Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bhai Sahibs Dastar

Bhai Sahibs Dastar

AKJ · 01 Dec 2004

What sort of dastar did Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji wear? and how do we know? what proof do we have?, hope that last part didn'tsound rude. Im just trying to find out, and what sort of colors did he wear? i Would be greatful if Kulbir Singh could reply back to this one, as i suspect he will know best, if not, anyone else i would be grateful to! Vah

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

Balpreet Singh · 02 Dec 2004

From the pictures we see, and from the words of those Singhs who did Sangat with Bhai Sahib, we know that Bhai Sahib tied a navy-blue dastaar and orange keskee. There was nor laR at the back of his dastaar either. It was tied in the gurmukhi dastaara style. You can see this dastaar style on Bhai Jeevan Singh and many other Singhs in the Jatha. Hope that helps.

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

A Singh · 02 Dec 2004

I'm still curious to understand why Bhai Sahib Jee wore an orange keski. There was thread where Kulbir Singh and Manjot Singh both agreed that Maryada dictates that one must wear a Blue Keski as Blue should be the first colour to touch our Kesh. So what was the reason for Bhai Sahib's choice of colour -which is also quite popular today with many Singhs in the Jatha, Taksal and also in the SGPC. Any thoughts?

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

asd · 02 Dec 2004

gud question

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

garja singh panjab · 02 Dec 2004

Bapoo ji wore a 'gurmukhi valee' dastar style. this sort of style means there is no lar done at the back of the pagh, lar means when we hold in mouth and then push in at the back of pagh after tieng. bapoo ji did not do this style and he did not do puni on his pagh either. this style is like what the puratan singhs did, no lar at the back and no puni, the style most people do this days is navatan style not puratan. bapoo ji wore a dark blue pagh with a kesri keski that usually went round his head 5 times. he also wore a sarabloh ka chakkar with another chakkar of mala above this. he also wore more than doh sarabloh kai karai on each arm which were very heavy, so my grandfather used to say. they were weighing about 1 pound each. bapoo ji usually wore a khandaa on his pagh aswell, sometimes and aad chand and sometimes a khanddaa. he also wore hazooeyaa a white hazooreyaa most of the time and in his later life he was wearing glasses aswell round glasses like my grandfather used to tell me.

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

Anon · 02 Dec 2004

maybe blue for dumalla and orange otherwise?

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

garja singh panjab · 02 Dec 2004

bapoo ji wore a kesri keski, which went around his head 5 times over and a small blue gurmukhi valee dastar over it . blue and kesri are tradisional sikhi colors - keski colors.

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

need to lengthen my dastar :S · 03 Dec 2004

Puratan Gurmukhs have also mentioned that the dastar width and length used to be such, that if death was nearby, the body can be covered using the dastar there and then (that is the dastar not the keski underneath!) Gurmukhs were ready for death. Another amazing point on the importance of the dastar!. You can imagine how CK their thinking was.....waheguru waheguru waheguru

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

S1ngh · 03 Dec 2004

Having a laar at the back doesn't always mean you put it in your mouth. I have a laar at the back but it don't put it in my mouth. I hold it with one hand while doing the first laar. I prefer the back laar as it keeps my dastaar tied tight.

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

A Singh · 03 Dec 2004

S1ingh, you are quite correct concerning the back lar as I also have one and certainly have never put this in my mouth. As per Keski colours:- Blue is mandatory for the Khalsa -this is evident from sources like "Guru Ki Sakhia" and also the "Sarabloh Granth". Please correct me if I am wrong, but since when has "kesri" become a colour of the "puratan" Keski? The two referenced texts are both puratan and dependent on your belief, one even authored by Guru Sahib -please explain who we are, or who any Sant, Baba or Bhai Sahib is to decide and change the Maryada of Guru Sahib?

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

Singh · 03 Dec 2004

Another Bhatt Vehi says that the punj pyaaray were made to wear double-coloured dastaars ie. contrasting keski and dastaar. Sarbloh Granth is NOT a good source, since much of it is adultered. It is not accepted by any scholar. But if you accept the Bhatt vehi account that means you also accept that keski is a kakaar. That's good enough for me. We can disagree on the colours but at least you agree it's a kakaar.

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

inside out · 04 Dec 2004

Dear Singh, No offence intended here, but your response seems so typical of many AKJ and SGPC youth who freely quote effective "one liners" from the Sarabloh that they have heard during kirtan or read in some book (i.e "rehit pyaree muj ko, or "Khalsa mero roop hai khaas" etc), yet when other lesser known portion of the Sarabloh Granth (even from the same Shabads they are using!) are brought forward which challenges their existing ideas or those of their role models, they claim it is not a Sikh text! The Bhatt Vahi is NOT a Sikh text! Since when have these texts formed part of our maryada -sure it supports the notion of Keski, but since WHEN have these been a part of our rehitnamas or hukamnamas? NEVER! These are not Sikh sources, how can we as Sikhs look to non-sikh sources like Bhatt Vahis or Cunningham or Macaufille (as so many from the Sanatanists to the SGPC and AKJ) do today, these have never been, are not and never will be our rehitnamas! The Sarabloh Granth, for whatever issues may arise is still a text commonly used for many "SIKH" purposes and is certainly of more importance than the non-sikh Bhatt Vahis. Guru Ki Sakhia are certainly a "SIKH" text and more reliable as a source than either of these two more many scholars, these clearly speak of a BLUE keski. Finally, Singh Sahib, with no disrespect to your personal stance on the matter, but I have not indicated anywhere that Keski is a Kakkar and I certainly do not accept Bhat Vahis as a source for "SIKH" maryada. In view of this, my question still stands, why have we seen many influential reformists in the past century ignore this part of our maryada whilst preaching many other aspects of maryada which shall we say are obsure to many other Sikhs?

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

Singh · 05 Dec 2004

You are ignorant. Plain and simple. You claim Guru Kian Sakhian is a Sikh text but not Bhat Vehis? Do you not know that Guru Kian Sakhian is based on Bhatt Vehis? These Vehis are written by Sikh bhatts. Anyways, if you quote from Guru Kian Sakhian, you must agree that it says keskee is a kakaar. So if you quote from it and take it as authority, then great. You take keski as kakaar. Sarbloh Granth has references to events even after Guru Sahib's ascent. So how exactly is it puraatan? Scholars all agree it is not.

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

A Singh · 06 Dec 2004

ALL scholars do not agree to its non-puratan nature. Please have a look at the thread mentioned earlier where even the respected Bhai Kulbir Singh and Manjot Bhaji agree to the colour having to BLUE! Speak to real chardi-kala Singhs from 1984 like Nihang Baba Nihal Singh of the Tarna Dal, he'll clearly show you that this is the true maryada.

Re: Bhai Sahibs Dastar

A Singh · 07 Dec 2004

Singh: One more thing, why are you twisting this into a "Keski is/is not a kakkar" issue? We are discussing dastaars and the maryada evident in the Khalsa of Neela Bana, particularly with regard to the first material to touch one's Kesh.