Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

HINDU GODS !!!

HINDU GODS !!!

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 30 Nov 2004

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh . The word Nanrayan has occurred several times in Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji. Similarily the word Madhau, and Damodar and many more words that are also used in Hindu myth as well. Let us look at these a bit more closely: 1. The word Narayan is combination of two words: Naar+ayan, Naar means water, and Ayan means house/home in Sanskrit. Just like Nanak+Ayan means house of Nanak, the word Narayan means: the one who resides on water. Or we can say it is reference to mythical figure Sri Vishnu ji lying in sleeping posture/mudraa on water as lotus stem comes out of its navel, and then Brahuma appears from the lotus flower. (Brahmaa dived deep in to this stem to fathom the expanse of Vishnu's creations. Yatha Mukhwaak Dhann Dhann Satguru Nanak Patshah ji: Goojri Mahalla 1 (489): Naabh kamal te Brahmaa upjey Beid parhey mukh kunth sawaar!! Ta ko untt na jaee lakhnaa awat jaat rahey gubaar!! Vishnu dee nabhi 'chon Bruhmaa ji peida hoey, te apney gall nu swaar swaar key ohna ney Beidaa dee rachnaa keeteee. goojaree mehalaa 1 || Goojaree, First Mehl: naabh kamal thae brehamaa oupajae baedh parrehi mukh ka(n)t(h) savaar || From the lotus of Vishnu's navel, Brahma was born; He chanted the Vedas with a melodious voice. thaa ko a(n)th n jaaee lakhanaa aavath jaath rehai gubaar ||1|| He could not find the Lord's limits, and he remained in the darkness of coming and going. ||1|| preetham kio bisarehi maerae praan adhhaar || Why should I forget my Beloved? He is the support of my very breath of life. jaa kee bhagath karehi jan poorae mun jan saevehi gur veechaar ||1|| rehaao || The perfect beings perform devotional worship to Him. The silent sages serve Him through the Guru's Teachings. ||1||Pause| rav sas dheepak jaa kae thribhavan eaekaa joth muraar || His lamps are the sun and the moon; the One Light of the Destroyer of ego fills the three worlds. guramukh hoe s ahinis niramal manamukh rain a(n)dhhaar ||2|| One who becomes Gurmukh remains immaculately pure, day and night, while the self-willed manmukh is enveloped by the darkness of night. ||2|| sidhh samaadhh karehi nith jhagaraa dhuhu lochan kiaa haerai || The Siddhas in Samaadhi are continually in conflict; what can they see with their two eyes? a(n)thar joth sabadh dhhun jaagai sathigur jhagar nibaerai ||3|| One who has the Divine Light within his heart, and is awakened to the melody of the Word of the Shabad - the True Guru settles his conflicts. ||3|| sur nar naathh baea(n)th ajonee saachai mehal apaaraa || O Lord of angels and men, infinite and unborn, Your True Mansion is incomparable. naanak sehaj milae jagajeevan nadhar karahu nisathaaraa ||4||2|| Nanak merges imperceptibly into the Life of the world; shower Your mercy upon him, and save him. ||4||2|| Here we may even say some thing that is going to irk those who are deadly against Brahmins/Bipars: Guru ji says: So Brahmin, Brhum jo bindey! Har seti rangg rataa!! i.e. Brahmin= The one who has understood Brahmaa and is in perfect tune with him!! That means, we can extrapolate this truth to mean that all humans who become one with Waheguruji are infact true Brahmins. Gurbani also tells us that if we reflect upon Brhum (the creator), our inverted lotus of heart also becomes upright, and then the tenth door can be opened and taste the Amrit dhaar: Yatha Gurji's Mukhwaak Gauri Dakhni Mahalla 1 (153): Ultyio kamal Brahum bichaar!! Amrit dhaar gagan das duaar!! Tribhavan beidhyiaa aap muraar!!! Murr-aar is Krishanji who destroyed demon known by the name Murr. Therefore, all creation is impregnated by Sri Krishanji. In this case what do we do then? Guruji says: Bhujj bal