Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Pad Chhed bir

Pad Chhed bir

Singh · 07 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh. I know that this topic must have been discussed several times; however, I am new to this site. Thus I have never seen any post. My question is, should we still respect or even call it the Guru Granth Sahib if it is written in pad chhed form? Should we still do maatha tek? Also, weren’t Guru Granth Sahibs that caught on fire in the US written in pad chhed form? If they were, shouldn’t we still respect pad chhed form. (not saying that pad ched birs are acceptable) Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh.

Re: Pad Chhed bir

kabaddi · 07 Dec 2004

Pad ched birs are acceptable, sure the 'words' are joined, BUT THE MEANING IS THE SAME... I don't know what to say if you can't accept pad ched birs as guru also, the meaning is the same, the meaning of the shabads are the same... When you read a shabad or tuk from a pad ched bir it is the exact same as saying it from a larivaar bir, it will sound exactly the same... people will say when they 'words' were seperated the meaning could change with the change of our pronunciation... Well thats why we have santhiya...

Re: Pad Chhed bir

A Singh · 07 Dec 2004

Singh, Do you respect your Gutka? Most of these are in Pad-Ched form? Why should we think any less of Maharaj (notwithstanding that LArivaar is the authentic saroop).

Re: Pad Chhed bir

huh · 07 Dec 2004

Isn't the message the same?

Re: Pad Chhed bir

Singh Khalsa · 08 Dec 2004

Obviously Padh Chedh saroops should be given lots of respect, as should every piece of Gurbani.. but there's a difference between "respect" and "considering it to be the Guru". Only the unaltered, unchanged version that Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee MADE to be the Guru can be the Guru. There are dozens upon dozens of potential mistakes in Padh Chedh saroops, where splitting words could go either way. How could Guru Sahib possibly be imperfect? It can't be... Thus, only the Lareevaar Saroop can ever be Guru.

Re: Pad Chhed bir

Khalsa · 08 Dec 2004

There's a Tape of Sant Kartar Singh Jee Bhindravale where he says: “Padshed eh athiant Manah hai” (Padshed is absolutely forbidden). Near the end Sant Kartar Singh Jee further says: Padshed, Padgand eh ik manmat hai, eh nahi karni chahidi (Padshed, padgand is a manmat, it should not be done) Akhar Judmay rehan danay chahiday nay (the words should remain attached(laridar)) Sant Kartar Singh Jee clearly calls Padshed 'manmat'. As for Matha Teking, we can even matha tek in front of a Gutka as it is bani, but that is not the issue of this debate. The issue is whether or not Padshed should be allowed. Clearly if great men like Sant Kartar Singh Jee calls it 'manmat' and Bhai Randhir Singh Jee calls it 'Maha Manmat' then who are we to argue?

Re: Pad Chhed bir

Kaur · 08 Dec 2004

For information regarding pad chhed saroops, here are some older posts I found by doing a search: --> "Bittersweet Gurpurab: True Guru Lost" http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=17136&t=17126#reply_17136 --> "A Panth Without Its Guru" http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=10989&t=10870#reply_10989 --> "Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh on Pad-Chhed" http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=3604&t=3604#reply_3604 --> "LADIVAAR FONT??" http://www.tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=834&t=834 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ I'm sure there are many more posts on this site regarding pad chhed saroops and larivaar saroops. Just do a search if you need more clarificaiton or more information. You can also read more on this topic in the "Gurmat" section of this site.

Re: Pad Chhed bir

Maltoner · 08 Dec 2004

You Simranjote veere, did ya change your id from khalistani to kabaddi? guy email me ok ?

Re: Pad Chhed bir

Singh Soorma · 08 Dec 2004

Khalsa- how do u say that Sant Kartar SIngh ji said that. show me proof. thats the most ridiculous thing ive ever heard of. thats absurd taksal doesnt believe in pad ched.

Re: Pad Chhed bir

A Singh · 08 Dec 2004

Dear Khalsa, The matha tek is the debate not ped ched/larivar, "Singh" asked the following question:- "My question is, should we still respect or even call it the Guru Granth Sahib if it is written in pad chhed form? Should we still do maatha tek?" The answer is clearly YES, we still matha tek the saroop, although most agree that larivaar is the authentic form of maharaj. Now, if I am mistaken here please correct me (i.e. no we should not respect the pad-ched saroop).

