Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Problem

Problem

Someone · 01 Dec 2004

I just read that section called Girl is Obsessed. I have similar problems to this. I know a girl around that age maybe older and she most likely pictures herself being a housewife and married in the future. She doesnot care about jobs or other things like that. She just wants to get married. She is in first year university right now. Please offer some realistic help.

Re: Problem

Singh Khalsa · 01 Dec 2004

What's wrong with being a house-wife? Being a housewife is Ok, but I suppose you're right too... she should always be prepared to work as well, and nowadays everybody needs an education to work.

Re: Problem

Hmm · 02 Dec 2004

Yeah but thinking about this all day long? And whats gonna become of your life afterwards? I mean, how long are we gonna be living...?

Re: Problem

g · 02 Dec 2004

hmmm what is wrong with that ? and why is it any of your concern unless you are that girl... why do you feel it necessary to stick your nose in places it does not belong

Re: Problem

g · 02 Dec 2004

and how well do you know this girl that you should be concerned? you said around the age of 15 maybe older... you cant be that close if you dont know her age? if shes in the first year of uni then shes probally at least 18 sounds like your an outside observer who doesnt know her very well and is just judging her and sticking your nose where it does not belong... from what you have said I have seen nothing wrong what so ever with anything? what is the problem and why is it necessary to decuss this young womans life on this board consentrate on your self are you so perfect that you need to go around judgin other people ?

Re: Problem

gypsy123 · 03 Dec 2004

i think i can understand where Someone is actually coming from. perhaps the idea of being married and being a housewife is pre-occupying this young lady's mind a little too much and is affecting her studying? or maybe she has this idea planted in her head so that she does not HAVE to study? could be all sorts of reasons. the best advice to offer the girl - if she wants to hear it - is that she should figure out exactly what she wants. if she doesnt want to study, then she shouldnt study! the choice is really up to her. i dont believe Someone is judging the girl as such, more like a concerned friend who doesnt perhaps want to see her fail in school.

Re: Problem

g · 03 Dec 2004

gypsy your makin asumptions that they are a concerned friend... but they never said it is distracting the girls studying... from what they wrote I got that they dont know the person very well... they dont even know the girls age... and that they think that the girl being a housewife is wrong... for whatever reason... thats the only info they have givin... they never wrote their concerns... its sounds like somone who doesnt know the whole story has heard things about this girl... and is being judgemental... thats what I get from it.. not that they are a good friend of this girls

Re: Problem

Someone · 04 Dec 2004

Gypsy is right. This girl says the minute she knows she will get married, she'll jump head over heals and forget her education

Re: Problem

..... · 04 Dec 2004

Would the question to ponder then be whether marriage is pre-ordained or is it something that is within our control?

Re: Problem

g · 04 Dec 2004

good for her then I would be happy for her rather than find something wrong with it... the thing I dont get is why are you soo concerned... so she wants to be a housewife... she wants to be taken care of and supported thats what she wants... its funny how we always think that we know whats best for someone if she gets married and her husband can support her then what are you concerned about?

Re: Problem

Bhainji.. · 05 Dec 2004

Dear "g" From you posts, it seems that you are becoming very defensive, although given the impersonal nature of the internet, I may be misjudging your tone. I agree that you have a valid point, that other's shouldn't interfere with a personal choice of a young woman if she has already decided to get married and be supported by her husband. I think that many people devalue the role of a wife, and believe that taking care of any future children and domestic duties don't constitute "real work." However, I also believe that "someone" who raised the point in the first place, is genuinely concerned for a young person- whether 15 or 18 or 21 for that matter- who may be naive to the harsh economic realities that the majority of us currently face. It's very rare that a husband can afford to support his wife and children comfortably based on his own income. The majority of families nowadays comprise of two primary bread-winners, not only becuz women want to work in the paid labour force, but also due to the economic NECESSITY..even if her husband is well off in the beginning, any change of circumstance may require her to contribute financially, and she may face considerable challenges without an adequate education.. It doesn't hurt to have an education..If this young woman looks at it as an opportunity to expand her mind, make new friendships etc., she won't be looking at it only as a means to become employed... And who knows, if she marries a financially secure man, then her education may help her in other ways, but if down the road she needs to find gainful employment, then her education did serve its purpose... Alot of time, young persons need guidance, even if they feel that they have life figured out. Education as a backup plan seems like good sense in this day and age, dont' you think?

Re: Problem

g · 06 Dec 2004

yes you make a good point about education but that still doesnt mean she is doing something wrong... we cant discuss this properly because we dont know all the facts but from what we do have... it seems that the girl is doing nothing wrong and should be left to her own buisness