Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

About Gangu Brahmin

About Gangu Brahmin

Baljit Singh · 02 Dec 2004

Gangu is said to be the "rasoyia" of the tenth Guru. I always wonder how come that Guru was taking the food prepared by a hindu servant. Please throw some light about it under the pretext of Bibek.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Balpreet Singh · 02 Dec 2004

Let's look at this fact: despite telling all Sikhs to eat in the Langar and not care about caste, do you think Guru Gobind Singh Sahib would have a personal Brahmin cook? It doesn't even make logical sense. Guru Sahib did not have a separate cook for himself. There used to be Guru ka Langar that everyone including Guru Sahib ate. No historical text gives an account of Guru Sahib having a separate cook for himself. Then who or what was he? I've heard a number of explanations but the one that makes the most sense is that Gangu was a cook, but not for the Sikhs. When the Kashmiri Brahmins came to meet Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib, Gangu was a cook for them since they would not eat in the langar.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 03 Dec 2004

why would a Brahmin" need to cook anyway ? Didnt they all get to eat free ?? IMHO brahmins were toatl free loaders living off the offerings of the jajmaans.." I pray for you...you give me food" was their occupation...same as today. jarnail singh

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Balpreet Singh · 03 Dec 2004

strict Brahmins won't eat food cooked by "low castes", and langar would not be acceptable to them Take the case of the Shankracharya that was arrested in India recently. He is a strict Brahmin and in an article about his arrest they say, "In the jail, his food is cooked by a Brahmin constable. He is allowed to do puja. He is provided with all the puja samgri. He is treated with reverence in custody too. All the wild allegations about his mistreatment in the jail are untrue." http://www.rediff.com/news/2004/dec/01inter.htm So, the Brahmins from Kashmir did indeed need a cook, and it's most likely Gangu was their man.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Jasvir kaur · 03 Dec 2004

surprised ?? They wouldnt EAT Guru Ji's Langgar...BUT thye were quite happy to Get GURU ji's HEAD as sacrifice to free them from Aunga's Frenzy.. Whats so surpprising about the shankarcharya also ?? Bhai Sahib Bhai Rabdheer Singh Ji was TORTURED horribly for just this RIGHT !!! BUT HE won the battle in the end. Jasvir Kaur

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 04 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. The arrested Shankarachrya is a Head of the Hindu religion in Hindu India..so nothing great about his privileges in prison..and he is quite happy to cook his own food but has he protested about other "brahmins" in the prisons?? are they gettign the same privileges ? Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh Ji was a "political" prisoner ( actually prisoner of conscience) who as an ordinary prisoner fought tooth and nail for these REHAT Principles for himself and other gurmukhs. Sometimes the Authorities would give the "privileges" to Bhai Ji...but deny them to other gurmukhs...BHAI SAHIB JI would continue the struggle until ALL gurmukhs got them. Jarnail singh

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 04 Dec 2004

I really really really doubt that Gangu would be a cook for Brahmins Our Guru Sahib, who started wearing a kalgee when the Moghuls said you can't Our Guru Sahib, who gathered an army when the Moghuls said you can't Our Guru Sahib, who wore weapons when the Moghuls said you can't Our Guru Sahib, who gave amrit to everybody when the caste system prevailed Our Guru Sahib, who broke the barrier for women enslaved under the gender-biased society Our Guru Sahib, who went against EVERY SINGLE social stereotype and oppression That Guru Sahib would NEVER hire a seperate cook for Langar and insult Mata Khivi Jee.. never.. Langar is the food that angels and fairies dream of the chance to have Langar is the food of the soul.. Guru Sahib would not fall into "Bipran kee reet" and try to CATER to Brahmins Gangu must have been somebody else - some other position. But definately not a cook.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

khalsaa · 04 Dec 2004

Gangu was a cook in the Guru's langar. He was one that even remained by the Guru's side when the 40 mukteys wrote the badhava and left. For 12 full years I believe. They say that when you fall it is over little things. He went through so much difficult times and the downfall came over a bit of material wealth.....

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

............ · 05 Dec 2004

the most interesting thing i have noted is langar is part of sikhi from the earlier guru sahibs so why would Guru ji have a brahmin cook? Guru ji drank amrit from the same bhatta as the panj pyarey and ordered in rehetnamey to eat with fellow sikhs. At a time when brahmin influence was being fought by Guru ji himself why would he eat from a non sikh especially since the vibes of the person go through the food? Guru ji yet set examples in many things himself for us to follow. The story of having a brahmin cook kind of brings brahmins back into our folds, had he been a sikh then i could believe it but not as a brahmin.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