Re: Pad Chhed bir

dhan hamara meet · 08 Dec 2004

What about Gutkas though as A Singh pointed out?

Re: Pad Chhed bir

Premi · 08 Dec 2004

Is this not an issue that the panth should decide on? I mean like Ragmala, Meat, Pad-ched and a lot of other issues they need to be sorted out and a decision made. I mean SGPC is printing the birs in both formats so you can't blame the sangat who for the most part have no idea about the difference. A collective decision needs to be made and guide the panth. Until then I think both birs should be respected equally. Re:Taksal, I have heard that katha to, so why do they print pad-ched gutkas and pothee's?

Re: Pad Chhed bir

Singh Soorma · 08 Dec 2004

Taksal Believes in Padched and Lareevar as 1 equal bani. Both as Sggs ji. Lareevar is not higher then Pad ched and Padched is not Higher then Lareevar they are the same. both guru ji.

Re: Pad Chhed bir

R Singh · 08 Dec 2004

All gurbanee should be respected, whether it is pad ched or lareevar. Every Singh that I've ever met shows utmost respect to all gurbanee. This is not an issue. However, Gurbanee was given to us in Larivar form and no sikh has the power to 'modify' their guru because they find the guru too 'difficult.' The sikh follows the guru, no matter what. You don't change your guru, you accept your guru. The authentic form of Sri Guru Granth Saahib Jee is in Larivar.

Re: Pad Chhed bir

Singh · 08 Dec 2004

By bowing to pad ched guru granth sahib, you are disrespecting the true guru in larivar form which Guru Gobind Singh ji accepted. Why are we so eager to accept a guru which is created by people other than the Guru? Are we becoming like another sect the "Pad ched guru believers"?

Re: Pad Chhed bir

A Singh · 08 Dec 2004

Should Gutkas be in Larivaar Saroop too?

Re: Pad Chhed bir

kabaddi · 08 Dec 2004

By bowing to pad ched guru granth sahib, you are disrespecting the true guru in larivar form which Guru Gobind Singh ji accepted. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- By not bowing to a pad ched bir you are disrespecting guru ji... the meaning is the same, the only difference is the words are split up to make it easier for people to read.... THE MEANINGS ARE THE SAME, PAD-CHED BIR IS TELLING US THE EXACT SAME THING as LARIVAAR BIR... THE MEANINGS AND MESSAGE OF BANI IS OUR GURU... SO you are disrespecting... Its cool if you dont believe in pad-ched bir, but dont try to convince everyone else that your disrespecting guru ji by bowing to pad-ched bir... if thats not manmat, i dont know what is... There are also slight differences between the original larivaar birs we have, so which one are you gonna matha tek to??? since there all slightly different? your argument doesnt hold up

Re: Pad Chhed bir

khalistani · 09 Dec 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! all bani shud be in lareedar saroop and no, my names khalistani i dont who kabaddi is no ones saying padched, the actual act is correct, the act is a very bad thing to do but i think some problems arise when people go to lenghths of not even respecting the bani in padched saroops, which i belive happened once bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Pad Chhed bir

respectfully · 09 Dec 2004

I disagree. By not bowing you would be showing great disrespect and that failure to bow would be more indicative of hankaar than anything else. On the issue of pad ched or larivaar, I am undecided and hope the Panth can come to a resolution as serious discussion on this issue would be beneficial - I would be happy with whatever decision is reached. In the meantime, both saroops are Guru ji in my eyes and they will be afforded the same respect. This talk of true Guru (as opposed to a fake Guru!!!????) is highly disrespectful and Sikhs should refrain from making such comments. That is gurbani housed within the physical body, and while the physical body may have some difference, that saroop still deserves every ounce of respect we have and there should be no hesitation in laying down one's head, either in deference to Guru ji or in defence of Guru ji's honor. If the pad ched saroops are an excercise in manmat, then lets hit that matter in a responsible manner and slowly (or quickly) replace those saroops with larivaar saroops. In the meantime, show whichever saroop, pad ched or larivaar, the utmost respect. respectfully, Respectfully Singh wrote: > By bowing to pad ched guru granth sahib, you are disrespecting > the true guru in larivar form which Guru Gobind Singh ji > accepted. > > Why are we so eager to accept a guru which is created by people > other than the Guru? > > Are we becoming like another sect the "Pad ched guru > believers"?

