Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

www.shastarvidiya.org

www.shastarvidiya.org

Mr. Moorakh · 26 Mar 2003

What’s up with this new website: www.shastarvidiya.org ? They are insulting AKJ everyway they can by passing rude and sarcastic comments. Further more they are even doing Nindya of Bhai Randhir Singh Jee, and Bhai Fauja Singh Jee. Apparently this site is made by Nihangs. Who are these UK Nihangs? and why do they hate the AKJ so much for? And why do they worship Devis and Devtas? Further more, they look at lord Shiva for their warrior inspiration, when infact we are suppose to look at Guru Gobind Singh Jee for our warrior inspiration. Do these guys represent the mainstream Nihangs veiws? I think these UK nihangs might be linked with the GOI and RSS in some way or the other. Would do you all think about these UK nihangs?

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Khalsa · 26 Mar 2003

I personally feel sorry for them. They seem so confused, and the only thing that i can see that is good about them is there training. The videos are pretty cool. The whole purpose of the site seems to be to make fun of akj. Attacking panthic shaheeds and great gursikhs for no apparent reason. Pretty juvenile stuff.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Administrator · 26 Mar 2003

Dear "Son of Guru Gobind Singh jee", We have accidently erased your message prior to approval. Please repost your message,.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

dasandas · 27 Mar 2003

It is sad to see that bemukh khulasa has come into tact to ruin the panth. who are these people to insult anyone? I like the baana. I personally like their tolerance for other religions. it is more than evident that they don't worship hindu dieties, but rather respect them instead of closing their minds off to them. I guess its like understanding what they were about to further understand the meaning behind certain things. the fact that they don't have a sant figure is so commendable. I don't believe there have been any sants after guru sahib, and anyone who is deemed to be one, is everyone else's shortcoming in forgetting guru sahib and giving others credit for guruji's bakhsish. In all honesty, gursikho, we will never ever know how things were in guruji's time. So at best lets try to follow gurmat to our best waheguru ji ka khalsa, waheguruji ki fateh

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Mkhalsa · 27 Mar 2003

Waheguroo jee ka khalsa waheguroo jee kee fateh!! The UK "NihUNGS" have done it again. this is another site on the sarbloh.info network. These people are not sikhs. First clue: they worship hindu gods. They call guru sahib "Adi Granth." Also, they misquote Guru Sahib, as well as Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer singh jee. These people have no sharam (shame). they put up pictures of gursikhs and put derogatory remarks about them, Such as Uptej Singh "Teji", without whom there would be no gatka in the west. And Bhai Amolak Singh Jee (Sydney) who was shot in 1978 attack. They quote all these so called nihung jathedars and others. Singhs have talked to these people that are quoted on these websites. They said that they are either lies, or misquotes. Again these people have no sharam. One of the jathedars of tarna dal said all that chatka and bhang stuff on their site has nothing to do with them. Real nihungs want to distance themselves from this pakhand. I am not sure about this but I have heard from some singhs that this "96 crore budha dal" or whatever they say they belong to is a figment of their imagination. They are making up sects and i wouldnt put it past them that they could be RSS agents. HAHA one of their followers was in Toronto from what I heard plucking his arm saying "did i break my amrit now?" .. "how about now?" .. "now?" these people are disgusting.. and they are the true nangs. and in all humbleness, i can state that these people are not sikhs and i hope nobody ever considers them as such. sorry if i offend anyone but the truth can be seen from how disgusting their website is. --Mkhalsa

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

kkaur · 27 Mar 2003

The material on the site is wack. But, one thing you have to commend is the SHASTAR VIDHIYA ITSELF!!! This is no comparison to the "gatkaa" that is seen in shows by the western akharas. This is DEFINITELY the real deal. They know the absolute martial science of each weapon, its use, its methods of training... They are kings of shastar abhyaas. Lets at LEAST praise them on that much, and LEARN from them. Check out the videos in the Multimedia section, Niddar singh is a true gurdev of Shastar Vidiya.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

SarblohKaurKhalsa · 27 Mar 2003

WaheguruJeeKaKhalsa,WaheguruJeeKiFateh! Dear "dasandas" jee, You wrote: "I personally like their tolerance for other religions. it is more than evident that they don't worship hindu dieties, but rather respect them instead of closing their minds off to them. I guess its like understanding what they were about to further understand the meaning behind certain things." With all due respect jee, I think there is a world of difference between having tolerance for other faiths, and actually worshipping the dieties of those faiths. The site in question does in fact seem to promote the worship of those dieties, not merely respect for them, which is strictly against Gurmat. We should indeed tolerate other religions, but we, as Sikhs of the True Guru, bow only to our Satguru. Not worshipping other dieties does not mean that we have closed our minds to them and is not a sign of intolerance. It simply means that we are Sikhs of our Satguru. In terms of tolerance, I believe the views expressed on that site fall far short of being tolerant. How much tolerance does it require to insult the shaheedi of those who gave their lives for the Panth? How much tolerance does it show to insult great Gursikhs of the Panth?? How much tolerance does it take to viciously chop the head off of a small helpless animal??? The shastar vidiyaa videos are just about the only good thing on the site. Watch and enjoy those, but we should disregard or deprecate all the rest.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

g-unit · 28 Mar 2003

There is dispute here because there is akj bashing going on by these nihangs. but dont you think they have some validity to them? nihangs have been around since guru ji's times. Akjs have been around 60 years. They feel they are living out the way guru ji said they should live, so does akj......BUT how does akj know they are living the true way - they only started recently. their maryada is shared by only a very small portion of the panth, so taht means the rest of the panth is misled? I think everyone is getting mad here because they feel the nihangs are TOO radical. But tahts because mroe and more sikhs are getting away from the roots, so everything is softening up. they are calling what's not familiar to them 'radical'. IF someone were to coem to sikhi and use a jatha for guidance.....would they choose akj, damdami taksal.....nihangs?? Please someone answer this. This post is not about controversy. Jathas are not for affiliation, but for guidance. So my question is.....why would a new sikh choose the path of an akj sikh over say a taksal or nihangs, when the latter two were started out by guru ji himself......? Please let this post stay up because there is not thing wrong with it other then the facts being bluntly put.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Mr. Singh · 28 Mar 2003

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji kee fateh I agree with Sarbloh Kaur's views. Just one more thing i wanted to add. All the shastar vidya is guru sahib. Noone should feel that the only way to learn the true vidya is through these morons. If one honestly tries to learn and does ardaas in front of guru sahib guru sahib will do all the kirpa and the person can gain as much knowledge as he she wants waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji kee fateh

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

dasandas · 29 Mar 2003

dear sarblohkaurkhalsa bhainji, about tolerance, the designer of the website www.shastarvidiya.org is clear in what they do not like about the aforementioned shaheed/gursikhs etc. They are entitled to their point of view. what determines a good gursikh for most is derived from one's direct relationship with guru sahib and the "soji" guru sahib has given to his/her sikh. everyone else is on a bandwagon. now, speaking practically, have you ever met bhai randhir singh? or bhai fauja singh? the chances are, probably not. what you decide is good and bad is based on heresay. if someone hasn't heard about either, then life doesn't change does it? and if someone has heard and cusses, life still doesn't change. the truth is that guru-ji has taken "lekha" of his gursikhs, and the best we can do is ask for bibek-buddhi to determine what is right and wrong. unless one is sant theirself or great gursikh theirself, I would plead to the sangat to stop putting people up on pedestals. it is untruth! let us all remember, that every human has sinned. hence, no one is actually better or worse than anyone.. the best one can be is "trying".

