from the start to now. the only thing that prevents our eka is these bs little culture traps that need to be replaced with amrit.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
kulwinder Singh · 26 Dec 2004
DRUGS ALCOHOL and BHANGRA, I would say Bhangra is no way near (Actually light years away from Drugs and Alcohol) in it damages( if any one could please printout what are those damages are ? ) to society, I agree that drugs and alcohol are potentially harmful to society if it goes out of hand, but still think on just personal level it is far less harmful then alcohol on moderation ( you should make a difference between users and abusers of alcohol rather then one blanket to cover all, I have many friends who drink but never ever get mindless drunken to be abusive, I would hate to say those people are equally bad as somebody who believe in caste system to me the whole idea is strange), yes drugs I agree with as evil as it make people dependent on them.
also dear admin Ji
you say
"When an insect attacks only the Leaves" of the plant. the farmer still sprays the whole plant ( even the entire khet)...he doesn’t say this is an "leaf problem" lets worry about the rest of the tree."
on the concept I agree with you but let's make sure we do not burn the plant or poisoned the plant with our puritanical Brahman Wad because that is too harmful for the common good of humanity and Sikhs are part and parcel of humanity,
Let the minor differences of personal choices do not create a kind divisions in the society, let's bring people together rather then look down on others, let's encourage others to engage in principle maters rather then demonising who chose to be bit different from us.
Let's understand and fight the pure evils like lack of knowledge rather then just individual issues not to say if the individual issues are engulfing the whole society then it has to be sorted too. but channel your energies well to get to the point or at lease near to where Gurus want us to be.
Thanks
Kulwinder Singh
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
p kaur · 27 Dec 2004
JoSikhaKoPucheJaatSohSikhNahiMeroAadJugaad
Those who ask a sikh's caste, they are not my sikh, they never were, and they never will be
--Sache Patsha Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
sikh · 27 Dec 2004
Sikh Reht Maryada - Published by Dharm Parchar Committee Amritsar
page 26 reads
"Anand Sanskar
a) A sikh man and woman should enter wedlock without giving thought to the prospectives spouse's caste and descent."
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
sikh · 27 Dec 2004
1)
http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=5826
pairee(n) pai paakhaak hue gurasikhaa(n) vich vaddee samaaee
Falling at and becoming the dust of the feet is the great trance for the Sikhs of the Guru (their caste should not be considered).
2)
http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=5559
eaekas thae bahu roop karoopee ghanae dhikhaaeae
By getting divided into myriad sects(and castes) they produced a horrible look.
kalijug a(n)dhar bharam bhulaaeae ||aa||
They all were deluded by kaliyug.
3)
http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=5563
chaarai pair dhhara(n)m dhae chaar varan eik varan karaayaa||
Dharma was now established on its four feet and all the four castes (through fraternal feeling) were converted into one caste (of humanity).
4)
http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=5565guramukh varan avaran hoe niv chalai gurasikh visaekhai||
The special feature of the Sikh of the Guru is that he goes beyond the framework of caste-classification and moves in humility.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
... · 27 Dec 2004
Some sikhs are under the illusion The ten bodies of our Gurus only preached for spiritual equality.
A manuscript written by Ahmed Shah Batalia in 1818 AD ( Twarikh E Hind)
and partly published by sohan lal suri in his history book as an appendix to the first volume also mentions the incident of the creation of the khalsa.
It reads interalia:
" I Guru Gobind Singh wish you all to embrace one creed follow one path, rising above all differences of the religion as now practiced. Let the four hindu castes who have different dharms ( faiths) laid down for them in the shastras ( holy book of the hindus), containing institutes of the varnashramdharma, abondon them altogether, and adopting the way of mutual help and co operation, mix freely with one another....
Let men of four castes recieve my baptism of the double edged sword , eat out of the same bowl, and feel no aloofness from, or contempt for one another."
The Guru by raising his disciples to his own level and by abolishing the disctintion between himself and the khalsa, established complete equality of expression and thought with his community of sant soilders. He organised a socio political body of the spiritually awakened but earth aware people who were to spearhead the movement for the liberation of a whole society. He transformed the whole socio political set working alongside the people and for the people in the interests of the whole people in every sphere of their lives."
"Gobind (Guru Gobind Singh) had thus abolished social disctinctions ( by mixing all the hindu castes and muslim social classes) and had taken away from his followers all the useless rituals and superstitions."
Jd Cunningham
Gurmukh Nihal Singh
Ye shall love man as man making no disctinction of caste and creed.