Re: Pad Chhed bir

jss · 09 Dec 2004

wait a minute here... isn't thes padched saroops printed by the sgpc under akal takt approval??? you guys are probably right that the original saroops were lareevar and that we should probably stick to them...but to tell the common singh that he is disrespecting guru ji by matha teking to padched saroop is nonsense.... if anyone here doesn't feel that padched is right...then maybe you should go to SGPC and our panthic agoos and give THEM the lesson...so that THEY can change the ways...

Re: Pad Chhed bir

Singh · 09 Dec 2004

Do you know that there are more than 465 shabads in the guru granth sahib ji which are made pad ched differently by each individual printer. Which printer would you consider correct in printing the pad chedd saroop? Which Guru is correct the larivarr or Pad ched ? Please answer my question. The meanings are differnt for each shabad which is printed and made pad ched by each individual printers Mat. Which is not GURMat.

Re: Pad Chhed bir

Caprice Sun · 09 Dec 2004

Their is an excellent article on this site on the matter...it is highly recommeded that everyone who contributes to this thread read that article. I think of pad ched saroop as a pothi sahib and afford it the same respect. It is not mandatory to matha tek to pothi sahib but one can do it out of sharda. If I ever go to gurdwara sahib where they do parkash of pad ched saroop then I matha tek, mostly because I don't want to create a scene. Now many of you will ask are you not matha teking to gurbani. The message is the same etc. etc. Well no the message is not the same. Pad ched is done by people and thus there will always be mistakes. Doing pad ched incorrectly changes the meaning drastically. The worst thing is that majority of the people accept pad ched to be correct and never try to learn paath for themselves. Doing paath from a pad ched saroop breaks the direct connection between Sikh and Guru. You are giving the task of discovering gurbani to someone else. why would somone want to miss the opportunity of discovering their guru? Think about it. Is it, "EkOankar Satgur parsad" or "Ekoankar sat gurparsad". If we can't even decide on this then how can we proceed on to all the rest of Gurbani? So to answer your question ... I think ideally we shouldn't go anywhere where they do parkaash of pad ched saroop because that is the only way to force the gurdwaras to revert back to doing parkash of larivaar saroop. You guys know what the worst thing is. First we do something (printing pad ched saroops) and then instead of correcting our mistake and asking guru sahib for forgivness for having such overly large egos... we try to justify our actions. Guru is eternal, PERFECT and complete truth. When we filter gurbani through our limited intellect by printing pad ched saroops then we are taking that quality away from guru sahib. I think this is a serious mistake. And all people who promote that padched saroop is same as larivaar saroop are equally guilty as those who printed pad ched sarrop in the first place... and might I mention they did it against resolutions passed by SGPC against pad ched printing.

Re: Pad Chhed bir

kabaddi · 09 Dec 2004

ok i just have one last question thann for everyone... the original larivaar saroops.... such as kartarpur bir... they have differences between them, however slight they may be... so if you say you wont say pad-ched birs are not guru, than WHICH LARIVAAR BIR IS YOUR GURU, BECAUSE NONE OF THEM ARE EXACTLY THE SAME !!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Pad Chhed bir

