Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Singh · 02 Dec 2004

How enlightened! I dont' like what you have to say and though I can't contest it, I'll just ban you and your book. Time to ban the Akhand Kirtani Jatha too. Don't forget Kavi Santokh Singh's Suraj Parkash and also Giani Gian Singh's Panth Parkash. Disprove the book point by point or accept ragmala isn't bani. Takht Patna Sahib bans book Declares Giani Gurdit Singh ‘tankhaiya’ Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, December 2 In an unprecedented move, the Sikh clergy of Takht Patna Sahib today declared Giani Gurdit Singh, a close associate of Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, Jathedar, Akal Takht, as ‘tankhaiya’ for the book ‘Mundawani’. They also imposed a ban on the book. The development is likely to plunge the Sikh Panth into a crisis once again. This is, perhaps, for the first time that any Takht has directed the Jathedar of Akal Takht to clarify his stand. Earlier, Takht Patna Sahib had asked Giani Gurdit Singh and Jathedar Vedanti to appear at Takht Patna Sahib to clarify on the contents of “Mundawani”. The issue of Giani Gurdit Singh is being taken up at the next meeting of Sikh clerics at Akal Takht. The ‘hukamnama’ (directive) was signed by all five Sikh priests of Takht Patna Sahib, including Jathedar Iqbal Singh. On the other hand, Jathedar Vedanti has summoned a meeting of the Sikh clergy at the Akal Takht to recommend action against Jathedar Iqbal Singh. Jathedar Vedanti had taken the initiative to bury the hatchet with the jathedars of Takht Patna Sahib and Takht Hazoor Sahib and made them sign a common statement that the Akal Takht, being the supreme Takht, would take up panthic issues while the rest of the Takhts would decide on regional issues.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Finally · 03 Dec 2004

What took them so long. I dont see the end here though. More Gurduwaras to speak out and follow which will cause an uproar and hopefully get the Government Controlled SGPC and Joginder Singh Vedanti removed from the Akal Takhat which belongs to the Sikh Panth.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Jasvir kaur · 03 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. What on Earth is "FINALLY" talking about. What SINGH has posted above is "NORTH" and what Finally is saying is "SOUTH". What makes anyone think that Takaht PATNA SAHIB is under "PANTHIC" control ??? must be living in the middle ages... Both the takhats patna and Hazoor sahib are MORE under the GOI than Akal takhat and SGPC ever can be...at least the sgpc is "elected" by the Sikhs....the two takhats are directly controlled by the State Govts and the Jathedars are APPOINTED DIRECTLY without ANY PANTHIC CHOICES WHATSOEVER. ALL this just shows what a TRULY ROTTEN MESS we are in.... next the takaht patna may issue a hukmnama requiring every gurdwara to have parkash of PARALLEL GRANTH beside the GURU GRANTH JI as is at takhat patna.....because tkahat patna jathedar iqbal singh has already claimed in a book written by himself that his takhat is superior to akal tkahat and came first. serious crisis is right..a battle royale is sure to follow...SIKHS LOSE GOI wins. This is GOOD NEWS to the DERAWALLAHS and SANTS...the more the siksh fight the better for them....and if the fight opens up old wounds like raagmala as this hukmnama does....still better. Jasvir Kaur

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Bijla Singh · 03 Dec 2004

"at least the sgpc is "elected" by the Sikhs" really? since when? tohra, jagiro, talwandi, vedanti are all panthic traitors. which sikh jathebandi selected them? it was people of sgpc who raised their hands and turned their back to panth in 84. real gursikhs gave shaheedi. if there was any sikhi left in sgpc there wouldn't be much corruption. "This is GOOD NEWS to the DERAWALLAHS and SANTS" please provide few names so I can understand who you call "Sant." if you meant fake sants then I must say either you are a sant or you are not. fake sant doesn't exist. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Rain drop · 03 Dec 2004