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

g-unit · 29 Mar 2003

why cant someone say something taht mite contradicit the akj evn though it mite be rite?

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Khalsa Soulja · 29 Mar 2003

g-unit it is very easy to justify all of the akj beliefs with gurbani. how can u justify cutting up goats, basically idol worship, taking cannabis, putting two things that arent even the guru at guru level (sarbloh and dasam granth? what are the differences between akj "rehit" and hte sgpc "rehit"? well keski.......thats an obvious one - and its pretty well known that women used to wear keskis and no longer do. even sites like panthkhalsa.org and fauj.3giga which arent even akj (fauj.3giga agrees with raagmalla even) agree that women should wear keski not chunni. some rehitnamas say keski as kakkar. some hukamnamas say keski. this is controversial. BUT we can be 100percent sure that keski should be worn nearly all the time, for men and women other difference - raag malla - obviously this cant be justified by gurbani (its a modern argument that has arisen from corruption) and in the end comes down to personal view. many non akjs are also anti raag malla. so again this is up to the specific person. and as for kuttha, well its just blatant that meat of any kind is dissallowed. that should go without saying. all the akj views are inline with akal takht and gurujis. but how can we justify sukkha, and other such things? we CANT. akj jatha gives guidance on how to live a true gursikh lifestyle. nihungs tell u its ok to decapitate animals, see dasam and sarbloh granth as gurus, have sukkha and many other crazy things. NONE can be backed up with gurbani.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

g-unit · 29 Mar 2003

why cant the nihangs be right? they are from gurujis times. taksal is from gurujis times. They were BOTH started BY GURUJI himself. akj started 50 years ago. why cant waht nihangs be saying right? why does akj have a say as to whats right and whats not right? is the whole panth except akj wrogn about rag mala and keski issuse??

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Mkhalsa · 29 Mar 2003

Singho lets first agree these people arent really nihungs..

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Tarvinder Kaur · 30 Mar 2003

Vaheguroo jee ka khalsa, Vaheguroo Jee kee fateh I'm not too clued up with this controversial stuff, but I just wondering about the post by Khalsa Soulja. Firstly you state that dasam granth is not bani and that it shouldn't be put at the level of Guru Granth Sahib Je, yet all historical accounts state that prior to SGPC all three (dasam granth, sarbloh granth, and Guru Granth Sahib Jee) were placed side by side. Also as confirmation that at the least, dasam granth is a part of the panth or should be classed as gurbani is that in the amrit sanchar the amrit is stirred by the khanda and the 5 baniya are repeated. 3 of those baniya are from dasam granth... any ideas on why this occurs? Secondly at the amrit sanchar we accept the five men who repeat the baniya as our Guru just as Guru Gobind Singh Jee did at Anandpur Sahib, so whatever they utter is guru bani (the word/prayer of the guru). So if they repeat the same words as those from the dasam granth, then that would prove that dasam granth is actually gurbani...wouldn't it?? Even AKJ maryada as well as all main stream sikhi (minus SGPC), state that the 5 baniya are the minimum nitnem and in that once again are the 3 baniya from dasam granth.. SO if dasam granth isnt a part of sikhi or the panth, then why are the contents repeated daily and MOST importantly why are they a part of the creation of amrit?? as im sure you would all agree without the bani amrit would just be water with sugar in it. ?? Well these are my few questions for the day. Hopefully, someone with more knowledge will be able to clarify the above.. remember, i'm still learning. Also since i would like proper knowledge, please do not just answer questions by stating that "well its just blatant...." or "that should go without saying" as this doesn't really prove anything. Thanks a bunch, Tarvinder Kaur

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

singh · 30 Mar 2003

vaheguru i love the weoponry, the culture of warriorstyle life but i disagree with all the afore sed anti gurmat stuff and cussin akj and bhai sahib down is a big letdown to the site and people will see past it.... but i hope and pray there can be dialogue, to overcome this, cos in the long term this is bad for any dwindling unity in the panth and secondly the info on the site can easily get into the hands of the wrong people, external orgs bent on destroying sikhi, who come on the net, we argue meat shudnt be eaten, all they gotto do is put that link up with jhatka, we say sikhs r one fraternal brother and sisterhood of beings and bang put up that site that says akj sikjs r this but us nihungs sikhs r that..... i think we shud try and talk to the main guys to sort these probs out...these diffs will in future no doubt be used as ammo against sikhs when the sado elements get hold of it..

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

rsingh · 30 Mar 2003

I found the shastervidiya site amusing in some ways. The way they try to expose all these fake gatka people who put on gatka shows just to inflate their own egos. These 'nihungs' obviously have no ego and do everything purely for seva, as is evident from the two line long titles they give themselves. Pure humility. And of course, they do this seva to preserve and practice the great nihung warrior spirit. Incidentally, is anybody aware of the great panthic seva these warriors have performed thus far? It must be truly amazing seva, in order for them to be able to put down people like Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh. After-all, what really did Bhai Fauja Singh do? Yeah, we know, he spent some years in jail after delivering punishment to a dusht and did massive amounts of paat and simran. And yes, he led a group of singhs against the nirankarees and took 11 or 12 bullets and gave his shaheedi for the panth. A shaheedi honoured by the entire panth. But I suppose that pales in comparison to the fearless feats of Nidar and his crew. They are true warriors. They cut up goats (or at least show pics of other people cutting up goats). Apparently, that's what makes a true sikh warrior - chop up a poor, defenceless goat. A truly courageous feat. Those goats are more dangerous than you might imagine. They might not be armed and fight back the way the Narakdharee militiamen did or Indian Paramilitary did, but they can bite or worse, urinate on you. But don't worry, Nidar and his crew are here to protect the sikh faith from these goats. I salute Nidar and the nungs of England for protecting us all. But, these nungs still have a long way to go before they can reach the level of their great buddha dal leader, Santa. A true warrior if there ever was one. At the time the sikh panth was under the worst attack it's ever been under, what great seva did Santa do? He joined Indira Ghandi and sold out the Sikh Panth. These wannabe nihungs are pathetic. The true nihungs of Guru Saahib were those who fought and died. People like Bhai Fauja singh, Bhai Amrik Singh, Baba Jarnail Singh, General Shubeg Singh, Bhai Anokh Singh and countless others. People like Santa and now these British Nungs, run around dressed in sikh bana, holding all sorts of shasters and claim this khalsa heritage to be theirs exclusively and question the right of other singhs to wear this bana. Yet, when the time came to be tested, they ran. Worse, they joined the enemy. Pathetic. To dasandas, Your statement about anyone's feelings about Bhai Randheer Singh or Bhai Fauja Singh being based on hearsay, is ignorant at best. I suppose you could say our views on any person, whether a gursikh from the guru period like Baba Buddha Jee, or a Gursikh of the Misl period like Nawab kapoor Singh Jee or someone like Akali Phoola Singh, or even some dusht like Abdalee or Indira Ghandi, are based on hearsay. Maybe we should comletely rid ourselves of history, as we were never there and it's all based on hearsay. For myself, I can say my views on Bhai Rhandeer Singh are based not only on hearsay, but the SEVERAL DOZEN BOOKS WRITTEN BY HIM. After reading these books, we don't need any hearsay. Also, the lives and actions of gursikhs speak for themselves. Bhai Fauja Singh gave his life for the panth. This speaks for itself. Is this based on hearsay? As much as any other part of the world's history is. Your next comment about our lives not changing if we never hear of these people is also.... I'll just say strange. Of course your life won't change. And it won't change if you don't hear of any other gursikh either. But that's the point, isn't it? Your life won't change. If you live a miserable, good for nothing life, you will continue to do so. But if you do hear of the life of some gursikh, your life might change, as thousands of lives have. And this is what sikhee is about. Changing your life. And as far as cussing someone, gursikh or not, that will change your life. Read gurbanee. Nindiya has a negative effect. Just like if I've done somebodies nindiya in this post, I will pay. As far as putting people on a pedastal, if somebody's actions are great, then they will be respected and honoured. That's just the way it is and has always been. We shouldn't worship anyone, but learning from and giving due respect to the lives of gursikhs is entirely acceptable in sikhee. Lastly, we all have the jot of Vaahiguru in us and so in that sense, nobody is better or worse. However, the actions committed by one can be classified as good or bad. To say otherwise is to be blind. And these actions are attached to a certain individual, so we can 'judge' whether somebody has acted badly or not. Yes, I used the word judge. JUDGE!! For example, I can 'judge' that KP Gill (butcher of punjab) is a bad person. He murdered and raped thousands upon thousands of people. The jot inside him may be the same as anyone else, BUT the actions committed by him are worse than most other people. So, he is a 'bad' person, as defined by the actions he committed. The rest of us may have sinned in some way as well, but that doesn't alleviate the magnitude of his sins or make other's sins as great as his.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Khalsa Soulja · 30 Mar 2003