biiir Brahum sukh sagar, garat parat geh lehu anguriaaa... Go hold the finger of Waheguruji (brhum) because he is the ocean of joys and shall save us from the swamp of mayaa. Infact Guruji says: Khandd Brahmund ka ikko thanaa, Gur pardaa khol dikhayiaaa!! There is only one origin of all Khandds and Brahmunds, ONLY SATGURU JI pull the curtain away to show us this magnificient spectacle. Khair: We were talking about Bruhmaa sitting on top of Lotus flower. one day he wanted to fathom the agum agochar's rachnaaa. look what happened according to Satguru Nanak ji: Prathmey Bruhmaa kalley ghar ayiaaa. Brhum kamal payaal na payiaaa. Aggyiaa nahi leenee bharam bhullayiaaa (Gauri Guareirry Mahall 1 227.). Yes he could not reach the bottom of the creation. Why because he tried it without Sri Waheguruji's permission by submitting completely. After pointing towards these MYTHOLOGICAL tales, Satguruji TELLS US: Gurdev Satguru Parbruhm Parmesher, Gurdev Nanak Har namaskraa!! Yes, for Gurmukhs: Parbruhm, Vishnu, Prmeshar, Brhumaa all is SATGURU NANAK PATSHAH JI. And thus if one knows Guru, Brhum then that person is infact BRHUMAA AAP: Babba Brhum janatt tey Brhumaaa!! (Gauru Mahalla 5 258). 2. Madhau: This word is made up of Ma+Dhau i.e Ma= Mother, Dhau=Husband. Therefore it literally means Husband of the mother. Which is father. It infact it also means Ma-Mayaa, Dhau=Husband i.e. husband of Mayaa or owner of mayaa i.e. Maya=Lakhmi and her Husband is Vishnu ji. It ultimately refers to creator Vishnuji or Waheguruji ultimate possessor of all creation. Merey Madhau ji sat sangat miley su taryiaa...Madhau Har Har Har mukh kahiyiaey...Eisi Madhau khinch taneee. Tori na toottey chhory na chhoottei... 3. Damodar: This word is made up of Dam+uddar. Dam means rope and uddar means stomach in Sanskrit. The complete literal meaning then becomes: The one who has a rope tied to his stomach. And that is Krishan ji whos' Mother used to ties him with rope because he was very naughty child. And Krishan is incarnation of Sri Vishnu ji. Therefore the terms refers to Waheguruji. Yatha Mukhwaak : Dyaal damodar Gurmukh payieye hor kitey na bhatee jeeo.... Gopal damodar deen dyaal. .. Madhusoodhan damodar suammi!! Rikhikesh gowardhun dhari murli manohar Har gangaa!! Mohan madhuv Krishan murarrey!! (maroo Mahalla 5, 1082). In these shabads, Madhusoodan is Krishanji who destroyed Madhu demon (Madhu nu sudh keeta=Madhusoodhan).Gopal is Krishani because he used to graze the cows (Gau+pal). Rikhikesh=Shiromani Rishi, Greatest Rishi of all is Sri Krishanji. Gowardhandhari=The one who carried the Gowardhan mountain=Sri Krishanji. Murli Manohar=The one who used to play heart-enchanting flute=Sri Krishanji. Har Gangaa=On banks of Gangaa that originated from hair of Shivji (Har). CONCLUSION: From all above, what do we conclude? Does it mean we are Hindus? NO. Does it mean, we should extract new theories and philosophies such as Nanakian, Narayanian, Madhusudanian, Gopalian?? NO. Should we keep going Hindu-Bashing, Brahmin-hating/Anti-Bipran-ki- reet campaign? Na Na Nan Nan. NO.None of this. We need to know one thing, one akhar: Eik Akhar har mann basat Nanak hot nihaal!! Ikkooonkaar satgurprsad Waheguru ji, Satnaam!! Sari Shrishti da malik IKK Waheguru ji hai hor sabh extrapolations of mind hai ji. My late dad used to say to me : Manjit Puttar Ji, please remeber this: GYAAN de gall vich rassa hai, ehnoo jidhar marji khichi jaoo. That the KNOWLEDGE is that animal who has a rope tied to its neck. Pull whatever direction you want, it shall go. Guruji iss nu jhakh marnaa kehndey hann. i.e. Horr haumei jhakhanaa jhaakh!! Guru ji says: Kahey re bakkwaad layio?? Jinh har payioo tinhey chhupayioo!! Bakkwaad is exactly foolish meanderings jisnu assee Punjabi 'ch bakkwaas vi keh dinddey haan, i.e. wastage of speech and energy of mind. Manjit Kaur