Finally Ji if you are below twenty, your post can be defined as ignorance. If above twenty, please do try to be intelligent. Learn Logic.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

to jasvir kaur · 03 Dec 2004

"serious crisis is right..a battle royale is sure to follow...SIKHS LOSE GOI wins.This is GOOD NEWS to the DERAWALLAHS and SANTS...the more the siksh fight the better for them....and if the fight opens up old wounds like raagmala as this hukmnama does....still better." Interesting that you mentioned this my sister, we have just received word from india that the accused rapist baba mann, pehowa wala is trying to get out of the punjab area whilst the heat is on him. He has booked programs and is planning a large nagar kirtan in Patna sahib. The dates are early January 2005!!! What a sad state of affairs our religion is in. What will stop the wrong people taking control of our faith? Gurfateh, Kulbir Singh Dhillon

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Jasvir kaur · 04 Dec 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. bijla singh ji, the sgpc has elections, hundreds of thousands of SIKH voters, and a general House of the elcted representives... although i totally agree that this is at all NOT SATISFACTORY... BUT on the other hand give a few examples of ANY SAT BABA JI DERA that ELECTS its derawallah leader. ALL of them are SELF APPOINTED GADDHIDAARS/ appointed by the OUTGOING jathedar. One FINE EXAMPLE of a SANT BABAJI who has been EXPOSED is pehowa walah baaba maanna...who is finding the PUNJAB too hot to sit down and so is GOING to PATNA SAHIB to be with his SUPPORTERS. THIS is also a not so subtle "warning" to the Akal takaht sgpc etc in PUNJAB....Be careful, I have powerful supporters at this Takhat !!! so dont mess with me. EXPOSED is right JI, the OTHERS have NOT yet been EXPOSED !!! thats the only difference between them and pehowaa... If you dont beleive me..JUST READ the comments of "chelas" about baba pehowa BEFORE the EXPOSURE..you will find there is NO HOLIER baba ji than him in the entire sikh world..Many in LOndon UK still Beleive all this is a LIE... So stop living in a fools world...a THIEF is not a thief until he gets "CAUGHT"..like pehowaa,and many many others before him... Jasvir Kaur - NO SANTS except GURU JI.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

((((:>>>>> · 04 Dec 2004

This is part of a clear long term plan to get rid of all the panthik singhs. Singhs will fight against singhs. This is what RSS, sants, daodgy akalis all want. Make the Taksal fight the AKJ. Kill them both off. Then the Panth belongs to the RSS and thier snaatanist partners! I hope pro-raagmala groups have sense and see what the scam is! They should not play along blindly!

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

...... · 05 Dec 2004

Yeah it must be some big conspiracy to break up the sikh religion. Yeah right. Anyone that tried to finish the sikh religion have themselves been finished.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

GUrpreet Singh · 05 Dec 2004

vendanti and Gurdit Singh should just goto Patna sahib and clear this up with the pathedar there. The real problem here is a power sturuggle by appointed jathedars on 2 takhats

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 05 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Thats what i meant by being divided in unity and the rss/bjp/hindutva/sanatanists/niddars /nungs/etc etc being UNITED in divisions. The AKJ/Taksal/others are all SIKH Jathbandis akin to Rivers - small and large flowing into the VAST OCEAN of Sikhi-Gurmatt. The trouble begins when some leaders take political stands and then use that to justify their religious stands...Rivers will always be rivers and any river however large it may become will always be smaller than the ocean We are so quick to pointout each other. When baba Giani gurbachan Singh Ji walked out of the Akal takaht instituted Ragmaala Comittee, he was asked whether he would be pursuing his Anti-Raagmaala agenda..He gave a written undertaking that he would abide by the Akal takaht directive and as long as he was alive he didnt raise this issue...neither did Sant giani jarnail Singh ji Khalsa. The whole Maryada was upset when Bhai jasbir singh Rode was Jathedar at Akal Takaht for a short time....and he on HIS OWN started enforcing the Taksal maryada...which is wrong s the panth ahs not been consulted. In the present set up i dont think there can be a Panthic Consultation on the lines of the one that began in 1910 through the Chief Khalsa Diwan and ended in the SGPC general House in dec 1935 when the present SRM was formulated and enforced. Inspite of teh SRM having been apssed by the sgpoc general house through a Gurmatta..some vested interests still continue to call this SRM a Kharrra/draft etc..while completley "forgetting" that "their maryada" is NOT even a Khharra/draft/anything whatsoever except the maryada of their own small jatha...with not a single singh sabha/gurdwara/institution/ etc consulted or asked to contribute. I hope saner minds will prevail. jarnail singh