i think everyone got confused on what i said. i believe dasam granth is gurbani (apart from hikayat). but i DO NOT believe that it is on the same level as the guru granth. the guru granth was compiled by the gurus and flows perfectly. it has nothing that is particularly misleading and is vetted by the guru himself. the dasam granth is incomplete in places, is not vetted by the guru and was compiled by a normal person. i accept everything in hte dasam granth but i cannot put it at the level of the guru granth since there has never been anything official proclaiming it a guru. same with the sarbloh granth - if guruji said "i proclaim the adi granth, dasam granth (which hadnt even been made then!!!!!!!) and sarbloh granth your 3 eternal gurus" then i would agree with the nihungs. the fact remains that the dasam granth is a great source for spirituality and warrior-ness but it isnt at the level as the guru granth. maybe im completely wrong, perhaps the 3 granths should all be considered guru, im not sure. i guess having all 3 up together wouldnt be that bad, but calling the dasam granth "dasam guru granth durbar" is WRONG. as for g-unit, marajuina is condemed in the guru granth. meat is condemned in the guru granth, even in the dasam granth. how can these "nihungs" be right? it is NOT in sikhi to crush up weed, mix it with poppy and almonds and drink it. it is NOT in sikhi to put goats blood in a sarbloh bowl. however its much more easy to justify wearing a keski all the time.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Tajinder · 30 Mar 2003

well, we have always been told since we were children that Sri Guru Gobind Singh is the tenth Guru Nanak Sahib jee. So surely the correct place for the bani of our Guru's is next to each other. Unless we want to think we are the Guru and try to seperate them and make distinctions.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Harbhajan Singh · 30 Mar 2003

Waheguru Jee Kaa Khlase, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh, Dear Sangat Jee, What I seem to understand from most of the posts is that some of us agree with the man-matt that the Nihangs try to portray as true Sikhi (they agree that all intoxicants except tobbaco is ok within Sikhi even Alcohol which they call Panj Ishnan(please correct me if im wrong), marrying a none-sikh is ok, beleiving in Hinduism and their gods is ok). I agree with the point that the Akali Warriors were the true warriors in the times of Guru Jee up until the Anglo-Sikh wars. However is there any documented account of any participation in any Morcha or any agitation against Sikhs by the Indian Government, that the Nihangs as a large Sikh Warrior Body took part in. 1984 which to some of us who lived it was the Kulookaraa of our times. The Nihangs probably played a minority part in the Battle but they disgraced themselves in front of the whole Sikh Nation when they rebuilt the Akal Thakt on the behest of the Indian Congress Government which in turn was taken down by the Sikh Nation. If you ask ordinary people in Punjab what they think about Nihangs which I’ve done several times when I visited. The impression I get from punjabis and Sikhs in Punjab are basically they are free-loaders, lazy people, have connections with the police who then turn a blind eye on their drug activities and also have protection rackets setup and harass people for money like the police and gundas. They only come out in big processions and show off (I used to have the opinion that they were great warriors of old, and had great institutions like the great Japaneese warrior schools but sadly I was wrong). Is this the way off life of Guru Ka Fauj? Would Guru Jee be happy with this way of life? People who have suffered for the Sikh Nation i.e. Bhai Fauja Singh Jee and Bhai Shaib Randhir Singh Jee are having their reputation destroyed. Who are these people to even talk about them. The person who has his face plastered all over the website has anyone been to his demos. There is no humility in his appearance, there is pure ego and the Language he sometimes uses in front of our Sisters and Mothers is down right degrading. He might be quoting some bani but doesn’t he know that some of it might be appropriate. Being knowledgeable of some martial discipline doesn’t give you the right too condemn anyone who you want and act like your superior. Bhai Fauja Singh Jee took the true challenge when confronted by Evil (nirankaris) he gave his Life. His companions also gave their life as well. Before that he spent most of his life trying to encourage Gursikhs in becoming Guru de Pyare so when the time come they would be strong enough to follow the True Akalis of old. What dose this website and its Hindu/Dodgy Sikh philosophy encourage people to become? Don’t look on the Fanciful webstite and think they must portray true Warriorship. I’ve been practising Martial Arts for over 15 Years. It’s not the art you learn that makes you better than anyone else it is the Humility that you practise this in and the respect you have for others that make you great. I’ve met Grandmasters of so many martial arts and it’s their Humbleness and their wish too keep on learning which encourages their students not their EGO. Most of them don’t even have fanciful titles unlike this 238932492369 crore jatha. However I hope the Worldwide Sangat also realises this group is very small in number and not really recognised in the UK. That’s why they have probably resorted in AKJ Bashing. Or as most people outside AKJ have realised there documentation is very similar to the RSS. You just have to wonder are they what they say they are, or are they something else? Harbhajan Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Singhnee · 31 Mar 2003

>>>>>>>>>>why cant someone say something taht mite contradicit the akj evn though it mite be rite? <<<<<<<<<<< Singhs and singhnees would love to hear if somebody will criticise akj for not following gurmat but otherwise it is not right hating akj because They are not taking any lives(killing animals for their jeebh rass) They are trying to follow tat-gurmat They are not compromising Guru Sahib's rehat to fit in so called panth of dhillay sikhs. Yes they are few because of Guru Sahib jee's furmaan: "Ko VIRLAA gurmat challai jeeo" Guru Sahib likes quality not quantity. "Rehat pyaari muj ko sikh pyaara nahe" Guru sahib jee gave same rights and duties to his singhs and singhnies. So why singhnies don't have to wear dastaars when they get amrit? Did Guru Sahib call women khalsi in any of his writings? Are there different hukams for singhs and singhnees in Baani? Who's following Guru Sahib's rehat then? We should be thankful to Waheguru who sent Bhai Sahib bhai Randhir Singh jee to remind us all Guru Sahib's rehat which was almost alop at that time. Bhul chuk muaaf jee! Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