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Singh · 01 Dec 2004

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh . I think the post is rather unclear, and not put across in a clear way, but jumps from point to point. Basically Naarayan means the being who dwells on Water. We know that this is used in Gurbani and refers to Waheguru who dwells not only on water but land and the heavens as well. Murari in gurbani is not used for Krishna, but Waheguru as it was God who really destroyed the demon Murar. Simply these are karam nams for Akal Purkh, and where used for Krishna etc Guru Ji makes it clear that he’s referring to them and not God. On ang 1082 Guru Ji is telling us how Waheguru is inside Ram Chander, Krishna etc and the deeds performed by them are his. Just like Guru Ji shows how Waheguru is himself the fish, water and net.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Person · 01 Dec 2004

Doesn't Narayan refer to the one who is in all men. Nar = Man Ayan = house/home. Is the Nar in Narayan spelt the same way as Nar in Gurbani as in Narsingh or Nar used in other places. One thing which is for sure is that Murari does not refer to Krishna who is Vishnu’s incarnation and in turn Waheguru. As in Gurbani Vishnu is not Waheguru but a chela or servant of God, subject to births death etc. Murari is a quality name for God, and if or when ever used as a name for Krishna it is made clear.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Person · 01 Dec 2004

Also think it's Go Pal = World Sustainer rather than GauPal cow sustainer. This is the translation in most texts

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

IAgree · 01 Dec 2004

I don't think Har means Shiva as said in the original post. I think it simply means Lord, as in Har(i) Rama or Har(i) Krishna = Lord Har(i) Krishna etc. Har or Lord is than used in Gurbani for God. Does anyone have another opinon of the meaning of Har, or Damodar for that matter.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

A Singh · 02 Dec 2004

LORD??? Oh yeah, the high-caste european male Lord? How so very protestan! I almost forgot that we are Sikhs!

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Singh · 02 Dec 2004

A "Singh" What do your comments refer to. Sahib in Gurbani also means Master is this also Protestant and upper class. Lord or God it appears is the closest translation of Har, perhaps you can add something of value to the discussion? Do you believe Har is used for Shiva in Gurbani, or do you no idea, in which case do some research and don’t waste time in topics you know nothing about. Another thing to mention is that Gopal means world sustainer, as in Go World and Pal to sustain. If the Go was meant for cows as wrongly translated by the original poster where would it leave Gobind. Here Go again means world and bind stands for sperm or seed = the seed or souce of the World = God. If Go meant cows it would translate Cow sperm. Perhaps the original poster would care to give her references for her translations and thinking. BTW - "Gurdev Satguru Parbruhm Parmesher, Gurdev Nanak Har namaskraa" The above Parmeher, Parbrahm are karam nams for God in Gurbani and not Visnu or Bhrama. The shabad is saying Guru Ji is one with God, not Visnu or Bhrama

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Jasvir kaur · 04 Dec 2004

Heavily LOPSIDED hindu based arguments of bhen ji manjit kaur. Do you really beleive in meanings ?? Funny how the sant baba supporters have not sent in a single reply because these meanings appeal to them. They must be thanking their heavenly stars..at last another supporter of their viewpoints...funny now the three in one and one in three theory is not mentioned ?? or it only works when their views are rejected ?? I wonder. jasvir kaur

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Person · 06 Dec 2004

I don't think this has anything to to with Sants etc, so its best to stick to the discussion in hand. All names used for Waheguru In Guru Granth Sahib Ji have meanings, which is a fact. It's a a shame however that some ignorant people think these names are for Ram Chander, Krishna etc.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