respectfully · 06 Dec 2004

Dear Balpreet Singh - This is an interesting topic and I don't have much to add but the below explanation does not seem to mesh with past Sikh practice. Even Kings had to eat langar with the common people before meeting Guru ji - I don't see why Guru ji would make an exception for the Kashmiri Brahmins in this regard. In addition to being hypocritical, it would undermine the concept of langar. I think, perhaps, a far simpler explanation may be that Gangu was a cook for Guru ji's household (at least before 1699). True, the institute of langar was always present but everyone did not eat langar, all the time - people went home, mothers would cook food for their children etc. Guru ji's household may have employed any number of paid servants. Gangu may have been one of these servants - a household cook who just happened to be a brahmin. Also, while he became a traitor in the end, he may have been a shardalu Sikh beforehand, doing his service to Guru ji and His family with love. Remember, there were 40 tyar par tyar Singhs who also faltered at a critical moment even if they did redeem themselves afterwards. Of course, this is just another possible explanation being offered on my part - no real facts or research backing this up. Balpreet Singh wrote: > > I've heard a number of explanations but the one that makes the > most sense is that Gangu was a cook, but not for the Sikhs. > When the Kashmiri Brahmins came to meet Guru Tegh Bahadur > Sahib, Gangu was a cook for them since they would not eat in > the langar.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Taksali Singh · 13 Dec 2004

<<<<< Author: Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani Date: 12-02-04 16:30 why would a Brahmin" need to cook anyway ? Didnt they all get to eat free ?? IMHO brahmins were toatl free loaders living off the offerings of the jajmaans.." I pray for you...you give me food" was their occupation...same as today. jarnail singh>>>> Gyani Ji, May I know your qualification? Also, are you from those peasant families the ones are dying in India due to agricultural debts and thought of trying another profession and becoming pathi and ragi was easy way out? Now I tell you why I wrote such a blunt message against you because you have insulted Gursikhs like Kirpa Singh Dutt who became Khalsa and fought for Guru Gobind Singh Ji. If you ever get a chance then visit Jammu and Kashmir and see Sikhism values adopted by Gursikhs there and mostly come from Brahmin background. You should do some "Naam Abhiyas" and it will give you some piece of mind. Kashmiri Pundits were Gursikhs as stated by Professor Harbans Singh in his encyclopedia where he quotes that Guru Jee told them to go and tell Aurangzeb that " if they can convert their Gurus faith then all kashmiri pundits will embrace Islam"... Balpreet Singh They were Sikhs not Hindu Pundits and Kirpa Singh Dutt became khalsa and so do his son and they faught in Guru Gobind Singh's army so it proves that they were not strict brahmin the way you have written in your post but " Sharda-waan" of Gurus.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

khalistani · 14 Dec 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! i doubt that gangu wud cook for only brahmins that sort of throws offf the purpose of langar, for caste guru je wudnt make special excpectations bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Jasvir Kaur · 14 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Taksali Singh Ji, ( You are obviously a BRAHMIN who hasnt left his brahminism behind) "blunt" messages like blunt weapons...DONT CUT. You are yourself a VICTIM of your own blunt weapon.... you fail to see when a person EMBRACES AMRIT....he leaves his Jaat-Paat in the DUSTBIN OUTSIDE the Amrit Sanchaar Room. HOW CAN SARDAR KIRPA SINGH "DUTT" be a BRAHMIN and a SINGH of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI at the SAME TIME ?? Your TAKSAL taught you that ?? i am surprised ?? And did GURU GOBIND SINGH JI give this man a SPECIAL PERMISSION to keep his DUTT Caste name after his SINGH name..or is that another TAKSAL "special pass" to "brahmins" only. YOU have grossly INSULTED Guru Ji by saying Kirpa singh "DUTT" fought for GURU JI. NO such thing.... GURU JI wouldnt stand for such a gross violation of His Just announced AMRIT...can you imagine a man proudly announcing he is a "DUTT" standing just beside Bhai Daya Singh Ji/Bhai himmat Singh Ji..or even beside Bhai Ranghreta Guru ka Beta...and GURU JI not saying anything. IMPOSSIBLE. THAT is the REAL INSULT to the memory of Kirpa singh..and it is by a TAKSALI SINGH !!! and i cannot get more blunt. and also a "kashmiir pandit" CANNOT be a GURSIKH at the same time. A sword scabbard ( in case you dont understand this is the container in which a sword is kept) can only have ONE sword. so at any one materal time period.. a person can be a kashmiri pandit or he can take amrit and become a Gursikh (taksali also). Many many "Brahmins" like a Kesar singh "CHIBBAR" were brahmins in disguise to sabotage Sikhi...and they proved it in their writings which are ehavily brahminised. These are the types who tried to hide two swords in the same scabbard !!!! Anyway this thread is about Ganggu brahmin... are your "taksali sources" also saying he was not a "brahmin" cook but a GURSIKH ?? Jasvir Kaur

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

singh1 · 14 Dec 2004

gangu brahmin wasn't a cook... for brahmins or sikhs. he was there for the children... he may have given them some education (sanskrit and stuff)... he was never a cook.. that's just a common misconception. Guru Jee didn't keep special cooks. Where ever they stayed, there was langar available whenever it was needed. 24/7

