Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Watch Out

Watch Out

...... · 24 Nov 2004

Saad Sangat jio old news to some, however for those who are not aware our youth are at risk due to anti sikh designs and views recieved through books, lectures and people posing off as sikhs. I have had a group of young boys from sikh parivars approach me in my local gurdwara confused about Baba Deep Singh jis sis cut shaheedi questioning me "how is this rational or humanly possible? likely his head was cut a bit and over time our uneducated pindus through generations exaggerated it to sis cut." they further doubted the panj pyareys sis was cut off instead "bakrai used". An elder person holding Khala Afghana views was responsible for telling them this. The reason im posting the article below from khalsa alliance which has vast info on such manmutt is to watch out for people falling under this pattern be it one point, 2 5 10 20, the person does not always lay all their cards out at once. the last thing we need is more division while vested interests using it as an opportunity. (KA = Kala Afghana) Bhog & Guru Granth Sahib - Doing bhog of Deg in presence of Guru Granth Sahib is manmat according to KA. Sri Amritsar Ishnan - KA states that the holy water of the sarovar should NOT be referred to as Amrit. Baba Attar Singh Ji Mastuana - KA condems Baba Attar Singh Ji for doing continous Simran on a minimal diet as refers to is as Tap. Washing our Feet - KA criticizes the practice of washing our feet before entering Darbar Sahib or our Gurduara Sahibs. Amrit Vela - KA states how can you call a particular time of the day Amrit-Vela when so many evil things happen around the world at that time. Narak-Surag - KA states that those who follow religion from the fear of Narak are not religious beings. He suggests that Narak and Surag are a figment of our imagination. Bhai Veer Singh Ji - KA criticizes Bhai Veer Singh Ji for making anti-Gurmat statements expresses dissapointment about his works. Amritsar Sarovar - KA implies that there is no basis behind the belief that partaking ishnan in Amritsar sarovar will wash away one's sins. He states that it has nothing to do whatsoever with the Gurbani verse : "RamDaas Sarova Natai || Sabh Utray Pap Kamatai|| Baba Deep Singh Ji's memorial - KA argues against the need for a memorial for Baba Deep Singh Ji where Baba Ji's severed was laid to rest. He refers to this as idol worship. He questions even whether Baba Ji's severed head had fell at that particular place. Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit - KA questions the historical reference that (1) Amrit could revive the dead (the Panj Piarays). (2)Amrit could rid one of previous sins. (3) He states that this kind of belief will convince an Amritdharee to committ further sins. (3)He states that Guru Gobind Singh Ji never accepted the Panj as his Guru (Appay Guru Chella) (4)KA states that the reference to Guru Gobind Singh of reviving the Panj Piyarays after cutting their "sees" are pure lies. Baba Jarnail Singh and Baba Harnam Singh Ji (Rampur Khera) - KA states that Baba Jarnail Singh Ji committed acts that brought about the current downfall of the Panth. Baba Jarnail Singh Ji desecrated Sri Darbar Sahib when defended and fortified it. By giving shastars and motorcycles to the Sikh youth, he (Baba Jarnail Singh) made us into murderers and robbers (dakoos). KA states that even after Baba Harnam Singh also joined in, their Panthic wishes were never fullfilled. He questions their sincerity and wonders if they were are all "bhekhee" (charlatans). Panj Piaray and Guru Sahib cutting their sis - KA redicules the reference to Guru Gobind Singh of reviving the Panj Piyarays after cutting their "sis". Khanday-Batay da Amrit & Sweet Pittasay - KA states that to consider that sweet Pittasay were to be used in preparation of Amrit is a maha-Paap (enormous sin) since it implies that : (1) Dasam Patshah must have understood Naam-Amrit to be bitter. (2) Dasam Patshah had forgotten the Pittasay and his mistake was corrected by Mata Jito Jee. States that this Pittasay eposide is a myth and was made up by the enemies of this faith. Amrit & Naam - KA states that calling Amrit Naam is BrahmanVaad. Jao Tao Premo Khellan… & Baba Deep Singh - KA redicules the use of this tuk in reference to Baba Deep Singh deed of fighting with his sis on his palm. 1699 Vaisakhi and the Tent - KA redicules Sikh history's reference to use of a Tent in 1699 Vaisakhi. 