A Singh · 06 Dec 2004

Dear “Singh” I am in no way suggesting that “Har” is used for Shiva or any other “karm” naam refers to a Devta or Devi. Just as most posters appear to be caught up with the flavour of the month “we must not amalgamate into hindus” I am concerned more generally with we must remain Sikhs! We have our own path, which is GURMAT. All the talk of Lord, Saviour etc can be found in many translated Sikh texts, particularly those endorsed by the Sikh Missionary Society where even Shabads like “He Gobind, He Gopal He Dyal Lal” get translated into “Oh Lord of the Universe, Master of breath, grant me thy mercy”. This may on the surface appear innocent and my taking issue with it trivial, but I beg to differ, as this is no less a concern than all those seemingly ‘pro-hindu’ translations everyone seems to take up matters against. Pick up any such English translation of Gurbani and then have a look at a bible (particularly those commissioned by the Church of England) and you’ll begin to see an emerging trend. Again, as I often thought, this is fine, its the closest English we can get to Gurbani and it just shows certain similarities between our faiths, however look closer and one will find a greater degree of subliminal messages. All the English translations and terms will invariably invoke Akal into Masculine terms only and will uncannily sound like Biblical readings. Is it any surprise that whilst in India we have issues with Gurdwaras and perceived threats from Hindu issues, we take a blind eye to the similar non-Hindu threats arising locally in the West, where we have Gurdwaras holding Akhand Paths for Chirstmas, Sikh representatives talking of similarities between Christianity and Sikhism to the extent that both are effectively identical, the emergence of more and more Church related paraphernalia in Gurdwara buildings, to more extremes like those of Rajinder Singh Chowdhury and the instance of Gurdwaras in Canada where the Sangat actually sat in the Gurdwara Sahib on Chairs and Maharaj was placed on an alter or as I personally witnessed in Victoria, where Mona members of the Sangat refuse to even cover their heads with a Rumal and Ladies attempt to sit cross-legged whilst wearing dresses! There are numerous more issues that arise further with this type of mentality.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Person · 06 Dec 2004

A Singh, While I agree 100% that the use of bible style old English ie thy, thou and what not should not be applied in translations of Gurbani the fact remains that the best translation for Har is Lord or God. Likewise as you mentioned the best translation of Gopal is indeed World Sustainer. Therefor there is nothing wrong or unsikhi in translating these words as they actually are. It does not make us unsikh or Christian in any way if the best translation of karam nams like Sahib = master, Har = Lord or God and Gopal = World Sustainer. This in no way takes us away from the path of Gurmat, please clarify how translating a karam nam how it really is into english does so. Honest and true translations of gurbani DO NOT result in foolish people thinking that we are Christians, rather it is there own mentality. In my opion Lord, World Sustainer, Master ets should be used in translations for the simple fact that they are the English translations of the word, and therefore not doing so is changing what Gurbani is saying for ones own ends. However all the thy, thous etc and other Christian type wordings which are not a true and honest translation of Gurbani should not be permitted. BTW it’s not the flavour of the month that fools seem to think Guru Ji is referring to Krishna, Ram Chander, Shiva etc but a long standing issue, which will ultimately have a greater impact going forward. Talking about the issue and Gurmat in no way means that I myself or anyone else is ignorant or unaware of the inroads and attempt made by other missionary faiths, as you appear to be suggesting.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 07 Dec 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. person wrote: << I don't think this has anything to to with Sants etc I beg to differ. IT has EVERYTHING to do with the "sants/derawallahs/Taksals"...because the PRODUCTS of these are the ones that strongly propogate that this is GURU JI invoking Shiva /Hari/Raam chander/Krishan Ji etc etc...that there is no difference...we are hindu descendants.. etc etc. just hear a Sant deras kathawachak/speaker/raagi and he will say these things, bring up "false/made up/concocted/ not proven/" sakhis etc from hindu purans/vedas. etc to explain gurbani..adn link the two as if Gurbani is just an "explanation" of the Veds/purans/Ramayana/Mahabharta. ONLY a person who is solidly based on say Prof sahib singh Jis Darpan on Guru garnth will NOT say such things as he knows all thse Hindu gods are not what they are in Gurbani..just references and not the means to waheguru. Jarnail Singh

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

A Singh · 08 Dec 2004

Dear "Person" Thanks for your reply. Again, my concern is not so much others making in roads into Sikhi, as much as it is in Sikhs, as a bid to distance themselves from largley Hindu agents of miscreant (RSS, VHP etc) and their propaganda, begin to adopt customs which are also not Sikh. The examples I gave of the largely Western and Protestan Christian influence are not the works of missionaries or priests, these are the actions of the Sikhs themselves and arising from either (a) the aforementioned issue to distance ourselves from all that is Hindu and (b) as a bid to what some clearly think is 'progressive' and hence to borrow a phrase from "Gyani" Jarnail Singh Jee, "copy cat bhed chaal" of the white man. Take a look at the majority of Gurdwaras in Canada, particularly in Victoria, and also some in parts of the UK, and you'll see this for yourself. During the 1999 V&A talks when I was in London, the Bhai Sahib from Soho Road Gurdwara (GNJS) on the presentation video made a comment to the effect that in essence "Sikhism is just like that what is in Christanity, we have ....".