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

A Singh · 14 Dec 2004

Jasvir Kaur, I find you to be the one who is insulting. Check your facts more clearly please, before insulting everyone who doesn't conform to your reformist mind set. You take issue with Kirpa Singh retaining his Dutt surname, yet ignore that even Guru Sahib did this in his own writing wherein he refers to himself as Gobind SINGH, Sodhi Rai. More importantly you insult Kesar Singh Chibber on account of his Brahmin background, this is exactly what Madan Singh does in his writings on Raagmala, yet freely refers to Teja Singh Bhasauria amongst his list of commendable scholars! I do not deny that the likes of Kesar Singh Chibber and Bhai Chaupa Singh have allowed certain family matters come to the front in their works, BUT and a big BUT is HOW if this DIFFERENT to the centuries of JAT biased works that have come in the cannals of Sikh history??? Would you like some examples, have a look at the heavily Jat-biased writings of Giani Gian Singh and his ill and grosteque comments on any non-Jat, particularly Brahmins, Ramgharias and Rangretas. This trend has been evident since his time and throughout Sikh history endorsed by the SGPC, IOSS and others. I'm not going to spell out all this information here, just go and read through the Sakhia and literature you have available and look between the lines to see the truth -be they Tat Khalsa or Sanatan Singh Sabhias, ALL have been Jat influenced, yet we continue to see celebrated individuals like Kesar Singh Chibber, the prohits of the Guru's House being insulted by today's reformists.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Kabadi · 14 Dec 2004

<<>> HOW DO U KNOW THAT?

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Jasvir Kaur · 15 Dec 2004

how does he know that ?? because he was there...( playing kabaddi perhaps).. In one stroke he "kills" the entire "sikh history tradition" whereby ganggu is called "cook" Rasoiya... Anyway has anybody ever referred to a SANSKRIT TEACHER as "ganggu "..each and every Sanskrti teacher or Learned Brahmin is called respectfully PANDIT....Pandit Hardyaal during Guru nanak ji's time....and Kashmiri PANDITS..during Guru Teg bahadur Ji's time.... BUT this guy is just plain old "Ganggu rasoiyah"...Sanskrit Teacher ?? callase gannggu rasoiyah ?? surely not. Which respectable sanskrit educated brahmin pandit would stand for that ?>?? stands to reason. common sense. Would a respected "Giani Ji" stand for being referred to as "thakru rasoiyah" ??...so why call a respected sankrti teacher that ?>? NO WAY. Jasvir Kaur.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

sikh · 15 Dec 2004

jasvir kaur you yourself use your caste name in your email, kindly self inrospect. great gyanis here such as jarnail singh use their caste names freely. Guru Granth Sahib Ji contains clan names as do Guru Gobind Singh Jis writings.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Taksali Singh · 16 Dec 2004

Bibi Jasvir Kaur, You do not need to make it Taksal vs. other Sikhs. You can insult me but leave great institutions like Taksal away from this discussion. Let me ask you a simple question. Have you left Jattism? Is Brahmanism is bad or Jattism in 21st century? Now let's come back to original discussion. Why it hurts you if Pundit Kirpa Singh Dutt has been mentioned as Dutt? If caste mentioning was this bad then why accounts of Panj Piyare were recorded by great gursikhs with clan/surnames? Read Bhai Kahan Singh Nabha's Mahan Kosh and it has most of the Gursikhs caste background with their village info and Bhai Kahan Singh Nabha was Jatt of Dhillon clan. Guru Nanak gave his updesh to all varnas of Hinduism with same eye. You can read Gurbani to read about that salok, which exist in Asa Dee war. Now do not get angry just because Taksali Singh wrote his name as Dutt but read Professor Harbans Singh's encyclopedia in which he clearly writes him as Pandit Kirpa Singh Dutt, so you might want to go to Akal Takhat Sahib and report Professor Harbans Singh because my source was professor Harbans Singh. And why I call Pandit Kirpa Singh Dutt a gursikh because he earned it. Guru Sahib called Kashmiri Pandits as his own Sikhs, so who are you to go against Guru Tegh Bhadhur Ji's word? http://www.sikh-history.com/sikhhist/gurus/kirpadutt.html Do you want to see the bad effect of Jattism? http://www.jattworld.com/exoops/modules/newbb_plus/viewforum.php?forum=5

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 16 Dec 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Dear Sikh ji, sorry to contradict you... BUT I am NO "great" and NO "gyani". ( certainly NOT as in Sant Giani Thakur Singh Ji, or Sant Giani Jarnail Singh Ji, or Sant Giani Kartar Singh Ji etc etc...) also i DONT use my CASTE name. ( but I do "know" my Caste name - it is DHILLON...but I have not used it at all.. Thank You for your kind words and i am not offended in any way. Jarnail Singh Arshi