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Bijla Singh · 06 Dec 2004

"When baba Giani gurbachan Singh Ji walked out of the Akal takaht instituted Ragmaala Comittee, he was asked whether he would be pursuing his Anti-Raagmaala agenda.." please provide proofs. I have read about this meeting in madan singh's book and he has distorted the facts. companions of Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji say something different. I think one meeting took place in 1945 but it was not any major meeting, only some anti-raag maala people (bhasaurs) got together and passed resolutions. not even Bhai Randhir Singh Ji was present there. I do not doubt Baba Ji abiding by Akal Takhat and He never wanted to start any trouble but that does not mean that he admitted he was wrong. and Gursikhs don't have any "agenda". they just do parchaar. avoid starting controversy just provide some sources. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 06 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. What type of proofs ? Isnt it proof enough that the Raagmala was NOT read at Akal Takhat UNTIL Rode became jathedar for a few months. Even When Jarnail Singh Bhinderawalah was PHYSICALLY in "control" of the entire Complex this same maryada CONTINUED as before. To me that is proof enough that Both baba ji gurbachan Singh and Baba ji jarnail singh totally RESPECTED the decision of the Guru Khalsa panth OVER their own personal jatha..and didnt try to ride rough shod over...except a shallow person like Rode ( who didnt last long despite being accorded the BIGGEST WELCOME CEREMONY at his Taajposhi as jathedar !!). Can I put the ball back in your court and ask you for the "proofs" of the "few bhasauris" in the meeting in 1945 ? WHICH meeting was a MAJOR meeting ?? what is your definition of a Major and Minor meeting ? Isnt it a fact that the Kharrra is not a kharra but passed at sgpc General house in 1945 vide GURMATTA as on all other decisions..so how does a gurmatta become a kharra ??..but people still continue to say kharra/draft and want proofs ?? BTW this has been discussed umpteen times and people are bored to death. You are right that Gursikhs dont want trouble...but look at what Gursikhs and Jathedars are doing now ?? we gave them an "inch" and now they want a MILE !! I hear jathedar patna is going to declare jathedar Akal takhat a Tankhiyah in a day or two !! jarnail singh.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

avidya · 06 Dec 2004

Gurfateh Sorry Jarnail Singh Arshi, from what I know the Taksal are joined with Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib on issues of Nanakshahi calendar and also Gyani Gurditt Singh's book. Therefore I ask you to ammend your statement to read 'AKJ' alone. Now, please notice the fact that I've always answered your questions sincerely. Please return the favour and answer my simple question. Do you believe, as you have implied, that Taksal are knowingly or unknowingly helping the RSS and BJP? If so what is your proof? Thank you

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

A Singh · 06 Dec 2004

Bijla Singh, It is not suprising to find that Sardar Madan Singh has distorted the facts, he even associates Teja Singh Bhasauria with others he considers to be great scholars and derides other gems such as Kesar Singh Chibber as Sikh only in name! I'm not suggesting that I am wholly supportive of Kesar Singh Chibber's works, however how is he termed "only Sikh in name" and not a single bad word uttered against the Panthic Dhust "Teja Singh Bhasauria", who is far more of a threat than most of the other seemingly trivial issues discussed elsewhere -a man who ripped apart the Saroop of Maharaj.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Who cares · 06 Dec 2004

