Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
www.shaheedkhalsa.com · 14 Dec 2004
Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ke Fateh
Protest at Birmingham Repertory – Behzti
Wednesday 15th Decmeber 2004, 5pm – 9pm
The Birmingham Repertory Theatre supported by an Asian Arts association are promoting a play which is showing at the Birmingham Rep from December 9 – December 30.
The play called Behzti (dishonor) is a black comedy by a Sikh play write, Gurpreet Bhatti.
Some Sikhs including Council of Sikh Gurdwaras have been in discussion with the theatre and imploring on them to make changes as the play makes a mockery of the Sikh religion, its institutions and community.
The theatre and writer have refused to make changes to the setting of the play in a Gurdwara wherein acts of rape, abuse, murder are conducted and sacred Sikh symbolism is dishonored. For example the turban is stored in a shoe rack and scriptures are recited in such a provocative setting.
The theatre has alleged that as the writer is herself a Sikh not all Sikhs disagree with the play. The theatre is promoting and condoning inflammatory material by first commissioning the play, and then providing a platform for its enactment. SAMPAD as an Asian arts agency is exacerbating the blasphemy by promoting the production and thereby hurting the sensitivities of a significant proportion of Asians who SAMPAD supposedly represents; Ironically SAMPAD rarely promotes positive Sikh images or Sikhs artists.
You are urged to join the protest on Wednesday 15 December outside the Birmingham Rep from 5pm to 9pm. Please join the protest to make it clear that such plays are not only misrepresentative but will provoke racial unrest in the otherwise relatively harmonious race relations we have in Birmingham.
JOIN the PROTEST against our Behzti.
See below for information……………
http://www.birmingham-rep.co.uk/core_asp/showpage.asp?theid=161
Behzti (dishonour)
A play by Gurpreet Kaur Bhatti
The Birmingham Repertory Theatre is presenting the black comedy Behzti which is being promoted by SAMPAD (an Asian arts association).
The theatre has taken a decision to use public money to mock and ridicule the Sikh community and its institutions. Behzti is a remarkably appropriate title of the clear intent of both the writer and the Theatre administrators towards the Sikh community. There has been a determined strategy to ‘dishonour’ the Sikh community by placing within the context of the Gurdwara and associated imagery acts of blasphemy, and depicting those who selflessly devote and dedicate years in contemplation of humanity and its creator as ignorant bigoted hypocrites.
Hypocrisy, lies and artistic values
Upon commissioning this play the Repertory Theatre’s managers realised that the play posed offence to the Sikh community and chose to consult the Sikh community. Even though the views expressed by representatives of the Sikh community came in clear and to the point, after two months of discussion, it has become evident that the consultation was a tick-box exercise to only please the funders and cover their own back: there was never any intention to listen to nor implement the concerns raised.
The theatre has alleged that as the writer is herself a Sikh not all Sikhs disagree with the play. This would suggest that arts representatives from the Rep are representative of the arts world, however, representatives of Sikh institutions are only as important as an individual despite how upsetting that one individuals’ views may be. In fact the ttrhetare is using this argument to condone their own actions in promoting and condoning inflammatory material by first commissioning the play, and then providing a platform for its enactment. SAMPAD as an Asian arts agency is exacerbating the blasphemy by promoting the production and thereby hurting the sensitivities of a significant proportion of Asians who SAMPAD supposedly represents; ironically SAMPAD rarely promotes positive Sikh images or Sikhs artists. How representative is SAMPAD of all sections of the Asian communities and what is the need for SAMPAD if it cannot embrace the specific sensitivities that diverse communities have?
Any right ‘not to be offended and abused’
The realisation of the opportunity to offend and alienate the Sikh community wasn’t enough. The Rep still agreed to censor plays that other writers had written for the Rep on the basis of ‘artistic merit’. The right to ‘freedom of free speech’ has been seen as a right greater than the right ‘not to be offended and abused’. With these sort of sensitive policies, one can’t wait for the BNP to come to power!
Nepotism?
Interestingly the writer’s previous play was titled ‘Besharam’ (Punjabi for unashamed), again a wonderful word to express her and the theatres feelings about the Sikh community, and had also been commissioned by the Rep.
Same writer same theatre, same community at the receiving end. Networking really does work, or is that Nepotism?
Bumming Nep
The writer in presenting such a controversial play has provided an essential service, after all we here of rape, murder and abuse taking place in Sikh Gurdwaras every day. Don’t we? The writer says that she believes drama should be provocative and relevant. One of two in this case is a failure of huge magnitude. The theatre should be renamed Bumming Nep, with all the nepotism, boys & girls networks, and titillation that takes place behind closed doors.