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Kulwinder · 16 Dec 2004

Are you all going crazy, using a caste based sir name, village name, pen name or any other kind of status to identify some one have been in practice since history started, Sikhi's main issues is with when somebody discriminate in their life either in daily life or in marriage issues, that is where it is a serious evil play part, and we should all kick this evil out for good. If I have to explain with the context of the history, then Gangu was Rassioea ( which mean one who look after the kitchen ) , it is perfectly ok to have somebody who can do the some accountancy ( being Brahmin Gangu would have some literacy) skills to manage the very busy kitchen resources, if that person happened to be Brahmin, why it would bother Guru ji, Guru ji’s open fight is with Brahmanism ( Bahamanwad) rather then Brahmins, Remember he asked his Guru Dad to give his life for Hinduism( purely for human rights issue), You can not even think for one micro second that Guru ji would discriminate with somebody on the basis’s of caste. I hope this put the end to the issue. And stop saying nasty things to each other, we are all Humans and that is the end of everything, no Chamar or Brahmin all Just Humans,

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Taksali Singh · 16 Dec 2004

Khalsa Ji ( admin) Can I have fair chance of giving correct answer to Jasvir Kaur? Here is my response to user who uses e-mail ID [address removed] 1. Bhai Kahan Singh Nabha a great scholar has given accounts of most of the famous Sikhs with their castes/clans information. 2. Guru Nanak in his bani gives equal message to all “Varnas" (e.g Khatri, Brahmin, vaishya and Shudra) while mentioning their name. 3. Guru Sahibs have included “Bhats" bani in Guru Granth sahib in which they have given extensive description of merits of Guru Amardas along with his clan “Bhalla" .... 4. Most of the Bhagats caste information is available in Guru Granth sahib. If having caste name was considered "taboo" then why they've added it? Don't we consider all gurus as same jot? It means they knew that Khalsa ceremony will occur in near future. 5. Why great scholar professor Harbans Singh has mentioned Kirpa Singh as Pundit Kirpa Singh Dutt? Do we own more knowledge than Professor Harbans Singh? 6. Why there are accounts available where five disciples’ clans/castes were recorded during khalsa ceremony? End of the story: http://www.sikh-history.com/sikhhist/gurus/kirpadutt.html [b]This is quiet amazing that Jasvir Kaur uses her clan name. [/b]

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

A Singh · 16 Dec 2004

Thank you "sikh". It seems Bhen Ji Jasvir Kaur in her 'ultra-modern' reformist drive wishes to see a Sikh "NATION" which are ALL IDENTICAL in form, thought and practice... ...don't know about you, but I've heard similar theories before during the early-mid part of the 20th century in Europe... ...well, let's just say we all FORGET and LEAVE our clan names, and adopt "Khalsa" or just Singh and Kaur -then, what do we do when it comes to marriage? can any Singh marry any Kaur and be assured that there are no blood relations involved?

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

sikh alliance for all · 16 Dec 2004

a singh, what you are writing above has happened to my saka mama. we come from a neemi ( low zaat). My mama shak amrit in late 1970s after he finish service in indian army. Coming from the lowest rungs of asian society the likes of my uncle and relatives were most keen to drop their surname in favour of singh and kaur alone after their first name. At marriage time he picked his match she introduced herself as ......... kaur. 7 year into their marriage they both talk random about their nankai. It so turned out they were both "kainth" on their mothers sides. kainths being a very small number would somewhere down the line be related to each other. I think its wrong to be proud of caste names but we must bear in mind the dangers of incest if we only call each other singh kaur. Whats worse? carrying your surname for convenience sakes? or those who write ream loads on sikhi and twist their caste views in with devious ways.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Taksali Singh · 16 Dec 2004

[b]A Singh,[/b] I find your posts inspiring and you speak truth. We cannot marry our blood relatives. [b]Jasvir Kaur Thind,[/b] You should practice what you preach and stop insulting gursikhs like Pandit Kirpa Singh Dutt and great institution such as Dam Dammi Taksal. Sorry, admin, I thought that my message was not allowed because I checked it last night twice, so that's why I responded again with my humble request that I should be able to post. [b]Kulwinder,[/b] You should support your assertions with reliable sources otherwise it is only your subjective response.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

khalistani · 17 Dec 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru jeke fateh!! omv just cause some writes their last name doesnt mean their caste crazy even guru je was called gobind rai even bhai gurdas je referes tot hem as the sodhi leinage bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru jeke fateh!!

