Gay marragies
AGA · 14 Dec 2004
Whats the sikh perspective on gay marraiges does it say anything in the Guru Granth Sahib relative to this?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
AGA · 14 Dec 2004
Whats the sikh perspective on gay marraiges does it say anything in the Guru Granth Sahib relative to this?gkd · 15 Dec 2004
gay marriages are just that GAYs!nghn! · 15 Dec 2004
Dear gkd, Using the word "gay" to describe things you view as negative or undesireable is only reflective of your own ignorance. Even if you think homosexual relationships are wrong, there's no need to use the label "gay" to connotate something not good in your opinion. That would be like me referring to all idiotic comments on this forum as "so gkd".Kulwinder · 16 Dec 2004
Dear AGA, the Sikhism promote the path which allow and encourage people to full fill the life to the full in the family which keep the society going in a healthy form, as the gay marriage would be restricted to that couple and family life Would be limited for that reason it is not the ideal, hence you can't expect this to be mentioned as one of the approved solution. I hope it clear your question. thanksfauji · 16 Dec 2004
if you start saying things are "so gkd" half of the people won't know what you are talking about.gkd · 16 Dec 2004
god made adam and eve not adam and steve, homoz are messed... it goes against simple darwinisim. ex: if u threw all homos on an island, they'd soon die out, because they can't reproduce...its against nature..they're wrong.khalistani · 17 Dec 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru jeke fateh!! we all need to chill out sexual desire for men is wrong sexual desire for women is equally as wrong all sexual desire is wrong however, and this is a BIG however we do need to reproduce as a part of naturewe need to repopulate the earth so we marry women, have kids, live in gristhi jeevan and can u give me a thuk from bani that says god made adam and eve?? we arnt chrisians who say pleasure in wedlock is ok in wedlock it inst a kureight, thas for sure but, and this is a big but the reasons kaam and other doots are so deadly itsa chor, theif it steals ure bhagti so if u do paat then have kaam at night wit ure wife guess where ure paat went?? kaam stole it so we get stuck in a cycle thas so hard to get out of and we go in charasi lakh da gera over and over again only those who are out of it know true anand a person who has sexual desire for women shudnt be saying anything to anybody anytime of kaam is bad we shud get past kaam sexual desire krode anger lobh greed moh wordly attachement ahankar ego only then when we see our TRUE beloved bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru jeke fateh!!fannist · 17 Dec 2004
there was an interesting discussion about this on mkhalsa's blog at mkhalsa.comask · 17 Dec 2004
you can have your opinion on gay relationships if you like. However realize that gay people right or wrong for being gay in your opinion are discriminated against. This is WRONG! Christianity and Islam have cornered themselves into intolerant views on gay relationships. Christians in the west try to bring in uneducated opinions from other minority religions including sikhs so they can substantiate their close minded view. Stupid sikhs being used, cheer on without thought. Many sikh males also are insecure in their masculinity hence profess their crude bravado and express their hatred against people who they have absolutely no understanding of. If two adults have a certain perspective on life, whether it is ill or whether it is genetic or environmental who are you to comment if they don't harm anyone. In fact it is your duty to as a Sikh to stand up for any discrimination against them as human beings. No different than Guru Tegbahadar standing up for Hindu's even though he disagreed with Hindu practices. Forget what you see in Hollywood. It is media that largely stereotypes and mocks gay people while purporting to accept. Start with the above knowledge, respect the person as a human being. You may not have an answer but you can start with basic respect for people as people.khalistani · 17 Dec 2004
vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! in my opinion and wat i get from bani gay marriges in sikhi are forbidden u cant have two men do anand kaaraj cause that sort of defeats on of the prposes and if someone is gay, and cannot overcome their desires, of course they will suffer in dharam rais darbar bani says anyone with any kaam will suffer but someone with kaam for women is the same thing as gay BUT at least even if u marry a women and have kaam, u can still overcome it and ure marrige will stillll have a point together for gay people, once the sexual desire is gone, then they have really no need to be married anymore bhula chuka mafgkd · 17 Dec 2004
so khalistani we're mormons, where pleasure is wrong all 2gether?kulwinder Singh · 17 Dec 2004