A Beacon of Truth and Hypocrisy
There is no place for hypocrisy in any quarter; the writer has concentrated on a minority faith community, less than 1% of the population in the UK, less than 2% in India and less than 0.25% worldwide, and not considered the impact on the community of its minority status and the impact this sort of mockery has on a continually victimised community. For example, Sikhs are still classified as Hindu under Indian law, any attempts by Sikhs to extol their own practices have been hindered and subjected to violent vilification. Only 20 years ago the government of India destroyed the Sikh reference library in a deliberate effort to subjugate Sikh culture. In efforts to submerge Sikh practice the government of India gave equal prominence and public funding to right wing Hindu organisations to extol Hinduiastion of Sikh practice during the tri-centenary celebrations of the Sikhs in 1999.
Tabloid Values
The playwright Goraprit Batty, the angelic beacon and protagonist of truth couldn’t have been more hypocritical. In her desire to unearth and make a stand for the ‘losers’ amongst the Sikh Diaspora, Goraprit hasn’t gone out and dedicated her time to voluntary work nor has she established a charity to help alleviate poverty from those faced with adversity. She and the Bumming Nep have instead chosen to use tabloid style titillation to deliberately mock Sikh practice. Could the intention be the same as tabloids- sex and racism sells tabloid newspapers; are you buying or have you already bought your ticket?
Playwright or Social Policy Maker
The drama quite remarkably indirectly makes a suggestion that social research agencies have lost the plot. Public scrutiny has found that public agencies, including the welfare state, are socially exclusive, do not respond to the needs of minorities, and continue to be inherently discriminatory through the practice of historical infrastructural commitments which do not respond to the changing demographic needs of diverse communities and those most in poverty.
Batty comes up with such a remarkably simple finding, she would have us all believe it is amazing that so many others missed the obvious. The play suggests that the evils in society stem from the Gurdwara, because the people who run these immoral places only display outer imagery of Sikhism and do not make any effort to actually change their inner beliefs and practices. Thus rendering their practice of Sikhism meaningless, and this impact on Sikhs and their everyday lives is leading to winners suppressing losers. By virtue of this suggestion, is the Sikh community to blame for the fact that many Sikhs couldn’t get jobs after the demise of heavy industry and had to invest their redundancy packages on businesses, usually corner shops, in order to provide a roof and food to their families? Many mature Sikh men and women still are unable to get jobs outside of businesses owned and managed within the community. Many second and third generation Sikhs have to be twice as qualified and work twice as hard to gain career progression in both public and private employment. It is this discrimination that has led to Sikhs enterprising in British society. Many of those the playwright describes as ‘losers’ have not been allowed to move into employment by the institituitional racism that has been paramount in British society and is still rife in arts establishments.
Perfection of Guilt
Unfortunately not everybody can be as perfect as Goraprit, and as such most Sikhs do have their inadequacies. Goraprit has chosen to discard outer Sikh practices and in doing so, maybe out of a feeling of guilt or some other psychological trauma, feels that those who do show outer practices are usually hypocrites.
Another interpretation of the outer practice of Sikh imagery could be perceived to show commitment and, though we are all sinners, seen as one step towards perfection. Clearly Ms Batty has already found perfection and is now in a position to condemn the practices of others and Sikh Gurus. Why does she not just find another label that suits her better if she doesn’t want to follow Sikhism, after all Sikhism is one of the only faiths that does not forcibly inculcate at birth: the follower is free to choose his or her own path. However, the Gurus who Batty says were ‘brave revolutionaries with the finest minds, warriors who propagated values of egalitarianism and selflessness’ also made it clear that there was no room for hypocrisy and that God was not interested in labels.
‘‘Only he (or she) is a Sikh who lives by the discipline.’’
This means that the outer practice that Goraprit is so uneasy about is as important as the inner practice. The loss of either at the expense of the other is considered hypocrisy in Sikhism.
The Preacher at the Theatre
We are all sinners Batty, it’s just that some don’t need Gurdwaras to preach, just ignorant, Eurocentric theatres, who have no real interest in diversifying their audience. The custodians of the arts enjoy playing to their colonial history and depicting ‘the natives’ as they see not as they are. They need loyal servants to do their work, in the days of the Raaj they gave land and titles to those who betrayed their community, today some will dishonour themselves and their community for the sake of a job.