Who cares wat Jarnail Singh Arshi thinks. Just cause some1 refutes his arguments doesnt mean they are wrong. Jarnail Singh doesnt know everything as his hankaar on this board shows. Hes just a regular poster on this board as anyone else. Just because he posts more and trys to use his muscle like he knows everything doesnt mean squat to me. One thing for sure i'll let u know Jarnail Singh is that Rag Mala whether being read or not read is NOT being refuted by the Jathedar of Patna Sahib. If it were the issue Rag Mala then we would have heard the Jathedar of Patna Sahib speak out along time ago against people who dont read Rag Mala. Thats not the case. Its the book Mundavni which is so suspect in the eyes of many outside of the Akhand Kirtan Jatha. The book written by Giani Gurdit Singh is being questioned not Rag Mala itself. The book is suspect and so is this so called Giani. Get your Facts Straight.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Bijla Singh · 06 Dec 2004

my question was about the actual meeting that took place which according to some people "Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji left out of disgust because He couldn't answer the questions." All Nihung Jathebandis read Raag Maala so Raag Maala was being read at Akal Takhat Sahib until British took over in 1849 simply because Akal Takhat Sahib was under Nihungs' control. just because Raag Maala was not being read for some period of time doesn't make it right. when Keski was made optional Bhai Randhir Singh Ji didn't start any trouble at Akal Takhat Sahib but doesn't mean he admitted he was wrong or the decision at akal takhat was right. it was the puppets of british that had control over akal takhat sahib. they changed everything. troubles bhasaurs started are known to the panth. i am not talking about whether raag maala is bani or not I have my mind made up but I am simply talking about the so called "meetings" anti-raag maala people talk about and then declare the decisions to be "Guru Khalsa Panth's" decisions. tell me what meeting did Baba Gurbachan SIngh Ji go to, what year and who else was present there? this is the are I want to explore to find some facts. again, I am not discussing raag maala because I have no doubts. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

mr. singh · 06 Dec 2004

Bijla singh, what you talking about? you guys and your british theories. You can't prove anythihng, so just blame the british. were you there when raag mala was read before 1849? no, you just made that up and passed it off as fact. good job and when you can't blame the british, blame bhausaur. another good tactic. although you probably can't list the actual points that bhasuar got in trouble for.. but it's all good though, just use his name to blame everything on. by the way, there was no meeting in the 1940's by any bhasaur people. they were out of hte path by then.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

yeah right · 06 Dec 2004

nihang control over akhal takth sahib. the good old days when they cut up goats and worshipped hindu gods at the akhal takht and didn't let women in there either. Because they weren't good enough and should only get kirpan amrit. Those good old days, right? If the patnaa saahib jathedar could control the panth, we'd be back in those good old days. the days of hindu sikhs. YEahhhh.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

g singh · 06 Dec 2004

You're way wrong A Singh. Madan Singh had his facts right and provided all the references too. You guys just can't face the facts so you throw in other stuff. Like Teja Singh. Instead of letting your emotions run wild, give your reasoning skills a chance for once. Please. Your bro, g singh

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Why? · 06 Dec 2004

Patna Saahib Jethedar has his strings pulled by other people. The issue here is whether Patna Sahib Jathedar has power to do this. He doesn't. THis pwoer is with AKal Takht. He's trying to get some pro ragmala grops with him on this issue. THis is dangerous. In order to punish someone over writing against ragmala, these groups will undermine panthic traditions and the pwoer of Akal Takht. The panth will be damaged even more. THey should think carefully before supporting this guy. THe other issue is free debate. Can you just ban something (an idea or whatever) just because you don't agree with it? Should be debated and argued, as this issue has for so long, or just ban it?