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Singh · 08 Dec 2004

Prof sahib singh Ji's Darpan on Guru Granth Sahib Ji also agrees that Damodar refers to Krishna with a rope around its stomach.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

ks narula · 08 Dec 2004

lets end this hindu debate once and for all. what context are we ment to be hindus? religiously or ethnically? most sikhs from sakas were never part of india even before sikhi they were known as sultanis with a sufic influence. However the unversal nature of sikhi appealed to many other ethnic groups in india ie mazabis chureh chamars who were hindus and in some cases still are. Our gurus were from the khatris but most sikhs are jatts who have had no hindu connection except for those who have moonlighted their surnames to match themselves with sakas from chamar backgrounds. Thats the ethnic bit sorted. Now religious, if the gurus told us worship one god and no devi devte end of, yeh rspect the fact these beings existed, were created by God but thats it only Shabad is the Guru. Why do we have to keep repeating the same ol crap?

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Singh · 09 Dec 2004

The problem is when fools think names like Ram + Ram Chander & Gopal = Krishna.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 10 Dec 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. as long as we continue "holding" on to the drawstrings of the hindu religion/culture...we will never be complete Sikhs... Guru Ji fist declared: Na hum Hindu na mussalmaan.... Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha wrote" Hum Hindu nahin... As long as the Christians didnt let go of the Jewsish background.. Christianity never flourished..... IT even went agaisnt GOD's LAW and CHANGED the sabbath from Saturday to SUNDAY.....look at Christianity today... 2 billion people As long as Islam didnt break away from its pagan arabic roots and jewish roots...it too didnt grow much. It also went agaisnt GOD's LAW by Changing sabbath from Saturday to FRIDAY... IF Hindu gods etc were that important GURU NANAK would never have broken the Janeau laws, etc etc...after all what harm can a thread do. Guur Ji was Born and bred in a HINDU family...YET He BROKE all these "laws"..and Disregarded all tsoe vedas, puranas, simrtis... WE MUST break away from the STRANGLEHOLD of Hinduism to survive and flourish.....or we will end up like Buddhism..jainism etc. Already so much of hinduism is already being brought in by the Bbaehs/derawallahs and is diluting the mesaage of Gurbani. SIKHI is a unique new revealed religion...lets follow our GURU Ji ONLY. jarnail singh

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

A Singh · 10 Dec 2004

Gyani Jee you wrote:- "WE MUST break away from the STRANGLEHOLD of Hinduism to survive and flourish.....or we will end up like Buddhism..jainism etc. " And you gave examples of Islam and Christianity "flourishing" above too. This is all fair and well, but I can't reconcile your comments concerning Buddhism with this assertion. Clearly you refer to the "NUMBERS" of Muslims and Christians in the world as the attribute that describes your opinion of "flourishing". However the Buddhists are also large in number, all over SE Asia and also in the Western Hemisphere. If NUMBERS are the name of game (which for me personally they are not, but anyway), how have the Buddhists failed? Secondly, if we are so concerned about becoming like Buddhists in our supposed fate, please outline exactly what is so bad about their condition? They have indeed flourished in many places and influenced so much in the modern world. Finally, if we are to look to modern day Christians and Muslims, as you suggest, in a bid to grow and 'flourish', then let's actually look at them carefully -how many of the modern day masses in Islam or Christianity actually follow anything near the original tenants of their faith and how many are radical members of recent man-made reformist movements with various political ties and agendas and consider themselves to be the ONE true CHOSEN faith. Is this what WE REALLY should be?