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 14 Dec 2004
If this were an anti-Muslim play, then the local council would give their backing to the people against it, as everybody seems to be trying to avoid upsetting the Muslims, but when it comes to Sikhs, nobody wants to know.
If the Muslims were not able to put a stop to something like this amicably, there would probably be a suicide bomb- that's where we are different- Muslims value their religion above their own lives, hence you see them readily dying for their beliefs. We have had great soormay in the past and around 1984, but the supply of hardline Singhs has dried up. We still have KPS Gill, Kuldip Brar etc freely wandering around- if Sant Bhindranwale were around, they would be long gone like Narakdhari Gurbachana.
Panth ki jeet
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
only depicting some truth. · 15 Dec 2004
Rape, adultry and other aspects of this play, do unfold in our gurdwara's throughout the world, ask baba mann pehowa wala about his atrosities...
May be it will help to open the eyes of our people, to the sad state of affairs our gurdwara's are in.
Kulbir Singh Dhillon
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 16 Dec 2004
I am not saying that we should act like Muslims- quite the contrary- I am very proud of Sikh heritage and history. The point I was trying to make was, Muslims have managed to create the kind of image that people are afraid to speak against their religion- Salman Rushdie is still effectively in hiding for writing "The Satanic Verses" which was deemed as mildly offensive even by many Muslims. We have the Hindu far-right attacking our religion outright every day, but nothing is done about it, partly because the enemy knows that they can manipulate and "buy" a lot of our leaders/people- so called Sikhs like Badal, who would rather be associated with Hindu fanatic groups than give up power. Muslims don't defect in this way- there is a lot of "eka" (togetherness). I know they display this in a bad way- they are intolerant of others- even those who want to peacefully practice their own religion aren't allowed to etc, which I do not agree with.
Glad to be a Singh.
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
Dear Kulwinder... · 16 Dec 2004
Dear Kulwinder,
You will have to go into 'older topics', to the thread regarding the exposing of the
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
........2 akoi · 20 Dec 2004
speak for yourself akoi!
rest of us are busy with seva!
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
singheeee laaad · 20 Dec 2004
Good news the play behztii has been stopped it willnot be shown...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/west_midlands/4112105.stm
After 2 weeks of peacful protest saturday night finally brought the Rep theatre to its senses!!!
Vahegurrooo Ji Ka Khalsa Vahegurooo Ji Ki Fateh!!!!!
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
Concerned Singh · 20 Dec 2004
This play has had tax payers money in order to produce it. It is taking place in a theatre that has public funding. Sikhs in Birmingham are tax payers.
Whilst I support the peaceful demostrations outside the theatre. One way in which the sangat could protest is by stop paying their taxes. They cannot fine you and put you all into jail. Remember the non violent ways of Gandhi and Martin Luther King.
I support you
WKWF
T Singh
Paris, France
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
www.SikhLionz.com · 20 Dec 2004
Thank Waheguru for that!
Well done to all concerned and it'll come as a great christmas present to the sikh community :)
However notice how one-sided the media really are in ignoring the simple fact that the sikh symbols and gurdwara context could so easily have been changed and yet were only included for maximum negative effect. They had months and months where they could have made slight amendments to these factors but refused to despite requests by the anglican and catholic bishops of birmingham, sikh leaders, leaders of birmingham city council, mps, etc.
Who cares- we won!
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 21 Dec 2004
I am glad that this filth disguised as art has been stopped. Over the past few days, I have however been completely offended by the bigoted and ignorant British public views I have heard/read in the media. Reading through some of the views on the BBC news website made my blood boil. I have posted a reply too, however it has not been published yet (surprise surprise): Here is the text of my message: "Everyone is going on about free speech etc. but would people like to have paedophiles expressing their rights? I think not! Free speech is fine, but when it is completely offensive, a line has to be drawn. I have read/heard some bigoted views over the last few days e.g. a gentleman who said "The church and Christianity are always ridiculed in the media, so why are Sikhs so sensitive about their religion?". I will tell you why- we have respect for our religion- the UK is probably the most disrespectful nation in Europe when it comes to their own religion- how many people will visit the Church over Christmas? this is Jesus Christ's birthday, but the faith of the English seems to be in the pub. Another woman said "Britain was once a democracy, but now we are being dictated to by people we once gave refuge to"- who exactly did you give refuge to? - not the Sikhs- we came here because of a labour shortage after WW2. The British seem to forget that they ruled over India for a couple of hundred years, a period in which atrocities against the people of India were a regular occurrence, so when you say "the Sikhs are violent" remember your own past".
Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
Jeet Singh Bhogal · 21 Dec 2004
After reading the messages left on the above board brings to light the well known fact that Sikhs really cant stick together. We have this so called Sikh women writing and producing Drama about the Gurdwara and disgracing our religion and guess what? we have people like Akoi who has the nerve to call Sikh hypocrtites. The only hypocrtites are people like you Akoi. From your name I cant tell whether your a Sikh or not, but my guess is that’s your nick name. you call yourself a Sikh? Go and ask your parents that’s if they are from the Sikh about our Sikh History. Our Gurus died for us and this is how you repay them.
I totally agree with Pardip Singh Bilga, just because the Uk takes the piss out of Christianity day and night it thinks it ok to do so with other religions. And its people like Gurpreet Kaur Bhatti that think there White and try and mold there beliefs. Well you cant, we love our religion and when you love something so much and some people Like Bhatti take the piss the love turn to anger.
I would love to know about this Gurpreet Kaur Bhatti. I bet that she knows nothing about the Sikh faith. She just carries the Sikh name because her parent chose it for her. Bhatti knows shes done wrong hence why has shes gone into hiding? Im my view she should be stripped of her name as that name is from the Guru Granth Sahib of which she is making a mockery of.
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
Sikh Protestors are morons · 21 Dec 2004
the simple fact that you claim "muslims" would deploy a suicide bomber shows your knowledge of this wider society. As a sociologist, i can tell you that Islamic fundementalism is a minority, Britain is a democracy, i think the Sikh community of Britain (well the protesters) need to understand that the voilence shown did not help the reputation of Sikhs.
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 22 Dec 2004
Everyone is talking about free speech this and free speech that- are we going to extend this right to paedophiles? Are rapists, child murderers now going to say what they want? I think not! Why did the hook handed Muslim cleric from London have his British passport taken away and was arrested? Wasn't he expressing his "freedom of speech" in this democratic country? Why the fine for the Spanish FA for the racist chants at black England players in their friendly game, were the Spanish fans not expressing their rights? There seems to be a lot of hypocrisy from the British public surrounding this issue with us Sikhs- we have been labelled as violent mobsters, yet remember the mob rule implemented by dozens of predominantly white English people in a southern British city a few years ago when they heard a former child abuser was living in their area? This spread throughout the country and even a Paediatrician was targeted because a gang thought he/she was a Paedophile. There is a limit to free speech, so we should all think about examples like these before saying we are to allow freedom for all to say what they want, as it cannot just work when it suits us and is insulting to somebody else's religion.
As for so called Sikhs going on about freedom of speech- stop being so apologetic and stop acting like the the lap-dogs of the goreh- tell them straight- if our religion is offended we will to everything to protect it!
Nanak naam chardee kalla
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
Naridner S Sall · 22 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh
For those who call this a victory and a christmas present,are lost , the play is going to be staged in another venue in Birmingham, what are the sikhs going to do ,storm that building too. As we carry on the Bhezti of the Sikhs will happen beautifully all over the UK. The writer of the play is disillusioned in sikhi and went as far to damage sikhi, if we had just left it alone it would 've been better we WOULD HAVE NT DONE OUR OWN BHEZTI. But now we have done our behzti already AND I'm afraid I reckon we 'll continue to do our own behzti , can you not see or can the members of those Gurdwara's not see with their own eyes and ears that they have fallen in this trap.
This is only a start there are loads of disillusioned Sikhs out there ready to pounce and damage Sikhi as much as possible.And they are disillusioned because it's the Gurdwara committee members that have failed them toally over the generations and continue to do so to this day, and hence the result.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 22 Dec 2004
Dear "Sikh Protestors are morons" ji, you can stick with your Sociologist ideas and sit hiding behind your textbooks- the POINT I was getting at when I referred to Muslims and suicide bombs was that Sikhi holds far greater value than individual lives (for me anyway)- I applaud the brothers who went forward and showed that we will not tolerate this kind of filth when it comes to our religion. You can keep you "wider society" to yourself. If you are a bibi, then I recommend that you take some time to learn about Sikhi and it's values and how great Sikhs have given their lives to uphold it's honour. If you are a male, then either you are not a Sikh, or the type who wears bangles instead of a kara.
Gur Fateh
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
Valjinder Singh · 22 Dec 2004
Protest
Freedom of Speach
Freedon of Expression
Freedom of reply
Freedom to reject a view
These are human privaliges.
Terrorism and religious wars start when a minority are not allowed to express a view.
The best way to answer this would be for us to produce other plays which promote real values of sikhism.