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Canadian Singh · 06 Dec 2004

The problem is that they can't refute G. Gurdit Singh's points. He's completely dismantled everything they say, so rather than fighting him intellectually, which these people can't do, they just try banning him. He's completely proven his points. They have no response. So, ban the book and prevent people from seeing the truth. And at the same time, let some RSS controlled Jathedar take down the power of Akaal Takt. That's what it's all about. They just can't face the fact that Raag Maalaa isn't GuruBanee. The Mudaavanee book proved this. If they had any real responses to this book, they would have responded in kind, not by trying to ban the book. These people are following the path of the Tali-BAN. Just ban what you don't like.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Admin · 06 Dec 2004

Please stay on topic. Any name calling will not be tolerated. Also, if this thread descends into a pro/anti ragmalla debate, or into a jathebandic fight, the thread will be closed.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

peace · 07 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh this is to "yeah right" not all Nihangs chop up goats and worship hindu gods and not allow women to do seva. LISTEN: Sant Baba Nihaal Singh Ji Khalsa....of Harian Vellan Wale Nihangs...The Jathedar of the Tarna Dal...they were the last GurSikh who got a BIBI and allowed her to do Kirtan Seva in Darbar Sahib complex. They sat near the Bibi and said NOBODY can stop her. This is a proven fact. Sant Baba Nihaal Singh Ji Khalsa also does not EAT MEAT. He can't go on the record and start doing parchar of that cause soo its controversial to some and Baba Ji does not want to start up tension. But BABA JI does not eat meat and does not go by that philisohy. I TALKED TO THEM PERSONALLY, I ASKED THEM. Baba Ji's views are not like some of the messed up nangs...thats why Baba Ji is even critisized on these Nang sites....those shastervidya sites or something like that....Baba Ji is critisized for their views!! My point being is they are a REAL NIHANG. What Nihang Singhs represent. So plz do not think all Nihangs are like that. Real Nihangs like AKAALI BABA PHOOLA SINGH JI KHALSA...they controlled SRI AKAL TAKHAT SAHIB. and when Bijla Singh said that Raag Mala was being read before the british...thats true....its not MADE UP. The Taksal Jathedars even mentioned that it. They wouldn't make that up. Without arguing if its Bani or not, they said IT WAS read at Sri Akal Takhat Sahib before. So Bijla Singh did not make that up, just to clarify things.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Bijla Singh · 07 Dec 2004

my focus was not on the authority of raag maala. mr.singh, your post clearly shows your ignorance about this matter. I did/do not want to get into this raag maala gurbani debate. but do some research on bhasaurs. btw, he and his wife were declared tankhaiya by akal takhat sahib and bhai randhir singh ji did not want to see his until he did pesh. before 1849 Nihungs who controlled Akal Takhat were like Akali Phoola Singh Ji. just because I wasn't there doesn't mean it is not a fact. I wasn't there when amrit sanchaar of 1699 took place but it is still a fact. I can say people like you can't prove anything and just made up some stuff and pass it off as a fact. "yeah right", you actually think all this disrespect was taking place during Sikh raj? really shows your knowledge. I specifically asked jarnail singh not anyone else. my question is specifically about the meeting. when did it take place, what year and who was present there? what jathebandis? provide some names. madan singh distroted the facts because laal singh went to the jatha to see if baba gurbachan singh ji agreed with sgpc rehat maryada and he didn't so laal singh returned after a week. baba ji's students are still alive today and they were present there when laal singh went to meet baba ji. if baba ji really walked out of the meeting then who else was with him? his students were always with him. so name some students. there is always the story of other side and I want to know it for my own knowledge. it looks like you kids don't have something better to do than wasting time in arguing about raag maala. any detailed information about the meeting (without any debate) will be appreciated. until then good luck on your fights. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

mr. singh · 07 Dec 2004

bijla singh, what about bhasaur? Did I defend them? What's your point? What do they have to do with the discussion? what does them having to be excommunicated have to do with this? Nothing. You can't face the actual facts, so you bring in bhasuar. And yeah, I know who was Jathedar pre1849. Thanks for the history lesson. If you were wearing your glasses, youd notice that i said my comment was about reading raagmalaa back then. It wasn't read. I don't think Kavi Santokh Singh would have gone against the Akal Takht and written against rag mala if it was being read at akal takht back then. peace, ... same thing. See above. Your only argument is so and so singh said so. If that was good enough for everyone, we wouldn't even be having this discussion on rag mala, would we? Rag Mala wasn't read back then, you guys can make up all the history you want. Stop your ignorant attacks and remarks and present some real points. about your meetings. Baba Gurbachan singh Jee was sent a letter by the jatehdar back then about the decision not to read ragmala at the takht and asked them to respect this decision. Baba Gurbachan SIngh Jee didn't change his stance, but he never did parchar against the akal takht decision. It was never that big an issue for them that they'd split the panth, like the people of today.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Admin · 07 Dec 2004