1699 Vaisakhi and the Tent, Baba Gurbachan Singh Bhindran - KA redicules Sikh history's reference to use of a Tent in 1699 Vaisakhi, and attacks Baba Gurbachan Singh Bhindran for mentioning it. Adultry & Bhai Randhir Singh - KA states that Bhai Randhir Singh Ji wrote that Adultry was allowed in the Rahit. Adultry & Bhai Randhir Singh - KA states that Bhai Randhir Singh Ji wrote that Adultry was allowed in the Rahit. Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit & 3 Banees of Dasam Patshah - KA redicules reference to Jaap Sahib, Swaiyay, and Chaupai Sahib as Banees recited during Amrit-Sanchar. Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit & 5 Banees - KA states only the Banees in Guru Granth Sahib were part of the Amrit-Sanchar ceremony. To consider that other three (Jaap Sahib, Swaiyay, and Chaupai Sahib as Banees) were read by the Guru Gobind Singh Ji is utterly direspectful to our SatGurus. Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit & reviving of the Panj Piyaray & Shakti - KA redicules the concept of Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit & reviving of the Panj Piaray & the divine powers (Shakti) of Amrit. He also referrs to Amrit-dharees as "Papian di Santaan" (offspring of sinners) Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit & Shakti - KA again redicules the concept of Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit & the divine powers (Shakti) of Amrit. Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit & reviving of the Panj Piyaray & Shakti - KA redicules the concept of Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit & reviving of the Panj Piaray & the divine powers (Shakti) of Amrit. He also referrs to Amrit-dharees as "Papian di Santaan" (offspring of sinners) Charan-Amrit - KA redicules that Sikh tradition of Charan-Amrit that existed until Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit replaced it in 1699. He refers to it as a Brahmanic ritual. Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit & Amritdhari Singhs - Redicules Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit & Amritdhari Singhs Panj Piaray & Guru Gobind Singh Ji - He states that Guru Gobind Singh Ji never accepted the Panj as his Guru (Appay Guru Chella) Panj Piaray & Guru Gobind Singh Ji - He states that Guru Gobind Singh Ji never accepted the Panj as his Guru (Appay Guru Chella) Panj Piaray & Amritdharis - KA Ridicules Panj Piaray & Amritdharis, tells story of a man who was so fed up with Amritdharis that he cut his Kes and never kept them again. Mai Sewan & Singhnees in Mir Manu's Prison - Ridicules why could not Guru Sahib create a Mai Sewan (who could travel many miles through Divine Kirpa) among the Singhnees in Mir Manu's Prison so they could warn the Khalsa Dal. Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit & Patits - States that was responsible for making Sikh children cut their Kes, smoke tobacco, and become Patits. States that for Sikhs, becoming a Singh is a "bharm" (superstition) of the mind. Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit - States that those who consider Khanday-Batay-da-Amrit as becoming "Guru-waley" (inititation into Sikhism) are mistaken. Anand-Karj - Redicules the Panth Parvan Anand-Karj Ceremony. Lables the Anand Maryada as based on Brahmanic Rituals. Court of Dharm-Raaj, Bhai Randhir Singh, Unseen-World. - Redicules Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's references to the Court of Dharm-Raaj in his book "Unditthee Duniya", as based on Brahamic granths. Punishment from Jums, Chitar-Gupt, Dharm-Raaj's court States that the idea of punishment from Jums, Chitar-Gupt, Dharm-Raaj's court are all illusion and fiction created by religious leaders. Bhai Randhir Singh - Labels Bhai Randhir Singh as a "Bipree Agent" (an agent of the Brahmans) Bhai Randhir Singh, Unseen-World. - Redicules Bhai Randhir Singh for describing the "Unditthee Duniya" (Unseen World), and lables it as "koor-kobaarr" (trash) of the Brahmans. Bhai Randhir Singh, Bhindranwale & others. Redicules Bhai Randhir Singh, Bhindranwale, and other Mahapurakhs for having belief in Chitar-Gupt, Dharam-Raaj, Jums, Narak/Surag, and the afterworld. Khanday-Batay, Amrit & Mantar - States that the water put in a sarovar or bowl (Khanday-Batay) can never be called Amrit. Nor can anyone blow any Mantar (WaheGuru) in water and turn it into anything powerful (Amrit). He credits the Brahmans for creating such a belief. http://www.khalsaalliance.org/kala.php

