Re: tabla jisss (akj) fans of kirtanee
................. · 30 Nov 2004
fateh jee..
jus was wondering..what makes you so sure that these younger tabla jis, are not jus playing because of this 'fanism' thing your talkin bout... u seem very close minded...veerjee....its sewa....
also... y does it bug u soo much?... is ur attentiion taken more by these mere individuals..and not the bani thats being sung?...
forgive me if i sed anything wrong
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh!
Re: tabla jisss (akj) fans of kirtanee
!!!!!!!!!!!! · 30 Nov 2004
yeah i agree!!! fanism is getting out off control specailly of tabla jiss are getting involved!! yeah and i know what you mean these teenagers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Re: tabla jisss (akj) fans of kirtanee
Harbhajan Singh · 30 Nov 2004
Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh
Dear 'Singh',
Yeah it does sound wierd!!!
I think it should be applauded that young Tabla Jee's in UK are getting time to do the seva. For years in the UK not many youth wanted to do Keertan seva and Tabla seva and it was left to a handful to do the seva for hours at a time. I hope young keertanees also get time aswell now, but then we might hear people saying Older keertanees need time. No win situation!!!
However looking at most smaghams in the World not just the UK most of the Tabla Jees are young. I cannot play Tabla but i do know some of these Veers who spend up to 10 hours or more a week practising and trying to learn from Tabla masters.
Do you think they learn just because they are a Fan of some one? they learn because they want to do seva. Also have you ever thought that they might have been requested to do the seva. Or the Keertanee might appreciate that the Tabla Jee has made a effort in his learning and would like him to play.
It is easy to criticise anyone on a forum. However please ask some older tabla jees in the UK who used to do the seva and they would tell you themselves that the younger ones first need the oppurtunity to play at smaghams and secondly they are much better then them at their young age.
This board was somewhere I used to go for inspiration and still is thanks to posts from Kulbir Singh and others, but I find myself replying after a very long time to a ridiculous post.
Bhul Chuk Marf Karna
Waheguru Jee Kaa Khalsa, Whaeguru Jee Kee Fateh
Re: tabla jisss (akj) fans of kirtanee
Tabla Master · 30 Nov 2004
"Hey alll you wannabees out there, i am the tabla master, i play tabla where ever i go, i have played since i was born, so don't test with me, i have the god given right to play all night with whom I want, cus I play for the right reasons !!!!! which is my own balea balea, I can tria kit this and tira kit that if you know what i mean :)"
The above is pure sarcism, i'm really surprised the admin let this thread on, but as they have its worth discussing, now cus somone has played since they we're young they are playing for the right reason ??? what is the right reason, is it sewa ??? is it bale balea ??? is it obession ??? first you should define the right reason !!!!!
Secondly if you have been playing many years surely it is about time you let youth play who don't get a chance, after all these yeare of playing ain't you tired of it, don't you want to sit their and listen to the kirtan ??? you can hardly blame youth wanting to play as they are young, they have eagerness to show what they have learn't, not being funny but the in the last few years in akj worldwide the youth that have come on to the scene had really shown what tabla is really about, in terms of an art.
Thirdly and finally its seems weird that somebody who isn't a tabla player (might be) has taken it so seriously, I was at the rainsbhai and all I saw was every kirtani had a different tabla player, which is a good thing !!
Seva should be shared, it isn't a god given right, yeh maybe some youth do want to play with a particular kirtanee, that you can understand as they are youth, its even sadder whens its the elders !!! which i don't think is the case is it ???? Also the UK need to give more time to youth kirtanee as well, as that is where the future of AKJ kirtan is in the youth as long as they are guided.
Bhul Chuk Maf
AND REMEMBER I AM THE TABLA MASTER !!!!!!!!!!
Re: tabla jisss (akj) fans of kirtanee
@@@@@?????!!! · 30 Nov 2004
I don't understand what u mean by the term fanism ....... if u are listening to kirtan becos of specific individuals doing the kirtan, and they only go to listen to a specific individual's kirtan - what's wrong with that? u might say that u shud be more interested in the bani than the keertaniya - i agree, BUT if the style of the keertaniya is such that it draws ur attention closer to Gurbani, then where's the problem? let me elucidate.......
we shud remember that the Guru's gave us/encouraged us to listen to/undertand Gurbani through kirtan/raag/musical accompaniments becos it's a means by which one's mind is attached to Gurbani/Guru/Waheguru. now if the keertaniya is "cack" (no offence to anyone intended), and ur mind is not attached to Gurbani thru the person's kirtan, then there is no lahaa/benefit to be gained from that - and whilst i respect their efforts to sing Gurbani, and of course the Gurbani that they sing is Guru, i cannot help but not be interested in the individual's kirtan. this is not a reflection on them personally, becos they may be doing kirtan with great sharda and pyaar, but just that they don't hit the right notes for me (speaking metaphorically, of course.....)
we shud also remember that people are only a "fan" of the keertaniya becos of that person's kirtan - we're a fan of the Gun or Skill that the person has - not a fan of the individual themselves - without the ability to do kirtan, we wudn't know who the keertaniya is - they'd be nobodys. the key thing to remember is that the "fanism" only exists becos of the Bakhshish or Kirpaa on the keertaniya that the Guru has done on them to be able to do kirtan in a skilful way - kirtan is a "nirmolak heera" - it is never given to any old Tom, Dick or Harry. Bhai Mardana Jee had a gift from Waheguru to play the rabab with such beauty that, coupled with the Divine Words uttered from Guru Nanak Dev Jee's Pavittar Rasnaa, the surrounding area would be filled with a Divine aura, capturing anyone and everyone in its vicinity. We respect Bhai Mardana Jee because of the beautiful kirtan that they could do. however, if the keertaniya gets pumped on Ego becos of his kirtan (as Satta and Balwand did), or does kirtan with no sharda or pyaar or just for the money, the Guru will punish the person themselves and perhaps even take away the skill that the person has. also, the Ego or lack of pyaar with which the kirtan is reflected in the quality of kirtan - the sangat will not wish to listen to them. this has happened to many a keertaniya that thinks that they're all great/fantastic/the best keertaniya in the world, etc, etc - these Hunkaari keertaniyas just wither away. We, as 'fans' of that person's kirtan don't need to worry about the keertaniya at all, as after all, we're not interested in the person 'per se', we're only interested in the kirtan that they do.