Dear Khalistani Ji, You need to get grip on the life, you seems to be living in some strange galaxy (not even same planet, solar system or even our galaxy), you believe that Kam is the only thing which happen between wife and husband then you must have some Bonkers understanding of faith you are in, the intimacy between husband and wife is called Aanad in Sikhism and to get Guru's approval we do Aanad Karage ( Wedding in simple English). the Kam you are referring to does not exist between loving wife and husband, so please get your head sorted and see what the world is all about, nearly all the Gurus had children and enjoyed the relationships with their wife very well. I do not know how to say any more politely apart from, get your mind sorted it is not bad but very good to have loving relationship with your wife and have as much as sex you can have with your wife with her consent, it will only benefit you as couple and make your partner stronger and then you joy will increase, and please try to see the sex as God's gift to humanity rather then just Kam, as Kirpan is very different from Talwar same was sex with wife is very different from Kam. I think I made my point. Thanks@@@@@@ · 18 Dec 2004
>>>>>I do not know how to say any more politely apart from, get your mind sorted it is not bad but very good to have loving relationship with your wife and have as much as sex you can have with your wife with her consent, it will only benefit you as couple and make your partner stronger and then you joy will increase, and please try to see the sex as God's gift to humanity <<<<< HAHAHHAAHHAAHHAHAHA YOU JOKER HO WCAN YOU SAY SUCH RUBBISH, NAAM IS A GIFT FROM GURU JI NOT SEX, TO HAV SEX WITH YOUR WIFE FOR ANY OTHER REASON THAN REPRODUCTION IS AGAINST GURMAT, IT'S NOT NATURAL AS YOU ARE USING CONTRACEPTIVE TO STOP NATURES NATURAL PROCESS. HAVING AS MUCH SEX AS POSSIBLE WILL NOT MAKE YOU A STRONGER COUPLE IT WILL JUST MAKE YOU MORE FULL OF KAAMkhalistani · 19 Dec 2004
Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! veer je u wont WANT TO have relations with ure wife anymore once u join with vaheguru je the diesire will leave u y cause its kaam kaam means sexual desire guru je doesnt give u special times to go and have kaam and as veer je or bhenji said naam is the gift to us naam, sewa, and bani not sex thas the oppisite of wat guru je wants for us remeber on ure last time even if u think of ure family u become a pig if women a prostitute so wat happens if u die while having relations with ure wife? and ure thinking of kaami thoughts u think guru je just gonna ignore that?? naw my veer je remeber, we aint christians that we say when in wedlock, its party time the only thing is in anand kaarj it aint a bujaar kurieght but u still get kaam which destroys u and loots u of ure bhagti bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!g · 19 Dec 2004
there is no such thing as a gay marriage... marriage is between a man and a woman... you cant redefine that to suite your own needs if anyone claims they have a gay marraige it is a fake marriage... and there is no gay in religion you can not be any religion and be gay... all religions say that being gay is wrong... so if you want to be gay then fine go do it but keep it to your self and stop trying to redifine marriage keep your gayness to your self I dont want to be walking down the street and see gay people acting gay... like in the gay parades where they walk around wearing practically nothing and humping eachother... this is disgusting and anyone who does it should be put in jail for indecent exposure and lude conduct... but if we did that we would have so many gay activists complaining... I find gay to be very annoyinggkd · 19 Dec 2004
k sex is wrong? ok u know with technology these days u can get ur wife/self pregnant without touching ur spouse!.. · 19 Dec 2004
'g' I strongly feel the same way about us STRAIGHT people. Why isit acceptable for a man and woman "humping" each other? its the same.ilovemkhalsaveerje'sblog.com · 20 Dec 2004
go read mkhalsa veer jee's blog mkhalsa.com find the blog on homosexuality, read the entry, read the comments/discussion very good points made there homosexuality cannont happen in sikhi. but nothing is wrong witht hem. read the blog. end. gurfateh jiog · 20 Dec 2004
I never said that it was ok for a man and a woman to hump eachother but last time I checked they dont organize parades and walk around with there clothes off humping eachother they tend to keep that kind of behavior in clubs or behind closed doors... where as gay people feel they have to flaunt their gayness infront of everyone so they can be "accepted" but they need to keep that stuff behind closed doors or their own clubs where we dont have to see itkulwinder Singh · 25 Dec 2004
Dear Khalistani and @@@@@@, I am sad to realise that you have no Idea that love between husband and wife( also love making between husband and wife) is completely different from lust. You both seem to be alien to the elementary human values. How can one be a good Sikh if they do not want to be a good human? ?erm..... · 25 Dec 2004
