BIRTHDAYS of GURUS ??
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 02 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Dear All
Now that all the hustle and bustle about celebration of birthday of Guru Nanak is over, I have some question to share with you for an answer.
Is there any historical evidence showing that Guru Angad Dev Ji celebrated the birthday of Guru Nanak or of any of the Gurus celebrating birthdays of their predecessors? Is celebration of birthday of Guru in accordance with the teachings of our Gurus? Was our Guru ever born? If Guru is born, then he will also die. On the one hand we say that our Guru is Shabad and it never dies and is never born. On the other hand we are inviting the whole world to come and see us celebrating the birthday of our Guru. On the one hand we say that Sikhism rejects theory of incarnation and on the other hand in every Gurdwara our preacher say at the top of their voice that this day is the Avtarpurb (day of incarnation) of our Guru. Are these not contradictions? How do we explain them to our kids and to the world at large? Can we explain this as respect for our history? I don’t think so. That is not the way to respect and preserve history. Sikhs have created great history but have displayed total disregard to preserve it.
Regards
Jarnail Singh
Re: BIRTHDAYS of GURUS ??
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 03 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
dear author: ??? Ji,
This is a "DISCUSSION FORUM"...not a "TELLING FORUM".
Secondly will you please "tell" me who the heck is afghanistan da kala ?...and why is he so vital to you ? This is a discussion about GURU JI......not USA/BUSH/Talibans etc in afghanistan. THAT is NOT our problem at all. I am sure all of dont give a heck about the talibans in afghanistan. dont dirty the waters with personal attacks/innuendos that dont make sense.
Gurkirpa ji has given a very good point. The point of the discussion is to discuss all viewpoints.
Jarnail Singh Arshi
Re: BIRTHDAYS of GURUS ??
Jasvir kaur · 03 Dec 2004
Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
Here is a copy of a reply from Sardar Gurmit Singh of Khalsa Mission Australia/New Zealand on this subject published on Sikhs Sydney Forum. These are the types of educated responses based on GURBANI that help in a Discussion and not "useless questions ansd perosnal attacks...
Dear Jarnail Singh jee ( this is the ORIGINAL POSTER of this question on Sikhs Sydney and I wonder how Gyani jarnail Singh left out this information...because this Jarnail Singh is NOT the same JSArshi gyani who posted this on this Forum.... THIS should also put to a well earned SLEEP many who think they are so good detectives and FBIs...and who always "SEE" three as ONE and ONe as Three !!!)
and other well wishers of the Guru Khalsa Panth,
Waheguru jee ka Khalsa Waheguru jee kee Fateh
I fully agree with you that Sikhs should neither celebrate Birth Days of Guru Sahibaan nor our children's. This practice is a sheer imitation of others.
There was no such practice in the past. Perhaps we have already made up our minds - not to obey our Guru. Please have a look at pages 91, 284,
396, 496, 1138 and many more in the Guru Granth Sahib. Attachment is also forwarded for your general information and further advice. Thanks,
Gurmit Singh.
Posted by Jasvir kaur ( NOT an alter ego of JSArshi Gyani...but an independent daughter of Guru Ji.)
Re: BIRTHDAYS of GURUS ??
Bijla Singh · 03 Dec 2004
it is called Gurpurab not birthday. purpose is to go to Gurdwara, join satsang and learn the history of our Guru Ji. otherwise, our future generations will forget the history and miss satsang. also, if gurpurabs shouldn't be celebrated then forget about shaheed purabs of fifth Nanak Ji, ninth Nanak Ji, shaheedi divas of great gursikhs and not to mention Vaisakhi of 1699. right? 1699 was the day not when Khalsa was born but when Sikhs were given a final form and united together and became Akal Purakh Ki Fauj. these days remind us of our history. why forget these days? we shouldn't. plus someone mentioned Bhai Gurdas Ji's vaar. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: BIRTHDAYS of GURUS ??
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 03 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
First of all let me offer my profound apologies for the unintentional error in leaving out the acknowledgement line in the earlier post. Bhen Ji jasvir Kaur is absolutely correct, the original poster is a dear friend who lives in Australia and frequently writes on SikhsSydney and Learning Zone as well.
This could be taken as "plagiarism"...and I am grateful no one has taken this step.
Now to Veer Singh Ji's question. Bhai Gurdass Ji is Guru Arjun Sahib Jee's Mama Ji, respected scribe of the Aad (Guru) Granth Ji that Guru Arjun Ji prepared in 1604...and a well known writer in his own right....still the fact remains that his "BANI" although given the title of KUNJI..did not get included in the Granth ji...as it obviously DID NOT reach the High Standard of GURBANI....
Now we all know and can TESTIFY to the FACT as stated in GURBANI, that AKAL PURAKH is AJOONEE, AKAAL, FORMLESS...and so doesnt take BIRTH. Gurbani also states clealry that Gurmatt doesnt beleive in AVATARS.
We are also clear that the AAD GURU of Guru nanak ji is SHABAD GURU - WAHEGURU..and this SHABAD GURU is ETERNAL, AJOONIE, and doesnt take birth or die. Guru Nanak Ji's JYOT that is in the Shabad guru waheguru is in the GURU GRANTH JI.
Guru Ji Himself in all their forms/ jyot stated that they are His MINISTRELS dhadees, of Waheguru...saying whatever HE instructs them to say...in other words the Guru Jis are instruments of Waheguru to bring us his GURBANI- SHABAD...this Shabad is the REAL and ETERNAL GURU.