- Guru Gobind Singh
Namdariye deliberatly arrange variety caste marriages to eliminate the social evil. This has united them further and prevented them from opening caste only namdari deras within. Not full of praise of any sect, however they have outdone sikhs on an important unification ideal which is not a prerequisite but does help create that equal society to which we strive to create which may bloom to end time. Radasuamees on the other hand have broken into different sects in agra and punjab.
One vital point modern deras use sweetness, diversity modernisation tactics used by sects to pull in followers while we remain stuck to 19 th century constructs (rise of political aristocracy snubbing minorities) in our own instituitional set up.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
kulwinder Singh · 27 Dec 2004
I agree totally that the pump and show off at the marriages is not in line with the Sikh’s core principles of living in modesty and we should all encourage others to avoid such time, money and effort wasting thing in life.
But my point was that Alcohol , Drugs and Strangely Bhnagra is not an evil of same stature as caste system.
I know so far three marriages where, non of this happened one was my friend got married and he had simple Anad Karage and after words a religious song singer came and sang the Bir Ras Poems while every body had lunch in a hall, other one was where a AKJ guy got married in the Gurdawara and after eating lunger everybody when home, and thirdly my own wedding we just did the Anad Karag in Gurdawara and after the lunger most people went home, some came back to my in-laws house for simple tea, I think my whole wedding must had cost around £200 including path done by own family at home.
Dear Arshi Ji
You said “you see it is an accepted fact that the "higher" your caste...the more Foonfah you have at your wedding.... so alcohol, bhangra djs dancing singers invited, hundred and one foods catered, Marriage palaces, hotels, etc etc are all there to IMPRESS people...â€
Your statement including " fact that" words put a question mark in my mind which put some shadow on you ability to rise above the caste system. ( If I am wrong then apology other wise you must sort this in your own mind. My comments have been enforced by the fear that you have not completely
Left the system and still believe subconsciously that higher casts have some specially privileges, duties, style or status to maintained, which is complete rubbish, what if a lower caste person is finically far more well off then higher caste and show off far more in weddings then somebody who is higher caste but is no way near in finical terms to the other one, how can you say then what you have said as fact?
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
kaur · 28 Dec 2004
caste is very outdated. I will purposely marry in another caste just to break free from this hindoofied serpent.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Javir Kaur · 29 Dec 2004
i second that kaur bhen ji. way to go. IF we the new geenration stick our necks out our parents and the oldies cannot do anything..
i am a kmboj and i married a jatt...everybody who was somebody in my relatives were making unsavoury noises..tsk tsk etc but i ddint care and went ahead anyway. i am very very happy.
jasvir
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
decide which side of the line · 29 Dec 2004
what do you think is the grand significance shown by SatGuru Sachey Patshah Gobind Singh Ji of putting one head of a Panj Pyara Ji on another Panj Pyaras Ji body?
Account of Abu Al Traafi (auranga spy turned ajmer singh)
Bhai Dya Ram came forward to Guru Ji. Guru Ji right in front of all, cut off his head from the body in one stroke. Every body present was stunned. Then Guru Ji again thundered and demanded one more head. Right on Guru's call, Dharam Chand got up, came to Guru Ji, bowed his head and said here is my offering of my head. Guru Ji, again, in one stroke cut off Dharam Chand's head from his body.
Now there was a big commotion in the Diwan. But Guru Ji in his thundering voice went on demanding heads, one after the other. Himmat Rai, Mohkam Chand and Sahib Ram got up and offered their heads. Guru Ji cut off the heads of these three also.
Many from the congregation went to Guru Ji's mother, and narrated the whole happenings in the Diwan to Mata Ji.
Guru Ji cleaned up the blood from the five bodies and heads, and even washed the floor, Then the Guru of these infidels, STITCHED ONE HEAD WITH OTHER BODY, one by one. This process took about three hours. Then he covered these dead bodies with white sheets.
Eyewitness Account of Vaisakhi 1699(From Urdu Pamphlet)
Gyani Dalip Singh "Komal" of Dhaunola informed that this book is lying in the archives of Aligarh University."
you have bani, Rehat maryada, Akhal Takhat, a crystal clear eyewitness acccount of 1699 and common sense as logical guides to this entire issue.
Ask yourselves the pros and cons of amritdari ( khalsa ) different caste marriages.
Are we to remain turkans jats nais after amrit?
How will this impact the sikh faith in changing conditions under which we live?
(as stated by another post genetics and punjabi castes may not be fact but on the preconcieved idea they are)
a) Is it biologically an advantage or disadvantage for a gene spread?
b) Does a genetic spread hinder the spiritual progress of sikhi within an individual? If it does, how about the countless punjabi muslims and former cross hindu classes, who became sikhs in early days of sikhi during which sikhi flourished?
c) Didnt Guru Gobind Singh abolish the notion of bioligical genes in one hit by joining different heads with different bodies?