~taste of own medicine?~ · 31 Mar 2003

I don't agree with these guys from Shaster Vidiya at all... ...but on a side note. I have seen many times in the past on AKJ forums of SOME akj singh "putting down" other sikhs who are not a part of AKJ. Perhaps now some of these singhs will know how it feels to be put down too. AKJ is not the supremacy of sikhi...no ONE Jatha is. When you judge someone you don't define them...you define yourself.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

punit · 01 Apr 2003

g-unit is right. we should go to proven vets, not these newcomers.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

sangh · 01 Apr 2003

MKhalsa's remarks where ignorant at best. Maybe if people took time to read what they wrote. Not Gursikhs. WHY? because they dont agree with akj? So i guess that makes 99% of the Khalsa Panth fake. Worship of Hindu Gods and Goddess? Maybe its more then meets the eye here, maybe these gods and goddess are representations of the many forms of Akaal. Many historians and scholars note Akali Maharaj Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji for worshiping of Shastars. However nihangs do the same thing and we condem them. I found much truth exposed on this site. However do condemn the negative remarks made by these Singhs of Guru Gobind Singh in regards to Bhai Fauja Singh, but then again they are entitled to their oppionions. As per them choosing to eat meat, they've found ways to justify it and I can agree with what they have to say. In conclusion I applaud Niddar Singh's open challange to all and ask that maybe next time you go through the site you read things with a more open mind.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Gaiani · 01 Apr 2003

I think there are many mislead people here, they believe that AKJ started by Bhai Sahib is something new and also that Nihungs and taksaal are puraatan. To the first point AKJ is just following the Tat Gurmat not starting anything. About Dasam Granth being placed beside Guru Sahib, the Dasam Granthy was compiled by Bhai Mani Singh, not by the tenth guru so it is not Guru endorsed. Also Dasmesh Patshah said the Hukamnaama; Sub Sikhaa Koh Hukum Hai Guru Maanayoh Granth. This proves that Guru sahib said that Guru Sahib is Guru not Sarbloh or Dasam Granth.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

SINGH · 01 Apr 2003

guys theres soo many extreme rss people on the web spreading hatred against sikhi, can u imagine how useful that info on the site wud be to them? im not talking about the hindu dieties, meat or sukha...but the way in which jatha is ripped..to outsiders its like amritdhari orthodox sikhs ripping other amritdhari orthodox sikhs remember outsiders r looking at the bana... then to top that off, what about the young hopeful people who wud like to become sikhs and want to learn about sikhi,theyl get put off with these blatent divisions, ok its fair enuff to outline the rehats r diff, that can be accepted but insulting jathebandis wont help... now jus imagine another 84 comes tomorow, will sites like this help akj and nihungs to work together in future? u cud be defending the akhal takhat again side by side akj and nihungs taksalis etc.. anything can happen... panthic unity is dwindling fast, we gotto preserve every bit of it brothers n sisters...this is what rss and goi want to split us up , i read on one of the rss sites, they accuse guru nanak of coming talking about ram then splitting hindus up against other hindus saying now the same will happen to sikhs.. but u see the sikhs r doin it to themselves, the rss goi r watching laffin and use it as ammo to split us up like hell.. what we do reflects on a bigger picture, singhs and singhnis whether akj or nihung, dont fall urself in that pit..ur playing into the hands of the goi... i feel its better if elders of the panth meet and discuss this problem, just accept rehat diffs exist call a halt to knocking each other....if u dont agree with jhatka sukha rag mala wat not fine, leave it at that..we r creating hurdles for future sikhs if they see divisions like this all out...

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Singhnee · 01 Apr 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Maybe if people took time to read what they wrote. Not Gursikhs. WHY? because they dont agree with akj? So i guess that makes 99% of the Khalsa Panth fake >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> What you mean by panth bhai sahib jeeo? Guru Sahib's panth can't nind Great naamrasi, Rehatvaan Gursikhs who follow Guru Sahib's hukams. If 1% keeps rehat and follows Gurmat, don't kill others, don't do nindyaa of Gursikhs, that is Guru jee's KHALSA PANTH. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> As per them choosing to eat meat, they've found ways to justify it and I can agree with what they have to say. <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< How you can justify taking others lives. Is it ok if someone kills your child with jhatkaa? Gurbani condemned it then how one can justify by using his/her moorh matt(dirty mind- "Jo ratt peevai(n) mansa(n) ten keo(n) nirmal cheet"). Read Guru Nanak Dev's Baani you will find out what Guru Sahib says about Hindus' Gods and Goddess pooja(worship). After reading that you won't be comparing shasters with moorties. Bhai Phauja Singh was a MARAD, a Gursikh who gave his life for Guru Sahib's respect. Did any Nihang go there to stop narakdharies putting there feet on Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee? Where were their shasters at that time? so who deserves to be Guru Gobind Singh's khalsa panth? Pleaseeeeeeeeeeeee next time read Gurbani more carefully and review history with open mind. Muaaf karna if I wrote anything wrong in bir rass. Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!!

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Singh · 01 Apr 2003

Giaini wrote: "Also Dasmesh Patshah said the Hukamnaama; Sub Sikhaa Koh Hukum Hai Guru Maanayoh Granth. This proves that Guru sahib said that Guru Sahib is Guru not Sarbloh or Dasam Granth." Um, the only problem is that this tuk does not come in any Bani. It is from outside of Bani. It is part of a Dohra that is not in the Granths. It is just written down in historical texts. Someone can correct, but i think it comes in Giani Gian Singh's documents originally (the same Giani Gian Singh who wrote that Guru Gobind Singh Ji used to take feem/drugs and Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji wore a janeyoo and tilak). I'm not arguing against this line. But to use this tuk which is not in any Bani to prove one Granth is Dhur Ki Bani and the other is not, does not make any sense. sorry.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

AKALI SINGHNEE · 01 Apr 2003

--post edited by admin-- these so called ''NIHANGS'' dont listen. they messed in their views. So why is it that the people that are at the forefront of Sikh student activities and representation regularly attend clubs? Some of these 'nihungs' regularly attend clubs, is this not a direct contradiction of what they preach, or supposedly preach? How can these people stand in front of a group of Sikh students and tell them what Sikhi teaches? Going to a club is not the place for a Gursikh as it is the perfect place for the five vices to flourish and win the battle against the mind. Clubs propagate sex, drinking, drugs etc. is this where a Gursikh is to find his/her Sadh Sangat?? It does not matter whether they do not drink or do not smoke, the simple fact is, should they be here? This Kaljug that we are in is hard enough, why make things harder for ourselves by attending these kinds of places, and when the people who are meant to be teaching us what Sikhi is about are doing it, where does that leave us? People like this should step down from the very responsible position, or openly admit to their mistakes and takes steps to amend them, Sikhi does not tolerate actions that harms Sikhi whether it be from outside forces or as in this case internal and I urge these people to change their ways. "When all other means have failed is it right and just to draw the sword" some of these uk 'nihungs' have demonstarted in front of youth as in ppl hu haven taken amrit jus like uni talks hu wanna knw abt sikhi and they are doin WRONG paarchaar.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Mkhalsa · 01 Apr 2003

Well if you follow your logic singh you could be saying that guru granth sahib jee is not really guru and we are all living false lives.. i dont think your logic works.. (unless that is really waht u are getting at)

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

NaamBiyaasi · 02 Apr 2003

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh It is Sad that there is Such hate in this world. Nindiya of others that follow different paths. Others such as the originators of this site, stating they practise the right path, whilst others follow another. Sad that is. Without Gian they talk of Gian, without Love they talk about Sikhism. What a Sad world we live in. Learn to Love and Walk the Path of Truth within you. Such a Love goes beyond the intellect, do not suffocate yourselves in it. SatNaam Sahai Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

AKALI SINGHNEE · 02 Apr 2003

sum 1 replay to me !