This thread is turning into a raagmaalaa fight. We've had enough of those (do a search if you're really interested). This thread is now closed, unless someone has points relevant to the orignal topic. Admin

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

A Singh · 07 Dec 2004

Dear Admin, Please allow this thread through to clarify my position and also contribute constructively to the discussion:- Dear G Singh Bhaji, Thanks for your message, please note I am not challenging Madan Singh's view on raagmala nor am I discussing Raagmala, as the Admin have indicated this has been done plenty of times. My point on Madan Singh's book is simple, he may have presented 'references' however he clearly refers to historical and puratan Singhs such as Kesar Singh Chibber as "sikh only in name" whilst lists Teja Singh Bhasauria amongst others he considers to be credible scholars, without an ounce of mention agianst him. This is simply bias -and blantantly because Kesar Singh is a Brahmin. For the record, I do not, as some people of late have been keen to suggest, have any "agenda" let alone a 'sanatanist' or even a 'nihang'. The issue on this thread is simple, Patna Sahib has taken a stance on this book Mundavani which appears out of line when compared to their 'jurisdictional' role as controlling local affairs only, however clearly if they have chosen to act outside of their jurisdiction and effective undermine the authority of the SGPC in the Akal Thakt, there must be some reason for that. From the posters so far, we see either (a) it's because Patna Sahib are pro-Ragmala/anti-AKJ or (b) Patna Sahib are under the demonic controls of the GOI and are pushing their agenda to discredit panthic bodies like the AKJ through banning this book. I would like for the Admin to present the following on line for all to think about and perhaps start a new thread to discuss if necessary. -How many of us have read the book Mundavani? -Surely, as one poster suggested, if the motivation was solely raagmala related, Patna Sahib could have taken such action a long time ago. -Given that we have Patna Sahib stepping outside of its defined jurisdiction, what does this mean for the authority of the Akal Thakt? -It is fine for us in the West to try and side with the Akal Thakt as a bid to hold panthic unity, however when others in India openly defy this, surely we must understand that this is not a one way street. Given the above, I don't see the need to boil this down to the usual ramblings of Raagmala, Nihangs, AKJ, GOI etc. Let's actually step aside from all of this (for goodness sake, Sikhi is so much more vast and moreover, these arguments are beginning to sound like a broken record). I request we start a thread on Mundavani (keep this existing one closed by all means) and sensibly do vichaar on this book to understand what it says and why it has caused this occurance. Humbly, A Singh. g singh wrote: You're way wrong A Singh. Madan Singh had his facts right and provided all the references too. You guys just can't face the facts so you throw in other stuff. Like Teja Singh. Instead of letting your emotions run wild, give your reasoning skills a chance for once. Please. Your bro, g singh