Re: Watch Out

singh4life · 25 Nov 2004

why is he called afghana? he doesnt look afghan to me. are there a lot of sikhs who dont believe in panj banis? ie 3 banis? why did they want to shorten the panj banis? if we reduce bani surely that would have less assar on our souls. These kind of people claim to be scholars and talk with such authority then how could they miss the significance of 5? 5 kakar, 5 sarovar, 5 takhat 5 piarey. who exactly was kala afghana to decide whats what in sikhi? the guy cant even mann sikhi so who was he to question it? If his followers dont agree with sikhi they should find another faith that suits them dont try to chop and change sikhi it will never work. Sikhi is here to stay as it is, in the end all those who try to destroy it depart empty handed. sangats should keep their eyes peeled for anyone displaying even one of those listed points. can anyone tell me who IOSS are?

Re: Watch Out

Son of Guru GObind Singh Ji · 25 Nov 2004

Kala Afghana is a name of a pind.

Re: Watch Out

ManjitKaur · 25 Nov 2004

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. In certain PUBLIC places such as Railway stations, bus stops etc there are prominently placed signs of warning that say: BEWARE OF PICK POCKETS.... The Pick Pockets will usually hang around thse places and POINT out the SIGN to the Travellers..... and you know what.... EACH TRAVELLER when shown this sign will AUTOMATICALLY touch/feel/the POCKET etc that contains all his Cash and valuables.... THAT BEHAVIOUR is EXACTLY what the PICKPOCKETS are looking for as it IDENTIFIES the POCKET to be picked !! The SIGNBOARD actually makes the job of pickpockets easier... I see the SAME TACTIC in the Mail Above. I am NOT a KA supporter...BUT SO MANY STATEMENTS are SO DRASTICALLY WRONG and MISLEADING that it makes me laugh. IT is NOT KA BUT PROFESSOR SAHIB SINGH in hIs MONUMENTAL GURUGRANTHDARPAN of 10 volumes that gives the CORRECT MEANINGS of the Tuk: Ramdass sarovar nahteh...and how the sarovar is NOT the AMRIT of GURBANI. NO way does the word "Ramdass" mean GURU RAMDASS JI and this TUK has been seriously MISINTERPRETED by sants and derawallahs to twist its meaning. GURBANI is amply clear that JAPP/TAPP/Bathing at SAROVARS/FASTING/Giving Pain to your body/etc etc WITHOUT PREM of WAHEGURU are empty RITUALS...Gurbani says that this HUMAN BODY is the HARIMANDIR in which the NAAM-AMRIT RESIDES...it is the RESIDENCE of WAHEGURU...so who in his right mind will say that giving it TORTURE is good ?? IF someone LOANS you a Marble Palace to live in temporarily will the owner be very happy if you HACK the WALLS, break the marble tiles, pull up all the nice plants in the garden, etc etc - this is exactly what the japping tapping sadhus of hinduism do to "please" God. Gurbani wants PREM PREM and more pREM.. Many other points i dont agree with KA - especially those relating to Bhai sahib bhai Randhir Singh Ji. That is KA's personal opinion and i dont have a problem with anybody's personal opinions about anything. I dont see why others should too...after all everyone is entitled to have his /her opinion. IF you people want to attack KA properly then you must properly IDENTIFY only the Wrong points and attack them BASED ON GURBANI. As i understand all KA's GURBANI translations are Based on Prof Sahib Singh and no body can touch him on that point. Inspite of the excommunication and all that hoo hah KA's books are being downloaded and read more and more...what does this prove...the SAME thing that others have failed to do before us...as the Catholic Church with martin Luther, Galileo, Charles Darwin etc etc...NO one can stop progress and new ideas. The greatest DAMAGE was done when the person who excommunicated KA was himself GUILTY of publishing on GOLAK funds of the SGPC a BOOK that is so INSULTING to the GURUS...He WITHDREW the bOOK and BANNED it after kA made noise..and then took his revenge on KA. IF he was RIGHT then he wouldnt have banned his own BOOK....and NATURAL JUSTICE is that he should have stepped down from the post and allowed others to excimmunicate ort hear out kA. Now its too late..One mans's Haumaii has damaged the whole Panth. Just yesterday this same person AUTHORISED a Gurbani katha Vichaar book by an EX SP of Punjab POlice who murdered many Sikh Youths..shows his true character. MK

