Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Rehras or So Dar

Rehras or So Dar

JagdeepK · 25 Nov 2004

A leanrned Gurmukh was telling me that the original name of Rehras was So Dar and that the first two lines (Dukh Daru Sukh Rog Bhayya . . . . ) are not part of the original So Dar da Paath. Please enlighten me on this. So are we reading the wrong 'So Dar' by reading some lines that were originally not meant to be in it? Why was the original name of the Paath changed to 'Rehras'? Why do the Gutke today have the two lines included when they were not meant to be there? JagdeepK

Re: Rehras or So Dar

Kesdhari · 25 Nov 2004

According to Akal Takht Maryada if im not mistaken RehRAas sahib is from Sodar till end of Mundavani (+ salok M 5)

Re: Rehras or So Dar

stupid person · 25 Nov 2004

according to akal takhat sahib it is from So Dar Rag Asa Mahala 1 up to Mundavani Mahala 5 and Salok Mahala 5 according to many jathas including akhand kirtani jatha it is from Asa Mahala 1 (Dukh Daaroo) up to Mundavani Mahala 5, plus the 2 Saloks and 2 Mahala 5 shabads including "Rakhe Rakhanhaar" in the above two, the Chaupai Sahib begins from "Hamree Karo Haath Dai Rachha" and ends at "Sarab Thaur Mo Hohu Sahaee" line according to many jathas including dam dami taksal, it is from "Har Jug Jug Bhagat upaaeiaa" then Asa Mahala 1 (Dukh Daaroo) up to Mundavani Mahala 5, plus the 2 Saloks and 2 Mahala 5 shabads including "Rakhe Rakhanhaar" this is also many jathas including nanaksar, that extra banis are read before and after, including "aartee" in the above two, the Chaupai Sahib begins from "Chaupai: Pun Raachhas Kaa Kaataa seesaa" up to "Saadh asaadh jaano nahee." with all of the original dohras and saloks. When there will be a Sarbat Khalsa samelan, the differences will be reconciled. Until then it's best to read the Rehiras Sahib that you feel in your SOUL is the right one. Rehraas means "Living wages" - it means the money that you make to be able to live. Guru jee says "Har keerat hamree rehraas" - which means that God's praises are the wealth that helps a Sikh live Rehraas is the proper name since the Khalsa was created in 1699. please forgive my mistakes, vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefathehhhhhhh!!!!!!!!

Re: Rehras or So Dar

Singh · 25 Nov 2004

The Akhand Kirtani Jatha has no set rehraas sahib, so it would be wrong to say the Akhand Kirtani Jatha believes X. When I received amrit, I was told that to do Rehraas as is defined in the Akal Takhat Maryada, and that was an amrit sinchaar organised by the Akhand Kirtani Jatha. Some Singhs in Jatha do much longer rehraas and even do 40 pauris Anand Sahib in it, and others do the "short" version. Rehraas Sahib in puraatan times was as much as you will find at the start of Sree Guru Granth Sahib. Later it was extended to include Benti Chaupai and Anand Sahib and Mundavani/M: 5. Other additions depend on Jathebandi. I know old Taksal Gutkas and those printed by G. Mohan Singh of Bhindar Kalan begin at Dukh Daroo, not Har jug jug. Rehraas can mean daily wage and it can also mean obeisance.

Re: Rehras or So Dar

taksali katha vachak · 25 Nov 2004

According to Taksal it starts from har jug jug bhagat opaya

Re: Rehras or So Dar

Singh · 26 Nov 2004

According to Sri Guru Granth Sahib the Sachi Taksal of Khalsa Panth the So Dar starts at : SoDar Rag Asa Mahala 1 Abulan andar sabh ko, abhul Guru Kartar.