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
singh soorma · 29 Dec 2004
It looks like some of us want to be part of hindu caste system all over again.
To the hindu caste lovers your in the wrong religion and your either born into good houses and use sikhi for your own vested interests and you will NOT go far Guru Ji does NOT bless brahmin followers. Reassess what your commitments to the SIKH NATION are! Is it for your own mukti sake? Or to bring sikhi onto the global forefront with miri piri for singhs and singhanis.
If you are not attuned to the spirit of the Timeless its time to comprehend yourselves and make changes. With or without you Sikh Religion moves on.
Sikhi is meant to grow while you hold onto ancient caste system created by manu the brahmin?. Thats right your bowing to manu.
That dastar on your sehr is not worthy while you bow to manus hindu instructions.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Javir Kaur · 30 Dec 2004
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji Ki fateh.
Guru nanak ji ABOLISHED CASTE... in GURBANI....and by personal example
Guru Angad Sahib jee Abolished caste.... same as above and establishing Guru ka Langgar
Guru Amardass Ji Abolished caste... by following all the above
Guru Ram dass Ji abolished caste.... by all the above and building sarovars for all to bathe together/drink together
Guru Arjun Ji abolished caste..
Guru hargobind Ji abolished caste..
Guru har rai ji abolished caste..
Guru Har Krishan Ji abolished caste..
Guru teg bahadur Ji abolished caste....
Guur Gobind Singh Ji abolished castes dramatically... MIXED UP BODIES/HEADS ( according to one account above...I wonder why we still refer to his MUSLIM NAME before we write his SINGH NAME ...to "prove" our story is true !! Would the story be any LESS "TRUE" IF a SINGH wrote it ?? I wonder )
ALL the BHAGATS ABOLISHED CASTES..
AFTER 500 YEARS.. we still HAVE CASTE.... ???? WHO is STRONGER... "caste" or "our SIKHI" ?? the answer is obvious .... ALL that hard work of cutting off the heads and mixing them up ( never mind the different blood groups/immune rejection of foreign body parts/ etc etc..and the FACT that "CASTE" is All in the HEAD....( I am a "THIND" and no matter on how many bodies MY HEAD is TRANSFERRED TO I will REMAIN a THIND....because what is Below the NECK is a no-thinking piece of FLESH/BONE..) I have full faith in mY GURU JI... he doesnt need to cut, wipe blood, stitch for THREE HOURS etc etc...HE can DO anything in the BLINK of an EYE...) We dont edd to Physiacally transfer our heads.. we need to Change our MIND SET in the head we have on our shoulders.
Sorry no offense meant to anyone.
jasvir Kaur
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Jaat Part 1 · 30 Dec 2004
the madness of belief in castes has a very strong hold in Sikhs! In one hand the propagators of the Sikh Dharma mouth platitudes about a casteless society preached by the Masters, but on the other hand, they practice it madly. What a paradox and hypocrisy!
Per Gurmat, any one who believes in Jaat-Paat cannot be a true Sikh; for the castes only relate to the body; not to the Self (Soul, Spirit or Truth). In other words, the caste-conscious person is a material being (Manmukh) who has confounded the Self for the physical body
The Gurbani (Sri Guru Granth Sahib, SGGS) roars that the madness of false pride of caste results in two things: Sin and corruption. In spite of such strong warnings and consequences, majority of the Sikhs are inflicted with this grave disease of Jaat-Paat. Having said that, it should be of no surprise to see the prevalence of sin and corruption in the society
All living entities are under the influence of the three modes of Maya's material nature (illusion, conditioned mind, ignorance, duality, etc.). It clings to everyone except the spiritual beings. It affects mortals many ways. And one of the ways Maya snares us into its illusion or hallucination is through our false pride of caste.
Aachaar biyuhaar biaapat ih jaat: It (Maya) impinges upon us through our charactor, occupation, and caste (sggs 182). why so many living entities are engulfed by the razing fire of madness of false pride of caste? It is so because the mortals, due to ignorance, identify themselves with the material body instead of the real Self. A spiritually blind cannot understand this. Why? Because the casteless Infinite Consciousness that the Gurbani talks about is not the subject of unmeaning rituals, lip worship, garbs, ceremonies, mundane history, culture, outer looks, material logic, scholarship, and speculations. Only a Gurmukh or a True Sikh — a Self-realized person — knows it.
Jaat ajaat ajonee sambhayu na tis bhayu na bharmaa: The caste of God is castelessness; He is unborn, self-illumined, without desire and doubt (sggs 597).