Perhapse this is the time we can adopt a more positive attitude to parchar. In the old days people liked to read and write therefor it was normal to write a book or an artcle for news papers. Listening to a giani is not easy, specially when you know he has not been there, he has only got the tee shirt .... excuse the expression.
These days our kids study with playstation games , and internet sites. I like to think this is learning by illustration.
I am not supporting the Bhatti cause but She/He has had the guts to put money where the mouth is. Lets not quarrel about what is right and wrong, lets get on with showing people what is right.
Lets make a movie about the sikhs who used to risk their lives to free the women from the mugals. Lets make a movie about the vertu of the Sahibjadey. Lets make a movie about the power of prayer. Lets make a movies about bhai Kanya Ji ,
The gurudwarey are under attack from many sides I have to say. Now days people can have a prayer said on radio by donating money using visa cards. You do not actually have to go to see the GURU any more.
I have seen the attendance of service decline over the last few years. due mainly to the mis management of same. Not wishing to dwell on this too much there are faults, OK , so lets sort them out ...... easily said.....all thoes have benn in management more than 5 years please take a bow.
A new approach is required, I am not sure I have the answer but it requires a rethink. otherwise others are going to win.
But quashing a view is not the answer, respond in a positive manner. Let the public know trhat we are part of a bigger picture and not just limited to gurudwaras.
How many examples of rape are there in the holy trinity of the gurudwara?
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
Naridner S Sall · 23 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh
Singh Jeeo very well said,those actions you mention are of high importance and I hope we take them on and move progresseively. I wish you were on newsnight the other day instead Dr. Rai.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
kulwinder Singh · 24 Dec 2004
Dear singhni,
When I said just ignore this drama issue, I said from the core of sikhi, everyday you say in your ardas to turn a blind eye ( akhi dekh ke undith keta) to keep your own uplifting on track. I give you examples,
1. Guru Nanak Dev Ji in his life time when was sworn as Bea'ta la but he did not try to hurt those people, he had enough Sikhs to fallow his one word to sort these kind of people but he never ever actually went to hurt anybody who hurted him, he always chose to enlighten the people and then make them see what they were doing was wrong.
2.Bhai Datu Ji kicked Guru Amardas Ji , Guru Amardas ji did not say even a word against Bhai Datu Ji, If Guru Ji wanted all he has to do is just give a gesture to his Sikhs and they would have done trillion time more hurt to bhai datu ji then just a kick,
I can carry on giving you examples but I think this is enough to make you see how my comments are close to sikhi then what you have expressed.
Point Made - I hope you can see the facts now
Thanks
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
Naridner S Sall · 29 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh
I heard last night Ms Bhatti is due to make an announcement today in the press, the Sikh response needs to thought out and planned. Some forums have mentioned that a SMART UK operating similar to SMART USA , needs to be set up, I would say it's more than necessary, let's make this a goal for 2005 and achieve it.
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh
Re: Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Against Anti-Sikh Play - Behzti
SANT JI IS ALIVE · 29 Dec 2004
Its happened the jago is returning singhs r going to wake up and catch the sikh spirit soon enuff. this kind of bayadbi dus not go unpunished.dis almost the same as narein whu was brought 2 justice for criticizing guru sahib
Protest at Birmingham Repertory - Look at thgis hypocrites of freedom of speec
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 31 Dec 2004
It is amazing the same media,that has been crying out FOUL about the play being banned-the BBC has to day banned a play if it is not altered which it says could have been offensive to women and the gays,What happened to the freedom of speech that it has been crying out aloud?????
Has some one asked them the definition of what is construed as offensive ?Thisjust reflects openly the inbuilt intrinsic Racism within the entrenched institutionally racist white controlled media.
The BBC today banned a play and asked it to be changed so that it does not offend the gays and the women.
How amazing,the same BBC,along with many other tabloids that was fuelling against the Sikhs,and labelling the entire Sikh people for violence that was pertuated by a very small number of people who cannot all be guranteed were even sikhs,and crying out foul about the Sikhs throttling the freedom of speech, has taken this step because it involves white gays and white women ?The boundary certainly changes fast.....what a hypocrisy!!
The Sikhs should catch on to this and play this up ......this was on the news ,,BBC world service at 15.00 hours.This just shows to the white press it is ok to mock others ,but not if their own gays and women are involved.
May be the people who had a lot to say about Sikhs can explain this double standards!Show those who are writing a petition against the Sikhs, what a bunch of hypocrites these actors are and how low they can stoop to to get publicity and some 2 minutes fame!
GSK
PS I have nothing against the gays.It is just a point.