Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

"Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

"Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

bs_singh · 05 Dec 2004

How do we stop this? Any suggestions? I suggest we give Tankhya to "Sikhs" who visit/pray at mandirs

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

GUrpreet Singh · 05 Dec 2004

there is nothing wrong with going to a mandir, just dont pray there or worship and statues. If you are there for the purpose of gaining knowledge about the hindu religion, wats wrong in this?

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

huh · 06 Dec 2004

Fateh, Would you think its reasonable if people from other religions starting giving out the equivalent to the 'Tankhya' in their religion to people whom simply visit our Gurdwara Sahibs? Yea, I think it’s a pretty silly thing to do too... Fateh. Ps, I'm talking about 'Sikhs' who simply visit Mandirs etc.

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

gkd · 06 Dec 2004

sikhs invite all their friends 2 paats/langaars, friends also that are not sikh so we must reciprocrate.

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

pavandeep · 06 Dec 2004

Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh, I've never been to a mandir, so I don't know what hindus do there. I do know that many of Guru Nanak Dev Ji's teachings reject hindu rituals. How important is it to learn about hinduism, if it was rejected by our Guru? So as Sikhs, even though we aren't opposed to any religion, wouldn't it be wrong to actually go to a mandir (and participate in or even observe the rituals Sikhi rejects)?

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

dil · 06 Dec 2004

WGJKK,WGJKF; Here I am sorry to say that we will be considered as equivalent narrow minded as muslims. I have seen some muslims visiting gurudwara with friends but never bow in front of Guru Sahib. They even eat langar. Cover their there head as required. But they will never bow in front of Guru sahib. We feel very bad. Same thing if you go to mandir and does not follow some minimum rituals. At least to show the gathering that we respect your faith. How good it will be. They will not see us with hatred. I hope every one understands. No question of declaring Tankhaiya, Sorry for hurting some one un knowingly. WGJKK,WGJKF;

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

gsingh.... · 06 Dec 2004

I have been to a few hindu mandirs b4 but not recently. Whenever I go to Gurdwara, my hindu friends come along with me. When I hav to go with them, i go as a tourist...but i dont do maatha tek....i say them our religion forbids idol worship.....but i havnt gone to a hindu mandar for more than 7-8 years now.....I find silly those Sikhs who go to mandirs....get themselves tikka sorta thing.....bow b4 idols....or ring the bells.....that look silly and ridiculous

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

inside out · 06 Dec 2004

<> We are free to visit other places of worship, we are encouraged to learn and read about the world around us..Guroo jee encourages we LIVE IN THE WORLD. You can visit a mandir and not participate in things which make you feel uncomfortable or 'less of a Sikh'. So then it's okay for others to visit Gurdwaras, how hypocritical and ignorant. May I remind you that Sikhi exists and thrives because of the universal nature of 'Gurmat'. In that case, I suggest we give a tankhya to Sikhs who are close-minded!!!