Gurmukh jaat pat sach soi: God is the caste and honor of the Gurmukh (sggs 560).
Ekam ekankaar niraalaa. Amar ajonee jaati na jaalaa: The Unique Lord is Peerless, Immortal, unborn, and without caste and involvement (sggs 838).
Naari purukh nahee jaat na janamaa naa ko dukh sukh paaidaa: (Before the rise of material consciousness) neither there was female, nor male, nor caste, nor birth nor did any one suffer pain or pleasure (sggs 1035).
Varan jaat chihan nahee koee sabh hukme sarist upaaidaa: God has no color, caste and mark; by His Will, He creates the whole world (sggs 1075).
Jaanahu joti na pooshahu jaatee aagai jaat na he: Recognize God’s Light within all, and do not inquire or consider caste, as there is no caste in the world hereafter (sggs 349).
Jaatee dai kiaa hath sach parkheeai. Mahuraa hovai hath mareeai chakheeai: What merits is in the caste? Truthfulness is measured within. Pride in one’s caste is like poison—he who taste it will die (sggs 142).
Manmukh And Jaat-Paat
According to the Gurbani, one who believes in Jaat-Paat is a Manmukh (egotistic or material being). He is Spiritually blind; hence, without Intuitive Wisdom. His life is perplexed due to ignorance of his True Nature, which is Pure Consciousness. In such a perplexed state of mind, a materialist thinks that this world is solid or permanent. However, the inside reality is to the contrary. The only thing that is permanent is the Spirit (Infinite Consciousness) that pervades within evrybody and everything.
People in material perplexities are called in the Gurbani by different names. Such names include Manmukh, Saakat (faithless cynics), Kusang (bad company), Aatam Ghaatee (self-murderer), Chor (thief), Mayadhaaree (Maya-stricken), Bimukhan (nonbeliever), Jhooth or Koorh (false or fake), nondevotee, demon, beast, idiot, fool, animal, material-being, spiritually ignorant, etc.
A Gurmukh is a Self-Realized person. By awakening Divine Grace within, he has killed his inner ego. He is a humble being, who is jealous of no one. Ever engaged in meditaion on the Divine (Japa or Name-Simran), he is completely immersed in the Infinite Consciousness, Waheguru. Hence, a Gurmukh is a casteless being. As the Infinite Consciousness or Waheguru is casteless, so is he. All his actions are selfless; for he is purified in and out. He sees the All-pure in all. Being spiritually wise, he knows the Essence of the Divinity as all there is; in everything, everywhere, and beyond measures. That's his casteless caste! This is the sign of a true Sikh. No other mundane qualification matters.
Hari Bhagta kee jaat pat hai Ram: The caste and honor of the Lord's devotees is His Naam (sggs 768).
Hamree jaat pat sach naayu: The Name is my caste and honor (sggs 353).
Metee jaat hooye darbaar: Effacing my caste, I have become the Lord's courtier (sggs 875).
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Jaat Part 2 · 30 Dec 2004
In spite of the fact that no true scripture or spiritual teacher supports the caste system, there is a rigid caste system among the Sikhs, Hindus, Buddhists, Jain, and so on. For instance, in their villages, Shudras or Dalits are not even allowed to draw water from wells used by so-called upper castes, or enter the temples managed by the upper caste. What a shameful hypocrisy!
What went wrong? The weakness of our religions is that their propagators do not practice what they preach. As a result, what has remained of the great teachings of the Masters and the scriptures is the unmeaning rituals, lip worship, showoff spirituality, religious robes, dogmas, and so on. People indulge in so-called religious activities but hardly ever bother to better themselves, mend their ways, change their mentality or know "Who I am?". Consequently, the man is unable to embrace all mankind as one so preached in the scriptures.
Due to this stupidity of the propagators of religions, many people become converts, particularly those deprived, discriminated against and destitute tribal and lower castes. It's equally shameful for other religions to manipulate and exploit such people by converting them into their respective religion for ulterior purposes. Is this the solution? No. Because, by converting others, all they are doing is magnifying the problem by creating more divisions, differences, discrimination, fanaticism, and hatred in the world. At the present, all organized religions are inflicted with error. In the words of a great one, "But religion is not always purely known — and even less often purely practiced — which gives rise to differences."
The sage Tulsidaas says: "At the touch of the philosopher's stone, metals become gold. Likewise all castes, even the butcher and the untouchable, become pure by repeating the Divine Name. Without the Name the people of the four castes are but butchers."
Hence, to classify or identify a person with certain caste based on his heredity or family of birth is shear ignorance. The quality of the Jeeva (individual being) depends on one's attributes and actions. In other words, one's quality is determined by how he responds to the three modes of the material nature, not by heredity, race, caste, color, or some other nonsense notions.