r.singh · 09 Dec 2004

This was discussed at length on the sikhsangat message board. Here's the link. http://forums.waheguroo.com/index.php?s=20f979a03815bb8acaa9363456a6a023&act=ST&f=2&t=6960&hl=lareedhar&st=20 We fully respect all gurbanee, and as respectfully said, any gursikh should be willing to give his life for any gurbanee. However, the issue of Guruship is different. I'm re-posting a message I posted on sikhsangat. >> I didn't think too much about this issue, but one day while sitting in a divaan (with pad ched prakash), it struck me. Just pause and think rationally about it for a minute. If you think that since banee is banee and that there is no difference in having pad ched saroop or lareedhar, than what was the point originally of starting pad ched? If there is no difference, why take the effort to print a new saroop instead of keeping the one already being used? Obviously, since people thought that there was a difference. They think that padched is easier to read and makes guru saahib 'more accessible'. So if we were to make a chart comparing pad ched and lareedhar and put check marks for all the qualities that these saroops have (this is purely hypothetical, since the qualities of gurbanee are infinite), we would have check marks for both sarroops for all the different qualities (according to these people). Except at the very end. Pad ched would have one extra quality; ease of reading. Or, looking at it the other way, we will have identified a 'weakness' in lareedhar saroop. So then these saroops are no longer regarded as being equal. Padched is considered superior since it is 'easier' and 'more accessible'. This is also why people choose to do prakash of pad ched over lareedhar and argue so much in favour of it. Now lets step back and take a look at this. Guru Saahib (first Guru Arjun Dev Jee and then Guru Gobind Singh Jee) gave us lareedhar saroops. These saroops were then given gur gaddi (keep in mind that 'banee guru, guru hai banee...' always applied but gur guddi was given to Guru Granth Saahib Jee by Guru Gobind Singh Jee and not before this). Sikhs fully accepted this. Pad ched of banee may have been done to gutkays, but never to the full Guru Granth Saahib. But then eventually, some sikhs decided they found a flaw in Guru Saahib: Guru Granth Saahib was too 'hard' to read and wasn't accessible to the masses. So they tried fixing this 'flaw' that the guru's had apparently overlooked by doing pad ched and in effect, 'improving' their guru. Can you imagine this? The sikhs decided that the Guru given to them by Sri Dasam Pita Jee was lacking in some quality and so, the sikhs decided to make their guru 'better'. Isn't this the biggest form of blasphemy possible? Some may think that I'm being extreme in my analysis. But just think about it. You don't change something that is perfect. So why change the form of our guru? You'd only do it if you thought there was something wrong. You don't fix something that isn't broken. If both forms were truly thought of as equal (which they can never be since one was given by our guru's and the other by people using their own mat), then there would never have been a need to make pad ched. But these people think it's better, so that's why they've tried replacing the guru made lareedhar saroops by the man made pad ched saroops. Every time we accept the pad ched saroop as being the true guru, we are basically agreeing with the stance that the original lareedhar form of Guru Granth Saahib Jee, given Gurgaddi by Guru Gobind Singh Jee, is flawed. Why else would we do prakash of something other than what Guru Saahib gave us? You can try making all the arguments you want, but in the end it comes down to the point that the only reason of replacing lareedhar saroop with pad ched is if you think pad ched is better (by being easier to read, etc). If you accept this, then you've accepted that the Guru's made a mistake and gave us a flawed guru, which the sikhs had to then fix. This may sound harsh to some, but this is the truth. No reason to back pad ched saroop unless you think that the original choice of the guru's was flawed. It doesn't matter what any sant or baba says. What the guru's gave us was perfect. All these babay will claim over and over about how they won't allow even one letter of gurbanee to be changed. Yet they don't seem to have a problem with the decision of the Guru's being challenged and the whole Guru Granth Saahib being changed. I remember something Hardeep Singh of Toronto telling me. He said they had an amrit sanchaar at Scarborough Gurdvara saahib, with lareedhar saroop prakash. Afterwards, some kathavachak at the gurdvara trashed them for using this saroop, saying how there was no difference in saroops and that these singhs are just trouble makers. Hardeep Singh said he approached the kathavachak later on and asked him about why Guru Gobind Singh Jee didn't just make Guru Granth Saahib Jee pad ched to begin with, since Guru Saahib was all knowing and would have known if it would be too hard to read in the future. Was it because they had a lack of paper and were trying to conserve paper? Or was there a problem with the ink that prevented them from leaving gaps? Or was it because Guru Saahib wan't in fact 'janee jaan' (all knowing) and so, didn't realise that there would be idiots born in the 20th century who wouldn't be able to learn paat in lareedhar? Just to add, the panth has never officially accepted pad ched saroops. The only official decision taken by the panth (by the SGPC and Chief Khalsa Diwan) was to ban publication of pad ched saroops. This decision has never been overturned, although the SGPC eventually started ignoring it's own decision. >>