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Singh · 13 Dec 2004

Perhaps Gyni Ji’s analogy was not the best one. However the FACT remains that at one time Buddhism was a major force in India second only to Hinduism. However as Macalith even mentions the steady inroads made by Hinduism into Buddhism ie the Biddha being regarded an incarnation of Vishnu etc, eventually let to Bunddhism in India being absorbed into Hinduism. Although some argue that the invasions from the North also had a role, the fact remains that Buddhism only survived as it managed to export to other territories where Hinduism could not reach it, as in its very birth place of India over years of Hindu influence Buddhism almost completely died in India.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

P Singh · 13 Dec 2004

"Or we will end up like buddhism?" What is this supposed to mean? Many north americans are EMBRACING Buddhism.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Jasvir Kaur · 14 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. I agree with Veer A Singh Ji above. Imho that is what Gyani ji meant and the danger is clearly written on the wall. Come to PUNJAB and see for yourself.... a POORAN AMRITDHAREE is as easy to find as a needle in a haystack....you will see no dastaars....if you do see one wearing a dastaar...his beard will be missing....if he has a beard intact..NO KIRPAN !!!! Even if you go to a seemingly "pooran amrtidharees" house, with all those kirpan gatra thing.... you might see that the Akhand Paath going on has a coconut/red cloth/pitcher of water etc etc .. Another pooran amritdharees household will have the gatra wearing ladies going to this "samadh" and that samadh for tweets toonas, shardha, sukh lahonee, matha tekna, this sant sewa derawallah sewa etc etc.. SIKHI - TRUE SIKHI of Guru nanak is getting to be very very rare commodity in my KAPURTHALA/SULTAN PUR LODHI area..here you will see thousands of melas/samadhs/of muslims pirs and what not..aND "SIKHS" ALL OVER THE PLACE..and of course these same sikhs also go to the gurdwaras and aklai dal samagams..ladies of my own household have so many samdhs to go to lahh sukhaan/pray for sons/ etc etc adn all of us wear kirpan gatra and took amrit.... HINDUISM is a Boa Constrictor that will Swallow Sikhism just as it did Buddhism a long time ago.... writing on the wall... Sikhi flourishes overseas as SIKH population in India FALLS... Jasvir Kaur

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

A Singh · 14 Dec 2004

"HINDUISM is a Boa Constrictor that will Swallow Sikhism just as it did Buddhism a long time ago.... writing on the wall... Sikhi flourishes overseas as SIKH population in India FALLS... " This is something I have been hearing all my life and frankly, I find it hilarious when all the "SIKHS" on this forum and others, put up one hate thread after another about "India", even when asked is it not the land where our Gurus lived and preached and died, they respond, it is a vile land that killed our Brothers in the 1980's. I totally agree with the issue on the 1980's and the GOI is totally responsible for its vile and repulsive actions. However, let's just step back and look at this... Buddhism has hardly been eliminated from India, granted its stronghold is now more predominant elsewhere in the World and slowly growing in its expanse, but even in India, in the North and in the Deep South, one can see Buddhism still alive. Unlike Sikhs, who on one hand love to hate India and slag off the "country and land" as well as the politicians (the latter of which is totally understandable) and want nothing to do with it, yet on the other hand, complain about Hindu influences running abound throughout India because clearly they are concerned about their roots and rights within their motherland (given that Punjab is in India -and let's not forget that not all Sikhs are Punjabi)...the Buddhists have frankly moved on, they have not allowed the barriers of space and time to result in their absolute demise, as many Sikh authors seem to suggest...interestingly these same Sikh authors are the very people to also mention that the Khalsa is universal and quote lines from the Sarabloh Granth (which they then suddenly refuse to accept as an authentic text on issues such as the treh mudra and blue keski) and that the Guru Granth Sahib of universal importance, yet we SIKHS are so hung up on Land issues? What's the deal? J Kaur Bhenji, you in the same statement indicate that Sikhi is flourishing outside of India, so what's the big deal? Are we supposedly to be fixed, static and country specific?