Re: Rehras or So Dar

......... · 26 Nov 2004

"according to many jathas including dam dami taksal, it is from "Har Jug Jug Bhagat upaaeiaa" then Asa Mahala 1 (Dukh Daaroo) up to Mundavani Mahala 5, plus the 2 Saloks and 2 Mahala 5 shabads including "Rakhe Rakhanhaar" this is also many jathas including nanaksar, that extra banis are read before and after, including "aartee" in the above two, the Chaupai Sahib begins from "Chaupai: Pun Raachhas Kaa Kaataa seesaa" up to "Saadh asaadh jaano nahee." with all of the original dohras and saloks. " i just wanted to correct something, i'm pretty sure nanaksar believes chapai sahib to begin at "bahur asur ka kaatas maathha sri askayt jagat ke naathha.."

Re: Rehras or So Dar

seeker · 26 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Giani Mohan Singh is not with DAMDAMI TAKSAL....yes he is curretly at Bhinder Kalan, but when Sant Kartar Singh Ji Bhindranwale became Jathedar, they moved the Taksal to Mehta. Anything printed by Giani Mohan Singh Ji's Jatha is not TAKSAL....there is a misconception in some ppl's minds. He prints literature and he writes Mohan Singh Bhindranwale....that is fine cause he is from there. some of his books say Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale's name on it...he wrote that out of respect to them as he learned from them for some time. Due to that, some GurSikhs get confused and think its the same literature as Taksal. but no, if its published by Taksal, it will say "Damdami Taksal." None of Giani Mohan Singh Ji's literature has "Damdami Taksal" written on it... hope that might clarify something

Re: Rehras or So Dar

Niranjan Singh · 26 Nov 2004

>>>None of Giani Mohan Singh Ji's literature has "Damdami Taksal" written on it... I am not trying to start another origin of Taksal debat here, and I apologize if I am digressing, but want to point of that the name "DamDami Taksal" is fairly new and it does not appear in older Gutkas or pothis. Originally Baba Gubachan Singh went by the name "Jatha Bhindran" so both Gutkas and pothis printed by Baba Kartar Singh Ji and Baba Mohan Singh mostly say "Jatha Bhindran." One would say "Bhinder-Kalan", the other "Mehta." I have seen one reference published by Baba Kartar Singh Ji using "Taksal Damdama Sahib" but the front of the pothi still says published by "Jatha Bhindran." Now days, "DamDami Taksal" is used mostly by the Mehta Singhs instead of "Jatha Bhindran." Even if the Bhinder-Kalan Singhs don't print using the new Taksal name they are still an important part of the current day Taksal as the Mehta Singhs are. In fact Baba Gurbachan Singh Ji's entire family and grandson are connected to Bhinder-Kalan and are an integral part of the current day Taksal. Baba Mohan Singh Ji (Bhinder Kalan) is a Naam-Bannee waley abhyaasee Gurmukh, along with Baba Thakur Singh Ji (Mehta). We should respect them both regardless of their headquarters.

Re: Rehras or So Dar

respect · 26 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Singh Sahib Niranjan Singh Ji, you're right about Taksal publishing Gutkay and literature and using the name JATHA BHINDRAN a lot compared to Damdami Taksal, it wasnt as much used before....good point... i have Pothis where it says TAKSAK SRI DAMDAMA SAHIB....yep you're right....sorry if i spoke a lot before.

Re: Rehras or So Dar

singhagainstbling · 26 Nov 2004

niranjana singh i don know much about history of jathebandis but i jus wanna say on SA someone was spreading rumours about baba mohan singh and langar a while back.