Re: Pad Chhed bir

J Singh · 09 Dec 2004

I agree that we should only have Larivar Saroop of Guru Sahib but how many of us are REALLY able to FULLY read, interpret, and comprehend Larivar Saroop, and how many are able to do santhia de sewa? Even when we do read from Larivar or give santhia, most of us are bound to make many many mistakes (perhaps more than the pad ched saroops, in my humble opinion) in interpreting Gurbani as most of us learn to read and write Gurmukhi in pad-ched form. We need to train more Sikh scholors to provide santhia de sewa as many Gurughars don't even have Larivar Saroops. Question of "disrespect, flaw, and weakness" doesn't arise in my mind as we DO END UP DOING PAD CHED while reciting Gurbani as it's IMPOSSIBLE to literally keep on reading on and on from Larivar Saroop CONTINUOUSLY without pausing or understanding the "words". Guru Sahib definitely are janee jaan (all knowing) and did not prohibit us from doing pad chedd either.

Re: Pad Chhed bir

.. · 10 Dec 2004

J Singh. I totally hear what your saying but dont you think that the loosing of Larivaar has put us in this position of not understand/reading Larivaar. If fools did not adjust things in Sikhi to their own preferences, we would not be in this postion today. I do understand that Larivaar needs to be learnt etc.

Re: Pad Chhed bir

A Singh · 13 Dec 2004

Whilst I personally believe that the larivaar saroop is more authentic, to argue we should not respect the pad-ched saroop is frankly idiotic -what will it take, the RSS to turn around and begin disrespecting these 'ped-ched' saroops? What we the KHALSA think of this? Nothing, because, it wasn't the 'real' saroop? One other observation here, is that many people speak of larivaar is a uniquely Sikh concept, well, this maybe a surprise, but it's not. Many non-Sikh texts from the same era and earlier were also larivaar. I agree that the imparting of knowledge which was once conducted through more authentic mediums has collapsed with the rise of the common joe posing as a 'Gyani', 'Bhai', 'Baba' and/or 'Sant', with this clearly matters such as reading larivaar, raag kirtan, dhyan etc have declined or been ignored, with frankly stupid justifications put up in place to defend the right for the present status quo.

Re: Pad Chhed bir

Jasvir Kaur · 14 Dec 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. agreed veer A Singh Ji. Perhaps we should adopt larivaar in our DAILY LIFE as well. ALL TEXTS..including Guru Ji's Hukmnamas etc are all in LARIVAAR style. It is just an aspect of the way things were then.... Soheregoestherestofmymessageisinlarivaarcanwelivewiththatorisitpractical ??? jasvir Kaur

Re: Pad Chhed bir

.. · 14 Dec 2004

Bani is laari. No need for daily life writting. Bani is above us

Re: Pad Chhed bir

Jugraj Singh · 16 Dec 2004

A Singh, >>> to argue we should not respect the pad-ched saroop is frankly idiotic - what will it take, the RSS to turn around and begin disrespecting these 'ped-ched' saroops? >>> No one has argued that we shouldn't respect pad-ched saroop. No Sikh would. People are simply saying that the larivaar saroop is the poora guru. I don't understand the argument. First we think we are intelligent enough to change maraharaj da saroop then instead of admitting we made a mistake (which according to mata passed by the panth we did) we go on to justify that mistake. I want to know from the people that promote the printing of pad-ched saroop... why? Why do you promote it? What is your reasoning? Please enlighten the rest of us moorakhs who belive that Guru Sahib knew what he was doing when he wrote Gurbani in Larviaar saroop. I mean if he only wrote bani in larivaar because that was the style of the time then I guess that Guru Granth sahib jee being in the form of a text also was a reflection of the time and we can go ahead and install a computer on the Gurgaddi. That way we can have both larivaar and pad-ched saroops. Even better huh??? Look, we out did our ancestors!! We improved our guru and made our guru more approachable to the new generation!! This is sure to give the panth chardi kala in the coming decades. Jasvir Kaur, What was the point of your post? What are you trying to convey? Please refrain from wasting board space. It make the theads unnecessairily longer.