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Singh · 14 Dec 2004

Perhaps you need to re-read A Singhs post, he is not agreeing with your comments.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

jagmeet singh · 14 Dec 2004

just carry on doing your own bhagti jasvir kaur and let the panth sort things out. When you have developed on sikh matt then you may participate.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Singh · 15 Dec 2004

A Singh writes "Buddhism has hardly been eliminated from India, granted its stronghold is now more predominant elsewhere in the World and slowly growing in its expanse, but even in India, in the North and in the Deep South, one can see Buddhism still alive." However you fail to mention that infact Buddhism was a major force second only to early Hinduism or equal to it. Therefore still seeing Buddhists alive does not mean it has survived happily in India, as it has drastically decreased and been eroded into small almost insignificant numbers, from once being a major religion in India. This took a number of years, but the fact remains if Buddhism did not grow outside India it would be almost non existant as it is in the land of its birth, India.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

khalistan zindabad · 15 Dec 2004

why dont we focus on the positives of spirituality wihin the confines of sikhi? why do we need to constantly read messages from these malaysian gang if you really want to do something about hindu influence then please just put sikhi into your life for a start. Have pride in your sikhi! Stop this negative pile of poo! talk about positive things! naam japna, encourage a person through gurbani, love others, sacrifice, seva, shaheeds, follow what its saying huna? this negative filth 3 people on this site keep repeating, is really non productive! just ask yourself what really works to bring more people to the fold of Guru Ji? nam simran and encourageing sikhi? or whinging on about hondus hindus junglis brahmins? if you really care for the security of the sikh panth put your actions to it!

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 16 Dec 2004

Khalistan Zindabad... Your own post contains the following words... GANG...FILTH...NEGATIVE...POO...yeah it really STINKS to high heaven. NOTHING about all that naam japp, simran, shahedee, seva etc etc blah blah blah... in what way is your post POSITIVE ?? Zindabad ?? you must be joking.. productive ?? not at all. I found it to be just murdabad. Sorry to burst your little bubble. To be POSITIVE..you have to set the example. Lets have one really good positive mail from you on Naam japp, SEWA, SIMRAN, GURBANI..( but you must know such positive posts require a LOT of HARD WOK/research/input etc..... while POO/gang/filth just happens naturally...so be warned. Empty slogans are easy..show us proof. BTW no one is "forced" to read anybody...or forced to reply..and no body certainly doesnt force the admin to publish these "gangster" posts...all the "SIKH" gangsters are in CANADA ( read the newspapers)...none in MALAYSIA.( Show me a single news report about sikh gangs in malaysia) Jarnail Singh

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

A Singh · 16 Dec 2004

Dear "khalistan zindabad" That is exactly my point! Complaining and whining about Hindu this and Hindu that is not going to propagate Sikhi, in fact it gives rise to more internal enemies like Kala Afghana and the IOSS, who take this anti-Hindu stance to the extreme. But moreover, whilst not ignoring the issues surrounding the likes of RSS -who can BE EASILY defeated and countered in all of their notions, all this talk of Buddhism is factually incorrect. Allow me to address further... "Singh" writes... "However you fail to mention that infact Buddhism was a major force second only to early Hinduism or equal to it. Therefore still seeing Buddhists alive does not mean it has survived happily in India, as it has drastically decreased and been eroded into small almost insignificant numbers, from once being a major religion in India. This took a number of years, but the fact remains if Buddhism did not grow outside India it would be almost non existant as it is in the land of its birth, India." Singh Bhaji, you have proved my point exactly -"Buddhism was a major force second only to EARLY Hinduism or equal to it" What was this EARLY Hinduism you speak of -is it was is today defined as Hinduism? Have a look into this, and you'll find many authentic traditions inspired by the VEDIC texts and others also do not exist in mainland India were the RSS inspired HINDU NATIONALIST (which is more a political issue than a religious one). Like Buddhism, these traditions continue to flourish elsewhere and have not died out as SIKH authors claim, they have simply chosen NOT to be held up by the boundaries of LAND...which is no surprise in the case of the SIKHS, who have had their Jat leadership over the past 200 years + making policy decision solely based on LAND! you further state "fact remains if Buddhism did not grow outside India it would be almost non existant as it is in the land of its birth, India" Again, most SIKHS don't even like India today! Why the pre-occupation with it? The actual FACT is that BUDDHISM DOES survive the world over including INDIA in its northern extremes AND all over the Southern parts.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Singh · 16 Dec 2004