i agree with khalistani veerji 100% gay marriages is all about sexual desire..nothing else.. otherwise there would be no gay marriages..Mkhalsa · 26 Dec 2004
Kulwinder Singh, you obviously do not know what naam is. And you obviously do not know what rehat is. Khalistani is ONE HUNDRED percent correct with what he is saying. Unfortunately it seems you are so obsessed with kaam you have the audacity to even suggest that guru sahib loved to indulge in kaam.. tenu sharam nehi ondhi? you know little children read this board and you post this stuff.. sure, sex makes a manmukhs relationship strong, thats how they connect, they have no other means, and they call it a spiritual link.. HA! WHEREAS gursikhs connect on a MUCH DEEPER and much more INTIMATE level by doing naam abhyaas together, doing amritvela together, doing patt together, doing keertan together. For practicing naam simran with your wife will connect you a lot deeper than anything else. I am not married, so what do I base this on? Because when I do naam simran with other gursikhs, I can feel such a deep connection with them that its much stronger than any manmat sexual relationship that you think is some kind of a connection.--- · 27 Dec 2004
I feel like im gonna throw up after reading some of this stuff. You don't gotta tell us what goes on at those parades.Javir Kaur · 28 Dec 2004
gkd ji, Even IF all the ones thrown on an island were not just males....everyone would still die out... WHY ?/ inter-breeding thats why. The same DNA is useless...and agaisnt Darwinism as well. Thats why God dint create Adam and Eve or Adam and Steve.... HE CREATED EVERYTHING. this adam eve story is a tall tale that doesnt stand up...just two peoples DNA genes would have died out eons ago. There is a a lot more to gay than just "married/SEX/LOVE etc". There are a lot of SANTS/BABAS who are celibate..and they spend a lot of time with other celibates...doing "naam abhiyaas"..so why cant two other males want to stay together and do "naam abhiyaas"...surely staying together is NOT just for SEX ?? people can have other interests. Why are people so narrow minded ?? jasvir kaur1 · 28 Dec 2004
dear jasvir karu, how many gay couples do you know that are gay so they can do naam abhiyaas together? I think you are the one that is narrow minded here. two males when they do naam abyhiaas together do it as brothers, not as gay partners. By suggesting this, you are ruining the pavitr relationship that two gursikhs have. please odnt suggest such stupidity again1 · 28 Dec 2004
you know what I think is the problem here? People are confusing SIkhi and gurmat with societal values. Before, even mainstream socity was against homosexuality, but now because of this movement in soceity which says gay is a-ok, people think gurmat should change and say that gay is ok too. Well it might be ok in society, but not in sikhi. Society is always changing. For example, before, people had to be dressed decently in public, but in the 19th centurey, this new movemnet came in with equlity and stuff, and now you have half neaked women walking around. But just because society changed, does not mean sikhi did............................... · 29 Dec 2004
If there are two people living together of the same gender they are usually called room mates. Gay is not a relationship, it is a sexual orientation. It is manmat. Keep the stupidity and narrowmindedness to yourself please.Javir Kaur · 29 Dec 2004
dear 1 ji, i really dont know any gay couples...i dont even know any gays. period. i also dont know any brotherly gursikhs who are doing naam abhiyaas together. my question si if two gursikhs can do a naam abhiyass together..why cant two other non-sikhs do naam abhiyass together without being labeled gay. To me that is not stupidity but avalid question..we just cant dismiss the entire non-gursikh male population as gay if any two or three want to do yoga/naam abhiyaas/breathing exercises etc ec together. thats all. jasvir kaurKulwinder Singh · 29 Dec 2004
Dear MK Khalsa Ji You have written::: Kulwinder Singh, you obviously do not know what naam is. And you obviously do not know what rehat is. Khalistani is ONE HUNDRED percent correct with what he is saying. Unfortunately it seems you are so obsessed with kaam you have the audacity to even suggest that guru sahib loved to indulge in kaam. Dear MKKhalsa Ji I will emphasise on that Yes I may not know about Naam as much as I should but I know about what is humanity is all about. Which is the first step towards being a good Sikh, It is impossible to be a Sikh ( I am not even saying a good Sikh) before you can be a good human being if you really want to know what Guru expects from you. If marriage life with your wife( female wife) and sex with her is some how is just a Kam, then you should have medical insemination as somebody suggested above. Either you have no idea about what Love with your