Cure From The Disease of Jaat-Paat
Thus, we know from the scriptures that we are made in the True Image of One God. Still, we behave to the contrary. Why? Because our false ego-sense or pride stands in the way as a formidable wall. Contrary to this, those who are free of egoism, for them the Truth (Waheguru) is the easiest thing to know! They live in it, "here" and "now".
Therefore, one cannot know the Truth if his actions are egotistical. In other words, it is impossible to know the Truth by constantly feeding the fire ego (Haume). Therefore, the Gurbani teaches us that, in order to know the Truth, one has to starve the false ego. Unfortunately, instead of starving it, most of us continually feed it!
The deluded mind creates divisions. Consequently, the ignorant mind is the greatest enemy of an egotistical person. To the contrary, the same mind is the best friend of a person who has eradicated his false ego from within. Accordingly, to realize the Self, the deluded mind needs to be dissolved. As long as there is this contending mind, one will be controlled by the ego. How can one free himself from all these road blocks in the Way to realize Truth? One thing is for sure: The outer looks, mere focus on mundane culture and history, empty rituals, and all superficial and shallow practices compared to the Real Essence will not do the trick! If anything, such egotistical practices will sink one more and more and more into "darkness".
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Jaat Part 3 · 30 Dec 2004
The Gurbani provides us with the sure cure and remedy. It teaches us as to how one can turn the "inverse lotus" upwards, and awaken the inner Light and see the All-pure in all. As time and again indicated in the Gurbani, the key is in becoming Spiritual Being — immersing in God Consciousness or Shabad-Surti.
Shabad mare taa jaat jaae: One rids the pride of caste by becoming Shabad-conscious (sggs 429).
Hari Hari karat jaat kul hari: Uttering God's Name, caste and lineage are effaced (sggs 874).
Naa mai jaat na pat hai naa mai thehu na thaau. Shabad bhed bhram kattiaa Gur Naam deeaa samjhaae: I have no caste or honor; I have no place or home. Pierced through by the Shabad, my doubts have been cut away. The Guru (God) has inspired me to understand the Naam (sggs 994). Those turned Godwards belong to the caste of the True God; for they abide in their True Nature, their bosom-friend. Accordingly, the Gurbani teaches us to ever abide in the Divine Name. By singing, hearing, remembering, and contemplating the Divine Name, one is saved, caste or no caste.
Achaar biuhaar jaat Hari guneeaa: The Lord's praise is my culture, occupation, and caste (sggs 715).
The madness of cast distinction can be eliminated by the true love of God; for the God's true lovers are ever casteless! Through the Divine love the "low caste" becomes pure, and no longer remains bewildered. How can we attain this love of God? By removing the "dirt" of hatred, desires and fear from our heart. The Gurbani declares that loving devotion is the only essential thing. That is to say, one attains Divine love by constantly keeping the Divine Name in his mind with faith and sincerity; which purifies the Inner Shrine of the Heart within. We cannot see our reflection in a dirty water. However, once the dirt is removed from water by a purifying agent, one sees his reflection in it! The Divine name is the purifying agent!
God is one, but His names are many. Therefore, what is to be remembered is that there is only one God, and that He dwells within all hearts equally. If this simple truth is realized, then the entire humanity will become a one family of single race and caste!
Maanas ki jaat sabhai ekai pahichaanvo: Recognize the entire mankind as one family (Paatshaahee 10).
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 31 Dec 2004
Caste has no place in Sikhi.People who beleive in caste have no place in sikhi,just as sikhi has NO place for such sikhs.
What a bunch of sad people still chained to the slavery of casteism.Amazingly,they never get chained to such sad affairs when the boy or girl go out and marry a tamil,or Hindu or Christian or malay or Chinese...or even a GORI,who may have had about half a dozen previous boyfriends,not only boyfriends BUT live in common law husbands...and guess what ....????I see the parents blotting to noend ...wah wah mera jawaii gora ..yaan meri noo barri changgi gori a.....if only they knew what the number of the son was in the que for her......!
Singho jago,hosh sambhalo, like paggrri sambhaal oye sikha ......and live in the 2st century .
Chaan Pardesi
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
gk · 31 Dec 2004
Nobody would look or ask about my caste when i grew up i thought everybody were just sikhs. But now everywhere you look caste seems to pop up almost to a point where a person would repeat what caste they are than what religion they belong to.
My two cents worth punjabis are having difficulty living upto sikhi and then theres a vacuam left fill up the void left behind, thats where caste comes in like the inn thing a fashion statement i am this i am that, forsaking a very large part of what our gurus taught.