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

sangh · 02 Apr 2003

MKHALSA: bani guru guru hai bani.. in nitnem gutka's you place all dasam pita's bani along side bani from sri guru granth. Lets follow your logic and seperate the two, better yet lets just stop reading Dasam Pita's bani all together as your logic states, its not bani and as it is not bani we shouldn't be reciting it, because if its not bani it must be kuchi bani. Bani GURU... anything that was written by GURU SAHIB is bani. EVERYTHING. Never have the nihangs said Sri Guru Granth Sahib is not bani. And it indeed is the current guru of the sikhs, they simply take into account that the BANI is the guru. as per posts in regards to hindu gods/goddsesses maybe its time you looked at it from a metaphorical view and not just be satisified with the translations you read of sikhitothemax ( I do not mean this as an insult to SikhiToTheMax), bani is MUCH deeper then many of you seem to believe. As per the panji who wrote about the nihangs going to clubs and going against what they preach, I've met many akj youth who date, eat out, dont keep bibek etc. GURANTEE you there are members of the Jatha who also go to clubs and parties. However it is suffice to say that these individuals are not a representation of the jatha in general rather a few people who are victems to Kal Jug. Now something I find particularly interesting is the Jatha's reaction to the nihangs eating meat. Whenever AKJ is questioned about making their own rehat in regards to Keski as a kakaar and Raag Maala not being bani they will be quick to say that they follow the panthic rehat set by the Akaal Takht which states keski and raag maala are both optional but doesn't it say the same of MEAT? So WHY!?! the sudden change in your general stance? Finally I would just like to know the Jatha's replies in regards to the comments made towards Bhai Randhir Singh Ji ( I hold nothing against Bhai Sahib as they where amazing Gursikhs) but I'm curious as to the remarks made by these singhs in regards to Bhai Sahibs literature. ( [url] http://www.shastarvidiya.org/htmls/chatka.html [/url] ) Please excuse my millions of spelling errors.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Kulbir Singh · 02 Apr 2003

I just want to mention that it is not appropriate for so called UK Nihungs to write bad things about Bhai Fauja Singh and Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee. It is fine if they push forward their ideology but it is not right to attack a panthik organization and panthik gursikhs. By doing so they are only discrediting themselves and their ideology. I doubt that the real nihungs in India have this kind of hatred for jatha. I heard that Bhai Fauja Singh and some of this friends learned some gatka from Buddha Dal and if the Nihungs call Bhai Fauja Singh's gatka a "circus", then they are only doing ninda of Buddha Dal as they are the ones who taught some parts of Gatka to Bhai Fauja Singh. I really liked that post by Bhai Harbhajan Singh in this thread. He so hilariously got his point across. Very well written post!! I urge Bhai Harbhajan Singh to post more often. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

AKALI SINGHNEE · 02 Apr 2003

they not '' NIHANGS '' they are called '' NANGS ''

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

rsingh · 02 Apr 2003

Sangh, About the article on Chatka. I'm not responding on behalf of the AKJ and I think most of the people here are responding as individuals, not as official representatives of any organization. From my understanding (and hopefully somebody will correct me if I'm wrong), the British 'nihungs' didn't say or show anything that disproves Bhai Saahib's writings on Chatkaa. Actually, they provide evidence to support Bhai Saahib. Bhai Saahib said that Chatkaa was an old Hindu practice that some sikhs had picked up along the way. The shastarvidiya site acknowledges that chatkaa of goats is an old practice of hindus. They also state that chatkaa is never mentioned in the Guru Granth Saahib. They then mention two tuks from the Dasm Granth that mention chatkaa and try to discredit Bhai Saahib with these tuks. However, these two tuks mention chatkaa of humans, in battle. They mention chatkaa as a method of killing with one blow in battle. They do not say anything about chatkaa for animal sacrifice rituals or chatkaa maas. Bhai Randheer Singh wrote about Chatkaa MAAS (meat obtained through chatkaa). Hence the title of the tract, 'Chatkaa Maas Prathiyae Tat Gurmat Nirnay'. The self proclaimed 'nihungs' of the UK have basically proven what Bhai Saahib Randheer Singh wrote: that chatkaa maas is never mentioned in any banee of the guru's. I also have a comment about chatkaa gatkaa. The british 'nihungs' often claim that gatka is a fake copy of the real martial arts and that gatka is simply the name for a wooden stick (and yes, gatka is the name for a wooden stick). But then what exactly is Chatkaa Gutkaa? How can one perform Chatkaa with a wooden stick? Isn't this almost an oxymoron? I've heard that some real nihungs from India (Baba Nihaal Singh) claim that chatka gatka is completely made up. Did the British 'nihungs' simply make up this term because it rhymes and might sound 'cool' to people? That's pretty sad. Sangh, about your meat comment. As far as I know, the Jatha agrees that Kutha maas is prohibited. They simply disagree with the SGPC definition of kuthaa. You can read about it in the Literature section. I also don't think anybody here has stated that Guru Gobind Singh Jee's banee isn't Gurbanee. You're just trying to cloud the real issue by trying to say that. The arguement is that the gurgaddee was given to the Guru Granth Saahib. The Dasm Granth and Sarbloh Granth were compiled later and weren't given the gurgaddee. Dasm Pita's banee is gurbanee but the gurgaddee was given to the Guru Granth Saahib. Only Guru Saahib can pass on and bestow the gurgaddee and Guru Gobind Singh Jee did that. You can argue whatever you want, but the fact will always remain that guru Saahib gave the gurgadee to the Guru Granth Saahib and not the Dasm Granth (which wasn't even around at the time). In fact, the generally accepted modern version of the Dasm Granth was finalized around the turn of the last century. Even today, different groups seem to have slightly different versions of the Dasm Granth. This doesn't mean that Guru Gobind Singh Jee's banee isn't held in high esteem and seen as Gurbanee. Of course it's Gurbanee.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Khalsa Soulja · 02 Apr 2003

i agree completely altho i do think that chatka gatka looks kinda gangsta from the videos lol it sounds like a takaway from a indian restaurant tho (no offence meant to anyone) ................edited by Admin............... Dear Khalsa Soulja, we have edited comments related to Dasam Granth. As per hukam from Sri Akal Takhat, we should not discuss the authenticity of Dasam Granth.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

NJSingh · 02 Apr 2003

Rsingh, Gatka is a word that has been fabricated over teh years and translates to the "Rythm Of..." Probably of shastar. But Chatkaa Shastar is simply, the rythm of attacking with 1 blow to the neck. These nihangs have applied this definition to preparing food and maas. Which is wrong. Chatkaa is for battle purposes only. It is supposed to be the most powerful art.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

sikh · 05 Apr 2003

the bit i hate on that site is when the author calls shaheeds "fanatics". thats an insult to the whole sikh panth. the shaheeds didnt die for any jatha they gave their kurbani for the whole sikh faith when guru granth sahib was being attacked... to say they were fanatics is the theme line exactly what the indian media and brahmins call sikhs fighting and dieing for their rights against indian opression.. ask urself a question how can any sikh call a shaheed a fanatic when they died for what we consider god?? wud any sikh do that??