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

............ · 06 Dec 2004

The underlieing tension from what i see is the confusion some sikhs are facing who see other sikhs worshipping and praying to idols and singing songs to make money out of it. This is more on tv serials and news in India but a sad sight to see a singh dancing happily to a statue in himalaya on alpha tv but what wont a person do for money? I do know some mona from sikh family going to mandirs, i dont think its about religion as such. Everyone has different reasons i talked to one who claims a dhadi vaar sounds to fanatical for him. But his reasons for going mandir was more to do with absence of gianis and having grown up in a sikh community where everyone looks at each other. Pandits are not fussed in responsibility and hindus are spaced out to do anything they want in mandirs in the name of fluid progress . Everyone thinks the grass is greener on the other side, if sikhs create a positive environment in a gurdwara 1) Get in gianis who are passionate in spreading sikhi but not a codiefied dictate. Who do not judge you, but explain to a person the benefits of simran, bani and sharing, like slowly weaning people towards sikhi instead of telling them bluntly with that angry look they are not sikh. This builds the persons life base on sikh ideals and opens up the horizen to perhaps one day take amrit then being shunned away as an apostate. One person having sikh leanings creates more avenues to their future children and spreads to friends. 2) We need committees dedicated to sikhi who spend their time and energy working for the upliftment of community ie marital guidance panels for people facing problems, career guidance, drug rehab, creche facilities for newly weds (what better place for a child to be than a gurdwara as well as being taught) and single mothers n kids. Too much punjabiness elitism, selfish leaders are motivated by their own name and money at the moment to do anything for others. 3) Get in youth to do seva and realise the benefits of giving apart of their self even once a week to feel part of the sikh community. At the moment the oldies will not like youngsters doing anything. If a mandir gives you a koochi to maanj the pandey while the oldies dont even let you wash dishes in the gurdwara where will you go? 4) Keep only positive side of punjabi culture ie language, expression, looking out for one another, and get rid of the things that are punjabi that are attacking the community. Gossip, backstabbing, fighting to be leaders, looking down on others, staring at people as if they come from the moon. 5) Create that type of missionary atmosphere where young sikhs enjoy talking about their history and how to better their lives and spread the word to other sikh children to increase the unity. 6) set up classes for kids and adults in dealing with muslim hindu pressure of conversions/influences. 7) i am not married yet but have been told the freshies stand around checking out peoples wives and sisters. If i had sisters and wives i would be very careful and lnever leave them on their own, but why is this happening and no one seems to be bothered? in 1980s there would be singhs gaurding every quarter of the gurdwara. Juts looking at somebodies family members the wrong way is bad enough. 8) I have started to hear cases where a woman is touched up by random guys and gianis. Singho ask yourself how would a woman feel? what is a person meant to think? In our wise judgements its easy to think thats not an excuse. NOOOO its not but when you put 10 things together that form part of the mess we face you gotto realise each person reacts different from yourself. Remmeber your talkin about people who havent even taken amrit or tasted the rass of sikhi or come close to bani. I once talked to a girl from toronto who told me she never went gurdwara. I asked why? She told when she was 9 a giani took her into a random room and started touching her up. She is now 24 and never goes gurdwara or talks about sikhi yet respects it at arms lentgh. This is a person who wasnt amritdhari and never experienced the rass of sikhi. Another girl whos mum is amritdari went to gurdwara for relatives akhand paat and was looked at by a freshie who then came over brushed past her back on purpose and touched her and smiled. She felt scared and turned back instead of going darbar she walked into langar hall to go with her mum started doing the dishes while her mum was serving on other side. The girl looks into langar hall the freshie was standing there smiling at her. The girl felt upset and ran towards her mum the freshi legged it, the mum was so angry shouting and pulled her kirpaan out. Thats all i can think of for now, but we need changes not in sikhi but how we run our nerve centres the gurdwara or form part of it, team work.

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

............ · 06 Dec 2004

if we have our nerve centre sorted then whats the best place to go? gurdwara or mandir? look back to old days in sikhi and what bought people in. That way we would also attract non sikhs and sikhi may grow if we practice it properly and stop the manmutt going on. Nobody is forcing us to go mandirs or become hindus or muslims, its down to what we face. Look at the persons jeevan who goes mandir and sit down and ask them why? i gaurantee it will come back to the way they view the gurdwara having issues. Ask that person if they ever read bani or japped naam? or even spent time in sangat who would give them selfless love and sacrifice for their betterment?

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

! · 07 Dec 2004

"If someone has everything they need at home, they why should we go beg to our neighbor?" - Bikramjit Singh (surrey-valay) This statement was once used by Bhai Sahib in a lecture to describe visiting all other places of worship. If you research gursikhi and the richness of it, then why go beg at the doors of other religious institutions for wealth? All the wealth is under your nose, just research it. The fact that the gates to gurdwara sahib are always open to people of all ages/races etc. shows how accepting our religion is, this does not mean all other religions feel the same way. I know for a fact that if I went to a different religious institution the main goal of those in that place of worship would be to convert me to their religion.

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

Caprice Sun · 07 Dec 2004

According to Hindu doctrine... you can't convert to hinduism. You've to be born a hindu.

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 07 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Jihra gharoan rajia hoyeh..osnuu bahar dee roti dee bhukh nahin hundee.. All those flimsy excuses..like at the gurdwraa the oldie dont let me do sewa but at the mandir they gave me a koochee to maanj their bhandey..??? AT Harmandir a few oldie families are monopolsiisgn all the sewa...BUT the LADIES are not giving way and saying OK we are going to the Mandir..instead they went on and started a morcha to be allowed to do sewa....a battle here and there but the war is still to be won..and sooner or later they are going to wn it... IF the oldies dont let you do sewa...get afew youngies together and occupy the other sewas... clean the car parks, get greenery and beautify the car parks, surroudings, paint the walls, wash teh toilets..THERE are a thousand and one SEWAS....dont just rush to bhandey..chaur...degh sewas only...do Jorrian dee sewa... you will find very few doing this !!! Where therte is a WILL there is a way....BUt if you are lkooking for excuses...it is easy....just go to the nearest mandir/masjid/church...??? Jarnail Singh

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

A Singh · 07 Dec 2004

Again, we see a clear cut thread showing that Sikhs today simply believe like the Pigs in George Orwell's Animal Farm:- "All animals are equal, but some are more equal than others"

Re: "Sikhs" going to Hindu Mandirs

............ · 07 Dec 2004

maaf karna jarnail singh please forgve this moorakh i didnt mean to write excuses. I wrote what goes on, perhaps i shouldnt next time, maybe i should learn from my elders.