Re: Rehras or So Dar

A Singh · 26 Nov 2004

Rehras Sahib was rarely written down in puratan days, as Gutkas, believe it or not came much later. The emphasis on having one's nitnem 'kant' was also prevalent and to this day is still encouraged amongst all Sikhs, including the AKJ and Taksal. Just like in Bhai Gurdas Ji's time Nitnem was only JapJi Sahib in the morning, Sodar in the evening and "Aarti" Sohila at night, such practices have 'DEVELOPED' with the Panth as it developed. The Taksali version is one of many and is certainly not the final definative version. When Guru Gobind Singh completed his works, he would have instructed the Khalsa to recited Chaupai Sahib twice (i.e. at Amrit Vela and in the evening) and also include the Anand Sahib (5 Pauris + close). As Maharaj journeyed down south to Nanded, it is quite conceivable that he instructed his Singhs to recite more Dohras, Sorthas etc long side the Chaupai Sahib in the Rehras. This Bani is indicative of many that have DEVELOPED with the Panth, others include:- Shabad Hazaare Shabad Hazaare P10 These two in fact by the 18th century were deemed to form part of and complete Jap Ji Sahib and Jaap Sahib respectively, a praticed even adopted by Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh as referenced in his autobiography. Dukh Bhanjana Sahib And those of you who have the Khalsa Sundar Gutka of the Buddha Dal, there are many more such as:- Dhumala de Salok Aarti-Aarta and others like Bhagautee Astothar and Bhram Kavich which were never written down until much later. This whole "but in Guru Granth Sahib" it does appear as such or it say "Sohila and not 'Kirtan' Sohila" and blah blah arguments are typical of Sikhs today who are obsessed with 'reformation' and denial of past traditions. Personally, why don't you go and join the Church of England, they love to reform and distort history and tradition as well...and follow "modern, scientific, logical, rational etc" trends, just like all the Sikhs today do...and look at what these idiots have achieved -GAY PRIESTS! Well done CoE, don't worry there'll be plenty more to follow your foot steps.

Re: Rehras or So Dar

- · 26 Nov 2004

the more gurbani and longer the rehras sahib ji - THE BETTER if we do a shorter version - fine, that means we do the minimum, but to those who do longer and more gurbani, we should not question why they do a longer version. i hope to extend my rehras sahib ji one day

Re: Rehras or So Dar

Mr. Singh · 26 Nov 2004

A Singh, It's good that you give information and post your views.. However, why do you have to turn it into a 'us versus them' thing and start attacking people? It shows weakness and lack of faith in the strength of your arguments. Why else would you need to try ridiculing people? I find it strange when I see people attacking those who ask for clarification based on gurbanee. The Guru Granth Saahib is where everything starts and ends for us so if someone is confused, they should obviously go to the GUru Granth Saahib. Any tradition that isn't in line with Guru Granth Saahib Jee shouldn't be held onto by sikhs. As you showed, there are various differing traditions. THerefore, you can't impose these on everyone and say that this is correct. Many traditions were anti-sikh. If it wasn't for these 'reformist' sikhs, we wouldn't be Guru Nanak Dev Jee's Sikhs any more. Rather than being afraid of reform and finding the truth, you should embrace it. If the traditions you cling to are true, then they will pass the test of gurmat and you don't need to worry. Also, it's good to read as much gurbanee as you can. However, this doesn't mean that you then change the definition of what that banee includes and condemn all those who don't follow your lengthened version. You now have people who add sampat into sukhmani sahib looking down on those that read the original version of sukhmani saahib and accusing them of reading less paat. It's ridiculous.

Re: Rehras or So Dar

A Singh · 26 Nov 2004

Mr Singh, I note your closing comments and it is indeed ridiculous. I am in no way trying to assert that one is superior to the other, however the fact is that all over this forum people are looking to target those who follow the Taksal or Nanaksar or anything else by using this argument "Guru Sahib say this or that" when discussing the Maryada of these Panthic movements. What does it achieve? Nothing! Exactly, but it seems to be getting all so popular, look at the remarks made by J K Thind using the same ideology. Rehit may have support in Guru Sahib, but a rehitnama is something quite different, so comparing the two together is a little falacy which will only end up leading us down the same path of Kala Afghana and SDO. Gur Fateh! A Singh