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

SINGH · 07 Dec 2004

People need to look at the history of Sri Patna Saahib. The Jathidars of this holy takht weren't involved in panthic affairs over the last 50 years. Any meetings of Jathidars involved the 3 Punjab Takhts and usually 2 head granthis (Darbar Saahib or Sri Akhal Takht Saahib). It's only over the last couple of years that Patna Saahib Jathidar has taken on this new role. If anybody wants to understand why he made this decision on this book, just examine his statements and decisions over the last couple of years. He is clearly trying to assert his role as at least an equal to that of the Akal Takht Jathidar. At the same time, he is emerging as a champion of causes dear to certain segments of the sikh society, mainly the Sant Samaaj and all related groups. The problem with the latter issue is that many view his decisions as biased. A Jathidar should be clearly unbiased and just as importantly, he should have the appearance of being unbiased. It is crucial to appear unbiased if one is to pass judgements on devisive issues. Otherwise, the person and the institution loses credibility. This is what is happening with Patna Saahib. It appears to many people (not all of course) that this Jathidar simply issues hukamnamas according to his own beliefs, with a complete and total bias. Most people also can't understand why this Jathidar is now suddenly issuing so many statements and edicts, and especially in direct violation of what is seen as the traditional role of this institution. It's also difficult to understand why he always seems to be attacking the institution of Akal Takht Jathidar and trying to undermine its credibility. This is where the accusations of RSS and GOI influence start. Even is these accusations turn out to be baseless, it is still the responsibility of the Jathidar to act in a way to clear up doubts. He needs to make his decision making process much more transparent and to explain why he is now taking the role he is taking. Otherwise, untold amounts of damage will be inflicted simply due to confusion and suspicion in the minds of the sikh masses. Already over the last few years we have seen mass confusion about edicts from the Takhts. This needs to be cleared up. Eventually, the roles of Jathidars will have to be re-examined. There will be no other solution. Too much damage has been done to these institutions and they have lost a lot of credibility in the minds of many people. Also at issue in the case of Patna Sahib is whether the decisions of this Jathidar take into account the many different perspectives within the panth. This is always a question when any edict is passed. With the Akal Takht, they will try to give some appearance of due representation and due process. Typically, you have 5 singh saahibans from different Takhts or Gurdvaras and usually with some variety in sikhi school of thought. They also have various groups which they consult with, such as the Dharam Parchaar Committee. Additionally, there is some sense of accountability as well. We may not agree as to whom they should be accountable to, but there is some sense that they are accountable. Some people with insst that the Jathidar does not have to be accountable and his edicts are 'god-sent'. Basically, this is giving them the same authority as the pope within Catholocism. In Sikhi, many would disagree with this and would be of the viewpoint that there has to be accountability to the panth. If the decision is made within an accepted framework of Gurmat and is not in violation of any Gurmat principles, then such a decision or edict (by 5 Khalsas) will be treated as 'holy.' However, the process needs to be transparent and if there are any deviations from Gurmat in the decision making process, then accountability is a must. With Patna Saahib, you don't really have any of this. At least, that is the appearance and in making judgements, appearance is as important as reality. All five singhs are from the same Takht and this gives the appearance that they all hold similar values perspectives. This would limit the amount of discussion and vichaar done before making a decision. They also don't have groups with the resources or diversity of the Dharam Parchaar Comittee to act as advisory panels. As far as accountability goes, up until now, there appears to have been none. The Jathidar there seems to act with complete impunity. What makes it even worse is that many sikhs view this Takht as being under 'hindu control.' Many people claim that the management of the Takht answers to a state appointed panel. Lastly, the Jathidar of Patna Saahib appears to have a grudge with the Jathidar of Akal Takht Saahib and many of his decisions seem to be made as part of this power struggle. The fact that the Jathidar of Akal Takht Saahib is involved in this latest ban and has been called forth by the Jathidar of Patna Saahib only reinforces the view that this latest edict is simply part of this power struggle and has no real basis. That it involves raagmaalaa, a controversial issue that is dear to those that the jathidar has been allying himself with recently, simply adds to the perception that the Jathidar is acting with bias and to settle personal scores. If the situation of Jathidars and edicts isn't resolved, there will only be more pain and infighting within the panth.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

waheguru · 08 Dec 2004

does anyone know where I can get the book "MEra Pind" by this guy I live in the U.K.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 08 Dec 2004

he has a website which has all his books plus a lot of related information. Please visit http://www.gianigurditsingh.com. Jarnail singh

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Search For Tat · 08 Dec 2004

Mera pind is written By Giani Gurdit singh, not sure if it is the same one. You can get it from Sikh Missionary in Southall. As far as the rest, everyone should think, who is benefitting from this. Singhs fighting singhs, jathedars fighting jathedars, only benefit the RSS which already controls all sikh colleges, and is slowly gaining control of the panth.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

avidya · 08 Dec 2004

Gurfateh Jarnail Singh ji, please answer my simple question on this issue and share your gyaan. Have you got proof of what you say, or is it just your hearsay? I'm sincerely interested to know how you got to making such a statement. Thank you