Some of the panjab muslims from famed panjabi classes ( mirza, gondal etc) i have dialogued with will reaffirm their roots and identity to being a muslim only. Sikhs have lost the plot at this time. No wonder we get laughed at.
Yesterday i sat down and watched a pakistani channel broadcast an intelectual muslim hosting an international seminar raising many valid points affecting youth and society today and how to address, and provide corrective measures.
We sikhs are not even willing to sit at one table together without fighting.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Dharamveer Singh · 02 Jan 2005
GK ji, yes that is a correct thing to say. "caste" per se is gaining popularity because SIKHS are not true sikhs... they lack a lot and so try to make it up by saying...so what if i dont keep my beard intact.... i am a JATT so that should mean something at least...???
1. standards of sikhi are constantly dropping.... people are saying..at least that person is not cutting his hair ( only his beard)...or at least that person ahs a dastaar on his head ( even though his head under the pagg is clean)..or at least that girl didnt marry a tamil/muslim/chinese/gora....( the person is mona "sikh" /punjabi/jatt etc )...te lower we drop the lower our standards get..a ghona mona sikh jatt is better than a gora, a beard trimmer is better than a complete ghona mona hat wearer, a pagg wearer is better than a compelete sir gumm, a drinker is beter than a smoker/drinker ( at least so and so doesnt smoke yaar..so what if he has a few drinks )...and so on and so on...
2. the children of these neo jatts go to school and flash their jattpunna..making others wake up to theirs as well...and if one doesnt have the jattpunna ..then tarkhanpunna, marassipunna, ravidasspunna will do just as well because one must belong to a group..let it be any group as long as it is agroup..sikhi doesnt count as a group becasue no one is a perfect sikh..but ravidassia.....no standars to keep except be born a ravidassia !!! cool man, this is the way to go. who needs to join sikhi group whch has so many standards..nitnem, amrtivela, amrit etc etc...i would rather be a ravidassia !!
3. in conclusion CASTE is the MIRROR on our wall... if we dont stand in front of it it doesnt exist.....but if we do stand in front of it it shows us to e what we are.....and even flatters us..and we like that..
BUT GURBANI is like the MIRROR as well..but when we stand in front of it, it shows us to be what we can be....and we dont like that as it is hard work..and the Gurbani mirror exists whether we like it or not..it is inside us.
Dharamveer Singh taksali
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Kulwinder Singh · 02 Jan 2005
How hard is for you to say to your child to find a Sikh life partner and nothing else is important i.e. caste, colour, race, nationality, language, political orientation or which ever Jatha they belong to ?
Is that really hard for you as parent ?
I have a little daughter, I have no problem ( saying problem is also bit sad but we are addressing the issue) if my daughter marry any Sikh. that is all I want a Sikh any Sikh ( nothing below that nothing more then that).
Can you say with hand on your heart that is ok with you all the readers if you have children.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
.. · 03 Jan 2005
kulwinder singh thats the reality now in the youth! Any sikh following Guru.
We just have few diehard castists using any pretence to keep it alive by keeping behind the ancient brahmin made walls, then really looking for the gurmat answer of unity.
I mean sikhs are not living in delhi and punjab only are they? They have been living in canada uk usa since the turn of the last century, so how big can differences be? what are we doing to overcome them? are we playing a role big enough to bring sikhs together?
At home a child is told "tu eh tu oh ah" when he or she grows up. Then 8 hours a day you go to university the youth now doesnt see his her "hindu caste" in practice anymore. Instead he or she finds a random person offering to help when he or she is stuck on important assignments, someone of another caste is there to help support you when your in trouble, sikh students meet in sikhi week to discuss youth matters ther nobody is a jatt chumar turkan but simply sikhs. But wait! my own cousins never help me, they always competing with me and jelous of what i am. Maybe blood aint always thicker than water.
Your social circle helping you is made up of new different groups. That youth then studies important big things law, sociology, economics how the world works. That youth realises this thing i call myself "mah eh ah tu oh ah" its part of some hindu myth made donkey time ago., it does not relate to my life. I do not have an ari saw a needle a plough a broom in my hand today i have a pen so does the ghumar the nai the jat the lubana down the road. He and she is in the same boat as i am to make something new of my life to shape my destiny, so we can all better contribute to a world that no longer demands you to work and live in your occupational jaati.
When the muslim youths are harrassing sikhs every other day sikhs are experiencing this unity because there is no other way. When the racist gorey call your parents "pakis" because of their appearance your kid asks the same would have happened to my chumar jat turkan neighbour? Here no one looks at your caste we are all "pakis" to gorey and "bunhead turbanators" to young muslims. In 84 no hindu looked at whether your a jatt chumar nai they idenitified the dastar on your heads.