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

warrior*princess · 05 Apr 2003

wahegurujikakhalsa::wahegurujikefateh Being a lover of Shaster, I was very excited about visiting their site!LOL But... I was definately saddenned and angered at seeing how slaughter was promoted, hinduism was worshipped, akj and Bhai Randhir Singh ji was insulted and how BAISTEE of Sarbloh, Shaster is done and the fact that GURU JI's, WAHEGURU ji's hukum is dis-obeyed really gets me! Overall, they definately seem like confused people. BUT I have heard that sometimes, this type of NANGS are usually put by Government people to further dellude Sikhi..and their site is a very good example of this and their ignorance/lack of knowledge of Sikhi. The common element of nangs in india who think they are nihangs is their ignorance of the Sikh Religon. Do not forget their initial website of Sarbloh.info....When i visited their site for the first time, i did not like the way Guru ji's photo was displayed amongst the Hindu Gods...but at the same time i felt confused about whether i am taking it too seriously. BUT after seeing shastervidiya.com, it has most definately proved my doubts. The WORST thing is that Gurubani is beautifully displayed in the headers of their site but the completely wrong image is being portrayed right underneath!.... The other day when walking home, I had to pass by a truck that had cows hung upside down with their heads cut off...I DONT EVEN WANT A SIKH ASSOCIATED with that type of conduct of slaughtering or meat eating....SO it was over-whelmingly grose to see how the entrance page was of a slaughtered goat! We were contacted by the owner/maker of Sarbloh.info via email and veer ji sounded innocent-like in comparison to what shastervidiya is potraying...so it might REALLY possible that they are mis-lead people and unaware of the correct Sikhi...or they are just another type of rss (esp the worship of hindu gods and cannibis, or anti-sikhi sites). wahegurujikakhalsa::wahegurujikefateh

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

g · 06 Apr 2003

the same person who created sarbloh.info helped create shahster vidya - so forget the innonocent approach when they spoke to u- these guys are clever they know exactly wut they are doing.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

dasandas · 06 Apr 2003

to the singh who took everything I said out of proportion to make an exciting and extreme point of view. I just want to say, there are no black and whites (regardless of how you interpret gurbani or anything in life). I still stand by my point, and say that one would have to consider bhai randhir singh ji, and bhau fauja singh ji to be ideal sikhs in order for your comment to be valid. talk to some sikhs, and the ideal sikh was baba nand singh, or ishar singh kaleran wallay, or even baba gurbachan singh bhindrawalla. Interestingly enough each of these gursikhs have also had their own spin on sikhi. I am talking facts not nindya or anything else. AND because they are all within a spectrum which is acceptabel, I am not criticising sikhi or any of the mahapurkhs (this being said, mainly with the intent of not offending anyone). bhaji, you have mentioned many great gursikhs from the past, I Do not deny anyone their love, exhibition of their love, or their lifestyle. My faith tells me that each gursikh will be like a blossomed full grown flower within a garden.. no 2 are the same, although they are. for the sake of history, lets remember that akali phoola singh lashed maharaja ranjit singh for sleeping with moran (she wasn't his wife). we all know from historical sources that maharaja ranjit singh was a drunk. hence, if these brothers of ours (the uk nihangs) point out that smoking is the bujjhar kurehit. this proves it. now, don't get me wrong. I am not condoning drinking. I don't condone meat, but if someone has the heart to do it, and will with their own hands...let them. lets not try to make the truth more pure. stay in chardeekallah singh

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

warrior*princess · 07 Apr 2003

i TOTALLY agree with 'Sikh'...when someone cussess the Shaheeds that is just so much baistee to Guru ji, hence waheguru ji!!!!!!! No doubt about it. I dont want to think about it anymore, gets me arrrrrgggggggggg Dont worry too much about these people, to ignore them and to make others aware of their incorrect potrayal of Sikhi is the best thing to do....and to make sure that we stick to our bana..that is a Sikhs duty.... always remember......... rehit pyaree muj kaw Sikh pyara Naa Hai (Guru Gobind Singh Ji) bhul chuk maaf karna for any mistakes according to gurmat wahegurujikakhalsa-wahegurujikefateh

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

Sardaro · 07 Apr 2003

A friend of mine recently talked to this diddar "singh" apparently their 4 kuraits are: 1) no halal 2) no removal of kesh 3) no tobacco 4) no sleeping with muslim women they said it is ok to sleep with other women before marriage as it helps make you a stronger sikh. HAHAHA..

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

member · 07 Apr 2003

wjkkwjkf i have one question for the sangat, does anyone know of a naami gursikh who eats meat and takes pang and slanders other great singhs? no, so why take their garbage opinions into consideration, by looking at what they do anyone can see that there is no way for them to have any bir rass (which only real guru ki fauj is blessed with, not bajjar kurehitis and nindaks).

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

rsingh · 08 Apr 2003

dasandas said, >'to the singh who took everything I said out of proportion to make an exciting and extreme point of view.' Haha. I guess you're referring to me. I looked back at my post to see if maybe I got carried away. Well, I don't think so. I took everything you said at face value and replied as such. Maybe you could explain what it is that I took out of proportion. It would also be nice if you could tell me what extreme point of view I've taken. >'I just want to say, there are no black and whites (regardless of how you interpret gurbani or anything in life).' Hmmm. That sounds nice, and may be true in many cases. However, the picture isn't as hazy as you would like us to think. There are some blacks and whites and also some very dark and light shades as well. If there weren't, it would be pretty much impossible to even get started on the path of sikhee, or on any path for that matter. >'I still stand by my point, and say that one would have to consider bhai randhir singh ji, and bhau fauja singh ji to be ideal sikhs in order for your comment to be valid. talk to some sikhs, and the ideal sikh was baba nand singh, or ishar singh kaleran wallay, or even baba gurbachan singh bhindrawalla.' Which comment are you referring to? I said that their writings and actions speak for themselves and that I believe these singhs to have been great gursikhs. I also said that hearing about the lives of gursikhs can have a huge positive impact on our own lives. I don't really understand what your point is and what it is that you're standing by. Maybe you should state your point clearly and straight out. >'for the sake of history, lets remember that akali phoola singh lashed maharaja ranjit singh for sleeping with moran (she wasn't his wife). we all know from historical sources that maharaja ranjit singh was a drunk. hence, if these brothers of ours (the uk nihangs) point out that smoking is the bujjhar kurehit. this proves it.' No, actually, this doesn't prove anything. I can give you examples of historians writing that some Sikhs smoked and so, it was acceptable for sikhs to smoke. We all know that this isn't true. The self-proclaimed nihungs of the UK give an example on one of their websites of some European historian writing about the lifestyle of some 'sikhs' of the past. They describe these 'sikhs' as users of hemp and 'spirits' (alcohol) and the UK 'nihangs' try justifying the use of intoxicants with this example (along with several other examples). I think anybody with even half a brain knows that someone who drinks isn't a sikh. It is completely condemned by Guru Saahib. These guys are trying to make a rehit based on the lives of some nangs and of course, their great imaginations. >'stay in chardeekallah singh' Thanks. You too.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

nihang singh · 08 Apr 2003

yes to simran_sewa_sacrifice... some of the nihang jathedars were proper nihangs with uchi avastha. baba kirtan singh ji, was not particularly known for taking sukha or eating mahaprashaad, but he was known as a brahmgyani (even by taksali's). I'll let everyone do their own research. as for, bhang, no.. it is not meant to be an aid in spirituality. Secondly, raghbir singh bir in his book writes of how meat should be avoided, but again, its upto us on how we interpret kutta.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

sikh · 08 Apr 2003

drinking is totally against gurmat, theres plenty of bani that tells us y drinking is bad and y it shud be avoided..