Re: Watch Out

singh · 25 Nov 2004

Manjit Kaur, you understand WRONGLY when you say that KA's gurbanee translations CAN'T BE TOUCHED ..because they ARE all based on Professor Sahib Singh's translations.. Firstly, even if they were BASED on that work, Prof Sahib Singh ISN'T UNTOUCHABLE.... PLEASE don't turn him INTO some sort of SANT.... HE did an incredible JOB, but he can still BE questioned. However, KA uses his own MANMAT to present THESE translations. sO don't just USE prof's NAME to defend KA HE wasn't excommunicated BY just one person... but BY five... he WAS given teh chance TO go there AND present his CASE.. hE chose not TO do so on the grounds of SOME flimsy excuse

Re: Watch Out

Niranjan Singh · 26 Nov 2004

Manjit Kaur, You obviously don't know anything about KA or Prof. Sahib Singh. If you did you would not be making such statements. Why don't you take some time and read the following pdfs : "Prof. Sahib Singh Di Kasvattee and Kala-Afghana" Parts 1, 2 and 3 at : http://www.khalsaalliance.org/articles/ProfSahibSingh_di_kaswati_kala.pdf http://www.khalsaalliance.org/articles/ProfSahibSingh_di_kaswati_kala2.pdf http://www.khalsaalliance.org/articles/ProfSahibSingh_di_kaswati_kala3.pdf You will find out that KA's interpretations are NOT based on Prof. Sahib Singh, in fact they are compeltely opposite of Prof. Sahib Singh's views on Amrit, Amrit-Vela, Simran, etc. KA was excommunicated on the request of Guru Khalsa Panth, which included panels of Gurmukhs such as Bhai Joginder Singh Ji Talwara, and other prominent members of the Akhand Kirtani Jatha, Dam-Dami Taksal, Tarna Dals, Singhs Sabhas, etc. Visit : http://www.khalsaalliance.org/kala.php for more info on KA. You also wrote : >>>the person who excommunicated KA was himself GUILTY of publishing >> on GOLAK funds of the SGPC a BOOK that is so INSULTING to the >>GURUS...He WITHDREW the bOOK and BANNED it after kA made >>noise..and then took his revenge on KA. Bibi, you obviously have been brainwashed by the KA nastics. If you are reffering to "Gurbilas Patshahee 6" then perhaps you should do some research before making such statements. This book is NOT banned, and it was NOT written by Vedantee. It is an historic text containing the information (partly inaccurate) of our Sixth Patshah and Sri Akal Takht Sahib Jee. Vedantee mentions CLEARLY in the preface that this book contains misinformation, and it is being published for historical reasons. Much like the RahitNamas book was published by Pro. Piara Singh Padam. What is the difference then ? Why didn't any body scream bloody murder when Prof Padam published his book ? That also contains a lot of offending information. In case you didn't know, Gurbilas P6 is the oldest and most complete reference of our Sixth Patshah's life and backgorund of Sri Akal Takht Sahib. In order to please their Hindoo masters, I am sure enemies of Sri Akal Takht Sahib would love to trash the only old reference material mentioning the importance and building of Sri Akal Takht Sahib by Sixth Patshah. Why do all the KA chamchays have a problems with preserving and re-publishing historical records of our history ? We all know these accounts have been tampered with and been manipulated with, but so have all of our RahitNamas and Birs of Guru Granth Sahib Ji, and Dasam Granth di Banee. Should we ignore ALL of any part of our history, RahitNamas and our Banees to please a couple of cry-baby KA chamchays ? I don't think so. Funny that KA who happens to have more than just one screw lose, writes total trash, and people like this Bibi accept it like divine knowldege, but are hypo-allergenic to historical writings such as Gurbilas P6. That is why they keep parroting exactly what KA wants them to parrot, even on Panthic sites such as this. Before his chamchays go around referencing Prof. Sahib Singh Ji, first find out how much love and pyaar he had for Gurbanee, GurSikhi, Sri Darbar Sahib, and the Khalsa Rahit, before trying to link him to a dirty dog like KA.