Re: Rehras or So Dar

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 26 Nov 2004

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. I wonder why are we so "afraid" of kala Afghana/SDO etc..?? Are they stronger or is our FAITH in GURU Ji/ GURBANI stronger ?? looks like some people are so WEAK in their FAITH....even SHADOWS like KA frighten the living daylights out of them and they start seeing KA/SDO in every body and behind every tree/bush/under every stone.. I am flabbergasted with some responses... The GURU that shines brighter than a QuintzillionTrillionMillion suns seems to be "dim" and candles like KA seem so "bright" ??? PARADOX i just cant fathom... MY FAITH in GURU JI is so strong...no one can shake me...not the christian missionaries that come visiting every week, not the Jehovah's Wittnesses, not the Islamic websites, not the krishna/rama myths...not the sants babas that coem visitng every sunday at the Gurdwara...NO ONE. Can somebody enlighten me as to why these people frighten some of you so much... Jarnail singh

Re: Rehras or So Dar

.. · 27 Nov 2004

yes my faith is so strong i read 3 banis oh dear how will the amrit sinchar take place? well im sure science will find a way! never mind miri piri, well the church priests controlled the congregations im sure i can hehehe. i cant even begin to believe mecca revolved around guru sahib but somehow i believe kala peelah lal brangah afghanas word. ooh charan door, i cant be seen doing that, how menial, i am a scholar with many titles how can a being of my stature be seen doing this? i have an idea let me chop this off sikhi, ah yes my way. hey no ones looking who cares? you see when i reseach all day i dont realise the ego inside me that i am now the don. How could shaheed baba deep singhs head fall off and his body fight? science doesnt agree? hmmmm who shall i believe science or sikhi? hmmm tough choice but you see because i dont have the shardah in gurbani and naam my head is full of research and all kinds of junk i just fail to understand hmm why do we research all day? why dont we just get on with the real deal given in every shabad to jap nam? i dunno im jus weak, but can i show you that? no i want to show you that im a singh, whos singh am i? who do i represent if i cant even stand by what my Guru gave? Whos singh am i that i cant even believe what my Gurus did? Whos singh am i that i spit at the shaheeds magnificient feats? see i can feel the science and rational thinking running through my pores connecting to my heart, what use is faith? even that is a ritual come on sangat we have to modernise all in the name of afghana rss government india wala. i hope the admins can see the patterns occuring on this site lately PLEASE ADMINS GET THE NASTICS OFF THE SITE

Re: Rehras or So Dar

GUrpreet Singh · 27 Nov 2004

Just for clarification The length of the banis in a taksal gutka correspond to those which are found in Bhai Mani Singhs Gutka

Re: Rehras or So Dar

G Singh · 28 Nov 2004

"How could shaheed baba deep singhs head fall off and his body fight? science doesnt agree? hmmmm who shall i believe science or sikhi?" How is that sikhi???is that written in gurbani or history???Is history 100% accurate??If the Gurus wouldnt do karamaat, why wud Baba Deep Singh?? Apparently he did ardaas askin for himto be returned to darbar sahib, bt that doesnt justify the karamaat....everything is in wahegurus hukam, so why would he use his powers to change that?? Also i would like to mention that this is a discussion forum, discussions are calm, donot involve personal attacks on each others faiths....so i ask you next time, before you post, think about what the nishani of a gursikh should be....

Re: Rehras or So Dar

Bijla Singh · 29 Nov 2004

""Apparently he did ardaas askin for himto be returned to darbar sahib, bt that doesnt justify the karamaat...."" No it doesn't but what it justifies is that when true Gursikhs do ardaas there is no way to hold them back. They will do everything they did ardaas for. "karamaat" is only for your own benefits but Baba Ji fought for Darbar Sahib not for himself or just to show how great of a warrior he is. When Bhai Mati Das Ji was cut in two pieces, sound of JapJi Sahib kept coming from both pieces. would you call that a karamaat also? or history isn't 100% accurate? think before you write something. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: Rehras or So Dar