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

dasandas · 08 Apr 2003

to RSINGH (alright. here goes it): Your statement about anyone's feelings about Bhai Randheer Singh or Bhai Fauja Singh being based on hearsay, is ignorant at best. > ignorant, I think not! the way these "gursikhs" were measured was by the amount of walking they did barefoot. and how discriminative they were in taking. langar. sikhi does not need puritans to set any example. our guru's did so. I suppose you could say our views on any person, whether a gursikh from the guru period like Baba Buddha Jee, or a Gursikh of the Misl period like Nawab kapoor Singh Jee or someone like Akali Phoola Singh, > you are right, the only difference though is that its not the "akj" or people who have their emotions and interests at stake who promote these sikhs. no one was perfect... accept that. Many people who write about gursikhs speak as if they were perfect.WRONG...IGNORANT AT BEST. or even some dusht like Abdalee or Indira Ghandi, are based on hearsay. > so these people were dushts! what gave you the right to call anyone a dusht. Just because you are humble in front of guru sahib, doesn't mean that you have the right to be a judge anywhere else. I don't agree with what they did. on another note, everything is heresay because it has fact, but the interpretation and grandeur given is all based on the authors and their respective views...facts are facts. you may view walking barefoot and starving as a virtue because of bibek. I personally think its a bit far fetched. Maybe we should comletely rid ourselves of history, as we were never there and it's all based on hearsay. > a bit extreme here my friend. and if this is face value, I hope it works with everything in life. For myself, I can say my views on Bhai Rhandeer Singh are based not only on hearsay, but the SEVERAL DOZEN BOOKS WRITTEN BY HIM. > he lied about shaheed bhagat singh wanting to become amritdhari. so, it makes me question how much the rest of it was true. After reading these books, we don't need any hearsay. Also, the lives and actions of gursikhs speak for themselves. > you mean like passing out at the site of a flower dying, or having so much bhagtee that an alchemy solution consumed him.?? Bhai Fauja Singh gave his life for the panth. This speaks for itself. > very true. I would have to agree with you here. Is this based on hearsay? As much as any other part of the world's history is. > so you have now decided to become humble and rational, hmmm. interesting and no, bhai fauja singh was fairly recent. although if you read the "Version" of 1978 by the gov't, bhai fauja singh went in swinging at everyone. (If I am nirnankari.. whats the truth? am I going to believe that bhai fauja singh was a great humble man, or a tyrant. ps. I am not nirankari, and even if I were it doesn't qualify me as being a "dusht"). Y our next comment about our lives not changing if we never hear of these people is also.... I'll just say strange. Of course your life won't change. And it won't change if you don't hear of any other gursikh either. But that's the point, isn't it? > you are right here. it is the point. Your life won't change. If you live a miserable, good for nothing life, you will continue to do so. But if you do hear of the life of some gursikh, your life might change, as thousands of lives have. > yeah, or anyone inspiritational. And this is what sikhee is about. Changing your life. And as far as cussing someone, gursikh or not, that will change your life. Read gurbanee. Nindiya has a negative effect. Just like if I've done somebodies nindiya in this post, I will pay. > agreed, It depends on bhavna. saying something "anti" gursikh, is not a sin...so long as it is done with the intention of demonstrating a flaw. otherwise our nihang brothers are gettting their way paved for heaven. As far as putting people on a pedastal, if somebody's actions are great, then they will be respected and honoured. That's just the way it is and has always been. > no not always, remember that people are only praised when someone has something to gain. We shouldn't worship anyone, but learning from and giving due respect to the lives of gursikhs is entirely acceptable in sikhee. Lastly, we all have the jot of Vaahiguru in us and so in that sense, nobody is better or worse. > I agree with you here. However, the actions committed by one can be classified as good or bad. To say otherwise is to be blind. > no, I disagree. everyone is good and bad based on what you determine is good and bad. apart from god, everything else is crap. And these actions are attached to a certain individual, so we can 'judge' whether somebody has acted badly or not. Yes, I used the word judge. JUDGE!! For example, I can 'judge' that KP Gill (butcher of punjab) is a bad person. > he's my chacha. my cousin's love him off. he is a good father to them. tell them he's bad.! (get the drift). He murdered and raped thousands upon thousands of people. The jot inside him may be the same as anyone else, BUT the actions committed by him are worse than most other people. So, he is a 'bad' person, as defined by the actions he committed. > he personally raped thousands of people? hmmm. his actions are his actions. get your point. I don't see it as being black and white. lets not deny that some of our "kharkoo" brothers were oppurtunitsts and thugs. not everyone who was or is still in that mode of thought have the intentions of a greater sikh homeland. so many people are bought out by the government (within our panth) that it is quite ignorant to claim that the few virtuous ones speak for the lot. The rest of us may have sinned in some way as well, but that doesn't alleviate the magnitude of his sins or make other's sins as great as his. > about mr. gill. for the indian government he was an enforcer, for his kids he was a father. for each person in his life he meant something else. I see it from your point of view (don't get me wrong), but be humble in judging others. guru sahib has made us sikhs, not dharam raaj!

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

dasandas · 08 Apr 2003

to rsingh again...again Haha. I guess you're referring to me. I looked back at my post to see if maybe I got carried away. Well, I don't think so. I took everything you said at face value and replied as such. Maybe you could explain what it is that I took out of proportion. It would also be nice if you could tell me what extreme point of view I've taken. < the extent you went to with heresay. you took your point to the extreme. you exxagerated the "heresay" explanation. many things aren't meant to be taken at face value. Hmmm. That sounds nice, and may be true in many cases. However, the picture isn't as hazy as you would like us to think. There are some blacks and whites and also some very dark and light shades as well. If there weren't, it would be pretty much impossible to even get started on the path of sikhee, or on any path for that matter. < honestly, I don't want you to think like me. I am just giving my point of view.I do agree about the starting point, but the blacks and whites are very very few. I find many who "latch" onto blacks and whites,get caught on a really superficial level of things in life. where rights and wrongs (as they deem, personally or cult-collectively) becom their gauge. Which comment are you referring to? I said that their writings and actions speak for themselves and that I believe these singhs to have been great gursikhs. I also said that hearing about the lives of gursikhs can have a huge positive impact on our own lives. I don't really understand what your point is and what it is that you're standing by. Maybe you should state your point clearly and straight out.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