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 17 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. I can "understand" taksali singh's tenterhooks about his message... we are all like that...Once we have written our "masterpiece" we cant wait to see it in PRINT right there on top of the FORUM !!! thats why we check every five minutes... Now to the serious stuff. Gurbani frowns on "EMPTY PRIDE" ( in our caste/caste names etc ) That means...IF I think that just being a "Dhillon" will GUARANTEE me a place at the right side of GURU JI..then I am sadly MISTAKEN...because that name is absolutley worthless in the realm of SPIRITUALITY/Gurmatt/religion etc..and in the Next World. People get so "worked up" seeing DHILLON behind my name...and I got fed up of answering "amrtidharee's questions" so I dropped it in public BUT I STILL let my children KNOW..what we are...a CLAN that for the purpose of this world needs to know so as to stop incest..however remote. IF THAT is the reason behind keeping to ones clan name i dont think it clashes with any "amrtidharee principle". A person with the "KHALSA" prefix last name may be MORE full of HAUMAII than one with DHILLON...who knows ?? Anyway this is my own very personal opinion.....no one nedds to bother. The other day i read about the new Indian Army Chief..Jaswant Joginder Singh...NOW that is a fresh approach... we can have a First Name, Middle Name and also keep the SINGH as last name. Any contradictions/objections ?? Jarnail Singh

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

A Singh · 17 Dec 2004

Dear "Taksali Singh", Thank you for your kind words. Dear "sikh alliance for all" Thank you for sharing your personal situation for all to learn. Personally I see no issue in retaining one's family name, it is part and parcel where we come from and who we are, I have personally my family lineage back to a pind in Punjab and checked the local references and can see my "Sikh" family line extending all the back to the times of Guru Nanak Dev Ji, who met with the founding member (i.e. first Sikh) of my family and thereafter Sikhi has been flowing in our blood, the records show that the "SINGH" name has been within my family for the past 300 years, which of course is an inspiration for me personally. Others I know from friends, have family names indicative that the move to Sikhi came during a latter Guru period or even more recently, nonetheless, it is inspiring for them to know that they are part of a 'chain' so to speak, keeping the flame of Sikhi alive within your family line. Retaining one's surname is NOT anti-gurmat in the slightest, what Maharaj has advised us against is taking false pride in our caste and/or discriminating in religious affairs on the basis of caste. This is what the real message is, otherwise, let's be honest, yes there are -broadly speaking, differences in mannerisms and other personal matters between the various caste groups, this is what makes life interesting and SIKHI unique, in that it does seek to eradicate all these and make a "Nation" of "look alike, think alike, feel alike" robots as many of our modern reformist like to aim for, but elevate us above mundane ramblings and actually have the coming together of people under one banner (that of Akal Purakh -Sri Asikhet!), just as Akal is "ek roop, anekh darshan" so too is Akal's creation.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

ravidasia · 17 Dec 2004

i am sure you are a dhillon giani sahib as Rana Partap Singh a sikh! My rishtedars are arshi too

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 18 Dec 2004

ravidassia, I am the ONLY ONE "ARSHI" in my family.....its a Pen name for use in my poems and wriitngs. So sorry to disappoint you I have no other "arshi "relatives....THEY all PREFER DHILLON much to my chagrin. BUT I would be proud to associate with Bhagat Ravidass...who Guru Arjun Sahib jee puts on a Pedestal...."a worthless chamaar whose name is Japped all over the worlds and who gets more matha tekked all over the Sikh World today than any DHILLON i know anywhere... ...Sadly Nature made me born as a Dhillon Jatt and my family roots are well established..if anyone wants to know that is...but it doesnt matter one bit to me...thats why I use "Arshi" and my Dad used "DALER".. and everyone who is anyone in Malaysia region knows who we are. My Pind in Bhatinda is Tallewaal and my family still lives there ( if you are interested that is )...and my Nanake is Mandi kalan and my family also lives there as well ( Sidhu Brars) Please enlighten me on who the heck is rana partap singh ?? one of your relatives ? just curious. Also i would dearly like to know if you have any "DALER" relatives as well ?? since my dad is dead i cant ask him. You seem a better choice since you are well informed about this caste stuff !! Jarnail Singh

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

kulwinder Singh · 18 Dec 2004

Dear Taksali Singh Ji, you have said "You should support your assertions with reliable sources otherwise it is only your subjective response" which bit of my note you feel need assertion with reliable Sources ? thanks

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 18 Dec 2004

Ravidasia ji, Unwittingly you have hit the nail right on its head.....Thats what this thread and all those threads about Hindu "gods" in Gurbani...have been discussing. The "ARSHI" as in Gyani arshi...is a completely different word from the one you mean as in "My ARSHI rishtedaars"... The TWO are Galaxies APART. The RAAM in Gurbani written bY Bhagat Kabir, Guur Sahibaan is a Completley different word...and Not the RAAM as in "RAAM" CHANDER of Ayudhia.... You are not alone. Many many before you have been "misled" by just the WORD. When I was learning Paath, I was thrilled to high heaven to see my MOTHERS name in Guru Granth Ji.... I was so excited I just got up and ran to tell my dad that GURU ARJUN JI knew about Mother and wrote HER NAME in His shabad....How naive I was...the GURCHARAN in Gurbani was NOT my mother GURCHARAN KAUR....( and my dad brought me down to earth with a tight SLAP on my face as i had left the Guru Granth Ji uncovered in my excitement...now i am much wiser and dont get struck" blind" by just a "WORD" My own late dad used the word KHAMOSH as his pen name.....but his clan is SIDHU BRAR.....now if you happen to find some long lost rishtedaars named "khamosh"..they have nothing whatsoever to do with my dad because He was the One and ONLY "KHAMOSH" in our family...all others are sidhus. My younger brother is a "ZAKHMI", one is a "RANGEELA" and the youngest is a "KAMZOR" but they are all sidhu-brars by birth. There used be a very famous Ravidassia Singh ( i mean Chamaar) in Singapore during the early 1950 whose name was Sardar Chanda Singh "BHARAMTORR" and he was President of the Ravidass Singh sabha Singapore. ( this sabha is now DEFUNCT..i think)..i beleive he failed to "bharm torr" anyone that he was a SINGH and not a chamaar...because we people never give up our clannish thinking. By the way I am intrigued as to why you call yourself "ravidassia" ?? The Ravidassia are people who beleive ONLY in Bhagat Ravidass and they call him GURU Ravidass...they are NOT SIKHS because they DONT beleive in the GURU GRANTH JI or the other Bhagats/Gurus BUT ONLY REVERE Ravidass. TRUE SINGHS revere everyone in Gurbani.....and dont call themselves Ravidassia, Namdevia , kabiriaa, etc etc. Manjit Kaur