wife mean (Ok you are not married but It is such a shame that you can not get out of your mind that Lust and Love are two completely different things, what you are saying is Nuclear power to generate electricity is same evil as nuclear bomb, I think if you have any intelligence then you will figure it out how wrong you are. But I doubt it very much you seems, one of those Puriterian Sikh BRAHMINS (Yes Sikh Brahmins Who think they are Pure and everybody else is just some kind of inferior subjects) who poise threat to the core ideas of sikhi of being the easiest religion in the world acceptable to everybody and do in deed work for everybody. You want Sikhi Just for your own Kind, Just Like those Brahmins who kicked the Bhagat Naam Dev Ji Out of Temple. ( Yes It seems to me you are like one of them). In case I am wrong God forgive me for it (and I apologies to you if I am wrong) By no means I am saying that relationship between husband and wife when they do path and religious things together is less important or generate less love for each other indeed it can be the strongest bond between to people then anything else. But labelling the Love as lust, to me is an evil it self and just designed to make people have some dirty, inferior complex about them self, Sikhism liberate people from backward thinking, Sikh move away from just being symbolically Pure of just rituals of being celibate. The Real celibate is the one who have nobody else on the top of their list apart from God. If husband and wife should have sex just for reproduction then how many children are allowed or the optimum number ? any thought ? anybody ? Do not say thing, which are impractical and pathetic, Sikhism is very practical religion and keep it as it was suppose to be rather then bastardisation of it with some silly ideas generated with your own narrow minds.Kaur · 30 Dec 2004
I think that all human beings are sensual in that we perceive and experience the world through our senses. So realistically, these kinds of interactions and perceptions tie us to the false world of delusive pleasures, maya. This is not to say all sensual things are evil, bad or wrong. Many are good things. Just not the highest good. They all form attachments which will be broken from us at death, so we suffer when we lose these things, when we lose this body identification. So the point about suffering? Try not to be so attached. Spirituality is something more interiorized, more subtle, and less defined. But for spirituality to be equated with physical response is incorrect. All too often the world mistakes physicality for love. Marriage which is a good match can be filled with sensitivity, loving gestures, affection, other-directedness, etc. And in fact, marriage is an analogy for the soul's relationship with the Divine Beloved. The union which is wholy other-directed and giving as well as receiving. But there is no physicality in spiritual union. The love which can never pass away or decay or be limited is beyond bodily expression or experience. In any event, discrimination, ostracism, fear, retaliatory words, hostility, or even physical violence are not a spiritual way to approach people who are different or who are gay. Are we showing them a better way when we act like this as Sikhs or push them away with hostile words? It is even possible some among our children will find themselves struggling with gay desires someday. Are we teaching them a way to deal with this and still remain Sikhs of the Guru? Because all Sikhs are required to be holy and pure. And all Sikhs are human beings who will struggle with some things and even fail. But our beloved Guruji gives us the way to overcome all these things. This is a very sensitive topic and requires more maturity than can ever be given on a message board. But essentially it is correct that lustful physical desires pull you away from spiritual striving. But we need not be violent about this. Guruji knows where we are at as human beings and will help us overcome all the delusions and traps of the world. We can still be loving and affectionate as people, without confusing this with genital expression, or giving in to the anti-values of a hedonistic society which promotes indulgence. Sexuality is reserved for marriage according to Gurmat. I hope those of you struggling with a homosexual self-definition, who also want to understand Sikhi will seek out older, wiser heads you can look to for guidance. You do not have to act on every inclination. Practice acting on things for you betterment and spiritual good.Gerk · 30 Dec 2004
I am pretty afraid of THIS gay thing actually. I heard from some friends that if you use the same toilet seat as a gay person you CAN become gay yourself! and now I have been reading that it's the gay AGENDA to first GET marriage passed then, they are GOING to be forcing guys to marry other guys. This IS face people, they start small but get big! We need to make SOME kind of petition guys, it's unacceptable!