Sikhs have to admit to being backward on this that when we are living in our little punjabi suburbs nobody is going to call you paki or bunhead no more so now we become turkans nais jats chumars.
One hell of a point raised by women on a different forum is honour killings. " why do some parents kill their daughters for marrying out of caste and not their sons?" see the more we hang onto this the more people are beginning to question it. Its still not too late to adopt Guru Gobind Singh Jis equalitarian principles and your children will start to see their parents have such ideals that are worth dieing for.
Instead of holding onto caste behind walls we should be fighting for issues that are worth fighting for womens rights, equality in seva and gurdwara, campaigining to gurdwaras to drop their caste names, hold rensbhais in caste gurdwaras on purpose so the local sangat get exposure to sikhi and kirtan laha, and have the SMART style thing to counter media.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Kulwinder Singh · 03 Jan 2005
Well Said Dear Author Ji.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
................. · 04 Jan 2005
when i have children no matter what gender they are i will tell them when they are mature enough the choice of marrying a gursikh with values caste is no bar, simple way is best way chardi kala
caste is important to those who believe in it i do not thankfully.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
punjabi · 04 Jan 2005
loads of divorces going on, so now mum dads are saying if you find your own partner its ok as long as he or she is sikh or we will help you find someone and caste isnt as big as its pumped by some.
A lot of things are changing very fast.
radaswamis are not just very rich and powerful in punjab now but they have managed to convert our own martial stocks to their side, so we are now being depleted of our much needed soldiers in england. It starts off with somebodies mom n dad then the kids turn that way. little surprise why the gurdwara sangat is going down.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
dust · 05 Jan 2005
well thank god everyone here is at least civilised in discussing. If this were sikh history forum or jattworld.com there would be never ending war with caste name calling.
What do we intend to do now bury this under the carpet or actually do something about the caste fiasco and its effects?
Seems generally, society is kinda comfortable with caste living softly side by side with sikhi and marrying in caste is a sure way to keep their social status alive.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
ss · 06 Jan 2005
doing jaat paat is bad but nearly everyone does it.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
singhni · 06 Jan 2005
i would marry an educated singh over a pindu exposed to hindian customs. Never thought about prospective caste because a singh is just a singh and a singhni is a singhni what connects the entire family is naam with one collective goal to attain liberation.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
kulwinder Siongh · 06 Jan 2005
Simple and Fantastic words Dear Singhni Ji.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix cas
Gurinder Kaur · 23 Jan 2005
Sikhism is totally against caste system. but the fact is sikhs still follow this caste system. either they do for their own thinking, or for society because honour is something really valuable for them. if one's daughter or son has been married to the person of other caste than theirs. its obvious society will think bad (in most cases). i am from saini family. but do not believe is caste system. but surely my parents do. ... from my experience i would like to share this incident that happened with me couple days back. me and my friends were talking about intercaste marriages. there was this "jatt" girl (not mentioning her name) , said i would let my kids marry whoever they want but should only be from jatt caste. as i already said castes do not matter...i said castes does not matter long as they are from same religion (not considering what society thinks). and i told her there was this saini girl got married to jatt boy. they are happy couples but i hear even my relatives saying it was not a good decision. again mentioning caste system ..... evaluating standards. even though both of these castes are so close. (if looked by their standards) that girl did not know i am saini and she said "there is a big difference between both of these castes. sainis are even below the businessmans". i was quite surprised to hear this...and since then i have done quite a lot of research on sainis and jatts. and what i have found is that jatts were the lowest caste in hindus. they became sikh to live in dignity. and now i dont know what is she saying low caste to. ... anyways i am not saying anything bad to jatts but the jatts who really think they are the upper caste...they better do some research on their identity.
if u really think you are sikh then i would suggest please get rid of ur subcastes as last names and use only "kaur" and "singh". and remember sikhs do not believe in castes as they all are equal. and that is the real true identity of sikhs.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix cas
Gurinder Kaur · 23 Jan 2005
Sikhism is totally against caste system. but the fact is sikhs still follow this caste system. either they do for their own thinking, or for society because honour is something really valuable for them. if one's daughter or son has been married to the person of other caste than theirs. its obvious society will think bad (in most cases). i am from saini family. but do not believe is caste system. but surely my parents do. ... from my experience i would like to share this incident that happened with me couple days back. me and my friends were talking about intercaste marriages. there was this "jatt" girl (not mentioning her name) , said i would let my kids marry whoever they want but should only be from jatt caste. as i already said castes do not matter...i said castes does not matter long as they are from same religion (not considering what society thinks). and i told her there was this saini girl got married to jatt boy. they are happy couples but i hear even my relatives saying it was not a good decision. again mentioning caste system ..... evaluating standards. even though both of these castes are so close. (if looked by their standards) that girl did not know i am saini and she said "there is a big difference between both of these castes. sainis are even below the businessmans". i was quite surprised to hear this...and since then i have done quite a lot of research on sainis and jatts. and what i have found is that jatts were the lowest caste in hindus. they became sikh to live in dignity. and now i dont know what is she saying low caste to. ... anyways i am not saying anything bad to jatts but the jatts who really think they are the upper caste...they better do some research on their identity.
