Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

KHALISTAN

KHALISTAN

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 09 Dec 2004

I have a general question/view I would like to share. I get the impression from quite a proportion of Sikhs who live outside India, mainly Europe, US, Canada that they are in favour of establishing Khalistan. I personally am neither for Khalistan, nor against it. I really believe in what Sant Bhindranwale believed- that we want to stay as part of India, however as equal citizens, not as slaves, so it is really up to the government if it wants to keep Sikhs as part of the nation, if not, then we will take Khalistan. I was thinking to myself yesterday, how different the views of people back in Panjab are- Khalistan is hardly ever mentioned, whereas here, in the western countries, there is a call for a separate homeland. I then thought "If Khalistan were to be created tomorrow, how many of us would leave these countries, to go back to what more or less is going to be the old Panjab, but with a new name?" I thought about how we may "enjoy" the yearly visit for 3-4 weeks to Panjab, but how would we feel about living there permanently? If we are honest with ourselves, there can be no overnight change in the way Khalistan/Panjab would be run, as we would have the usual Panjabi politicians, again lusting after power and really forgetting about Sikhi along the way, as has happened in the past, after 1984 and the armed struggle. How many of us are genuinely prepared to leave our lives of luxury- driving the top cars, living in large houses, employed in high posts, to go back to Khalistan and really start a new life? Most of us wouldn't go and find a job straight away so what would be the source of income, apart from those of us who have "jameen"- even farming is going to be a struggle for those of us who are used to sitting in a comfortable office earning a living. My question is- this Khalistan we are asking for- who is it really for? For the Sikh nation, or is it just a romantic ideal for people living thousands of miles away? Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh!

Re: KHALISTAN

Manpreet Kaur · 10 Dec 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh! Imagine a country where there is no discrimination against our Sikh way of living. Not having to remove your kirpan when entering a court. Not having to wear a smaller kirpan when you go to school. Not having to take up home schooling because your school banned wearing a dastar (France situation). We get a week off when its Christmas time, imagine getting a week off to celebrate Guru Nanak's birth! Pardeep veer ji, what you said about Punjabi politicians just lusting for power and forgetting about Sikhi along the way. Well, I think thats the whole point of having Khalistan, a Sikh homeland. Guru Hargobind introduced the concept of Miri-Piri. Basically the concept is that religion could not flourish without exercising temporal power and temporal power could not be exercised in the RIGHT direction without RELIGIOUS GUIDANCE. Maybe thats the reason why the Panth is run by a bunch of confused selfish people. hhmmmmm something to think about! and you asked, "How many of us are genuinely prepared to leave our lives of luxury- driving the top cars, living in large houses, employed in high posts, to go back to Khalistan and really start a new life?" We all indulge in living luxurious lives and driving nice cars, but is that what being a Gursikh is about? Nothing wrong with that, but they are simply just material things. The attachment to them shouldn't be there in the heart of a TRUE Gursikh. I'm sure Guru's Khalsa would give up this life and move over to help make and maintain a homeland for such a GREAT khom. Plus theres many Sikhs in India too. There is no talk about Khalistan there because of the korrupt gov't. That doesn't mean theres no desire for it. Manpreet Kaur

Re: KHALISTAN

indy · 10 Dec 2004

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh Sant Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale in the 80s stood with the panth, the struggle then was not for Khalistan, its was a struggle for basic demands, instead off giving us our demands they gave us bullets and tyres around our necks. talk to any singh from the Damdami Taksaal he will tell u that Sant ji said when not if Sri Harimandir Sahib is attacked the foundation stone off Khalistan will be laid. In the Gurmattas of the Sarbat Khalsa 1986 the wishes off those Gursikhs who laid down their lives defending Darbar Sahib were carried out and a all out war off independence was launched. It is not to us to decide it decision has been made by the Shaheeds. When the singhs off old fought many battles they did not think off themselves or why or who they were fighting for they fought for TRUTH end off. We as Sikhs don’t care if the ppl off panjab want khalistan or not khalistan is not a piece off land it’s the Rule of the Khalsa where there won’t be any AKHI ppl every1 would be treated as human beings. Read the deceleration of Khalistan it will give u a glimpse off what Khalsa Raaj is about. Its only 2% of te population that ever gets off their backsides to do anything. My wish is to walk in the footsteps off Bhai Amrik Singh Bhai Sukdev Singh AKAAL indy

Re: KHALISTAN

harpreet · 10 Dec 2004

Sounds far fetched but what about the idea of purchasing a large piece of land somewere other than PUnjab to start Khalistan. Like buying out a small country in a part of Africa or something, and just getting the basic ideal of Khalistan off the ground and turning it into a reality. This would help get Sikhs recognized as a soveriegn people, without much of the political problems Indian politicians bring to the table. With the financial success many Sikhs are seeing this could be an option to look at. Or maybe its all just jibberish.