rsingh · 09 Apr 2003

dasandas, Glad to see you came out and shared your true feelings. > ignorant, I think not! the way these "gursikhs" were measured was by the amount of walking they did barefoot. and how discriminative they were in taking. langar. sikhi does not need puritans to set any example. our guru's did so. No, actually most people look at the amounts of paat they did and the love they had for their guru. The fact that they kept strict rehit is part of this. Many gursikhs from many different jathas kept and keep these rehits. You don't seem to agree with this. That's your call and not something I'm going to spend time arguing about. > you are right, the only difference though is that its not the "akj" or people who have their emotions and interests at stake who promote these sikhs. no one was perfect... accept that. Many people who write about gursikhs speak as if they were perfect.WRONG...IGNORANT AT BEST. Ahh, where to begin? Firstly, these singhs don't need to be promoted by anybody. Secondly, these singhs are respected and honoured by the majority of the panth, not just the AKJ. You seem to have some sort of deep seated dislike for these singhs and the AKJ, and this won't let you accept this. That's fine though. You don't have to like them, nobody does. You also seem to be putting words into my mouth. Where did I use the term 'perfect'? I spoke of gursikhs. I never said anything about anybody being perfect. >'IGNORANT AT BEST.'< Haha, what are you, a parrot? > so these people were dushts! what gave you the right to call anyone a dusht. Just because you are humble in front of guru sahib, doesn't mean that you have the right to be a judge anywhere else. I don't agree with what they did. on another note, everything is heresay because it has fact, but the interpretation and grandeur given is all based on the authors and their respective views...facts are facts. you may view walking barefoot and starving as a virtue because of bibek. I personally think its a bit far fetched. What gave me the right to call anyone a dusht? The same one who gave you a right to question my right to judge and the same one who gave you a right to judge the people you judge. You've made many judgements in your posts, so stop being a hypocrit in questioning my right to judge. I guess Shaheed Bhai Satwant Singh and Shaheed Bhai Beant Singh and the vast majority of the panth were also guilty of judging Indira? I will agree that interpretation of facts depends on the individual and their outlook on life. However, most of these facts are based on 'hearsay', since we weren't there. You initially questioned Sarbloh Kaur's views on certain gursikhs as being based on hearsay and I simply pointed out that most of our beliefs about the past are based on hearsay. > a bit extreme here my friend. and if this is face value, I hope it works with everything in life. My comment was based completely on your statement, in order to show that your statement made little sense. And yes, it is at face value. If you find it extreme, maybe you should re-check your original statement. And yes, it does work with everything in life. > he lied about shaheed bhagat singh wanting to become amritdhari. so, it makes me question how much the rest of it was true. It seems that your making judgements and jumping to conclusions without looking at the facts. I found Bhai Saahib Randheer Singh's writing on Bhagat Singh to see maybe if my memory was failing me. Nope. It seems as if you're the one who is lying or just confused. Bhai Randheer Singh doesn't say that Bhagat Singh wanted to take amrit. Kapoor Singh the historian says this, not Bhai Randheer Singh, so maybe you should accuse Kapoor Singh of lying. Bhai Randheer Singh says that Bhagat Singh left their meeting saying that he was no longer afraid to die as he knew his soul was immortal. He also said he would keep his hair if Bhai Saahib wanted him too. His family (his sister) agrees that Bhagat Singh in fact kept his hair after this meeting, and their are photographs to prove it. It seems that some people who dislike or hate the AKJ and Bhai Randheer Singh are trying to spread misinformation in order to discredit Bhai Saahib. > you mean like passing out at the site of a flower dying, or having so much bhagtee that an alchemy solution consumed him.?? Sure. Why not? It's funny how that's all you can find out of the amount of literature Bhai Saahib produced. And the alchemy solution consumed him? Not quite. Maybe you're the one who's prone to being extreme in your analysis. > so you have now decided to become humble and rational, hmmm. interesting and no, bhai fauja singh was fairly recent. although if you read the "Version" of 1978 by the gov't, bhai fauja singh went in swinging at everyone. (If I am nirnankari.. whats the truth? am I going to believe that bhai fauja singh was a great humble man, or a tyrant. ps. I am not nirankari, and even if I were it doesn't qualify me as being a "dusht"). Humble? No, actually I didn't notice or intend any humility in my post. I admit, it was quite an arrogant and condescending post. This is a shortcoming. I felt no humility in writing that post and I didn't try to put on a false mask of humility. However, my post was quite rational, all throughout. Bhai Fauja Singh was recent, but it's still history. Recent history. As far as looking at it from a Narakdharee point of view goes. You could say that about any part of our history. All the wars sikhs fought. Do you think the adversaries would say the same thing that sikhs say about these struggles? Indira Ghandi and the Indian government called Sant Jarnail Singh all sorts of names. The Sikh nation sees him as a hero. You can even go back to the guru's and see what the powers of the time said about them. As a sikh, I will look at events from a sikh point of view. The sikh panth will judge any event based on gurmat. You can look at them from a narakhdaree point of view or an RSS point of view or whatever you want. I don't know about narakdharees being dushts or whatever, but if you were one, you would definitely be excommunicated by the sikh panth. > no not always, remember that people are only praised when someone has something to gain. This is a rather cynical comment. This may be the case sometimes, but not always. I praise Sant Jarnail Singh because I admire him, not because I have anything to gain. What do I have to gain by praising anyone except god? I praise people that I admire. > no, I disagree. everyone is good and bad based on what you determine is good and bad. apart from god, everything else is crap. Of course. You may argue about relative and absolute truths and blah blah blah... When it comes down to it, there are good and bad actions. Rape is bad. Anyway you look at it, it is bad. Tobacco is a bujjer kurehit for a sikh. No matter what the bhavnaa, it is still a bujjer kurehit. A sikh decides on whether an action is good or bad based on gurmat. You may argue that one person may view another person's understanding of gurmat as manmat. True. But there are still actions that you can and must determine to be good or bad. If there weren't, you couldn't really follow the path of sikhee. Not only sikhee, you wouldn't be able to live in society. > he's my chacha. my cousin's love him off. he is a good father to them. tell them he's bad.! (get the drift). Nope! I don't get the drift. If my father raped someone, he's wrong regardless of whether he's my father or not or what my opinion is on the matter. It doesn't matter who loves him or doesn't. According to gurmat, he is wrong. Even according to society at large and the established legal systems, he would be considered wrong. Maybe in some fantasy world, he might be considered to be a good person. > he personally raped thousands of people? hmmm. his actions are his actions. get your point. I don't see it as being black and white. lets not deny that some of our "kharkoo" brothers were oppurtunitsts and thugs. not everyone who was or is still in that mode of thought have the intentions of a greater sikh homeland. so many people are bought out by the government (within our panth) that it is quite ignorant to claim that the few virtuous ones speak for the lot. I guess maybe we should tell the Jews that they're giving Hitler a bum rap. He didn't personally kill all those people. As far as kharkoos are considered, I didn't say anything about them one way or another. And you're right, many people are bought out by the government. But the sins of some misguided kharkoo doesn't justify or lessen what KP Gill did. > about mr. gill. for the indian government he was an enforcer, for his kids he was a father. for each person in his life he meant something else. I see it from your point of view (don't get me wrong), but be humble in judging others. guru sahib has made us sikhs, not dharam raaj! And to the Sikhs, he was a butcher. What's your point? We should be humble in judging and maybe give him a medal or something? 'KP, you were a good enforcer and father, so here's your medal. We'll overlook what you did to our brothers and sisters, as we can't really judge you.' Give me a break!! God gave us a brain to be able judge right from wrong. I don't give a .... if he was a good whatever. In the end, he butchered tens of thousands of people. If sikhs can't judge, then how can they ever know when to use those kirpans that Guru Saahib gave them? I will agree that there are limits to judging and a sikh should overlook people's personal flaws as long as these flaws don't cause widespread damage. It doesn't mean you don't notice the fault or mistakes in others, you just overlook it. In fact, you must notice even in determining sangat from kasangat. This isn't acting as dharam raj. We don't condemn people or enforce anything on them. But in order to better yourself, you must notice and then fix yourself. However, if the flaw is such that it causes death and suffering in others, then a sikh must judge and act in whatever way they can. Now your next post. < the extent you went to with heresay. you took your point to the extreme. you exxagerated the "heresay" explanation. many things aren't meant to be taken at face value. I think I already explained myself above. < honestly, I don't want you to think like me. I am just giving my point of view.I do agree about the starting point, but the blacks and whites are very very few. I find many who "latch" onto blacks and whites,get caught on a really superficial level of things in life. where rights and wrongs (as they deem, personally or cult-collectively) becom their gauge. I can agree somewhat. However, completely abandoning rights and wrongs doesn't work either. They always exist. have a good one. ( i have purposely given you stuff to work with enlighten me Mr. R.SINGH) Thanks. I'm not here to enlighten you or anybody else, and I don't think you're here to be enlightened. We have our points of view, and in the end, I think we are just going to have to agree to disagree.

Re: www.shastarvidiya.org

ADMIN · 09 Apr 2003

We think that all constructive debate has been exhausted, so this thread will be stopped here.