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

omg · 18 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh benti to everybody who posted on this thread....please remember Sikhi tells us to show PYAAR in life....Pyaar for Akaal Purkh and all others. please please dont forget that....that will take us far thank you

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

.. · 18 Dec 2004

Arshi is a surename from the Ravi das community. Who needs surenames when we have Singh Kaur ?

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

JSDhillon "Arshi" Gyani · 19 Dec 2004

author ji, yes I know "arshi" is a surname of chamaars..and a Google search for "arshi" will produce 99% "Arshis" are MUSLIMS..and one famous one in Punjab is Noor arshi ( i think he/she is a singer or something) BUT as I have said this is my PEN NAME..to me it is just a WORD.."arshi...one who resides in the arsh - skies..( OPTIMIST...or maybe DAY DREAMER..sheikh Chilee ) as opposed to a FARSHI..one who is earthbound ( pessimistic or maybe "practical").. As bhen ji manjit kaur has so explicitly explained the word RAAM can have two meanings...so can many other words Basically if BHAGAT RAVIDASS is proud to say he is a CHAMAAR in his GURBANI... i find it difficult to beleive why his co-casteists refuse to use the word and coined ravidassia/ravidass community ?? IF I was a Chamaar..I would say so... I am sad that no "dhillon" wrote any gurbani and is thus NOT a revered Bhagat..but why are ravi das community trying to pass off as "sidhus/dhillons" ?/ When I read this thread I did a google search and came across comments that ravi dassias are "adopting" jatt names like sidhus/braras/dhillons by the thousands expecially in West..BUT the PIND back home reveals the TRUTH ( whatever value that has to anyone..but I am told NO one in his right mind will ever Marry anyone WITHOUT CHECKING the PIND in PUNJAB.....thats just how we are....roots are roots. I cannot pass off as a chamaar even with "arshi" behind my name..and a chamaar cannot pass off as "dhillon" behind his name as our roots will reveal a "mango tree" from a "kikkar tree"( one is not better or worse than the other!!) I agree with you..no one needs Singh/kaur less....but you know what..GURU JI created the Khalsa to STAND OUT in a MILLION HEADS ( of non khlasa)...and in a million KHALSA HEADS..some want to "stand out" as "khalsa/Tohra/MeraPind/Bhinderwalah/dhillon/arshi/Zakhmi/rangeela/etc etc....let them be. People cannot be "forced". jarnail Singh