ALL bani/history/varaan/sakhis/ etc MUST stand the KASWATTI of GURBANI. IF anything "conflicts" with GURBANI....it cannot stand the test. It all depends on us ultimately whether we want to beleive in GURBANI or others outside sources which may have been adulterated/changed...there is no gurantee of this as only the GURBANI is sealed to prevent adulteration/alteration. This is my personal view and doesnt affect anyone else's beleifs. For me GURBANI is the ONLY TRUE ultimate answer to all questions.
Jarnail Singh.
Re: BIRTHDAYS of GURUS ??
Bijla Singh · 04 Dec 2004
celebrating gurpurabs is just another way to thank the Waheguru for His presence in a form of Jot Nanak. He appeared as Nanak, guided us for 240 years and then stayed with us forever. Why not thank Him? because of gurpurabs we go to the gurdwara, do satsang, listen to kirtan, do seva and learn our history and pass it onto our future generations. everything is 100% pro sikhi.
we celebrate gurpurabs in the remembrance of the day when Jot Nanak "pargat" in this world and darkness and fog of ignorance was dispelled. just like Guru Ji, His Panth also did "pargat". "Pargteoy Khalsa Parmatam Ki mauj" Guru Ji said Guru is Sikh and Sikh is Guru. So if Guru Ji has pargat divas so does khalsa. these days remind us of our history.
thinking of gurpurabs as "birthdays" or "avtars" is ignorant on your part.
one thing surprising is that jarnail singh with a degree asked this question. people who spend years in studying sikhi mostly come up with answers rather than questioning. if people with degree started questioning then who would be left to preach sikhi? btw jarnail singh, did they not teach you the meaning of gur+purab? i will try to find katha on gurpurabs that has very good meanings. it explains why we say gurpurab instead of "birthday".
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: BIRTHDAYS of GURUS ??
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 04 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
Author ?? Ji,
As Veer A Singh has also observed your questions are not clear. Anyway all your questions have been adequately answered by many including Veer A Singh.
The "imaginary" reason as to "why" "some" ( who are these some ??) recite 3/4/5/6/7/8/9/ banis and "why" "many" ( who are these ??)..i admit i am lost in your forest ?? I cant see the trees or the fruits or the forest. Its best you ask "some" who know. I DONT.
THANK YOU.
jarnail singh.
PS. i am not "wise". Please dont put this weight on my shoulders. There are many many more brighter minds on this forum who although younger in age are farther on the path than me...
Re: BIRTHDAYS of GURUS ??
Son of Guru · 04 Dec 2004
Why do we need to question about Gurpurabs?
I know about another "Gyani" who also questions why we read the "lawan"
shabad during Anand Karaj. He says this shabad is a reunion of Guru to God as such we should not read to humans.
If we don't have Gurpurabs where are we going to hear out histories?
Re: BIRTHDAYS of GURUS ??
Jasvir kaur · 04 Dec 2004
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
bijla singh ji,
you make it sound like someone with a "degree" CANNOT ask questions or shouldnt. Isnt a person with a degree a SIKH ?? Cant he "learn" any more ?? surely you are not suggesting only "ignorant" people can ask questions..why jump on the PERSON ?? just answer the question.
This is a FORUM for LEARNING.... some "learned" and not so learned ones behave like the "devils' advocate" to ASK certain questions...so a DISCUSSION can take place. Not everyone who asks a question has to be "stupid", "uneducated", "illeterate", ...even degree holders PHDs can ask..and they have every right to ask. NO ONE IS Forced to answer...if you felt that way you should have kept your "answer" to yourself.
Your answer is full to the brim with Haumaii.
Sorry if i have written bluntly.
jasvir Kaur.
Re: BIRTHDAYS of GURUS ??
everpresentdevils · 05 Dec 2004
everpresentdevil no.2 says:
i don't celebrate anything on Mon,Tues,Wed,Thurs or Fri cuz its school days n me teachers give me sooo.. much homework n by Friday i m already 'fri'ed. for the weeknd!! i wish i didin't hv to go school... ... ..tsk..tsk.,.!!!!!
everpresent devil no.3 says:
yea..yea..I only want to celebrate anythin thats on Saturday or Sunday cuz....
...Saturday is 'Sat'(Truth) day and....
...Sunday is 'Sun'(Listen) day and me mommy like 2 take me 2 gurdwara 2 'Listen' 2 histories, lectures, ladies gossip, mens politics..etc,etc..its fun for me!!!
everpresent devil no.1 says: ahem...ahem... i enjoy guru's birthdays cuz there is ladoo..mithai..barfi..samosas..jelebis..gulab jamun..fireworks..may many sweets.. etc etc in the gurdwaras..yum..yum..yummy!!! i wish everyday was guru's birthday...i enjoy it so much....!!
anything wrong with that??huh??
please..please let us enjoy our guru's birthday...please,,please..don't take it away...please..please..i beg u learned men...please..please don't take it away...pleasezzzzzz.!!
vjkkvjkffromtheeverpresentdevilsbusyeatingleftoverEskimojelebisatthegurdwarainAlaska..!!!
Re: BIRTHDAYS of GURUS ??
Jasvir kaur · 05 Dec 2004
waheguru ji khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh.
dear son of guru ji,
we all "know" of some one...."sant ji", baba ji, Mahapurash Ji, Sri 1008 Ji, etc etc who says this and that..... whats the big deal about this gyani youi know ??
We must use our Guru given intellect and bibek budhi to make our own conclusions.... these gyanais and dsant ababs can say what they please..JUST LISTEN to YOUR DAD - GURU JI.
Jasvir Kaur - Daughter of Guru Gobind Singh Ji who listens to no one.