Re: Watch Out

singh · 26 Nov 2004

Good points by Niranjan Singh. However, I'm quite certain that Gurbilas Patshahee 6 was banned by the SGPC. You should check that info again. It doesn't only have a few messed up parts, but rather, some really anti sikh stuff. I agree that it is of historical importance and should be kept for scholarly research, but with a good degree of caution.

Re: Watch Out

Niranjan Singh · 26 Nov 2004

>> I'm quite certain that Gurbilas Patshahee 6 was banned by the SGPC. Singh Ji, SGPC has no such authority to ban books, it was merely pulled from publication due to all the hoolabalaa by the Kala nastics. Being of historical importance it is still available from most book stores in Punjab selling books on Sikhism. There is no HukamNama or edit banning the book itself, if there is please provide references. BTW, here is what "The Sikh Reference Book" says about "Gurbilas Pashahee 6" : "...a narrative, mainly of the life and the events of Guru Hargobind Singh Sahib, in verse... This work preserves an important period of Sikh histroy. No other book gives so minute details of the relevation of the Akal Takht Sahib, the construction of the building of Takht Sahib, the battles of Guru Sahib etc... Some of the dates given by the autor are incorrect and there are several mirepresentations in the book but, in spite of this, IT IS AN IMPORTANT SOURCE OF EARLY SIKH HISTORY. Accoding to the autor the book is based on the account told to Bhagat Singh and Gyrdev Singh (the teachers of the author) by Bhai Mani Singh. (p.74)

Re: Watch Out

A Singh · 26 Nov 2004

is exactly the type of person attracted by the likes of Kala Afghana, The IOSS, Teja Singh Bhasauria, Sanatan and Tat Khasa Singh Sabhas etc etc, modern reformist movement who seek to break from traditions which they now fail to understand and deem themselves to be the very face of "progress". These are the same people who have existed for ages in the West are would more the likely crucify their lord Jesus Christ if he returned on account of being more Christian than He. Clearly we are seeing many of this type growing in the Panth today.

Re: Watch Out

? · 28 Nov 2004

why shud kala the heretic devil afghana be allowed to have his say when he insults Guru, Sikhi, shaheeds, rehet? wouldnt you agree manjit kaur ji? can you please tell me what kind of points you agree with him on? does he have any right points?

Re: Watch Out

? · 29 Nov 2004

manjit kaur i am still awaiting your response.

Re: Watch Out

mirch · 30 Nov 2004

interesting, if the panthic dushts actually had a valid point the sangat would listen to it but so far mr kala has shown only one thing that he has taken the stand to attack the Khalsa insituition. He is full of contradictions that are easily taken apart. This is the first time i am hearing amrtidhari saying manjit kaur wrote "That is KA's personal opinion and i dont have a problem with anybody's personal opinions about anything. I dont see why others should too...after all everyone is entitled to have his /her opinion. IF you people want to attack KA properly then you must properly IDENTIFY only the Wrong points and attack them BASED ON GURBANI. As i understand all KA's GURBANI translations are Based on Prof Sahib Singh and no body can touch him on that point." why are you so defensive of a panthic enemy?