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Taksali Singh · 19 Dec 2004

<<<>>> Gyani Ji, I have no pride whatsoever and I don't even take pride in being Sikh either. We are Sikhs and others are Hindus and it doesn't make us better than others. I feel that as Sikh we have another foundation and path to achieve salvation through simran, gurbani but this is not the only way to do so. We should love everyone as they all carry the same light of God. If we see someone is going on a wrong path then spread the knowledge and do prayer in front of Guru Granth Sahib. I have not written any “masterpiece” but responded back to your [b]“village mentality"[/b] which exists although you have lived in Malaysia for quiet sometime. Do you think Gurus were like us? Do you think they were writing messages like you with racial bias? Do you think it would have been possible for Gurus to have that many followers if they had used language like you? You can scroll up and see what you have written and then compare it with Gurus lifestyle and teachings. Sorry, if I offended you but my intention was to use bitterness to open locked brains with grace of God. Now you can call me anti- anyone and I have no problem with it but I’ve spoken as lion of Guru Gobind Singh. [b]Guru Arjan Dev Ji wrote, " Fire is contained in all firewood, and butter is contained in all milk. God's Light is contained in the high and the low; the Lord is in the hearts of all beings. || 1 || O Saints, He is pervading and permeating each and every heart. The Perfect Lord is completely permeating everyone, everywhere; He is diffused in the water and the land. || 1 || Pause || Nanak sings the Praises of the Lord, the treasure of excellence; the True Guru has dispelled his doubt. The Lord is pervading everywhere, permeating all, and yet, He is unattached from all. || 2 || (SGGS p.617) (By Dr Sant Singh Khalsa)[/b] WaheGuru Jee Ka Khalsa. Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Parminder kaur Dhillon "nikki" · 19 Dec 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. This thread is about Ganggu the so called COOK... and when we have apparently Finished all our "ammunition".. we then turn on our own ..wah wah this is all we can do. what i absolutley dont understand what a member's so called caste/dhillon/arshi/"arshi"/ etc etc has to do with all this. I am sorely disappointed that the Admin allowed such a personal attack by a ravidassia...his one liner adds absolutley nothing to the arguments, its just an empty one line of gutter talk. so what if he is a ravidassia ..who cares ? so what if he has rishetedaars named arshi..who cares ? so what if it is a "surename" ( sic...the word is surname) of ravidass community? as far as we are concerned Bhagat Ravidass Ji DID NOT use it in his name..so how can people claim to be ravidassia and use a name that he doesnt use !!! for all we care so called ravidassia may a hundred muslim/christian/choorreh rishtedaars..so what do we have to do with this. do we come here to learn about ravidassia's chamaar rishtedars....what value did this one line add to this discussion board. my opinion is that this is trying to attack another member plain and simple and admin shouldnt have allowed it. I have been reading posts here for a long time and never wrote a single reply.but this time i had to. i hope admin will not allow such nonsense posts in future..it is a waste of forum space. equally useless are one word posts: good, very excellent: ya lol etc etc. please do some research and wrtte something substantial. Thank you Love to all PKDhillon. PS i dont want anybody to tell me he has rishtedaars in the chooreh/mirassi/chheemba community with surename like nikki. it is just a nickname. I am a dhillon and i am proud of it...why do we read Gurbani which says the Gurus were Sodhis/bedis.bhallas etc. i have persoanlly seen more haumaii in so called kattar sikhs who wear long cholas and round dastaars, carry long nine inch shining kirpans, lots of khandas, big karras etc and ...Guur ji knows all - no need to preach to others.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Gaganpreet Singh Randhawa · 19 Dec 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. my 0ne cent worth. You people are all crazy and need to enter the mental asylum. Who the heck cares who this arshi is and if he is a khalsa /ravidassia mirassi or whatever ??? Answer his questions, his ideas, his articles, his writings... if you can. why go after his name ?? who cares if his name is ??? I have read his numerous writings..he has already clearly explained that this is his pen name and he doesnt use his caste....do you all know him better than his own family ?? how did that happen ? so what if he uses his caste also ?/ please keep to ones own - if you dont want to use caste name whatever that is your right..why deny anyone else his her right ?? Also he has alredy explained that his caste clan is dhillon and he gave his pind nanake pind etc....go to punjab and investigate if you are really hung up about that but please leave this forum atmsophere well alone free of thsi ( i dont understand why any one would want to stick any caste to him anyway..are you thinking of giving him a girl in marriage or something...mad crazy thats all i can say. either you people dont read properly or you dont understand what a pen name nom de plume means...shows rural punjabiness !! a pen name can be any word - made up or new word or any type of word..it may even be JS samurai, JS bahadur etc does that mean he is japanese if his name is samurai ?? or nepali if his name is bahadur ?? most neplase gurkhas are named bahadur..so baba banda singh bahadur must have been a gurkha !!! as bahadur is a gurkha surename !! what logic ?? utter stupidity pardon me. A lot of us silent readers out here read these forums but if such utter gutterish continues we may leave..who wants to read stupid one liners about this caste name and that without any gurbani naaam jap techniques or hsitory. GSR

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

shekhpuria · 20 Dec 2004

whats the fuss about a surname? fact, there were smaller number of asl punjabi jats in sikhism before the british land act( specifically designed for jats) . After that for upward mobility in the south asian cast systm, people from other casts started calling themselves gill bains sidhoo virk and the rest... On one hand it is good to learn where ones famnily entered sikhi on the other but as many practiucing gursikh have prooved sikhi is in the living and breathing it Bhai rama singh ji example. Theres nothing wrong in keeping ones surname or dropping it. best wishes both ways!

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

I wonder · 20 Dec 2004

I wonder, why dear posters start discussing hot. Please...............