back to the topic title, there's some keertaniyas that i'd love to play tabla with - they inspire me so much to go on the guru's path - i have huge respect for them becos of the skill/Gun that they have - but i try to remember that i'm listening only to them becos it draws me closer to the meanings of the Gurbani that they are singing. if i was interested solely in the tunes that they play .... well, then there's a whole of world of music out there.....
Please forgive any bhull or anything anti-Gurmat in this post
May Waheguru bless us all with Lagan and Pyaar to Gurbani and the singing of the Waheguru's praises through Keertan:
har keerathan sunai har keerathan gaavai || this jan dhookh nikatt nehee aavai ||2||
Listening to the Kirtan of the Lord's Praises, and singing the Lord's Kirtan,
misfortune shall not even come near you. ||2||
Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh
Re: tabla jisss (akj) fans of kirtanee
dissappointed · 01 Dec 2004
wjkk wjkf
Yeh singh totally agree toooo much fannism not enough pyaar for guru ji.
its not just tabla players but those that sit with who they want as well, jumping on for better keertanees (who they feel are better keertanees) and going home when the normal (not superstar) people are doing keertan. in response to @@@???!!! saying fanism isnt bad, in a way you are right we get a chance t o listen to gurbani because of a keertanee BUT fanism is a big no,no, as it starts with these little gulaa and then goes to people following the keertanee telling them how good their keertan(danger of causing haumai) and making this an opening line in getting to know them ie.emailing them, ringigng them and finally stalking them. at this stage the keertan effect has gone and FANNISM takes over.
then people jump on for these keertanee ie.sitting with them/playing tabla with them and then go home.
whilst in bhai sahibs time and as narrated by gyani amolak singh ji you would not even find 1 person in the langar hall in those days as the pyaar and prem was much greater and goals of spiritual achievemnt were higher and would sit all night and day no matter who was doing keertan and not go home till the ardaas was done.
as to the original post all tabla players should play with alll keertanee by turn as this would cause no friction but if a keertanee requests a specific tabla player which doesn't happen much these days then that is not a problem. also tabla players who do sevaa all week in a smagam should play with that keertanee at the main programme, and fellow tabla players should have respect for each other if knowing that one has been doing the seva then let him play whatever the keertanee may feel as most keertanne are not that fussy. this way there will be no friction and moaning about people only come to certain programme for certain keertanee,.
then maybe we will able to create an atmosphere of the olden days and yearn more for the ras of gurbani/naam and stop these silly criticisms.
wjkk wjkf
Re: tabla jisss (akj) fans of kirtanee
!!!!!!!!!!! · 01 Dec 2004
'Singh'
Get a life man!!!
Do you actually know how stupid you sound. If you got a grevience, I personally see hate coming through aswell, Take it up with the AKJ UK stage secretary.
Or you might be one of the many who needs to bring your brilliant observations on a AKJ Forum where nothing can actually be done about it rather than read messages.
I don't know how long you been in the Jatha but 10 years ago. The elder Tabla Jees used to be TEENAGERS ASWELL. Also many countries abroad now let younger Tabla Jees play including US, Canada, Europe, India. Also when a Young Tabla Jee from abroad comes to the UK they are allowed to play with the best Kirtanees but you don't hear anyone complain, Do You? I sense some prejudice coming through against younger UK Tabla Jees.
Also your comment about young Tabla Jees not playing with anyone else, you must live with them 24/7 and know exactly who they play tabla with and which programs they go to other than Rehnsbhais.
Also as your quite good with observations you mustve observed Kirtanees actually motioning some of these Tabla Jees to play with them. Come on don't say you haven't as you like to observe what happens on the stage rather than on the Keertan, Right?
I think there are 3-4 good young Tabla Jees in the UK who will get better and better. So I hope the Stage secretary will give them time and also give Young Keertanee time aswell.
Fateh!!!
Re: tabla jisss (akj) fans of kirtanee
Valid Point Made · 01 Dec 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!!
Harbhajan Singh, this is not a ridiculous post as you suggested. It is a problem and it WILL for sure cause a disease to smagams. A very valid point has been made which needs to be addressed. It's fine to do tabla seva for kirtani's etc etc. But its also important to have rehat and be the kind of character that is humble to every kirtani, be it a kid to a bajurag.
To ' @@@@@?????!!! ', please kindly listen to what Giani Amolak Singh Ji has said (vichar video from TO smagam) about Fanism. Then relate it to whats happening today. There is NO justification for it and if a chardi kalaa gursikh like Giani Amolak Singh Ji noticed it, don't you think he has seen both extremes?, after all, they did have the sangat of the original jatha. Next thing that will happen is that rainsbhai's will end up being a 'concert' event, with bouncers in the Gurdwara door!!!, seems funny huh?.....maybe some people will think that it will never happen, but this is KALJUG sangat, so wake up!. Learn from the history, and adopt it with whats happening today. Leave politics aside, if anybody is doing kirtan/tabla/kartalai seva, then leave your ego's behind and become the dust of the sangat.
So if this topic helps any of the present day or future tabla/kirtani/etc sevadars, think about their actions, then this topic was worth it. We need to hold onto Gurmat values as tightly as we can.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!