Re: KHALISTAN

lakhvir singh · 10 Dec 2004

Manpreet Kaur Ji, WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh! You have said that I couldn't have put in better words myself. Indeed, your response, would make me come to a Khalistan where I can build upon the sacrifices of my Gurus and their great GurSikhs . . . even if I were to give up all my conforts of living in a 'better and advanced' country, what would I have sacrificed in return that could be greater that has already been sacrificed? All the luxuries and comforts are illusions and would give them up and choose to live a humbler life in my Punjab, my free Punjab, where I can walk in the footsteps of my Guru, without being looked at like a 'terrorist', 'fundamentalist', 'orthodox', 'extremist' and all that we face in those very countries we call of comfort. The struggle remains there, too, but if I were given a choice to return to my 'Shaheedan di dhartee', what better honour could this poor Sikh have been blessed with? So my answer would be, yes, I would go there, to my Guru's country, where I could practice freely what my Gurus blessed me with. Even if I were the only one to return there, and the rest would choose to remain abroad, I would still go there anyway. After all, what can we give the Guru back in return, if nothing else? WaheguruJi Ka Khalsa. WaheguruJi Ki Fateh! L* ------------- Manpreet Kaur wrote: '. . . Imagine a country where there is no discrimination against our Sikh way of living. Not having to remove your kirpan when entering a court. Not having to wear a smaller kirpan when you go to school. Not having to take up home schooling because your school banned wearing a dastar (France situation). We get a week off when its Christmas time, imagine getting a week off to celebrate Guru Nanak's birth! . . . ' '. . . Well, I think thats the whole point of having Khalistan, a Sikh homeland. Guru Hargobind introduced the concept of Miri-Piri. Basically the concept is that religion could not flourish without exercising temporal power and temporal power could not be exercised in the RIGHT direction without RELIGIOUS GUIDANCE . . .' ' . . . We all indulge in living luxurious lives and driving nice cars, but is that what being a Gursikh is about? Nothing wrong with that, but they are simply just material things. The attachment to them shouldn't be there in the heart of a TRUE Gursikh. I'm sure Guru's Khalsa would give up this life and move over to help make and maintain a homeland for such a GREAT khom . . .'

Re: KHALISTAN

10th regiment · 10 Dec 2004

khalistan is to be made in punjab nowhere else the idea of khalsa raj i think is brilliant but will never work as people are not generally religious or wanting to stick to strict codes of conduct what we need is just a seperate country we can call our own, the ideals of a theocratic state wont work we need to be pragmatic and try to perusade not just sikhs of punjab but also the so called hindu untouchables that khalistan wont be an extreme religious state but a true democracy built on khalsa principles i.e. fairness and equality if we stick to the notion that only khalsa can rule and everyone has to be khalsa in khalistan etc i think it wont work when the babbars began to enforce strict codes of conduct in rural punjab in the late 1980's early 1990's, only certain sections of the people liked it eg. the poor families who couldnt afford big weddings for their daughters but the rest didnt. we need to appeal to the majority and not the minority people to make khalistan there is so much potential for khalistan since punjabis are very independant people, it is just a question of fidning the right strategy to achieve it and it will achieved, no doubt about it because the sangat in the sarbat khalsa of 1986 has spoken

Re: KHALISTAN

ks narula · 10 Dec 2004

khalsa raj is not an idea it is complete part of sikhi penned in dasam granth ji, ordained by Guru Sahib Himself and forms part of our ardas. With or without untouchabls raj will come when Guru Himself is happy with his sikh when we keep rehat fully and really ready to give our heads for the quam and not for a public statement. the untouchabl do not have panj pyarey, must begin parchar of sikhi mat to their children, take down their flag and replace it with nishaan sahib, and stop the hindu untouchabl from smoking beeris in and around their gurdwaras as seen in punjab. This is all due to no rehet. However on good note at least keeping guru granth sahib ji but now they must take its responsibility and severe links with hindu mat and fully enter the sikh panth and be counted as sikhs and abide by it respectfully and put a stop to hindus entering with beeris. There should be no confusion! youth sikh, non amritdari as well as few amritdari see khalistan as a fundamentalist state not because of its nature or guns smoking out oppressors, but because the khalistani speakers dont present their case properly to the public, get gussai, politics result in fighting between themselves in guirdwaras, end up with slanging hindus down this looks very bad for the cause of khalistan because its meant to be about freedom, justice equality and sikhi mat.

Re: KHALISTAN

gkd · 11 Dec 2004

PUNJAB = KHALISTAN NONE OTHER PUNJAB WILL BE KHALISTAN KHALISTAN WILL BE PUNJAB...THE NAME OF PUNJAB WILL STAY WITH KHALISTAN. Punjab is the land that is fertile only with the blood of shaheeds, want 2 give that up? himmat not money can make religion.

Re: KHALISTAN

!!! · 11 Dec 2004

KHALISTAN JIN DA BAAD !!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: KHALISTAN

Jasvir Kaur · 12 Dec 2004

A SIKH WHO IS NOT A KHLAISTANI IS NOT A SIKH. JASVIR KAUR KHALISTANI IN KHALSITAN

Re: KHALISTAN

A Singh · 13 Dec 2004

If Punjab is Khalistan, can we expect the Pakistani Government to hand over the other half, especially given that we have so many historical sites of relevance to the Sikhs that have been lost there. What are our thoughts on this matter, moreover where do we draw the boundaries? Afterall, Maharaja Ranjit Singh's reign had the borders expanded to Delhi and Afghanisthan -are we, the Khalsa of the 21st century, willing to settle for less? On the same note, what is the proposition with regard to the management and seva of historical Gurdwaras in Hazoor Sahib and Delhi. Many people here feel that Hazoor Sahib is already a RSS-infiltrated Gurdwara, however what certainty do we have, if this is true, that this will not spread further and beyond throughout to Gurdwaras and other Sikh sites which will NOT be in what is being defined as Khalistan.