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

A Singh · 20 Dec 2004

Dear Manjit Kaur, Please calm yourself down and your insults to everyone who isn't a 100% copy of yourself and your ideas. Terming Ravidasias as non-sikhs are frankly insulting and misfounded. Whilst I may not agree with their notion that Bhagat Ravi Das was a "Guru" in line with the Sikh Gurus, they are nonetheless a part of the Sikh Panth and do consider Guru Granth Sahib as Guru, one only has to visit their Gurdwaras to see this as evident. The reason for their existence can be in simple terms be traced back to the rise of Jat power and politics within the Panth and the subsequent oppression by Jats of all others who would traditionally be Shudras like themselves. Of course, the rise and upward mobility of the Jats within Sikh ranks, further fueled by the landrights bestowed upon them following the reign of Maharaja Ranjit Singh and also during the time of the British, increased the animosity between the Jats and others like Tarkhans, Kalals (although these two groups experienced some upward mobility as well after the sucesses of Jassa Singh Ramgharia and Sultan-e-Qaum, Jassa Singh Alhuwalia, respectively) and particularly those termed as Mazbhis. This is still evident today in Gurdwara Politics and even the good old Sanatan movements like the Nihangs (who although led by a Khatri are predominantly Jat majority) where a separate langar is held for the "chautha paur" (I have seen a discussion of this raised by the moderators of Sikhawareness and to date only Vijaydeep Singh has tried to reconcile the practice but in the end agreed with its fallacy as well and with the points raised by the moderators that this is blatantly a pratice unaligned with Gursikhi). This in the last century caused, after much in the way of reconcilation attempts by the non-Jat communities the rise of two significant changes in the management of Gurdwaras, both of which have grown considerably since -the Ramgharia Sabhas (grouping together all Tarkhans, Lohars, Mistries etc) and the Ravidasia Gurdwaras. (Other lesser known groups can also be classified here -such as Bhatra Singh Sampradha). Ravidasia Gurdwaras, do have parkash of Guru Granth Sahib Ji and also do perform all necessary protocol in terms of a Gurdwara Service, the only significant differences being their view that Bhagat Ravi Das was also a Guru (with whom they affiliate given his caste background and the treatment meted out to them by the Jats and others) and the invocation of his name within the Ardas. I am not supporting their practices, but to start terming them non-Sikhs without understanding why they do what they do is perhaps what the "Jats" of old wanted in the first place, to make Sikhi exclusive to themselves.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

kulwinder Singh · 25 Dec 2004

Shame on all those who are proud of their caste as Guru Granth Sahib ji says. " Jo Jaat Ka Karee Guman So Murakh Andaha Agiean " Those who are proud of their caste are stupid, blind( intellectually) and nuisance. So make your mind up are you all above said by Guru Ji or you are Guru’s pride Choice is simple be a Sikh or be a non Sikh.

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

hm · 26 Dec 2004

sikhs arent meant to believe in caste are they? gangu was a decieving traitor but is it right to call him by caste or race when sikhs arent ment to believe in it in the first place? If its ok to call the gangu brahmin there are over 100 000 sikhs from brahmin origins in india. If your answer is sikhs dont have a caste, then why does it come into play when it suits? Another bias i have noticed is no one will refer to bhai mati das bhai sati das brahmin background but they will to kesar singh chibber. Now when the same is reversed on panthic traitors such as badal? punjabi chief ministers ( under whos rule lakhs of sikhs were murdered)? killer of amritdaris mr gill? and the partition of both punjabs? why is the caste not mentioned of those now?

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Mkhalsa · 26 Dec 2004

kulwinder singh, where in gurbani is this line?

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

sidki · 27 Dec 2004

There is a PDF file in Punjabi describing another aspect of Gangu's story : - http://f4.grp.yahoofs.com/v1/cCPQQawgq4oRiYJPa6exQkdZup9MJRhB8oZKdudVlGMVwmpXux6PM1L-bl4ey1LReW2U9Q9M2cf6ZfoR3-Ib-g/gangu_baare.pdf You must be a member of this group to access this file. There are some other useful files also in that group. More files will be added very soon. http://groups.yahoo.com/group/sidkisikh/

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

kulwinder Singh · 27 Dec 2004

Dear Mkhalsa, I mentioned this line, as I have seen in the one of the temples walls. I had a look on the Sikhitothemax.com and I can only come to the line of dhhan bhoom kaa jo karai gumaan || so moorakh a(n)dhhaa agiaan || Either I somebody wrote wrong in the temple or it may be from some other writings of some other Sikh. In any case I seriously apologies to you and all for making mistake which was made due to just reading from the Display boards of temple, I am going to that temple again to check and I will mention to the people in the temple to change it or give me some help to locate where they have written from. But my apologies are unconditional and sincere to all of you and dear admin if you think it is appropriate then please take my comment related to this matter off. Thanks Kulwinder Singh

Re: About Gangu Brahmin

Gyani Jarnail Singh Dhillon · 28 Dec 2004

waheguur ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. valid points "hm".. ji, Very Valid indeed. Why is "brahmin" being tagged to ganggu's name all this while ?? And WHY is it not being mentioned that Tohra/badal/Talwandi/Langgah/KPS gill...etc etc who have SARB NASH SIKHS and GURMATT..are JATTS ?? very funny ?? I think it is because we change our rules according to our whims and fancies...... when we "dont like" Brahmins....we mention this tagged to all the traitors.....and IF we happen to be Jatts... we try and not mention this in the case of badal/tohra and company.. Thats how we are.. Jarnail Singh