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

EkAurSikh · 08 Dec 2004

waheguru JI! The URL below gives more details about "Mera Pind". You can browse pages and read other people's comments and also it tells you where/how to buy it. Sat Sri Akal http://www.gianigurditsingh.com/books.htm#2

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

A Singh · 08 Dec 2004

Bhai Sahib Jarnail Singh Jee "Gyani", Please could you answer Avidya's point concerning the Taksal as this is crucial, for similar hints and statements have been made before about Baba Thakur Singh Jee and the RSS. Thanks, A Singh.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 09 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Dear Veer Avidya ji and A Singh Jio, The proof is in the pudding. I am neither a taksali nor an AKJ ( or PKD). I am a simple Gursikh and i follow all matters concerning the Sikhs closely. Takaht Patna would never take the actions it is taking now without a "unseen hand"...it has been awfully quiet these 50 years because it suited those in power...and now it is time to twist the lion's tail. In its entire Sikh history the Takhats patna and Hazoor sahib have NEVER once issued any hukmnamas..lately there is a divergence on the Dasam granth/Raagmala issues between the Akal takaht and Patna Sahib. The DG issue was pushed under the carpet by diplomacy but this mundawnai issue seems to be ignited...and is going out of control..and the ONLY party that will be BURNT is the KHALSA PANTH. Divide and Rule is the "rule" and those who fall for this line are putting the Panth in danger...whoever they are...I am not particularly concerned. I am aware of "similar hints" and "statements" you mention....but you flatter me too much..my "opinions" are strictly MY OWN. I have no power to make "statements"...but i as like many others have the Guru Given bibek budhi to make "calculated" and "informed" decisons...some may be wrong some may be right..only Guru Ji really knows. jarnail singh

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

avidya · 09 Dec 2004

Gurfateh So your 'informed' opinions are based on nothing more than your own feelings without any citeable evidence, then you should be careful how you present them for you are misleading people who may know none better. Please be mature enough to state 'this is my opinion without any clear evidence' next time before embarking on making controversial or conspiritorial comments. thank you

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

jagmeet singh · 09 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh. What i woul i say is only that jathedar of patna sahib doesn 't have any right to summon jathedar of Akal Takht Sahib. Because all the pathic issues are resolved at Akal Takht Sahib. What jathedar sahib has done is totally wrong. Now this is going on to be a war of words between two takhts. Also he said about banning of AKJ. That shows his feelings about religious organisations. The AKJ/TAKSAL are flowers that serve sikh panth today. No body canb say such type of words for them. Gur fateh.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

................. · 09 Dec 2004

most readers of this forum would say exactly the same about you avidya.

Re: Mundavani Book Banned by Jatherdar Patna Sahib

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 10 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh. so avidya ji, as far as i am aware only the likes of Prof Ganda Singh, baba Karam Singh Historian, Bhai Sahib bhai Veer Singh, Prof Jodh Singh, Bhai Sahib bahi randheer Singh, Prof sahib Singh, Prof Harbans Singh, etc etc have the time to do serious RESEARCH, look for old manuscripts, provide "evidence" ( which is still not enough for many "vidyaks" like myself who have their own set of beleifs from their own babas/sants/sanatan nihungs etc etc and dont care two hoots about such professors)...MOST of the posters on this FORUM are just like me. We read something,hear something and we give our own "opinions" or opinions derived from some other source/book ec we may have read.... THAT is a basic understood by everyone type of thing.... I dont know what your problem is ?? Surely you are not claiming that ALL your writing is solid evidence based FACTS as true as GURBANI...that is the impression i get from your "posts" as they twist and turn all over the place...and i have never seen a statement in your posts that says what you insist I must write in mine... Any way I think every poster on this forum has his own mind and he / she can make it up on his/her own volition...no one is thsat "naive" as you make them out to be. Jarnail Singh