JagdeepK · 29 Nov 2004

Hmm...about Baba Deep Singh Ji...whether it is possible or not, we cannot judge history. Judge if we must, should be our own faith and personal belief in the power of Ardas. If we have an unshakeable faith, we will understand that Baba Deep Singh Ji's Guru was capable of the unbelievable. Okay, I think we went off-track...I thought I was getting answers about my question? Any more insights? Could someone also tell me something else about So Dar da paath... JagdeepK

Re: Rehras or So Dar

Jarnail Singh Arshi gyani · 29 Nov 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. WHAT i want to know is who brought up the subject of 3 banis, baba deep Singh Ji's head. I have read each mail with a fine tooth comb....and no one except the holier than thous...who bring up their own points and then try to be so "faithful" through their own arguments...in an effort to diss other gursikhs. Dont forget it is he who eats the mirchaan...who feels the pain. By the way NASTIC is one who DOES NOT beleive in GOD/Allah/Waheguru/Hari/Jesus/Krishan etc etc. The NASTICS are COMMUNISTS. ATHEISTS etc who DONT BELIEVE IN GOD/WAHEGURU's existence and only depend on Science/Fact as can be seen with the eyes and felt etc. I have seen no such "NASTIC" on this site....this by its very terms is a SIKH/GURMATT RELIGIOUS SITE where everybody comes to learn about GURBANI and discuss such issues..BUT EVERYONE has a BASIC BELIEF in the 10 Gurus, Guru granth sahib jee and Waheguru and Gurbani as Shabad Guru and MOST if not all are Amrtidharees who do NITNEM. Those that are not yet amrtidharees/gurmatt fllowers are trying to learn as much as possible to follow the path...but the "ULTRA-RELIGIOSTS Kattarrs so called HOLIER than ALL of US" are the pain in the neck trying to force feed everybody their own brand of religion/maryada...no has fallen for that and never will. Discussion Forums are just that- DISCUSSION and NOT MONOPOLY of THOUGHT. They forget the Number one Lesson of GURBANI - PREM...PREM...pREM and more PREM....animosity just drives people away...but to some people the "lesser" the better then they can show off their superiority in doing 25 banis nitnem. longer this and longer that. SORRY ji, everyone learns at his own pace... 3 is better than one, and firve is better than 3.....short is better than none..and longer is beter than shorter...BUT let everyone find his own pace...who cares if you can run at 100 miles an hour....in the end the hare lost to the tortoise.(HAUMAII did that.) Luckily for all of us the Admins are pretty much liberal thinkers...who allow debate as well as discussion ( within limits of Gurmatt of course and that is ok by me)..and NEVER allow any one "idealogue" to dominate as if it is his forum..and everyone else should get off/be dropped/shut out/banned/etc etc..You point ONE finger at someone.......FOUR point towards yourself. dassan dass jarnail singh

Re: Rehras or So Dar

mirch · 29 Nov 2004

g singh define karamat for me please? do you feel shaheed baba deep singhs head did not come off his head while fighting? and are you implying sikhs should not look at history of shaheeds but only at gurbani?

Re: Rehras or So Dar

A Singh · 29 Nov 2004

Gyani Jee, I am not afraid of Kala Afghana or SDO, but the work done by these two characters is of far greater concern than the ramblings of the RSS or VHP, which is what usually gets most people on this forum agitated. My faith in Maharaj is unshakeable too, but you forget that whilst RSS and VHP may present blanket statements like Sikhs are Hindus and that the Gurus are incarnations of Vishnu, the likes of KA actually have convinced many many Sikhs that Jaap Sahib, Savaiyae and Chaupai Sahib Bani are fake and in the process attacked the very roots of the Khalsa. Yes, this has been addressed by the Khalsa Alliance Team amicably, but have a read of a post by a Niranjana on Sikh Sangat where they indicate an instance in a Gurdwara in Halifax, Canada have actually enforced a ban on the Chaupai Sahib Paath totally! It isn't long before this continues across Canada and beyond and clearly demonstrates the lack of power the SGPC/Akal Thakt hold in enforcing their so-called "ban" on Kala Afghana.