if u really think you are sikh then i would suggest please get rid of ur subcastes as last names and use only "kaur" and "singh". and remember sikhs do not believe in castes as they all are equal. and that is the real true identity of sikhs.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
g · 24 Jan 2005
im glad people put wordly values over everything else... why dont you say you would marry a good person over an educated one like that means anything.. I hate you people and your stupid brains i hope you all die
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 24 Jan 2005
Caste is totally irrelevant to someone not born or raised in one.
Guru says it doesn't matter. If it's good enough for guru, it's good enough for me.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
st · 24 Jan 2005
gurinder kaur ji i get the essence of your message.
I was not born a jatt please do not take this the wrong way, but lets not blame any caste for the caste system or cal lanyone high or low. the jatts are a very valuable part of punjabi history, and even contributed greatly to sikhism. However once they took amrit they are no longer jatt but sikhs of Guru ji like we should be. I appreciate their mark in history but as sikhs not as jatts, the same would apply to others on ly because sikhism does not allow me to believe in jaat paat.
The discussion on caste is good as long as we dont point fingers at each other. I am a firm believr of no caste, but because of its sensitivities i wouldnty like to see any caste put up or down because then it looks like we ourselves believe it on one hand and make a hoo haa about it on other.
the truth is caste is an old peopls thing, it is dieing out, we cant marry who we want at present because of parental pressure. But that pressure will die off by another generation therefafter.
look at how you came into sikhi, look at how another will come into it. Akj is special in a way because it totally emphasies practical living of sikhi. The rehat of the jatha has no room for caste at all. Our parents screwed up because they did not fully adopt sikhi in its pure form and still hanged onto caste and juggled it with culture.
Let me make a point here i have seen time after time old boys ( 35+) make sweeping generalisations about people of different castes like city people are clever sly savy etc. I may not be a jat but i am from a very traditional punjabi family and have been bought up that way. I used to think my flesh and blood ( family) were part of my very breath ( literally speaking).
Today all my cousins just compete whos got the fastest car, the biggest house, position, respect. Uncles aunts these are all just names of people made up. I have been through rock bottom economically, almost broke, my family, my relatives did nothing to help me i was all alone and expected to deal with things, its a shock when you fend for yourself and believed your family was there for you. I was lucky my friend helped me.
My friend is what many of these 35+ year old castists would call sly city dwellers. My friend was not even amritdhari, but maintained kes, fought for the right to wear a round dastaar in the force when no one did, does paat everyday which i believe has made him follow the qualities of gursikh compassion, support, helping people. This i could not even find in my own family. The guy may be nothing in many peoples eyes here, but its keeping even part of that rehat that made him what he is closer to a sikh than some i know, and thats stark contrast to the sweeping generalisations people make.
The caste stigma developed only because of indian culture. But now superpowers are pushing for more multiculturalmism therefore caste will die a slow but well deserved death.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
st · 25 Jan 2005
i just remembered my friend not only fought to wear a round dastaar but also to not wear the chequered strip over his dastaar the metropolitan police wear on their hats.
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
sikha da dust · 25 Jan 2005
gurinder kaur ji farmonthi eh
"anyways i am not saying anything bad to jatts but the jatts who really think they are the upper caste...they better do some research on their identity."
mismoner to think all jatt were low caste. Southern punjabi branch are from royal rajput, sindh entry point via jaisel and bikaner , many starting with royal families and gory military history. This group was already well established with chaudar.
BUt you are correct on the northern branch, they had to actually fight with arms to gain power and territory. Because this branch never acceded to foreign custom they were pushed down when foreign ruled which is why some people think they were low caste . But through force of arms they wrested power their way and its what they made after for themselves what counts. It was sikhism that gave these brave soldiers a new life and sardari.
So please be careful what you read bhenji .
But caste is dead in young so fikkar not!
Re: Is caste important in marriages, Do you approve, object or encourage mix castes
S1ngh · 25 Jan 2005
I read above somewhere about Bhai Randeer Singh jee, marrying people into different castes? Are there any stories or examples of this??