I think that it’s an extreme over simplification and easy way out to argue that one should practise their own sikhi and only than comment on misrepresentation of sikhi. People do practise sikhi which is why they are concerned about gurbani being misquoted and names used by Guru ji for God being misquoted into being the worship of Ram Chander, Krishna etc. You say follow what the shabads say, but that’s exactly what we are trying to find out (ie the original post giving wrong meanings). Anyway how do you know who has and has not got sikhi in thier life to begin with, therefore how can you ask someone to do somethinhg which they are alreeady doing, unless you are an all knowing person,lol. Indeed time is best spent on ones own naam, gurbani and sikhi, however we also have a responsibility to comment when gurbani is changed and meanings altered against the very fabric of Gurmat ie one formless God. The reason for my posts is not Bhamin bashing, I couldn’t care less about Bhamins but if you read the original post names have blatantly been mis translated which needed correction, and they were obviously wrong as the original poster has not replied. Replying to misquotes is not Hindu bashing, but vicharing the meaning of gurbani, just blindly saying get on with nam, and gurbani without even knowing the meaning is a foolish easy way out.

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Putt Jattan Dey · 18 Dec 2004

jasvir kaur states "SIKHI - TRUE SIKHI of Guru nanak is getting to be very very rare commodity in my KAPURTHALA/SULTAN PUR LODHI area..here you will see thousands of melas/samadhs/of muslims pirs and what not..aND "SIKHS" ALL OVER THE PLACE..and of course these same sikhs also go to the gurdwaras and aklai dal samagams......" from my understanding certain dominating punjab groups ie sandhus grand ancestral fathers were pirs like pir kala. Hence celebrations of great ancestors! Jatt Di Satt -

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

Singh · 19 Dec 2004

A Singh For your information the early Hinduism which I am referring to holds with most aspects of modern Hinduism, ie caste divisions, the laws of manu and rituals even held by groups such as RSS. Therefore as you claim these have not vanished or have moved abroad in any way. The fact of my post which you appear to be incapable of coming to grips with is that Hinduism in whatever form through years of gentle insurgency absorbed Buddhism within itself. Thus from once being a major religion in India with millions of followers it has now become a rarity, being no more than 1% of the population. As for your comments that most Sikhs do not like India so "Why the pre-occupation with it?, the fact is that I have no preoccupation with it. This topic is about misquoted gurbani and Hindu gods, not India, to discuss India start a new post. However when Gurbani is misquoted and used in wrong ways regardless where ever it is happening in the World, we are duty bound to argue the true meaning. For example in this very post wrong translations of words like gopal were given. Hence I responded not because I have a preoccupation with India, but for the simple reason that where Gurbani is misquoted the correct translation must be given. The fact is that this misuse of gurbani ie names like Ram, Gopal etc being used out of context for hindu personalities is a growing trend, which with the current state of affairs is set to grow, while people like you are seemingly more concerned with cakes at the Gurdwara beinf a beadbi rather than the changing of gurbani. For example a famous singer Jagjit Singh was recently singing the shabad Hey Gobind, hay Gopal, Hay Dyaal lal in front of some statues of Krishna in a Mandir in India. Like I said I do not have any pre-occupation with India as you narrow mindedly try to claim, but where words in gurbani are misused and wrongly translated ie from world sustainer to mean Ksrishna than even though it may not seem as a major beadbi to someone like you, who is more concerned with cakes a the Gurdwara for me the wrongful translation of gurbani is far more serous and can indeed have a wider impact of the slow erosion of the boundaries of what Sikhism and Hinduism are, just like with Buddhism where the Buddha was preached by Hinduism as being the incarnation of Vishnu etc. For me the issue is of misguoted gurbani, and not politics of a land be it Indi or where ever, which you A Singh keep reffering to, perhaps becouase for some strange reasion you cannot even understand my basic points

Re: HINDU GODS !!!

A Singh · 20 Dec 2004

Dear "Singh" Thank you for spelling out your "basic" points. I have no issue with ensuring the correct usage and understanding of bani and that much has been indicated. My points were raised with respect to your claim that we as Sikhs shall face the same fate as Buddhism, but you fail to grasp my basic point on this matter. Anyhow, I agree that this thread is concerning Hindu Gods, so we'll leave this discussion for elsewhere. Have a good day Singh Sahib! A Singh.