Re: Rehras or So Dar

LOL · 29 Nov 2004

hahaha ".." iam loving your post. thanks for expressing my feelings without knowing i felt the same way.

Re: Rehras or So Dar

? · 29 Nov 2004

jarnail singh what to you comprises nitnem can you clearly tell us please? i am learning too. why is it some read 3 and others 5? i am sure if its 3 there has to be a reason please tell us you seem to be knowledgable on history. i also agree with A Singh the greatest damage is being done inside sikhi by those disguised as sikhs attacking it at its roots.

Re: Rehras or So Dar

A Singh · 01 Dec 2004

Dear "?" Your question on Bani for Nitnem is not black and white, as with many things. We know that most sources agree on the 5 Banis required to prepare Amrit, however as per daily Nitnem, this I seen range from 3 to 7 or more, depending on how one counts. The present day maryada endorsed by the SGPC stipulates only 3 Banis for the morning with the Chaupai (short) and Anand (short) included within the Rehiras forming 4 banis and kirtan sohila the 5th for daily nitnem. Damdami taksal and others maintain that it should be all 5 banis for Morning nitnem, independent of Rehiras and Sohila Sahib. If one looks at Sunder Gutkas (from the Damdami Taksal, Nanaksar and the Nihangs) one sees a larger format, usually along the following lines:- Jap Ji Sahib Shabad Hazaare Jaap Sahib Shabad Hazaare P10 Tav Prashad Savaiyae (Swarag Shudh...) Savaiyae (Deenan Ki pritpal...) Tav Prashad Chaupai (from Akal Ustat) Benti Chaupai Anand Sahib (full) This can be 9 banis or 7 banis or even 5 banis depending on how you count them (i.e. many consider Jap Ji Sahib and Jaap Sahib incomplete without the respective Shabad Hazaare). A Nitnem routine akin to above however is usually maintained by many Babas, Sants, Bhais and influential Sikhs if we look at their life accounts. Nihangs, Namdharis and others follow the above and then usually add to that the following:- Aht-Chandi Chariter Chandi ki Vaar Ugardanti Akal Ustat Shastarnaam Mala Personally, whilst reading Bani is always recommended, getting hooked on quantity over quality is not the same. I always find it amusing that in our present age, we hear so much about so and so "Chardi Kala Singh" does 101 Paaths of this or that bani each day, which compared to older accounts is very different -where someone would 'cross the world ocean' by hearing or contemplating a single line of a Shabad. Hope this helps, A Singh.

Re: Rehras or So Dar

? · 02 Dec 2004

thank you A singh for your good insight this has given the opportunity to learn more. i would like to pose my question to jarnail singh gyani as i dont believe its about number of banis. Surely if some read 3 there must be a reason why were two rejected?

Re: Rehras or So Dar

A Singh · 02 Dec 2004

Whilst we await the wise words of our Gyani Sahib, just something else to consider:- By not reciting something are we in fact 'rejecting' those lines or bani? For example, the recitation of 5 Pauria from Anand Sahib in the evening or at the close of a kirtan divan -does this mean we 'reject' the others? Likewise, when one recites only 5 Pauria from the Jap Ji Sahib when beginning a Sehaj Path? I have often thought about this with respect to the shortened Chaupai Sahib, i.e. Is it simply because the "bani" ends at that stanza and the remainder is only 'references' ? Personally, whilst this "may" be true I maintain my personal stance that the SGPC has cut this short on account of their paranoia and lack of understanding with regard to the lines commencing:- "Kirpa karee hum par Jugmata..."

Re: Rehras or So Dar

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 04 Dec 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh. I have no idea where the 3 versus 5 banis argument came about. The SRM - Sikh Rehat maryada of the Akal Takhat Approved/SGPC Printed states: <<<